Why Taiwan, its National Day & President Tsai Ing-Wen challenge Beijing & its ‘Akhand China’ policy
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 พ.ย. 2024
- #TaiwanChina #TaiwanNationalDay
The Chinese embassy in New Delhi issued an unprecedented caution to Indian media To avoid calling Taiwan a nation, Republic of China and its leader the president on its national day. This was preceded by Taiwanese President Tsai Ing-wen calling for “meaningful dialogue” with mainland China as long as it was willing to resolve antagonisms and improve cross-strait relations. In episode 590 of Cut The Clutter, Shekhar Gupta simplifies the complex 100-year story, what is Taiwan and the issue with mainland China and its One-China policy.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Correction: Zhou Enlai was born in 1898. Error regretted.
Taiwan's GDP per capita is around $25000. Which is
around 2.5 times than that of China. Shekhar Gupta erroneously compared India and China’s GDP per capita in nominal terms with Taiwan’s GDP per capita in PPP terms. The error is regretted.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
All maps are for representational purposes.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read Chris Horton's Taiwan’s status is a geopolitical absurdity here: www.theatlanti...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Please support good journalism by paying for it. Subscribe to ThePrint. Links for both domestic & overseas subscribers are provided here: theprint.in/su...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint : bit.ly/Subscrib...
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
Please support good journalism by paying for it. Subscribe to ThePrint. Links for both domestic & overseas subscribers are provided here: theprint.in/subscribe/
I never paid for online news, but today it changed!
It's a request to make a CtC on how Biden would deal with china if he got elected please please please please
Sir I think you have confused GDP per capita with per capita income. Taiwan's GDP per capita income is not 57,000 dollars. It is 26,000 dollars. You compared Per capita income of Taiwan with GDP per capita of India. Please correct it. Thanks
@@whyhaveaname5963 our Shekar Ji may make few mistakes. Because he is not reading it from a script.
1)पत्रकारों की लगातार हो रही हत्या पर बहुत बड़ा खुलासा।
th-cam.com/video/9JneUFcGzqI/w-d-xo.html
2) फेक न्यूज पर अब तक का सबसे बड़ा खुलासा।
(Part-1) th-cam.com/video/rxlc3N3J1jU/w-d-xo.html
(Part-2) th-cam.com/video/tR26ShdG118/w-d-xo.html
Hello guys, If you really feel that - this issue is important and if you like the video, then pls share the video & subscribe this channel.👍🏻
I am an Indian . Who has been living in Taiwan ( Tsipei ) for the last 37 years. I am writing to you to congratulate you to have presented . most wonderful , factually accurate, succinct and with correct inference!
I don’t think many people would have succeeded in encapsulating , very complicated issues in a video of 30 minutes!!
I have been seeing your videos for a long time - but now I have become your fan !! I will subscribe to your channel also !
With kind regards from all Indians living in Taiwan - Ashok Puri
Mr SG, You should not be shy of Referring to Tibet or Taiwan as distinct from China. While India respected One China policy, China promotes separatism in J & K, north East. If China doesn’t respect India’s integrity, India need not hesitate to say that Tibet is under Chinese occupation, or that Taiwan is independent of PR China.
Forget about Tibet. Modi had not yet pronounced the word 'China' since China occupied India lands.
@@joyal876 You mean since 1955.. when they built a road through Aksai Chin.
We need not hesitate, but our country doesn't do that and we should stand by that and not do anything stupid.
@@ammlu3556 modi went 6 times to China, hugged and kissed everyone there. And China fake back and occupied Indian territory as a revenge
@@BayPorWah there's nothing interesting here, just we have to respect our country's stand on these issues.
I thought Haryana was the unit of measurements when talking about other countries: 1.5 Haryana, 5 Harayana 😁
Hahah. Good one
In population, it is similar to Haryana. Lol !
For china the measurement of gupta ji has to be kerala.
SG if possible please make a CTC on the recent radical islam separatism bill of France.
its radical islam sepratist
@@RishitSrivastava007 oh sorry, thanks for correcting me
Bhai source ?
@@saurabhmishra2363 www.theguardian.com/world/2020/oct/02/emmanuel-macron-outlines-law-islamic-separatism-france
@@saurabhmishra2363 source th-cam.com/video/PTIfnZkVANk/w-d-xo.html
Since a long time I was confused with this Taiwan issue...you cleared it in less then 30 min..Thanks a lot sir...
Taiwan: UNITED IN TAKING ON CHINA
India: Farooq Abdullah seeks China's intervention for Kashmir.
