One can easily sense the discomfort the ladies had over all that awesome expression of self-defense in a culture that has among its tenets resistance to tyranny (grins in admiration).
Personally I believe there's a difference between Gatka and Shasta vidya. Gatka is a ritualistic performance being a show dance without little practical use in actual combat and where as shastar visits is the art of combat dating couple thousand years back even 1000 years before the Sikh faith was born into the Indian society. I don't believe nidar singh is fake it's just people opposing him lack the knowledge to comment on whats real and what's not. Gatka drives its roots from shastar vidya
NIDAR SINGH IS NOT A REAL NIHANG. WATCH HIS APOLOGY VIDEO HE RAN AWAY FROM OTHER NIHANG JATHABANDEES HE DOESNT DEBATE WATCH THE SIKH YOUTH VIDEO ON HIM
The first book on Shastra vidya has just been published! Backed by textual evidence and nearly 120 images. It's not related to Nidar Singh. Please visit our channel for the book trailer. Thanks.
Fake you mean he doesn't know anything about Shastra vidya? I appreciate him even for trying it, did you ever think you may have prejudice? He ran away?, you will ran away right now if you face any fanatics, that is samrt thing to do instead of trying to fight bunch of shunakas.
@@gshrdy5415 actually the Indian hating sikhs surrounded him and forced him to write an apology because he praised Hinduism for starting Sikh martial arts which is a historical fact .
How can he be the last master when they are several nihangs in India. So were are they learning from. So do all the whole india/punjab sikhs learn from him. Boosting about himself n is definitely not a sikh.
+Parmindar Singh You are getting confused with the sport gatka and THIS Sanatan Shastar Vidiya which is for real combat. He is not boasting. There may be Nihangs in India (Punjab to be specific) but they don't know this art.
+Bappa Rawal yes the nihangs don't know this art because nidar made it up. This is not Shastar Vidya. Go to Buddha dal or tarns dal or any nihang dal in India and learn real Shastar Vidya
Himat Singh This art seems to have a lot of content for one person to make it up. I highly doubt that Nidar could make this up himself. Or anyone for that matter.
Bappa Rawal This “art” has no backing no evidence that he is the “last master” of it. Go watch the Video where Nidar apologizes to the Panth. He apologizes for his actions and the spreading of a fake art.
he is true guru gobind singh ji baba banda singh bahadur learned the same from their school of warfares its actually thousands of years of martial art skills from the indian community
Now did those two have to comment like that at the end of that report, I guess they forget how much blood was spilled and cultures shattered for the sake of the british empire.
Why does she need to throw in that it's being practiced safely and not in our streets, what do they really mean when they say "our streets " think about it
Funny story. The sabers the Brits issued to cavalry had a somewhat flat edge ground on them. This is when the modern perry-riposte, edge on edge bashing was in common use. You can still give a good wack with one though with a charge on horseback. The Brits had the shit scared out of them when the Indians were finding the British discarded sabers, giving them propper grinds, and chopping Brits in half with them.
Is Nidar Singh an accurate example of Nihangs and are Nihangs themselves accurate examples of real Sikhs? I thought Sikhs don't like praying to Hindu deities or partaking in Hindu rituals.
He is self appointed last master of Gatka. There are thousands of Nihangs in Punjab and they gather at Anandpur Sahib on Hola Mohalla. Nobody knows him in the Sikh homeland of Punjab. Basically he has media access and he tries to use popular Indian culture to gain limelight. He is nothing what a true Sikh should be. Sikh dont believe in idol worship. A Sikh doesnt bow his head to anyone but Guru Granth Sahib (Sikh's Holy Book and Spiritual Leader).
Kamal Benipal mr benipal first of all he is not a gatka fighter he is practicing santan dharm shatra vidya , you can look for more of his video , so may be there are more gatka fighters in punjab but i guess very few shastra vidya fighters,. another thing about idol worshipping, you are foolling urself only, guru gobind singh ji is himself great devotee to godess chandi. and deh shiva bar mohe eha explains the rest don't be the victim of western propaganda read ur scriptures without biasness u will be enlightened.
Utkarsh Srivastava what is 'deh shiva bar'? And the reference to Chandi is in Dasam Granth Sahib; a secular text which has writings from other sources and is not as important as Guru Granth Sahib
ronki23 sir, deh shiva var mohe eha is i guess a sikh prayer , so dasam granth is not a sikh text , means i was wrong on my part to say gobind singh ji was lord shiva and godess chandi devotee. hmmm ok
Why do the western media journalists always start the story in a demeaning words? Is this how it's done in the west? Am I not getting it because of cultural difference?
by god's grace we still have this art and spirit alive in India and Punjab.with all due respect he is not the last master of this art.we have even better in Punjab!
not jst looks like ,,,IT ACTUALLT IS...but the ignorant sgpc wont accept this...we sikhs in india want to learn this art...but our panthak jathebandis like sgpc has banned this... it was tought by guru arjan dev jih to saeb sri guru hargobind jih...nd then later advanced during gueugobind sikngh ji's time period....
