He read the story while sitting in the bus station and couldn’t get it out of his head, so he wrote the song. It’s very haunting. Gordon Lighfoot is, without a doubt, a living legend here in Canada.
I love that he wrote such a touching song to bring awareness of this tragedy. Also, I read that Gordon donated all the proceeds of this song to help the families that were directly affected by this tragedy. A heartwarming and wonderful gesture. Thank,s for this reaction.,
One of the true Canadian gems was Stompin' Tom Connors. He travelled around Canada writing songs about the people, places, and experiences he had. A real man of the common man and a great storyteller.
I grew up listening to Stompin' Tom!! "I'm Bud the Spud from the bright red mud, rollin' down the highway, smilin'"!! He sang such iconic Canadian songs!!!
We have a bronze statue of Stompin' Tom here in Sudbury! We can stop by and pay our respects when we're downtown getting stink-o on a Sudbury Saturday Night!
Gordon Lightfoot - November 17, 1938 - May 1, 2023 - RIP Gordon Lightfoot and thank you for sharing your incredible talent with the world. You were one of a kind and will be missed by millions.
Gordon wrote this because he was angered that the newspaper accounts were so shoddy, most of them mis spelled the name of the ship. It should have been front page news, but some stuck the story further back. He felt an injustice had been done to those who had lost their lives. He researched it, and wrote the song. All proceeds from record sales were given to the families. Gordon attended every memorial every year in Detroit. He’s a good age now so I don’t know if he was able to keep it up. Another song he did chronicling an historical event is “ Black Day in July” about the 1967 riots in Detroit.
It’s interesting that it’s still pretty inaccurate. He was confronted with some of it as new info emerged and now performs lyrics differently when in concert.
@@Kal_El_Krypton The only inaccuracy is the hatch caving in. When he wrote the song there was no info on what caused the wreck. That's the lyric that he changed. It's still not known for sure, but they think either the freighter ended up riding the crest of two waves, and the boat just broke in half (it was overloaded), or dove into a wave and just never came back up. The waves were immense in the storm, and the forces boats are subjected to on Lake Superior are enormous.
From the very 1st note, my eyes began to water.😥 I'm a Canadian who who was 21 y.o. at the time and living in Ft. Erie, Ontaro when this happened. I have heard this song a million times through my long life and Gordon Lightfoot is one of our prouder moments. Thank you for this video. Oddly, today is Nov. 12 as I watch this and the Fitzgerald went down on Nov 10, 1975 and located Nov 14th, 1975. And, FYI, she was carrying taconite iron ore from mines near Duluth, Minnesota to iron works in Detroit, Michigan, Toledo, Ohio and other Great Lake ports. She had been doing this run for 17 years until the day of her ill-fated final voyage. I only just found you and love how empathetic you are. Keep 'em coming.
Lightfoot also sang Black Day in July, about the riots in Detroit in 1967...There have been a lot of Canadian groups and artists making socially important statements in their songs...
I was thinking of Black Day in July. There is a good video on here with archival footage. My husband is Alaskan, and I played it for him, and he had never learned about the riots. He was really impressed with the song.
First concert I ever attended was Gordon Lightfoot in Place des Arts in Montreal. It was 1969 and he sang "Black Day in July." He is truly a Canadian icon.
This song takes you from the couch to a horrible day in the middle of the cold cruel and beautiful Lake Superior…Gordon told the story, he didn’t focus on or try to perform a vocal masterpiece, although it was exceptional as well…he wanted the audience to listen to the story, feel what those poor sailers felt and its consequences to them, their community and family. The instrumental accompaniment was brilliant, starting slowly and simple building stronger like the storm itself…. storytelling in its finest form.
I love seeing this John. Gordon Lightfoot was my father's favorite artist. As a Canadian it really warms my heart seeing an American espousing the virtues of one of the greatest Canadian artists that never really gained a real significant amount of notoriety in the States. He is such an amazing storyteller. His lyrics are always so poignant. I'm a new subscriber and I've really enjoyed your history videos. It's always interesting hearing reactions and observations about Canadiana from foreigners. Even from one like yourself that has some foreknowledge about the subject matter. Keep up the great work. If you do decide to do more of these Canadian song or musician reactions might I advise not doing the more renowned artists South of the border to start with. I know you mentioned absolute icons like Rush, Neil Young and The Band (man, isn't Robbie Robertson just incredible?). They all should and absolutely deserve to be discussed in a cultural and historical sense. But instead I would suggest learning about and reacting to Canada's most beloved band that very few (and I really do mean very few) Americans have ever even heard of... The Tragically Hip. They are really Canada's band. We hold them so close to our heart's because their songs are simply dripping with Canadiana. The fact that they were so huge here and completely overlooked south of the boarder also contributes to their love from Canadians. Like Gordon Lightfoot they are incredible storytellers. When Gord Downie (The Hip's lead singer) died I read an article, I think it was in Rolling Stone, where the author called Downie Canada's Bob Dylan. Wheat Kings, Grace Too, Fiddler's Green and Ahead by a Century are all incredible examples of how strong their songwriting was. But if you plan to go down The Hip rabbit hole of song reactions I suggest you start with "38 Years Old". Trust me, you'll be hooked. Cheers from a northern cousin.
Yes, yes and yes. Thanks so much for the suggestion. I totally agree. The one thing I thought of doing with the Band is Acadian Driftwood. It’s not as well known here as songs like the Weight and it tells a Canadian story. But I don’t think I’ve ever heard a Tragically Hip song so you have piqued my interest for sure.
@@johnf-americanreacts1287 Oh man, I had forgotten about Acadian Driftwood. Great pull! I'm gonna have to see if I can find it on TH-cam later. I haven't heard that song in forever. As for my Hip suggestion, I'm going to apologize in advance. Every American friend that I've introduced to The Hip have all exclaimed "how have I never heard of these guys?!?" and became kind of addicted. The Hip aren't as technically sound as say Rush or The Band. But their raw and scaled back rock sound is really captivating. They may very well become your favorite new hidden gem of a band. Enjoy.
@@johnf-americanreacts1287 You must check out The Hip (as we call them). Grace, Too would be my recommendation for first song by them..... ;-) They have many, many really great songs.... Loving your channel, thanks for your content!!!
@@johnf-americanreacts1287 - Burton Cummings an amazing voice. Zal Yanovski of the Lovin' Spoonful. Denny Doherty of the Mamas and the Papas. Joni Mitchell. KD Lang. Leonard Cohen. Celine Dion. I'm probably older than most here but these folks from the 60's and 70's were top notch. I also loved Great Big Sea from Newfoundland.
As a ex Canadian sailor I can say each trip through the Sault Ste Marie locks was humbling. There is a lifeboat and life preserver from the Fitz resting in the center of the locks. Every time we went through the locks, the entire crew stopped what they doing if they were able to and gave their thoughts and prayers to those brave men who never made it home. As a resident of the area, it is a known fact that the big lake never gives up her dead in any instance. The water is too cold. It only changes a couple of degrees between summer and winter. The bodies do not bloat and float to the surface because of the water temperature. They just sink. Terrible description but it is the explanation.
Thank you John for highlighting Gordon. Living along the Detroit River I watch the huge freighters daily. I often think of the Edmund Fitzgerald and the tragedy that took the lives of the sailors that November. This song has a very haunting melody that can’t be forgotten and Gordon Lightfoot does a fantastic job telling the story. He is one of Canada’s greatest songwriter/storytellers. Thanks again for this. 👏👏🇨🇦🇨🇦
@@laurabailey1054 I don't remember the reporter, do you know his name. I remember Jacques Cousteau came to check out the ship, we were waiting at the river to see the Calypso go by. Was surprised by how small it was.
Gordon Lightfoot is an amazing artist and storyteller. This particular song is haunting and you can’t help but sing along with it. We had to remember the lyrics of the song like it was a poem when I was in grade 8. Another artist you may want to check out is Stan Rogers and two of songs, The Northwest Passage (which some Canadians wanted as our national anthem) and Bluenose (after a famous ship - it’s on our dime).
Some amazing songs Stan Roger's wrote. Very much a Canadian legend. Underappreciated and was taken out too soon. His death was tragic and heroic. His brother Garnet has a great catalogue of music too. For Stan, I would also recommend Lies and Lock-Keeper. Also the a capella Barrett's Privateers. For Garnet, I would recommend Frankie and Johnny, his cover of King of Rome, or This Shirt.
I live in Gordon Lightfoot's home town of Orillia, Ontario. There is a bust of him in front of the Orillia Opera House and a lane named after him. You might also want to listen to his song "Sundown" among others. The Stephen Leacock museum is also in Orillia.
