My guess is that the two men singing that note took breaks at different times in such a way as to give the continuity to the note. I am a baritone and I tried it and I highly doubt it is practical that anyone held that note that long
At 10:18, I believe it is F2 -> Eb2 -> C#2 -> Ab2 -> Bb2... meaning it goes up. But check out that great C2 that follows at 10:24. I also had some different measurements with a few other places, and if I am right there could be more omissions anywhere else. Nevertheless, this video is genius from start to finish... The designated "Bb1" after 3:32, I hear no Bb1, instead, I hear F2 (not C#2) then Bb2 (not 1) > F2-F2 > Eb3 > C#3 > C3 > Bb2 (the F2 is the only place I hear the bass split away to lower notes from the baritone -> on "da-da" in "pa-DA-DA..."). For the very next clip with multiple labels of "Bb1", I hear no Bb1 at all. Instead, I hear the basses singing no other note but G2 for every syllable. Also, for the very next clip that is labelled A1, I hear A2 not A1. After EJ sings "good will to everyone" I hear the bass sing E2 -> A2 -> C#2, going up to merge with the baritone after the E2, not down. Another one... At 2:16, the basses do drop down to C#2 as correctly shown but then the repeated "dum's" they make next in the same clip are F#2s not C#2s as they were labelled. BTW starting at 2:32, there are C2s that were missed: the bass to the screen-right starts singing "yona yona"??? (I don't know what is being said) but an octaves lower so he goes back and forth from C#2 to C2, the steady C#2 from earlier in the segment at 2:26 had already been faded out before that point.
I wish they would give the Basses a few pieces here and there to hear their ability. They're just as accomplished as the rest of them but never get any real time to shine. The only time I can think of a belter the basses got was in that Halloween collab with Paint.
To this day, I am not satisfied that Sarah is Alto. She has such a clean and crystal clear voice, light and with almost no weight in the bass. Her singing the Mermaid song doesn't sound like Alto. Is she really a Alto?
She lightened her voice when singing that solo to fit the part better. Perhaps it's also because she discovered that she sounds a LOT like Jodi Benson when she does that. Sarah's an alto - listen to ' the man with the bag' to get an idea of what she normally sounds like. Believe it or not, Chrystal actually has a higher voice - she's a soprano! Jamey just writes individual parts for each singer, and Chrystal happens to have a fantastic tone in her low end.
Glenn Miller would sound really good in this setting, if that would ever be possible. Karl Hudson is a fantastic bass that can hit a resonant C2, but Glenn Miller is Glenn Miller. He also has a nice high range that would easily fit with the higher bass parts.
@@abedinsubashi some baritones can sing F#1 with subs. That’s not very low for subs, and it’s definitely not oktavist level since the real ones sing in chest voice.
The stuff from A1-C2 here is a good example of mixed chest/fry. Still legitimate singing but the vocal structure is starting to slacken a bit too much, and you can hear the resulting extra "buzz" on top of the note.
That’s likely from JC, the older white guy. He has tremendous power in his low range but I’d call him more of a low baritone than a bass - he bottoms out right around C. Karl Hudson, the African American man, has a lower voice and can hit those notes, although I’d imagine A is probably about his basement.
@@charliecampbell6851 If you can get a low C with decent power you're probably a bass-baritone or bass. Not necessarily a profundo, though. Karl Hudson, based on what you said, sounds at least like he's a low bass if not a profundo.
jc is a low-placed baritone and his lowest chest note is typically somewhere around D2-C2, whereas karl is actually a true bass and bottoms out at like Bb1-A1. i wish he would sing lead more often to let him show off his low chest notes bc he, as a true bass, is very valuable as most acapella groups struggle to find true basses due to them making up like 1/40th of the population
@@heliotropeskies5918 Good info, though I think you're probably being WAY too generous with that 1/40th statistic. It's probably more like half that for the population of people who sing and far lower for the population in general. To be fair, however, I do think Vladimir Miller's comment about "one million people, one basso profundo" might be too far in the other direction.
@@GamingDrummer89 its just an approximation as choir is split into tenor parts and bass parts and the extremity of the range therein is determined by whether or not it's part 1 or 2. approximately 1 in 20 people who sing bass in a choir are true basses so depending on whether that statistic is founded upon whether thats bass 1 and 2 or juts bass 2. that would make it somewhere between about 1/40th of the male population are basses to like 1/150th of the population are basses and 1 in probably like 15 of those basses is a profundo if i had to guess
It would have been very easy for the producer to simply record each voice during warm ups. She/he did not; and we received a wonderful montage of their voices and spirits.
Hi, there’s not a higher note in there. Likely just your ears buzzing back at you. I have a similar experience with a few songs from Voces8 where I swear I can hear screamer notes but nobody else can.
Also, did you know that Krystal and the bass joined within the past 2 years, and the "numerous" clips that you are referring to were published before that point?
