Review Series: Cobbler Union-3 Unique Pairs, 1 Undeniable Conclusion
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 ต.ค. 2024
- Visit theelegantoxford.com for all of your shoe care needs.
Products I recommend/used in this video:
Saphir Leather Dye: theelegantoxfo...
Saphir Leather Lotion: theelegantoxfo...
Saphir Medaille d’Or Cream Polish: theelegantoxfo...
Saphir Pate De Lux Wax Polish in Mahogany: theelegantoxfo...
Saphir Horse Hair Brush: theelegantoxfo...
Saphir Pig Bristle Brush: theelegantoxfo...
Saphir Welt Brush: theelegantoxfo...
Need help with a mirror shine? Here’s my in depth tutorial: A COMPLETE, DETAILED, & UNCUT GUIDE TO A MIRROR SHINE: A GUARANTEED SHINE
• A COMPLETE, DETAILED, ...
A guide to sole savers:
• MY LOCAL COBBLER INSTA...
My Experience at the Allen Edmonds Trunk Show:
• I GOT MY DREAM SHOE AT...
The Elegant Oxford is a Clothing & Apparel Project Offering Premium Shoe Restorations, Patinas, & Artisan Shines for Quality Men’s Shoes.
If you have any questions or would like your pair shined, email me at theelegantoxford@gmail.com
Follow me on Facebook and Instagram at The Elegant Oxford.
Follow The Elegant Oxford:
INSTAGRAM:www.instagram....
FACEBOOK: / theelegantoxford
TH-cam: / @theelegantoxford
That cognac museum at the beginning was absolutely stunning.
Great to have you back Preston...we appreciate your knowledge
Thank you! I appreciate your support
Thank you, Preston. You introduced me to the entire concept of quality shoes. I value your opinion. There is no one I trust more when it comes to shoes
Thank you so much! I appreciate your support
Great review. I have more Cobbler Union shoes than any other brand in my closet. They are truly nice shoes, and rotate some wild designs into their in season. For the beveled waist you want the City or the Louvre/Ritz lasts.
Perfect review and so eloquently put. I do own the Winston Museum Calf as well as a Double Monk Strap. Cobbler Union is fast becoming one of my favorite shoe brands.
Oh my... I absolutely love the Winston. I wanted to see the Robert and now considering the Winston after I buy the Robert.
Great video as always Preston. I cut my proverbial teeth on Cobbler Union. I have 7 pairs from them..............I would LOVE to see you do the Sunburst Patina on the Wingtips. I think that they'd look really dope with that Patina.
Hey James! Glad you’re such a fan of CU.
A sunburst is another job a lot of people are requesting as well. Might have to do that
@@TheElegantOxford I think you may need to acquire a dozen pair of the wingtips!!🤔✨
Excellent review! I own a couple of CU’s and I fully agree with your comments. I had not looked into the boots, but will definitely do now. Thanks.
I really like this format for the videos. I would love to see you wearing (don’t know if they would allow it), just to get an impression of the feel while wearing, a view of the shoes from your perspective and how they would crease, like you did for the boots. Thank you for all your hard work.
Dressy European jump boots are by far my favorite style, slough that balmoral is gorgeous as well. Awesome video, thanks Preston!
Thanks! Yeah the boots were seriously my favorite!
@@TheElegantOxford how was the sizing on the George?
Excellent. I have several pairs of shoes made in Spain. Excellent shoes--right up there with the Edward Green and John Lobb shoes I own.
I just bought the George boots, cant wait to wear them for the rest of the winter and spring :)
I had a pair of the Roberts for a while know and find them to be very comfortable. One of the reasons they are so comfortable to walk in is because the soles are made from a softer leather than say a JR sole. The quilted footbed also provides a decent amount of cushioning. They are simply great shoes especially for the price. On the patina color recommendation, I second your choice of green.
Thanks for the info on the Robert and glad to hear you liked them so much!
One of your best videos. I’ve been interested in this brand for some time but haven’t seen any quality comprehensive reviews. Thank you.
Thanks for watching Andrew!
Leave them as they are. Beautiful color!
Preston,
I think they taper the lace holes closer together going towards the top in case you have a ‘V’ gap. This will make all the lace holes end up the same distance apart and this fools the eye into not seeing the gap.