I’m loving these little anecdotes and bits of information. Thanks. Funny story, I was listening to Sundown and Gordon sang the line about finding some creeping down her back stairs, and my 9 year old daughter asked, why would someone do that? Are they a burger? To which I of course answered yes. 😂
As a Canadian, I love and support our great Canadian Musicians.. I dont think the rest of the World realizes how great our Musical history really is. Thank you for showcasing the great Gordon Lightfoot..an amazing artist.
I was happy to begin with someone I know well who I know is underexposed here in the US. I’ve been getting a lot of great suggestions of artists I don’t know and I am excited to explore coming up soon. Thanks for the comment Glenna.
The Edmund Fitzgerald passed by on the river I live near at least 2 to 3 times a week, it's a huge ship and very recognizable. The night it sank the winds were extremely high, the bridge connecting Canada and the US was even swaying a bit. I went down toward the river to see if I could see the bridge swaying and had to turn back, the wind almost blew me on the road, I couldn't imagine what the ships must of been going through. The next morning we found out that beautiful ship sunk. It was heading back to our river and going to Zug Island. The loss of the poor crew was heartbreaking and that incredible ship, the Edmund Fitzgerald was sorely missed
So glad you examined this masterwork. Don't know if you've heard of it, or perhaps even listened to it, but I highly recommend Gordon's tribute to Canada, "The Canadian Railroad Trilogy". It should be our national anthem. Thanks, and keep up the good work.
I have the Canadian Railroad Trilogy on one of my vinyls, Gord’s Gold. I love the song but I haven’t listened since I started this channel and I think I’ll do it here too. I’m sure I’ll have a different perspective and appreciation for it now. Thanks for the suggestion and for watching.
I'm a 56 year old Canadian, and I've been listening to this song for most of my life, but I still tear up when I listen to it. Also, Sundown is another great song from this storyteller.
One of my favourite songs from one of my favourite artists. The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald still brings chills, after all these years! Thanks for this video.
Thanks for the terrific video. Two other Canadian musicians that might not be so well known by Americans are Bruce Cockburn and Stan Rogers, both singer-songwriters. Cheers!
The line that always gets me is the cook saying " fellas, it's been good to know ya's " This artist doesn't just write songs, he crafts them. Canadian Gold !! My favorite by Gordon Lightfoot is "The Way I Feel ", a pretty unknown song of his. Good job on the reaction !
You talked at the beginning of Canada exporting culture. One modern export, is the legendary Terry Fox’s story and his accomplishments! There are videos on TH-cam about him, and his historic run. If any knows what the best one is, please leave a link, for me, they all make me cry! Stay safe, stay sane, stay Strong Ukraine 🇺🇦
I’ve seen Neil young twice! He was fantastic with pot smoke in the air! Lol. Gordon Lightfoot taps his foot on a board and goes through it every time he sings!
So haunting. Artists like GL make me proud to be Canadian. I've listened to that song at least 100 times on my play list, and probably 100 more. Thank you for your tribute to him.
Something you might want to search out and or focus your channel on for a day or two is ... how Canadians live their lives .... we are simple but good people ... we live life hard ... we are highly educated ... and we treat people well. Our music as you have found is based upon living life. I'm a west coast seafarer and love that fact. I have lived my life on the Pacific, have salt water in my veins and have webs between my toes to prove it. I am of Icelandic heritage, hailing in Canada from Gimli, Manitoba (or in otherwords New Iceland) , and could not call myself prouder to declare ... I am Canadian. You will not find this kind of love for country anywhere else on the planet ... other than in Canada. Canada is my home and my great passion.
@@johnf-americanreacts1287 You might have to do the different regions in Canada separately as while we are all Canadian, we all differ from each other. My favourite Gordon Lightfoot song is Early Morning Rain. Great video, John! Thank you!
I absolutely love Gimli, Manitoba. I'm into aviation, especially commercial airliners. The story of Air Canada Flight 143 and the calm bravery and steady hands of Captain Bob Pearson and First Officer Maurice Quintal landing the crippled Boeing 767 at the decommissioned air force base in Gimli is awe inspiring. Canadian courage at it's finest. The Gimli Glider is legendary.
I got repetitive full body goosebumps. On this momentous and busy day, amongst all else, something made me check your channel, and although I haven't sung this song for awhile, I remembered every word. I had the privilege of meeting and knowing Gordon Lightfoot many a time, including after his stroke when he played at the Old Massey Hall to an audience of two, one being me. I was good friends with his neighbor in an enclave near St. Clair and Yonge in Toronto where he lives, and can I just say what a humble, modest, and oh so real human he is. Not a whiff of superiority about him. His ability to weave stories into songs is second to none, and I thank you more than I can say for bringing it all back to me. I've travelled and sailed on each of the Great Lakes, swam and camped and cottaged and lived on and near them. All comes flooding back to me in mental images, so thank you, thank you, thank you. A bronze sculpture was unveilled in Orillia, Ontario, where he was born some years back, and he really didn't know what all the fuss was about.
Wow! What a privilege. I got that sense about him from a few interviews I’ve watched. To be honest, I only really discovered him a few years ago. Yes, as a music fan I knew of him and if you asked me 5 years who he was, I would have said a Canadian folk singer that sings that song Sundown. Then one day I was relaxing listening to a Bob Dylan station on Pandora and If You Could Read My Mind came on. I know I had heard it before, but I had never truly listened to it. It is a beautiful song. From there I got hooked and went all in.
@@johnf-americanreacts1287 I'm so glad you discovered him. He has a truly unique way of telling stories through song. I'm so grateful for your thoughtful, considerate, historic Canadian content. I neglected to mention that this song hit #2 on the American Charts, and #1 in Canada, and that all monies made from this song Gordon donated to the families of the 29 men lost. A class act.
He is absolutely a legend!!! He does it all and is still selling out venues in the US and Canada at the age of 83. Gordon will celebrate his 84th birthday on November 17th. God bless him and his wonderful band. All of them accomplished and talented musicians. The Edmund Fitzgerald went down in 1975. I lived in Windsor Ontario for over 40 years. Every year on November 10th at The Mariner's Church in downtown Detroit they, to this day, toll the bell 29 times in memory of each member of the crew, It is haunting.
This song has always blown my mind!! The music itself sounds like wavy water!!! I remember when this song was on the radio and peoe would stop talking and listen to every word!! Gordon Lightfoot is certainly on of our gems!!!
Wow john, I'm been enjoying your vids very much, and then this one about Gordon...wow !!! He's a home boy here in Orillia Ontario....Theirs a big bronze bust of him in front of the opera house. Also a life sized statue of him at Tudhope park on the beach. Definitely the pride of Orillia, He does still play the opera house here from time to time...
Murray McLaughlin's song, "Out Past the Timberline" is my favourite song. Since you appreciate songs that touch the heart and are patriotic, this one really fit both criteria.
what a good idea for a remembrance day tribute from an american showing his appreciation for canada. a very special canadian showing his appreciation for some very special americans. it's perfect.
My dad was a proud Canadian and Gordon Lightfoot was one of my dads favourite artists, and this song in particular was always on rotation in his house. He passed away in 2020, and my sister and I were allowed to write messages on his casket before he was put to rest. We chose lyrics from this song. Thank you for your reaction.
I’m sorry your Dad passed just a few years ago. What a touching tribute to you’d dad. We lost my father-in-law in 2021. He was like a dad to me as well and was a musician. He and I would sit up late listening to records and I distinctly remember getting him into Gordon Lightfoot one of those nights. Thanks for sharing your personal story. Peace from NY.
Great song John and thank you for the video, the thing I like best about Gordon's lyrics is just how visual they always are. I am a Canadian here on prince edward island and the song of Gordon's that always resonated canada to me was "A Canadian Railroad Trilogy'. It probably represents a similar scenario of building the railroad across the US. Just the opening lyrics "There was a time in this fair land when the railroad did not run When the wild majestic mountains stood alone against the sun Long before the white man and long before the wheel when the green dark forest was too silent to be real". Right there you have a very colorful visual, and the song is full of them. On the first day of spring there two songs I always make a point of listening to at some point in the day. The first is Gordon's 'Pussy willows cat tails', and the Beatles 'Hear comes the sun'. Both just warm the sole. Anyway thanks again.
Awesome. That song is on my Gord’s Gold album. Some others mentioned it in the comments so I listed to it again, and am hearing it with a new perspective since starting this journey with all of you. Thanks the the conversation.
Thank you for this. I am watching this is December of 2023 and sadly we have lost this legendary poet and musician. It is wonderful to know his music is will live on :)
I heard this song when I was just a kid and even then I had tears in my eyes. So even hearing this song now the tears they flow. Grew up hearing Gordon Lightfoot and love his songs. I have driven across Canada twice and each time going around Lake Superior it takes a Day and a half. So thank you for this video and I can see it touches you to.
