I think it's so cool that they did this! Love when artists give fans something unexpected! I need to react to a performance by the rap racha now lol!🦁 Here is my reaction to the original Muddy Water song if you haven't seen it: th-cam.com/video/Wyqm74whu4g/w-d-xo.html
Appreciated your honest commentary! Just to give it a little bit more context: before fanmeets, fans can fill out forms where they write challenges and different things that they would like to see the members do, from dance challenges to games to song covers etc. One of the ideas selected for that fanmeet was for the Muddy Water and Waiting for Us subunits to cover each others' songs, so that's how it came to be. It was never supposed to be super serious or anything, just a fun challenge for the fans to enjoy! And of course they slayed because they're incapable of not slaying, but like they were definitely playing around and having fun with it
Someone has forgotten and someone does not know at all, but Seungmin is a versatile, versatile and incredibly talented person. He is really great at rapping, and since the debut of the group, he has been training regularly and on the show "Weekly idol" he read faster than the main rapper of the group, and this is considering the fact that Seungmin is the main vocalist. PLEASE REACTION TO SEUNGMIN RAP COMPILATION.
I always thought that Chan having Felix’s part is because he is probably out of the four of them that can sort of go that low comfortably.( I’m still roughly a new stay. But I only know that the clips I’ve seen the 3 can only go so low not as low as Felix.)
I was very surprised I.N did Changbin’s part. 😂 Considering that I.N and Seungmin hardly ever raps they did really well. It was a fun thing to do. Also when the rapline did Waiting for us. Switching things up makes for a fun show.
Naw, you were right, that missed second definitely was felt, but he makes up for it in the second half. And he did better, at least in the concert I went to. It was amazing live. This performance made me want to hear a Seungmin rap verse so badly. He needs more rap solos, this proved he can definitely to it.
These covers were definitely used to give a sweet surprise to Stay with the changeup of the members. Knowing Chan, if it was to be a "serious" remake, he would have made sure the boys new rap verses, would have been in their own "style". As you said, rappers usually will write their own flow and these boys can & do.. and please continue to give your honest opinions (you're respectfully.. no shade). I respect that. If there are some who would be a little sensitive, but they just need to put on their big people pants... no shade -- facts. Looking forward to the rapline's waiting for you..
Chan knew what he was doing when he "tried" to go low 😂😂😂 one of the perks of all the members being able to do everything. They can do fun things like this. There are random clips around you can find of Seungmin and I.N rapping. A compilation video to check out about 8 rappers 8 singers. th-cam.com/video/Nvaa78VTkyY/w-d-xo.htmlsi=2VXEzoA7eZBfVfCP
Just woke up in my time zone and here is the flip side of Muddy Water! Glad you had a bit of fun with this one. There is an in joke in the fandom that Seungmin is the best rapper so this was fun for the fans. He once sang Han’s part in an old Maniac (think that was the song) performance when Han was unwell. He also many years back beat both Han and Changbin for speed reading a long passage on a variety show. But he does take a much more chill, laid back approach, it’s his style so not as sharp and punchy as Han. I think I’ve also heard Seungmin joke he wants to be a rapper on another variety show and on yet another, when asked “What did you want to be when you grew up?”, the members thought baseball player as that was his original dream before injury, but his reply was “Changbin”. He did recently sing and “small” rap with Han when they did a duet of Han’s SKZ record of Volcano. It was at the end of the recent 2 Kid Show with the both of them. Thanks for your reaction. Look forward to more.
Glad you reacted to this one! Although stays like to say they all can sing and rap, they do have their own strengths and weaknesses. I don't think you said anything that would warrant a hatetrain lmao I know some ppl are sensitive to critisism but I agree with what you said. Tho chan has rapped before and lee know has had small rap parts, I.N and seungmin are very clearly vocalists (that they pride themselves in). thats also seen in the other unit cover. Although they CAN sing, waiting for us is a challenging song. But it was fun and unexpected and I hope they switch unitsongs more just to spice it up (also I know I said in my comment that this was from their dome tour but apparently it was from their fanmeet oops)
Appreciate that! And yeah you know how stans are, very quick to check someone who's hating & I would do the same (I consider myself stay as well) BUT I wasn't in anyway trying to hate, just wanted to point out something I noticed is all.
