► To download PDFs:web.telegram.org/k/#@DrVipanGoyal 👉 Uttar Pradesh PSC (Pre + Mains) Live Foundation 2024 Batch 9 : bit.ly/4671XzA Admissions Closing on 27th November 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM 👉 Bihar PSC (Pre + Mains) Live Foundation 2024 Batch 9 : bit.ly/474Dcp4 Admissions Closing on 27th November 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM 👉 Uttar Pradesh RO/ARO 2023 (Pre + Mains) Live Comprehensive Batch 3 : bit.ly/3u41Jw2 Admissions Closing on 28th November 2023 | Live Classes at 6:00 PM 👉 Odisha PSC (Pre + Mains) Live Foundation 2024 Batch 7 : bit.ly/462OQj1 Admissions Closing on 27th November 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM 👉 Haryana PSC (Pre + Mains) Live Foundation 2024 Batch : bit.ly/49S71uK Batch Starting on 2nd December 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 8:00 AM 👉 Assam PSC (Pre + Mains) Live Foundation 2024 Batch 7 : bit.ly/49t6wqO Admissions Closing on 27th November 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM 👉 Madhya Pradesh PSC (Pre + Mains) Live Foundation 2024 Batch 7 : bit.ly/4741QpT Admissions Closing on 27th November 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM 👉 Punjab PSC (Pre + Mains) Live Foundation 2024 Batch 4 : bit.ly/471kOO4 Admissions Closing on 27th November 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM 👉 Jammu & Kashmir PSC (Pre + Mains) Live Foundation 2024 Batch 4 : bit.ly/3sv5D0jj Admissions Closing on 27th November 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM
Abhijit is most real, honest and objective in his thoughts, views and analysis of India, the world and everything else. And all from a position of knowledge, information, logic, science and sound rationale
@@kunalthakur3415well he also hated capitalism industrialization,wanted closed economy,hated democracy etc etc ... But these assumptions are would could basic,,,so chill Netaji Subhash is our Hero anyway ❤
@@kunalthakur3415 I don't think he was so, but it's about dictatorship and disintegration of Indian union....anyways personally he is greatest freedom fighter who sacrificed everything. But remember just because someone loves you doesn't mean he can help you. And I think he understood that Indians at then present condition are mostly not law abiding people as you can see today, so he thought about such a regime to discipline us, but as AIM said, once dictatorship starts it has no limits or end.....no worries
I liked his comments on several topics and including particularly on India being a Super Power. I don't know why some people even think that way showing their ignorance. Once you live in America for a long duration, you begin to see how America has transformed into a Super Power. It is not just financial power. Your military power, higher educational institutions, research and development, infrastructure, and most importantly, GDP(personal) plays a dominant role. In India, we have a long way to go and it may never happen because of our significant poverty.
America became powerfull just after bretton wood conference, in 50s, thats hardly 70 years back. What are you even talking about. Prior to ww2 america was not like todays america. If your are talking about education, show me one world class institution from china which was getting high ranking 20 years back. This is the same mindset which kept up confidence less as a nation for last 70 years. We are already formidable military power. Going to be the formidable economic power in next 20 years with a potential of 20 tril. We are education powerhouse in asia, our diplomacy is top notch hardly 98% countries can match, we have cultural dept, geographical advantage. The list goes on. Dont believe this ganju. I dont even understand why study iq even invited him. His analytical ability is of a 12th standard student. watch few of his podcast, and you will understand, he is just another overrated attention seeker. He just memorize some bullet points and keep playing with words around that knowledge. Want to see real analytics just follow subject experts. Like md khan for ancient history and archeology like that.
@@watanabe00738Congratulations on being an optimist. But all your statements about India has one thing in common. "India will be....". The fact is India isn't all those. India has always been a country with huge potential & it will remain so in future.
Yes they don't live with Jihadis and their educated sympathiser and Christian missionaries and communist and urban naxals and khud ki roti sekne Wale neta log Jo n to sanatan Dharma jante hai na hi patriot hai.. eg Congress . America made sure there is less development throughout the world in order to be seen as superpower, and all these activities I mentioned is heavily funded by USA,along with China ,KGB RUSSIAN AGENCY in the past and some Islamic states, directly to missionaries and indirectly to Pakistan and our Dhruv rathee,congress like liberandus to destabilize India to become Bharat , a culturally rich morally dhramic , sone ki chidiya wala Desh , did you understand Jon Snow. Jai Shree Ram 🚩🚩
Looking forward towards this podcast...😊 Hopefully we will see major gaurav arya and major Bakshi too in coming lectures too..😊.. youth need to be more aware about India's security issues...
