Genesis 39 Now Joseph was taken down to Egypt,+ and an Egyptian named Potʹi·phar,+ a court official of Pharʹaoh and chief of the guard, bought him from the Ishʹma·el·ites+ who had taken him down there. 2
The iceberg format is such a great format to gove someone a quick dive into a subject. Start with the common, easy things and continue into ideas that compound on other ideas.
There’s absolutely no way I was playing nhl while you talked about NHLer birthdays and brushing my teeth when describing the process as something mythical/magical. That’s so wild.
It's funny that you say Gemeinschaft and Gesellschaft are intimidating words. You pronounced them pretty well, whereas your pronunciation of Tönnies made me chuckle a bit 💀
@@henri4356 the assumptions we make are smaller, and the conclusions we draw are much more limited in together affect our understanding of the world. Half the things in this video are leftist drivel that relys on no evidence. Whatsoever, or have been disproved since
@@henri4356 idk about this dude, but for me, i’m attempting to pursue a math degree mainly because i enjoy doing math as, for now, it comes very easily to me. i am also autistic and feel like math is better suited for the way my brain works. however, i also love the humanities (sociology, literature, art history, etc.) and WOULD go for one of those degrees, but it requires a considerable amount of extra effort i have to put into understanding because i still have issues processing words largely due to ADHD (judith butler was kind of a nightmare to read but the stuff i did fully understand was based and i think their work is valuable). i’m constantly cycling in and out of burnout, so if i’m even doing school i’d rather do something i like but is better suited for me and requires less energy
@@prodigal_southernerits over-appreciated lol. The only concept of his of some value is “alienation” and that is why he is mostly popular in soft sciences like sociology
To add to race as a social construct. The society and culture of each “race” tends to reinforce their own differences, causing people to have children with people who look like them. This reinforces these racial divides and keeps the boundaries thriving. It’s hard to imagine an America where a person would not say “im white/black/asian” etc compared to never stating it at all. Acknowledging this classification causes the classification to exist.
I‘m very thankful for this channel. great content i love every video. pls keep up the good work! i can assure you all your hard work was or is worth it !!
these are actually down to earth and about things im always thinking about in my life whcih is great i totally didnt expect sociology to be this much of a w
Ironically, it feels like Weber's Iron Cage might be breaking down, at least at the fast food places I frequent, because the menu boards are used to show ads and promos most of the time, meaning I need to check if the item I want is still offered or 'converse' for a couple seconds before I can make a decision
Loved this vid. The Pygmalion Effect really hit home. All my teachers expected me to be a success. My classmates however thought I was a loser. I really don’t know what I am now. I am a graduate of Grad school but I still live with my mother and sister. Who was right?
This Gemeinschaft versus Gesellschaft is also important in one huge area of Politics. Large Parts of the Alain de Benoist influenced european new right (and related persons like Dugin) have a slogan called "Gemeinschaft statt Gesellschaft" (Gemeinschaft instead of Gesellschaft). These groups are opposed to modernity and what you called the Iron Cage. (Most times, they use the Heideggerian Term "Gestell" instead. Gestell is a german word describing a structure which forces components of a larger machine like a car to stay at their designated place to ensure their proper functioning and placement, keep their proper distance and prevent them from damaging each other. For example, if a motor moves too much, it might lose its connection to the fuel tank or if the connection to the fuel tank is elastic, too much movement might cause the machine to be inefficient because the fuel needs to travel larger distances to reach the motor. A Gestell prevents that. Heidegger called technologies influence on society and its drive for efficiency a "Gestell".) And they are mostly traditionalists who want a kind of Confucianists or Hindu System where a priest has a certain degree of respect due to his priesthood, there are certain duties of fathers towards children and vice versa.
Why are you describing me? I studied sociology for undergrad, anthropology for masters, and now, studying philosophy. My individual agency is limited by my intersectionality: a brown Asian middle class female with an unseen disability (ADHD and anxiety). But I dont victimize myself. Im just self-aware of what opportunities are available to me, then get by from what is available
Hate to draw comparisons, but this is so much better than that other guy that reads off of AI generated nonsense. Hope your channel blows up and you do some other content, be it video esaays, commentaries, deep dives and the like. Not that I don't like your content right now, just that inside these tier-lists and icebergs are specific topics that deserve their own videos imo. Have a wonderful day!