All of us in the States knew that Gordon Lightfoot came from the great country Canada! He was one of my favorite songwriters and singers. God Bless him for writing and singing this amazingly sad disaster that happened in 1975. It’s haunting and I’ll never forget it, I lived on Lake Superior at that time.
You should give Great Big Sea a listen. They have sea shanty's, songs about working in the mines, Newfoundland in general and hit songs like "Ordinary Day", "Consequence Free" and "It's The End of the World". Also another great band is Spirit of the West, they are a band from BC, I am sure you've heard of their song "Home for a rest ". Thank you for speaking about Canada and Canadians so nicely 💞
Thanks John, that song brought back memories of watching him play at the Old Massey Hall, an iconic performing arts venue in Toronto, built in 1894 I believe. The acoustics of that venue has to be heard to be appreciated. His performance of The Wreck of the Edmond Fitzgerald there has embedded that song in my mind forever. Truly a Canadian folk icon!
so this is my second video I've watched the you've done. When I was young my dad had Gordon on both 8 track and vinyl he is amazing. Now here is another Folk singer that is truly Canadian his name is Stompin Tom Conners and the Canadian history he brings to music is just amazing, have a listen.
If you want to try a Canadian song in the style of a sea shantee try Barrett's Privateers. It's pretty amazing. It's a fictional story but it's a great song and a very catchy tune.
I knew Gordon, first through my red radio as a young girl, and later on, personally, due to a friendship with his neighbor. I wrote a long story about him when you first came out with this video at the time. When I first heard about his passing here in Toronto earlier this night, I immediately thought of your coverage of him, and, after going through more than a few photos, and memories and songs, I wound up here, and intend to share this video to my FB page along with my personal story. Amongst all of the interviews, which he didn't really enjoy doing, and songs and concerts and all the rest about him on TH-cam, I'll write my tribute to him and share your video you did here, as my tribute to him. I can't help but feel a sense of loss, yet realize that he was one of a kind, and that I so appreciate your doing this video so respectfully all those months ago. Did you realize that over 300 musical "greats" of all genres have done covers of him, including Harry Belafonte, whom we just lost within the week. Gordon had many friends, and his band-mates never left him, most played over 45 years with him. Did you know that his wife of 9 years now is the American actress Kim Hasse? He's left an amazing legacy, and I happened to be on a livestream with mostly American friends when news of his passing came and I was amazed at how many knew and loved him, writing immediate lyrics of songs that immediately sprang to mind. There will be many mourning his loss, myself being one, but what an amazing legacy of music he left us with. He has 6 children and grandchildren, one who is 11 and recently performed live. When asked one time in an interview how he'd like to be remembered, he said what my dad always taught me when camping "to leave the campsite cleaner than you found it". He in fact loved Muskoka, near his birth home, and Toronto, his life-long adult residence, and found fame in Britain and Australia, as well as in the US. It was his choice to stay in Canada, and be less famous, because he so loved it. He was, is and will always be our "poet laureate". It's been awhile and I just wanted to thank you, once again. Signed, Your Canadian "cousin".
Bob Dylan is a big fan of Gordon Lightfoot and has very complimentary things to say about him. Another powerful piece is Gordon's "Great Canadian Railroad Trilogy " about the building of the Railroad from sea to sea. This was no easy task through some of the most difficult terrain. Much easier to build railroads north and south as opposed to east and west. This was a determined effort by Sir John A McDonald, to keep Canada from becoming American. I love the song.
Yes. I think Bob Dylan inducted Gordon into the Canadian music hall of fame. What accolades when Dylan says Lightfoot is one of the best of his generation. I agree.
You might be interested in checking out Susan Aglukark. She is an Inuit singer from the Northwest territories . She sings a blend of rock, country, and folk music touching on her culture . Very upbeat and worth the listen. Her biggest hits were O Siem, and Hina Na Ho which means celebration in her native language.
An interesting reaction video to music may be to Canadian Astronaut Chris Hadfields cover of “Space Oddity” that he filmed from the ISS, or his original song which he duets with the lead singer from Barenaked Ladies. Not too often music videos are made in space. He created some of the most interesting content from space.
Watching your tribute to Gordo again just a few days after his passing really touched me. If you were here in Toronto this old girl would give you a great big hug...❤❤❤
This song always brings tears to my eyes. It has such a haunting melody to it. Lightfoot is my all time favourite. I've seen him in concert many times. I also happen to have all his vinyls but only because, when I bought them, vinyl was all you could get. I'd really enjoy more content like this. Thanks for another great video.
Thank you so very much for doing a segment on Gordon Lightfoot Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald. A little tear comes to so many people's eyes when they hear that song. Thank you
Gordon Lightfoot has the most unique and beautiful voice. This is a tough song to sing, emotionally and getting the right beat to start again. Dude, thank you for this channel
Thank you for your coverage of the song John. It means so much to me because we RV July and August up on the Canadian north shore of Lake Superior, and have done for twenty years. It is my favourite place in the world. Where we stay we can look across Superior to where the Edmond Fitzgerald went down. We miss Gordon Lightfoot so much. I have listened to this song a thousand times but it sounds so much better on your vinyl.🇨🇦
Tidbit: Since then, every ship that pass where the Edmond sank, ring their bells/horns 29 times in memory of each man that passed. So touching. Also, since Gordon passed, now the bells tole 30 times now. This from Brent Hartley .... Yes its a true event, Im a US Navy vet and currently a member of the Merchant Marines, sailing on the S.S. Roger Blough a great lakes freighter. The S.S. Edmund Fitzgerald was launched on June 7, 1958, she was the largest ship on the lakes at the time. She left Superior, Wisconsin, at 2:15 p.m. on the afternoon of November 9, 1975 with a cargo of 26,000 tons of taconite ore pellets. She and another freighter the S.S. Arthur M. Anderson were downbound for the locks at Sault Ste. Marie, when they were caught in a November gale with 75-knot winds (81 to 86 mph) and waves as high as 35 feet. Just after midnight on November 10th. Fitzgerald and Anderson were in regular contact, and Captain Ernest M. McSorley of the Fitzgerald radioed Captain Bernie Cooper of the Anderson to report that Edmund Fitzgerald was taking on water and had lost two vent covers and a fence railing sown and the vessel had also developed a list. The last communication from the ship came at approximately 7:10 p.m., when the Anderson asked how she was doing. McSorley reported, "We are holding our own." She sank minutes later so fast that there was no chance of getting into a life raft. No distress signal was received, and ten minutes later, Arthur M. Anderson lost the ability either to reach Edmund Fitzgerald by radio or to detect her on radar. The loss of the entire crew of 29 and the mystery of her sinking and this song have made her a Legend. As I said Im a sailor on the S.S. Roger Blough and let me tell you when the lakes turn nasty it is the most terrifying thing you'll ever experiance , all you can do is secure the ship batten down all hatches and heave to and ride it out there's nothing else you can do, except take your Dextroamphetamine for sea sickness and man your stations or try and lay down in your bunk.
I am a Michigander. I was 17 when this happened. I have never forgot it, and love Gordon's song. That ship was huge. Can you imagine a 30-35 foot wave. Think about how high that ship sits off the water. Then a hurricane west wind. Unbelievable! That Lake is haunting some days. It can look dark and deep standing on shore. The bell now sits at White Fish Bay Museum.
I was living jn Sault Ste. Marie, Ontario on the night of that storm so I can appreciate what it must have been like on Lake Superior. I have never forgotten that night. Sadly Gordon Lightfoot has passed since you put out the video. To know how impressive this event was struck me personally my grandson learned about the legend in a history project that he did perhaps in Grade 7 several years. He memorized the song and to this day can sing every single word of the song.
My younger brother also is a drummer. Due to distance and disability, (me) I haven’t seen him in years. When you air drummed along with the song, I could see him doing the same move in the same spot, and it brought tears to my eyes. Factoid about the song. Gord introduced the song to his sidemen with no rehearsals. The song we both love immensely was recorded the first time he played it with/for them. That’s the version on Summertime Dream, and the only one you’ll hear unless you see him in concert.