Also, when you do these reviews or first impression videos, I think it would be a good thing to measure the height of the heel in respect to the inside and outside ball of the ankle. A high quality shoe will have an asymmetric design to properly fit the lay of inside and outside ankle bone. I think that’s critical to a comfortable fit in a shoe and it’d be interesting to see which brands just use a generic pattern and which have these fine measurements taken into account.
Great review, that golden harvest’esch shoe is such a beautiful color. They all are actually. Thanks!
Great points!
I am a huge Cobbler Union supporter! I have 7 pairs and looking to pick up two more (sneaker and an oxblood smith loafer). I love everything about the brand and truly believe they are the best value in mens shoes on the market. Their staff and leadership is absolutely amazing and I cant recommend them enough! Thankfully I live in metro Atlanta, so stopping in to see the team is rather easy!
Wow that’s cool! Wish I could visit the Atlanta show room! Thanks for watching
That sole of the first pair, I thought it was almost like a Chesterfield. Looks very comfortable. And that outer sole almost mirror smooth. Unbelievable craftsmanship. The second pair, I'd wear it without a doubt. Probably blasphemy, but even under a pair of nice jeans (not a suit man... Yet) and those boots, wow! That grain like look. Never seen anything like that. Let me head over to their website.
Glad you liked the three pairs!
Definitely worth considering. I have had the Francis doublemonks for over 2 years now and they are simply great shoes.
I have 8 pairs of Cobbler Union. They are stunning, each in their own right. Worth every penny.
I agree! Really liked how mine turned out
This video format is amazing, i got to relax and learn
Thanks for the input Jose!
The mustard color shoes are my fav, great presentation as usual, keep them coming plz
Hi Preston. Unfortunately the cobbler union doesn't manufacturer the George boots anymore and the Winston mustard yellow, most of the sizes are sold out.
The Winchester is very similar but I'd recommend going for the smooth rather than the pebbled leather options. I have the black (pebbled) and the brown (smooth). The black I got at regular price and while the craftsmanship is great the larger does take a bit to break in. The brown Winchester I got on clearance and at under $300 they were a steal and while the color wasn't the most glamorous brown everything got fixed with a touch of patina. The calf leather feels super smooth and even the leather lining feels 2× better than the pebbled version.
Love all three.
Stellar video, I had an endorphin rush from beginning to end, not in the least due to the alluring, sensual and riveting narration. These shoes are marvellous, the Winston brogues are truly spectacular, a dressed-up version of a Tricker's classic. They might have a touch of burnishing but nothing more. And then there is the use of that gorgeous Prince of Wales backdrop fabric; such class, such style, worthy of a Pal Zileri suit. This video is epic.
Thank you! Really appreciate your words!
I think the Winston with a green or a blue patina would be stunning. Would of loved to see the Robert and Winston on. All three shoes are beautiful! 💕
Blue is good too!
Stunning shoes and I heard about this brand not long ago and this week I placed my first order I have Magnanni and TBNY a few Cole Haan’s for comfort and Johnston &Murphy a few Boss as well but everything is shoes from Cobbler Union I ordered a pair of boots in my eyes the most beautiful boots I have ever seen in my life they are black leather and black suede boots I’ll come back and write the model and my thoughts, a American brand deserves to be supported by us and specially when they do such a amazing work y’all might mention other per se Italian brands but this shoes are at the same price and Goodyear welded and amazing designs so support our brands!!!
My black cap toe oxford is their Richard. Nice beveled waist and red sole. I like it.
What a surprise that you purcchased THAT boot. I've been eyeing them for awhile.
I like this format
Awesome! Thanks for letting me know
Fabulous review and long awaited because I have hesitated to buy because of hassles in shipping to Canada and making a mistake. To me the Winston in that color is a knockout color for those with panache (and self confidence)! Very similar to the difficult to find vintage Imperials I've been looking for in that color. Insofar as changing them up I would not go there if it was anybody other than yourself doing the work, way too dangerous. A 2 tone color scheme might work with green hues but would make them even more 'Dandy' than a regular spectator shoe IMHO. In your hands it will no doubt come out superbly !