To be fair, Minnie was doing a stylistic take on his part. I feel that he came in late on purpose, and he owned that stage. He attitude here is something else. I wish he raps more. He can freestyle too, though you can't find many videos of it :) The rap switch is so awesome too, they all sound fantastic in "Waiting for us"
Idc what other people say, I really appreciate your honesty Like yeah "Stray kids have no real position" etc but the reality is that some members are better at rapping and others at singing and it's fun when they try each other specialties Anyway thank you for your reaction, as always I enjoyed it a lot!
Appreciate your comments! And yeah everyone is supremely talented, they just don't all have the same exact talents which is actually good for balance in a group, it's not shade
I had a whole paragraph yesterday night about how you had to watch this, to comment on the original version reaction but I fell asleep before posting 😅 Great you did! I'm glad you give a honest reaction, by the way. You pointed out what your experienced ears would have changed, but were professional about it. And the most important part, you had a good time. Just... now you have to do the same with "Waiting for Us", both original and switched versions 🤭🤭
I've not heard the og version. I'm a baby Stay. So I'm still going through their music. Which I need to hurry up cuz they're making another comeback. I'm gonna go listen to the og version now.
this give me the vibe: Seungmin: i want to be a part of 3Racha. Changbin: then i lose my Job... I.... I Lose my Job... when you walking in... well, I.N was pretty good at imitating Changbin iconic sounds))) Seems like Lee Know mic was little quiet 🤔
It's okay to critique as long as your being respectful which you are. Don't worry and that your good. It would be surprising if Suengmin and IN were as good or sounded the same as Changbin and Han. 😊
Yay! Im glad you reacted to this, even if it didn't fully live up to your expectations. I like your honesty 😊 This was a fun surprise for us as fans. I look forward to your Waiting For Us vocal and rap line performances!
I don’t think you said anything controversial haha, I think the original version of both songs are best but it’s a lot of fun to see them switch it up and do a good job of it too.
Yeah but you know how quick stans are to take anything as shade. Just wanted to explain something I noticed and also remind everyone I am stay too, I love them too lol.
I was waiting for u to put Aussie connection to the Chan Felix section 😂 They were all honestly just having fun with this...if they were being 100% serious it would have a whole other vibe lol
FIRST, as I've told you, I'm here for the truth, your truth! So never lie here... SECOND, they are not called a group of ACES for nothing. They can all sing, rap, and dance. THIRD, I totally agree with you on the rap things that you explained. I'm definitely no expert on rap, but I know that a lot goes into it, and Han and Changbin write their own verses of course cause A, It's them, and B, It's for them. So, If someone else sings the same verse It's going to sound a bit off. But, they did sound good! I haven't heard that before (really surprising for me to be true... I'm an OVER consumer of Stray Kids) + I know that Seungmin had some rapping lessons before, but I'm not sure about I.N lessons in general for rapping. Before this performance, I'm sure they did work on it a lot, with a teacher or with Changbin and Han themselves. + For me at least, hearing I.N rap like that is even more impressive, even though Seungmin's part was way harder and he's not a professional rapper but I heard him rap before and I know that he can pull that off if he wanted to, I already know he's good, but with I.N It's different, cause I don't think that I have ever heard I.N rap seriously before, maybe just little "skits" of back and forth with 3Racha on their behind the scenes show that they have "SKZ Talker".
I think the performance was mainly a fun gift for Stay rather than a serious thing like you said. You're not wrong in saying the timing was slightly off and that Seungmin was being laid back. He's able to go fast but doesn't have the same kind of tone or level of practice as Han. They all still did a great job especially since it's a common thing in K-pop for rappers not to be able to sing and vocalists to not rap at all. Hence, Stay get to say we have 8 all-rounders as SKZ has 8 singers, 8 rappers, and 8 dancers. That's not even counting the producing (3RACHA), insane lyricism (3RACHA and mainly Hyunjin), and melodies (3RACHA and Hyunjin) that they do themselves. Basically, even with an imperfect performance, they're insanely talented which is why I don't think you should get a ton of hate.