No idea. I just thought it was a funny story related to the video you and others might like. :3 Just to clarify, the Indians using and improving Brit swords is funny. Disarming a general populous is disgusting. I'm a huge pro-gun, stereotype yank.
khalsa accepts raag mala. khalsa accepts Sri Dasam Granth... khalsa accepts Sri Sarbloh Granth.. Khalsa says waheguru not wagurooo and make bird noises.. khalsa was started by Guru Gobind Singh.. akj was started by a man made sect..
he is the last one teaching though... last gurdev passed away.. so hence in tht respect he is the last one... lots of akj and taksalis call gathka shastar vidiya to fob ppl off n get money
even more frightening is the self deception and delusion required for such feigned disapproval. An artifice that serves to distance the critic from the criticized, when both probably have equal part to play in the bloody past we all come from. Are we to hen peck and cluck our way out of violence or into it once more?
One can easily sense the discomfort the ladies had over all that awesome expression of self-defense in a culture that has among its tenets resistance to tyranny (grins in admiration).
Personally I believe there's a difference between Gatka and Shasta vidya. Gatka is a ritualistic performance being a show dance without little practical use in actual combat and where as shastar visits is the art of combat dating couple thousand years back even 1000 years before the Sikh faith was born into the Indian society. I don't believe nidar singh is fake it's just people opposing him lack the knowledge to comment on whats real and what's not. Gatka drives its roots from shastar vidya
NIDAR SINGH IS NOT A REAL NIHANG. WATCH HIS APOLOGY VIDEO HE RAN AWAY FROM OTHER NIHANG JATHABANDEES HE DOESNT DEBATE WATCH THE SIKH YOUTH VIDEO ON HIM
this guy is fake and everything on his website is fake. on the 300th celebration he ran away from the nihang Sikhs the real nihang singhs in India
The first book on Shastra vidya has just been published! Backed by textual evidence and nearly 120 images. It's not related to Nidar Singh. Please visit our channel for the book trailer. Thanks.
Doesn't matter
Fake you mean he doesn't know anything about Shastra vidya? I appreciate him even for trying it, did you ever think you may have prejudice?
He ran away?, you will ran away right now if you face any fanatics, that is samrt thing to do instead of trying to fight bunch of shunakas.
He is true
@@gshrdy5415 actually the Indian hating sikhs surrounded him and forced him to write an apology because he praised Hinduism for starting Sikh martial arts which is a historical fact .
How can he be the last master when they are several nihangs in India. So were are they learning from. So do all the whole india/punjab sikhs learn from him. Boosting about himself n is definitely not a sikh.
+Parmindar Singh You are getting confused with the sport gatka and THIS Sanatan Shastar Vidiya which is for real combat. He is not boasting. There may be Nihangs in India (Punjab to be specific) but they don't know this art.
+Bappa Rawal yes the nihangs don't know this art because nidar made it up. This is not Shastar Vidya. Go to Buddha dal or tarns dal or any nihang dal in India and learn real Shastar Vidya
Himat Singh
This art seems to have a lot of content for one person to make it up. I highly doubt that Nidar could make this up himself. Or anyone for that matter.
Bappa Rawal
This “art” has no backing no evidence that he is the “last master” of it. Go watch the Video where Nidar apologizes to the Panth. He apologizes for his actions and the spreading of a fake art.
Lift and Learn post the link please for that video
Guru gobind singh jis singhs. I wish i can have the kirpa of shastar vidiya
waheguru ji ki fateh
Idk why everyone is saying he is fake, clearly nobody watched the video, HE IS NOT TEACHING GATKA, he's teaching a form of military art
it was banned because the brits were scared of how the indians wielded swords
I have trained under him abe he is the best
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh.........TO
NIDAR SINGH KHALSA🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
he is true guru gobind singh ji baba banda singh bahadur learned the same from their school of warfares its actually thousands of years of martial art skills from the indian community
he is not the last sikh warrior
there are many in india
Now did those two have to comment like that at the end of that report, I guess they forget how much blood was spilled and cultures shattered for the sake of the british empire.
Why does she need to throw in that it's being practiced safely and not in our streets, what do they really mean when they say "our streets " think about it
This guy got EXPOSED
Kive expose
Angrej ke muh se shasht vidia bola nahi gia
Funny story. The sabers the Brits issued to cavalry had a somewhat flat edge ground on them. This is when the modern perry-riposte, edge on edge bashing was in common use. You can still give a good wack with one though with a charge on horseback. The Brits had the shit scared out of them when the Indians were finding the British discarded sabers, giving them propper grinds, and chopping Brits in half with them.
Is Nidar Singh an accurate example of Nihangs and are Nihangs themselves accurate examples of real Sikhs? I thought Sikhs don't like praying to Hindu deities or partaking in Hindu rituals.
He is self appointed last master of Gatka. There are thousands of Nihangs in Punjab and they gather at Anandpur Sahib on Hola Mohalla. Nobody knows him in the Sikh homeland of Punjab. Basically he has media access and he tries to use popular Indian culture to gain limelight. He is nothing what a true Sikh should be. Sikh dont believe in idol worship. A Sikh doesnt bow his head to anyone but Guru Granth Sahib (Sikh's Holy Book and Spiritual Leader).
