if they do this i would love to see them revert back to the old school challenges so that the new school don’t just dominate in all these physically competitive comps
Yess I remember the chess game POV from BB6 and the pressure cooker and so many other challenges where physicality wasn’t necessary to win, and it made things so unpredictable as far as who could win it
@@MorganDanielleBeauty The pressure cooker required a different kind of physicality. Plenty of the "old school" challenges were physical. Weird how selective your memories are. You want the CD-throwing comp back?
@@danielorlovaquinn In essence, Jun claims that Julie got to where she is today by fucking her boss, Les Moonves, while he was still married. Jun continues by saying that Julie is disliked by all at CBS and is only tolerated because she is the wife of the CEO. She also claims that Julie is bad at her job because she cannot improvise and lacks talent. These are not my opinions. I neither agree or disagree with them. I don't even watch Big Brother. I just like drama.
@@danielorlovaquinn In essence, Jun claims that Julie got to where she is now because she had an affair with her boss, Les Moonves, while he was still married. She continues by saying that Julie is disliked by everyone at CBS and is only tolerated because her husband is the CEO. Additionally, Jun states that Julie is bad at her job because she can't improvise and lacks talent. These are not my opinions. I don't even watch Big Brother. I just like drama.
I definitely want to see Jun again. Out of all the winners, I think she is perhaps the most equipped to potentially outmaneuver players of a later era; she'll chew you up, spit you out & reminisce in the diary room. Jun is very observant & discreet -- it would prove difficult to manipulate or dodge her to any meaningful extent. I actually see her forging a connection with the likes of Derek or Dan -- to develop a more reliable perspective as to what they're really doing.
If they ARE able to make this happen, they absolutely need to put in some sort of twist that will counteract pregaming. With the whirlwind of rumors about this season, I'm sure most of the BB winners have already been in contact with each other, and pregaming was perhaps the biggest reason BB22 was absolute garbage. Maybe they can team them up into unlikely pairs or something and make players who haven't pregamed together play with each other.
It’s not really possible to have a returnee season without pregaming. It’s just gonna happen. The only way to counter it is to have players that aren’t afraid to go against the grain and players that are savvy enough to shift if their pregame connections don’t pan out, which an all winners cast is gonna be composed of.
Taylor would also work with Cirie, Rachel and because she'll work with Rachel she gets Jordan and Taylor would probably have Josh and Kaycee trust and Derrick and Cody would want to work with her
I just watched your video about Jun and I'll be thrilled if she comes back. It would be so amazing to watch her try and pull off her strategy again. I can already see her trying to evict the ones who have good jury management and bringing along the most hated person in the house with her to the final two.
@@nicjoy4407Definitely, also, assuming that she didn’t change it up, she would have to rely on a more hated player than her, or less respected at least. In a house with the most respected players, she’d have a hard time finding herself with anyone but the most cutthroat players and the floating strategy may be very hard considering they very likely know her strat.
Long story short a few years ago will & boogie were asked to compete on the amazing race but will said no boogie got mad as he really needed the money & threatened will & his family leading will to get a restraining order
Hayden just did an interview yesterday and said he would do an all winners season or a shortened season and said he told them yes to BB22 all stars, but they pulled out at the end.
Your proposed cast list is 🔥🔥🔥 I am so sketched out by the BB16 winners that I would never want two of them in the same returnee cast. Nicole would totally be like, "oh, this time I'm gonna beat Derrick" and then blindly follow him again, lol
Nicole Cody and Derrick are all good players but they all tried to win by using mega alliances to win, which isn’t particularly impressive and it’s why I would only want to see Derrick come back by himself to show if he really is that good or if he needs a crutch to win! Heck, it’s easy to forget that for how impressive Nicole’s win was on BB18, we only got that because she was forced to regroup after her mega alliance fell through. Had that not happened we never would have seen how good a player she is!
Every guy who won deserved it (Except maybe Evil Dick). There's been some awful ones after the season (Adam, Boogie, Jackson, Andy, Dick, Drew?) But they all dominated their seasons. Plus Dr Will and Dan are the 2 greatest players of all time. The women who won have all deserved it too. Except Rachel. Her season was so MF rigged.
@totaldramatyler4484 no I agree completely like they all have deserved it, I just hope we get lots of great female players and competitors in the future!
I NEED Rachel on my screen again, she’s such good tv and seeing the more mature and level headed yet still the same feisty Rachel on Traitors gave me everything I needed. She’s a lock for this cast and hey, if Cirie is there too (if she wins this season) I think we’re in for a major power duo for the ages.
Rachel would make way too much sense considering she’s just as memorable and iconic as she was before but now she has much more of a general appeal that would make her less divisive than she was on her seasons! I agree with this take wholeheartedly!
I know! Her snake on the grass / amazing race with Elissa / the traitors performances were amazing. She did great and got so far given the circumstances.
If they cast Eddie, Jun and Lisa, I really hope they cast Drew too, because I could see new school targeting old school and I'm not sure if Eddie, Jun or Lisa would be able to win those hohs.
Aren't some of the early winners already in their forties, if not late thirties? I really like them, and I would LOVE to have another season. I do think that age/early game winners is going to be a big factor if we're talking about willingness to participate again.
Man I kind of feel bad for Steve how the producers like to pretend he didn't exist. Like you can tell production was rooting hard for Vanessa only for Steve to snipe her at the end. lol
I love your cast list, complete agreement about who'd make the cut. Josh and Rachel would be the chaotic frenemies we've all been waiting for in the past few seasons.