If by producing you mean instrumental/beat making, only Chan does that in the group, 3racha is responsible for topline making (or melody, as you said). But kpop uses the term producing for lyrics+topline too so yeah if we use it that way all members produced/co-produced songs several times, that's very impressive ❤
I also got slightly bothered by Seungmin being 1/2 a beat off in the pre-chorus. Particularly because I.N was so on top of the timing and crisp as crisp can be. I really wanted to hear that sharp back and forth too!!
Wait. I know they all can rap, but I thought Bangchan was a part of the rap line. Isn’t bangchan, changbin, han for rap line? Felix, Hyunjin, Lee Know, dance line? And Seugmin and IN vocal line? Have I had that wrong this whole time?
Based on my understanding of it: 3racha: Bangchan, Changbin & Han (Production/Writing Line & the original subunit) Rap Racha: Han, Changbin, Felix, Hyunjin (all of these members have a rapper position well they did before they got rid of positions) Dance Racha: Hyunjin, Lee Know, Felix Vocal Racha: Seungmin, I.N (& Bangchan SHOULD be considered apart of this but often isn't cause he's already in 3racha)
Okay so I understand why this is confusing. They have the official subunits: Producing/writing unit and yes also the original rap trio subunit that was formed and making music before SKZ, 3RACHA: Bang Chan, Changbin and Han. They do have their rap unit songs and still occasionally perform as a trio. DanceRacha: Lee Know, Hyunjin and Felix VocalRacha: Seungmin and I.N. However these are different from the division they most often have in their songs between vocalists and rappers. Members who rap the most are Changbin, Han, Hyunjin and Felix and members who sing the most are Seungmin, I.N., Lee Know and Bang Chan. Han could be in either one though because he had to step up as a vocalist after they became 8 members. So they all can rap and sing but obviously are more trained/comfortable in one or the other.
No I think racha units confused you but they don't represent the positions. Bang Chan is a vocalist (he does rap but not much), I don't know if you listen to their songs but Chan sings almost as much as Seungmin who is the main vocalist. 3racha is the producer unit
sorry guy but I think you're confusing some things, Stray Kids DON'T HAVE DEFINED POSITIONS, the 8 rap, the 8 sing, the 8 dance, In and Seungmin and Lee Know have already rapped on many Skz songs throughout their discography, of course it's not common but they are still rappers too, so much so that in Kingdom In who raps in part of the presentations and Lee Know at the beginning of Distric 9 started rapping, their tone is obviously different. but they still rapped very well, so much so that that's why the group doesn't have divisions like vocals, rappers and dancers, Chan said that as everyone does well in everything the group doesn't have divisions like that, Seungmin in one The program even managed to be faster than Han and Changbin hahaha I understand that you don't usually hear them rapping but don't underestimate them, In rapping in Kingdom was very important for them to win, Seungmin always says he's going to do a project focused on rappers, and in a performance of Gods Menu he had to do Changbin's rap part because Changbin was bad that day and couldn't attend and Lee Know usually raps in Skz's discography especially on the old songs and Chan is from 3racha so it's no surprise that he does rap lol just remember that Stray Kids doesn't have a rap line, a vocal line (Chan's own words in live), the members really have a more comfortable space in one position but it doesn't mean they just stay in that position
These are not Chan's words love, I understand your enthusiasm but OF COURSE they have positions. Just because Seungmin and I.N rapped a few lines in some songs doesn't mean they're rappers lol, this is not a kids group. And even Lee Know mostly sings, doesn't rap much nowadays. Being a rapper isn't that easy, they never even wrote their own raps. They never rapped full verses perfectly on beat in a live performance (except this one). So no, skz aren't 8 singers and 8 rappers. Hyunjin and Felix aren't good singers (they don't have to be) and Seungmin Jeongin and Lino aren't good rappers.
I have to respectfully disagree with you on one specific issue, Felix has a beautiful singing voice. Other than that I think when People say they can all rap they are referring more to the performance aspect not writing the raps. I know that many people will say you are not a real rapper unless you write your own raps and I agree with that too a point but especially in kpop is also a skill that you add to the group overall you may not write the lyrics but you can perform the rap for the group. Changbin and Han and even Chan write their own raps but they also will perform lines written by the others so it's all about your perspective. Also Felix and Hyunjin and IN have all written raps for in songs for them.