❤🎉 Please Invite JSD J Sai Deepak ,SC Lawyer he is just wow... Also thanks for this podcast , being spritual i think there is more to learn about Neta ji Bose as he is somehow sharp intelligent and spritual man ..i don't agree with AIM in this case may be i need reading or he but you can see now Nepal demand Monarchy discarding democracy. I think there is a forcefull push to Democracy as only political system good enough by western political thinkers which world studies. Our ancient Monarchies was (obviously except foreign Islamic cruel rulers doing things inline with Islam) different then other monarchies or better call them dictatorship , where Dharma abiding regime prevails and the moment Adharmi comes to power there was a change in monarchy without hurting any common people or crimes like raping ,looting n all..🙏
Welcome this faster version. These days almost all interview based or discussion based podcast exceed 45 minutes, or even hours. Yours is fast, to the point, relevant and informative.
12:20 bruh netaji literally made his own bank and currency when he was forming azad hind fauj and produced their own food and tried to send 1lakh ton of rice to the people of Bengal during 1943 and netaji also made so many good political relations that would have helped in the rise of economy and this guy is saying he doesn't understand economics ☠️
How is the Deoli incident not more talked about. I never knew what our governments have done. I had always despised the inhumane concentration camps both in Europe and America and even by the Japanese . But even we too did this and we aren’t even aware . More people should know about it
Ambedkar's own caste mahar still discriminate lower castes like mang/matang and bhangi. And harijan do same with valmiki and mahar. But no dalit leader has guts to accept this they only want to change others not themselves lol
See caste or class is inbuilt inheritance of every society it existed everywhere But some slightly overcome it through industrialization and others don't
Sardar Vallabh Bhai Patel as the PM would have been blessing ; we never had. SC Bose was too idealistic ,He was Gandhi in opposite direction and in a heterogenous society you never know the outcome. Patriot among Patriots Bose was tailor made for Defence Minsiter or an Army chief. Sardar was one of the finest politician in the world not just India ; realist and a visionary. To unify 560+ princely states is a marvel in itself. His prediction on China and Pak were spot on; which Nehru did not have. But to extrapolate Bose as Stalin is beyond foolery. He was idealistically in love with India ; that in politics can be a short-coming. Bhagat Singh SC Bose were people you want to emulate but your inner shortcomings prevent it. They were too good to be true imagine a 22-23 year old graduate readily giving up his life for our future that was Bhagat Singh No fear in the face of Death so was SC Bose gave up everything for INA and Indian Independence , saw nothing but the dream of a perfect India. This thought of perfection in real-politik can either be fatal or unstoppable. A man loves what he cannot be. Netaji SC Bose and Shaheed-e-Azam Bhagat Singh were those men.
I they both were swayed by communist ideologies...may be that would have been an impediment..By the way Netaji died in India in 1985.. Gumnami baba story is corroborated to be true through evidence and facts..I find Netaji to be a Sanatani at the last stage of his life..
But Stalin was the Reason why Soviet Regime had to Industrialize. However, I doubt that Subhash Chandra Bose would have operated in a similar fashion. Yes, we would have been under Communist Dictatorship kind of Regime.......but then again Nehru too was very similar to a Communist Dictator and Ruled India for a Period of 17 Years without any Opposition
I seen many msg about why India cannot become superpower😢. When you don't have any mindset for achivement, you will achieve nothing. I am very optimistic person and I want to India become great. We need awareness in our population about geopolitics and we need more education, so people can choose right leader
Being great & being superpower are slightly different. India can be great again. Even I hope for the same. But being superpower is burdensome, in this I agree with abhijeet.
This was very short and would have liked much longer in conversational style and not in Q&A format . Please get this chap again and have at least an hour of talk, he sounds very interesting and knowledgeable
I appreciate Abhijits vocal ness if Netaji But I think he didn't read well. Bose said he wanted the people of india to choose a leader and even in azad hind government he wasn't the leader as such , he was there as a representative of India 🇮🇳 Moreover he said , in the initial days it is better to have a strong Central government that will have complete control , and when our economy gets a certain stability the basic model that would be followed :- will be democracy ( people's government ) That's what he meant I think Abhijit has this tendency to take things into extremes by wrapping it with the terror of some past incident that didn't turned out well I don't know about Prime minister , but I think bose would have been the best defence minister . Because of his experience in Indian National Army . And also due to his relations with multiple leaders . It would have been easy for him to get military deals or alliance
A basic anomoly on AIM s argument if Bharat have lost his relevenve for British in 1910 why they wanted to control India till 1947 and beyond. This is the most silliest argument.
Why did British voters overwhelmingly voted for a disaster like Brexit? The answer to your historical question will get a clarity from contemporary times.
