Deep down piers Morgan agrees with every single thing that Sam Harris has said. That is why he didn't disrupt any moment of sam Harris blunders against muslims.
'Sam Harris, one of the world's great thinkers..."? Piers Morgan _starts_ the show with a lie and Sam Harris _finishes_ with one. Two evil men doing their best work.
Sam Harris only thinks Christianity and Islam are the problem. He never speaks harshly about Judaism because he is a Jew himself. Non practicing, but loyal to his tribe nonetheless. It’s in the interest of Jews like him to slander the goyim. Even as an “atheist” he never rebukes the mainstream views of many in his tribe, ie pro eradication of Hamas regardless of the collateral damage. Not much different than the mindset of jihadis but he won’t speak on it. He’s intellectually dishonest.
A good journalist often makes rhetorical questions even if he knows the answer, not all the audience is familiar with Sam's or any other guest work. It's a pretty good practice.
Nah it's nationalism. Zionism is political movement like hamas or isis. Most zionist are atheist jew like sam harris while more religious jew are supporting palestine. To make the conflict painted as religious conflict is just a cheap zionist trick
Damn. He doesn’t have a brain? The human body sure is incredible. Now I’m starting to wonder how many people I know don’t have brains. What should I look out for?
@JustinYiseverywhere hes just came to a simplistic conclusion on this based on anecdotes. He believes islam is untouchable, while peddling in tropes like 'they just don't care about their kids see, they strap their kids to bombs'. This sort of similar trope with way better connotations say 'they're puppetmasters' is instantly labeled antisemetic and seen a mile away. How is this a double standard where muslims are treated better? They've had 9k kids murdered and a huge % of the world still believes its justified! How is this some religion we somehow can't talk about? This is half of harris's whole career shitting on islam and he still has to mention how you can't even discuss the issue!
The irony of israel ! First ww2 and now this to others since. It makes no sense. I think the true "mensch" among many good jewish people, sees this in more clear light now, and try to seperate jewishness, judism apart from zionist fanatic state financed totaliatarian ideology. Nobody in the western world, can preach to muslim world, before we set a good human standard ourselfes first. Same with ukraine and the US. Israel does the opposite, and running towards the destruction, too proud to realize the tragegy on both sides in creates. its like there is deadline of getting the palenstinians out of Gaza. Netanyahu is clearly a dangerous madman, but he is a product of a sick culture belief, no different than muslim jihad, and remember, he supported the hamas also ! Israel is more corrupted in top than the western media realize, and it connect to the ickness in top of US policy, that always used power and force to enter into many area, where the have no place being in. All US wars have been for control, power and resources. Only ww2 was a war worth fighting against the nazi regime. Else they are holligans and loaters. Ofcourse they did not want russian missiles in Cuba, so how hard is it, for americans and europeans to understand russia dont accept US missiles and nukes in backyard to moscow with fast missile strinking distance. The neocons have been playing dirty pushing this on purpose, and US was pushing the conflick since hostile infiltration of government since 2014. I dont like Putin, but I understand we in west broke the minsk agreement again and again. Ukraine part of EU ??? ursula von dr leyen is not speaking for most of us in EU. She want digital central bank money and health pass and identity, she want EU army she want EU health system..in short she want evetuthing in few hands. dispite what most european people think. ONLY WAY the can force all this is by campaign of fear and crisis. My answer is the same as with turkey. NOOOOO..You must be kidding me..I for one is glad Turkey put its foot down to support and pressure israel away from this the madness genocide. Like Nelson Mandela said...the liberty of south africa is not complete, before the palentian are people free. I though israeli at least were clever people, but now see, they dont think long enough about how thing effect everybody, as they isolated themselfes in the world community. Human rights and decency must come above, all else for there to be solutions all can move towards. The west have shown its leadership mostly has been slow to realize whats right, but now also norway, ireland and spain is accepting Palenstina rights. Israel has shown they are not a democratic society by any standard, and it is no wonder when one listen to the madness many politician and israeli supporters talks of unhuman nonsense.
@GretsGarbo…yep, you’ve got that right. I’m constantly amazed that so many people seemingly love to make it all about Morgan more than any other interviewer. It’s clearly personal
Try listening to what they are actually talking about too - Not always, but many times it's pretty interesting, and you can learn something from it too.
Try to learn some critical thinking and some rules of the discussion. Person, which answers the question, is honest and does not bring some different agenda - is not interrupted. There is no reason. “Whataboutests” have to be interrupted WHEN THEY REFUSE THE ANSWER !!! They change the subject. They answer with their own question, they just start speaking about something else… With Muslims - I would tell them at start - EACH TIME YOU AVOID THE QUESTION, YOU FORCE ME TO TEAR THE PAGE IN KORAN ! That way it would be understandable for people, who do not respect the rules.
“I call it theory-induced blindness: once you have accepted a theory and used it as a tool in your thinking, it is extraordinarily difficult to notice its flaws. If you come upon an observation that does not seem to fit the model, you assume that there must be a perfectly good explanation that you are somehow missing.” ― Daniel Kahneman
Very good, except you're so blind you think it doesn't apply to you. If you truly understand the depths of both sides, you would come out somewhere around where this speaker is.
@@SR-df9jd when you have the Brit’s , French , German and Americans behind you , you know you are in good company. So , the Good Dr. is right and you are wrong .
I used to be impressed by Sam Harris! Hell, he even helped in me leaving Islam. HOWEVER, with age and more nuance acquired, I realized I almost started hating my own people by just listening to Sam Harris even though I could clearly see that they were definitely not what Sam Harris says. The more history I read, the more details I got, the more I could see that the only parts where the muslim world sees extremism and radicalism are the countries where the US, C.I-A have completely infiltrated the opposition. We know now, even Hillary Clinton admitted "We funded the wrong people" as she says. Sam Harris completely ignores that. The decades-long b0mbing of poor african, middle-eastern countries, the funding of T3rror groups. All of that is done by NATO and their Secret services. It's definitely not done by the over 2 Billion muslims around the world. I'm sorry Sam Harris! I can see through you now. You're stupid to not now this. You are just a disingenuous horrible person.
Piers... 1- Do you recongize the IDF as an illegal occupation forces? 2- Do you Condemn IDF's illegal atrocities of the last 70 years? 3- What should be the proportional response of the Palestinians?
Israel has had more than 12 wars thrust upon it from all directions including the sea by Muslim extremists who refuse them the right to exist. Israel has Democracy and Religious freedom but you want Islamic hegemony, tough on you when Israel wins for the xth time.
@TerminalCisternae wrong and wrong Israel started 1948 by taking a land didnt belong to it...Israel definitely started 1956 war and failed to achieve objective, started 1967 (and failed to steal Sinai TWICE), started the 2 Lebanese wars and lost in both and now apparently loosing this one as they failed to defeat Hamas as intended and now only bombing civilians to save face
@@hesha3000 bro live in an alternative reality 🤣🤣 u started 47 and lost ... 67 u started and Israel not only took Sinai! They took the west bank, gaza and Golan hights 🤣🤣 u guys called the first war nakba . And the second one naksa the 67 war took 6 days bro wtf are u talking about ,Israel dominated the air in the first day 💀💀 About Lebanon Israel leveled the south and u think u won 🤣 In Gaza Israel achieved complete military defeat 🤣 u guys were bragging that Israel won't inter on land .. they entered took all gaza and now have only two burgades of humus to deal with 😂
Are U talking about Muslims, if so, I agree. They are psychopath group, they committed the act of evil, than they are turned around claiming the victim role. The idiots buy them.
@@skontheroad He is a Muslim and a proud member of the religion of peace. The only doctors he knows are TNT doctors so he said nothing wrong there. Stop trying to correct everyone gosh!!
CHRISTIANITY AND JUDAISM WARP THE MINDS OF FOLLOWERS... SO WHAT DIFFERENCE? ALL RELIGION IS NUTS ANYWAY SO WHY PICK A SIDE? OH, I KNOW WHY, FAMILIARITY WITH YOUR OWN CULTURE, THAT'S THE ONLY REASON.
I am Muslim but we are more progressive than many atheists, my older brother has worn fishnets under his thobe for about a year and my parents have not said anything. Would you even support such a thing, or would you be too conservative?
@@mmhmm9271its all well and good you and your family let your bother wear leggings when he prays, but you are in the vast vast minority. How would your community feel if they knew? The majority of Muslims would not sanction such behaviour, many would resort to violence. When I meet moderate Muslims, I thank them for their progressiveness and liberal attitude, but I also remind them that they are outnumbered 100 to 1 within their own community. I wish more Muslims were like you, but sadly this is far from the truth. The toughest battle you will have to fight to make your approach mainstream will be other Muslims.