I feel like Xavier or Kaycee are going far in literally any season, so I can see them doing it. It really depends on if the winners really would want to potentially taint their legacy though. Just like drag race, nobody wants to go home first and be seen as the "worst winner" or whatever, so they combated that with no eliminations. I just dont know if it would happen, other than for them to get paycheck. I also think a season of only 3 weeks is not long enough. Maybe not 3 months but I would like AT LEAST one month and a half.
lol are you also obsessed with drag race? I love competition shows but bb and dr both have such major flaws in the competition aspect, which sucks as i want then to feel competitive
It feels like something that if does happen, everyone will get high expectations for seeing it, the less popular winners will join up to make a majority alliance, final three is something like Nicole/Adam/Cody and everyone ends up hating it primarily because their favorites go home early (see BB22)
@@scottc2076 Probably not first couple, but I can easily see her in a 12 player shortened season just getting sniped out in 9th if her side doesnt win HoH and the wrong person wins veto as most people will probably have the "she got taken to the end last time and won, lets not make the same mistake" opinion
@@scottc2076 people would want to work with Taylor like Andy, Xavier, Rachel, Derrick and Cody, Kaycee, Josh but I feel like Taylor will do whatever it takes to make sure a girl wins because she wants to protect women, Taylor is basically guaranteed jury In an all winner season, and in a interview Taylor was asked "who do you think would do well in an all winner season" she replied "I think Dan is the first boot and Me, Jun, Rachel and maybe Andy are the final 4.
12:29 That's hilarious to me, because I think Steve is the only winner who could play the exact same game as their winning game in a mixed returnee-newbie season and win.
i’m only hoping for 2 things: 1. the rumors are true 2. they don’t ruin it with many twists, let the game play out by itself the only twist i’ll take is invisible HOH and double eviction.
I feel if they make the all winners season, here is my things I think they would do/add: 1) Adding some international winners of Big Brother( like Canada or the U.K. for example) because I feel it will be interesting if some international winners play against the American winners of Big Brother 2) the All Stars 7 format. I think for a format Drag race did for that AS season( which was an All Winners season) is that none of the winners would be eliminated, a point system would be added to determine the final 2. Basically a simular format to AS7, but BB makes it their own version that makes sense.
A shorter game also works. This is all-winners. Winners don't get a week to plan. They're winners now. They've played the game. They know how this game work, & it's more fun with a faster game for them.
I think a Contenders/Winners season, or something like that, is more likely than just Winners. I just don't think they'll be able to get enough just Winners; too many will either not be asked back (Dick, Adam, Jackson, etc.), wouldn't come back even if invited, or just wouldn't be able to make the schedules work. And a Winners season would likely have a lot of earlier season players, which I don't think CBS would want for their ratings. Only the diehards like us even remember people like Drew Daniel or Lisa Donahue. I think CBS would rather have Janelle back AGAIN than some of the early winners. In fact, a Redemption/So Close type of season with people like Janelle, Paul, and Tyler would probably get a lot more viewers than an all Winners season, as strange as that might sound at first. But I'm down for either!
Maybe I sound like a big baby, but if it's not all winners or a super legends season with many winners on the cast, then just give me celeb 4 or all new players. Something about it would just feel so weird to me/unnecessary otherwise since we just got All-Stars 2 so recently - but that's just my opinion!
The only non-winners I would be okay with extending the invite to would be Danielle Reyes, Eric Stein, Paul A., Vanessa, or Tiffany. Other than that you might as well make it AS3, which no one really wants right now, or like you said include spinoffs and maybe even BBCan winners since Rachel has that connection. @@Ethanimale
@@ryanmclaughlin3197I’d love for Micheal to come back from last season. Since he tied Janelles record for most wins, it’s only right he comes back as well
... I REALLY don't ever need to see Janelle play yet again. She's already played four times in a game where a lot of deserving players haven't even been asked back to play a second time. We really don't need to see her play a fifth season and see her taint her legacy even further getting booted pre-jury for the third time in a row. She's not BB6/BB7 Janelle anymore and people really need to learn how to accept that.
This season being brought to life is crazy just like how if "The Best HOH Celebrations In Big Brother History" would be crazy if it was brought to life
The way I now NEED a Tamar/Jun/Taylor finale night... you're (hopefully) speaking into existence something I never could have dreamed of with this list, good sir!
Thanks, Ethanimale, now you got me super excited! My hopes of this happening before watching your excellent video was at a 2. Now, it's at an 8! After watching Sharon's interview with Hayden, he seems unlikely; however, money is a strong motivator. I would love it if they did a North American or international winners season. That would alleviate the small pool of female winners, and, selfishly, I would love to see Kevin Jacobs go up against some of the best to have ever played.
This would be an awesome cast, how about a season of big brother with known people from other shows like the challenge, survivor, etc? I’d love to see Johnny Bananas on the show
Hayden just said in an interview with Sharon Tharp that he would consider going in again for a shorter season but would probably not do it after they cut him last minute for BB22
my favorite winners are jun, dan, and ian. love danielle reyes but obviously she wouldn’t be included in this since she didn’t take the win ig lmao. i would sell my soul to see dan play as hard as he’s played before again - especially because i never watched his seasons live! would also sell my soul to see jun return. i think the beef with julie was awhile ago so i hope all’s forgiven because i need to see her face on an all winner’s cast reveal pls 🤞🏿 dan, jun, josh, drew, lisa, taylor, andy, xavier, hayden are among my favorites to see return i think. i can’t comment much on bb1 and bb9 winners because i have yet to watch their seasons in full (was always told just never to watch bb1 due to it being boring to sit through lol). dan may be very wishful thinking but i won’t give up hope.