SC Bose can be respected as freedom fighter but he is overhyped. His views on Secularism were no different from Nehru-Gandhi Muslim appeasement. His Socialism would have destroyed India
Bose was ranked 4th in ICS in the world and took a time of 6 month to prepare for the exam. And this guy says he didn't knew economics. Just read Bose's books on how he wants India to be. The man sacrificed everything for India and we did ? We just criticize him as another Stalin! That's a destiny Indian's chose.
One can admire Bose for his patriotism and contribution to India's freedom struggle while still recognising how bad/dangerous his economic ideas were. And we have more than a century of evidence today, case after case, of how big a disaster leftist/socialist/communist ideas have been for societies. And yes, no doubt Bose was highly intelligent. But intelligence does not make you immune to the seduction of communist ideas, especially in his time, when communism was relatively new and its biggest disasters were yet to unfold. So he was a product of his time, so perhaps we should not judge him too harshly. But as far as potential impact is concerned, I completely agree with AIM here... He would've been a disaster for our country economically, like any communist dictator. I still admire him for his contribution in our freedom struggle though.
I legit don't know what their issue is with each other. JSD has never said that we need to do away with everything that is colonial, in fact he has explicitly said that we don't need to do that. I am reading his books, and I've seen almost every interview of his. His position is very clear - That we need to be able to look at our issues from the lens of our own civilization. Which is to say that the Abrahamic mindset is binary, exclusive and competitive. Our civilization has been pluralist, inclusive and syncretic. A smart man as AIM would know this, yet I cannot understand why he'd be on bad terms with JSD. This is not the first time when he has spoken about this. Even JSD once said that he'd never be invited to their 'cliques'. So I imagine there are some deeper issues between them. Beyond ideological.
@RuturajGole Jsaideepak has said hmko american society sikhayegi transgender ko kaise treat karna hai (low castes ko to ache se treat ni kar paye tumlog uska jimemvar bhi british btadia lol) , he also said in one lecture hmare samaj ko government sikhayegi ki sc st se discrimination nahi karna and so on.. what is he aiming at if not dissmissing a western opinion about something whose vague alternative we think we have? obviously the example aim gave was not very clear, but J sai deepak has also said dont westernised or talk about emperical evidence when discussing ayurveda we need to talk about the anthropological socioligcal and development aspect of ayurveda and not go on the emeprical standard western has said. now if you know anythign about what emperical standard basicallly means you will know how stupid that point is.
Rejecting the opinion of westerns on how to treat a transgender just because the opinions are so called western rejecting the emperical evidence based aproach when discussing ayurveda just because the approach is so called western emphasizing on the name bharat instead of india just because it is western he also says that indian state should learn subject only in their mother tongue and if they want to go beyond it they can have some bridge course, he didnt specified the bridge course was of hindi or english.. but either way he is also against english except optional just because it is western.. this is the problem.. the fact that indians are naturally polyglot must be celebrated but no he reject reject reject i can go on and on regarding abrahmic mindset as binary where as your statement about outer civilizations is itself binary one
Before Aryan Migration theory which is false. But if it is true We still had Shukracharya and Daityas Indic civilization current day Middle east way was also Indic civilization
Bose is not a Marxist he is for industrialization of country there is a pdf in internet Subhash Chandra Bose on political and economic planning Stalin is successful in industrialisation of russia
Rahul seems to be distracted, not constantly focused, keeps looking everywhere and to me as a viewer seems pretty casual and not serious at the podcast
Fanatic..........Fun fact - till today Savarkar family has not married outside bramhin caste, and will not in next hundred years............yet he said savarkar wanted casteless society Andhbhkt will say intercaste marriage criteria nahi ho sakta......so you want casteless society, now you progressed and can touch them now... but don't want to mrry them and still upbring them.
Does sarvarkar family has anything to do with his idelogy? They might not be on same page with him as he was student in London for major of his youth days. And why are you blaming brahmins for less inter caste marriage, if you see statics of inter caste marriage in india the most of them are done by brahmins and the marriage within in caste is more frequent in OBCs and SC and even if a tribal person marry outside his tribe, they get boycotted by their own tribe. Before calling others andhbhakt you should first introspect yourself on your ignorance and stop peddling same rhetoric using stupid reasoning. Pehle khud aapas may shadi karo many low caste people themselves don't marry within some castes jinko vo khud se low samjhti h. Phir brahmins ko blame karna, inter caste marriage se pehle kitna aapne uplift kar liya ye bhi to dikhiye, ek caste ko blame karke Uspe sara ilzam dalna thik nahi.