![[eng sub] bang chan reaction to lee know's vlog | chan's room ep. 142](/img/n.gif)
I think it's so cool that they did this! Love when artists give fans something unexpected! I need to react to a performance by the rap racha now lol!🦁
Here is my reaction to the original Muddy Water song if you haven't seen it: th-cam.com/video/Wyqm74whu4g/w-d-xo.html
Yes the rap line did “waiting for us”!
Poor Bang Chan was not clowning. He was at the very end of his range, and chin down like he does is the only way to reach Felix notes
This was a great reaction! The performance was fun and unserious, which is something us STAY love to see
"IF I REMOVE MY BRACES I'LL CONQUER THE WORLD"
~Kim Seungmin🌹
Meanwhile Changbin: "I-I lose my job.."
Seungmin actually auditioned as a rapper for JYP. But they heard him sing and the rest is history.
Changbin: I'm going to be a singer
Seungmin: I'm going to be a rapper
JYP: Bestie I have some news for you lol
Seungmin once outstripped Han and Changbin on a variety show , speed reading/rapping. Whole of skz were flabbergasted.
That's insane! Very impressive
I never not laugh my ass off hearing Chan try to sing as low as Felix 😂😂
Also… Seungmin is a rapper. He ate Han’s part
Came in and slayed! Had no idea he could do that! Was very impressive
Seungmin not only nailed Han's part but his attitude, his aura, his stage presence, all just went crazily insane♥♥
Also whatever you said, is fact. So don't think my comment was meant to deny your fact.
Yes he really impressed me showing great skill & rapping ability
Appreciated your honest commentary!
Just to give it a little bit more context: before fanmeets, fans can fill out forms where they write challenges and different things that they would like to see the members do, from dance challenges to games to song covers etc.
One of the ideas selected for that fanmeet was for the Muddy Water and Waiting for Us subunits to cover each others' songs, so that's how it came to be.
It was never supposed to be super serious or anything, just a fun challenge for the fans to enjoy! And of course they slayed because they're incapable of not slaying, but like they were definitely playing around and having fun with it
Someone has forgotten and someone does not know at all, but Seungmin is a versatile, versatile and incredibly talented person. He is really great at rapping, and since the debut of the group, he has been training regularly and on the show "Weekly idol" he read faster than the main rapper of the group, and this is considering the fact that Seungmin is the main vocalist. PLEASE REACTION TO SEUNGMIN RAP COMPILATION.
They put their own twist on the song. It is hard not to hear and compare the original version, but it was fun to see/ hear their take on it!
For sure! Overall I like it!
I always thought that Chan having Felix’s part is because he is probably out of the four of them that can sort of go that low comfortably.( I’m still roughly a new stay. But I only know that the clips I’ve seen the 3 can only go so low not as low as Felix.)
I was very surprised I.N did Changbin’s part. 😂 Considering that I.N and Seungmin hardly ever raps they did really well. It was a fun thing to do. Also when the rapline did Waiting for us. Switching things up makes for a fun show.
Yeah it's a cool experience for the fans, love that they did this.
Bang Chang put together an A-star team that can rap, sing and can perform complex choreography routines.
Naw, you were right, that missed second definitely was felt, but he makes up for it in the second half. And he did better, at least in the concert I went to. It was amazing live. This performance made me want to hear a Seungmin rap verse so badly. He needs more rap solos, this proved he can definitely to it.
Appreciate that! Anyways Seungmin rapper era on next project? I would like one for sure
These covers were definitely used to give a sweet surprise to Stay with the changeup of the members. Knowing Chan, if it was to be a "serious" remake, he would have made sure the boys new rap verses, would have been in their own "style". As you said, rappers usually will write their own flow and these boys can & do.. and please continue to give your honest opinions (you're respectfully.. no shade). I respect that. If there are some who would be a little sensitive, but they just need to put on their big people pants... no shade -- facts. Looking forward to the rapline's waiting for you..