Thanks for your recommendation and your comment
Love the balmorals and the boots, Preston.
Thanks Armando! Good to see you on here!
@@TheElegantOxford thanks Preston!
Nice. Especially the Roberts.
I have two of the three. Great choices!
I'm saving up to get a pair of their Alex uR in cognac grain. They are gorgeous.
Nice! Let me know how they end up for you!
I love these videos!
Green please, asking because that color really challenges me and would enjoy seeing how you might tackle this with your vast color dye expertise.
Absolutely love all the shoes!! The mustard yellow wing tips are my favorite, followed by the boots and then the cap toes. I wouldn’t add any color myself, but I’m anxious to see what you come up with.
Thanks Mark! You’re right, the mustard calf looks amazing. Kinda makes me sad to change it
I own that pair of boots but in dark brown, freaking love them!
I also own that pair of oxfords but in black, it's a great pair!
Maybe I should go ahead and purchase the Winstons in dark brown....
As far as the presentation goes I like this format which makes me feel that we are interacting. As to the patina, I am wondering how an autumnal look, you know yellowes, gold and brown will look like? Ott you think? Anyways nice to see your post. And thanks for all the information.
Thanks! Yes, an autumn patina is another good choice I’m considering
Wow, the Jumper Boots are winners. 👌🏻
I've been wondering about Cobbler Union. I see them frequently as they do lots of marketing. So I'm a little suspicious when I see something being marketed a lot. They have some great casual styles and just announced a winter sale. So before I dove in, I thought I would check in... And I'm glad I did. I haven't seen anything negative so far. Quality looks deserving of the marketing.
I really like the Winstons and it's bold styling. I'd wear them with light-colored chinos and jeans. Maybe the right colored suit as well.
Thanks for the review.
Speaking as the daughter of a man who jumped into Africa, Sicily, Normandy and Holland with the 82nd Airborne Division, your boots are *not* reminiscent of jump boots. They are, however, quite similar to the pebble grain boots that were favoured by tankers. General Patton was known to wear them!
One thing you missed on the Robert, which was not present on the other two shoes/boots, was the Gentleman's notch. If desired, it could be easily added, or I should say, subtracted from the others!
I recently acquired a pair of Thursday Captains, in Old English, and I was wondering if you have any suggestions for creme and wax colours?
Btw, your wingtips could easily be worn with midnight blue trousers . . . by a Notre Dame, or Navy fan!!
Edit: Now that I think about it, I wouldn't be surprised if the George was named after George S Patton!!🤔✨
Nice video, the best part is to see you with he boots on. The internet needs more videos on foot! Please put your shoes on to end the reviews.
A deep burgandy would look killer on those wingtips
Hey Preston, would you do a video on how to shine pebble grain shoes?
For the Winston, a slightly darker color, still gold but maybe a late harvest. Just accents in critical spots. The closer to the sole, the darker the tint. Maybe a slight avocado or Kelly green accent here and there, but only minimal.
Masculine Wingtip.... I very very very love it....
This was a great review. I looked over their offerings on their website.
I’ve had my eye on CU for a couple of years now but each time I visit I’m disappointed that EEE widths aren’t available. I wish they did because those Winstons are a grail shoe for me now. I can’t get a hold of a Golden harvest Florsheim so this would be a handsome substitute.
Try asking if they'll do a custom MTO pair
I would like to see a blue patina on the yellow shoes.
This channel is too amazing
Great Review.. I think i'm going to be purchasing a pair from this shoe maker..
I'll go for a marble patina on the mustard like the one you did on the AE pair.
Great review! I've purchased multiple boots from them.
The boots were my favorite
I've known about Cobblers Union for a while but they don't offer wide sizes. 😩
I recently bought their Richard another Black Cap Oxford and I wear a 9.5 US EEE. It’s true that they don’t offer the same last options in wider, however they often make the same model in other lasts. I originally was looking at their city last but they recommended the 371 version in size 10. It fits perfectly. My recommendation if on their web site look at the last description and message their CS they were helpful. Though sadly some of their styles only to date come in one last. Most have at least another version.