@@downtoearth5443 Not the first time After that over whelming view of that video He had a 2nd interview with him because people can see how he keeps trying to cut his points off.. What planet do you live in buddy? Are you watching the same things we are watching or? 🧠
@@alitharealist4730 Mate, a lot of your Muzzlienm chums won't live with a Jewish state in that region - however small it may be. Cos your lot think ALL of it is Muzlienm land. That is the crux of this conflict. Besides, I LOLed when Bassem held up a map showing all the places in Europe the Jews were expelled from. But conveniently didn't make a mention of any of the countless pogroms perpetrated against the Jews by Muzlienms in the MENA region. Anybody with a quarter of a cerebrum, an iota of common sense and a sliver of basic human decency would know that. Unfortunately, that summarily excludes your ilk 🐵🐵🐵
If you knew what taqqiya is you'd understand why asking muslims if they want or agree with extremist things like honour killings , child marriage , shariah law , islamic world domination , killing apostates its just pointless asking muslims that stuff because they are every rarely truely honest about their religious beliefs and they can often get aggressive over criticisms of their religion
@@Mason-626 Taqqyia is actually a Shiite thing, not a Sunni Muslim thing. Lying is forbidden in Islam. Sam is not a scholar on Islam and seems to have a skewed view of it, while at the same time turns a blind eye to Israel's use of Torah and Talmud to justify atrocities and apartheid.
@@khalidnahar1929 jewish people don't go around doing what muslims do in the west , and no you cannot cherry pick what you follow or what you don't a real muslim does what the quran and the authentic hadiths say , most muslims are good people and are better people than muhammed and they who follow the law of the land over their religion and assimilate well , but there are many muslims who commit or agree with extremist islamic stuff like implementing shariah , jihadi terrorism , child marriage , killing of apostates , islamic world domination , blasphemy laws , stoning adulterers etc all that stuff and they will very oftenly lie about it or they may not answer at all or they will deflect either way its a big problem and its best we deport and halt immigration of muslims temporarily until we get rid of extremist islam , also muslims do forbidden stuff all the time hamas raped women dead and alive and when asked about it the spokeperson or whoever said rape is a sin or forbidden or whatever he said but he can't say that when muhammed raped saphiyya on the same day he slaughtered her husband and she was took as a female captive but muhammed thought she was hot and raped her that night and said marry me or be a sex slave basically so rape is not forbidden in islam and neither is being a pedophile cos mohammed did both of those things
Very peaceful conversation, it was like a bedtime night story. If Piers started doing interviews like this his rating is going to be down to the ground.
@@bassiejazz At least MMA is not a bunch of sophists spreading propaganda and lies. On top of being a bigot, Harris is an unhinged psycholoon who says completely ridiculous things like "If things were different, I would have been right"
In 1977 the ACLU defended freedom of speech for the KKK in Skokie Illinois. The ACLU argued that not allowing them to march in Skokie. The ACLU prevailed on the grounds that to stop them would violate their free speech. "I might hate what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it "
@@richpuzzo953 The First Amendment restrains only the government (federal, state and local), and not private employers, private colleges and private companies. You can not, for example, say whatever you want on social media, and most social media companies regulate the speech of users. There has also always been a debate over the limits of government restraint -see, for example, the Sedition Act of 1798, which outlawed "scandalous" speech against the federal government. Go back to school and get an education, Rich.
I would add that although there can be consequences for freedom of speech. There are many instances where businesses seek to stifle employees from speaking after their relationship with a business is finished. Speech can only be restrained if there's a NDA(non disclosure agreement). As long as it's not unprovably slanderous, you can say whatever you want. You can march through Harlem and yell your dislike for POC and nobody can stop you.
Only to appease supporters or apologists of jihadism who would go nuts if he didn’t use language to at least make them feel that this is a morally equivalent situation. It isn’t. There was a cease fire on October 6th. Radical Islam does not want peace. They are holding hostages and continue to fight. They vow to do it again. They do not want a 2-state solution, they want Israel dead and gone. Tell me how you have peace with a neighbour like that. Israel’s position since its creation has been defensive vigilance. There’s only so many times you can allow someone to threaten you before you become pro-active. The entire world holds Israel to an impossibly high bar and radical Islam to none.
The whole world is watching genocide in its worse form in this very moment and day after day, week after week 24/7. 14000+ dead children and a complete population is starving to death. 1,700.000 displaced. It is ethnic cleansing. Netanyahu and his government, together with supporters, are undoubtedly war criminals.
@@gnlout7403 lol Hamas showed a few guns, a coat and a laptop as evidence for Hamas’s HQ being in a hospital and I’m the one that needs a different information source? 🤣🤣
@@karlali7155 by the way operating out of a hospital isn't exactly the worst example of Behavior being done by these people nor is it the worst example of bad religious ideas.
@@gnlout7403 there’s literally no evidence to back up your delusions though… If there was a HQ in the hospital it would of been easy to prove when Isreal went in there and murders babies and showed no evidence of anything that remotely looks like a HQ.
I’m an ex-muslim living in Egypt near the current events. I say it loud and clear, Sam Harris knows nothing about the muslim world which was pretty tolerant with other beliefs during the European dark ages. Most of my muslim vicinity knows and I am being treated just fine. I know the muslim scripture does have some violent tendencies but so does christianity and Judaism. The way sam harris is only attacking the muslim faith seems pretty unfair to me while the real terrorist in that situation is Israel that was solely based upon a belief system of owning the land.
@@Maximumaneram and here it is … the red herring fallacy…. Misleading and distracting the argument to how bad islam is as a religion (something I definitely agree with) from the palestine situation and sam harris’s double standards leading to an actual genocide
All the pro-palestine people in the comments complaining that piers never interupts him make me sick 🤢 there literally isnt a single word a rational person could fault in this interview, yet you fanatics close your ears before ever listening to reason, you never refute anything, you just whinge piers is biased 😭
Well, I'm a rational person who used to enjoy listening to Sam destroy opponents in atheism v religion debates but now he seems to be specifically targeting Islam even though the Jusaism is being fanatically used to not only condone this war but to justify the existence of the religiously created state of Israel. Kinda double standards Sam! Almost as if you were finding it MORE REWARDING (wink wink) to pick the position you have on the side of the thieving colonial regime...
@ColonialHerstoryOriginal Where? Please link to it if you can. I saw Finkelstein's interview on Piers M, which was factually nearly bankrupt--a long digression about how he regretted a tweet he had made glorifying Oct 7 before he knew the magnitude of the attacks. I'd really like to hear NF try and debate Sam Harris on these issues, not to see SH "win", but to see if he could plant a seed of doubt or reconsideration in NFs brain.
You can easily identify every Muslim in this chat by seeing which ones complain about Piers not interrupting. It's funny because they are so sensitive that they need Piers to interrupt other non-aggressive guests so they feel ok about their religious representatives acting like 10 year old schoolboy bullies on television.
Asking a non Muslim about islam is like asking medicine to a musician. Sam should just stick to what he knows, him saying anything about islam "facts" Are just embarrassing.
Has Sam ever applied the same criticisms to the Israeli leadership? When Bibi quotes the old testament before going on to annihilate a defenceless people, does Sam ever recognise the role of religious fundamentalism on that side? Has he ever mentioned how Palesti nian land has been stolen because of the belief that it was promised to a certain people by God himself? If you're going to criticise the role of religion then at least be consistent. If a Muslim quotes the Quran during war, it will be called Islamic extremism straight away. There wouldn't even be a debate. But the same standard is never applied to the Is rae li leaders.
The difference is that Israel completely withdrew from Gaza almost 2 decades ago and they never showed any signs of ever wanting to go back in. Hamas on the other hand directly attacked Israel even though there had been a ceasefire for a long time. Actions reflect intentions and if Israel isn't even setting foot on Gaza for decades how can anyone credibly argue that Hamas had a plausible reason to attack? This stems back to islamic fundamentalism in that Hamas really does believe in martyrdom and retaking all the land that is Israel today. Israel never tried taking over Gaza, even though they have always had the capabilities of doing so. Granted, any right wing government in any country on earth is problematic in that they will always be driven by excessive tribalism or religious doctrine. But the point people are missing it seems to me, is that Hamas is far to the right of even the most extreme right wing elements of the government in Israel.
No. It’s very worrying indeed that the great Sam Harris has succumb to tribalism to this extreme. I had to unsubscribe, it was just getting harder and harder to listen to. All he has said about altruism morality etc. and he can watch genocide and hasn’t got a word of condemnation. I don’t know what bubble he is living in. Maybe he has no access to the images coming from Gaza. Maybe his you tube algorithm just spits out Douglas Murray and Ben Shapiro. But I always considered sam in a different league to this lot. A rational man who will look at the situation and give an honest answer. He is worse than the worst of the right wing. Ruined his legacy
@@johnkirby9755 Obviously children dying is always a tragedy and awful, but what exactly is Israel supposed to do in response to Hamas when they use children as human shields and fire rockets from civilian areas? That's like an unbeatable cheat code, where your enemy can never fight back because you are willing to sacrifice your own children. It's completely psychotic.
The “Son of Hamas” clip was so forced. He must have been paid to say that. Trying so hard to turn an occupation of Palestinians into an attack on Islam.
Well said Sam, when i was a moslem child i dreamed of becoming a martyr for Palestine and alaqsa shrine . And everyone around me did too. Glad i left that evil cult when i reached the age of reason.