I appreciate that & yeah it was a great fan moment & I love that they did it
Seungmin just ate this rap part
Had no idea he had that in him! Very impressive
Chan knew what he was doing when he "tried" to go low 😂😂😂 one of the perks of all the members being able to do everything. They can do fun things like this. There are random clips around you can find of Seungmin and I.N rapping. A compilation video to check out about 8 rappers 8 singers.
th-cam.com/video/Nvaa78VTkyY/w-d-xo.htmlsi=2VXEzoA7eZBfVfCP
I'll give it a watch for sure!
Just woke up in my time zone and here is the flip side of Muddy Water! Glad you had a bit of fun with this one. There is an in joke in the fandom that Seungmin is the best rapper so this was fun for the fans. He once sang Han’s part in an old Maniac (think that was the song) performance when Han was unwell. He also many years back beat both Han and Changbin for speed reading a long passage on a variety show. But he does take a much more chill, laid back approach, it’s his style so not as sharp and punchy as Han. I think I’ve also heard Seungmin joke he wants to be a rapper on another variety show and on yet another, when asked “What did you want to be when you grew up?”, the members thought baseball player as that was his original dream before injury, but his reply was “Changbin”. He did recently sing and “small” rap with Han when they did a duet of Han’s SKZ record of Volcano. It was at the end of the recent 2 Kid Show with the both of them. Thanks for your reaction. Look forward to more.
Seungmin rapper era on next project? Me thinks so!
seungmins rap was actually good
Glad you reacted to this one! Although stays like to say they all can sing and rap, they do have their own strengths and weaknesses. I don't think you said anything that would warrant a hatetrain lmao I know some ppl are sensitive to critisism but I agree with what you said. Tho chan has rapped before and lee know has had small rap parts, I.N and seungmin are very clearly vocalists (that they pride themselves in). thats also seen in the other unit cover. Although they CAN sing, waiting for us is a challenging song. But it was fun and unexpected and I hope they switch unitsongs more just to spice it up
(also I know I said in my comment that this was from their dome tour but apparently it was from their fanmeet oops)
Appreciate that! And yeah you know how stans are, very quick to check someone who's hating & I would do the same (I consider myself stay as well) BUT I wasn't in anyway trying to hate, just wanted to point out something I noticed is all.
To be fair, Minnie was doing a stylistic take on his part. I feel that he came in late on purpose, and he owned that stage. He attitude here is something else. I wish he raps more. He can freestyle too, though you can't find many videos of it :)
The rap switch is so awesome too, they all sound fantastic in "Waiting for us"
Idc what other people say, I really appreciate your honesty
Like yeah "Stray kids have no real position" etc but the reality is that some members are better at rapping and others at singing and it's fun when they try each other specialties
Anyway thank you for your reaction, as always I enjoyed it a lot!
Appreciate your comments! And yeah everyone is supremely talented, they just don't all have the same exact talents which is actually good for balance in a group, it's not shade
I had a whole paragraph yesterday night about how you had to watch this, to comment on the original version reaction but I fell asleep before posting 😅 Great you did! I'm glad you give a honest reaction, by the way. You pointed out what your experienced ears would have changed, but were professional about it. And the most important part, you had a good time. Just... now you have to do the same with "Waiting for Us", both original and switched versions 🤭🤭
Thank you! And yes I will definitely have to check out the other 4's song & performance
You won my heart with muddy water +tartus shirt❤
And what a grand prize it is!! Thank you for the gift!
It made me so happy they did this!! You should watch the reverse one where rapracha sang the vocal units song waiting for us!
I for sure will, I'm sure they ate!
Seungmin is a rapper, he is the main rapper❤
I was definitely impressed with his rap skills
Thank you for reaction😍 Also it's good to know you do react to recommendations and that too real quick. ♥
No problem 😊 And yeah it only made sense to react to this ya know?
This is the only version of this song I listen to 😂
I've not heard the og version. I'm a baby Stay. So I'm still going through their music. Which I need to hurry up cuz they're making another comeback. I'm gonna go listen to the og version now.
this give me the vibe:
Seungmin: i want to be a part of 3Racha.