I remember a couple weeks back when you commented that you were reviewing them on AE entrust. I have to say I was pleased with my Richards. But if I get another pair of oxfords I am going to go with that style. I agree with you that I like 6 eyelets. Though George though WOW. I think a blue on those Winston would pop nicely. Though it sounds to me ( something in your voice sound like you want to have your cake and eat it to) like you might need to add a second pair for yourself to leave un modified.
Get their 2 eyelet Derby
leve the brogues as they are... they are wonderful...they will darken over time
Thanks! A lot of people are asking me to leave them alone too
The shoe models are named after friends/seed investors of the founder, which I thought was cool. I bought a pair in Atlanta a few years back, and the owner happened to be at the store. They're definitely passionate about shoe making. Lovely guys (Daniel and Eric) and great shoe, albeit slightly on the heavy side and I needed a half a size smaller than usual.
PS: just posted the results of the first (amateur) polish I gave them... Far from perfect, but I was really proud of myself LOL
that kid skin part sound very scary :)) but great review as usual
Haha kidskin means juvenile goat skin and NOT the skin of a human child.
🤣
Cobbler is a brand I follow from a Long Time and I ll buy the Axel museum model from them.
Love the review! I was thinking green as well. Next time could you mention the off the rack price for the shoes you review?
The balmoral Oxford is beautiful. I also like the boots. Just wish their website was a bit more helpful on their shoes width. I was hoping to buy their Adelaide but just not sure if it suits narrow feet.
Neon Green!!!
Great videos, can you do a video on bringing a shine back to scuffed patent leather?
I'm looking at CU for loafers and suede chukkas
Deberían de sacar a los que descalifican los videos 👍
Ah, I think the tan Robert you saw at Farrington’s was mine. I took it there for triumph tips!
Haha that’s so cool! Great to meet the owner.
@@TheElegantOxford yeah, that was cool when you said it! Let's connect for a patina!
Sure thing. Email me sometime
Very, Very Nice 👍
I like number 1.
Number 2 is beautifull too. 👀
I can't say I'm impressed by the Winston, something about it just doesn't seem right. However I really like the Robert, it just shows class.
What did you ever do with the mustard yellow brogues? You mentioned you'd follow up with something. Thx,
Big fan of Cobbler Union so I appreciate the video!
Just a heads up though, there's an audio editing issue at 27:23
Oh you’re right! Don’t know why that happened!
I have not yet bought anything from CU but I must say, I ve been tempted and I ve browsed their website a few times and the website is pretty bad. It s such a shame considering the day and age and how much this accounts for in high end men s wear. Very nice video ! I might just get a pair soon nevertheless
I got the monks in oxblood and I can tell you that they are great shoes, beautiful and well constructed. I dont see difference between them and my Carminas.
I wonder when and in what situations the mustard Oxfords would be appropriate… thoughts please!
Usually with very casual outfits. Very light blue jeans or light gray trousers would work.
I want to own a brown shoe as beautiful as on the main screen. Want leather upper and lower.
What about a blue on those yellow shoes!
I'd love to see your agate/marble patina
Good review.
Thanks!
I prefer the live discussion as opposed to the voiceover
Thanks for the input David!
Its so odd to me it took you so long to give them a try. For the money, it is damn hard to not take them over AE. When they are on sale they have the same kind of price to quality ratio as something like TLB. The customer service is also great in my experience. Gonna have to look into getting a pair of those george boots!
You’re completely right! I slept on Cobbler Union for too long
@@TheElegantOxford my Francis pair in museum sit easily in my top 5 shoes in my 50+ pair collection. I want more but the budget has been so tight the past couple years lol
So many shoes, so little money. I totally understand that!
Glad CU worked out so well for you
You're a genius
Gorgeous shoes. Question: If you had one choice, which would you choose? Meermin, Carmina or Cobbler Union?
Honestly there’s room for all 3 in a wardrobe and they come in different price ranges. Cobbler Union shoes are less expensive than Carmina and are just as good if not better.
I'd love to see your opinion on some european brands (Berwick or Shoepassion), most of the brands you review aren't available in Europe (or the taxes are just too high for it to be a good choice).
Berwick is made in Spain right? Any trouble getting other Spanish brands like Cobbler Union, TLB, or Carmina?
