Karajan's rigorous approach suits this symphony very well. I really like this recording, it's the one I treasure in my collection. This is one of the best recordings of this symphony and probably my favourite one - this is how I picture this symphony in my mind.
Here in the comments section, There are a lot of people (musicologists, university students, etc...) who come with comments, snobbish, selfish and arrogants, People who seem that it not enough to solve the problems of their lives, and they hide listening to classical music recordings, criticizing other people taste's, acclaiming themselves for having a superior taste, many times criticizing other composers and conductors, when they make a good effort (The perfect is the enemy of the good). Then there are ordinary people, who are music collectors, or simple listeners who come to have a good time, without claiming superiority, or people who say they like all genres, or who're starting to hear something new, and probalby people who remember hearing said piece in a cartoon, film, or videogame (They can always investigate further if they want). I don't hate any Composer, (The composers is always right, when it comes to the intepreatation of his works, I think i'm like Karajan or Barenboim in that matter) I am 16 years old, I entered a music school when i was 8 years old, I love the "Academic Genre" , (as i like to call it, apart from "cultured" or "erudite") thanks to TH-cam, i have discovered the greatest recordings and concerts. I listen to different works deppending on the day, or my state, or while i'm reading a book, or researching, but i try to solve my behavior, knowing that these works do not hurt me. I also listen to any artistic genre such as Folk, Blues, Jazz, Rock, etc... because that is Music, an ART FORM (The same things happens to me with books and films) But like many people, I can't go a single day without listening to music. MUSIC KILLS NOBODY P. D.: I think Karajan has the same facial expressions as Beethoven in his portraits.
a mon sens LA meilleure integrale de karajan : puissance et maitrise totale tout en gardant la profondeur du CHANT BEETHOVENIEN!!!!!!!! Immortel comme il le desirait, ne vous y trompez pas je ne suis pas 1 fan absolu de Karajan! mais cette edition Mon Dieu est tout SIMPLEMENT PARFAITE !!!!!!!
22:20. One of the more thrilling IV accounts I’ve ever heard. Gardiner’s 1990s Archiv version shares its spirit, and accelerating tempi...and then some. Get back in line, if this is the wooden rollercoaster one prefers.
Estimado oppie47, lo primero gracias por compartir estas grabaciones de Beethoven por Karajan... Según dicen los expertos es el mejor ciclo de todos los que grabó... Solamente decirte que faltan la 6 (Sexta) y la 9 (Novena)... espero que te animes y las bajes pronto. Gracias otra vez.
The flavor of the sound (I'm not sure what it exactly is. Timbre? Tone?) at 2:49 is not like any I have heard in other recordings, and I really like it.
Karajan provided the exact tempo indicated by Beethoven. A lot of people think that Beethoven did not use the metronome correctly because it sounds always too fast. The question is: what happens with the slow movements? Should they also be played slower?
![Symphony No. 5 (Karajan) - Ludwig van Beethoven [HD]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/P08rkJ5Ugf0/mqdefault.jpg)
La cinquième la plus énergique, tout en restant parfaitement rigoureuse. Bravo Mister Karajan.
Karajan's rigorous approach suits this symphony very well. I really like this recording, it's the one I treasure in my collection. This is one of the best recordings of this symphony and probably my favourite one - this is how I picture this symphony in my mind.
私はこの演奏が大好きです。他にも素晴らしい演奏はありますが、こんな颯爽した若々しい演奏、聴いてから50年経っても変わりません。
Here in the comments section, There are a lot of people (musicologists, university students, etc...) who come with comments, snobbish, selfish and arrogants, People who seem that it not enough to solve the problems of their lives, and they hide listening to classical music recordings, criticizing other people taste's, acclaiming themselves for having a superior taste, many times criticizing other composers and conductors, when they make a good effort (The perfect is the enemy of the good).
Then there are ordinary people, who are music collectors, or simple listeners who come to have a good time, without claiming superiority, or people who say they like all genres, or who're starting to hear something new, and probalby people who remember hearing said piece in a cartoon, film, or videogame (They can always investigate further if they want).
I don't hate any Composer, (The composers is always right, when it comes to the intepreatation of his works, I think i'm like Karajan or Barenboim in that matter) I am 16 years old, I entered a music school when i was 8 years old, I love the "Academic Genre" , (as i like to call it, apart from "cultured" or "erudite") thanks to TH-cam, i have discovered the greatest recordings and concerts. I listen to different works deppending on the day, or my state, or while i'm reading a book, or researching, but i try to solve my behavior, knowing that these works do not hurt me. I also listen to any artistic genre such as Folk, Blues, Jazz, Rock, etc... because that is Music, an ART FORM (The same things happens to me with books and films) But like many people, I can't go a single day without listening to music.
MUSIC KILLS NOBODY
P. D.: I think Karajan has the same facial expressions as Beethoven in his portraits.
14:34 is one of the most beautiful moments in music history
Die beste aller neun Beethoven-Aufnahmen ! Unerreichbar!
Von Karajan, the king of all the great directors.
Wilhelm Furtwängler is God.
@@sphinxes1104 Yes. Even Karajan "copied" somehow the direction style of Wilhelm Furtwängler, although he gave to to it its distinctive nuances.
A great rendition, the best Karajan, year sixties
Beloved Beethoven with Karajan at the helm... ahhhh
I see karajan I press like
This is a perfect symphony as are most of Beethoven´s!
every one of his symphonies are unique, in their own way.
I grew up listening to his '63 cycle. The 5th was first.
Karaian is the greatest !!
This is the best performance
It's a very powerful song.❤
a mon sens LA meilleure integrale de karajan : puissance et maitrise totale tout en gardant la profondeur du CHANT BEETHOVENIEN!!!!!!!! Immortel comme il le desirait, ne vous y trompez pas je ne suis pas 1 fan absolu de Karajan! mais cette edition Mon Dieu est tout SIMPLEMENT PARFAITE !!!!!!!
22:20. One of the more thrilling IV accounts I’ve ever heard. Gardiner’s 1990s Archiv version shares its spirit, and accelerating tempi...and then some. Get back in line, if this is the wooden rollercoaster one prefers.
"Wooden rollercoaster" that is perfect!
La segunda mejor sinfonía de la historia con el mejor director del siglo XX.
Bueno, Beethoven consideraba a su 3ra Sinfonía "La Heroica" la más importante, pero eso fue antes de la 9na.
gracias Beethoven x existir para siempre!!!
Estimado oppie47, lo primero gracias por compartir estas grabaciones de Beethoven por Karajan... Según dicen los expertos es el mejor ciclo de todos los que grabó... Solamente decirte que faltan la 6 (Sexta) y la 9 (Novena)... espero que te animes y las bajes pronto. Gracias otra vez.
ive got goose bumps
Wonderful music!
THANK YOU!!...
The flavor of the sound (I'm not sure what it exactly is. Timbre? Tone?) at 2:49 is not like any I have heard in other recordings, and I really like it.
4 horns, it makes a difference!
Difficile superare questa esecuzione.
wow
Too good
O Destino bate à porta.
Oboe Solo & Difficult Passage
Allegro con brio
4:16
Andante con moto
12:40
Più moto
15:43
Allegro
24:36
25:08
26:06
27:55
Comentario de esta integral en: th-cam.com/video/k1gYPx--dCk/w-d-xo.html
El maestro, transcribe al maestro
17:20
zde hraje za nastroje
21:39
10:21
Too fast
Karajan provided the exact tempo indicated by Beethoven. A lot of people think that Beethoven did not use the metronome correctly because it sounds always too fast. The question is: what happens with the slow movements? Should they also be played slower?