To be honest. I think Jackson Mickie is a must for an all winners season. He’s the outsider amongst the personalizes and cliches of the winners. He’s also the only recent winner to really win his way to end and would be a needed physical competition opposition to keep an alliance combo of Kaycee, Cody, X, and Josh from steaming rolling the season via dominating every HoH. The fact he’s controversial would only make it more entertaining to see how he plays the game a 2nd time.
on ian - he replied to da'vonne's retweet of the bb reindeer games 2 hypothetical cast that had him on it and seemed interested, even if jokingly. i also think part of the reason he didnt have a good time on bb22 was bc he was forced to stick by nicole since she was the only other winner. i think in a season of all winners he would be a lot more willing to make a big move. he also likely wouldnt want to work with nicole after last time (thank god). maybe im just being delusional bc i would love to see him on a season where he would actually play. i would love to see him again in general lol
I think another theme for a season that would be interesting big brother USA versus Canada where half the cast is Canadian and the other half is American
I think if they really wanted to do this, it wouldn’t be difficult to pull an AS7 and call someone up from Canada if they needed to. Especially considering BB25 already has basically been an honorary season of BBCAN.
I JUST know wither Jun and andy will either work together closely or will try to get rid of each other whenever they can, they won similarly but difference is Jun was cut throat while Andy sugarcoated alot T-T
Jordan said recently on their podcast that she would never play again. Hayden recently said on another podcast that he’d consider it. Rachel DEFINITELY would play.
Pretty sure Maggie is a guaranteed no considering the wrongful death thing that she was caught talking about. Dick for sure too because he would probably be considered a genuine health risk.
Glad someone remembers how monstrous Maggot was. She dropped off the face of the earth for a reason, but most of the young superfans think if there's no [citation]. You can show them a transcript and they'll claim it's bogus or she was just strategizing. Absolutely insane.
My Cast: Eddie Unknown Will Lock? Lisa Lock Jun Lock? Drew Unknown Dan Lock? Hayden Lock? Rachel Lock Derrick Lock? Nicole Space Filler Cody Space Filler Xavier Space Filler Taylor Lock Marissa Space Filler Tamar Lock Meisha Lock?
Not an interview but Nicole did mention on IG that she "dreams" of waking up in the BB house again lol. I think her career kinda depends on keeping her name out there so considering how much press All-Winners seasons get and since CBS is definitely giving out a lot of money for this, I'm sure she's a lock.
I only have two comments on these picks since I could say way too much here: 1. As much as I hate Derrick and Cody as people, I would happily see Derrick compete on a second season without any pregaming or past connections to benefit him since that would really prove how much of his win was his own skill and how much was based on twists and benefitting from outside factors like a mega alliance and misogyny! 2. I would love to see Taylor come back but I also would completely understand if Taylor decided she didn’t want to risk a second occurrence of what happened to her during the first few weeks of BB24! That was emotionally traumatic for both her and many of the fans and I would not wish that shit on anybody!
Adam would be so cool to see again with his epic redemption story! Plus I have Jacob on Big Brother 25 OTEV! So maybe CBS is finally ready to remain people to big brother nine exist?
I don't like the idea of a super shortened season personally. I think winning it would come with a big asterisk, which would especially be a bummer for a 2x winner. I think bb has to be like 60 days at the shortest and a minimum of 12 hgs. I really do hope they start bringing back former hgs a lot more again though, it's always really cool to see how they change as people and players.
Thank you ethanimale for your videos!! We appreciate you taking time out of your day to make these for us🩷🩷Love you!! I remember Jun posted something on twitter the other day abt how she wants to meet kaycee on all-winners, i just started the video so im not sure if u mention it💀but i think thats a sign
CBS is gonna fight hard to get WIll and Dan given how iconic they are to BB lore even to the casuals. I'll be very surprised if they do this season without at least one of them playing.
These videos are so much fun to watch! Love the speculation. Makes me ponder about a season with the biggest blindside evictees or perhaps one with the first houseguest voted out? Bitter much? 🤣
I listened to that last night. He certainly gave some mixed signals, because although he did say that, he also said he would be interested if CBS contacted him for a shortened all winner season
I actually strongly believe that Derrick would not play again... He pre-gamed hard for CODY to go back in the house, but I think he knows his legacy would be at stake and its not worth it. I don't think Derrick would go in and want to be first boot because he'd be up there. Dan would 100% do it. The sad thing is that if they do this, they couldn't do BB: Legends for a while or really ever. There are many Legends who expressed major interest in a shortened season (like Danielle and Janelle), but most of them weren't winners so idk. If Winners couldn't work, especially due to women, they could switch to Legends too
I think the gender/ethnic diversity wouldn’t really matter in a situation like this because there’s only so many people you can choose. It’s not like survivor where you had like 38 different winners. So I. Think it would be understandable if there was an imbalance. Also, if Will and Dan are not on the season with Derrick he’s going to be targeted so hard it wouldn’t be fun. Will/Dan had the, how would they do on a return season mystery to them and they both proved it. Derrick doesn’t have that same advantage and they would just get him out as soon as they can. There’s only so much you can do and that goes for Dan/Will too not just Derrick.
Interesting idea might be an all 3rd place season. Lot of big names with big moves taken out in 3rd because the finalists were scared of a final 2 with them.
It might happen but honestly I need BB Production to really crack down on their bad twists and unbalanced comps. Seriously, bad twists ruin good seasons.
Some of these people are in their 40s, approaching 50. Would someone of that age want to spend 3 months in a house all them years later? Or do any good? I think you get 10 past winners at most wanting to do it again, and two winners have done it three times and another i believe six past winners have done it twice.
Question - Would you retroactively put Jag here? While his motivation for innitially coming on is null, He did say it was one of the best experiences he's had iirc 🤔
So Hayden according to his Sharon Tharp interview said he's a likely no in actuality due to friction with production, but his ears perked at the shortened season prospect. Hayden would be a big disruptor to some of the other cast members so I'd like to see him on.
