Magical Triangle - Think Outside The Box!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 มิ.ย. 2020
- Many people requested this one. It was asked to 9th grade students in India who had only learned geometry, so you are supposed to solve it without using trigonometry. I thank Anand Gautam for discovering the incredible solution!
Polish translation credit: Tłumaczenie: Przemyslav
Znajdź mnie tutaj: forum.cdaction.pl/blogs/blog/...
You can also solve the problem with trigonometry. This post does so for the 2nd part of the question:
brainly.in/question/16749924
Subscribe: th-cam.com/users/MindYour...
Send me suggestions by email (address in video). I consider all ideas though can't always reply!
Like many TH-camrs I use popular software to prepare my videos. You can search for animation software tutorials on TH-cam to learn how to make videos. Be prepared--animation is time consuming and software can be expensive!
Why are there comments before the video is published? Get early access and support the channel on Patreon
/ mindyourdecisions
If you buy from the links below I may receive a commission for sales. (As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.) This has no effect on the price for you.
Show your support! Get a mug, a t-shirt, and more at Teespring, the official site for Mind Your Decisions merchandise:
teespring.com/stores/mind-you...
My Books (worldwide links)
mindyourdecisions.com/blog/my...
My Books (US links)
Mind Your Decisions: Five Book Compilation
amzn.to/2pbJ4wR
A collection of 5 books:
"The Joy of Game Theory" rated 4.1/5 stars on 96 reviews
amzn.to/1uQvA20
"The Irrationality Illusion: How To Make Smart Decisions And Overcome Bias" rated 3.7/5 stars on 9 reviews
amzn.to/1o3FaAg
"40 Paradoxes in Logic, Probability, and Game Theory" rated 4.2/5 stars on 18 reviews
amzn.to/1LOCI4U
"The Best Mental Math Tricks" rated 4.3/5 stars on 19 reviews
amzn.to/18maAdo
"Multiply Numbers By Drawing Lines" rated 4.6/5 stars on 14 reviews
amzn.to/XRm7M4
Mind Your Puzzles: Collection Of Volumes 1 To 3
amzn.to/2mMdrJr
A collection of 3 books:
"Math Puzzles Volume 1" rated 4.4/5 stars on 26 reviews
amzn.to/1GhUUSH
"Math Puzzles Volume 2" rated 4.5/5 stars on 6 reviews
amzn.to/1NKbyCs
"Math Puzzles Volume 3" rated 4.1/5 stars on 7 reviews
amzn.to/1NKbGlp
Connect with me
My Blog: mindyourdecisions.com/blog/
Twitter: / preshtalwalkar
Newsletter (sent only for big news, like a new book release): eepurl.com/KvS0r
2017 Shorty Awards Nominee. Mind Your Decisions was nominated in the STEM category (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math) along with eventual winner Bill Nye; finalists Adam Savage, Dr. Sandra Lee, Simone Giertz, Tim Peake, Unbox Therapy; and other nominees Elon Musk, Gizmoslip, Hope Jahren, Life Noggin, and Nerdwriter. - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
Presh : 1+1=2
Me : ok , i got that one
well atleast you got that
Blackpenredpen 😂😂😂
Not gonna lie I had a relative once ask me if x + x = 2x, I said yes then he started arguing about it with my cousin lol
@@Daniel_WR_Hart ROFL
@@vol230 I wish I was trolling but unfortunately I'm not
I cannot believe that I’m watching this to entertain myself.
Good you developed your self and you improved your level in maths
But My Answer is Coming 70°(the asked one) and other one is coming (45+70)=115,180-115= 65°,please help!
same here,each time i open youtube and i see one video from this channel
May I ask why?
me 2...thot i see math 1 last time b4 i die due to kidney failure @16 :) ...bye world♥
Me: *solves the problem looking at the thumbnail using trig*
You: "the challenge is to do it without trig"
Me: 😲
Same hahaha
Me too
I don't even know what trigonometry is. Can someone tell me what it is?
@@deadble5k start with sin, cos, tan, etc and then learn how to manipulate it like algebra
Ikr, his solve is cool and all, but how to solve it pure mathematics
These videos* make me question whether I really deserve to be in college.
I hope you are joking. You understood the proof presented - that is vital in my opinion vs getting the ah ha momoment which can often be *not* so trivial
My friend, you and I are the same
@@salmanel-farsi3744 if it is not sp trivial that means it's also important so aren't you contradicting yourself?
@@leif1075 Thanks for highlighting the possible confusion. My point was to celebrate the understanding of the proof even if one could not arrive at the proof themselves. I will go back to adjust the wording..