Changbin: then i lose my Job... I.... I Lose my Job... when you walking in...
well, I.N was pretty good at imitating Changbin iconic sounds)))
Seems like Lee Know mic was little quiet 🤔
It's okay to critique as long as your being respectful which you are. Don't worry and that your good. It would be surprising if Suengmin and IN were as good or sounded the same as Changbin and Han. 😊
Yay! Im glad you reacted to this, even if it didn't fully live up to your expectations. I like your honesty 😊 This was a fun surprise for us as fans. I look forward to your Waiting For Us vocal and rap line performances!
Thank you!! 😊 And yeah it's a cool experience for the fans, love that they did this.
Seungmin😮😮😮🥳😍😍😍🫢
This was great effort from the boys! I really enjoyed it! ❤
Props to them for doing this. Very entertaining. Nothing is the same as the original but it was fun.
Absolutely love that they did this, such a great moments for the fans
I don’t think you said anything controversial haha, I think the original version of both songs are best but it’s a lot of fun to see them switch it up and do a good job of it too.
Yeah but you know how quick stans are to take anything as shade. Just wanted to explain something I noticed and also remind everyone I am stay too, I love them too lol.
I was waiting for u to put Aussie connection to the Chan Felix section 😂 They were all honestly just having fun with this...if they were being 100% serious it would have a whole other vibe lol
It took me a second but I got it! I was like "wait hold on now, me hears a bit of a twang.....oooooooooohhhhhhhh" lol
FIRST, as I've told you, I'm here for the truth, your truth! So never lie here...
SECOND, they are not called a group of ACES for nothing. They can all sing, rap, and dance.
THIRD, I totally agree with you on the rap things that you explained. I'm definitely no expert on rap, but I know that a lot goes into it, and Han and Changbin write their own verses of course cause A, It's them, and B, It's for them. So, If someone else sings the same verse It's going to sound a bit off. But, they did sound good! I haven't heard that before (really surprising for me to be true... I'm an OVER consumer of Stray Kids)
+ I know that Seungmin had some rapping lessons before, but I'm not sure about I.N lessons in general for rapping.
Before this performance, I'm sure they did work on it a lot, with a teacher or with Changbin and Han themselves.
+ For me at least, hearing I.N rap like that is even more impressive, even though Seungmin's part was way harder and he's not a professional rapper but I heard him rap before and I know that he can pull that off if he wanted to, I already know he's good, but with I.N It's different, cause I don't think that I have ever heard I.N rap seriously before, maybe just little "skits" of back and forth with 3Racha on their behind the scenes show that they have "SKZ Talker".
Ahhh okay so you were shookth like me lol. Glad we could go on this journey together
YEP! It was worth it watching it with you for the first time! @@AmariLeone
I think the performance was mainly a fun gift for Stay rather than a serious thing like you said. You're not wrong in saying the timing was slightly off and that Seungmin was being laid back. He's able to go fast but doesn't have the same kind of tone or level of practice as Han. They all still did a great job especially since it's a common thing in K-pop for rappers not to be able to sing and vocalists to not rap at all. Hence, Stay get to say we have 8 all-rounders as SKZ has 8 singers, 8 rappers, and 8 dancers. That's not even counting the producing (3RACHA), insane lyricism (3RACHA and mainly Hyunjin), and melodies (3RACHA and Hyunjin) that they do themselves. Basically, even with an imperfect performance, they're insanely talented which is why I don't think you should get a ton of hate.
Absolutely, they're an insanely talented group & I love them for it
If by producing you mean instrumental/beat making, only Chan does that in the group, 3racha is responsible for topline making (or melody, as you said). But kpop uses the term producing for lyrics+topline too so yeah if we use it that way all members produced/co-produced songs several times, that's very impressive ❤
please react to Changbin's performance of the song Tomorrow
I'll add it to my list
I also got slightly bothered by Seungmin being 1/2 a beat off in the pre-chorus. Particularly because I.N was so on top of the timing and crisp as crisp can be. I really wanted to hear that sharp back and forth too!!
You get me!!! Overall he showed that he can rap & this was just for funsies but timing is super important in rap and when it's off it's off
Please react to Stray Kids Lost me -first take….its live in a studio!!
