“Hoorah for General!... what’s his name?” This movie may have some of the best action sequences in cinema, but the comedy is extremely underrated. This scene is just purely hilarious.
Yeah but this movie takes place in February-March 1862, when neither Lee nor Grant were famous. Lee command small detachments of coastal forces in North Carolina, and Grant just only started his first battles (capturing forts Henry and Donelson in Tennessee) 🤪 In that moment the most famous Confederate general was Albert Sidney Johnston, not Robert Lee.
Lenin Luna It is but a concentration camp has just the purpose to concentrate a number of people from the same kind. The term goes back to before the 20th century.
despite being a huge fan of Clint Eastwood, for me the best actor was Eli Wallach (Tuco). he really stole the show, without him, the movie wouldn't have been the same.
I think they were both equally as good. They just made a great duo. Clint was quiet, with only a few words spoken, while Tuco was an over the top loud mouth. But they somehow got a long (for the most part)
@@LordWellington15 Right. Two great characters, with two great actors performing in a way to create the right mix in order to make this masterpiece. Love this film. R.lP to mister Eli Wallcah, and to the great Lee Van Cliff. They are missed.
Yeah, you could say the Union officer showed his "true colors" to the "idiot" who spent like ten seconds insulting his army thinking he was talking to the rebels.
This movie is really comedic in an odd way. It’s dark, violent, gritty and set during one of the bloodiest wars in American history yet manages to get a cheeky laugh out of you every now and then. Tuco in general is goofy. With his nonsense quotes about Spurs or him having a bath with his gun and killing someone, to this scene, or his constant rage and disbelief when Blondie messes with him.
@@SinisterBlitzo9 depends what is classed as the best, classics like Shane, Wagon Master, The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance are all true cinema classics, but very different to TGTBTU
@@Kelly14UK Yes it's funny but all three of them were likeable rogues. When I saw Oliver on stage. Rowan Atkinson as Fagin got thunderous applause at the end of the show. Eli Wallach gave the performance of his life as Tuco though. His acting was second to none. Priceless.
These movies are not known for their historical accuracy. Blondie's using a Winchester repeating rifle, for God's sake more than a decade before it was invented(1873). It's more mythic, kinda like what we collectively in our modern heads think of when we picture the old west. Accuracy need not apply.
Paul 00075 And don't get me started on the revolvers in this movie. This movie is a prequel though. The other two parts of the dollar trilogy take place after the civil war. So I presume Leone reused the props he had at hand, that were fitting in those movies. Other parts of the movie are actually quite well researched, so he clearly put in some effort.
Yeah but remember these were low-budget films, and still they managed to make the best Westeners ever. Also 99% of the audience don't notice the historical unaccuracies.
That's the beauty of this movie, very very few westerns have any kind of comedy at all they're so serious and gruff, this had a lot of good comedic bits
@ Indeed. And especially the time were making Westerners. No other people did it better. Great work on their part.
4 ปีที่แล้ว +3
@@couldyoupassthesaltplease.2006 Also the Italian Westerns were the first to introduce the "anti-hero" archetype (i.g. The Man with No Name) American westerns were mainly white hats vs black hats AKA good vs bad
One thing I find interesting is the depiction of the Civil War in this movie. The troops look tired messy no rousing speeches you can almost tell how none of them have had a bath in weeks. Most depictions of the war even made decades later they may up the gore but usually the slog of it all is missing.
“What is the best film of all time? I am gonna tell you. I will tell you the greatest film that has ever been made. It is an undeniable fact. It is the ultimate truth. There is no denying, no room for debate. This isn’t even my opinion, for it’s not my favorite film. This is pure fact, for the film I am about to mention is undeniably, indubitably, the most epic of epics. The Film of Films! It is the standard by which every other film, before and after, is judged! The greatest film of all time is not Gone with the Wind, is not Citizen Kane, is not Casablanca, is not The Godfather. The greatest film of all time is The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly.”
Hmmmm…you aren’t out of line with this thinking… no buts…however Godfather one or two…are knocking at your heels. Ahh, hell….I’ll agree with ya…if you don’t forget Papillon
Tuco & Blondie were in a confederate uniform(gray).In a distance they thought the soldiers were also in a gray uniform. That is why Tuco shouted" hurrah for the confederate and to Grant(union)" which is wrong and corrected by Blondie to be " Lee(confederate". Next scene is they are already POWs in a Union prison camp!
