Btw, look at Chris Rupp’s reaction video to their moana medley, in the comments he said that he contacted Geoff and the bass when Geoff sings lead is actually Geoff multitracked :))
Interesting video and great work! Corrections: -1:30 I know also PJS has written F2 but it's actually a F# -Eli's chest range actually stops at Eb2, the rest is non-melodic and in Moana isn't him -6:20 he also hit a chest Bb1 -8:38 I thought it too but probably G1 growl -8:50 only reaches F#1, if there was a E1 it wouldn't be countable anyway -10:53 chest -11:22 F# -11:31 not the lowest recorded subharmonic note (B0 if you believe at Warriors, if not C#1) -12:05 not the lowest recorded growl note (live B0 + end of Moana) -J. None has a Bb4 and his highest mixed note is C5 -17:50 falsetto -19:30 probably head note, very well sustained, it'a too high for him to be mixed -20:00 these Earl's high notes are just cries, and the same for Eli at 20:30 and all the others cries -22:00 F# So without counting fry: Geoff: B0-F#1-B4-Eb5-A5 Eli: C2-E5 Earl: A1-F#2-F#5-G#5 J: F#1-C2-A4-C5-B5 Layne: G0-Bb1-Bb4-B5
thanks for the comment, i mainly agree. I believe that 8:38 is most likely chest. also, the notes in warriors are actually pitched down by one octave (they confirmed that in their newest q&a) in the same livestream, they also confirmed that eli has a super low range and sang bass in moana. i actually do believe that geoffs g#5 is mixed, sounds very much like that. for me, at least elis notes around 20:30 are countable. im not sure whether it's chest or head voice (or even mix?) at 17:50. do you have a link for geoffs b0 growl and do you know in which song j hits the Bb4?
@@TM-pf1kp you can watch my video of Geoff Castellucci Ultimated Vocal Range for thr B0; he sings a Bb4 in Queen in 5 Min and it should be included in his vocal range by Marcello Bass
@@TM-pf1kp Nah the Moana medley eli didn't sing the bass, he was just lip syncing - th-cam.com/video/8KXnB9jWa6I/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=TheCharismaticVoice timestamp 53:20
8:40 is growl Also I think Layne’s G0 is artificial 10:55 is chest I don’t think Earl’s chest voice goes that high, neither does Eli. Eli’s E5 is mixed for sure, as well as some notes below Nice compilation
I absolutely love Eli even for his low note, J none is so perfect for the low note brought a lot of soul, the king of low of the lowest note and the core of Voiceplay is Geoff. Lyane Stein is known as inhale and exhale singing. Everything is perfect.
We will miss his Energy that he bring in Voiceplay. We absolutely miss his high note. I know that J None and Eil will always hitting the high note in place of Earl Elkin Jr. 🥺
Layne's G0 is not real. It was lowered down in editing. You can hear that his town changes in an artificial way when he goes down. Also it's weird that his throat bass range goes from D1 to G0. It's a huge gap so it's weird that there's nothing in between.
eli's line in moana is actually geoff layne says so in an interview
This video is so amazing! It needs MUCH MORE views!!!
wow, thanks :D
@@TM-pf1kp: what is your vocal range? Just wondering.
Btw, look at Chris Rupp’s reaction video to their moana medley, in the comments he said that he contacted Geoff and the bass when Geoff sings lead is actually Geoff multitracked :))
Interesting video and great work!
Corrections:
-1:30 I know also PJS has written F2 but it's actually a F#
-Eli's chest range actually stops at Eb2, the rest is non-melodic and in Moana isn't him
-6:20 he also hit a chest Bb1
-8:38 I thought it too but probably G1 growl
-8:50 only reaches F#1, if there was a E1 it wouldn't be countable anyway
-10:53 chest
-11:22 F#
-11:31 not the lowest recorded subharmonic note (B0 if you believe at Warriors, if not C#1)
-12:05 not the lowest recorded growl note (live B0 + end of Moana)
-J. None has a Bb4 and his highest mixed note is C5
-17:50 falsetto
-19:30 probably head note, very well sustained, it'a too high for him to be mixed
-20:00 these Earl's high notes are just cries, and the same for Eli at 20:30 and all the others cries
-22:00 F#
So without counting fry:
Geoff: B0-F#1-B4-Eb5-A5
Eli: C2-E5
Earl: A1-F#2-F#5-G#5
J: F#1-C2-A4-C5-B5
Layne: G0-Bb1-Bb4-B5
thanks for the comment, i mainly agree. I believe that 8:38 is most likely chest. also, the notes in warriors are actually pitched down by one octave (they confirmed that in their newest q&a) in the same livestream, they also confirmed that eli has a super low range and sang bass in moana. i actually do believe that geoffs g#5 is mixed, sounds very much like that. for me, at least elis notes around 20:30 are countable. im not sure whether it's chest or head voice (or even mix?) at 17:50. do you have a link for geoffs b0 growl and do you know in which song j hits the Bb4?
@@TM-pf1kp you can watch my video of Geoff Castellucci Ultimated Vocal Range for thr B0; he sings a Bb4 in Queen in 5 Min and it should be included in his vocal range by Marcello Bass
@@alebormio4842 yeah i knew about the Bb4 in quenn in 5 min and i included it at first, but it doesn't really sound like chest to me.
@@TM-pf1kp Nah the Moana medley eli didn't sing the bass, he was just lip syncing - th-cam.com/video/8KXnB9jWa6I/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=TheCharismaticVoice timestamp 53:20
8:38 could be growl but it's slightly off key at the start so it is a F#1 but goes to a G1
8:40 is growl
Also I think Layne’s G0 is artificial
10:55 is chest
I don’t think Earl’s chest voice goes that high, neither does Eli. Eli’s E5 is mixed for sure, as well as some notes below
Nice compilation
11:20 is F#1
8:40: Lyane Stein actually hit A0.
@@deanmarion5477 what
@@matthewdockray9745: yup, not G0
I absolutely love Eli even for his low note, J none is so perfect for the low note brought a lot of soul, the king of low of the lowest note and the core of Voiceplay is Geoff. Lyane Stein is known as inhale and exhale singing. Everything is perfect.
Just only a slight correction is that the G#1 u showcased as a subharmonic was a chest note in the song “kiss”
Are you talking about Geoff
@@deanmarion5477 yeah
@@White2530: 🤤
@@deanmarion5477 tf my guy 😂
@@White2530: I know, we love his subharmonic.
Good vid bro but there are some things that could be fixed. The "A#1" in Queen in five minutes is supposed to be a Bb1.
that's - literally the same note?
i even wrote Bb1
what other things are wrong?
@@TM-pf1kp i didnt even think abt it bro. Sorry. And the G#1 in Kiss is a chest note. Not a subharmonic. And Layne's "G0" is an A0.
@@skylarwalton5381 yeah you're most likely right on these ones
@@TM-pf1kp im gonna go back through and see if there are anymors
Earl is leaving the group 🤧
😓
We will miss his Energy that he bring in Voiceplay. We absolutely miss his high note. I know that J None and Eil will always hitting the high note in place of Earl Elkin Jr. 🥺
It’s funny listening to everyone’s lowest notes and then Geoff is half an octave lower in the background
Layne's G0 is not real. It was lowered down in editing. You can hear that his town changes in an artificial way when he goes down. Also it's weird that his throat bass range goes from D1 to G0. It's a huge gap so it's weird that there's nothing in between.
@kobeteam777_Gaming: I thought is G0, now I understand now.
@kobeteam777_Gaming: 😁