Jordan and Jeff have a podcast and just last month she said she never wanted to do Big Brother again. But who knows, maybe things would change if it was a short season. Derek and Cody have both said they’d do a shortened winner season and that neither would come unless they were both there.
And now for the recent winner, Jag: Yeah, sure. They def would call him, since he is kinda unique in the circle. As one wild drag queen once said: "They need someone to go home first"
Idk what do you call this season idea what the concept is you take one person from each place for example, who take someone who place second lake Monty someone who plays third like JC so on and so forth. I just think it would be fun to see people who got deep into the game and maybe got robbed and good players who didn’t make it far.
I’m just sad Paul doesn’t have a chance. Yes, his jury management is terrible, but he is one hell of a strategist and would love to see him go against winners. Just wish he would’ve won.
I like how realistic ur cast is but jesus christ that would be so underwhelming to have only 1 of my top 2 winners oat (Dan, Derrick, Will, Cody, Andy) my dream cast with being semi-realistic would be Cody Derrick Dan Xavier Andy Hayden Jun Kaycee Taylor Lisa Rachael
Josh Martinez being the only two time Big Brother winner would make any season post BB20 with it 😂😂 (With that being said, I have yet to even finish BB22 -24 (despite hearing some good things about 23 and 24) because the toxic fanbase makes the show less fun to watch and since I'm someone who loves to share my thoughts about my favorite reality competition shows, the constant toxicity steered me away from being a fan of the show)
It could only be during winter when BB Celeb took place. 3 weeks, 14 people, 50% POC quota, and they would have to use winners from US, BB OTT, BB CAN, and Celeb BB. Tamar, Miesha, Morgan, Taylor, Kaycee, Rachel, Paris, Tychon, Xavier, Josh, Dan, Derrick, Andy, and Kevin Jacobs. Alternates: Sarah, Marissa, Jun, Terrell, Eddie, and Hayden.
i know it's a different type of show but when drag race (US line) did an all winners season one of the contestant was from one of the uk seasons, so i could see the producers asking one of the canadian, australia or uk winners to compete
I’ll admit i’m not the biggest Josh fan but after he recent appearance in The Challenge USA 2… i think he wins an all winners. period. He’s really shown how great his social and strategic game is and he will also do well in the challenges.
I think CBS has been leaning into redemption stories. While not BB, Survivors biggest characters in the last two seasons are Carolyn - a recovering addict, and Jesse- who spent time in jail, so I still wouldn't count out Adam. Can come out, have a nice segment on how he turned his life around & really remove alot of the stigma on his win // Big Brother 9.
If Derrick joins an all winners season he would have the HARDEST beginning of any player because everyone on the cast knows how good he is and they will all be gunning for him But if he does somehow gets out of that situation then he'd 100% be the greatest player of all time (I don't think Derrick will win but he definitely could find a way to win against all the odds) I think that Derrick's biggest obstacle is Andy and I genuinely believe that Andy could get Derrick out
Hayden just said on an interview he told them never to call him again after they pulled the plug on him for 22 because he felt they pulled the plug because he’s too far conservative
if they do this i would love to see them revert back to the old school challenges so that the new school don’t just dominate in all these physically competitive comps
Yesssss but they would never even think of that lol
Yess I remember the chess game POV from BB6 and the pressure cooker and so many other challenges where physicality wasn’t necessary to win, and it made things so unpredictable as far as who could win it
@@MorganDanielleBeauty Those are the best challenges!
It should only the the most iconic challenges in BB history. Run them through the pressure cooker.
@@MorganDanielleBeauty The pressure cooker required a different kind of physicality. Plenty of the "old school" challenges were physical. Weird how selective your memories are. You want the CD-throwing comp back?
Jun was one of my favorite winners before I heard that she trash talks Julie. She has only gone up since learning that info.
😂😂😂
Wait what happened?
What’s so wrong with Julie?
@@danielorlovaquinn In essence, Jun claims that Julie got to where she is today by fucking her boss, Les Moonves, while he was still married. Jun continues by saying that Julie is disliked by all at CBS and is only tolerated because she is the wife of the CEO. She also claims that Julie is bad at her job because she cannot improvise and lacks talent. These are not my opinions. I neither agree or disagree with them. I don't even watch Big Brother. I just like drama.
@@danielorlovaquinn In essence, Jun claims that Julie got to where she is now because she had an affair with her boss, Les Moonves, while he was still married. She continues by saying that Julie is disliked by everyone at CBS and is only tolerated because her husband is the CEO. Additionally, Jun states that Julie is bad at her job because she can't improvise and lacks talent. These are not my opinions. I don't even watch Big Brother. I just like drama.
I definitely want to see Jun again. Out of all the winners, I think she is perhaps the most equipped to potentially outmaneuver players of a later era; she'll chew you up, spit you out & reminisce in the diary room. Jun is very observant & discreet -- it would prove difficult to manipulate or dodge her to any meaningful extent. I actually see her forging a connection with the likes of Derek or Dan -- to develop a more reliable perspective as to what they're really doing.
If they ARE able to make this happen, they absolutely need to put in some sort of twist that will counteract pregaming. With the whirlwind of rumors about this season, I'm sure most of the BB winners have already been in contact with each other, and pregaming was perhaps the biggest reason BB22 was absolute garbage. Maybe they can team them up into unlikely pairs or something and make players who haven't pregamed together play with each other.
I would like to see maybe a BBCanada winner come on similar to how The Vivienne came on All Winners for Drag Race
@@SignatureFox713theyd just get instantly targeted
@@mechanicalthephantomonial7757 or, alternatively, they’re the “free agent”
psst… chilltown pregamed in all stars 1. it changes near nothing
It’s not really possible to have a returnee season without pregaming. It’s just gonna happen. The only way to counter it is to have players that aren’t afraid to go against the grain and players that are savvy enough to shift if their pregame connections don’t pan out, which an all winners cast is gonna be composed of.