@@gnlout7403 Several of his assertion: 1) that Hamas did it because of religious reason instead of the more obvious answer of resistance against occupation 2) his broad painting of Islamic nations as somehow having having an inherent potential for extremism and jihadist mindset (he's clearly never been to Indonesia), and that somehow aspiring to become a martyr (in the negative sense) is inseparable from Islam's way of being. 3) Saying that UN funded schools are teaching kids to to hate Israel. In order to be able to come to that broad generalization, there would need to be a study to see exactly what curriculum they teach, and how prevalent it is. I have seen videos of schools in Israel that also teach questionable dogmas with regards to Palestinians, but I would not assume it is necessarily prevalent without more data. There are a few others but I can't be arsed to explain it to you without writing a longer essay.
@@ChrisAlbertH47 To your first point, I'd read the 88 charter of Hamas. "Israel exists and will continue to exist until Islam will obliterate it just as it obliterated others before it". And this gem "the end will not come about until Moslems fight Jews and kill them. Then the rocks and trees will cry out o Moslem there is a jew hiding behind me. Come and kill him" That one is from a 1400 year old religious text, a hadith. As far as occupation, Israel pulled every jew out of Gaza in 2005. The Palestinians said thanks by electing a genocidal death cult who has in their Charter an explicit religious text calling for the extermination of the Jews. Then Hamas launched 6000 rockets into Israel. So Israel closed the border. I would have too btw. Secondly, he's not painting a broad brush. He's pointing out that there are bad ideas within this particular religion such as martyrdom which help give rise to bad actions. He didn't even get into some bad ideas like the non consensual relations with slaves that Islam gives the OK for. This is why there were rapes Oct 7th. Except they don't call it that. I can post the words of scholars Shabir Ally or Suad Saleh on this topic, or you can Google it. Or the death penalty for apostasy. Third, yes, children are brainwashed into hating the Jews. I'd look up Farfour the mouse and Tomorrow's Pioneers for one example. Others are easily found with a Google search. 'Hamas summer camp brainwashes Gaza children to hate jews'. On a similar note, you can find mosques in places like England where imams are calling for the death of the Jews and the west in general.
At 11:20, just continued lies. Where is the HQ under the hospital? IDF Headquarters is in Tel Aviv surrounded by millions of civilians - why do you think Hamas launches (unguided) rockets towards Tel Aviv? “Embedded” in civilian populations - what would Sam say about reservists in the civilian population? Are they embedded?
How can you compare a military headquarters in the economic centre of a country to that which is underneath a hospital, which is placed there to maximize civilian human shields?!
This person (maybe a bot) believes a democratic country's military HQ that is clearly demarcated, with guards, fences and patrols is the same thing as a terror group building a bunker under a hospital intentionally, because it is a hospital.
@@jjacobs260 As rational as to go from point A to point B in Hebron by taking 1 hour of walking trip because of some street only reserved for zionist colonizers whereas it could take 10 minutes without the checkpoints.. Try again
I understand why the world is in so much trouble if Sam Harris is considered one of the world's greatest thinkers. In my opinion he act on bias and emotion and then offers "rational" arguments to justify his emotional or biased response.
I don't think it's about his background. He interrupts everybody by default, but makes an exception for those he agrees with as he has nothing to contradict.
According to his atheist moral compass (there is no God), the Jews should not be in that land because there is no such thing as ¨ God gave them the land¨ How can god give them the land if he does not exist ? which begs the question, what other arugment the Jews have to prove that the land is theirs other than the bible He goes on about Islam but he forgot the premise of Isreal is based on the bible if you are an atheist who does not believe in God you sould say, the Jews have right to live in that land becuase there is no God to begin with But you and Sam are puppets to Jews because you would not dare to talk about them
@@chihabahmed5207 that wasn’t his argument, which means you are either too stupid to recognise that, or just like to make assumptions and put words in peoples mouths. Me and Sam are puppets to the Jews and we dare not talk about them? You’re utterly deluded.
Yet he also chooses to ignore the dangers of non-religion and atheism and pretend that Islam is the big bad. Joseph Stalin was an atheist for example and slaughtered millions.
@dougbarker2227 he was and probably is still working for Israel's intelligence. What would you say if it was reported that Sam harris takes money from Israel's intelligence agency(which he doesn't) ? Would you still give his words the same weight? If the mosab dude actually wanted to do something he could have taken some other route like majid nawaz.
He was probably a psycho when he was in khamas, and is still a psycho. Dude could have been another majid nawaz but seemingly he just has too much hate in him.
@@lastshow3425 The dude literally saved thousands of innocent lives-both Palestinian and Israeli-by thwarting suicide bombings and terrorist attacks. Seems like a person with that perspective would be incredibly useful to understand the ideology of a terrorist organization. But yeah you can disregard everything he said because he's "biased".
its a game. they throw whatever dung that can and see what sticks. its an easy game bc much of America is willing to believe anything as long as it confirms their biases.
Nah. As long as what you are saying is legally protected by free speech, it should be allowed to be said online. Everything else (as has been seen over and over before) is a slippery slope.
The point is that Twitter/X is a private company. Our laws don’t apply. It’s not a public square - it is a privately owned company and they have a moral obligation to not condone terrorism, hatred, etc etc… just as Harvard does.
@@Hexadeci Terrorism is a crime, no need for additional restrictions. Sure enough, there will be some gray areas. But I'd rather have gray and occasional transgressions than authoritarians or moral busybodies dictating additional "rules".
Saying racial slurs isn't illegal, but have fun trying to find many businesses who want to pay you to do so and put their products next to that. The social media platforms that respond to the market and listen to advertisers will be successful and out compete platforms that refuse to regulate their content.
@@jasminbegum3335Wrong. Islam grows mostly through high birthrates. Pentecostal Christianity, attracts proportionally more converts than Islam each year, just as a single example.
@@logiic8835 Sure. Google the Pew study called 'the changing global religious landscape'. That shows that most growth in religions is due to birthrates and that Muslims are out-reproducing Christians by a large margin. Then Google 'Massive Growth under the Radar' by the Pulitzer Centre, which includes the quote "Pentecostalism is the fastest growing religion in the world". These are just examples. The other issue is that a lot of people fake convert to Islam to get married. I know several people who have done this. Others religions are not so closed these days... Want to marry a Buddhist, you don't need to become a Buddhist
So you are ok with civilian casualties? 15000 children?? Why has Israel stopped aid truck? Aid won't help hamas? And why is Israel killing in west bank without Hamas?
You are reading too much into it. Piers only starts acting up if he feels you are criticizing him. Piers did not interrupt Hasan Piker or Norm Finkelstein because they never hurt his delicate feelings. The second an Israeli official insults Piers, piers will go berserk.
Sam, the same could be said about Zionists. Son of Hamas has accepted that he is an asset, and he answers to his handler. Which I find strange that he doesn't mind being referred to as an asset!
Sam Harris, have you actually met a Muslim and conversed with them? Please go ahead and do that. Please do not dehumanize Muslims as extremists, they cannot be homogenized and labeled. Rather than dehumanizing lets try to reach out to Muslims and learn about their diverse beautiful cultures and ideals
Incredibly accurate description of the state of the Muslim world. I can agree with Sam Harris' view, having grown up in a predominantly Muslim community. We are dealing with a suicidal cult, in which billions of people fervently believe that death is beautiful than life.
It's incredible how Indian BJP bots just lie through their teeth and spread their propaganda. It is clear that you are from India and did not really grow up in a predominantly Muslim community. Your bigotry is showing. GTFO with your bs propaganda.
It's really sad to see someone who is considered one of the great thinkers in our times adopt such a superficial approach whenever it comes to something related to Islam or Muslims.
Its accurate. Compare jewish communities with muslim communities in every other country in the world and tell me which assimilate better and which commit crimes and terror attacks? How is it, no matter what continent, muslims always are somehow “discriminated” against, provoked, etc yet Jews simply live within their own community and dont bother anyone.
Only Islam can n will pull the world out of it inshallah stripe clubs n gambling places will shut down so men can take the money they earn to their wives n kids. banks will be forced to change their behavior they can make profit but the can’t squeeze the people. Like bank can buy car from the maker for 14k n sell to you for 20k for what ever period you 2 agree on NOT Penny of usury added. If you are earning money when year goes by you pay only 2% of all you have as taxes n keep the rest to take care of you needing brother or neighbor or cousin.
I feel sam says a lot of generalisation here. I’m not a Muslims but I’ve visited a few Muslim countries and I don’t think they are how he described them. I definitely don’t think the people of Gaza deserve the death penalty even if they have supported terrible leadership.
He made strong points against all religions (Islam more than others), then he was objective enough to separate the geopolitical aspect. And his opinion never changed, Israel is the colonial oppressor and the Palestinians have every right to defend their land in every way possible
"We can only imagine what Hitchens would have said on this topic" It would've been basically the same since Harris and Hitchens were both staunch defenders of Israel. But there's one big thing they wouldn't have seen eye to eye on, and that's Harris supporting the "race and IQ" theory, which has long been debunked. Harris never even entertained the idea of having experts with different opinions on his podcast. Unlike Harris, Hitchens openly opposed this idea and was proud to be the first to do so. So it's clear that they're not two of a kind. It's a shame that Hitchens isn't here with us anymore, especially when Harris is still pushing the 'race and IQ' notion.