@@saumyapandey2372Brahmins ne to sara system banaya hai ye varna system which became finally caste system. To varna system ko alive rkhne ke liye hai to brahmins ne ye intercast marriage ko oppose kiya hai . Aur Brahmins ko khud ko sabse uper bataya , shresth bataya even you can murder anyone expect Brahmins because Brahmins ne khud ko hi declare kr diya ki aisa kroge to brahm hatya hogi. Aur uske liye inhone varna system banaya (future cast system) . Women ki sexuality ko control kiya by denying them to pursue education . And yahi hai Brahminism ( brahmanvad) jo ki ek thought hai aur wahi thoughts jo baki ke varno ne adopt kiya . So it was always about Brahmins and Brahminism .they were responsible then and theirs ideology is responsible for today's honor killing in intercaste marriage 2. Yes Brahmins do intercaste because constitution gives them power to do so in special and hindu marriage act .after independence savarn women got equal rights on paper but they also got resources from their family . So they fought and demanded their full rights and started feminism movment in india . Uske baad se kaayi dasak(10) saal baad intercaste marriage kr rhi hai wo bhi because of savarna women especially Brahmins. 3. Other caste ki women ko abhi education nhi mil paa rhi hai early marriage ho jaati hai un caste hi halat hi aisi hai ki naa to koi asset hai (ex. Land) jo unki condition theek kr ske na hi unke pass education hai. Tbhi to aabhi bhi wo ek gulam ki trah hai . Brahmin women ke pass khud virasat me mila hai to wo kr rhi hai Aur caste inequality ,caste discrimination, honor killing ke piche ek hi reason hai wo mindset jo hai Brahminism jo invent kra hai Brahmins ne . So don't play victim card
► To download PDFs:web.telegram.org/k/#@DrVipanGoyal
👉 Uttar Pradesh PSC (Pre + Mains) Live Foundation 2024 Batch 9 : bit.ly/4671XzA
Admissions Closing on 27th November 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM
👉 Bihar PSC (Pre + Mains) Live Foundation 2024 Batch 9 : bit.ly/474Dcp4
Admissions Closing on 27th November 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM
👉 Uttar Pradesh RO/ARO 2023 (Pre + Mains) Live Comprehensive Batch 3 : bit.ly/3u41Jw2
Admissions Closing on 28th November 2023 | Live Classes at 6:00 PM
👉 Odisha PSC (Pre + Mains) Live Foundation 2024 Batch 7 : bit.ly/462OQj1
Admissions Closing on 27th November 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM
👉 Haryana PSC (Pre + Mains) Live Foundation 2024 Batch : bit.ly/49S71uK
Batch Starting on 2nd December 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 8:00 AM
👉 Assam PSC (Pre + Mains) Live Foundation 2024 Batch 7 : bit.ly/49t6wqO
Admissions Closing on 27th November 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM
👉 Madhya Pradesh PSC (Pre + Mains) Live Foundation 2024 Batch 7 : bit.ly/4741QpT
Admissions Closing on 27th November 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM
👉 Punjab PSC (Pre + Mains) Live Foundation 2024 Batch 4 : bit.ly/471kOO4
Admissions Closing on 27th November 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM
👉 Jammu & Kashmir PSC (Pre + Mains) Live Foundation 2024 Batch 4 : bit.ly/3sv5D0jj
Admissions Closing on 27th November 2023 | Daily Live Classes at 6:00 PM
Prakhar srivastava
😊⁰ pop a0⁰}0%000))>>1
We need more of ABHIJEET
then go for AC too
@@biswajeetdassh9305 he is a joker 😂
@@pranav_chalotraabhijeet chavda ki baat chal rahi hai. Tumhari nahi.
Abhijit is most real, honest and objective in his thoughts, views and analysis of India, the world and everything else. And all from a position of knowledge, information, logic, science and sound rationale
It’s a wonderful initiative by studyiq team for us to understand different perspectives on several relevant affairs. . Looking forward to it ! 😊
Strangely his views on subash Chandra Bose matches mine
Can you explain how netaji would have been a disaster in terms of economics ?
Yeah, even mine
@@kunalthakur3415
He believed in Communism.
Communism is a disaster for both economics as well as personal liberty.
@@kunalthakur3415well he also hated capitalism industrialization,wanted closed economy,hated democracy etc etc ...
But these assumptions are would could basic,,,so chill
Netaji Subhash is our Hero anyway ❤
@@kunalthakur3415 I don't think he was so, but it's about dictatorship and disintegration of Indian union....anyways personally he is greatest freedom fighter who sacrificed everything. But remember just because someone loves you doesn't mean he can help you. And I think he understood that Indians at then present condition are mostly not law abiding people as you can see today, so he thought about such a regime to discipline us, but as AIM said, once dictatorship starts it has no limits or end.....no worries
I liked his comments on several topics and including particularly on India being a Super Power. I don't know why some people even think that way showing their ignorance. Once you live in America for a long duration, you begin to see how America has transformed into a Super Power. It is not just financial power. Your military power, higher educational institutions, research and development, infrastructure, and most importantly, GDP(personal) plays a dominant role. In India, we have a long way to go and it may never happen because of our significant poverty.
it is not poverty it is a "colonial mindset" people still mentally slaves
You told about Power of DOLLAR 💲
America became powerfull just after bretton wood conference, in 50s, thats hardly 70 years back.