Thank you for using Kaycee’s best DR. Also, can you imagine a Taylor/Tamar/Jun alliance??? Make it happen CBS
PLEASE do NOT bring back Nicole Franzel!!!
Taylor would also work with Cirie, Rachel and because she'll work with Rachel she gets Jordan and Taylor would probably have Josh and Kaycee trust and Derrick and Cody would want to work with her
Derrick and Cody would rather work with Taylor over Franzel because everyone knows Taylor is trustworthy
Cirie may not want anything to do with big brother. have you SEEN her this season? gold, but shes also very annoyed at this game@@Ace_5Hunter
@@cwcamper9091we need someone to go home first !!
I just watched your video about Jun and I'll be thrilled if she comes back. It would be so amazing to watch her try and pull off her strategy again. I can already see her trying to evict the ones who have good jury management and bringing along the most hated person in the house with her to the final two.
The main issue would be that everyone knows her game plan, so I think she'd need to switch up a bit to succeed, but I would love to see it happen.
@@nicjoy4407Definitely, also, assuming that she didn’t change it up, she would have to rely on a more hated player than her, or less respected at least. In a house with the most respected players, she’d have a hard time finding herself with anyone but the most cutthroat players and the floating strategy may be very hard considering they very likely know her strat.
Dr. Will has a restraining order against Boogie?!? What the heck did I miss??? 😂
Long story short a few years ago will & boogie were asked to compete on the amazing race but will said no boogie got mad as he really needed the money & threatened will & his family leading will to get a restraining order
Hayden just did an interview yesterday and said he would do an all winners season or a shortened season and said he told them yes to BB22 all stars, but they pulled out at the end.
He would have made the season more interesting because I think he should/would replace Cody
Your proposed cast list is 🔥🔥🔥
I am so sketched out by the BB16 winners that I would never want two of them in the same returnee cast. Nicole would totally be like, "oh, this time I'm gonna beat Derrick" and then blindly follow him again, lol
Yeah that's unfortunately kinda how I feel about it as well
Nicole Cody and Derrick are all good players but they all tried to win by using mega alliances to win, which isn’t particularly impressive and it’s why I would only want to see Derrick come back by himself to show if he really is that good or if he needs a crutch to win!
Heck, it’s easy to forget that for how impressive Nicole’s win was on BB18, we only got that because she was forced to regroup after her mega alliance fell through. Had that not happened we never would have seen how good a player she is!
Woah TheRealJims I didn’t know you were a Big Brother fan
@@TheCreativiTeamposts It is one of my bigger vices, lol
seeing you here stunlocked me for a second lmao
idk why but i want all the 2nd placed players competing in 1 competition
paul would fucking crush it
I. Did not realize how few women have won big brother 😅 these girls better get these boys out in 25!!! Cmon we need to fill out the ranks out ladies!!
Every guy who won deserved it (Except maybe Evil Dick). There's been some awful ones after the season (Adam, Boogie, Jackson, Andy, Dick, Drew?) But they all dominated their seasons. Plus Dr Will and Dan are the 2 greatest players of all time.
The women who won have all deserved it too. Except Rachel. Her season was so MF rigged.
@totaldramatyler4484 no I agree completely like they all have deserved it, I just hope we get lots of great female players and competitors in the future!
I NEED Rachel on my screen again, she’s such good tv and seeing the more mature and level headed yet still the same feisty Rachel on Traitors gave me everything I needed. She’s a lock for this cast and hey, if Cirie is there too (if she wins this season) I think we’re in for a major power duo for the ages.
Rachel would make way too much sense considering she’s just as memorable and iconic as she was before but now she has much more of a general appeal that would make her less divisive than she was on her seasons! I agree with this take wholeheartedly!
Please…No!!
I know! Her snake on the grass / amazing race with Elissa / the traitors performances were amazing. She did great and got so far given the circumstances.
The end clip of Lisa crying into her dads arms with the winners jingle playing gotta be the best shot of big brother history
If they cast Eddie, Jun and Lisa, I really hope they cast Drew too, because I could see new school targeting old school and I'm not sure if Eddie, Jun or Lisa would be able to win those hohs.
very fair argument. In that case, Drew would be a good choice
Aren't some of the early winners already in their forties, if not late thirties? I really like them, and I would LOVE to have another season. I do think that age/early game winners is going to be a big factor if we're talking about willingness to participate again.
Lisa proving everyone that she deserved her win would be so iconic
Man I kind of feel bad for Steve how the producers like to pretend he didn't exist. Like you can tell production was rooting hard for Vanessa only for Steve to snipe her at the end. lol
I love your cast list, complete agreement about who'd make the cut. Josh and Rachel would be the chaotic frenemies we've all been waiting for in the past few seasons.
I feel like Xavier or Kaycee are going far in literally any season, so I can see them doing it. It really depends on if the winners really would want to potentially taint their legacy though. Just like drag race, nobody wants to go home first and be seen as the "worst winner" or whatever, so they combated that with no eliminations. I just dont know if it would happen, other than for them to get paycheck. I also think a season of only 3 weeks is not long enough. Maybe not 3 months but I would like AT LEAST one month and a half.
lol are you also obsessed with drag race? I love competition shows but bb and dr both have such major flaws in the competition aspect, which sucks as i want then to feel competitive
Andy and Jun are working together for sure! And you say I was rolling out videos fast 😂
It feels like something that if does happen, everyone will get high expectations for seeing it, the less popular winners will join up to make a majority alliance, final three is something like Nicole/Adam/Cody and everyone ends up hating it primarily because their favorites go home early (see BB22)
exactly
Nicole, Derrick and Cody would have an alliance
I don’t think Taylor would go home early at the least
@@scottc2076 Probably not first couple, but I can easily see her in a 12 player shortened season just getting sniped out in 9th if her side doesnt win HoH and the wrong person wins veto as most people will probably have the "she got taken to the end last time and won, lets not make the same mistake" opinion
@@scottc2076 people would want to work with Taylor like Andy, Xavier, Rachel, Derrick and Cody, Kaycee, Josh but I feel like Taylor will do whatever it takes to make sure a girl wins because she wants to protect women, Taylor is basically guaranteed jury In an all winner season, and in a interview Taylor was asked "who do you think would do well in an all winner season" she replied "I think Dan is the first boot and Me, Jun, Rachel and maybe Andy are the final 4.