You know the candy stories where people thought that evil strangers were handing out candy, & yet the kids who were getting hurt by candy was due to their relatives, it reminds me of a video by Maggie Mae Fish about Twin Peaks. She talked about child abuse & stranger danger, how in the 80s everyone thought that their kid would be abducted & abused by a stranger in a van. Yet most cases of child abuse are perpetrated not by strangers, but by people kids trusted like their parents or other family members. This is an interesting trend where people are more willing to talk about the danger of a mysterious boogeyman as opposed to people in their own group.
Thank you for putting out such great and videos! I really like your channel and enjoy your content. I find your videos very entertaining and informative. Keep it up! By the way the edited "The Big Lebowski" scene made my day 🤣
I'm amazed how being sociology major but in different country makes me look so different on the field. I knew all the things that you talked about but I would never said that they belong to the bottom tiers of the iceberg. For me Sociology becomes really strange when you start to deal with social ontology, or try to operationalize some philosophers that you would never connect with empirical studies, like Agamben or Augé. Overall great video, makes you think
the way I GASPED when I saw this nofication. I LOVE sociology sm and ur content is always top tier thank u for giving my life meaning for 2 hours ‼️‼️🗣🗣
Ik the iceberg format is horse so dead the body can't be found, but your icebergs are amazing you go indepth like literally no other content creator I know. I could keep gushing but you get the point. Your vids like this are awesome
Nice. Studied this stuff a decade ago nice to have the refresh. Always really interesting how the self is constructed through social interaction. Would be nice to have a neurological basis refresher too ;)
I watched through the first 15 minutes and the video looks very promising! Speaking of interactionism, Max Weber is totally unrelated, did you mean Georg Simmel? Moreover, I’d definitely mention Erving Goffman who was the most famous scholar who used this framework in empirical research rather than Cooley of Mead who were mostly thinkers.
Yeah that was really weird to see Weber mentioned along Mead. I’d say people like Weber and Simmel (to a larger extent) influenced with their more interpretation-based style the Chicago school with people like Goffman, though calling them a part of the same school of thought just feels a little wrong.
I spotted a couple of other mistakes. First, a major one, discussing protestant ethics, Max Weber is mentionned again in the context of interactionnism, but these two are from different realms. The second and the third are very minor issues. “Rich get richer and poor poorer” is mostly related to Matthiew effect (which should be in the iceberg), than to reproduction. Symbolic capital is built upon items from other capitals that are especially recognized in a specific field one’s acting. For instance, being able to write well (cultural capital) is barely recognized in the scientific field, but it’s of importance in the litterary field.
Thanks for the video, there are quite a few ideas I wasn’t aware of, especially towards the end. Sorry for occupying the comment section, but I'm fond of sociology :) I'd like to add things that allow us to go waaaaay deeper. These are my suggestions (from the tip towards the bottom): - stigmatization (Goffman) - techniques of the body (Mauss) - rituals (van Guennep, Goffman, Bourdieu) - total institutions (Goffman) - social construction of scientific facts (Latour) - unanticipated consequences (Merton) - The Twofold Truth of Labour (Bourdieu) - potlatch (Mauss) - non-human agency (Latour/Callon) - genius as a purposeful creation (Elias) - the predominance of the right hand (Hertz, Tcherkezoff) - social construction of consciousness (Elias)
DO ANTHROPOLOGY NEXT, PRETTY PLEASE!
that was what i was thinking
Sémiology. Dips!
PS: I realised as an American, you don't have any gothic cathedrals around. Nice to see one.
No
Hell yeah
as a currenty anthropology student who struggles with the different schools since radcliffe-brown, i second this
This is the best channel on youtube. I would love to see a Psychology Iceberg that focuses on concepts rather than experiments.
Ong
So, in other words, it's an ok channel, but you would have done better. Let's see it
Genesis
39 Now Joseph was taken down to Egypt,+ and an Egyptian named Potʹi·phar,+ a court official of Pharʹaoh and chief of the guard, bought him from the Ishʹma·el·ites+ who had taken him down there. 2
It really is! No other youtube channel I've watched even comes close to the entertainment value of these videos
@@illosovicnot what they said. Read again
more educational icebergs / videos please !!! can't get enough of em
Facts, Duncan's iceberg vids and Trey the Explainers iceberg vids are peak
this and a blunt
literally me rn
U get it
I wish I could still enjoy thc like I used to 😔
@@thecolorcomputerwhy can't you?
@pseudonymos_ I stopped for a long time, and now I get paranoid and nauseous every time I try 🫠
Bro finally guessed his YT channel password 💀
indeed
Yup
I don’t want to be _that_ type of person, but why do people still comment this?