@@salmanel-farsi3744 Thanks but I need to be someone who arrives at the proof themselves or comes up withba different proof..I don't want to be unexceptional..recognizing the proof or understanding it doesn't require nearly as much ability.
"Nothing out of the box is good, trust me"
Pandora
That made my day🤣🤣😂
Presh should give this comment a heart.
@Cara Peru. I always love being inside the box. 😜
Classic!!! 🔥💯😆
Schrodinger approves too
I've always found those problems so cool! Just rotating a triangle was the key, and I would never think about it until you showed us. Great job Presh!
Dont you find it annoying and frustrating and insulting?
Ahaa photocoPI
sumakit cjs well, in french π is prononced like "pee" so my username works better
I eventually realized you had to do it if you wanted a non trig solution to this problem but I wouldn't have satisfied the time constraints of a traditional math test.
That is why trig was invented. To save time and eliminate the need to come up with tricks.
It took me a couple of days jumping from one way to another until finally could jump out of the box
Oh dang - that was intense!
Just another jee problem 😪
3D god is watching 2D thing lmao
@@NamVu-im2xm lol
How are you here?
But My Answer is Coming 70°(the asked one) and other one is coming (45+70)=115,180-115= 65°,please help!
3:37 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯 being an Indian student that amazed me
Yes because race determines your reactions.
@@HeckaS no way , you got that wrong , as a student in Indian education system it's quite difficult to find someone who looks upon such questions and problems and I was amazed just because of the beauty of the question , I hope that you got my point ..
Why you have to mention "Indian " ??
@@Dev_1907 cuz this que is frm an indian 9th grade que paper
@@HeckaS they said that because the question was from the main course maths book for 9th graders in India
I always love "Out Of The Box" thinking like this. Thanks again Presh!
Hmmm. Sure it was an “out of the square” solution. 😜
I can't stand them. They always seem completely arbitrary
@@tjejojyj 😂 AMAZING BRO !! 😀👍🏻😂
But My Answer is Coming 70°(the asked one) and other one is coming (45+70)=115,180-115= 65°,please help!
The first part was real easy. 45 and 70 degrees part of the triangle has to equal 180 degrees. So the missing part must be 65. I didn’t exactly understand what the second part needed me to do so I just watched it after. Took me about 5 minutes tops
I actually thought about rotation and solved the first part.I was too lazy for the second part.But the point I wanna make is that due to your videos,Presh,I was able to get better at geometry quite a bit,and also in Math problem solving in general.I wanna thank you for that.My creativity also actually increased.Please keep coming up with such good Math videos.
Beautiful. The problem, the explanation, and everything this channel brings is pure amazing
Dayummmmm....Why i'm not find your channel early?... I just want to entertain myself with this something useful rather than a meme video or drama that wasting my time a lot while quarantine 😭😭😭
I have just came across this channel and I am so glad about it
And I definitely became the constant member of it :)
I’ve been watching you channel for a long time that i am able now to every problem you upload. It feels amazing when you say did you figure it out and the answer is yes :)
Ah yes, the negotiator
I really love this channel as it shows 'out of the box thinking'.It feels cool to do so.
The first time coming across ur videos I have started liking maths.you really have comprehensive explanations.THANK YOU.
Surprised that the solution doesn't involve the gougu theorem.
Lmao
what
Vszk 010 Pythagorean Theron is known as gougu theorem among mandarin speaking countries.
Use hua
This channel should be renamed as the Gougu theorem channel
Nice puzzle. I was content to solve this using brute force and was surprised to find whole number answers. This of course meant there was a more elegant solution. Thanks for showing the reflection trick. Immediately this brings to mind folding tricks, origami as one. if we fold the two flaps on either side, they would fit neatly within the larger triangle in the middle. Super neat!
Watching your last videos enables me to solve this problem on my own! Thanks Presh!
I'm impressed with myself that I actually understood this one from start to finish.
I clicked the video thinking that I'd have to hear all about the Gougu theorem. Imagine my pleasant surprise when I didn't.
Love from Mumbai, India.🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Love your videos, "Mind your decisions".
Good thing i stumbled upon this channel by chance. This is a good brain exercise. Looking forward to more math problems.
Your channel is making me feel so inadequate. LOL
Thanks for all the challenges, and answers.
I thought ur previous problems r simple but this one is truly some big brain stuff!!
When you know how to do the first part but the second part is a struggle.
yo sameee
Second part is more interesting😜😜
I found the second part easier for some reason
When you wipe you bum then have to wipe your hand after.
