When I went for my prostate biopsy, the surgeon asked what my favourite music was. I replied Pink Floyd. I was sent under to 'Comfortably Numb. Absolutely surreal!!!!
Hello! I am 63 and I also listen a lot to Pink Floyds music. What, if anything, does this song mean to you? Does it have message, do you think? 😊 Have a nice day, sir!
David Gilmour doesn't just play the guitar, he feels the guitar, he broadcasts the guitar, David makes the guitart broadcast feelings, what David did to and for this song truly transcends much much more than just playing a song, true musical perfection and David goes about it so humbly
David Gilmour is one of the GOATs. Sitting my head right now, not understanding how someone can not just play an instrument, but own it the way he does.
@@jibguy2003 Many will learn the skills to play well and even more technical than Gilmour if they put in the time. Not many will be able to create solos that grab you and provide an emotional response like this. Putting the two together is what separates musicians like Gilmour.
Nobody can make a guitar weep quite like David Gilmour, it’s mesmerizing! I’ve been listening since the 70’s, and I never grow tired of Pink Floyd’s body of work. They will undoubtedly be remembered for a long, long time.
I still think the studio version is the greatest solo ever and this live version is another amazing performance. So far as making a guitar weep, I would have to put Gary Moore up there as my top pic, Gary and "Greeny" were SUBLIME !
Yep. As a youngster back in the 70"s I bought my first double vinyl done by Pink Floyd. Despite listening to this version done by David probably HUNDREDS of time over the years the magic still works. GOOSE BUMPS!
I hear you. Born 1961, Wern't we lucky!!! Pink Floyd, Deep purple Led Zeppelin ..The 60s 70s and maybe 80s They were the times to be growing up! Other people have no idea
I saw Pink Floyd at the Orange Bowl 1988. I was in the 3rd row right in front of David Gilmour and during this solo it started to rain. it was magical!
I thought I would get through that solo this time, But at the very end of it when the music stopped I thought I've done it, And then I started to cry. Thank God for the gift that he gave David Gilmore, Because we're receiving a big piece of it ourselves. The one good thing I've got out of being 72 is my old rock and roll from the 60s and 70s, Thank you Lord☮️☮️☮️🤟🤟🤟
The magnum opus of all guitarists, and Pink Floyd the magnum opus of all groups, Set the bar so high . Listened with a bunch of flatmates in 1973 to Dark Side of the Moon and we all sat there dumbstruck in total awe of the quality, uniqueness, and technical excellence of the music. They never stopped.
As they were “putting me under” before a heart procedure I requested comfortable numb by Floyd and the nurse on the team played it for me as I was drifting off! I’ll never forget that! Awesome Doctor and a great team! Saved my life also! Thanks to all!
I never just drift off. I'm laying there looking up at the lights then the next second I'm in the recovery room and look at the clock and it's a few hours later. No drifting off for me, it's a switch, a time machine.
I had to have a MRI on my right shoulder early in 23 .When the tech went to put me in the tube he asked if I wanted to listen to music instead of the hammering sound of the machine, I told him sure. He put a set of headphones on me after I told him some Floyd , lo and behold here comes Comfortably Numb . Was told I had to have a total shoulder joint replacement , but cardiologist still have it on hold because of blood thinners from stents in November of 22 . Ah the joys and fun of getting old .
We All Know What Gilmour can do (what he is!) and Not “Just” for the guitar work but also as a brilliant Vocalist, But that guy on the Drums is Incredible!😮👍
Closest thing I’ve heard yet to matching the Pulse version. Just amazing I wonder if he is transported to another place while playing like we are while listening?
Brilliant, i was privelaged to have seen them live 50 years ago on their Dark side of the moon tour , what an awesome band and their legendary music will go on and listened to for another 50 years
Exquisite, sublime, unmatched. There are simply not enough superlatives to adequately describe how good this is. When my time comes to an end and I depart this world it will be to this masterpiece.
The smile on drummers face when he knows the solo is coming up, it's magical. Being part of that is something few will ever have the fortune to experience
Gilmour's solo takes all of the darkness, despair and hopelessness expressed in the lyrics, ramps them up to 11 and drives it like a stake through your soul. Pure artistic genius.