What are you even talking about. Prior to ww2 america was not like todays america.
If your are talking about education, show me one world class institution from china which was getting high ranking 20 years back.
This is the same mindset which kept up confidence less as a nation for last 70 years.
We are already formidable military power. Going to be the formidable economic power in next 20 years with a potential of 20 tril. We are education powerhouse in asia, our diplomacy is top notch hardly 98% countries can match, we have cultural dept, geographical advantage. The list goes on.
Dont believe this ganju. I dont even understand why study iq even invited him. His analytical ability is of a 12th standard student. watch few of his podcast, and you will understand, he is just another overrated attention seeker. He just memorize some bullet points and keep playing with words around that knowledge. Want to see real analytics just follow subject experts. Like md khan for ancient history and archeology like that.
@@watanabe00738Congratulations on being an optimist.
But all your statements about India has one thing in common. "India will be....". The fact is India isn't all those. India has always been a country with huge potential & it will remain so in future.
Yes they don't live with Jihadis and their educated sympathiser and Christian missionaries and communist and urban naxals and khud ki roti sekne Wale neta log Jo n to sanatan Dharma jante hai na hi patriot hai.. eg Congress .
America made sure there is less development throughout the world in order to be seen as superpower, and all these activities I mentioned is heavily funded by USA,along with China ,KGB RUSSIAN AGENCY in the past and some Islamic states, directly to missionaries and indirectly to Pakistan and our Dhruv rathee,congress like liberandus to destabilize India to become Bharat , a culturally rich morally dhramic , sone ki chidiya wala Desh , did you understand Jon Snow.
Jai Shree Ram 🚩🚩
Amount of knowledge inside his bald head is incredible..amazing 😊👏🙏🙏🙏
AIM- PRECISE ARTICULATION AND TO THE POINT 🙌
Looking forward towards this podcast...😊 Hopefully we will see major gaurav arya and major Bakshi too in coming lectures too..😊.. youth need to be more aware about India's security issues...
Very nice !! Good to listen to a different perspective...
Abhijit is always delite to listen ❤
Intelligent questions being answered in more intelligent way , thanks
It is intellectually satisfying to listen to Abhijit. My views on Netaji seems to be resembling him ..
Who does invite the OG and does podcast for only 20 Min? He should atleast be there for minimum 2 hours..
Only 20 mins of AIM?
You can talk to this guy for hours and hours. Try getting him for longer duration.
Loved the podcast
Excellent host
❤🎉 Please Invite JSD J Sai Deepak ,SC Lawyer he is just wow... Also thanks for this podcast , being spritual i think there is more to learn about Neta ji Bose as he is somehow sharp intelligent and spritual man ..i don't agree with AIM in this case may be i need reading or he but you can see now Nepal demand Monarchy discarding democracy. I think there is a forcefull push to Democracy as only political system good enough by western political thinkers which world studies.
Our ancient Monarchies was (obviously except foreign Islamic cruel rulers doing things inline with Islam) different then other monarchies or better call them dictatorship , where Dharma abiding regime prevails and the moment Adharmi comes to power there was a change in monarchy without hurting any common people or crimes like raping ,looting n all..🙏
Glad you think so, Atul
Yes! Please invite J. Sai Deepak
awesome conversation 🎉
Absolutely correct anology of India apart from few historical identities Abhijeet likes.
Although he is a bit pessimist but he has an incredible outlook and analysis of geopolitics. I would also mention that never say never..
Welcome this faster version. These days almost all interview based or discussion based podcast exceed 45 minutes, or even hours.
Yours is fast, to the point, relevant and informative.
It's not podcast.....only 20 minutes. Need to hear him more.
I'm glad AIM is here on podcast
Very good quick conversation 👌👏👍😊❤
great!!
What a perspective
Excellent
Excellent views and opinions based on solid facts, reading and sound scientific analyses.
Great podcast. Mitra is very knowledgeable
12:20 bruh netaji literally made his own bank and currency when he was forming azad hind fauj and produced their own food and tried to send 1lakh ton of rice to the people of Bengal during 1943 and netaji also made so many good political relations that would have helped in the rise of economy and this guy is saying he doesn't understand economics ☠️
Enjoyed the podcast 🙏
How is the Deoli incident not more talked about. I never knew what our governments have done. I had always despised the inhumane concentration camps both in Europe and America and even by the Japanese . But even we too did this and we aren’t even aware . More people should know about it
Yeh kab Hua ?? Can you please Explain
He always driven by his own doctrines and very insightful..