@@NomadFlowHitchens didn’t support Zionism though and saw Palestinians as oppressed. He said Israel had a right to exist but not continue to colonize others’ land
In 1906 a black man was kept in a zoo in the Bronx. In 1919 women had no vote in the UK. And in 1989 an English historian told his six year old son that this was the most amazing year he would live through as one communist regime after another fell to have totalitarianism substututed by liberal democracy. Please, Mr Harris, don't lose sight of these fabulous recent advances when you despair of similar alterations towards liberal thinking in Muslim communities.
Isn’t the whole concept of Israel religion driven!? The main difference between IDF & Hamas is that one is much more powerful. To be fair, I find Judaism and Islam the most similar religions out there.
Sam & his ilk justify Israels existence due to religion/the bible (while being atheists), also while pontificating that the other side is bad because of their religion. He gets an A* for outrageous hypocrisy.
@@AvidDocumentary Zyansts refer to their religion all the time as justification of their conquering Palestine...Sam has not condemned this . Also Christian Evangelists support the Zyanyst state because they think their god will reward them for protecting the Jews. Sam is an atheist but still he does not condemn or even mention this religious foundation and ongoing support of this colonial settler apartheid entity illegally usurping ancestral land from the Palestinians as well as completely ruining millions of lives in the process.
I like how this is titled "Piers Morgan vs Sam Harris" when they dont seem to disagree on anything
Deep down piers Morgan agrees with every single thing that Sam Harris has said. That is why he didn't disrupt any moment of sam Harris blunders against muslims.
'Sam Harris, one of the world's great thinkers..."?
Piers Morgan _starts_ the show with a lie and Sam Harris _finishes_ with one. Two evil men doing their best work.
@@undercoveragent9889 I think you have worms in your brain.
@@undercoveragent9889 Why are they evil? I think Islam is inherently evil.
@@alqaas1948 It's facts. Deal with it.
I laughed out loud when Piers asked if Sam agreed that religion was part of the problem. Sam has been talking about this for like... 20 years?
Sam Harris only thinks Christianity and Islam are the problem. He never speaks harshly about Judaism because he is a Jew himself. Non practicing, but loyal to his tribe nonetheless. It’s in the interest of Jews like him to slander the goyim. Even as an “atheist” he never rebukes the mainstream views of many in his tribe, ie pro eradication of Hamas regardless of the collateral damage. Not much different than the mindset of jihadis but he won’t speak on it. He’s intellectually dishonest.
A good journalist often makes rhetorical questions even if he knows the answer, not all the audience is familiar with Sam's or any other guest work. It's a pretty good practice.
Nah it's nationalism. Zionism is political movement like hamas or isis. Most zionist are atheist jew like sam harris while more religious jew are supporting palestine.
To make the conflict painted as religious conflict is just a cheap zionist trick
Yes. This time Sam got strongest evidences to support his position.
@@gabrielegagliardi3956 sam is a weasel
A wise man said: you can't convince a stupid person that he is not a thinker!!
So true
😂😂😂to call this guy a person with a brain is absurd let alone a "thinker"😂
The only place for people like him is in echo chambers like Bill Mahers show.
Damn. He doesn’t have a brain? The human body sure is incredible. Now I’m starting to wonder how many people I know don’t have brains. What should I look out for?
How can anyone be considered a thinker if they do not believe in God. Makes zero sense
@JustinYiseverywhere hes just came to a simplistic conclusion on this based on anecdotes. He believes islam is untouchable, while peddling in tropes like 'they just don't care about their kids see, they strap their kids to bombs'. This sort of similar trope with way better connotations say 'they're puppetmasters' is instantly labeled antisemetic and seen a mile away. How is this a double standard where muslims are treated better? They've had 9k kids murdered and a huge % of the world still believes its justified! How is this some religion we somehow can't talk about? This is half of harris's whole career shitting on islam and he still has to mention how you can't even discuss the issue!
‘We are dealing with a suicidal death cult’
The irony of israel ! First ww2 and now this to others since. It makes no sense.
I think the true "mensch" among many good jewish people,
sees this in more clear light now, and try to seperate jewishness, judism apart from zionist fanatic
state financed totaliatarian ideology. Nobody in the western world, can preach to muslim world, before we
set a good human standard ourselfes first. Same with ukraine and the US.
Israel does the opposite, and running towards the destruction, too proud to realize the tragegy on both sides in creates.
its like there is deadline of getting the palenstinians out of Gaza. Netanyahu is clearly a dangerous madman,
but he is a product of a sick culture belief, no different than muslim jihad, and remember, he supported the hamas also !
Israel is more corrupted in top than the western media realize, and it connect to the ickness in top of US policy,
that always used power and force to enter into many area, where the have no place being in.
All US wars have been for control, power and resources. Only ww2 was a war worth fighting against the nazi regime.
Else they are holligans and loaters. Ofcourse they did not want russian missiles in Cuba, so how hard is it, for
americans and europeans to understand russia dont accept US missiles and nukes in backyard to moscow with fast missile strinking distance. The neocons have been playing dirty pushing this on purpose, and US was pushing the conflick since hostile infiltration of government since 2014. I dont like Putin, but I understand we in west broke the minsk agreement again and again.
Ukraine part of EU ??? ursula von dr leyen is not speaking for most of us in EU. She want digital central bank money and health pass and identity, she want EU army she want EU health system..in short she want evetuthing in few hands. dispite what most european people think. ONLY WAY the can force all this is by campaign of fear and crisis.
My answer is the same as with turkey. NOOOOO..You must be kidding me..I for one is glad Turkey
put its foot down to support and pressure israel away from this the madness genocide.
Like Nelson Mandela said...the liberty of south africa is not complete,
before the palentian are people free. I though israeli at least were clever people, but
now see, they dont think long enough about how thing effect everybody,
as they isolated themselfes in the world community. Human rights and decency must come above,
all else for there to be solutions all can move towards.
The west have shown its leadership mostly has been slow to realize whats right, but now also norway,
ireland and spain is accepting Palenstina rights.
Israel has shown they are not a democratic society by any standard, and it is no wonder when one listen to the madness
many politician and israeli supporters talks of unhuman nonsense.
They don't stand for the Muslim Community fam
@@abdullahagboola-f9fWhy should they stand for terrorists?
@@abdullahagboola-f9f The vast majority of Muslims supported October 7th, everything they did was sanctioned in the Koran.
if piers morgan tell me that the sky is blue, imma go outside and look again
😂 solid
me too 😂
😂😂😂😂
Yeah, but do you condemn the clouds if it's overcast?
@GretsGarbo…yep, you’ve got that right. I’m constantly amazed that so many people seemingly love to make it all about Morgan more than any other interviewer. It’s clearly personal
Wow, you turned the title from Israel vs. Hamas to Israel vs. Palestine
It's because the first few comment posts are bots...clearly. Such an effort means that this promotion of AMS39K is a corporatist, authoritarian ploy.
It's Israel vs the world, nobody believes that Israel is the victim
Much the same l think
Well if u have read the Quran u would know that it teaches Muslims to hate the jews so in fact this is a religious war.
@@01karmacop no dawg
I just came to see if there was any interruptions and to my surprise Piers was so calm and relaxed😂
This is because he was listening to an existing ideology that the West does not understand. A threat to Western civilization.
Try listening to what they are actually talking about too - Not always, but many times it's pretty interesting, and you can learn something from it too.
Because Sam Harris talks the truth
Try to learn some critical thinking and some rules of the discussion.
Person, which answers the question, is honest and does not bring some different agenda - is not interrupted.
There is no reason.
“Whataboutests” have to be interrupted WHEN THEY REFUSE THE ANSWER !!!
They change the subject. They answer with their own question, they just start speaking about something else…
With Muslims - I would tell them at start - EACH TIME YOU AVOID THE QUESTION, YOU FORCE ME TO TEAR THE PAGE IN KORAN !
That way it would be understandable for people, who do not respect the rules.
@@NLF123 well to be fair both sides should be heard without interruptions and I guess audience are very wise and clever enough to decide the truth
Always good to hear from Ben Stiller!
all that was missing was a look of "blue steel" directly into the camera after Piers thanked him for coming on
nice haha
People have been saying the Ben stiller joke for years. It’s getting old.
@@magoelise Mimimimi
Lol. Sadly, he'd probably have a better take. Harris isn't the greatest thinker in this interview.
“I call it theory-induced blindness: once you have accepted a theory and used it as a tool in your thinking, it is extraordinarily difficult to notice its flaws. If you come upon an observation that does not seem to fit the model, you assume that there must be a perfectly good explanation that you are somehow missing.”
― Daniel Kahneman
Very good, except you're so blind you think it doesn't apply to you. If you truly understand the depths of both sides, you would come out somewhere around where this speaker is.
The best thing I read all week. Self awareness trumps intelligence.
@@ryanlevin6348keep telling yourself that. Mr.Levine. is that a khamas last nameby any chance!
@@SR-df9jd when you have the Brit’s , French , German and Americans behind you , you know you are in good company. So , the Good Dr. is right and you are wrong .
Harris is a quack. Very poor scholarship or science !
This video doesn’t deserve “vs” in the title given the lack of any substantive pushback.