My boy used to mock me for listening to the floyd, now he's in his teens, has it all on vinyl, and the other day I heard him playing and singing wish you were here on his twelve string from the other side of his bedroom door, my job as a parent is finally coming to fruition!
Andy Latimer of Camel does. Watch Ice, Stationary Traveller or Lunar Sea. And Steve Hackett. Watch Firth of Fifth or Every Day. And Steve Rothery. Watch Easter or Jigsaw. Gilmour's excellent, but others are at least as good.
Always amazes me, no matter how many hundred times I have listened to it. Personally, I think the one in the Pulse live record is the absolute best version of the solo.
We’ve been blessed as a society to have listened and seen these magical moments by absolute masters of their crafts. Like sitting in the back of the Sistine Chapel watching Michelangelo do his thing in real time. Breathtaking!!
I sat and listened to Roy Harper tell a story of what it was like to be on stage with Dave Gilmore, basically compared it to the same force as a solar wind.
Saw this masterpiece in Winnipeg on the 1st July 1994. Had to divert air traffic at the airport due to lasers being used during concert. Still to this day the greatest concert I’ve ever seen. Magical.
Some of the greatest lead guitarist ever came from England, Mr Gilmore was certainly in the top 5 all time! I was born in the 1960's and was lucky enough to grow up 2 miles from Alpine Valley Concert Theatre in East Troy WI. I have literally seen hundreds of shows lilve, but these guys as well as Led Zeplin were all done then. I missed them at Milwaukee County Stadium, but some friends went and tripped all night! Just legendary! One of the best guitar solo's ever written, and Britain produce alot of them! I personally love Maiden, but these guys gave Maiden the beginnings of their greatness! Just geniuses!
When you have all the excellent musicians as Pink Floyd represents here, Mr. Gilmore shines ever so brightly as they all give the epicness of this show, by far it will go down in the annuals of history. 🤙🌈🏝️
Featuring the happiest drummer in the world. Every shot of him, the dude is just loving life.
Yup, if he smiled any harder, he'd hurt his face!
I think he was finally promoted.
Same with Guy Pratt on bass. They know they are in the presence of a musical god
He knows he just locked down his place in music history, with distinction.
Love this drummer 🎉
There are great solos, and then there is this. Perfection.
Heard it hundreds of times and still get goosebumps every time. This solo is epic.
For once the overused word 'epic' is correct😊
I’m with ya!!!
When I went for my prostate biopsy, the surgeon asked what my favourite music was. I replied Pink Floyd. I was sent under to 'Comfortably Numb. Absolutely surreal!!!!
You're lucky. I got no anesthetic or Pink Floyd.
I had also a prostate biopsy last year but, unfortunately, no music at all !!
I hope they knock me out next time I need one of those biopsies 😬
How apt
@@Bizz55 Im sorry but, 😂😂😂
At 66 I listen to this song every day!
Hello! I am 63 and I also listen a lot to Pink Floyds music. What, if anything, does this song mean to you? Does it have message, do you think? 😊 Have a nice day, sir!
"a day without Pink Floyd, is like a day without sunshine " said a hitchhiker who I picked up about 25 years ago never forgot that and so true
Beat you there sonny, 75 and still bumpin' along. First saw them at Bromley college 1967. Brilliant and innovative then, still are
54 here and still loving it
70 and still listening every day, have not found anything to replace it .
David Gilmour doesn't just play the guitar, he feels the guitar, he broadcasts the guitar, David makes the guitart broadcast feelings, what David did to and for this song truly transcends much much more than just playing a song, true musical perfection and David goes about it so humbly
Exactly like Prince did it. One with the instrument.
Someone once said "Most guitars players plug into the amp. Gilmour plugs his guitar into his soul."
@@R0geR0sv0ld exactly right
David Gilmour is absolutely incredible!!!
David Gilmour is one of the GOATs. Sitting my head right now, not understanding how someone can not just play an instrument, but own it the way he does.
It’s easy to play like that when one practices the instrument 8-12 hours a day, 6 days a week for years.
@@jibguy2003 Many will learn the skills to play well and even more technical than Gilmour if they put in the time. Not many will be able to create solos that grab you and provide an emotional response like this. Putting the two together is what separates musicians like Gilmour.