It takes time to create quality videos
Blud thinks his outdated meme is still funny 💀
Wake up babe new Duncan Clarke just dropped
My favorite youtuber posts a video about my special interest on a day where i have nothing to do, perfect.
why is it special
16:45 "A lot of these rules can be kind of arbritrary" my autism is delighted by you saying this
Who?
so real
97 mins, 85Hz, archive footage. Oh yeah, it's dunkin time
Man your new video was nice
Fart Chad
Fart chad
dunkachino
I'm a gemeinschaft living in a gesellschaft world, raised to love everybody and doing it even if nobody notices it ❤
Ditto! It's often a thankless way to live, unfortunately.
14:17 "People don't like war very much" citation needed buddy
idk im pretty sure most people don't like going out of their way to hurt other people just because their government told them to
@@atmo1839Some do, some psychopaths get into the army as an excuse to kill people, like cops who become cops because they want authority.
Just started reading about sociology two days ago. This is gonna be real helpful
I love this videos. One suggestion I have is to read out loud each topic, for those of us who listen to you like a podcast, please. Thank you
The iceberg format is such a great format to gove someone a quick dive into a subject. Start with the common, easy things and continue into ideas that compound on other ideas.
As someone who studied sociology in university, this video is an absolute treat. Thank you for making this video!
He came back when we needed him the most 🙏
we truly live in a society
my mind is blown
I watched it a few times while I was asleep and it looked good. Will watch again now I'm awake. Thanks for sharing
Bro dropped a movie out of nowhere
There’s absolutely no way I was playing nhl while you talked about NHLer birthdays and brushing my teeth when describing the process as something mythical/magical. That’s so wild.
Just stopping by to say you're currently in my pantheon of absolute top tier TH-camrs !
It's funny that you say Gemeinschaft and Gesellschaft are intimidating words. You pronounced them pretty well, whereas your pronunciation of Tönnies made me chuckle a bit 💀
This video reminded me why I study math, philosophy and physics instead of the social sciences.
Why do you say that
@@henri4356 the assumptions we make are smaller, and the conclusions we draw are much more limited in together affect our understanding of the world.
Half the things in this video are leftist drivel that relys on no evidence. Whatsoever, or have been disproved since
Username checks out
@@henri4356 idk about this dude, but for me, i’m attempting to pursue a math degree mainly because i enjoy doing math as, for now, it comes very easily to me. i am also autistic and feel like math is better suited for the way my brain works. however, i also love the humanities (sociology, literature, art history, etc.) and WOULD go for one of those degrees, but it requires a considerable amount of extra effort i have to put into understanding because i still have issues processing words largely due to ADHD (judith butler was kind of a nightmare to read but the stuff i did fully understand was based and i think their work is valuable). i’m constantly cycling in and out of burnout, so if i’m even doing school i’d rather do something i like but is better suited for me and requires less energy
Thank you for uploading this.. looking forward to another fantastic video
can't imagine the time and effort you have to put to make your videos so amazing! Thank you for making it for us!
When I was getting started on High School, asked a big friend about what one may study in Sociology class. He said "basically, communist shit"
I think Marx is considered one of the fathers of sociology. His brilliance is greatly underappreciated by most people.
@@prodigal_southernerits over-appreciated lol. The only concept of his of some value is “alienation” and that is why he is mostly popular in soft sciences like sociology
@@utkarshnegi2584 have you actually read Marx or are you having an emotional response to seeing someone praise the bad man?
makes sense coming from a highschooler
@@viet_171 try reading it again, and really sit with the insult you tried to use. Lol
You should've added the concept of 'Asabiyyah theorized by Ibn Khaldun in the Muqaddimah.
To add to race as a social construct. The society and culture of each “race” tends to reinforce their own differences, causing people to have children with people who look like them. This reinforces these racial divides and keeps the boundaries thriving.
It’s hard to imagine an America where a person would not say “im white/black/asian” etc compared to never stating it at all. Acknowledging this classification causes the classification to exist.
Just watched the whole thing, great as always :)))
lol bro was watching at 60x speed
At work, I smile and act like it's my life because of the pressure. As I'm driving home, I hate my job. I'm sure this fits into one if those chapters.
I‘m very thankful for this channel. great content i love every video. pls keep up the good work! i can assure you all your hard work was or is worth it !!