I’ve only listen to Sam a few times but I really respect how clear and concise he is . He really does bring much needed clarity.
with lies and with information with no primary source ! he is a joke.
@@mohamedmdaini8143 nah ,
@@deathRampage-k5y yeaaah
Just saw Yasmine Mohammed and Sam Harris talk about these topics for a few hours, both of them very good to listen to. Thanks for the video.
I used to be impressed by Sam Harris! Hell, he even helped in me leaving Islam. HOWEVER, with age and more nuance acquired, I realized I almost started hating my own people by just listening to Sam Harris even though I could clearly see that they were definitely not what Sam Harris says. The more history I read, the more details I got, the more I could see that the only parts where the muslim world sees extremism and radicalism are the countries where the US, C.I-A have completely infiltrated the opposition. We know now, even Hillary Clinton admitted "We funded the wrong people" as she says. Sam Harris completely ignores that. The decades-long b0mbing of poor african, middle-eastern countries, the funding of T3rror groups. All of that is done by NATO and their Secret services. It's definitely not done by the over 2 Billion muslims around the world.
I'm sorry Sam Harris! I can see through you now. You're stupid to not now this. You are just a disingenuous horrible person.
Both are morons
They clearly don't know Alex Jones..the dude 100% believed what he was saying
Piers...
1- Do you recongize the IDF as an illegal occupation forces?
2- Do you Condemn IDF's illegal atrocities of the last 70 years?
3- What should be the proportional response of the Palestinians?
Israel has had more than 12 wars thrust upon it from all directions including the sea by Muslim extremists who refuse them the right to exist. Israel has Democracy and Religious freedom but you want Islamic hegemony, tough on you when Israel wins for the xth time.
Nonsense
All the questions are fake
Simple answer is all thous years u were the ones starting wars, losing them then cry about that 😂
@TerminalCisternae
wrong and wrong
Israel started 1948 by taking a land didnt belong to it...Israel definitely started 1956 war and failed to achieve objective, started 1967 (and failed to steal Sinai TWICE), started the 2 Lebanese wars and lost in both and now apparently loosing this one as they failed to defeat Hamas as intended and now only bombing civilians to save face
@@hesha3000 bro live in an alternative reality 🤣🤣 u started 47 and lost ... 67 u started and Israel not only took Sinai! They took the west bank, gaza and Golan hights 🤣🤣 u guys called the first war nakba . And the second one naksa the 67 war took 6 days bro wtf are u talking about ,Israel dominated the air in the first day 💀💀
About Lebanon Israel leveled the south and u think u won 🤣
In Gaza Israel achieved complete military defeat 🤣 u guys were bragging that Israel won't inter on land .. they entered took all gaza and now have only two burgades of humus to deal with 😂
I love people's excuses for abusing other people's rights they use the law all the time to do that
Are U talking about Muslims, if so, I agree. They are psychopath group, they committed the act of evil, than they are turned around claiming the victim role. The idiots buy them.
Gen0cide is fine??? Fake intelligence and morals.
The guy is paid by IDF.
Muslim religion is one of the worst but IDF is worst.
Yep, just like Takfir and Islam.
@@dagttvWhat is takfir?
Sam Harris has got it right ✅️
Somehow I heard Piers call Sam a thinker!! I must go to a TNT doctor to check my ears.
Lol! ENT (Ear, nose and throat).
Something tells me you don't like his thoughts..
@@skontheroad He is a Muslim and a proud member of the religion of peace. The only doctors he knows are TNT doctors so he said nothing wrong there. Stop trying to correct everyone gosh!!
😅
Not all doctors are thinkers for sure. (They may have the gift of "rote learner" ability and that's all).
Sam Harris is the voice of reason. He is so correct on Islam and how it warps the minds of Muslims.
CHRISTIANITY AND JUDAISM WARP THE MINDS OF FOLLOWERS... SO WHAT DIFFERENCE? ALL RELIGION IS NUTS ANYWAY SO WHY PICK A SIDE? OH, I KNOW WHY, FAMILIARITY WITH YOUR OWN CULTURE, THAT'S THE ONLY REASON.
I am Muslim but we are more progressive than many atheists, my older brother has worn fishnets under his thobe for about a year and my parents have not said anything. Would you even support such a thing, or would you be too conservative?
You misspelled voice of treason.
@@mmhmm9271its all well and good you and your family let your bother wear leggings when he prays, but you are in the vast vast minority. How would your community feel if they knew? The majority of Muslims would not sanction such behaviour, many would resort to violence. When I meet moderate Muslims, I thank them for their progressiveness and liberal attitude, but I also remind them that they are outnumbered 100 to 1 within their own community. I wish more Muslims were like you, but sadly this is far from the truth. The toughest battle you will have to fight to make your approach mainstream will be other Muslims.
_"It’s okay if Palestinians get deleted because we don't know which of them are armed resistance."_ - Sam Harris
Voice of reason indeed...
Wow Piers really listened to this guy. No interuptions 😅
He also listened to Bassem Youssef's non stop blather. What's your point, Mehdi.... Your side is losing the war 🤣🤣🤣
@@downtoearth5443 mudering children is not something to laugh at, you psychopath
@@downtoearth5443it's not a game ffs
@@downtoearth5443 Not the first time After that over whelming view of that video He had a 2nd interview with him because people can see how he keeps trying to cut his points off.. What planet do you live in buddy? Are you watching the same things we are watching or? 🧠
@@alitharealist4730 Mate, a lot of your Muzzlienm chums won't live with a Jewish state in that region - however small it may be. Cos your lot think ALL of it is Muzlienm land. That is the crux of this conflict.
Besides, I LOLed when Bassem held up a map showing all the places in Europe the Jews were expelled from. But conveniently didn't make a mention of any of the countless pogroms perpetrated against the Jews by Muzlienms in the MENA region. Anybody with a quarter of a cerebrum, an iota of common sense and a sliver of basic human decency would know that. Unfortunately, that summarily excludes your ilk 🐵🐵🐵
It’s a universal truth that wherever Islam goes, pain and suffering soon follow!
I think that’s USA
The title on the screen "Is Piers a free speech hypocrite?" 💀💀💀
*"You're one of the good ones Piers"*
Thank you for this.
Sam has been talking about these topics since he wrote the End of Faith years ago. Nothing has changed.
He's like a broken clock and just as incorrect with his assessments of Alex Jones and 4chingle. 😂😂😂
@@R14-m4zincorrect how?
And he is still not wrong
@@elmango705 His assessment of the Middle East is extremely shallow and unsophisticated and always has been
@@whatsthatnoise5955 Could you please elaborate on this?
These are the guests you should be giving a platform to not Islamist hatemongers.
I wonder if Sam Harris have ever been to a muslim country and talked with the normal people on the streets. I bet he never did.
If you knew what taqqiya is you'd understand why asking muslims if they want or agree with extremist things like honour killings , child marriage , shariah law , islamic world domination , killing apostates its just pointless asking muslims that stuff because they are every rarely truely honest about their religious beliefs and they can often get aggressive over criticisms of their religion
@@Mason-626 Taqqyia is actually a Shiite thing, not a Sunni Muslim thing. Lying is forbidden in Islam. Sam is not a scholar on Islam and seems to have a skewed view of it, while at the same time turns a blind eye to Israel's use of Torah and Talmud to justify atrocities and apartheid.
@@khalidnahar1929 jewish people don't go around doing what muslims do in the west , and no you cannot cherry pick what you follow or what you don't a real muslim does what the quran and the authentic hadiths say , most muslims are good people and are better people than muhammed and they who follow the law of the land over their religion and assimilate well , but there are many muslims who commit or agree with extremist islamic stuff like implementing shariah , jihadi terrorism , child marriage , killing of apostates , islamic world domination , blasphemy laws , stoning adulterers etc all that stuff and they will very oftenly lie about it or they may not answer at all or they will deflect either way its a big problem and its best we deport and halt immigration of muslims temporarily until we get rid of extremist islam , also muslims do forbidden stuff all the time hamas raped women dead and alive and when asked about it the spokeperson or whoever said rape is a sin or forbidden or whatever he said but he can't say that when muhammed raped saphiyya on the same day he slaughtered her husband and she was took as a female captive but muhammed thought she was hot and raped her that night and said marry me or be a sex slave basically so rape is not forbidden in islam and neither is being a pedophile cos mohammed did both of those things
@khalidnahar1929 you just used taqqiya abdul 😂
@@khalidnahar1929 No it is not. I am sunni and it is not a Shiite thing. Lol.
Piers is loving this
Attention whores love attention
💰
me too cuz it's true
Thank you for bringing Sam on to speak about this. He is truly the voice of reason we all need to hear.
Very peaceful conversation, it was like a bedtime night story.
If Piers started doing interviews like this his rating is going to be down to the ground.
Go watch Female MMA if you want to get excited. Sorry that intellectual conversations don't do that for you.
@@bassiejazz At least MMA is not a bunch of sophists spreading propaganda and lies.
On top of being a bigot, Harris is an unhinged psycholoon who says completely ridiculous things like "If things were different, I would have been right"
@@bassiejazz LOL....well said
In 1977 the ACLU defended freedom of speech for the KKK in Skokie Illinois. The ACLU argued that not allowing them to march in Skokie. The ACLU prevailed on the grounds that to stop them would violate their free speech. "I might hate what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it "
This is just idiotic. There is no value to society by letting people say whatever they want wherever they want to say it. None, zero.