The movie has the Battle of Glorietta Pass in the background, which happened in 1862. Grant was starting to become famous in 1862, but he was not the top Union guy then. He only assumed command against Lee in 1864.. So, is it an error to shout Grant and Lee's name? I am not sure. But I get it. Any other Union name, people would not likely know who it was.
tuco: hurrah! hurrah for the confederacy! hurrah! down with president lincoln, hurrah for president...errr what's his name? blondie: davis tuco: davis! davis! god is with us because he hates the yanks too! hurrah!
Great scene based on a story by Ambrose Bierce about a Union officer so covered in dust he looks grey. By the way, the Union officer might be Capt. James "Paddy" Graydon, leader of a Union "spy company" during the New Mexico campaign. And quit harping on the use of cartridge revolvers in the film, especially when they were more common than you can imagine. One company that copied the 1851 colt was said to have shipped cartridge revolvers(illegally)direct from the factory! Now look up the Prescott revolver, a solid frame cartridge revolver patented in 1861! It was a patent, not technology, that prevented more widespread use of cartridges.
One interesting thing is marching soldiers always broke step when crossing a wooden bridge - this scene shows why! Oh well, its great but still just another movie..
It has recently been stated that Batterville POW camp will be rebuilt! If you check out the location of the cemetery on Google earth, you can move over about a mile or so and see the outline of the prison camp. Now, this is crazy, but I would propose that they rebuild the bridge and blow it once a year!
The scene is filmed in a dry gulch very near the ocean on the south of Spain, Rambla de Salinas. This area is often used for movies and TV(including Rat Patrol). I would like to hear from an expert about the rank of that Union officer. Anyway, if they had been caught, the closest prison camp would be Illinois, although a Kansas installation was used as a transfer point. You can see the outline of the camp on Google Earth not far East of Sad Hill Cemetary.
They seemed to want to blend in with the crowd. So as to not ruffle any feathers 🪶 so to speak. But Tuco was able to make friends easily and adjusted well. His more reticent partner was a bit uneasy in his new surroundings.
You see in this desert there are two colors of uniforms my friend those that are the color of dust and those that are the color grey that get to go to prison. YOU DIG!
The movie is not 100% historically acurate. The maker is not english nor could he speak english. He also added dynamite in the movie qich was also not invented yet during the civil war.
I know the movie wasn't trying to be the most historically accurate, but my itch for being a know-it-all is acting up. Given the context of this being set in early 1862 during the battle of Glorieta Pass, there's no way in hell anyone would've known who Lee was, except maybe for his failed campaign in West Virginia. It would have made much more sense to mention Stonewall Jackson, who would have been well known for his actions at 1st Manassas. Grant had captured Fort Donelson a month earlier, so his mention makes sense, but Lee? No.
the commanders or what happened are not historically accurate. It's more of a Romanticized depiction of the entire events. In the movie what ends up happening is both Confederate and Union forces do a mutually assured destruction, where both forces wipe each other out which is why the trio has a chance to search for the loot (which was supposed to be used to pay for the Confederate army) in the chaotic aftermath.
I don't know much from the civil war, in Spain is called the secesion war. One side wanted to seced. Why? - The central goberment taxed imports, so the south had to by to the north many industrial goods. - Law between states wasn"t arrainged properly. The expose as example, not as the main claim, that scaped slaves were not returned. And the law said they should. So being in the union, was expensive and with no garanties. The wanted to go their own way. Central goberment: The main income werw import duties. So if the south secced, they would lose a lot of income. This is the main reason with Lincoln started the war. The north invaded the south. Lincoln, avolish slavery, after two years of war, and only im condederate states. He send 300.000 yound soldiers to death only in the union side. The black confederate. Yes there were black condederates, not many. Mainly the last years of war, due to the lack of soldiers. Jefferson Davies never had a traison sentece, becouse he had no court against him. He would prof he had rigths to break the union. What happened next after the war? The seed of a big centralizated institution was created. One general once said. The last time americans had figth for their rights and freedom, was during the civil war, and they lost.