David Gilmour is simply perfect.... The EPIC solo of all time, bar none.
Anche gli extraterrestri e gli animali che popolano il mondo si fermano ad ascoltare meravigliati il RE delle corde ❤
Cough Stevie Ray Vaughn cough cough…..
Simply incredible!! No words can express how great that man is!!!
Nobody can make a guitar weep quite like David Gilmour, it’s mesmerizing! I’ve been listening since the 70’s, and I never grow tired of Pink Floyd’s body of work. They will undoubtedly be remembered for a long, long time.
It sounds a bit ZZtp-ish, but Billy Gibbon has a nicer glassy sound.
@@RHINOTEJAS Billy Gibbons (& ZZ Top) is at the top of my list as well. He is one of the finest blues slide guitarists since Duane Allman.
I still think the studio version is the greatest solo ever and this live version is another amazing performance.
So far as making a guitar weep, I would have to put Gary Moore up there as my top pic, Gary and "Greeny" were SUBLIME !
Listen to Per Nilsson’s guitar playing for Kaipa and you’ll hear someone who make their guitar sing.
Mr. Mark Knopfler
Yep. As a youngster back in the 70"s I bought my first double vinyl done by Pink Floyd. Despite listening to this version done by David probably HUNDREDS of time over the years the magic still works. GOOSE BUMPS!
Fantastic. It could go on for hours. The best of the best. At 70 years old, it makes me feeling 20 again!
Love Pink Floyd! As a Gen X'r born in the 60's this is what the younger Generations are missing but can still enjoy!
I hear you. Born 1961, Wern't we lucky!!! Pink Floyd, Deep purple Led Zeppelin ..The 60s 70s and maybe 80s They were the times to be growing up! Other people have no idea
Without doubt..the best guitarist of our time…thank you mr gilmour
Bill Nelson of Be Bop Deluxe
We are blessed to hear David play. A treasure.
THEE most iconic solo…period! David Gilmore is an absolute musical genius with so much heart and soul. Totally unparalleled.
I watch this at least once a month, it never gets old. It's my favorite solo of all time!
His masterpiece at 70 years old.
Absolutely! What a genius!
It's great to hear David Gilmour playing in such good form.
He’s almost 70 during that time!
I saw Pink Floyd at the Orange Bowl 1988. I was in the 3rd row right in front of David Gilmour and during this solo it started to rain. it was magical!
I saw the division bell tour in Tampa the same way. Soon as the sun went down it started drizzle and our acid kicked in. It was amazing.
@@khb6686 nice!
I thought I would get through that solo this time, But at the very end of it when the music stopped I thought I've done it, And then I started to cry.
Thank God for the gift that he gave David Gilmore, Because we're receiving a big piece of it ourselves.
The one good thing I've got out of being 72 is my old rock and roll from the 60s and 70s, Thank you Lord☮️☮️☮️🤟🤟🤟
@terryandrews7271. Yes friend. You are absolutely correct. I know EXACTLY what you mean.
Feeling comfortable numb just listening to the amazing guitar solo.
Saw them live in Minneapolis...early 90s...amazing showmanship and music...
i never tire listening to this, Absolutely one of the greatest solos ever !!
No one like you .. only one David Gilmour ❤❤
Simply the Best !!!
The happiest drummer ever to be filmed
Taylor Hawkins was by far the happiest
@@N8QIO hahah that smile was infectious!
His name is Steve DiStanislao
I really like the Berlin wall version with van Morrison better .
You really need to watch Sina Doering, a/k/a Sina Drums.
Absolutely love the big grin at his band mates half way through!👍👍🙏
Perfection on a stage.
The magnum opus of all guitarists, and Pink Floyd the magnum opus of all groups, Set the bar so high . Listened with a bunch of flatmates in 1973 to Dark Side of the Moon and we all sat there dumbstruck in total awe of the quality, uniqueness, and technical excellence of the music. They never stopped.
Calm down
As they were “putting me under” before a heart procedure I requested comfortable numb by Floyd and the nurse on the team played it for me as I was drifting off! I’ll never forget that! Awesome Doctor and a great team! Saved my life also! Thanks to all!