Watching your videos while doing chores, a nice distraction:) Gordon Lightfood such a gem thank you highlighting this song written about such a tragic event. My father had this record and I remember hearing it growing up. I agree with some others The Tragically Hip I would argue is Canada's most beloved band. I remember first seeing them at an outdoor multiband festival in 92' it was quiet when we first arrived about 1/2 hour before their show as I had never heard of them thought it would be a light crowd then all of a sudden thousands of people surrounded me on the open prairie field in front of the stage. The crowd knew all of the words and were dancing and enthralled with the band and Gord Downie was such an animated performer. I was hooked. I remember I bought one of their cassettes and it was stolen at my siblings house party shortly afterward, the only cassette taken :( A few years later my sister was living in the Cayman Islands making tax free money with other expats ie Canadians, British and Germans. They all grew to love The Tragically Hip and invited them to Grand Cayman to play a concert as the Canadians there were missing home and what better band to invite than The Tragically Hip and to their delight the band accepted the invitation. My sister and her husband said it was one of the best nights of their life. Before and after the concert the band hung around the expats on the island so grateful and humble. When news broke in Canada a few years ago that the lead singer of "The Hip" had brain cancer his fans were heartbroken. The band decided to go on a farewell tour of Canada and so many tears were shed at their concerts from the band and fans alike. A final concert was televised for all Canadians to watch. I watched it with teary eyes with my husband and sons. Justin Trudeau our Prime Minister love him or hate him is also a Gen Xer like myself was in tears when announcing Gord Downie's death. Forever in our hearts 💕 🍁
I have to confess, I don’t know the Tragically Hip. I looked them up today in response to some comments like yours and I saw that Gord Downie died from Brian cancer. I will be doing reactions soon. It’s all I can do from watching everything I can now because I’m so interested. But I’ll wait until my reaction can be genuine. I’m so ready for it. Thanks so much for your comment.
As a Canadian and a musician of sorts.. really appreciate your appreciation of Rush at the beginning of the video. Absolutely one of my favorite bands, glad it's one of yours. I'm glad you're loving Canadian music artists in general. Along with other things Canadian.. the lyrics are brilliant but.. The guitar work in this song is particularly brilliant.. it really brings the story alive. Think I'll go learn it again. Thanks. Keep up the great work
It's terrible for me as a proud Canadian not to have enjoyed Gordon Lightfoot as much as I should have, but this most certainly has me addicted... however, if you want some more good Canadian folk music, check out the Newfoundland group, Great Big Sea. Wonderful stories about that spectacular island set to great rhythms.
The bell from the Edmund Fitzgerald is in the maritime museum near Whitefish Bay in Michigan. This song plays in the background. Also there is a platform to look at Superior and realize the vast size of it. When they took the bell from the wreck it was replaced be a bell with the names of the crew engraved on it.
I like to remind others of Robbie Robertson and Buffy Sainte-Marie as both are from Canada AND are Indigenous heritage. True originals of great songs, great talent. Others from various backgrounds, with history from around the world are Canadian, Paul Anka, and jazz from Oscar Peterson, and country legend Hank Snow
I'm so glad you liked this. My husband grew up near where Gordon spent summers, and he used to show up to community parties. A treasure. I would recommend Stopmpin Tom Connors - Bud the Spud, or Hockey Night tonight
Loved this, love your content. I just subscribed but I've watched many of your videos, I thought I had subscribed a long time ago. If you are interested, I highly recommend you listen to The Tragically Hip. Particularly the albums Up to Here and Road Apples. All their music is amazing, they are iconic Canadians. You'll love Gord Downie, the lead singer if you look into who he was as a person. It broke the whole country's heart when he passed.
I’ll be doing a reaction about Tragically Hip very soon. I started reading about him recently as I’ve been getting comments to check him out and then I stopped. I could tell it was a compelling story and I want a genuine reaction so I’m doing it this weekend because I actually can’t wait and want to give it my time and attention.
I went to the same high school as Joni Mitchell, 20+ years later. One day while I was in school she stopped by. Unannounced. Dropped off a signed picture and had a brief visit and left. I knew of her but didn’t really understand the magnitude of what she was. It wasn’t until many years later that I finally understood and was regretful of not knowing about her sooner.
Wow! So cool. Even if you couldn’t fully appreciate it at the time, you’ll always have the memory and now know how big of a deal that was in hindsight. Thanks for sharing.
The words to this gem of a song are truly poetic. I was eleven years old when the Edmond Fitzgerald was claimed by Lake Superior in November 1975 ( exactly what day in November I can’t remember) . Approximately a year later i would find myself standing on the shore of this immense lake in Deluth Minnesota contemplating the tragic event. You chose a good subject of a song to touch base on John . God keep my land glorious and free 🇨🇦 and God bless America 🇺🇸.
There’s a show here in Canada called Due South. The main actor (Paul Gross) had wanted to use this song in an episode that loosely mirrored this tragedy but Gordon (rightfully) would only say yes to its use if Paul got permission from the family of every single victim. Paul decided not to do that and ended up writing his own song called 32 down on the Robert Mackenzie. I didn’t know until years later of this story. Now I love both songs.
I had served in the US Navy and served on a destroyer (DD). While at sea we encountered two hurricanes and a monster typhoon. Gordon Lightfoot brought me to chills from my head to my toes for those men and their families. I have always felt a deep kinship with my Canadian brothers and sisters
Two bands come to mind, that are very popular in Canada, but not known much internationally .Check out The Tragically Hip and Blue Rodeo. Many great songs in their catalogues.
th-cam.com/video/9yteNPh-boY/w-d-xo.html This gives you an idea how much a band like Blue Rodeo can mean to Canadians. This was made during the pandemic to raise spirits.. th-cam.com/video/ghLk-BhT-P8/w-d-xo.html. This showing the depth of feeling during The Tragically Hip's last concert.
I give you a thumbs up before I watch your video just because I love Gordon Lightfoot's music and feel he deserves recognition. A true Canadian legend. I know the word legend can be tossed around loosely sometimes but Las a Canadian grew up listening to him, it's the only word I can use to describe him. I do agree he's underappreciated outside of Canada but here he's considered a national treasure. I'd put him on par with the late great American singer/songwriter Jim Croce..
I've only come upon your channel in the last 10 days or so. I am Canadian. And, well, the late Gordon Lightfoot was an ICON here. I saw him in concert 6 times, many years ago now. I've done textile art pieces inspired by his work and by that of the equally wonderful Joni Mitchell. Seeing Lightfoot's name come up on your post, a month or so after his death, well...I just had to watch. And I thank you for showcasing his work.
There was a time, in the not too distant past, where the Canadian music scene was, in the eyes of the American music business, Gord Lightfoot and Anne Murray. Not so anymore! 🇨🇦🖖🏻🇨🇦
A 6 minute long folk song about a nautical disaster that hit #2 on the charts. Occasionally talent and great art are accepted into everyday life.
"Does anyone know where the love of God goes when the waves turn the minutes to hours?".
Poetry. Pure poetry.
I know, right? Gets me every time.
Ya that line..good lord. Hits hard. I grew up on the water ( Newfoundland ) I’ve been in pretty heavy seas more then once. And that rings home.
That is the line that always gets me.
I work for the Canadian Coast Guard and this one line is always on my mind when we’re in dirty water….
I was a commercial fishing captain in Nova Scotia and that line means so much to me.
He read the story while sitting in the bus station and couldn’t get it out of his head, so he wrote the song. It’s very haunting.
Gordon Lighfoot is, without a doubt, a living legend here in Canada.
I love that he wrote such a touching song to bring awareness of this tragedy. Also, I read that Gordon donated all the proceeds of this song to help the families that were directly affected by this tragedy. A heartwarming and wonderful gesture. Thank,s for this reaction.,
That is true!
One of the true Canadian gems was Stompin' Tom Connors. He travelled around Canada writing songs about the people, places, and experiences he had. A real man of the common man and a great storyteller.
I always loved the Royal Canadian Air Farce' Stumpy Tom skit's!
The good ol' hockey game really is the best game I can name.
I grew up listening to Stompin' Tom!!
"I'm Bud the Spud from the bright red mud, rollin' down the highway, smilin'"!! He sang such iconic Canadian songs!!!
I’m from PEI. Stompin Tom is a legend
We have a bronze statue of Stompin' Tom here in Sudbury! We can stop by and pay our respects when we're downtown getting stink-o on a Sudbury Saturday Night!
I love this - your appreciation for Canada and Canadian culture is really quite impressive and respectful.
Gordon Lightfoot - November 17, 1938 - May 1, 2023 - RIP Gordon Lightfoot and thank you for sharing your incredible talent with the world. You were one of a kind and will be missed by millions.
Gordon wrote this because he was angered that the newspaper accounts were so shoddy, most of them mis spelled the name of the ship. It should have been front page news, but some stuck the story further back. He felt an injustice had been done to those who had lost their lives. He researched it, and wrote the song. All proceeds from record sales were given to the families. Gordon attended every memorial every year in Detroit. He’s a good age now so I don’t know if he was able to keep it up. Another song he did chronicling an historical event is “ Black Day in July” about the 1967 riots in Detroit.
I was a child at the time. It was definitely front page news in Ontario.
It’s interesting that it’s still pretty inaccurate. He was confronted with some of it as new info emerged and now performs lyrics differently when in concert.