It's called freedom of speech. If you don't like it,then leave. It's been around since 1789. If you're not from the USA,then don't come here.
@@richpuzzo953 The First Amendment restrains only the government (federal, state and local), and not private employers, private colleges and private companies. You can not, for example, say whatever you want on social media, and most social media companies regulate the speech of users. There has also always been a debate over the limits of government restraint -see, for example, the Sedition Act of 1798, which outlawed "scandalous" speech against the federal government.
Go back to school and get an education, Rich.
I would add that although there can be consequences for freedom of speech. There are many instances where businesses seek to stifle employees from speaking after their relationship with a business is finished. Speech can only be restrained if there's a NDA(non disclosure agreement). As long as it's not unprovably slanderous, you can say whatever you want. You can march through Harlem and yell your dislike for POC and nobody can stop you.
@@themaskedman221I am astounded at how un-American this take is.
This is the first time I hear Piers mention "genocidal war" as an aim of "some members of Netanyahu's cabinet".
Keep crying
Yes up till now it has only Hamas that is genocidal apparently.
Only to appease supporters or apologists of jihadism who would go nuts if he didn’t use language to at least make them feel that this is a morally equivalent situation. It isn’t. There was a cease fire on October 6th. Radical Islam does not want peace. They are holding hostages and continue to fight. They vow to do it again. They do not want a 2-state solution, they want Israel dead and gone.
Tell me how you have peace with a neighbour like that. Israel’s position since its creation has been defensive vigilance. There’s only so many times you can allow someone to threaten you before you become pro-active. The entire world holds Israel to an impossibly high bar and radical Islam to none.
Not apparently
It's Fact
The whole world is watching genocide in its worse form in this very moment and day after day, week after week 24/7. 14000+ dead children and a complete population is starving to death. 1,700.000 displaced. It is ethnic cleansing. Netanyahu and his government, together with supporters, are undoubtedly war criminals.
Respect to Sam Harris, one of the few people out there who understands Islam for what it is
He doesn't even understand a bit. He's just an Islam hater.
It's a death cult built on misunderstandings of Judaism and Christianity, mixed with paganism.
First time I agree wholeheartedly with Piers. His take on Alex Jones at the beginning is SPOT ON.
Critical thinker - “Hamas HQ is under a hospital”
Israel - “we’re changing it from the HQ to an outpost due to lack of evidence”
You should use Google. And change your information source
@@gnlout7403 lol Hamas showed a few guns, a coat and a laptop as evidence for Hamas’s HQ being in a hospital and I’m the one that needs a different information source? 🤣🤣
@@karlali7155 yes. If you think Hamas is not operating out of hospitals you are not paying attention.
@@karlali7155 by the way operating out of a hospital isn't exactly the worst example of Behavior being done by these people nor is it the worst example of bad religious ideas.
@@gnlout7403 there’s literally no evidence to back up your delusions though… If there was a HQ in the hospital it would of been easy to prove when Isreal went in there and murders babies and showed no evidence of anything that remotely looks like a HQ.
I’m an ex-muslim living in Egypt near the current events. I say it loud and clear, Sam Harris knows nothing about the muslim world which was pretty tolerant with other beliefs during the European dark ages. Most of my muslim vicinity knows and I am being treated just fine. I know the muslim scripture does have some violent tendencies but so does christianity and Judaism. The way sam harris is only attacking the muslim faith seems pretty unfair to me while the real terrorist in that situation is Israel that was solely based upon a belief system of owning the land.
When it comes to Islam, Sam Harris is just a mindless propagandist.
Ignorant!
He is just telling his audince, "guys calm down, they are bad people, dont feel bad about what is going to happen in next 8 month".
@@Maximumaneram I can sense a logical fallacy in your next reply but the answer is NO I have never been to Iran
@@Maximumaneram and here it is … the red herring fallacy…. Misleading and distracting the argument to how bad islam is as a religion (something I definitely agree with) from the palestine situation and sam harris’s double standards leading to an actual genocide
All the pro-palestine people in the comments complaining that piers never interupts him make me sick 🤢 there literally isnt a single word a rational person could fault in this interview, yet you fanatics close your ears before ever listening to reason, you never refute anything, you just whinge piers is biased 😭
Well, I'm a rational person who used to enjoy listening to Sam destroy opponents in atheism v religion debates but now he seems to be specifically targeting Islam even though the Jusaism is being fanatically used to not only condone this war but to justify the existence of the religiously created state of Israel. Kinda double standards Sam! Almost as if you were finding it MORE REWARDING (wink wink) to pick the position you have on the side of the thieving colonial regime...
@@myblighters to his credit, Harris did criticize Jewish extremists (settlers) in the West Bank.
Norman finklestein does a brilliant take down of this interview.
He's a jihadist apologist
@ColonialHerstoryOriginal
Where? Please link to it if you can. I saw Finkelstein's interview on Piers M, which was factually nearly bankrupt--a long digression about how he regretted a tweet he had made glorifying Oct 7 before he knew the magnitude of the attacks. I'd really like to hear NF try and debate Sam Harris on these issues, not to see SH "win", but to see if he could plant a seed of doubt or reconsideration in NFs brain.
NF doesn't have a brain to plant anyng in
@@alexbrown200 that's cute. One of the most renowned political scientists in America is brain dead. Do better
@@ColonialHerstoryOriginal So Renowned he isn't cited anywhere and did not get tenure anywhere... Next joke please....
You can easily identify every Muslim in this chat by seeing which ones complain about Piers not interrupting. It's funny because they are so sensitive that they need Piers to interrupt other non-aggressive guests so they feel ok about their religious representatives acting like 10 year old schoolboy bullies on television.
Muhammadans are such crybabies.
I always read the comments before embarking on a Pears Mormon video, to see if it's worth taking 10-15 mins from my life...I'll give this one a miss!
You should listen and learn
Such a bad way of thinking.
@@gnlout7403 What would they learn?
@@jmc5335 that Sam is correct in his criticism of fundamentalist Islam.
Do you disagree with anything factual that he said?
@@gnlout7403 I don't see child suicide bombers from many Muslim cultures. Maybe because that would be haram
Sam is great. It's encouraging to see a sane thinker once in a while.
We need more men like Mosab and Sam in this world. 💕🇮🇱🗽
No this guy is an ignorant chauvinist.
Well done Sam. Thank you from Israel.
All the educated Muslims commenting here and exposing their radical views and proving Sam Harris right!
Asking a non Muslim about islam is like asking medicine to a musician. Sam should just stick to what he knows, him saying anything about islam "facts" Are just embarrassing.
In fact only people with sense can see what stupid things your Islam says😂only people like you islamists can understand it.
Here comes the "free palestine" comments from ahmed, muhhamad, hussein and abdullah in 3...2...1...
so what ?
OP thinks the Israeli Diaper Force are great 🤣
Yes I will tell,freedom for Palestine
And me. Non-Muslim Christian. I have no idea what this thinker is talking about.
as you are uninformed@@opa8928
Sam keeps it real. When they say we love death more than Jews love life……. BELIEVE THEM!
They actually don't! that's wrong
@@tareksadmi7153 they actually do. Any religion where you think you get 72 virgins, is delusional.
@@tareksadmi7153 sorry it’s not wrong, you just don’t want it to be right. Keep hoping, wishing and “praying” see where that gets you.
@@Repackrider84 I’m no longer Muslim but I grew up around Muslims and I know Muslims and I’ve known Muslims all my life. That’s wrong.
@@tareksadmi7153 so you grew up in Iran, Pakistan, Sudan, Afghanistan, Gaza, Yemen, Saudi Arabia or Bangladesh under Sharia Law?
Has Sam ever applied the same criticisms to the Israeli leadership? When Bibi quotes the old testament before going on to annihilate a defenceless people, does Sam ever recognise the role of religious fundamentalism on that side? Has he ever mentioned how Palesti nian land has been stolen because of the belief that it was promised to a certain people by God himself? If you're going to criticise the role of religion then at least be consistent. If a Muslim quotes the Quran during war, it will be called Islamic extremism straight away. There wouldn't even be a debate. But the same standard is never applied to the Is rae li leaders.
Sam is part of the (((tribe))), of course he isn't going to criticize Israel.
The difference is that Israel completely withdrew from Gaza almost 2 decades ago and they never showed any signs of ever wanting to go back in. Hamas on the other hand directly attacked Israel even though there had been a ceasefire for a long time.
Actions reflect intentions and if Israel isn't even setting foot on Gaza for decades how can anyone credibly argue that Hamas had a plausible reason to attack? This stems back to islamic fundamentalism in that Hamas really does believe in martyrdom and retaking all the land that is Israel today.
Israel never tried taking over Gaza, even though they have always had the capabilities of doing so. Granted, any right wing government in any country on earth is problematic in that they will always be driven by excessive tribalism or religious doctrine. But the point people are missing it seems to me, is that Hamas is far to the right of even the most extreme right wing elements of the government in Israel.