Make your own thoughts. Increase your knowledge by yourselves. This will help you in judging what is right and what is wrong.
Abhijit chavda podcast loading
The Best analyst out there
Abhijit ❤
Jai Sai Deepak next....
Bharat evolved so much in 2 3 thousands years ,and experience every situations and we must have too no 1 power in world
He is 💯 true in all which he said
Maza aaayaaa
Beautiful…. Bring him again for a longer episode
Ambedkar's own caste mahar still discriminate lower castes like mang/matang and bhangi. And harijan do same with valmiki and mahar. But no dalit leader has guts to accept this they only want to change others not themselves lol
See caste or class is inbuilt inheritance of every society it existed everywhere
But some slightly overcome it through industrialization and others don't
Yes , we need brutal speakers like AIM . He may be annoying at sone levels , but does not sugar coat issues .
We need more of it...ye bahut jaldi khatam ho gaya bro
Aim❤ Pavneet Singh next😊
AIM is a realist with good details .
Brilliant!!
Logic intelligence always ❤❤ Abhijit Iyer Mitra 😂😂😂😂😂😂❤❤❤
The iyengar is back
Nice show 👍 with AIM 😎
Good to see AIM reaching out to youth via this & some other such similar channels. 👍👏🙏🌻🚩
I’m a fan of AIM
Sardar Vallabh Bhai Patel as the PM would have been blessing ; we never had. SC Bose was too idealistic ,He was Gandhi in opposite direction and in a heterogenous society you never know the outcome. Patriot among Patriots Bose was tailor made for Defence Minsiter or an Army chief. Sardar was one of the finest politician in the world not just India ; realist and a visionary. To unify 560+ princely states is a marvel in itself. His prediction on China and Pak were spot on; which Nehru did not have. But to extrapolate Bose as Stalin is beyond foolery. He was idealistically in love with India ; that in politics can be a short-coming. Bhagat Singh SC Bose were people you want to emulate but your inner shortcomings prevent it. They were too good to be true imagine a 22-23 year old graduate readily giving up his life for our future that was Bhagat Singh No fear in the face of Death so was SC Bose gave up everything for INA and Indian Independence , saw nothing but the dream of a perfect India. This thought of perfection in real-politik can either be fatal or unstoppable.
A man loves what he cannot be. Netaji SC Bose and Shaheed-e-Azam Bhagat Singh were those men.
I they both were swayed by communist ideologies...may be that would have been an impediment..By the way Netaji died in India in 1985.. Gumnami baba story is corroborated to be true through evidence and facts..I find Netaji to be a Sanatani at the last stage of his life..
Patel was a congressi, Gand.hi bhakt and British stooge. Bcoz our standards are too low, people like Patel to Modi are praised, even worshipped. 🚩
Stalin was also as much in love with Russia as SC Bose was with India
But Stalin was the Reason why Soviet Regime had to Industrialize. However, I doubt that Subhash Chandra Bose would have operated in a similar fashion. Yes, we would have been under Communist Dictatorship kind of Regime.......but then again Nehru too was very similar to a Communist Dictator and Ruled India for a Period of 17 Years without any Opposition
Video bahut acha tha
Glad you like it!
Please make this type of interview in English too
I seen many msg about why India cannot become superpower😢. When you don't have any mindset for achivement, you will achieve nothing. I am very optimistic person and I want to India become great. We need awareness in our population about geopolitics and we need more education, so people can choose right leader
Being great & being superpower are slightly different. India can be great again. Even I hope for the same. But being superpower is burdensome, in this I agree with abhijeet.
Good
That's it only 20 mins?? 😮😮😮
Good to have some truth bombs.
This was very short and would have liked much longer in conversational style and not in Q&A format . Please get this chap again and have at least an hour of talk, he sounds very interesting and knowledgeable
We never wanted democracy abhijit. I would've loved to stay in a dictatorship under mr. BOSE
Aim ❤
I appreciate Abhijits vocal ness if Netaji
But I think he didn't read well.
Bose said he wanted the people of india to choose a leader and even in azad hind government he wasn't the leader as such , he was there as a representative of India 🇮🇳
Moreover he said , in the initial days it is better to have a strong Central government that will have complete control , and when our economy gets a certain stability the basic model that would be followed :- will be democracy ( people's government )
That's what he meant
I think Abhijit has this tendency to take things into extremes by wrapping it with the terror of some past incident that didn't turned out well
I don't know about Prime minister , but I think bose would have been the best defence minister . Because of his experience in Indian National Army . And also due to his relations with multiple leaders . It would have been easy for him to get military deals or alliance
devloped country ban jaye wahi hum logo ke liye achievement rahega
use jyada meko cahiye bhi nahi or umid bhi nahi hai 😅
A basic anomoly on AIM s argument if Bharat have lost his relevenve for British in 1910 why they wanted to control India till 1947 and beyond. This is the most silliest argument.