@@Kal_El_Krypton The only inaccuracy is the hatch caving in. When he wrote the song there was no info on what caused the wreck. That's the lyric that he changed. It's still not known for sure, but they think either the freighter ended up riding the crest of two waves, and the boat just broke in half (it was overloaded), or dove into a wave and just never came back up. The waves were immense in the storm, and the forces boats are subjected to on Lake Superior are enormous.
From the very 1st note, my eyes began to water.😥 I'm a Canadian who who was 21 y.o. at the time and living in Ft. Erie, Ontaro when this happened. I have heard this song a million times through my long life and Gordon Lightfoot is one of our prouder moments. Thank you for this video. Oddly, today is Nov. 12 as I watch this and the Fitzgerald went down on Nov 10, 1975 and located Nov 14th, 1975. And, FYI, she was carrying taconite iron ore from mines near Duluth, Minnesota to iron works in Detroit, Michigan, Toledo, Ohio and other Great Lake ports. She had been doing this run for 17 years until the day of her ill-fated final voyage. I only just found you and love how empathetic you are. Keep 'em coming.
Thanks so much Chiclet for the information and your encouragement. It helps a lot. Peace from NY
If I had to pick a voice that sounds like Canada, it's Gordon Lightfoot. The way he sings, the stories he tells, they're Canada through and through
Lightfoot also sang Black Day in July, about the riots in Detroit in 1967...There have been a lot of Canadian groups and artists making socially important statements in their songs...
He also wrote Circle of Steel which touches upon the condition of poverty. Not nearly as good as In The Ghetto but still excellent
I was thinking of Black Day in July. There is a good video on here with archival footage. My husband is Alaskan, and I played it for him, and he had never learned about the riots. He was really impressed with the song.
First concert I ever attended was Gordon Lightfoot in Place des Arts in Montreal. It was 1969 and he sang "Black Day in July." He is truly a Canadian icon.
This song takes you from the couch to a horrible day in the middle of the cold cruel and beautiful Lake Superior…Gordon told the story, he didn’t focus on or try to perform a vocal masterpiece, although it was exceptional as well…he wanted the audience to listen to the story, feel what those poor sailers felt and its consequences to them, their community and family.
The instrumental accompaniment was brilliant, starting slowly and simple building stronger like the storm itself…. storytelling in its finest form.
I love seeing this John. Gordon Lightfoot was my father's favorite artist. As a Canadian it really warms my heart seeing an American espousing the virtues of one of the greatest Canadian artists that never really gained a real significant amount of notoriety in the States. He is such an amazing storyteller. His lyrics are always so poignant. I'm a new subscriber and I've really enjoyed your history videos. It's always interesting hearing reactions and observations about Canadiana from foreigners. Even from one like yourself that has some foreknowledge about the subject matter. Keep up the great work. If you do decide to do more of these Canadian song or musician reactions might I advise not doing the more renowned artists South of the border to start with. I know you mentioned absolute icons like Rush, Neil Young and The Band (man, isn't Robbie Robertson just incredible?). They all should and absolutely deserve to be discussed in a cultural and historical sense. But instead I would suggest learning about and reacting to Canada's most beloved band that very few (and I really do mean very few) Americans have ever even heard of... The Tragically Hip. They are really Canada's band. We hold them so close to our heart's because their songs are simply dripping with Canadiana. The fact that they were so huge here and completely overlooked south of the boarder also contributes to their love from Canadians. Like Gordon Lightfoot they are incredible storytellers. When Gord Downie (The Hip's lead singer) died I read an article, I think it was in Rolling Stone, where the author called Downie Canada's Bob Dylan. Wheat Kings, Grace Too, Fiddler's Green and Ahead by a Century are all incredible examples of how strong their songwriting was. But if you plan to go down The Hip rabbit hole of song reactions I suggest you start with "38 Years Old". Trust me, you'll be hooked. Cheers from a northern cousin.
Yes, yes and yes. Thanks so much for the suggestion. I totally agree. The one thing I thought of doing with the Band is Acadian Driftwood. It’s not as well known here as songs like the Weight and it tells a Canadian story. But I don’t think I’ve ever heard a Tragically Hip song so you have piqued my interest for sure.
Excellent suggestions.
@@johnf-americanreacts1287 Oh man, I had forgotten about Acadian Driftwood. Great pull! I'm gonna have to see if I can find it on TH-cam later. I haven't heard that song in forever. As for my Hip suggestion, I'm going to apologize in advance. Every American friend that I've introduced to The Hip have all exclaimed "how have I never heard of these guys?!?" and became kind of addicted. The Hip aren't as technically sound as say Rush or The Band. But their raw and scaled back rock sound is really captivating. They may very well become your favorite new hidden gem of a band. Enjoy.
@@johnf-americanreacts1287 You must check out The Hip (as we call them). Grace, Too would be my recommendation for first song by them..... ;-) They have many, many really great songs.... Loving your channel, thanks for your content!!!
@@johnf-americanreacts1287 - Burton Cummings an amazing voice. Zal Yanovski of the Lovin' Spoonful. Denny Doherty of the Mamas and the Papas. Joni Mitchell. KD Lang. Leonard Cohen. Celine Dion. I'm probably older than most here but these folks from the 60's and 70's were top notch. I also loved Great Big Sea from Newfoundland.
As a ex Canadian sailor I can say each trip through the Sault Ste Marie locks was humbling. There is a lifeboat and life preserver from the Fitz resting in the center of the locks. Every time we went through the locks, the entire crew stopped what they doing if they were able to and gave their thoughts and prayers to those brave men who never made it home.
As a resident of the area, it is a known fact that the big lake never gives up her dead in any instance. The water is too cold. It only changes a couple of degrees between summer and winter. The bodies do not bloat and float to the surface because of the water temperature. They just sink. Terrible description but it is the explanation.
Thanks so much for the perspective and info of a sailor.
Thank you John for highlighting Gordon. Living along the Detroit River I watch the huge freighters daily. I often think of the Edmund Fitzgerald and the tragedy that took the lives of the sailors that November. This song has a very haunting melody that can’t be forgotten and Gordon Lightfoot does a fantastic job telling the story. He is one of Canada’s greatest songwriter/storytellers. Thanks again for this. 👏👏🇨🇦🇨🇦
I live along the river as well, never forget the Edmund Fitzgerald, a beautiful ship.
Do you remember when the reporter from channel 4 Detroit dove down to the Fitz and did dives in the Detroit river to find interesting things
@@laurabailey1054 I don't remember the reporter, do you know his name. I remember Jacques Cousteau came to check out the ship, we were waiting at the river to see the Calypso go by. Was surprised by how small it was.
Thank you for taking the time to watch and comment. I’m sure living where you do, this song as a particularly special meaning for you.
@@debbie5859 it was WDIV reporter Mal Sillers who did the dive.
We have so many talented Canadian musicians Americans would be blown away
Gordon Lightfoot is an amazing artist and storyteller. This particular song is haunting and you can’t help but sing along with it. We had to remember the lyrics of the song like it was a poem when I was in grade 8.
Another artist you may want to check out is Stan Rogers and two of songs, The Northwest Passage (which some Canadians wanted as our national anthem) and Bluenose (after a famous ship - it’s on our dime).
Some amazing songs Stan Roger's wrote. Very much a Canadian legend. Underappreciated and was taken out too soon. His death was tragic and heroic. His brother Garnet has a great catalogue of music too. For Stan, I would also recommend Lies and Lock-Keeper. Also the a capella Barrett's Privateers. For Garnet, I would recommend Frankie and Johnny, his cover of King of Rome, or This Shirt.
I live in Gordon Lightfoot's home town of Orillia, Ontario. There is a bust of him in front of the Orillia Opera House and a lane named after him. You might also want to listen to his song "Sundown" among others. The Stephen Leacock museum is also in Orillia.
I’m loving these little anecdotes and bits of information. Thanks. Funny story, I was listening to Sundown and Gordon sang the line about finding some creeping down her back stairs, and my 9 year old daughter asked, why would someone do that? Are they a burger? To which I of course answered yes. 😂
As a Canadian, I love and support our great Canadian Musicians..
I dont think the rest of the World realizes how great our Musical history really is.
Thank you for showcasing the great Gordon Lightfoot..an amazing artist.
I was happy to begin with someone I know well who I know is underexposed here in the US. I’ve been getting a lot of great suggestions of artists I don’t know and I am excited to explore coming up soon. Thanks for the comment Glenna.
The Edmund Fitzgerald passed by on the river I live near at least 2 to 3 times a week, it's a huge ship and very recognizable. The night it sank the winds were extremely high, the bridge connecting Canada and the US was even swaying a bit. I went down toward the river to see if I could see the bridge swaying and had to turn back, the wind almost blew me on the road, I couldn't imagine what the ships must of been going through. The next morning we found out that beautiful ship sunk. It was heading back to our river and going to Zug Island. The loss of the poor crew was heartbreaking and that incredible ship, the Edmund Fitzgerald was sorely missed
Thanks for adding your experiences with the ship. It makes the song even that pore poignant to hear from people like you.