Don't ask!
th-cam.com/video/eEyQyixOGpU/w-d-xo.html
There is another elegant way to do this question, this was the way i did this question when it first came to me:
My solution is about to prove that this EF segment defined by a 45° in the square is aways tangent to the quarter of circunference with unity radious and center in A.
To do this take the quarter of circunference and trace a tangent segment of it, now with the intersection point "P" trace AP and look that the pairs of triangles ADE, APE and ABF,APF are congruents by the Side Side Angle case (SSA - common sides, unity side and straight angle). With it, see the congruence between DAE, PAE and PAF, BAP angles, nevertheless how DAE+PAE+PAF+BAP=90° and DAE=PAE, PAF=BAP, then PAE+PAF=45°, proving that EAF will aways be 45°.
So, we can guarantee that if we pass a quarter circunference in the problem with radious 1 and center A it will tangent EF. Doing this, let the intersection be an X point, now observe the AXF and ABF triangles - they are congruent by the same case before - and see that AFB and AFX(AFX=AFE) angles are both 70°, letting angle AEF= 65°(AFE+FEA+EAF=180° - EAF=45°, AFE=70°). (:
I couldn't solve this one, I tried the linear system of equations but it was singular. However, having watched this, I feel that I now have learned a trick that might help me solve problems in the future. Thanks so much for this wonderful channel!
Very interesting, I love Geometry and this is my edutainment. Thank you.
Also we can find the angle by folding ADE and ABF when we draw the height of AEF
Спасибо, Мастер! Благодаря Вам я увидела большие пробелы в своём образовании и в характере. Особенно много мне дали Ваши задачи по геометрии. Я восхищаюсь Вами!
I love your learning mindset that great people never stop learning.
Amazing solution!!!!!!! That's why I love this channel very much.
I’d have chosen a brute force method and simply made equations over equations and then slowly eliminating the unknown parts till I can solve it. But your way is much faster and easier. Thank you for making this awesome content.
I tried this but I was only got x+y=135 over and over again (where x is angle AEF and y is angle AFE)
May I know the application you used for presentation sir? Could you provide us a video tutorial on how to use it. Thank you very much
I am totally surprised☺ to subscribe a person like me. Sir, you are playing a vital role in transforming the education in simple and convenient way. Will gift your books to students on their b'day ☺.
We are inspired by you. Thanks for motivating us to do math videos 😌💝
Your "rotations" are always beyond the access of my imagination. Nice problem and solution.
Doesn't that make you feel bad?
good problem, not too hard, not too easy - and good clue on the title - which sort of gave the answer. Took me a while but got it.
This is crazy! This is about depth of mind. and very impressive. Thank you☄
Presh's way ("half angle" model) is good, I just want to show alternative, which is good too. Draw FH perpendicular to AE and meet @ H, thus A,B,F,H and E,C,F,H are co-circular (concyclic), respectively.
So ∠HBF=∠HAF=45° (circumferential angle), so BH must be the diagonal of ABCD; connect DH (which must be diagonal), so ∆ADH congruent to ∆CDH, thus ∠DAH=∠DCH=90-45-20=25°, hence, ∠HFE =25° too, bcz it's circumferential angle, so we get ∠AEF=90-25=65°
As for second part of the problem, we can use Gougu theorems and similar triangles (∆ADE and ∆FHE) to get answer, that's 2 (for you guys to do 😁).
Dude I have two doubts
First is that what you mean by co circular
Do you mean concyclic???
And second is that gougou is pythagoras theorem??
iam asian
@@ujjwalnarayan07 1, by that it means the four pts are at same circle. 2, yes, Gougu = Pythagorean
Takılmışız "sadece müziğin dili evrenseldir" diye.
Oysa ki her müziğin bir matematiği vardır ve asıl evrensel olan belki de matematiktir .
2+2 tüm dillerde 4 eder .
Newton matematik için "Evrenin dili" tanımlamasını yapmış.
Verdigin hesplamanın sonucu 2'nin 4'un +'nin.... tanımına bağlı. Eğer mantik zincirimizde bunlarin tanımiyla ya da bu fonksiyonlarla ilgili bir kırıklık, eksiklik ya da bu işlemin tümünün koşullarını overridelayan bir değişken/etken varsa düpedüz yanlış olan bir şey bile bazen teknik olarak doğru olabilir
katılıyorum geometriye bayılırım, ingilizcede sadece basit tanışma faslını bilirim ama videoyu çok iyi anladım :)
O zaman Matematik yapamayanlar da dilsiz oluyor herhalde? :)
:)
I almost gave up on this one even after guessing the answer, but took a pen and paper and quickly did it. Satisfying this one.