![20 Things You Didn't Know About The Good, The Bad & The Ugly [1966]](/img/n.gif)
“Hoorah for General!... what’s his name?”
This movie may have some of the best action sequences in cinema, but the comedy is extremely underrated. This scene is just purely hilarious.
The more U watch this movie, the more hilarious scenes or lines U come across. It's classic 💪🏾💪🏾💪🏾💪🏾
This scene and the music the put when you sea the blue color is 11 out of 10
the comedic department single handedly carried by tuco
Tuco stole the show!
Yeah but this movie takes place in February-March 1862, when neither Lee nor Grant were famous.
Lee command small detachments of coastal forces in North Carolina, and Grant just only started his first battles (capturing forts Henry and Donelson in Tennessee) 🤪
In that moment the most famous Confederate general was Albert Sidney Johnston, not Robert Lee.
1:06 Eastwood face says it all:
"Next time I'll do the talking!"
It sure does 😁
🤣🤣🤣
🤣🤣🤣
I always LOVED Tucos reaction when he realizes they’re actually blue uniforms
Union Colonel " YOU WERE SAYING"
Lol.
it's funny how they immediately switched to scene where they are in a concentration camp after that union captain dusted his sleeve off XD
ArnoldFTW97 that’s a POW camp, not a concentration one? It’s not like there was a mass genocide against Southerners.
Lenin Luna Some Union pow camps were no better.
Lenin Luna Laughs in General Sherman
@@lenini056 A concentration camp just means that prisoners are held in large numbers together in a small area.
Lenin Luna It is but a concentration camp has just the purpose to concentrate a number of people from the same kind. The term goes back to before the 20th century.
0:42 I know good casting when I see it. That man\soldier ain't saying nothing, but with that face, eyes and attitude he was spot on for that part.
Also the grinning guy immediately to his left, who looks like Teddy Roosevelt. He's like, "Ha Ha, you guys are SO screwed!"
despite being a huge fan of Clint Eastwood, for me the best actor was Eli Wallach (Tuco).
he really stole the show, without him, the movie wouldn't have been the same.
I think they were both equally as good. They just made a great duo. Clint was quiet, with only a few words spoken, while Tuco was an over the top loud mouth. But they somehow got a long (for the most part)
Sergio P. I hope they dont do a remake because tuco will be turning over his grave smh
@@LordWellington15 Right. Two great characters, with two great actors performing in a way to create the right mix in order to make this masterpiece. Love this film. R.lP to mister Eli Wallcah, and to the great Lee Van Cliff. They are missed.
I think it was Eastwood that said Tuco was the main character of the film as he had a special place in Leone's heart.
True
As a little kid I laughed at this scene with my dad as I watched the soldier brush the dust off his uniform
I laughed too when I first saw this scene. Tuco definitely regretted saying all that when he saw the true colors XD
I love it when they dust off. Its just a small comedic moment that sticks in my mind for some reason.
Yeah, you could say the Union officer showed his "true colors" to the "idiot" who spent like ten seconds insulting his army thinking he was talking to the rebels.
This movie is really comedic in an odd way. It’s dark, violent, gritty and set during one of the bloodiest wars in American history yet manages to get a cheeky laugh out of you every now and then.
Tuco in general is goofy. With his nonsense quotes about Spurs or him having a bath with his gun and killing someone, to this scene, or his constant rage and disbelief when Blondie messes with him.
@@georgethomas5109 Those that come in by the door and those that come in by the window
😂 Tuco is hysterical!
The film is a comedy, because it is a satire and parody of the Western genre
@@bigddannyflynn-filmmaker5694and yet it managed to be the best movie in the western genre
@@SinisterBlitzo9 depends what is classed as the best, classics like Shane, Wagon Master, The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance are all true cinema classics, but very different to TGTBTU
00:50 at that moment Tuco knew, he fucked up.
*wahhh wahhh wahhhhhh*
Hut 2 3 4 hut 2 3 4
Prisoners of War! Forwards... March!
It doesn’t matter. They would have got captured anyway.
@@michaelbarnett2527 but it was crazy funny
Gotta love Tuco.
Guy was funny despite his crimes.
@@Kelly14UK Everybody loves Fagin and Tuco.