12:29 That's hilarious to me, because I think Steve is the only winner who could play the exact same game as their winning game in a mixed returnee-newbie season and win.
I’m sorry but when you said “TAYLOR MOTHERF**KING HALE” I felt that in my soul.
i’m only hoping for 2 things:
1. the rumors are true
2. they don’t ruin it with many twists, let the game play out by itself
the only twist i’ll take is invisible HOH and double eviction.
I feel if they make the all winners season, here is my things I think they would do/add:
1) Adding some international winners of Big Brother( like Canada or the U.K. for example) because I feel it will be interesting if some international winners play against the American winners of Big Brother
2) the All Stars 7 format. I think for a format Drag race did for that AS season( which was an All Winners season) is that none of the winners would be eliminated, a point system would be added to determine the final 2. Basically a simular format to AS7, but BB makes it their own version that makes sense.
A shorter game also works. This is all-winners. Winners don't get a week to plan. They're winners now. They've played the game. They know how this game work, & it's more fun with a faster game for them.
I want a winners versus legends (best to never win) season soooo bad. Or winners versus runner ups
"I want to see my hero Dan again!" Will doesn't want to come back.
@@ninedaysjane2466 I said this mostly for Danielle Reyes to come back I know she was on reindeer games but I want her for a full season
I would rather we get second chances. I want a new winner. Someone that deserved it, but didn’t get it (i.e.: Michael, Tyler, Derek X.).
Jason
@@memeview2566 From BB 19? Sure!
@@nintendopro0391 no from bb 2 I think
An Adam redemption arc would be the funniest possible thing to witness
Eddie did play a different game, but he still had a strategy. He knew who he would lose against.
I think a Contenders/Winners season, or something like that, is more likely than just Winners. I just don't think they'll be able to get enough just Winners; too many will either not be asked back (Dick, Adam, Jackson, etc.), wouldn't come back even if invited, or just wouldn't be able to make the schedules work. And a Winners season would likely have a lot of earlier season players, which I don't think CBS would want for their ratings. Only the diehards like us even remember people like Drew Daniel or Lisa Donahue. I think CBS would rather have Janelle back AGAIN than some of the early winners. In fact, a Redemption/So Close type of season with people like Janelle, Paul, and Tyler would probably get a lot more viewers than an all Winners season, as strange as that might sound at first. But I'm down for either!
Maybe I sound like a big baby, but if it's not all winners or a super legends season with many winners on the cast, then just give me celeb 4 or all new players. Something about it would just feel so weird to me/unnecessary otherwise since we just got All-Stars 2 so recently - but that's just my opinion!
The only non-winners I would be okay with extending the invite to would be Danielle Reyes, Eric Stein, Paul A., Vanessa, or Tiffany. Other than that you might as well make it AS3, which no one really wants right now, or like you said include spinoffs and maybe even BBCan winners since Rachel has that connection.
@@Ethanimale
@@ryanmclaughlin3197I’d love for Micheal to come back from last season. Since he tied Janelles record for most wins, it’s only right he comes back as well
... I REALLY don't ever need to see Janelle play yet again. She's already played four times in a game where a lot of deserving players haven't even been asked back to play a second time. We really don't need to see her play a fifth season and see her taint her legacy even further getting booted pre-jury for the third time in a row. She's not BB6/BB7 Janelle anymore and people really need to learn how to accept that.
@@davidmernick7360 NEVER!! Haha.
I my opinion, I doubt that CBS will cast Eddie for an all winners season since they have to work the physical comps around Eddies physical disability
This season being brought to life is crazy just like how if "The Best HOH Celebrations In Big Brother History" would be crazy if it was brought to life
The way I now NEED a Tamar/Jun/Taylor finale night... you're (hopefully) speaking into existence something I never could have dreamed of with this list, good sir!
I’d love to see Hayden and Jun back. So good.
I would root for Lisa so hard. I was rooting for Danielle all of season 3, but it would be great to see her again.
Loved that you brought up Tamar to come back. Shes often overlooked but she played a great game while also entertaining us live feeders 😊
Didn’t know that about Adam. Happy to hear he’s turned his life around. I would love to see him back
Thanks, Ethanimale, now you got me super excited! My hopes of this happening before watching your excellent video was at a 2. Now, it's at an 8! After watching Sharon's interview with Hayden, he seems unlikely; however, money is a strong motivator. I would love it if they did a North American or international winners season. That would alleviate the small pool of female winners, and, selfishly, I would love to see Kevin Jacobs go up against some of the best to have ever played.
This would be an awesome cast, how about a season of big brother with known people from other shows like the challenge, survivor, etc? I’d love to see Johnny Bananas on the show
Lisa hugging her dad after she won was so beautiful ❤
I’m rewatching 14 right now and my god I would give anything to watch Dan in an all winners season lol
I am going to hold out hope for it lol
Winter Big Brother? I hope this is better than the last time we Big Brother 9 since that season sucks!