Is there a way to do this algebraically? I drew a imaginary line between A and C. And I used the property(or whatever it’s called) AB parallel to DC to solve for most of the angles in the problem. Eventually I came up with A LOT of equations to represent angle AEC and AFC, but I wasn’t sure what to do from there. Most of the equations are in the format of a+b=angle AEC(or whatever angle I want to describe). I want to know if there is a way to do this complete this with this method, cause that would be pretty cool. Thanks!
It's a problem of 9th grade student of India
china the same
Korea in 8th grade
Maybe they say "Grade 9" in India :-)
@@Tiqerboy its not a bymistake. This is what he said in video
@@user-ow2vf1dd3j in india 9th grade students are 13-14 years
What is the perimeter?
Paul: Imagine that we have a ruler.
I guess he has left his ruler somewhere out of the box.
ישראלי!
@@drorbenuliel9280עלית עליי
This is so cool! Thank you for sharing!
The first video I fully understand, thank you!
As a ninth grader in India, I'll admit that I was unable to solve this one, but I was able to understand exactly how you reached the conclusions. I just didn't think about rotation. Thanks for sharing this problem, we have tons of questions like these in our book since almost half our chapters in the book are geometry this year (Quadrilaterals, Triangles, Lines and Angles, Circles, etc).
This one must be of RD
yeah it must be
@@stupidstuart6478
Now I know I can't pass grade 9 in India. Thanks! :)
Its not bro i m indian i m in 10th
It was just a miscellaneous question
@@Anish-IITP bruh if you're weak in studies Dont actually defame us...
I am studying for IMO from grade 7 and we used to get such questions.
@@theUnmeshraj if u r overintelligent dont pop yr ass
@@theUnmeshraj btw. Best of luck Hoping under 1k rank in jee. Its not in sarcastic way. Imo atudents are really worth it.
@@theUnmeshraj Dude being able to answer this question isn't even a flex lol. A waste of time not to use trig, but I didn't and still got the answer. This question proves nothing about intelligence.
Bravo for the problem AND the solution! Congratulations to Anand Gautem.
👌. I haven't even thought of such a solution like this. Thanks for sharing this problem.
Never thought I’d encounter this problem again lmao we had it in year 8 math in China
Sorry i need to turn the bell on i refreshed the page at the perfect time tho
That's awesome I loved the way you figure it out......
I learnt the answer and advice others to learn. Thanks so much.
As a Canadian middle schooler, I got so incredibly close. The outside the box for me
8th grade?
I got 85
Love from india presh sir .. one thing I want to tell you that for your such amazing geometry videos i am able to improve my geometry to a great extent . ❤️ Btw i solved the problem using trigonometry and my answer came approximately ≈ 64.743 ≈ 65 . (Reason is because the values which the calculator gave was approximated ) but TBH your solution about rotating the triangle was great 👍 . Came to learn a new thing form you , thanks 😀
It can be also done by similarity and in most of the square triangle question rotating the triangle is clue:-)
We can also generalize it by taking angle theta instead of 45 degrees
@CHABBI SARKAR PJ Sir ka Bhakt
Really I cant live without Presh Sir
@@siddharthabhattacharya391 kon
I got that one with triangle math but you still blew my mind twice in this one
It is nice to prove your claim at 3:30 that the perimeter of CEF is always 2. If EC is 1-tg(alpha) and CF is 1- tg(45-alpha) .... It is nice to see it.
Just found another way! By drawing two circles with radii DE and BF, in vertices E and F, respectively. Ultimately finding the altitude of triangle AEF. The rest is pretty straightforward.
Ya
How do the two circles solve the first part (i have not even got to second part)
Thinking “Out Of The Box” is something that I should apply in geometry too.
Never thought Congruency will be used.
Love from Haridwar (India)❤️
I always make a point to try the problem before watching. I did the whole thing using trig, and when I started watching the first thing you said was "without using trig", duh, no wonder it wasn't so trivial. What a clever solution though. Good video!
Thank you very much for solving this problem. Good luck. Hi from Russia.
16 years ago i could solve it in 5 minutes ) but now i think "wow, amazing" :)
Everything was cool until this rotation.. I mean wth!
You are God Sir, Best teaching in my whole life and learn very easily. GREAT SIR 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Watched a handful of these videos in the last two days. I noticed not once (yet) has the Law of Sines come into play. It actually made finding the perimeter easier than finding the measure of the angle. Still, the solution does seem more satisfying than using Law of Sines.