So glad you examined this masterwork. Don't know if you've heard of it, or perhaps even listened to it, but I highly recommend Gordon's tribute to Canada, "The Canadian Railroad Trilogy". It should be our national anthem. Thanks, and keep up the good work.
I have the Canadian Railroad Trilogy on one of my vinyls, Gord’s Gold. I love the song but I haven’t listened since I started this channel and I think I’ll do it here too. I’m sure I’ll have a different perspective and appreciation for it now. Thanks for the suggestion and for watching.
I'm a 56 year old Canadian, and I've been listening to this song for most of my life, but I still tear up when I listen to it. Also, Sundown is another great song from this storyteller.
I'm embarrassed that I don't know who that guitarist was, but he was fantastic.
One of my favourite songs from one of my favourite artists. The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald still brings chills, after all these years! Thanks for this video.
No one could believe that a six minute folksong by an amazing musician would become so popular!
Gordon Lightfoot 'Canadian Railroad Trilogy". One of the songs I think defines Canada.
Thanks for the terrific video. Two other Canadian musicians that might not be so well known by Americans are Bruce Cockburn and Stan Rogers, both singer-songwriters. Cheers!
The line that always gets me is the cook saying " fellas, it's been good to know ya's " This artist doesn't just write songs, he crafts them. Canadian Gold !! My favorite by Gordon Lightfoot is "The Way I Feel ", a pretty unknown song of his. Good job on the reaction !
One of my favourites well!!
Gotta add Saturday Clothes!✌❤
I know right?
That line is so powerfully heartbreaking.
You talked at the beginning of Canada exporting culture. One modern export, is the legendary Terry Fox’s story and his accomplishments!
There are videos on TH-cam about him, and his historic run.
If any knows what the best one is, please leave a link, for me, they all make me cry!
Stay safe, stay sane, stay Strong Ukraine 🇺🇦
David, yes I second that because I want to react to one and I want to know it’s a good one.
Was lucky I saw Gordon live when he opened up for Simon and Garfunkel in 1993 here in Toronto. 60, 000 people silent when he did that song.
I’ve seen Neil young twice! He was fantastic with pot smoke in the air! Lol. Gordon Lightfoot taps his foot on a board and goes through it every time he sings!
Leonard Cohn's Hallelujah by KD Lang is Phenomenal...Both Canadians. Thanx for this - Awesome
Brilliant Gordon Lightfoot, a man without borders.
This is my favorite Gordon Lightfoot song. It still manages to bring a tear to my eye 35 years after I first heard it.
So haunting. Artists like GL make me proud to be Canadian. I've listened to that song at least 100 times on my play list, and probably 100 more. Thank you for your tribute to him.
Something you might want to search out and or focus your channel on for a day or two is ... how Canadians live their lives .... we are simple but good people ... we live life hard ... we are highly educated ... and we treat people well. Our music as you have found is based upon living life. I'm a west coast seafarer and love that fact. I have lived my life on the Pacific, have salt water in my veins and have webs between my toes to prove it. I am of Icelandic heritage, hailing in Canada from Gimli, Manitoba (or in otherwords New Iceland) , and could not call myself prouder to declare ... I am Canadian. You will not find this kind of love for country anywhere else on the planet ... other than in Canada. Canada is my home and my great passion.
I like the suggestion a lot. I hope to find the right video for that. I’m always open to suggestions. Thanks so much.
@@johnf-americanreacts1287 You might have to do the different regions in Canada separately as while we are all Canadian, we all differ from each other. My favourite Gordon Lightfoot song is Early Morning Rain. Great video, John! Thank you!
I absolutely love Gimli, Manitoba. I'm into aviation, especially commercial airliners. The story of Air Canada Flight 143 and the calm bravery and steady hands of Captain Bob Pearson and First Officer Maurice Quintal landing the crippled Boeing 767 at the decommissioned air force base in Gimli is awe inspiring. Canadian courage at it's finest. The Gimli Glider is legendary.
I got repetitive full body goosebumps. On this momentous and busy day, amongst all else, something made me check your channel, and although I haven't sung this song for awhile, I remembered every word. I had the privilege of meeting and knowing Gordon Lightfoot many a time, including after his stroke when he played at the Old Massey Hall to an audience of two, one being me. I was good friends with his neighbor in an enclave near St. Clair and Yonge in Toronto where he lives, and can I just say what a humble, modest, and oh so real human he is. Not a whiff of superiority about him. His ability to weave stories into songs is second to none, and I thank you more than I can say for bringing it all back to me. I've travelled and sailed on each of the Great Lakes, swam and camped and cottaged and lived on and near them. All comes flooding back to me in mental images, so thank you, thank you, thank you. A bronze sculpture was unveilled in Orillia, Ontario, where he was born some years back, and he really didn't know what all the fuss was about.
Wow! What a privilege. I got that sense about him from a few interviews I’ve watched. To be honest, I only really discovered him a few years ago. Yes, as a music fan I knew of him and if you asked me 5 years who he was, I would have said a Canadian folk singer that sings that song Sundown. Then one day I was relaxing listening to a Bob Dylan station on Pandora and If You Could Read My Mind came on. I know I had heard it before, but I had never truly listened to it. It is a beautiful song. From there I got hooked and went all in.
@@johnf-americanreacts1287 I'm so glad you discovered him. He has a truly unique way of telling stories through song. I'm so grateful for your thoughtful, considerate, historic Canadian content. I neglected to mention that this song hit #2 on the American Charts, and #1 in Canada, and that all monies made from this song Gordon donated to the families of the 29 men lost. A class act.
He is absolutely a legend!!! He does it all and is still selling out venues in the US and Canada at the age of 83. Gordon will celebrate his 84th birthday on November 17th. God bless him and his wonderful band. All of them accomplished and talented musicians. The Edmund Fitzgerald went down in 1975. I lived in Windsor Ontario for over 40 years. Every year on November 10th at The Mariner's Church in downtown Detroit they, to this day, toll the bell 29 times in memory of each member of the crew, It is haunting.
Don't stop , your channel is quickly going on me . Look very often for new videos.
An idea; focus on the Tragically Hip. Gord Downie was one of our treasures, and he's dearly missed. I just found yer videos. Nice work.
This song has always blown my mind!! The music itself sounds like wavy water!!! I remember when this song was on the radio and peoe would stop talking and listen to every word!! Gordon Lightfoot is certainly on of our gems!!!
Wow john, I'm been enjoying your vids very much, and then this one about Gordon...wow !!! He's a home boy here in Orillia Ontario....Theirs a big bronze bust of him in front of the opera house. Also a life sized statue of him at Tudhope park on the beach. Definitely the pride of Orillia, He does still play the opera house here from time to time...
Neil Young's song Helpless talks about his North Ontario town.
Thank you for your content.
Murray McLaughlin's song, "Out Past the Timberline" is my favourite song. Since you appreciate songs that touch the heart and are patriotic, this one really fit both criteria.
Awesome reaction our American cousin 🇨🇦 🇺🇸
what a good idea for a remembrance day tribute from an american showing his appreciation for canada. a very special canadian showing his appreciation for some very special americans. it's perfect.
Thanks friend. Much appreciated.
My dad was a proud Canadian and Gordon Lightfoot was one of my dads favourite artists, and this song in particular was always on rotation in his house. He passed away in 2020, and my sister and I were allowed to write messages on his casket before he was put to rest. We chose lyrics from this song. Thank you for your reaction.
I’m sorry your Dad passed just a few years ago. What a touching tribute to you’d dad. We lost my father-in-law in 2021. He was like a dad to me as well and was a musician. He and I would sit up late listening to records and I distinctly remember getting him into Gordon Lightfoot one of those nights. Thanks for sharing your personal story. Peace from NY.
Lightfoot songs stay with you forever but never get old.
Great song John and thank you for the video, the thing I like best about Gordon's lyrics is just how visual they always are. I am a Canadian here on prince edward island and the song of Gordon's that always resonated canada to me was "A Canadian Railroad Trilogy'. It probably represents a similar scenario of building the railroad across the US. Just the opening lyrics "There was a time in this fair land when the railroad did not run When the wild majestic mountains stood alone against the sun Long before the white man and long before the wheel when the green dark forest was too silent to be real". Right there you have a very colorful visual, and the song is full of them.
On the first day of spring there two songs I always make a point of listening to at some point in the day. The first is Gordon's 'Pussy willows cat tails', and the Beatles 'Hear comes the sun'. Both just warm the sole. Anyway thanks again.