Preston I'm little confused, are the Winston mustard shoes made in Vegano leather which still consists of calf skin. What I know is that the difference with boxcalf skin is that vegano leather it is not given the final finish in the tannery; or the Winston is made in Vegan leather (faux leather or fake "leather ") thank you, Julian Orozco.
Vegano is made from actual animal leather.
@@TheElegantOxford gracias
Could you do a video on how to dress for these types of shoes?
Sure! I included a dress style with the George Boot at the end but I’ll do them for other shoes as well
@@TheElegantOxford thankyou!!
I'd like to see what you do with the mustard wingtips for sure!
Isn't calling it a "balmoral oxford" a bit like saying something is "Verde green"?
I was under the impression that:
(American) Balmoral = Oxford (English)
(American) Blucher = Derby (English)
Please correct me if I'm wrong.
A Balmoral is a shoe with a vertical seam running along side the shoe that separates the lower from the upper or a shaft, if it’s a boot.
In the United States, the term is used incorrectly since actual Balmorals do exist and still carry the name.
Great shoes and styles BUT the half quilted insert will pull up when you remove your tree's they catch on the front of it and pull up where it's glued. I own 3 pair and all 3 do this. Never had this issue with AE. Oh yea they give you full length insert. Daniel you guys could do better.
Excellent content sir. I wear an 11 3E in AE . What size would you recommend for the Robert Museum 888?
I highly recommend reaching out to them for a recommendation. They offer free returns and that includes shipping. I honestly can't recommend them enough.
I have 6 pairs and grabbing a 7th very soon. I absolutely love CU. I feel that they are the best value in menswear - no question.
The winstons look like Loake Chesters
For the first pair of shoes, how would you walk with that sole, wouldnt it be very slippery on tile/wet surfaces?
Would you need to put a rubber sole on the bottom, like a sticker? Help/feedback in this area would be fantastic as I have two pairs coming my way!!!
Hey Graham. You’ll be totally fine. After the first 5 steps, the smooth surface will gain a rough surface.
Slips are rare unless you have metal nails on the heel like some vintage shoes did
Those shoes look incredible! I'm sold on the boot and the wingtip. What do you think about sizing? Is it similar to an AE?
Hey Joshua. They run true to size for sure but don’t offer wide widths it seems.
Love the video sir! Did you use Saphir Renovateur on those Roberts from Cobbler Union to condition? Just recently got a pair today in the museum ox blood. I know Renovateur can be harsh on certain colours patterns. Just wanted to ask the expert. Thanks!
Hey Mati. I used cream universal because it’s what I had on hand.
With museum calf, try a gentler conditioner like cream universal or leather lotion
Thanks sir! After the conditioning Would you still recommend hitting the museum calf with Saphir neutral Cream Polish and then a hard wax?
I’d go straight into wax. You can influence the color of museum using colored cream but I don’t personally do it myself
After conditioning, I was gonna hit it with Saphir Neutral Crème polish and then Saphir Neutral Hard Wax. Staying in line with your method.
For sure no colors. After the Creme Universalle, I was gonna hit it with the Saphir Neutral Creme Polish and then Saphir Neutral Hard wax. Staying in line with your method. How’s that sound? Im pretty lucky, I work in the same building as Cobbler Union man.
Preston you must be the same shoe size as I am! 8.5US?
8E is my normal size although I do go into 8.5 when wide isn’t available
@@TheElegantOxford I figured something was up when 8.5 was out of stock for those 3 shoes on Cobbler Union's website.
Could you review a pair of church’s from the UK
I’m interested in Church’s too. Just don’t like what’s happened since Prada purchased them
@@TheElegantOxford yeah that’s fair enough
Wingtips look like Baby pooh brown
How was the sizing for the shoes and the boot?
True to size. I ordered half a size up to compensate for my wider foot but they fit awesome
Where are the shoes made.
Cobbler Union are made in Spain
Are you familiar with Undandy out of Portugal? I own 6 pairs and love them... customizable and a great at around 200 usd each
Please do jacket and cowboy boots videos
I hate that you're forcing me to buy more shoes. Tell me more. lol
What pants to wear with those?
With the Robert? I’d say Navy Blue slacks for sure
@@TheElegantOxford No pinstripes?
Sure that works too!