Please make more of these these are so good
Amazing video as always Duncan, may the Algorithm bless this video
A nick rochefort clip in this one and the sam hyde lock sound bite from the philosophy iceberg is my man Duncan an MDE fan
Amazing video! Keep up the good work and deep dives! 👌
Good to have you back was just getting to my 5th rewatch of all ur vids
these are actually down to earth and about things im always thinking about in my life whcih is great i totally didnt expect sociology to be this much of a w
Finally another Duncan video
Ironically, it feels like Weber's Iron Cage might be breaking down, at least at the fast food places I frequent, because the menu boards are used to show ads and promos most of the time, meaning I need to check if the item I want is still offered or 'converse' for a couple seconds before I can make a decision
Loved this vid. The Pygmalion Effect really hit home. All my teachers expected me to be a success. My classmates however thought I was a loser. I really don’t know what I am now. I am a graduate of Grad school but I still live with my mother and sister. Who was right?
Both, lol.
@@crix_h3eadshotgg992 Gee thanks!
Ur Italian breh ain’t that normal
nothing wrong with living with family. especially during a recession.
This Gemeinschaft versus Gesellschaft is also important in one huge area of Politics. Large Parts of the Alain de Benoist influenced european new right (and related persons like Dugin) have a slogan called "Gemeinschaft statt Gesellschaft" (Gemeinschaft instead of Gesellschaft).
These groups are opposed to modernity and what you called the Iron Cage. (Most times, they use the Heideggerian Term "Gestell" instead. Gestell is a german word describing a structure which forces components of a larger machine like a car to stay at their designated place to ensure their proper functioning and placement, keep their proper distance and prevent them from damaging each other. For example, if a motor moves too much, it might lose its connection to the fuel tank or if the connection to the fuel tank is elastic, too much movement might cause the machine to be inefficient because the fuel needs to travel larger distances to reach the motor. A Gestell prevents that. Heidegger called technologies influence on society and its drive for efficiency a "Gestell".)
And they are mostly traditionalists who want a kind of Confucianists or Hindu System where a priest has a certain degree of respect due to his priesthood, there are certain duties of fathers towards children and vice versa.
You read the book "radical conservatism", am I right?
RETURN OF THE KING
Great video dude, glad you are back.
Why are you describing me? I studied sociology for undergrad, anthropology for masters, and now, studying philosophy.
My individual agency is limited by my intersectionality: a brown Asian middle class female with an unseen disability (ADHD and anxiety).
But I dont victimize myself. Im just self-aware of what opportunities are available to me, then get by from what is available
Seeing Adam and Nick in this video is insane
Did not expect a CumTown/Trueanon cameo
@@rashid8646 that was so weird to me that i had to take a cock in my ass
Hate to draw comparisons, but this is so much better than that other guy that reads off of AI generated nonsense. Hope your channel blows up and you do some other content, be it video esaays, commentaries, deep dives and the like. Not that I don't like your content right now, just that inside these tier-lists and icebergs are specific topics that deserve their own videos imo. Have a wonderful day!
Thank you for making that high tier content for us
as we went deeper in iceberg, it started to feel more like a psychology lecture than sociology
Beautiful content, absolutely loved it ❤
Awesome, very clear and interesting video.
my favourite part of this video is when duncan said "its dunkin time!" and started duncin all over the place
I've watched this like 4 times now.
The whole Dramaturgical Analysis section perfectly explains why being neurodivergent is so exhausting
You know the candy stories where people thought that evil strangers were handing out candy, & yet the kids who were getting hurt by candy was due to their relatives, it reminds me of a video by Maggie Mae Fish about Twin Peaks. She talked about child abuse & stranger danger, how in the 80s everyone thought that their kid would be abducted & abused by a stranger in a van. Yet most cases of child abuse are perpetrated not by strangers, but by people kids trusted like their parents or other family members.
This is an interesting trend where people are more willing to talk about the danger of a mysterious boogeyman as opposed to people in their own group.
Thank you for putting out such great and videos!
I really like your channel and enjoy your content.
I find your videos very entertaining and informative.
Keep it up!
By the way the edited "The Big Lebowski" scene made my day 🤣
I'm amazed how being sociology major but in different country makes me look so different on the field. I knew all the things that you talked about but I would never said that they belong to the bottom tiers of the iceberg. For me Sociology becomes really strange when you start to deal with social ontology, or try to operationalize some philosophers that you would never connect with empirical studies, like Agamben or Augé. Overall great video, makes you think
literally kicked my feet when i saw a new duncan clarke video
I've been waiting for another iceberg ever since the linguistics one was released a year ago, this is going to be huge
Your videos are parallel to Rubik's cube.