@@helencampbell9203 yeah Fagin was sort of likeable too. So was Long John Silver.
@@Kelly14UK Yes it's funny but all three of them were likeable rogues.
When I saw Oliver on stage. Rowan Atkinson as Fagin got thunderous applause at the end of the show.
Eli Wallach gave the performance of his life as Tuco though. His acting was second to none. Priceless.
Lmao they messed up real bad
Majorly. Funny as hell. Daft Tuco.
This movie actually takes place in early 1862 during Sibley's New Mexico campaign, which was before Grant or Lee ever took command.
These movies are not known for their historical accuracy. Blondie's using a Winchester repeating rifle, for God's sake more than a decade before it was invented(1873). It's more mythic, kinda like what we collectively in our modern heads think of when we picture the old west. Accuracy need not apply.
Paul 00075 And don't get me started on the revolvers in this movie. This movie is a prequel though. The other two parts of the dollar trilogy take place after the civil war. So I presume Leone reused the props he had at hand, that were fitting in those movies. Other parts of the movie are actually quite well researched, so he clearly put in some effort.
@@Zartoo_3rd_Overlord_ofBlargon7 that's not an 1873, that's an 1866 "Yellow Boy"
Yeah but remember these were low-budget films, and still they managed to make the best Westeners ever. Also 99% of the audience don't notice the historical unaccuracies.
I thought he used a Henry 1860.
When things go from bad to worse....
From Good
To Bad
To Ugly
How Tuco doesn't know the name of his supposed General 😂
Because they're not really Confederate soldiers, they just stole the uniforms.
it's just another way of emphasizing how tuco didn't care about the war
He stole the uniform
How David doesn't understand this scene.🙄
That's the beauty of this movie, very very few westerns have any kind of comedy at all they're so serious and gruff, this had a lot of good comedic bits
"God's not on our side coz He hates idiots also"
If that aint an iconic line then sorry 😂😂😂😂
Hilarious scene!
Elli Wallach is legend.
Watched this yesterday. Loved this scene
Only an italian could do this masterpiece scene.
Why?
@ Because of the low budget i would presume.
Anyways very good movies .
@@ursus4886 even the talent of the italian cinematic minds even in America the best actors and directors are of Italian origins
@ Indeed. And especially the time were making Westerners. No other people did it better.
Great work on their part.
@@couldyoupassthesaltplease.2006 Also the Italian Westerns were the first to introduce the "anti-hero" archetype (i.g. The Man with No Name) American westerns were mainly white hats vs black hats AKA good vs bad
One thing I find interesting is the depiction of the Civil War in this movie. The troops look tired messy no rousing speeches you can almost tell how none of them have had a bath in weeks. Most depictions of the war even made decades later they may up the gore but usually the slog of it all is missing.
On the road to sad hill a small detour to better ville prison one of the best scenes in movie history viva Sergio leone
0:47sec Million Dollar Reaction! 👌😂
Man this is such a masterpiece all the music even the whistling music is so amazing!
HORAH FOR THE CONFEDERACY!!!
Oh Tuco. He was so loud, hypo and mostly very annoying, but he was fabulous.
Blondie.:."God is not on our side because he hates idiots too". My favorite line in the whole movie. LOL
My brother laughed hysterically when he first saw this. Lol.
The story line never gets old,
I love the facial expression of Tuco upon knowing that the soldiers' uniform were not gray but blue! Magnificent acting!
FM: The Philippines
Is At This Moment Tuco Knew... He Fucked Up
One of my favorite scenes
0:54 imagine you in america 1800 and you have this music vibe i just get warm feelings of that
“What is the best film of all time? I am gonna tell you. I will tell you the greatest film that has ever been made. It is an undeniable fact. It is the ultimate truth. There is no denying, no room for debate. This isn’t even my opinion, for it’s not my favorite film. This is pure fact, for the film I am about to mention is undeniably, indubitably, the most epic of epics. The Film of Films! It is the standard by which every other film, before and after, is judged! The greatest film of all time is not Gone with the Wind, is not Citizen Kane, is not Casablanca, is not The Godfather. The greatest film of all time is The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly.”
Hmmmm…you aren’t out of line with this thinking… no buts…however Godfather one or two…are knocking at your heels. Ahh, hell….I’ll agree with ya…if you don’t forget Papillon
@@Playsinvain What does he know!? He lost the battle at Little Bighorn and got his entire command wiped out.