No. It’s very worrying indeed that the great Sam Harris has succumb to tribalism to this extreme. I had to unsubscribe, it was just getting harder and harder to listen to. All he has said about altruism morality etc. and he can watch genocide and hasn’t got a word of condemnation. I don’t know what bubble he is living in. Maybe he has no access to the images coming from Gaza. Maybe his you tube algorithm just spits out Douglas Murray and Ben Shapiro. But I always considered sam in a different league to this lot. A rational man who will look at the situation and give an honest answer. He is worse than the worst of the right wing. Ruined his legacy
@@johnkirby9755 Obviously children dying is always a tragedy and awful, but what exactly is Israel supposed to do in response to Hamas when they use children as human shields and fire rockets from civilian areas?
That's like an unbeatable cheat code, where your enemy can never fight back because you are willing to sacrifice your own children. It's completely psychotic.
@@LonexX18 THICKY!
The fact that Sam Harris considers himself to be a philosopher is hilarious 😂
The fact you think you can say or recognise who is or not is more hilarious
Good that you're easily amused, mate.
The fact that he’s called that by others has flown over your head. He’s one of our contemporary top 10 intellectuals, whether you like it or not.
@@matsbjur2535 I meet more intelligent people than him walking into Gregg's on a Saturday morning
I genuinely don't think he can be qualified as an intellectual. I think he seems to be quite short sighted and "tainted" when it comes to the Islam.
"one of the world's great thinkers"
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
The “Son of Hamas” clip was so forced. He must have been paid to say that. Trying so hard to turn an occupation of Palestinians into an attack on Islam.
100% true, thank you Sam Harris for having the courage to speak it
Well said Sam, when i was a moslem child i dreamed of becoming a martyr for Palestine and alaqsa shrine . And everyone around me did too. Glad i left that evil cult when i reached the age of reason.
Wow! I can’t say I know much, but you are a brave man. Sincerely, all the best to you. 👍🏻
Honestly people who say moselm they were never a muslim.
Sam Harris is a great thinker, well done. Fantastic interview
He occasionally is. Not this time. His inherent bias made him intellectually lazy whenever the issue of religion (especially Islam) comes up.
@@ChrisAlbertH47what did he say that was factually incorrect?
@@gnlout7403 Several of his assertion:
1) that Hamas did it because of religious reason instead of the more obvious answer of resistance against occupation
2) his broad painting of Islamic nations as somehow having having an inherent potential for extremism and jihadist mindset (he's clearly never been to Indonesia), and that somehow aspiring to become a martyr (in the negative sense) is inseparable from Islam's way of being.
3) Saying that UN funded schools are teaching kids to to hate Israel. In order to be able to come to that broad generalization, there would need to be a study to see exactly what curriculum they teach, and how prevalent it is.
I have seen videos of schools in Israel that also teach questionable dogmas with regards to Palestinians, but I would not assume it is necessarily prevalent without more data.
There are a few others but I can't be arsed to explain it to you without writing a longer essay.
@@ChrisAlbertH47 To your first point, I'd read the 88 charter of Hamas. "Israel exists and will continue to exist until Islam will obliterate it just as it obliterated others before it".
And this gem "the end will not come about until Moslems fight Jews and kill them. Then the rocks and trees will cry out o Moslem there is a jew hiding behind me. Come and kill him"
That one is from a 1400 year old religious text, a hadith.
As far as occupation, Israel pulled every jew out of Gaza in 2005. The Palestinians said thanks by electing a genocidal death cult who has in their Charter an explicit religious text calling for the extermination of the Jews. Then Hamas launched 6000 rockets into Israel. So Israel closed the border. I would have too btw.
Secondly, he's not painting a broad brush. He's pointing out that there are bad ideas within this particular religion such as martyrdom which help give rise to bad actions. He didn't even get into some bad ideas like the non consensual relations with slaves that Islam gives the OK for. This is why there were rapes Oct 7th. Except they don't call it that. I can post the words of scholars Shabir Ally or Suad Saleh on this topic, or you can Google it. Or the death penalty for apostasy.
Third, yes, children are brainwashed into hating the Jews. I'd look up Farfour the mouse and Tomorrow's Pioneers for one example. Others are easily found with a Google search. 'Hamas summer camp brainwashes Gaza children to hate jews'. On a similar note, you can find mosques in places like England where imams are calling for the death of the Jews and the west in general.
At 11:20, just continued lies. Where is the HQ under the hospital? IDF Headquarters is in Tel Aviv surrounded by millions of civilians - why do you think Hamas launches (unguided) rockets towards Tel Aviv? “Embedded” in civilian populations - what would Sam say about reservists in the civilian population? Are they embedded?
Yes the IDF headquarters are in a hospital. Sure. They are in a city where civilians live! See the same thing! Come on, you are full of it.
How can you compare a military headquarters in the economic centre of a country to that which is underneath a hospital, which is placed there to maximize civilian human shields?!
This person (maybe a bot) believes a democratic country's military HQ that is clearly demarcated, with guards, fences and patrols is the same thing as a terror group building a bunker under a hospital intentionally, because it is a hospital.
It's facinating to see how quiet piers is with this guy
When you hear a rational argument, there's no need to interject, I guess?
@@jjacobs260 As rational as to go from point A to point B in Hebron by taking 1 hour of walking trip because of some street only reserved for zionist colonizers whereas it could take 10 minutes without the checkpoints..
Try again
I understand why the world is in so much trouble if Sam Harris is considered one of the world's greatest thinkers. In my opinion he act on bias and emotion and then offers "rational" arguments to justify his emotional or biased response.
You can really just call that common sense . It’s the emotional people that often have the worst solutions to the worlds problems.
Wow, he literally doesn’t interrupt people of a certain background. 0 respect for Muslim guests
I don't think it's about his background. He interrupts everybody by default, but makes an exception for those he agrees with as he has nothing to contradict.
Is he for real??
It’s rare I listen to Sam and agree with everything he says.
According to his atheist moral compass (there is no God), the Jews should not be in that land because there is no such thing as ¨ God gave them the land¨
How can god give them the land if he does not exist ?
which begs the question, what other arugment the Jews have to prove that the land is theirs other than the bible
He goes on about Islam but he forgot the premise of Isreal is based on the bible
if you are an atheist who does not believe in God you sould say, the Jews have right to live in that land becuase there is no God to begin with
But you and Sam are puppets to Jews because you would not dare to talk about them
So you believe in made up stories?
Your straw mans are sad@@chihabahmed5207
@@chihabahmed5207 that wasn’t his argument, which means you are either too stupid to recognise that, or just like to make assumptions and put words in peoples mouths.
Me and Sam are puppets to the Jews and we dare not talk about them? You’re utterly deluded.
@@slayjay77 which ones?
10:56 "Trajesty" = when tragedy meets travesty
haha i heard that too, had to remind. Sam made up a word.
Love you Sam. Voice of reason.
You misspelled treason
You misspelled genocide.
Sam Harris is a legend
Sam knows the dangers of religion, and in particular, Islam.
Yet he also chooses to ignore the dangers of non-religion and atheism and pretend that Islam is the big bad. Joseph Stalin was an atheist for example and slaughtered millions.
Then probably you haven't read the Talmud yet
@@mohammadarsalan8738 Jews aren't slaughtering people in the name of their religion, unlike followers of the "Religion of Peace"
I am shocked by the sheer audacity of these genocide defenders to have anything to say about Islam or Muslims
Sam Harris speaks on facts ❤️. No bias, no emotions.
wtf man, the mosab dude literally worked as an undercover agent? in which world will his opinion be unbiased?
@dougbarker2227 he was and probably is still working for Israel's intelligence. What would you say if it was reported that Sam harris takes money from Israel's intelligence agency(which he doesn't) ? Would you still give his words the same weight?
If the mosab dude actually wanted to do something he could have taken some other route like majid nawaz.
He was probably a psycho when he was in khamas, and is still a psycho. Dude could have been another majid nawaz but seemingly he just has too much hate in him.
No man is unbiased but Mosab has a perspective few others have of both Hamas and Israeli government
@dougbarker2227 I have a bias towards not listening to biased people :D
@@lastshow3425 The dude literally saved thousands of innocent lives-both Palestinian and Israeli-by thwarting suicide bombings and terrorist attacks. Seems like a person with that perspective would be incredibly useful to understand the ideology of a terrorist organization. But yeah you can disregard everything he said because he's "biased".
I hate that they keep saying the same talking point. Which hospital had an hq? If so why after they took over the hospitals they still fighting
its a game. they throw whatever dung that can and see what sticks. its an easy game bc much of America is willing to believe anything as long as it confirms their biases.
You could Google it?
You’re saying that as if the entirety of Hamas is inside the hospital and would be checkmate if taken over
if you listen to the IDF before they would think that with all this command and control under the hospital which was all lies@@DanBorens
Al-Shifa Hospital
Nah. As long as what you are saying is legally protected by free speech, it should be allowed to be said online. Everything else (as has been seen over and over before) is a slippery slope.
The point is that Twitter/X is a private company. Our laws don’t apply. It’s not a public square - it is a privately owned company and they have a moral obligation to not condone terrorism, hatred, etc etc… just as Harvard does.