Hayden just said in an interview with Sharon Tharp that he would consider going in again for a shorter season but would probably not do it after they cut him last minute for BB22
OMG YES INCLUDE THE SPIN OFF WINNERS! They were all deserving!
my favorite winners are jun, dan, and ian. love danielle reyes but obviously she wouldn’t be included in this since she didn’t take the win ig lmao. i would sell my soul to see dan play as hard as he’s played before again - especially because i never watched his seasons live! would also sell my soul to see jun return. i think the beef with julie was awhile ago so i hope all’s forgiven because i need to see her face on an all winner’s cast reveal pls 🤞🏿 dan, jun, josh, drew, lisa, taylor, andy, xavier, hayden are among my favorites to see return i think. i can’t comment much on bb1 and bb9 winners because i have yet to watch their seasons in full (was always told just never to watch bb1 due to it being boring to sit through lol). dan may be very wishful thinking but i won’t give up hope.
What I wouldn't give to see Dan play at 110% just one more time.
Also holy moly thank you so much!!
Dan’s too streamer-pilled to go for round three at this point. Too busy doing it for the 596
To be honest. I think Jackson Mickie is a must for an all winners season. He’s the outsider amongst the personalizes and cliches of the winners. He’s also the only recent winner to really win his way to end and would be a needed physical competition opposition to keep an alliance combo of Kaycee, Cody, X, and Josh from steaming rolling the season via dominating every HoH.
The fact he’s controversial would only make it more entertaining to see how he plays the game a 2nd time.
on ian - he replied to da'vonne's retweet of the bb reindeer games 2 hypothetical cast that had him on it and seemed interested, even if jokingly. i also think part of the reason he didnt have a good time on bb22 was bc he was forced to stick by nicole since she was the only other winner. i think in a season of all winners he would be a lot more willing to make a big move. he also likely wouldnt want to work with nicole after last time (thank god). maybe im just being delusional bc i would love to see him on a season where he would actually play. i would love to see him again in general lol
I think another theme for a season that would be interesting big brother USA versus Canada where half the cast is Canadian and the other half is American
Love the tab being names "My cast and why it would rock"
Im new to the big brother series thanks to this youtube channel, i was disappointed to learn the all stars wasn't already all winners.
I think if they really wanted to do this, it wouldn’t be difficult to pull an AS7 and call someone up from Canada if they needed to. Especially considering BB25 already has basically been an honorary season of BBCAN.
I JUST know wither Jun and andy will either work together closely or will try to get rid of each other whenever they can, they won similarly but difference is Jun was cut throat while Andy sugarcoated alot T-T
Can you do a video about the best/worst instances jury management?
Jordan said recently on their podcast that she would never play again. Hayden recently said on another podcast that he’d consider it. Rachel DEFINITELY would play.
Pretty sure Maggie is a guaranteed no considering the wrongful death thing that she was caught talking about. Dick for sure too because he would probably be considered a genuine health risk.
Glad someone remembers how monstrous Maggot was. She dropped off the face of the earth for a reason, but most of the young superfans think if there's no [citation]. You can show them a transcript and they'll claim it's bogus or she was just strategizing. Absolutely insane.
The season should be called Winner Winter
My Cast:
Eddie Unknown
Will Lock?
Lisa Lock
Jun Lock?
Drew Unknown
Dan Lock?
Hayden Lock?
Rachel Lock
Derrick Lock?
Nicole Space Filler
Cody Space Filler
Xavier Space Filler
Taylor Lock
Marissa Space Filler
Tamar Lock
Meisha Lock?
Derrick would be a NO. If you follow the winners circle, you will know he promised his girls he wouldn't.
Wouldn’t be an All-Winners Season without Ethanimale videos!
I feel like Andy would have the highest chance to win twice considering how perfect his game was in BB15
Not an interview but Nicole did mention on IG that she "dreams" of waking up in the BB house again lol. I think her career kinda depends on keeping her name out there so considering how much press All-Winners seasons get and since CBS is definitely giving out a lot of money for this, I'm sure she's a lock.
I only have two comments on these picks since I could say way too much here:
1. As much as I hate Derrick and Cody as people, I would happily see Derrick compete on a second season without any pregaming or past connections to benefit him since that would really prove how much of his win was his own skill and how much was based on twists and benefitting from outside factors like a mega alliance and misogyny!
2. I would love to see Taylor come back but I also would completely understand if Taylor decided she didn’t want to risk a second occurrence of what happened to her during the first few weeks of BB24! That was emotionally traumatic for both her and many of the fans and I would not wish that shit on anybody!
Adam would be so cool to see again with his epic redemption story! Plus I have Jacob on Big Brother 25 OTEV! So maybe CBS is finally ready to remain people to big brother nine exist?
Honestly this is awesome lineup
I don't like the idea of a super shortened season personally. I think winning it would come with a big asterisk, which would especially be a bummer for a 2x winner. I think bb has to be like 60 days at the shortest and a minimum of 12 hgs. I really do hope they start bringing back former hgs a lot more again though, it's always really cool to see how they change as people and players.
Omg if they do All Winners and Julie Chen vetoes Jun being on we need to protest 😭
Thank you ethanimale for your videos!! We appreciate you taking time out of your day to make these for us🩷🩷Love you!! I remember Jun posted something on twitter the other day abt how she wants to meet kaycee on all-winners, i just started the video so im not sure if u mention it💀but i think thats a sign
CBS is gonna fight hard to get WIll and Dan given how iconic they are to BB lore even to the casuals. I'll be very surprised if they do this season without at least one of them playing.
These videos are so much fun to watch! Love the speculation. Makes me ponder about a season with the biggest blindside evictees or perhaps one with the first houseguest voted out? Bitter much? 🤣
Hayden just did an interview with Sharon Tharp and said he wouldn't come back to reality tv at this point 😕
I listened to that last night. He certainly gave some mixed signals, because although he did say that, he also said he would be interested if CBS contacted him for a shortened all winner season
Maybe their could Big Brother All Winner USA vs Canada! With an mix of US and Canada winners!