@@TheReaperMan275 but he seems so certain this time. Like death.
@@Playsinvain Bingo.
This is my favorite scene from the movie
Tuco & Blondie were in a confederate uniform(gray).In a distance they thought the soldiers were also in a gray uniform. That is why Tuco shouted" hurrah for the confederate and to Grant(union)" which is wrong and corrected by Blondie to be " Lee(confederate". Next scene is they are already POWs in a Union prison camp!
Tuco's look says it all : " FUCK .. ! " .
The movie has the Battle of Glorietta Pass in the background, which happened in 1862. Grant was starting to become famous in 1862, but he was not the top Union guy then. He only assumed command against Lee in 1864.. So, is it an error to shout Grant and Lee's name? I am not sure. But I get it. Any other Union name, people would not likely know who it was.
I guess they could have shouted 'Down with Lincoln'.
Correct. Grant went up against Lee for only the last year of the war. But most don't know that. When you think Civil War, it's Grant and Lee.
tuco: hurrah! hurrah for the confederacy! hurrah! down with president lincoln, hurrah for president...errr what's his name?
blondie: davis
tuco: davis! davis! god is with us because he hates the yanks too! hurrah!
it's actually down with General Grant. Up with General Lee.. God is not with you because he hates idiots also.. LOL
Hurray! hurray for dixie!
Love how the scene immediately switches to the marching
Prisoners of war!!!
Forward...March!!!
1234😅😅😅
Great scene based on a story by Ambrose Bierce about a Union officer so covered in dust he looks grey. By the way, the Union officer might be Capt. James "Paddy" Graydon, leader of a Union "spy company" during the New Mexico campaign. And quit harping on the use of cartridge revolvers in the film, especially when they were more common than you can imagine. One company that copied the 1851 colt was said to have shipped cartridge revolvers(illegally)direct from the factory! Now look up the Prescott revolver, a solid frame cartridge revolver patented in 1861! It was a patent, not technology, that prevented more widespread use of cartridges.
Mark W The focus is not ob historical accuracy but that is fine. After all it is a spaghetti western, a tale, some sort of campfire story.
They dun goofed
coolest movie ever
I love 0:47
Every1 needs a fteind like tuco lmao 😂😁😅😄
"God's not on our side because he hates idiots also!"
And away they went.
Surprisingly good elements of comedy given what happens in this movie.
When I watched this scene for the first time, I almost pissed off with laughter 😆😅🤣😂
I love this movie
One interesting thing is marching soldiers always broke step when crossing a wooden bridge - this scene shows why! Oh well, its great but still just another movie..
At the time when this movie takes place, neither Lee nor Grant were the leaders of their respective armies
This movie takes me all time 👻😆
esta pelicula es una jolla sine matografica una lellenda
una joya, cinematográfica, leyenda
blue or gray
these guys didn't give a crap about anything
Filmed in Spain
Friendly reminder: Never trust a group of horse with strange colour on their uniform
EPIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIC 😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎
It has recently been stated that Batterville POW camp will be rebuilt! If you check out the location of the cemetery on Google earth, you can move over about a mile or so and see the outline of the prison camp. Now, this is crazy, but I would propose that they rebuild the bridge and blow it once a year!
The scene is filmed in a dry gulch very near the ocean on the south of Spain, Rambla de Salinas. This area is often used for movies and TV(including Rat Patrol). I would like to hear from an expert about the rank of that Union officer. Anyway, if they had been caught, the closest prison camp would be Illinois, although a Kansas installation was used as a transfer point. You can see the outline of the camp on Google Earth not far East of Sad Hill Cemetary.
Tuco: I love the confederacy
Me: umm..who is gonna tell him 😅😅
Didn’t go as planned
They should've ditched the uniforms before they left the mission.
The stagecoach wagon had CSA written on the side. So it probably wouldn't have mattered
And what, ruin the plot?
They seemed to want to blend in with the crowd. So as to not ruffle any feathers 🪶 so to speak.
But Tuco was able to make friends easily and adjusted well. His more reticent partner was a bit uneasy in his new surroundings.