Thank You.🍃
Ahh this brings me back to my “Intro to sociology” college course 🙂↕️
Love the videos!
This is amazing. We need more.
59:12 couldn't this just be because there are way more weak ties than strong ties
In half a year, I'll feel guilty for watching this again.
Awesome work bro!
I was literally just watching your philosophy iceberg, great timing
The king has returned!
we missed u
Amazing to see a new post from you!!
I've never had an original thought it turns out
Omg he is back!!
Love Duncan uploads!
Ah man, I was hoping for that Horse Shoe Theory _Live!_ iceberg.
the way I GASPED when I saw this nofication. I LOVE sociology sm and ur content is always top tier thank u for giving my life meaning for 2 hours ‼️‼️🗣🗣
Ik the iceberg format is horse so dead the body can't be found, but your icebergs are amazing you go indepth like literally no other content creator I know. I could keep gushing but you get the point. Your vids like this are awesome
I'll never stop loving iceberg videos 🥺
Omg I loved how you put the RuneScape logos up there for skill/votintgbooth and gp(money) 😂😂😂 made my morning
Love listening to this while going to sleep
Thank you Iceberg Video Guy, very cool
This is SENSATIONAL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
It's a different feeling watching one of these videos day 1 when you're not subbed to the channel.
Nice. Studied this stuff a decade ago nice to have the refresh. Always really interesting how the self is constructed through social interaction. Would be nice to have a neurological basis refresher too ;)
YEAHHHHH BABBYYYYYY that’s what I’ve been waiting forrrrrrr WOOOOOOOOOOOOOO🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Who else is watching in 2024???
shut up
(Video came out yesterday)
(Beans)
Any year 202 BC? 👇
Aye🙌
More background fodder. Tysm king
woah hey! good to see you
the mr beast portion of this hits different… guessing it was written before all the very recent happenings.
I watched through the first 15 minutes and the video looks very promising! Speaking of interactionism, Max Weber is totally unrelated, did you mean Georg Simmel? Moreover, I’d definitely mention Erving Goffman who was the most famous scholar who used this framework in empirical research rather than Cooley of Mead who were mostly thinkers.
Yeah that was really weird to see Weber mentioned along Mead. I’d say people like Weber and Simmel (to a larger extent) influenced with their more interpretation-based style the Chicago school with people like Goffman, though calling them a part of the same school of thought just feels a little wrong.
I spotted a couple of other mistakes. First, a major one, discussing protestant ethics, Max Weber is mentionned again in the context of interactionnism, but these two are from different realms. The second and the third are very minor issues. “Rich get richer and poor poorer” is mostly related to Matthiew effect (which should be in the iceberg), than to reproduction. Symbolic capital is built upon items from other capitals that are especially recognized in a specific field one’s acting. For instance, being able to write well (cultural capital) is barely recognized in the scientific field, but it’s of importance in the litterary field.
Babe wake up new Duncan Clarke video just dropped
2:35 u think u just fell out of a coconut tree? You exist in the context
Can t believe he remembered his password lmao good to be back!
you think this video didn’t take 4 months to make? I’m thankful as hell for these amazing videos
Aight can't wait for literature iceberg
i love these videos so much
Great video. I'm so simple. Life is what it is and we are who we are. I like to keep it there.
Hi Duncan, big fan, hope you are doing well. ❤
Thanks for the video, there are quite a few ideas I wasn’t aware of, especially towards the end. Sorry for occupying the comment section, but I'm fond of sociology :) I'd like to add things that allow us to go waaaaay deeper. These are my suggestions (from the tip towards the bottom):
- stigmatization (Goffman)
- techniques of the body (Mauss)
- rituals (van Guennep, Goffman, Bourdieu)
- total institutions (Goffman)
- social construction of scientific facts (Latour)
- unanticipated consequences (Merton)
- The Twofold Truth of Labour (Bourdieu)
- potlatch (Mauss)
- non-human agency (Latour/Callon)
- genius as a purposeful creation (Elias)
- the predominance of the right hand (Hertz, Tcherkezoff)
- social construction of consciousness (Elias)
22:25 that insane actually
Yessssssssssssss FINALLY interesting iceberg
Excellent video. I am now SOCIETY.
Good content keep up
Cool fantano reference
sociology Ice berg? Today is the best day ever