I'll add it to my list
@@AmariLeone or any of their first takes really. 😁
Wait. I know they all can rap, but I thought Bangchan was a part of the rap line. Isn’t bangchan, changbin, han for rap line? Felix, Hyunjin, Lee Know, dance line? And Seugmin and IN vocal line? Have I had that wrong this whole time?
Based on my understanding of it:
3racha: Bangchan, Changbin & Han (Production/Writing Line & the original subunit)
Rap Racha: Han, Changbin, Felix, Hyunjin (all of these members have a rapper position well they did before they got rid of positions)
Dance Racha: Hyunjin, Lee Know, Felix
Vocal Racha: Seungmin, I.N (& Bangchan SHOULD be considered apart of this but often isn't cause he's already in 3racha)
Okay so I understand why this is confusing. They have the official subunits:
Producing/writing unit and yes also the original rap trio subunit that was formed and making music before SKZ, 3RACHA: Bang Chan, Changbin and Han. They do have their rap unit songs and still occasionally perform as a trio.
DanceRacha: Lee Know, Hyunjin and Felix
VocalRacha: Seungmin and I.N.
However these are different from the division they most often have in their songs between vocalists and rappers. Members who rap the most are Changbin, Han, Hyunjin and Felix and members who sing the most are Seungmin, I.N., Lee Know and Bang Chan. Han could be in either one though because he had to step up as a vocalist after they became 8 members.
So they all can rap and sing but obviously are more trained/comfortable in one or the other.
No I think racha units confused you but they don't represent the positions. Bang Chan is a vocalist (he does rap but not much), I don't know if you listen to their songs but Chan sings almost as much as Seungmin who is the main vocalist. 3racha is the producer unit
sorry guy but I think you're confusing some things, Stray Kids DON'T HAVE DEFINED POSITIONS, the 8 rap, the 8 sing, the 8 dance, In and Seungmin and Lee Know have already rapped on many Skz songs throughout their discography, of course it's not common but they are still rappers too, so much so that in Kingdom In who raps in part of the presentations and Lee Know at the beginning of Distric 9 started rapping, their tone is obviously different. but they still rapped very well, so much so that that's why the group doesn't have divisions like vocals, rappers and dancers, Chan said that as everyone does well in everything the group doesn't have divisions like that, Seungmin in one The program even managed to be faster than Han and Changbin hahaha
I understand that you don't usually hear them rapping but don't underestimate them, In rapping in Kingdom was very important for them to win, Seungmin always says he's going to do a project focused on rappers, and in a performance of Gods Menu he had to do Changbin's rap part because Changbin was bad that day and couldn't attend and Lee Know usually raps in Skz's discography especially on the old songs and Chan is from 3racha so it's no surprise that he does rap lol just remember that Stray Kids doesn't have a rap line, a vocal line (Chan's own words in live), the members really have a more comfortable space in one position but it doesn't mean they just stay in that position
I simply said I never heard certain members rap before so I was pleasantly surprised at how well they did. No shade was intended
These are not Chan's words love, I understand your enthusiasm but OF COURSE they have positions. Just because Seungmin and I.N rapped a few lines in some songs doesn't mean they're rappers lol, this is not a kids group. And even Lee Know mostly sings, doesn't rap much nowadays. Being a rapper isn't that easy, they never even wrote their own raps. They never rapped full verses perfectly on beat in a live performance (except this one). So no, skz aren't 8 singers and 8 rappers. Hyunjin and Felix aren't good singers (they don't have to be) and Seungmin Jeongin and Lino aren't good rappers.
I have to respectfully disagree with you on one specific issue, Felix has a beautiful singing voice. Other than that I think when People say they can all rap they are referring more to the performance aspect not writing the raps. I know that many people will say you are not a real rapper unless you write your own raps and I agree with that too a point but especially in kpop is also a skill that you add to the group overall you may not write the lyrics but you can perform the rap for the group. Changbin and Han and even Chan write their own raps but they also will perform lines written by the others so it's all about your perspective. Also Felix and Hyunjin and IN have all written raps for in songs for them.