Kamal Benipal mr benipal first of all he is not a gatka fighter he is practicing santan dharm shatra vidya , you can look for more of his video , so may be there are more gatka fighters in punjab but i guess very few shastra vidya fighters,. another thing about idol worshipping, you are foolling urself only, guru gobind singh ji is himself great devotee to godess chandi. and deh shiva bar mohe eha explains the rest don't be the victim of western propaganda read ur scriptures without biasness u will be enlightened.
Utkarsh Srivastava what is 'deh shiva bar'? And the reference to Chandi is in Dasam Granth Sahib; a secular text which has writings from other sources and is not as important as Guru Granth Sahib
Utkarsh Srivastava So now some Shrivastava will teach me my religion and culture? Thanks but no thanks
ronki23 sir, deh shiva var mohe eha is i guess a sikh prayer , so dasam granth is not a sikh text , means i was wrong on my part to say gobind singh ji was lord shiva and godess chandi devotee. hmmm ok
Why do the western media journalists always start the story in a demeaning words? Is this how it's done in the west? Am I not getting it because of cultural difference?
no hes fake hes just preaching hinduism
Narbeer Aujla you don't know what you talking about, go do some deep research before making any deluded comments.
Nice
These journalist are so unperared and bad
they say gatka is the traditional sikh art but this to me looks like the real deal
@Polako Polakovic we destroyed horrific armies of attackers, Check Sikh history.
Waheguru ji
looks like samurais got some competition now eh ;)
Beautiful art!
This is the REAL deal. VaheGuru Ji Ka Kalsa, VaheGuru Ji Ke Fateh
+Self Defence Straight up!
Self Defence Nidar singh is not a real nihang, he preaches against gurmat
You must be part of his crew.
Fake like him
its easy if they banned the art from you guys something I would have tought of was train with wooden weapon in the shape of these swords.
HE IS NOT THE LAST WHAT PROOF DO U HAVE BIG UP RESPECT TO NIDDAR
y did he post d hindu divinity pictures....
what a warrior
by god's grace we still have this art and spirit alive in India and Punjab.with all due respect he is not the last master of this art.we have even better in Punjab!
wtf what do they mean by last so niddar has gone to the whole of punjab and searched the whole of india
not jst looks like ,,,IT ACTUALLT IS...but the ignorant sgpc wont accept this...we sikhs in india want to learn this art...but our panthak jathebandis like sgpc has banned this...
it was tought by guru arjan dev jih to saeb sri guru hargobind jih...nd then later advanced during gueugobind sikngh ji's time period....
BBC correspondents need to improve their English and stop these two weird ladies from speaking in that ridiculous tone and manner.
*IT WAS BANNED DUE TO SOME REASON*
@lidder27 hes the last teaching master many tarna dal and buddha dal teachers use it... but dont show it..
Sikhs teaching self defence to the British army
true. but when they banded shastar vidiya, couldent the indians make wooden weapons in the shape of these swords and practice in secret.
No idea. I just thought it was a funny story related to the video you and others might like. :3
Just to clarify, the Indians using and improving Brit swords is funny. Disarming a general populous is disgusting. I'm a huge pro-gun, stereotype yank.
wow ur the first akj to say tht
@AKJCoventry I wish I could study this beutiful art! its the art of my ancestors!
khalsa accepts raag mala. khalsa accepts Sri Dasam Granth... khalsa accepts Sri Sarbloh Granth.. Khalsa says waheguru not wagurooo and make bird noises.. khalsa was started by Guru Gobind Singh.. akj was started by a man made sect..
Brilliant wasn't it?
he is the last one teaching though... last gurdev passed away.. so hence in tht respect he is the last one... lots of akj and taksalis call gathka shastar vidiya to fob ppl off n get money
nidar is a fake his art is not even gatka, i teach gatka and so do over a thousands
He's not teaching gatka if you actually listened to the video, he's teaching military art
Gatka is ritualised combat basically a dance.
@@codegrey9944 Gatka is not dance stupid
😂@@codegrey9944
nd where as this guy nidarr singh says he's the last teacher of this martial art.....===LOL===,
Stone age warrior at present tym you need some sophisticated wapon nt samurai or swords lol
now here with the forcast lol
even more frightening is the self deception and delusion required for such feigned disapproval. An artifice that serves to distance the critic from the criticized, when both probably have equal part to play in the bloody past we all come from. Are we to hen peck and cluck our way out of violence or into it once more?
Sikh kom da gadaar
no he is atrue sikh bhai aap hi btaao fir kiss training k saath ldtey thy sikh yoddhaa
What makes u so judgmental about him ?
gatka made for ony Sikhs not for other if any person learning gatka art the before he will be sikh. He is trained non Sikhs person.
Better than Kalaripayattu =)
How do u know?
shit duplicate nihang
Fake
Fake fudu
Fake Nihang
He is not even a Sikh.
traitor
he is a liar
FAKE
He is a liar.