I actually strongly believe that Derrick would not play again... He pre-gamed hard for CODY to go back in the house, but I think he knows his legacy would be at stake and its not worth it. I don't think Derrick would go in and want to be first boot because he'd be up there. Dan would 100% do it.
The sad thing is that if they do this, they couldn't do BB: Legends for a while or really ever. There are many Legends who expressed major interest in a shortened season (like Danielle and Janelle), but most of them weren't winners so idk. If Winners couldn't work, especially due to women, they could switch to Legends too
I think the gender/ethnic diversity wouldn’t really matter in a situation like this because there’s only so many people you can choose. It’s not like survivor where you had like 38 different winners. So I. Think it would be understandable if there was an imbalance.
Also, if Will and Dan are not on the season with Derrick he’s going to be targeted so hard it wouldn’t be fun. Will/Dan had the, how would they do on a return season mystery to them and they both proved it. Derrick doesn’t have that same advantage and they would just get him out as soon as they can. There’s only so much you can do and that goes for Dan/Will too not just Derrick.
you should do injuries that people sustained while in teh big brothger house. Christmas, Bridget, Victoria's wisdom teeth, etc
Interesting idea might be an all 3rd place season. Lot of big names with big moves taken out in 3rd because the finalists were scared of a final 2 with them.
It might happen but honestly I need BB Production to really crack down on their bad twists and unbalanced comps.
Seriously, bad twists ruin good seasons.
Ok hear me out. All first boot season
Some of these people are in their 40s, approaching 50. Would someone of that age want to spend 3 months in a house all them years later? Or do any good? I think you get 10 past winners at most wanting to do it again, and two winners have done it three times and another i believe six past winners have done it twice.
They need to do winners and favorites because people want to see Vanessa for sure.
Question - Would you retroactively put Jag here? While his motivation for innitially coming on is null, He did say it was one of the best experiences he's had iirc 🤔
So Hayden according to his Sharon Tharp interview said he's a likely no in actuality due to friction with production, but his ears perked at the shortened season prospect. Hayden would be a big disruptor to some of the other cast members so I'd like to see him on.
Jordan and Jeff have a podcast and just last month she said she never wanted to do Big Brother again. But who knows, maybe things would change if it was a short season.
Derek and Cody have both said they’d do a shortened winner season and that neither would come unless they were both there.
If all winners happens Paul needs to come in and host a comp😂
My only concern would be new school completely steamrolling, but besides that this cast is fantastic “chefs kiss” 👏
And now for the recent winner, Jag: Yeah, sure. They def would call him, since he is kinda unique in the circle. As one wild drag queen once said: "They need someone to go home first"
You lost me at Tamar 😂
Idk what do you call this season idea what the concept is you take one person from each place for example, who take someone who place second lake Monty someone who plays third like JC so on and so forth. I just think it would be fun to see people who got deep into the game and maybe got robbed and good players who didn’t make it far.
I’m just sad Paul doesn’t have a chance. Yes, his jury management is terrible, but he is one hell of a strategist and would love to see him go against winners. Just wish he would’ve won.
I like how realistic ur cast is but jesus christ that would be so underwhelming to have only 1 of my top 2 winners oat (Dan, Derrick, Will, Cody, Andy) my dream cast with being semi-realistic would be
Cody
Derrick
Dan
Xavier
Andy
Hayden
Jun
Kaycee
Taylor
Lisa
Rachael
6th woman would be Jordan
Josh Martinez being the only two time Big Brother winner would make any season post BB20 with it 😂😂
(With that being said, I have yet to even finish BB22 -24 (despite hearing some good things about 23 and 24) because the toxic fanbase makes the show less fun to watch and since I'm someone who loves to share my thoughts about my favorite reality competition shows, the constant toxicity steered me away from being a fan of the show)
It could only be during winter when BB Celeb took place. 3 weeks, 14 people, 50% POC quota, and they would have to use winners from US, BB OTT, BB CAN, and Celeb BB. Tamar, Miesha, Morgan, Taylor, Kaycee, Rachel, Paris, Tychon, Xavier, Josh, Dan, Derrick, Andy, and Kevin Jacobs. Alternates: Sarah, Marissa, Jun, Terrell, Eddie, and Hayden.
i know it's a different type of show but when drag race (US line) did an all winners season one of the contestant was from one of the uk seasons, so i could see the producers asking one of the canadian, australia or uk winners to compete
I’ll admit i’m not the biggest Josh fan but after he recent appearance in The Challenge USA 2… i think he wins an all winners. period. He’s really shown how great his social and strategic game is and he will also do well in the challenges.
I think CBS has been leaning into redemption stories. While not BB, Survivors biggest characters in the last two seasons are Carolyn - a recovering addict, and Jesse- who spent time in jail, so I still wouldn't count out Adam. Can come out, have a nice segment on how he turned his life around & really remove alot of the stigma on his win // Big Brother 9.
If Derrick joins an all winners season he would have the HARDEST beginning of any player because everyone on the cast knows how good he is and they will all be gunning for him
But if he does somehow gets out of that situation then he'd 100% be the greatest player of all time
(I don't think Derrick will win but he definitely could find a way to win against all the odds)
I think that Derrick's biggest obstacle is Andy and I genuinely believe that Andy could get Derrick out
maybe they should add canada winners too very interesting
Hayden just said on an interview he told them never to call him again after they pulled the plug on him for 22 because he felt they pulled the plug because he’s too far conservative
Remember that they really could pull from Big Brother Canada too!! That would be amazing.
Oh, Evel Dick would DEFINITELY come back. His ego is too much big for him to say no.
Dan Ghesling would mop the floor with all of them ..