I wish they would give the Basses a few pieces here and there to hear their ability. They're just as accomplished as the rest of them but never get any real time to shine. The only time I can think of a belter the basses got was in that Halloween collab with Paint.
Unfortunately, the creater(s) of Voctave decided to feature the Sopranos because, the audience seems to relate more to the melody. But if you interviewed the members of the ensemble, they would swear that they are a 'team' and no one gets favorable solos...but get parts assigned based on their given skill set. I hope this makes sense.
That sopranos G6 was so loud and resonant....not whistle but in head voice omg
wasnt resonant but ya
@@uiteren2845 ???
Nadiv Kaspi it wasnt resonant because it wasnt supported but it was loud
I disagree
i melt back into my seat whenever kate lott hit those crazy notes....the control that woman has is astounding to say the least.
Drew Sisco YEEEESSSS ME TOO
Nice to see people appreciate low notes as much as the highs... They are epic though.
Oh my.... C2 in 33 seconds,,, insane...!!
Sigit Gozy that lungs tho
My guess is that the two men singing that note took breaks at different times in such a way as to give the continuity to the note. I am a baritone and I tried it and I highly doubt it is practical that anyone held that note that long
Sigit Gozy Yes, it is! I have a pretty big lung and can hold a C2 for about 30 seconds but it is SO hard!
I can do D#2 in 39 seconds
@@weareone267 congratulations
holy f*ckin sh*t, a supported G6. Best of the best of the bes....
Kate, straight splendor!
beautiful work. thanks for the subtitles showing the notes. The sopranos give me incentive to learn more. love you all.
Kate’s E flats are her money note - the love medley and their most recent collaboration with Kirstin both have stunning E flats.
there's a A1 and a B1 in the background at 1:17 too before they end higher on the E1
Beautiful people!!!
I love all of them!
So much talent in one place!
At 9:30 she's like *F YEAH IM NAILING IT*
I made the high notes of the soprano Kate Lott of Voctave here :)
th-cam.com/video/XKcOH5F_8H0/w-d-xo.html
so you're saying that kate sung that G6 in head!!! unbelievable
Am I crazy for hearing an Ab1 at 10:21?
F2 -> Eb2 -> C#2 -> Ab1 -> Bb1
At 10:18, I believe it is F2 -> Eb2 -> C#2 -> Ab2 -> Bb2... meaning it goes up. But check out that great C2 that follows at 10:24.
I also had some different measurements with a few other places, and if I am right there could be more omissions anywhere else. Nevertheless, this video is genius from start to finish...
The designated "Bb1" after 3:32, I hear no Bb1, instead, I hear F2 (not C#2) then Bb2 (not 1) > F2-F2 > Eb3 > C#3 > C3 > Bb2 (the F2 is the only place I hear the bass split away to lower notes from the baritone -> on "da-da" in "pa-DA-DA...").
For the very next clip with multiple labels of "Bb1", I hear no Bb1 at all. Instead, I hear the basses singing no other note but G2 for every syllable.
Also, for the very next clip that is labelled A1, I hear A2 not A1. After EJ sings "good will to everyone" I hear the bass sing E2 -> A2 -> C#2, going up to merge with the baritone after the E2, not down.
Another one... At 2:16, the basses do drop down to C#2 as correctly shown but then the repeated "dum's" they make next in the same clip are F#2s not C#2s as they were labelled.
BTW starting at 2:32, there are C2s that were missed: the bass to the screen-right starts singing "yona yona"??? (I don't know what is being said) but an octaves lower so he goes back and forth from C#2 to C2, the steady C#2 from earlier in the segment at 2:26 had already been faded out before that point.
I wish they would give the Basses a few pieces here and there to hear their ability. They're just as accomplished as the rest of them but never get any real time to shine. The only time I can think of a belter the basses got was in that Halloween collab with Paint.
He likes to tease with the basses. Always leaving you wanting more. Brilliant writing I feel.
To this day, I am not satisfied that Sarah is Alto. She has such a clean and crystal clear voice, light and with almost no weight in the bass. Her singing the Mermaid song doesn't sound like Alto. Is she really a Alto?
She lightened her voice when singing that solo to fit the part better. Perhaps it's also because she discovered that she sounds a LOT like Jodi Benson when she does that. Sarah's an alto - listen to ' the man with the bag' to get an idea of what she normally sounds like. Believe it or not, Chrystal actually has a higher voice - she's a soprano! Jamey just writes individual parts for each singer, and Chrystal happens to have a fantastic tone in her low end.
I feel like this group would be amazing with an oktavist.
Odhran Winters David Kahn would be a really good addition. He can go as low as an F#1 with subharmonics. He can also belt a C5
Glenn Miller would sound really good in this setting, if that would ever be possible. Karl Hudson is a fantastic bass that can hit a resonant C2, but Glenn Miller is Glenn Miller. He also has a nice high range that would easily fit with the higher bass parts.
@@abedinsubashi some baritones can sing F#1 with subs. That’s not very low for subs, and it’s definitely not oktavist level since the real ones sing in chest voice.