They should have been on the Union's side
Run from the Beast quick hahaha 🤣🤣🤣
The name of the song is marcia
Thank you friend.
Was looking for it a long time
oh my god thank you, I was looking for this forever
Hhhhhha, so beautiful music 🎶🏴☠️
I like this scene😂😅
Genial!
Hurrah for the confederacy!!!
This is when Tuco knew...
CREDITS:
TM & © Paramount (1966)
Cast: Clint Eastwood, Eli Wallach
Director: Sergio Leone
That's a lot of motherfucking dust...
You see
"God's not on our side because he hates idiots."
You see in this desert there are two colors of uniforms my friend those that are the color of dust and those that are the color grey that get to go to prison. YOU DIG!
декорации конечно пиздец, забор, мост, вышки и тд всё вручную сделано,столько труда. не то что щас,хуяк пиздык и готово на компе или на зеленом фоне
🤣🤣🤣 its a prank L❤ve this movie watch this movie with my son ❤️🔥💪
Does anyone know of a replica hat that Eastwood is wearing here?
And that uniform happens to be Blue 🔵😂😂😂😂
CUT IT OFF TOOOO SHORT!!
Were they talking about general Eli ?
Grant wasn't in charge in 1862.
The movie is not 100% historically acurate. The maker is not english nor could he speak english. He also added dynamite in the movie qich was also not invented yet during the civil war.
But still, its a movie from 1970. Details were different that time aswell if you look at the movies from now
If you wonder how the maker could comunicate Eli Wallach could talk to him in french where he was fluend in.
"God's not on our side, 'cause he hates idiots also."
0:42
Me And The Boys Attacking Area 51 Then get trapped :(
🧐
🤣
And that, children, is why grey uniforms are a bad idea.
Hayatim ozeti (temsili degil)
future is oposite of harem on titanic
I m gray why you so hurry
What kind of American are you?
I know the movie wasn't trying to be the most historically accurate, but my itch for being a know-it-all is acting up.
Given the context of this being set in early 1862 during the battle of Glorieta Pass, there's no way in hell anyone would've known who Lee was, except maybe for his failed campaign in West Virginia. It would have made much more sense to mention Stonewall Jackson, who would have been well known for his actions at 1st Manassas.
Grant had captured Fort Donelson a month earlier, so his mention makes sense, but Lee? No.
Or they could have done with Hoorah for Jefferson Davis and down with Lincoln.
the commanders or what happened are not historically accurate. It's more of a Romanticized depiction of the entire events. In the movie what ends up happening is both Confederate and Union forces do a mutually assured destruction, where both forces wipe each other out which is why the trio has a chance to search for the loot (which was supposed to be used to pay for the Confederate army) in the chaotic aftermath.
JAJAAJAJAJA
I never understood this scene anybody?
They thought they were Confederate soldiers because of the dust covering their uniforms, instead they found out they were Union soldiers
Wrong army
المشهد ده كان عاوز الشاويش عطية ..
هو بغباوته بوشة العكر
Talking politics a non-partisan in the 2020's be like:
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Glory to the United States of America. Glory to the union.
Union suck im with the grey boys.
look how that turned out
Na, redcoats were better
I don't know much from the civil war, in Spain is called the secesion war. One side wanted to seced. Why?
- The central goberment taxed imports, so the south had to by to the north many industrial goods.
- Law between states wasn"t arrainged properly. The expose as example, not as the main claim, that scaped slaves were not returned. And the law said they should.
So being in the union, was expensive and with no garanties.
The wanted to go their own way.
Central goberment:
The main income werw import duties. So if the south secced, they would lose a lot of income. This is the main reason with Lincoln started the war.
The north invaded the south.
Lincoln, avolish slavery, after two years of war, and only im condederate states.
He send 300.000 yound soldiers to death only in the union side.
The black confederate. Yes there were black condederates, not many. Mainly the last years of war, due to the lack of soldiers.
Jefferson Davies never had a traison sentece, becouse he had no court against him. He would prof he had rigths to break the union.
What happened next after the war? The seed of a big centralizated institution was created.
One general once said.
The last time americans had figth for their rights and freedom, was during the civil war, and they lost.
@@etxarri85cz new york actually paid 80% of the taxes at the time, new york is squarely in the north.