I never just drift off. I'm laying there looking up at the lights then the next second I'm in the recovery room and look at the clock and it's a few hours later. No drifting off for me, it's a switch, a time machine.
I had to have a MRI on my right shoulder early in 23 .When the tech went to put me in the tube he asked if I wanted to listen to music instead of the hammering sound of the machine, I told him sure. He put a set of headphones on me after I told him some Floyd , lo and behold here comes Comfortably Numb . Was told I had to have a total shoulder joint replacement , but cardiologist still have it on hold because of blood thinners from stents in November of 22 . Ah the joys and fun of getting old .
🤣🤣🤣had this playing loud and clear on head phones whilst in the dreaded dentist chair …perfect
Don’t get no better than that!
I am so blessed to have ears to hear and eyes to see.
We All Know What Gilmour can do (what he is!) and Not “Just” for the guitar work but also as a brilliant Vocalist, But that guy on the Drums is Incredible!😮👍
So, so much an emotional guitar solo. Gives me goosebumps every time.
His playing gives me chills!! Absolutely love this man and his guitar!! No one better!!
I have seen twice. One of my fav bands and Gilmore one of my fav guitarists. I don't understand people that don't like Floyd. They transcend...
My favorite band, my favorite song, other bands, catch them if you can.
My lord David...❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Not lord but Sir😁
David Gilmour, the consummate artist continues to transcend the passage of time!!👍❤️👍
Brilliant. Been listening to this song for 30 years and it still is just awesome!
Truly a classic! And he did this at what age? Almost 70 at that time! 🙌🏻
Absolutely brilliant!!!!
Gilmore, incredible talent. We played this song in a band I was in, one of our best songs.
Closest thing I’ve heard yet to matching the Pulse version. Just amazing
I wonder if he is transported to another place while playing like we are while listening?
I'd like to think YES! He's playing is just so mesmerizing - one that you could stand listening over and over again.
You can tell for sure that Steve is transported! When did a drummer ever look so happy playing to such an exciting piece of music?
Eargasm!
That tone is SPOT on, too! Really hits different!
Absolutely breath taking !
Superior solo. Best all-around by ANY artist!!!!!!!!
Really 😂
David makes that strat sing One of my top5 of all time favorite songs ! Used to listen to this and get comfortably numb
This man is simply a legend !
Brilliant, i was privelaged to have seen them live 50 years ago on their Dark side of the moon tour , what an awesome band and their legendary music will go on and listened to for another 50 years
Thank you David for your fantastic music
Exquisite, sublime, unmatched. There are simply not enough superlatives to adequately describe how good this is. When my time comes to an end and I depart this world it will be to this masterpiece.
Always loved it... certainly one of the best!!!
So good! I’m 70.
Pulse live is the 'ultimate' solo by Master Gilmour - no question!
The version on Delicate Sound of Thunder is even better!
Saw the Floyd in Sacramento in 1988. That concert will be embedded in my brain forever. Absolutely incredible.
As for myself - 3 times in Melbourne, Australia 1988. Including opening night (without a ticket) 5 rows back, center stage.
EPIC... the greatest
Pink Floyd, the Best, David Gilmour, one of the best ever.
This is my own favourite version too.
We were lucky enough to see the ‘One Night Only Cinema Showing’ of this Show, in 2017.
Scintillating. 🎶🎸❤️🎸🎶
God Bless David, he was definitely brought to us from a Higher Power.
Proves it doesn't have to be played fast to be AMAZING and moving!
The smile on drummers face when he knows the solo is coming up, it's magical. Being part of that is something few will ever have the fortune to experience
Gilmour's solo takes all of the darkness, despair and hopelessness expressed in the lyrics, ramps them up to 11 and drives it like a stake through your soul. Pure artistic genius.
That's another way to describe it!
My boy used to mock me for listening to the floyd, now he's in his teens, has it all on vinyl, and the other day I heard him playing and singing wish you were here on his twelve string from the other side of his bedroom door, my job as a parent is finally coming to fruition!
Wow. That is amazing. Takes me back. Thanks for posting.
No worries! Thank you for watching! Same feeling!