Awesome. That song is on my Gord’s Gold album. Some others mentioned it in the comments so I listed to it again, and am hearing it with a new perspective since starting this journey with all of you. Thanks the the conversation.
Thank you for this. I am watching this is December of 2023 and sadly we have lost this legendary poet and musician. It is wonderful to know his music is will live on :)
I love him and will miss Gordon too.
You are an amazing person! Thank you for exploring our country more, intelligent heartfelt honest reactions ❤
You all are amazing people and I am so grateful for you all.
I heard this song when I was just a kid and even then I had tears in my eyes. So even hearing this song now the tears they flow. Grew up hearing Gordon Lightfoot and love his songs. I have driven across Canada twice and each time going around Lake Superior it takes a Day and a half. So thank you for this video and I can see it touches you to.
All of us in the States knew that Gordon Lightfoot came from the great country Canada! He was one of my favorite songwriters and singers. God Bless him for writing and singing this amazingly sad disaster that happened in 1975. It’s haunting and I’ll never forget it, I lived on Lake Superior at that time.
You should give Great Big Sea a listen. They have sea shanty's, songs about working in the mines, Newfoundland in general and hit songs like "Ordinary Day", "Consequence Free" and "It's The End of the World". Also another great band is Spirit of the West, they are a band from BC, I am sure you've heard of their song "Home for a rest ". Thank you for speaking about Canada and Canadians so nicely 💞
Thanks John, that song brought back memories of watching him play at the Old Massey Hall, an iconic performing arts venue in Toronto, built in 1894 I believe. The acoustics of that venue has to be heard to be appreciated. His performance of The Wreck of the Edmond Fitzgerald there has embedded that song in my mind forever. Truly a Canadian folk icon!
Thanks for your support of one of our greatest artists that showed support to us guys
Canadian Railroad Trilogy by Gordon Lightfoot....My fave Gordo song. He still tours and he must be 164.
so this is my second video I've watched the you've done. When I was young my dad had Gordon on both 8 track and vinyl he is amazing. Now here is another Folk singer that is truly Canadian his name is Stompin Tom Conners and the Canadian history he brings to music is just amazing, have a listen.
If you want to try a Canadian song in the style of a sea shantee try Barrett's Privateers. It's pretty amazing. It's a fictional story but it's a great song and a very catchy tune.
Oooh yeah that's a good one...
Lots of great Stan Roger's tunes. But this is a favourite of mine.
I knew Gordon, first through my red radio as a young girl, and later on, personally, due to a friendship with his neighbor. I wrote a long story about him when you first came out with this video at the time. When I first heard about his passing here in Toronto earlier this night, I immediately thought of your coverage of him, and, after going through more than a few photos, and memories and songs, I wound up here, and intend to share this video to my FB page along with my personal story. Amongst all of the interviews, which he didn't really enjoy doing, and songs and concerts and all the rest about him on TH-cam, I'll write my tribute to him and share your video you did here, as my tribute to him. I can't help but feel a sense of loss, yet realize that he was one of a kind, and that I so appreciate your doing this video so respectfully all those months ago. Did you realize that over 300 musical "greats" of all genres have done covers of him, including Harry Belafonte, whom we just lost within the week. Gordon had many friends, and his band-mates never left him, most played over 45 years with him. Did you know that his wife of 9 years now is the American actress Kim Hasse? He's left an amazing legacy, and I happened to be on a livestream with mostly American friends when news of his passing came and I was amazed at how many knew and loved him, writing immediate lyrics of songs that immediately sprang to mind. There will be many mourning his loss, myself being one, but what an amazing legacy of music he left us with. He has 6 children and grandchildren, one who is 11 and recently performed live. When asked one time in an interview how he'd like to be remembered, he said what my dad always taught me when camping "to leave the campsite cleaner than you found it". He in fact loved Muskoka, near his birth home, and Toronto, his life-long adult residence, and found fame in Britain and Australia, as well as in the US. It was his choice to stay in Canada, and be less famous, because he so loved it. He was, is and will always be our "poet laureate". It's been awhile and I just wanted to thank you, once again. Signed, Your Canadian "cousin".
Bob Dylan is a big fan of Gordon Lightfoot and has very complimentary things to say about him. Another powerful piece is Gordon's "Great Canadian Railroad Trilogy " about the building of the Railroad from sea to sea. This was no easy task through some of the most difficult terrain. Much easier to build railroads north and south as opposed to east and west. This was a determined effort by Sir John A McDonald, to keep Canada from becoming American. I love the song.
Yes. I think Bob Dylan inducted Gordon into the Canadian music hall of fame. What accolades when Dylan says Lightfoot is one of the best of his generation. I agree.
You might be interested in checking out Susan Aglukark. She is an Inuit singer from the Northwest territories . She sings a blend of rock, country, and folk music touching on her culture . Very upbeat and worth the listen. Her biggest hits were O Siem, and Hina Na Ho which means celebration in her native language.
Very interested. Thanks for the suggestion.
Oh YES!!! She is Amazing!
I LOVE Susan Aglukark! What a great recommendation!
An interesting reaction video to music may be to Canadian Astronaut Chris Hadfields cover of “Space Oddity” that he filmed from the ISS, or his original song which he duets with the lead singer from Barenaked Ladies. Not too often music videos are made in space. He created some of the most interesting content from space.
Watching your tribute to Gordo again just a few days after his passing really touched me. If you were here in Toronto this old girl would give you a great big hug...❤❤❤
This song always brings tears to my eyes. It has such a haunting melody to it. Lightfoot is my all time favourite. I've seen him in concert many times. I also happen to have all his vinyls but only because, when I bought them, vinyl was all you could get. I'd really enjoy more content like this. Thanks for another great video.
Thank you so very much for doing a segment on Gordon Lightfoot Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald. A little tear comes to so many people's eyes when they hear that song. Thank you
Always enjoyed listening to Gordon Lightfoot!!
Gordon Lightfoot has the most unique and beautiful voice. This is a tough song to sing, emotionally and getting the right beat to start again. Dude, thank you for this channel
One of my most favorite songs of all time. Thank you.
Thank you for your coverage of the song John. It means so much to me because we RV July and August up on the Canadian north shore of Lake Superior, and have done for twenty years. It is my favourite place in the world. Where we stay we can look across Superior to where the Edmond Fitzgerald went down. We miss Gordon Lightfoot so much. I have listened to this song a thousand times but it sounds so much better on your vinyl.🇨🇦
We used to sing this in school every single year, in November. Love it.
I’ve always loved Gordon Lightfoot. Thank you for this. Please do more.
Tidbit: Since then, every ship that pass where the Edmond sank, ring their bells/horns 29 times in memory of each man that passed. So touching. Also, since Gordon passed, now the bells tole 30 times now.
This from Brent Hartley .... Yes its a true event, Im a US Navy vet and currently a member of the Merchant Marines, sailing on the S.S. Roger Blough a great lakes freighter. The S.S. Edmund Fitzgerald was launched on June 7, 1958, she was the largest ship on the lakes at the time. She left Superior, Wisconsin, at 2:15 p.m. on the afternoon of November 9, 1975 with a cargo of 26,000 tons of taconite ore pellets. She and another freighter the S.S. Arthur M. Anderson were downbound for the locks at Sault Ste. Marie, when they were caught in a November gale with 75-knot winds (81 to 86 mph) and waves as high as 35 feet. Just after midnight on November 10th. Fitzgerald and Anderson were in regular contact, and Captain Ernest M. McSorley of the Fitzgerald radioed Captain Bernie Cooper of the Anderson to report that Edmund Fitzgerald was taking on water and had lost two vent covers and a fence railing sown and the vessel had also developed a list. The last communication from the ship came at approximately 7:10 p.m., when the Anderson asked how she was doing. McSorley reported, "We are holding our own." She sank minutes later so fast that there was no chance of getting into a life raft. No distress signal was received, and ten minutes later, Arthur M. Anderson lost the ability either to reach Edmund Fitzgerald by radio or to detect her on radar. The loss of the entire crew of 29 and the mystery of her sinking and this song have made her a Legend. As I said Im a sailor on the S.S. Roger Blough and let me tell you when the lakes turn nasty it is the most terrifying thing you'll ever experiance , all you can do is secure the ship batten down all hatches and heave to and ride it out there's nothing else you can do, except take your Dextroamphetamine for sea sickness and man your stations or try and lay down in your bunk.
I am a Michigander. I was 17 when this happened. I have never forgot it, and love Gordon's song. That ship was huge. Can you imagine a 30-35 foot wave. Think about how high that ship sits off the water. Then a hurricane west wind. Unbelievable!
That Lake is haunting some days. It can look dark and deep standing on shore. The bell now sits at White Fish Bay Museum.