Farookh Abdullah did not seek Chinese intervention in India. What he said was that the major section of kashmir Muslims disenchanted with India, will welcome China if it intervenes. He never said he will welcome Chinese intervention. He said people will not listen to him anymore as they consider him to be Indian stooge. He was just stating the mood on the ground. So why are you lying to say that he wants China to Intervene? Typical BJP double speak.
th-cam.com/video/9zbwwoRoYlM/w-d-xo.html
@@governmentofindia9623 Typical Islamists
@@Suresh_Kamath The man is a parasite whose family made their fortune by playing India against Pakistan and now are attempting the same with China. He was NOT STATTING THE MOOD ON THE GROUND rather attempting another of his GREAT BLACKMAIL SCHEMES that have served him so well in the past. There are somethings bigger than BJP and CONGRESS. He was passing his own idea disguised as the "mood". NONETHELESS, You are entitled to your opinion. Leftists are anyways irrelevant in the country.
Lets send him to Xinjiang. He can welcome the Chinese there ;)
thanks Indian friends with this excellent video !
Indian govt follows one china policy more than chinese govt itself while they openly claim Arunachal and ladakh
In case of AP and LADAKH. We don't follow One China policy.
After listening to SG you understand why journalists call their piece of work a "story". CTC is an awakening to how storytelling is essential to journalism 👍
Sir I love you . Even iam bjp supporter . U present unbiased news.... i wish all give news like you... u have set an example for Indian media.... I salute you sir
The stats provided are misleading
5:16 : Taiwan is not the country with the highest population density. Countries like Maldives, Bahrain and Bangladesh have higher population density (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_and_dependencies_by_population_density)
5:37 : If you are using the PPP (Purchasing power parity) GDP per capita, then you are right. But then the GDP per capita (PPP) of India then is between $7k to 9k and that of China's is $16k to 20k. You used PPP for Taiwan and nominal for India and China 😊😊. In nominal GDP per capita, Taiwan is only $24k, which puts it behind countries like UK, France, Australia and Canada. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(nominal)_per_capita
Bhai to jo koyi bhi ho " jai ho". Yeh gdp ppp mere samj ke bahar hai, par u have reminded Sekhar sir that every one is watching keenly for him to commit mistakes
fair point. The print shouldnt try to manipulates stats for its own agenda
@@rajasekhe - Np Bhai. Jab bi aap ke pas samay hoga to explain karoonga
@@agytjax 🙏
You are really great Sir. I have read about Taiwan from different sources but never had this kind of clearity. Today is real cut the clutter. More power & life to you Sir.
What kind of a deal was that? Peanuts for us and Pistachios for them? India recognised Tibet as a part of China and China recognised Sikkim as a part of India. Tibet is like 100 times Sikkim. Why couldn't India get China to give up claims over Arunachal Pradesh and Aksai Chin, during this deal? Was there something else to balance this deal out?
Dear SG, we need a CTC on this! Interested people please hit LIKE
The courage and tremendous guts of the brave and fearless president of Taiwan Mm. Wein are admirable and examplery. Such a challenging person must be appreciated and respected
Really Educative CTC today. Now I understand why people like calling you Professor.
I lived in Taiwan for 7 years ; It is amazing place and vegan friendly in compare to China. President Tsai lost her majority like 2 years back and had to resign from the party; and now she is extremely popular. I respect her because She is amazing and cat lover.
Belated Happy National Day Taiwan ✌🏽👍🏽
I just day...Taiwan Independence Day TAIWAN 🇹🇼🇹🇼🇮🇳🇮🇳
@darsh mart I'm from Sikkim.... Why don't you visit Sikkim !? I'll give you freedom for your entire generation !! 🙂
Shekher jee is true PROFESSOR! Excellent in everything!
I've just paid from UK for the amazing quality of journalism the print provides. Hats off to you Mr gupta and your colleagues. A balanced view of news is very important. I prefer watching the videos uploaded on print as it seems mature people are analysing the state of affairs. Please keep up the high standards Mr Gupta. The print is a voice of tranquility bearing in mind the nastiness propagated by most of the Indian media channels.
Hi Rajdeep. Thank you for being a loyal supporter of ThePrint.
Mad love to Taiwan and the Taiwanese people. ❤️
A very lucid explanation of the complex Chinese and Taiwanese history in easy and simple way... thanks a lot for enlightening us on the current and historical aspects on this part of globe... Shekhar Gupta gaaru , your gracious style of presentation is unique and classical...🙏🙏🙏
Guptaji you are brilliant on topics like these .and good to hear that even you can't understand the full depth of Chinese Chinese mindset. Also give insight of why is tibbatan lama is so revered all throughout the world. And his role in world politics.
I am sure, will have great time watching!
