We Should Question World War 2
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 ก.ย. 2024
- Following the controversy stirred up by the Tucker Carlson interview with Daryl Cooper we argue that the bourgeois narrative on WW2 should be questioned properly.
Be sure to check out our website where you can find the latest articles:
marxengelsinst...
You can also find more of our work on our patreon page
www.patreon.co...
If you want to support the work we do here then you can also donate using the link below:
www.buymeacoff...
If you want to contact us you can do so on the following email address
editor@marxengelsinstitute.org
This was one of your best Streams ever Alexander! Thanks!
Yes, I totally agree. I've even downloaded the video to listen to it again.
1:51 Start
Cheers
Thanks
Alex ! You are a great student of history. Warm greetings from Cork, Ireland !
i watched that Garland & Joti interview on Proletarian TV on TH-cam (2 times so far), it was incredible imo.
Perhaps you could have her on as a guest someday
It would be great to hear from both for sure 👍
Thanks Alex, great video. Learning a lot since I have started to watch your videos. Regards from Queensland Australia.
Always an eye-opener. Many thanks.
Excelent show! I would recomend the work of french historian J. Chapoutot on how the nazism was not all that appart from colonial ideas and practices promoted by the french and english.
What is the name of the book? I was just thinking about the history of the second world war that can be relied on, I know it is not just that particular theme in history that is not easy to get reliable history books on, almost with any history we are presented with the same issue.
I might just check out the book you mention, as I am looking for a reliable history book on the subject.
Some of his books are translated in English. If you understand French, try to listen to some of his lectures in TH-cam.
th-cam.com/video/QeeiaOWBk_g/w-d-xo.htmlsi=bbDJMp5y_Pb3Nq1y
@@veramarquesalves7744 Thank you for letting me know. I will try to look at his English translations. I unfortunately and embarrassingly don't know French, but I will try to look at his English translations on Amazon.
Thank you so much for your reply.
Thank you Alexander excellent,
Thank you,,informative as always...
👏👏👏 you are a gem on TH-cam
My father faught the French Vichi in Syria in the early 1940"s. He was in the Seventh Division of The Australian Infantry Force. His Division was taken out of Syria and sent to New Guinea where he faught against the Japanese at Milne Bay.. In view of France having Fascist roots, I am strongly opposed to the French occupying a.position as a permanent member of th UN Security Councel.
You sound like an intelligent, educated, civilised guy but you really need to read what Douglas Read reveals about the Nuremberg charade in his book "The Controversy of Zion" (notably about personnel and the timing of the executions) to have any understanding of that unholy enterprise which is grounded in truth.
Douglas Read was the celebrated foreign correspondent of the Times from the early 1920s up to just before WW2 when he resigned in disgust over the kind of editorial suppression of the truth we have gotten so used to today from EVERY mainstream media outlet.
Thank you Alexander! You know how many arguments I had over the years (I am 71). I even argue now, but what I get is simple and repeated brainwashed replies. Even in University as a mature age student I relied mostly on Marx and Engles, plus my father's statement who was a Greek sailor before, during and after the 2nd world war. He always said thank the heavens for the Soviet Union or we would be kicked from here to the ends of the world. He passed away when the Berlin Wall fell-1989. He considered Mao great who made the Chinese 'people' again. He went to China before the war and hated how the people were treated (as slaves). Great work Comrade! (P S I told my 80 + Welsh friend that the red flag comes from Wales and he said he never knew that!).
I can recommend Jacques Pauwel's "The Myth of the Good War: America in the Second World War".
Can you give a paragraph cliff notes?
big ups for the video. I guess Feder's anti-usury policy was used to entice the working class's support. He was then replaced by Haljmar Schact whose personal connection to Montagu Norman and creating the Bank of International Settlements is interesting; the fellow certainly got around.
46:14 the Brits kept promising to the poles that if they keep up fighting the Germans then somehow someway the Brits will reach Poland and help them despite not lifting a finger.
first time i hear hudson's been ignoring the tendency of financialization of capital.. very surprising.. particularly because he isn't ..
also appealing to emotion (like calling the ruling class completely heartless plus some expletive) is probably nice but it's unscientific and is not marxist .. it's idealistic and probably not even true .. this is important because it just goes against the most basic marxist (and hegelian) truth that every consciousness begins from itself and it's own material conditions, and just blocks the understanding of why this or that class generally lacks empathy for their class opponent ...
Me too, first time to hear someone criticize Hudson. So much information on the internet, I will question Hudsons statements after this video.
@@Nasko789 nice.. you bulgarian ? ... i'm from dimitrovgrad..
@@tsenotanevmakedonec sum, dimitrovgrad vo bugarija pretpostavuvam?
@@Nasko789 yes .. bugarski dimitrovgrad... here we call *nasko* somebody who's name is atanas .. or anastas ..
Michael Hudson is literally the god-son of trotsky. He seems to be constantly pining for "industrial capitalism" (i.e. capitalism) and dumping on "Stalinism" (i.e. socialism).
Thanks again, any chance you have a podcast form of your live stream?
I’d like it very much if this could be a podcast, as well.
🛸question everything
Was zelensky ever into art?
No,,but he was a good pianist...
Is this Daryl Cooper?
I love your show but you have not obviously been engaged with Hudson's work too deeply. Unless you've read or a great deal of all his work, how do you know what exactly he has or has not engaged in and how can you purport to be such an authority on what his work does or does not address.
Thank you Alexander. I would like to know your views on the Antony Sutton book: Wall Street & the Rise of Hitler.