Amazing from indonesia🇮🇩
This made me realise how out of shape I am with math. I remember having this in my grade 4 mock exams in the Philippines.
Nice video. Nice solution, it's out of the box..
What software do you use to make the video?
It’s like half quiz
and half math.
Enjoyed much!!
Just one word to say:- "WOW"
Directly connect the diagonal！
So, after fill by program completed , How to write code send auto? Your clip just fill , but didn't to send.
Thanks very much presh to this amazing hard puzzle i didnt solved but now i understand it pleaz always share with us that kind of puzzle
I had a doubt how can you construct 20°and AF=AF' AT SAME TIME
th-cam.com/video/osuflRQzsm0/w-d-xo.html see the second method
Love from INDIA..🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
One of the greatest nations.
Me 2 India 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
India is the smartest country in the world
Only love will not work, you need to solve the problem in in the first place 😉 Btw, both Asia and Europe are smart
It is such an amazing animation in teaching the students. Could you tell me which software you use?
Great question and explanation!
Alternative solution
Create 2 equations involving 2 unknown variables on point E and F.
Problem solved..
No!
Equations are Boring part of Mathematics, But I used to see everything in the form of Geometry - Stephen Hawking
Me: It's really True !
Thanks man for such interesting question and solution.
These vids are great . i turned on the notifications for them.
I found the length of the perimeters interesting, as far as the angles all triangles equal 180 degrees so solving the unknown angle was no problem .
i miss you mathematics&geometry.. now im a med student :(
merhabalar. videonun kapak fotografindaki bilinmeyen aciyi 80 derece buldum. siz bu konuda ne dusunuyorsunuz ?
Şimdi evrenin sırrını çözücen hadi bakalım
@@cerencemal1617 kim evrenin sırtını cözecek reyiz?
It's very cool! I don't understand this fact! Thank you!
Nice
You can also solve the first part by proving that the center of circle (AEF) lies on AC
İngilizcem yetersiz olmasına rağmen görerek anladım gayet anlaşılıyor, umamırım mesajımı anlamışsınızdır 😌
Oh god I can actually recall something like this coming in my 9th grade exams
The rotation solution is really elegant and satisfying! I got there maybe a little more laboriously just solving a system of equations with unknown angles AEF, AFE, FEC, and EFC: AFE + EFC = 110; AEF + FEC = 115; FEC + EFC = 90; AEF + AFE = 135. So AEF = 65, FEC = 50, EFC = 40, and AFE = 70.
Angle e and f both side satisfy with 65 and 70 so this doubt create because exactly answer not solve angle e is 70 or 65 confusion create
I used trignometry and sin rule but your solution is beautiful
I couldnt solve this even with trigonometry
Me
Law of sines
When I see these types of problems, I usually try to set up a bunch of equations and then solve for the unknown variables.
Yeah everyone does that ig because we've all been taught that way. Whenever something is unknown just start assuming variables and then it's just one variable after another and then try and get those many number of unique equations.
I extended segment EF to create a new angle and apply the exterior angle sum theorem and I got 45 + (unknown angle) = 120 because triangle has 3 sides and 360/3 = 120. I got that the unknown angle = 75. Is there anything wrong with this?
Pls I have a problem on total surface area of irregular shape. Please how do I send it to you? It is also a think out of the box problem.
2:00
F' : let me introduce myself
btw this was a cool problem even tho i wasn't able to solve it and found it complicated you made it seem easy
@@tommydecarite4121
That's the thing with any master of skill, they are so good at it that when they do it they make it seem easy. Goes for math, goes for juggling and about anything in between. You only discover how hard it actually is when you are trying to do it yourself.
I found x = 65 and P = 2 ... it looked easier than what it actually is 🧐
How did you solve for P though? The way he did it?
Leif we know the angles DEA = 65 and AFB = 70 so we can find EC = 1- 1/tg(DEA), FC = 1 - 1/tg(AFB) and EF comes straight from Pitagora ...
@@christianfunintuscany1147 what the heck is tg?? And pythagoras doesnt eliminate the variables in this case so you dont get the answer..
Leif sorry ... tg is the function tan, if you know the angle you know its tangent and because the side equal 1 you can easily find the other side, you can do this in both triangles ADE and ABF in this way you find FC and EC then with Pitagora theorem you find EF and you have the perimeter FC + EC + EF. ok ? Sorry for the confusing tg ... :)
First ever ( mind your decisions )question I was able to solve.
Does the side of the original square need to be 1(x) for the perimetre to be 2 (2x) or is it always 2 ?