@@Hexadeci Terrorism is a crime, no need for additional restrictions. Sure enough, there will be some gray areas. But I'd rather have gray and occasional transgressions than authoritarians or moral busybodies dictating additional "rules".
Saying racial slurs isn't illegal, but have fun trying to find many businesses who want to pay you to do so and put their products next to that. The social media platforms that respond to the market and listen to advertisers will be successful and out compete platforms that refuse to regulate their content.
I am Christian that supports humanity!. Nothing to do with religion.
One of the worlds great thinkers 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Thinker of justifying genocide His the best at
Sam is no longer an atheist, he is a ziontologist now!
What do you mean.. he is a jew after all
If you criticize the religion of peace, you can get rest in peace 💀
Religion of Justice ⚖
Why don't u cover up you حرمة
@@randomrfkov It's a religion of genocidal psychopaths.
@@randomrfkov Yeah. Dark ages justice.
You mean Sam's religion? Judaism?
“The real problem of radicalization is not, I would say, connected in any way to real world grievances.”
~Sam Harris, Moral Philosopher
Ideas indiscriminately posses poeple.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Facts 💯
Source?
Sam Harris created an entire philosophy to wrap his racism around. It would be quite impressive if it wasn't so deeply sad.
All the butt-hurt muslims in the comment talking about Bias. Not a single one addressing the truth being told by Sam Harris.
Of course, Piers Morgan isn't going to interrupt this guy smh
Thank you for such true words. The whole world must wake up and stop radical Islam before it is too late.
The last two decades have seen billions poured into this ridiculous policy
But yet the rate of people coming to islam is growing day after day. So confusing.
Free Palestine
@@jasminbegum3335Wrong. Islam grows mostly through high birthrates. Pentecostal Christianity, attracts proportionally more converts than Islam each year, just as a single example.
@DocnoXXX bring data
@@logiic8835 Sure. Google the Pew study called 'the changing global religious landscape'. That shows that most growth in religions is due to birthrates and that Muslims are out-reproducing Christians by a large margin. Then Google 'Massive Growth under the Radar' by the Pulitzer Centre, which includes the quote "Pentecostalism is the fastest growing religion in the world". These are just examples. The other issue is that a lot of people fake convert to Islam to get married. I know several people who have done this. Others religions are not so closed these days... Want to marry a Buddhist, you don't need to become a Buddhist
thanks for a very polite, delightfully one-sided discussion guys
You mean the truth?
Bet you would say that, if it was two people you agree with, right?
Sam is describing how Piers is falling for the civilian casualties PR game and Piers is speechless 😅
So you are ok with civilian casualties?
15000 children??
Why has Israel stopped aid truck?
Aid won't help hamas?
And why is Israel killing in west bank without Hamas?
Why am i not surprised that the man managed to speak for a long time !?
Because Piers is notoriously unsympathetic to terrorists and their cheerleaders
You are reading too much into it. Piers only starts acting up if he feels you are criticizing him. Piers did not interrupt Hasan Piker or Norm Finkelstein because they never hurt his delicate feelings. The second an Israeli official insults Piers, piers will go berserk.
Sam, the same could be said about Zionists. Son of Hamas has accepted that he is an asset, and he answers to his handler. Which I find strange that he doesn't mind being referred to as an asset!
He lives in America - not Israel.
Sam Harris, have you actually met a Muslim and conversed with them? Please go ahead and do that. Please do not dehumanize Muslims as extremists, they cannot be homogenized and labeled. Rather than dehumanizing lets try to reach out to Muslims and learn about their diverse beautiful cultures and ideals
Look up Maajid Nawaz , they have a book / movie together. Do your research.
Great work Piers! Questions on point.
But sad reply from Sam.
Incredibly accurate description of the state of the Muslim world. I can agree with Sam Harris' view, having grown up in a predominantly Muslim community. We are dealing with a suicidal cult, in which billions of people fervently believe that death is beautiful than life.
It's incredible how Indian BJP bots just lie through their teeth and spread their propaganda. It is clear that you are from India and did not really grow up in a predominantly Muslim community. Your bigotry is showing. GTFO with your bs propaganda.
And where did you grow up? Because according to Islamic religion suiciders are doomed to hell, I'm curious about the country you are stating here!!
You are not allowed to kill yourself in Islam, it’s a straight ticket to hell
This guy is clueless
Thank u Sam for your courage and honesty. As an ATHEIST myself you are one of my heroes
I expected some differentiation from Sam Harris tbh. Not just the narrative of the IDF.
Islam will rule your world very soon
Check his roots.
your surprised he prefers democracy over fascism?
@@muhammedrizwan5611 wow his he a member of the tiny hat club?
WOW! is right. A guy like this who doesn't answer the questions but twists everything around.
Well of course, he hates Palestine and loves censorship, he's piers sort of guy
Sam harris is on point with this
Er no... he's so ill-informed it's breathtaking.
@@ibntulun9405 no, its you that is ill-informed
@@benoliver2826 Touché 😂
@@benoliver2826 "No U" - you
Highest respect and admiration to Harris’s visions, genuine courage, and extensive knowledge.
If you close your eyes, it sounds like Piers Morgan is actually speaking to Martin Byrde from Ozark lol.
It's really sad to see someone who is considered one of the great thinkers in our times adopt such a superficial approach whenever it comes to something related to Islam or Muslims.
Its accurate. Compare jewish communities with muslim communities in every other country in the world and tell me which assimilate better and which commit crimes and terror attacks? How is it, no matter what continent, muslims always are somehow “discriminated” against, provoked, etc yet Jews simply live within their own community and dont bother anyone.
Yes I agree. The world is doomed.
Only Islam can n will pull the world out of it inshallah stripe clubs n gambling places will shut down so men can take the money they earn to their wives n kids. banks will be forced to change their behavior they can make profit but the can’t squeeze the people. Like bank can buy car from the maker for 14k n sell to you for 20k for what ever period you 2 agree on NOT Penny of usury added. If you are earning money when year goes by you pay only 2% of all you have as taxes n keep the rest to take care of you needing brother or neighbor or cousin.
Ok cowardly boomer
I feel sam says a lot of generalisation here. I’m not a Muslims but I’ve visited a few Muslim countries and I don’t think they are how he described them.
I definitely don’t think the people of Gaza deserve the death penalty even if they have supported terrible leadership.
imagine if british had to atone for their leaders this way
Spot-on analysis from Mr. Harris
Sam Harris as always dropping truth bombs.
Love this! We can only imagine what Hitchens would have said on this topic.
He made strong points against all religions (Islam more than others), then he was objective enough to separate the geopolitical aspect. And his opinion never changed, Israel is the colonial oppressor and the Palestinians have every right to defend their land in every way possible
@@aessam8821 see, even atheists can't get along!
"We can only imagine what Hitchens would have said on this topic"
It would've been basically the same since Harris and Hitchens were both staunch defenders of Israel. But there's one big thing they wouldn't have seen eye to eye on, and that's Harris supporting the "race and IQ" theory, which has long been debunked. Harris never even entertained the idea of having experts with different opinions on his podcast. Unlike Harris, Hitchens openly opposed this idea and was proud to be the first to do so. So it's clear that they're not two of a kind. It's a shame that Hitchens isn't here with us anymore, especially when Harris is still pushing the 'race and IQ' notion.
@@NomadFlowHitchens didn’t support Zionism though and saw Palestinians as oppressed. He said Israel had a right to exist but not continue to colonize others’ land
@@NomadFlowsam is atheist jew, he's all for zionism. The more religious a jewish person, the more they hate zionism
In 1906 a black man was kept in a zoo in the Bronx. In 1919 women had no vote in the UK. And in 1989 an English historian told his six year old son that this was the most amazing year he would live through as one communist regime after another fell to have totalitarianism substututed by liberal democracy. Please, Mr Harris, don't lose sight of these fabulous recent advances when you despair of similar alterations towards liberal thinking in Muslim communities.
Great comments. The guy just expresses clearly facts we all have witnessed for too many years.
Harris clearly drinks the Israeli kool aid.
As a self confessed atheist that sam claims to be he sure does have a bias towards Christianity and Judaism . What a great representation of atheism
@@BertrandHolton lol they are
@@BertrandHolton I’m Indian . Very familiar with Jainism . Where in what statement have you seen that I said that
@@BertrandHolton yes
Thank you Sam Harris!!
Isn’t the whole concept of Israel religion driven!? The main difference between IDF & Hamas is that one is much more powerful. To be fair, I find Judaism and Islam the most similar religions out there.
Sam & his ilk justify Israels existence due to religion/the bible (while being atheists), also while pontificating that the other side is bad because of their religion.
He gets an A* for outrageous hypocrisy.
Where did he justify Israel's existence due to the bible?
@@AvidDocumentary Zyansts refer to their religion all the time as justification of their conquering Palestine...Sam has not condemned this . Also Christian Evangelists support the Zyanyst state because they think their god will reward them for protecting the Jews. Sam is an atheist but still he does not condemn or even mention this religious foundation and ongoing support of this colonial settler apartheid entity illegally usurping ancestral land from the Palestinians as well as completely ruining millions of lives in the process.
@@myblighters Israel is a secular country. Humus isn't.