@@abedinsubashi David Kahn is an amazing bass, but no oktavist.
Fucking love JC
Blair De La Rosa that's the bass right?
Blair De La Rosa i think so
yea dat
Is EJ mixing those notes?😍😍
amazing ...angelic
10:46 is this edited or ARE THERE REALLY FIRST OCTAVE NOTES BC I CAN HEAR A C#1!!!
@@KajiVocals Dang, and now they have an F1 on the new album. I’m excited to see if they do it lower Jejeje.
The stuff from A1-C2 here is a good example of mixed chest/fry. Still legitimate singing but the vocal structure is starting to slacken a bit too much, and you can hear the resulting extra "buzz" on top of the note.
That’s likely from JC, the older white guy. He has tremendous power in his low range but I’d call him more of a low baritone than a bass - he bottoms out right around C. Karl Hudson, the African American man, has a lower voice and can hit those notes, although I’d imagine A is probably about his basement.
@@charliecampbell6851 If you can get a low C with decent power you're probably a bass-baritone or bass. Not necessarily a profundo, though. Karl Hudson, based on what you said, sounds at least like he's a low bass if not a profundo.
jc is a low-placed baritone and his lowest chest note is typically somewhere around D2-C2, whereas karl is actually a true bass and bottoms out at like Bb1-A1. i wish he would sing lead more often to let him show off his low chest notes bc he, as a true bass, is very valuable as most acapella groups struggle to find true basses due to them making up like 1/40th of the population
@@heliotropeskies5918 Good info, though I think you're probably being WAY too generous with that 1/40th statistic. It's probably more like half that for the population of people who sing and far lower for the population in general. To be fair, however, I do think Vladimir Miller's comment about "one million people, one basso profundo" might be too far in the other direction.
@@GamingDrummer89 its just an approximation as choir is split into tenor parts and bass parts and the extremity of the range therein is determined by whether or not it's part 1 or 2. approximately 1 in 20 people who sing bass in a choir are true basses so depending on whether that statistic is founded upon whether thats bass 1 and 2 or juts bass 2. that would make it somewhere between about 1/40th of the male population are basses to like 1/150th of the population are basses and 1 in probably like 15 of those basses is a profundo if i had to guess
Nice!
It would have been very easy for the producer to simply record each voice during warm ups. She/he did not; and we received a wonderful montage of their voices and spirits.
9:26 mixed or HV D6?
It's HV. You can hear also the D5 of E.J. so it may confuse you :)
FeDsax98 thank you ^^
FeDsax98 yea i heard EJ too
9:56 After around two seconds I seem to hear a second, much higher note.
Is that an A6, whistle-like, I'm hearing at 9:58 ?
No,there's no much higher note in there..she's just sustained that note but not going higher..that's it!
Alright, maybe I'm hearing some sort of overtones OR it's just that my ears are ringing >.>
Hi, there’s not a higher note in there. Likely just your ears buzzing back at you. I have a similar experience with a few songs from Voces8 where I swear I can hear screamer notes but nobody else can.
Yeah, but I hear an Eb8 😂
10:46
I wonder what a tenor G6 would sound like
3:27
God girl! Shew!....
This type of music doesnt do anything for me but these singers are shockingly talented
that's my vocal range lol
Bo•Prince the thing is: does it sound good? My total “Range” is B0-C#6 but that doesn’t necessarily mean I can sing in that range.
n i c c I can go up to a fugging G79 if I see a roach
Not to be rude but it probably doesn’t sound 1/8 as good as these singers do.
My vocal range is like of Kate Lott. I can sing the high notes and it is so easy to me
Why did you feel the need to mention this?
Slimse T right!!!!
Hey,you don't need to be rude..what the heck?!!
Bruhhhhhhhh🙄🙄🙄
Wow, I can't help but wonder how many hours were put in to avoid showing the two black singers in this video.
what the hell is wrong with you
you're so right. I didn't even realise it. Where are Chrystal and the dude?
Would you like me to timestamp all the times they both appear just to prove you wrong, or why don't you try watching the video again.
Also, did you know that Krystal and the bass joined within the past 2 years, and the "numerous" clips that you are referring to were published before that point?
@@slimset4532 would u like to timestamp when i started caring about what u have to say abt this? you'll have to wait tho, that part hasn't come up yet
I wish they would give the Basses a few pieces here and there to hear their ability. They're just as accomplished as the rest of them but never get any real time to shine. The only time I can think of a belter the basses got was in that Halloween collab with Paint.
Lanky I really agree!
They do get to shine; it's folks like you (who pay attention to the details) who give them the credit they deserve! :)
Lanky listen to You're a mean one Mr. Grinch
Unfortunately, the creater(s) of Voctave decided to feature the Sopranos because, the audience seems to relate more to the melody. But if you interviewed the members of the ensemble, they would swear that they are a 'team' and no one gets favorable solos...but get parts assigned based on their given skill set. I hope this makes sense.
@@Bowling_Dude one song