As a Taiwanese, your introduction is very detailed, and the relationship between Taiwan and mainland China is very complicated...
Awwww Sir ❤️😍
Looking so handsome today... ☺️❤️
Love from Dimapur.....
I like Shekhar ji more, when he talk about Geo political issues... 💝
Finally, calling a spade a spade, China's policy is, what is known to India (absurdly I may add to RSS type people Akhand Bharat), 'Akhand China' policy, that's what One China policy is. That is why it will keep expanding. As a Chinese dung beetle has kept a foot on your backyard for 1-2 years, eventually the Chinese state will claim it as 'belonging to it since ancient times'. Akhand China policy is an absurdity that needs to be called out.
What a stupid comparison, RSS is a small organization and don't have presence in all of India plus they only talk and don't do anything. Every country in the world has some sort of right wing cultural organization even in highly developed European countries. And you're comparing this organization with a powerful state's strategic policy. Its like comparing a stone with a tank.
@Professor Severus Snape just because RSS is a nationalist organization, you seem to have all sorts of issues with it. You are just regurgitating some Congress nonsense
Even if GOI does not recognize Taiwan as a country, Indian media has advantage of being in a democracy to call Taiwan and even Tibet to be separate nations lol.
Even after 27 mins of decluttering, the conclusion is 'this is a complicated situation!' 😂
Jokes apart, I am a regular viewer of your videos Mr Gupta. They are very informative and insightful. Pls keep up the amazing work! 🙏
Lol at the description
Chinese embassy: avoid calling Taiwan's leader the president on its national day
Next line in description: "This was preceded by Taiwanese President Tsai Ing-wen..."
Katal ek dum
hahah.. really??
@God is great- America is great ok Chinese bot
Dear SG - Thank you for very interesting cut the clutter. Really removed significant ambiguity about the history one china.
Insightful and informative. It's a pleasure to be one of your avid fan, a continuous learning student of life. Keep it coming Sir. Thank you.👍🙏
Shekharji is a g8 storyteller. It was just warming up, the video has come to an end. What I like, Shekharji when he has to say something more but holds up, he would emphasis on that point with a smile and would repeat it multiple times. Added inquiringness on this topic
One 0f the best #CTC . Kudos to you Mr. Gupta.👌
India should recognize Taiwan as a country, think of repercussions. The world’s largest democracy, 1.33 Billion people, recognize Taiwan as an independent democratic country. ♥️
18:26 "1st free open election in China,since we believe in one China policy"
I found this sentence the best and the most cunning sentence I ever heard.
Sir aap tow GOLD ho. I want this skill of urs
One of the best CTC.
Taiwan is so complex and there seems to be merit for what mainland is claiming. However, who are we to challenge an island which is thriving better than the best
Hi Arun. Thank you for writing in. Do keep following us.
Thanks for such an elaborate report on Taiwan
Good job Guptaji 🙏
Sir I think you have confused GDP per capita with per capita income. Taiwan's GDP per capita income is not 57,000 dollars. It is 26,000 dollars. You compared Per capita income of Taiwan with GDP per capita of India. Please correct it. Thanks
Rightly pointed.
Hi. We have issued a correction in the description. Thanks for writing in.
I usually watch TH-cam at 2x speed, but when it comes to your
Cut the clutter, I reduce the speed to1.5x bcs i dont want it to be over so soon!!
I think for one time Shekhar ji failed to unclutter the Taiwanese Clutter. Too difficult to understand. I will listen one more time. But Shekhar ji's style of narration is fascinating.
Imagine if all of china was a democracy like Taiwan.... peace on earth.
@bobtheman 3 not if you are brainwashed on communist propaganda 😒
Superb explanation...... 👌
Nice jacket, Shekharji. Favoured by more than one PM, but suits your casual yet erudite style even better...
Shekhar ji your explanation in Tawan is excellent . Can we have cut the clutter video on Tibet
Thank you for a detailed insight and connecting the dots 🙏
Beautifully decluttered.
Love your commentary Shekar Ji
Gupta uncle Dabs! 🔥🔥🔥 17:58
My new favourite episode!
"Elephants often underestimate the little mouse. All it needs to do is get inside the giant's trunk and game over ... "
Vietnam was USA's Kryptonite.
So was Afghanistan for the Russians.
Taiwan might turn out the same for China.
Thank you sg, I've been busy
Fantastic..
Great research and presentation
Mr Shekhar looks so smart today
Talked with a Mainland Chinese guy on WhatsApp today. Was introduced to him through a Chinese TH-cam channel discussing an unbiased view of Chinese politics. You guys can check out the channel, there are English subtitles too. It is a great channel:想做教育家的Klaus
th-cam.com/channels/Z4NwvuGYgFyjnRRJekdnHw.html
Anyway, he is a good person and was sad that people of his country didn't see behind the lies of the CCP. He just hoped that China gets democracy where everyone will be free.