I hadn't heard this for years. Holy cow, the power of it. Gordon Lightfoot, one of our national treasures.
I was living jn Sault Ste. Marie, Ontario on the night of that storm so I can appreciate what it must have been like on Lake Superior. I have never forgotten that night. Sadly Gordon Lightfoot has passed since you put out the video. To know how impressive this event was struck me personally my grandson learned about the legend in a history project that he did perhaps in Grade 7 several years. He memorized the song and to this day can sing every single word of the song.
My younger brother also is a drummer. Due to distance and disability, (me) I haven’t seen him in years. When you air drummed along with the song, I could see him doing the same move in the same spot, and it brought tears to my eyes. Factoid about the song. Gord introduced the song to his sidemen with no rehearsals. The song we both love immensely was recorded the first time he played it with/for them. That’s the version on Summertime Dream, and the only one you’ll hear unless you see him in concert.
Wow, what a talented band to get that all in the first take without rehearsing it. Thanks for that info.
It's such a special song. A rare type of song because it doesn't have a bridge, so it's more of a poem with music. So moving.
Greetings from 🇨🇦
Always enjoy you respect for Canada and your interest.
Watching your videos while doing chores, a nice distraction:) Gordon Lightfood such a gem thank you highlighting this song written about such a tragic event. My father had this record and I remember hearing it growing up. I agree with some others The Tragically Hip I would argue is Canada's most beloved band. I remember first seeing them at an outdoor multiband festival in 92' it was quiet when we first arrived about 1/2 hour before their show as I had never heard of them thought it would be a light crowd then all of a sudden thousands of people surrounded me on the open prairie field in front of the stage. The crowd knew all of the words and were dancing and enthralled with the band and Gord Downie was such an animated performer. I was hooked. I remember I bought one of their cassettes and it was stolen at my siblings house party shortly afterward, the only cassette taken :( A few years later my sister was living in the Cayman Islands making tax free money with other expats ie Canadians, British and Germans. They all grew to love The Tragically Hip and invited them to
Grand Cayman to play a concert as the Canadians there were missing home and what better band to invite than The Tragically Hip and to their delight the band accepted the invitation. My sister and her husband said it was one of the best nights of their life. Before and after the concert the band hung around the expats on the island so grateful and humble. When news broke in Canada a few years ago that the lead singer of "The Hip" had brain cancer his fans were heartbroken. The band decided to go on a farewell tour of Canada and so many tears were shed at their concerts from the band and fans alike. A final concert was televised for all Canadians to watch. I watched it with teary eyes with my husband and sons. Justin Trudeau our Prime Minister love him or hate him is also a Gen Xer like myself was in tears when announcing Gord Downie's death. Forever in our hearts 💕 🍁
I have to confess, I don’t know the Tragically Hip. I looked them up today in response to some comments like yours and I saw that Gord Downie died from Brian cancer. I will be doing reactions soon. It’s all I can do from watching everything I can now because I’m so interested. But I’ll wait until my reaction can be genuine. I’m so ready for it. Thanks so much for your comment.
The music in this tune is hypnotic...❤
RIP Gordon Lightfoot we lost a true Canadian legend last year.
As a Canadian and a musician of sorts.. really appreciate your appreciation of Rush at the beginning of the video. Absolutely one of my favorite bands, glad it's one of yours. I'm glad you're loving Canadian music artists in general. Along with other things Canadian.. the lyrics are brilliant but.. The guitar work in this song is particularly brilliant.. it really brings the story alive. Think I'll go learn it again. Thanks. Keep up the great work
Yes, a lot of Canadian musicians are really smart and poetic lyricists - not least of all Neil Peart.
It's terrible for me as a proud Canadian not to have enjoyed Gordon Lightfoot as much as I should have, but this most certainly has me addicted... however, if you want some more good Canadian folk music, check out the Newfoundland group, Great Big Sea. Wonderful stories about that spectacular island set to great rhythms.
The bell from the Edmund Fitzgerald is in the maritime museum near Whitefish Bay in Michigan. This song plays in the background. Also there is a platform to look at Superior and realize the vast size of it. When they took the bell from the wreck it was replaced be a bell with the names of the crew engraved on it.
They also salvaged the anchor
I like to remind others of Robbie Robertson and Buffy Sainte-Marie as both are from Canada AND are Indigenous heritage. True originals of great songs, great talent. Others from various backgrounds, with history from around the world are Canadian, Paul Anka, and jazz from Oscar Peterson, and country legend Hank Snow
I'm so glad you liked this. My husband grew up near where Gordon spent summers, and he used to show up to community parties. A treasure. I would recommend Stopmpin Tom Connors - Bud the Spud, or Hockey Night tonight
Gordon is a national treasure and an amazing songwriter. I've been lucky enough to see him in concert several times, once from the front row.
Loved this, love your content. I just subscribed but I've watched many of your videos, I thought I had subscribed a long time ago.
If you are interested, I highly recommend you listen to The Tragically Hip. Particularly the albums Up to Here and Road Apples. All their music is amazing, they are iconic Canadians. You'll love Gord Downie, the lead singer if you look into who he was as a person. It broke the whole country's heart when he passed.
The Hip will always be alive. I'm sure Gord is smiling down right now.
I’ll be doing a reaction about Tragically Hip very soon. I started reading about him recently as I’ve been getting comments to check him out and then I stopped. I could tell it was a compelling story and I want a genuine reaction so I’m doing it this weekend because I actually can’t wait and want to give it my time and attention.
I went to the same high school as Joni Mitchell, 20+ years later. One day while I was in school she stopped by. Unannounced. Dropped off a signed picture and had a brief visit and left. I knew of her but didn’t really understand the magnitude of what she was.
It wasn’t until many years later that I finally understood and was regretful of not knowing about her sooner.
Wow! So cool. Even if you couldn’t fully appreciate it at the time, you’ll always have the memory and now know how big of a deal that was in hindsight. Thanks for sharing.
The words to this gem of a song are truly poetic. I was eleven years old when the Edmond Fitzgerald was claimed by Lake Superior in November 1975 ( exactly what day in November I can’t remember) . Approximately a year later i would find myself standing on the shore of this immense lake in Deluth Minnesota contemplating the tragic event. You chose a good subject of a song to touch base on John . God keep my land glorious and free 🇨🇦 and God bless America 🇺🇸.
There’s a show here in Canada called Due South. The main actor (Paul Gross) had wanted to use this song in an episode that loosely mirrored this tragedy but Gordon (rightfully) would only say yes to its use if Paul got permission from the family of every single victim. Paul decided not to do that and ended up writing his own song called 32 down on the Robert Mackenzie. I didn’t know until years later of this story. Now I love both songs.
I had served in the US Navy and served on a destroyer (DD). While at sea we encountered two hurricanes and a monster typhoon. Gordon Lightfoot brought me to chills from my head to my toes for those men and their families. I have always felt a deep kinship with my Canadian brothers and sisters
Thanks for your service, very sincerely.
Two bands come to mind, that are very popular in Canada, but not known much internationally .Check out The Tragically Hip and Blue Rodeo. Many great songs in their catalogues.
th-cam.com/video/9yteNPh-boY/w-d-xo.html This gives you an idea how much a band like Blue Rodeo can mean to Canadians. This was made during the pandemic to raise spirits.. th-cam.com/video/ghLk-BhT-P8/w-d-xo.html. This showing the depth of feeling during The Tragically Hip's last concert.
Yes!! I agree two of my favourite Canadian bands!!
I give you a thumbs up before I watch your video just because I love Gordon Lightfoot's music and feel he deserves recognition. A true Canadian legend. I know the word legend can be tossed around loosely sometimes but Las a Canadian grew up listening to him, it's the only word I can use to describe him. I do agree he's underappreciated outside of Canada but here he's considered a national treasure. I'd put him on par with the late great American singer/songwriter Jim Croce..
This is indeed a brilliant piece of music. Gives me the shivers every time.
I've only come upon your channel in the last 10 days or so. I am Canadian. And, well, the late Gordon Lightfoot was an ICON here. I saw him in concert 6 times, many years ago now. I've done textile art pieces inspired by his work and by that of the equally wonderful Joni Mitchell. Seeing Lightfoot's name come up on your post, a month or so after his death, well...I just had to watch. And I thank you for showcasing his work.
Wow, thanks so much for your kind words. I just reacted to Joni Mitchell a few days ago. Peace from NY.
The very ethereal sound makes it sound timeless. It could be a story from hundreds of years ago, not just less than 50 years.
Yes, the electric guitar especially almost sounds like weeping or longing
One of my favorite songs!
There was a time, in the not too distant past, where the Canadian music scene was, in the eyes of the American music business, Gord Lightfoot and Anne Murray. Not so anymore! 🇨🇦🖖🏻🇨🇦