Why did British voters overwhelmingly voted for a disaster like Brexit? The answer to your historical question will get a clarity from contemporary times.
@@Margallachimp thats not comparable.
SC Bose can be respected as freedom fighter but he is overhyped. His views on Secularism were no different from Nehru-Gandhi Muslim appeasement.
His Socialism would have destroyed India
Wowwww
This guy is intelligent intresting funny witty...sometime he talk rubbish but he is humorously...
Wow
We need Anand Ranganathan, J Shai Deepak, Abhijit Chavda , Minakhi Jain
Incredible man Abhijit Iyer Mitra 😂
Hes right i am a jatav from up and i want hindu society to be a casteless society thats is why i stopped voting for bsp and started voting bjp
Self identified super power, best comment 😂😂😂😂
Bose was ranked 4th in ICS in the world and took a time of 6 month to prepare for the exam. And this guy says he didn't knew economics. Just read Bose's books on how he wants India to be. The man sacrificed everything for India and we did ? We just criticize him as another Stalin! That's a destiny Indian's chose.
One can admire Bose for his patriotism and contribution to India's freedom struggle while still recognising how bad/dangerous his economic ideas were.
And we have more than a century of evidence today, case after case, of how big a disaster leftist/socialist/communist ideas have been for societies.
And yes, no doubt Bose was highly intelligent. But intelligence does not make you immune to the seduction of communist ideas, especially in his time, when communism was relatively new and its biggest disasters were yet to unfold. So he was a product of his time, so perhaps we should not judge him too harshly.
But as far as potential impact is concerned, I completely agree with AIM here... He would've been a disaster for our country economically, like any communist dictator. I still admire him for his contribution in our freedom struggle though.
I want you to do a podcast with prashant dhawan 😅
Yes its a Study Channel 😂😂😂...
Campaigning for 2024 power by ..P😂
Great spokesperson 👍
If it was Campaigning all 20 min would have been about modi but it's not. May be you're allergic to the person who lauds modi even in one line.😂😂
@@saumyapandey2372 😂😂😂 aapko kese pata chala...
Bhakt sahab 😀
@@chisac1Modi lives inside your head rent free
@@bladerunner20491 😂😂 3.0 😂😂
He criticized Modi more than P....
We need to produce more. That will increase our GDP
Bring Ankit shah on your podcast.🙏
Major gurav arya
That decolonisation jibe was aimed at JSD 😳. AIM raised a legitimate point, wonder what SDJ response would be.
I legit don't know what their issue is with each other. JSD has never said that we need to do away with everything that is colonial, in fact he has explicitly said that we don't need to do that. I am reading his books, and I've seen almost every interview of his. His position is very clear -
That we need to be able to look at our issues from the lens of our own civilization. Which is to say that the Abrahamic mindset is binary, exclusive and competitive. Our civilization has been pluralist, inclusive and syncretic.
A smart man as AIM would know this, yet I cannot understand why he'd be on bad terms with JSD. This is not the first time when he has spoken about this. Even JSD once said that he'd never be invited to their 'cliques'.
So I imagine there are some deeper issues between them. Beyond ideological.
@@Sukhbindar-y3b whole world how ridiculous yaar
@@Sukhbindar-y3b wtf? When did he say that? Citations? Matlab kuch bhi XD
@RuturajGole Jsaideepak has said hmko american society sikhayegi transgender ko kaise treat karna hai
(low castes ko to ache se treat ni kar paye tumlog uska jimemvar bhi british btadia lol)
, he also said in one lecture hmare samaj ko government sikhayegi ki sc st se discrimination nahi karna and so on.. what is he aiming at if not dissmissing a western opinion about something whose vague alternative we think we have?
obviously the example aim gave was not very clear, but J sai deepak has also said dont westernised or talk about emperical evidence when discussing ayurveda we need to talk about the anthropological socioligcal and development aspect of ayurveda and not go on the emeprical standard western has said.
now if you know anythign about what emperical standard basicallly means you will know how stupid that point is.