Mr. Gupta, please share these perspectives with your viewers: not calling Taiwan a nation is to a avoid misleading the Taiwan citizens. Tsai Ing-Wen’s ancestors are from the Japanese troops that remained in Taiwan; they are the major land-owners, and she is one of the wealthiest family in Taiwan. Taiwan’s economy has benefited greatly as a major trading partner with China. Tsai Ing-Wen calling for independent tied to her Japanese heritage. There are more than 500 thousand business families have already immigrated back to China; there is a wealthy neighborhood in Shanghai call “little Taipei”.
SG will get threats from the Chinese embassy now
His 'past' will now be leaked 😂😂
Very good briefing of Taiwan.
U are the best🙏
Very informative video...
3:37 to 4:10 is exactly how passed all my Mechanical engineering theory subjects exams. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
i support Taiwan. Long live Taiwan.
SG, a good bedtime story teller.
Show name cut the clutter. Ends the show saying it is all complicated 🤣
Great info sir.
when changaishek took over Taiwan, local population was 30%,with minor tribal population,70% was from mainland china ,who were rich and entrepreneur .
Even I recognise one china policy. According to me their is only one China and I don't see Taiwan as china. There is only one China but there is also one Taiwan and one Tibet which are not china.
For next year republic day celebrations..Modiji should invite Taiwan president as chief guest.
India should have recognized TAIWAN after 1962. Chiang Kai Shek would have been a loyal ally.
@bobtheman 3 Islamic Trojan Horse Pakistan was worthy for the Chinese. It is Chanakya statecraft which our foreign policy mandarins does not have a clue. They work only for their wages.
Beautiful place. Lived there for 5 years. 👍
The written language of the two territories is different. You call it simplified in China and traditional in Taiwan.
Republic of India should support Taiwan as sovereign country I personally believe to hit back against adversary China.
Shekhar jee,
Does one need Chinese visa or Taiwanese visa to visit Taiwan as a tourist today ?
You forget to mention in 1897 Subhash Chandra Bose was born in India
Looking forward to a COC on US Politics please!!
Chinese Embassy : Don't do a story on Taiwan.
Shekhar Gupta: Hold me beer while I do #CTC on this very topic.
Nailed it sir 👌
My beer*
@@darshilmashru8479 My bad
Hi Abhishek. Do keep tracking ThePrint.
AS A REGULAR VIEWER OF THE PRINT, I WOULD RECOMMEND A NEWS BULLETIN HAVING 100 TOP NEWS FOR THE DAY WHICH WOULD MEAN GOOD BYE TO ALL OTHER NEWS CHANNELS. THE NEWS BULLETIN SHOULD BE GOOD QUALITY WITH ALL IMPORTANT CURRENT AFFAIRS OF THE DAY.
Just an addition, the Taiwanese passport is now updated and it now only says Taiwan!
That's a shame.
Love the flowers in the background 😊
May Indian govt say One China policy But Indian citizen recognize TAIWAN as a country.
1:15 When has telling someone NOT TO DO SOMETHING EVER WORKED? We and esp Indians thrive on DISOBEDIENCE.
After cutting clutter,still it remains clutter,Mr.Gupta
Tera mera reminds me of song from Humraaz.. Tu husn hai main ishq hoon tu mujh mein hai mai tujh mein hoon..
:)
Also please make an episode on akhand bharat.
Very nice
I think Arnab Case might bring quality back to journalism.
You have false hopes
beta aise saste nashe na karo
SG 1998 Zhou Enlai was born in china
Me-yeah he's my class mate
Today I came to know why government doesn't take any hasty decisions on taiwan or Tibet.
It's like the opposition party in India moving to Andaman and form another country named 'Also India'.
Chang kai shek did not flee to taiwan. He fled to an island called Formosa which was renamed Taiwan
India must secretly support this current Taiwanese President. Even though it's very difficult to do as India have signed on for "one China Policy".
Sir hatsoff to u 🙏🙏🙏 i m huge fan of u
Shekhar Sir, Thanks for finally speaking about Taiwan 🙏🏻🙏🏻✌🏻
Looking handsome Shekar Sir!
Happy tiwan national day
Important and informative video. But, the prrsenter was wearing the microphone too low and the voice was barely audible.
SG...its Half hearted job.
I laughed so hard when I heard China issuing directives to Indian media. It's like China doesn't understand what democracu and freedom of speech mean....wait.