These legends will live on when others fade away ❤
Wow that was something else!!!!
Lovely - I had the prililege to see him and the band play this live in the 80's in Manchester - best gig I've ever attended - thank you for posting
Love it!! The greatest generation of music in the last century.
The BEST guitar solo ever!! No one tops this one performance, no one.
Andy Latimer of Camel does. Watch Ice, Stationary Traveller or Lunar Sea. And Steve Hackett. Watch Firth of Fifth or Every Day. And Steve Rothery. Watch Easter or Jigsaw. Gilmour's excellent, but others are at least as good.
Adventures in a Yorkshire Landscape, Bill Nelson of Be Bop Deluxe, from the original Live in the air age album.
@@user-bl5jr5vz6i Bill Nelson is brilliant, yet not widely known now.
Always amazes me, no matter how many hundred times I have listened to it. Personally, I think the one in the Pulse live record is the absolute best version of the solo.
ШЕДЕВР !!!!!!! БРАВИСИМО !!!!!!!
There will never be another Pink Floyd or David Gilmour!
This Fender stratocaster sound and David Gilmour solo are out of this world...
I’ll never stop listening to to Floyd especially this talented guitarist
We’ve been blessed as a society to have listened and seen these magical moments by absolute masters of their crafts. Like sitting in the back of the Sistine Chapel watching Michelangelo do his thing in real time. Breathtaking!!
David thank you absolutely fabulous 😅
I sat and listened to Roy Harper tell a story of what it was like to be on stage with Dave Gilmore, basically compared it to the same force as a solar wind.
Roy Harper you mean right? Lucky YOU!
@@FunkyMusic_24 No it was his brother Rou🤪😁
One of the greatest!
Incredible, no words ❤
See Pink Floyd live MSG NY in Early 70s very close seats so grateful I got to see them when they were in their prime
Saw this masterpiece in Winnipeg on the 1st July 1994. Had to divert air traffic at the airport due to lasers being used during concert. Still to this day the greatest concert I’ve ever seen. Magical.
Ohhhhhh! What a time to be alive! So the laser thing was really a BIG thing back then!
@@FunkyMusic_24 ~ Yes it was … spectacular!
So beautiful. I forgot about all the crap going on in this world and just floated away in the rhythm 🤙❤️🇨🇦
Omg and God bless David he is one the most talented guitar players ever and his passion for the instrument is phenomenal and deserves much respect
No one better ever!
Bill Nelson of Be Bop Deluxe. Adventures in a Yorkshire Landscape from the original Live in the air age album.
This is just plain AMAZING!!
That song takes me to a happy place
@@quintonhorne5152 damn! Same here!
Some of the greatest lead guitarist ever came from England, Mr Gilmore was certainly in the top 5 all time! I was born in the 1960's and was lucky enough to grow up 2 miles from Alpine Valley Concert Theatre in East Troy WI. I have literally seen hundreds of shows lilve, but these guys as well as Led Zeplin were all done then. I missed them at Milwaukee County Stadium, but some friends went and tripped all night! Just legendary! One of the best guitar solo's ever written, and Britain produce alot of them! I personally love Maiden, but these guys gave Maiden the beginnings of their greatness! Just geniuses!
I used to think the intermezzo solo was the greatest, but then I realized it was this one--the incredible, unmatched outro. Thanks for reminding me!
This track is in my Will, to be played at my funeral alongside the Stones, Sympathy for the devil.
The tone, tone , tone, TONE!!!
Saw him on his last tour.....and have tickets for his next.....can't wait!
I'm 66 as well, I'm with you brother!!!
@@DougGurley-vv4pt thanks man!
When you have all the excellent musicians as Pink Floyd represents here, Mr. Gilmore shines ever so brightly as they all give the epicness of this show, by far it will go down in the annuals of history. 🤙🌈🏝️
Seen him live in ‘94. I’ve seen most of all the greats. Pink Floyd was the best.
Love Gilmore's solos! So melodic and beautiful! Gives me goosebumps every time!
There's nothing like hearing it in person. I wept.
Perfection...
Pink Floyd and headphones 👍
Greatest of all time? Who can say. But that was freaking awesome!