Rejecting the opinion of westerns on how to treat a transgender just because the opinions are so called western
rejecting the emperical evidence based aproach when discussing ayurveda just because the approach is so called western
emphasizing on the name bharat instead of india just because it is western
he also says that indian state should learn subject only in their mother tongue and if they want to go beyond it they can have some bridge course, he didnt specified the bridge course was of hindi or english.. but either way he is also against english except optional just because it is western.. this is the problem.. the fact that indians are naturally polyglot must be celebrated
but no he reject reject reject
i can go on and on
regarding abrahmic mindset as binary where as your statement about outer civilizations is itself binary one
Aayeeein 😐
Harappa and post that is Recent Ancient civilization .
Before that is actual ancient Civilization .
Ouch
❤
Pavneet Singh next podcast please
Appreciate your honesty boss
But you are not accurate on Netaji
You better read the Bengali works of his if you can
Only 20 mins
Everything he said after 17.50 is true. Anything he said before that “NO”
Aaise podcast entertainment ke liye ache hai exam point of view se to disqualified ho sktey hai hum 😂
Thank you Taklu uncle
People are not ready for Abhijit 😂😂
Well done study iq .....atlast u guys found out abhijeet is the boss
Before Aryan Migration theory which is false. But if it is true We still had Shukracharya and Daityas Indic civilization
current day Middle east way was also Indic civilization
Bose is not a Marxist he is for industrialization of country there is a pdf in internet Subhash Chandra Bose on political and economic planning Stalin is successful in industrialisation of russia
From self identified as a momo and now self identified as a superpower 😅
Rahul seems to be distracted, not constantly focused, keeps looking everywhere and to me as a viewer seems pretty casual and not serious at the podcast
Fanatic..........Fun fact - till today Savarkar family has not married outside bramhin caste, and will not in next hundred years............yet he said savarkar wanted casteless society
Andhbhkt will say intercaste marriage criteria nahi ho sakta......so you want casteless society, now you progressed and can touch them now... but don't want to mrry them and still upbring them.
Bramhin is a barna not caste,caste is all about birth related but barna is all about your karma and guna, read bhagwat Gita
@@Priyans-bf3fn how do you become brahmin
where do i apply?
Does sarvarkar family has anything to do with his idelogy? They might not be on same page with him as he was student in London for major of his youth days.
And why are you blaming brahmins for less inter caste marriage, if you see statics of inter caste marriage in india the most of them are done by brahmins and the marriage within in caste is more frequent in OBCs and SC and even if a tribal person marry outside his tribe, they get boycotted by their own tribe.
Before calling others andhbhakt you should first introspect yourself on your ignorance and stop peddling same rhetoric using stupid reasoning.
Pehle khud aapas may shadi karo many low caste people themselves don't marry within some castes jinko vo khud se low samjhti h. Phir brahmins ko blame karna, inter caste marriage se pehle kitna aapne uplift kar liya ye bhi to dikhiye, ek caste ko blame karke Uspe sara ilzam dalna thik nahi.
I myself is a sc/st & even we don't like marriages outside of our community aur haan we don't like Bramhins
@@saumyapandey2372Brahmins ne to sara system banaya hai ye varna system which became finally caste system. To varna system ko alive rkhne ke liye hai to brahmins ne ye intercast marriage ko oppose kiya hai . Aur Brahmins ko khud ko sabse uper bataya , shresth bataya even you can murder anyone expect Brahmins because Brahmins ne khud ko hi declare kr diya ki aisa kroge to brahm hatya hogi. Aur uske liye inhone varna system banaya (future cast system) . Women ki sexuality ko control kiya by denying them to pursue education . And yahi hai Brahminism ( brahmanvad) jo ki ek thought hai aur wahi thoughts jo baki ke varno ne adopt kiya . So it was always about Brahmins and Brahminism .they were responsible then and theirs ideology is responsible for today's honor killing in intercaste marriage
2. Yes Brahmins do intercaste because constitution gives them power to do so in special and hindu marriage act .after independence savarn women got equal rights on paper but they also got resources from their family . So they fought and demanded their full rights and started feminism movment in india . Uske baad se kaayi dasak(10) saal baad intercaste marriage kr rhi hai wo bhi because of savarna women especially Brahmins.
3. Other caste ki women ko abhi education nhi mil paa rhi hai early marriage ho jaati hai un caste hi halat hi aisi hai ki naa to koi asset hai (ex. Land) jo unki condition theek kr ske na hi unke pass education hai. Tbhi to aabhi bhi wo ek gulam ki trah hai . Brahmin women ke pass khud virasat me mila hai to wo kr rhi hai
Aur caste inequality ,caste discrimination, honor killing ke piche ek hi reason hai wo mindset jo hai Brahminism jo invent kra hai Brahmins ne . So don't play victim card
My question- with all these answers how much marks he will get in UPSC/UPPSC interview?😅
-100 😭
his both IAS parents say he is not made for us . Us likes those who agree with them
You will never clear UPSC.