Proof Of Modi Performance- Exclusive Unseen Data Cut On The Crux Of The Matter | Rahul Shivshankar
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 มี.ค. 2024
- Senior economist PK Basu reveals that the growth during the first term of PM Modi surpassed all previous five-year prime ministerial terms, notably outpacing the UPA era
However, SC Garg, Ex-Finance Secy, counters, stating that the average growth of the UPA term ultimately takes the lead over the NDA
#PMModi #LokSabhaElections2024 #CruxOfTheMatter | n18oc_india
![บุกร้านไอศกรีม VJ วุ้นเส้น !!!! [ดูคลิปเต็มหน้าช่อง] #Short | PANG ORNHIRA](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/g549nEhKZdc/mqdefault.jpg)
I come from the state of Sikkim,today we have functional airport,railway under construction and this has been possible when Modi ji came to power.Also welfare schemes like PM samman nidhi,Fasal Bima Yojana,PM awas yojna, Toilets, Opening of bank accounts, Ayushman bharat, mudra yojana,ujjwala yojana,MSP subsidies,Agricultural tools for farmers,Jal jivan mission everything has been delivered to the last man standing in the society and this would not have been possible without the vision, leadership,credibility, honesty,capability of Modi ji, which is why we are grateful and pray for Modi ji❤😊🙏
Thank you for writing about facts from grass root level. It’s very difficult to believe media but coming from first hand experience.
It is amazing and puzzling that any progress reported about India becomes questionable and questionable because Modi is in power, but the same methodologies used in America for reporting its economy's status is taken very compliantly as a word of gospel. It is unfortunate that world organisations go to the extent of scruitinising India's progress by devising the most innovative and scientific methods for India only to probe its progress. It is not their fault. Rather, it is because India's own insiders, illiterate armchair overnight turned "experts," create doubts and false narratives about it with the loudest mega phones they can get hands on.
Aptly put. 👍🏻
I will not get fooled by this data. One can not fool all people all the time. Now it is time to re-think. Do not get fooled by godi media's data.
Modi is the ONLY one who can save Hindustan. None other.
Darshan, well put totley agree with you..
UPA sucked India dry like leeches sucking blood. That was the UPA era of poverty, regressive policies, 'kadi ninda', 'raj' politics, submissive to foreign powers, divisional & communal politics, suppression of Hindus, biased laws and complete destruction of democratic values by dynastic politics. A broken Bharat era where people were depraved and deprived of basic amenities, like gas, water, electricity, transportation, good roads etc.
As a data analyst I must say this is a good way to show progress. My vote is for BJP.
Read my comments above and vote for congress
@@pardeeptandon lol I am not ur servant and I will vote for BJP.
@@gumdrop465 Andh Bhakts do not get cured by facts,
This is why people chant Modi Modi❤
This just proves that last 10 years were exceptional and noteworthy, having said that travelling around India last 7 years I have seen it with my eyes the phenomenal development espacially in infrastructure and also in people you do not see much abject poverty that I use to see and get upset in the 80s, 90s, 2000s, in 2009 took 9 hrs by road to haridvar from Delhi last year it took 3.5 hours with a 40 mins rest stop.
400 paar in 2024 jai shree ram
For example some one waved a magic wand, 5G instantly appeared on the earth of India. Within a blink of an eye Internet evolved from 2g,3g,4g to 5g like overnight! Within a night, everyone got satellite signals working for all mobile services, like within a night!
Jai Shriram is a wrong word. It is jai seetharam like radhakrishna, parvatiparmeswara. Bulldozer jhumla party of India made a blunder due to over enthusiasm that hindutva is dying. I don't know whether hindutva is dying or not. Sanatana dharma would no die till humanity lives on our planet earth
@@manchikantimurty7375You are partially right , but Not completely right.
Thank you for the correction but I purposely left mata Sita's name out of this Dirty filthy politics that happens in our country. Mothers are precious and pure so should not be used in politics or political statements. Jai Hind 🙏 🙏
as a data professional this is an amazing analysis
O
@@Zab10China opened its economy in 1978 and India opened its economy in 1991, China is one party govt where long term plans are able to progress and finish in a regime where people cant protest to stop any projects or to repeal laws, and India all know what type of govt system we have. China saw steep growth in past 20 years and now experts say India's growth began now. After covid India had highest growth in world and even in next year IMF predicted India to have highest growth and China will be far lower around 4% at 2nd place. Lets be positive and analyse beyond politics and give constructive criticism
It shows that the government has focused on construction activities during the last 10 years. That explains why the rich has become richer. Apparently, major funds have been diverted to certain states only and not uniformly to all the states.
Sri Modi Ji is agift to our nation, he and his team of ministers have done wonders for our country that could not be done by the Khangress govt over almost 70 years of Khangress rule. Be it border security, industrial progress, indeginous manufacturing, defence, aero-space exploration, sending Gaganyaan to the moon, flying Tejas in our skies, infrastructure-of roads, railwaays, bridges, economy, education..even on the world stage our national impression has never been better, and in each & every area of importance to common citizens, Modi Ji has touch crores of lives. Even the whole world looks up to Modi Ji for his wisdom and skill in managing complex geopolitical situations. PLEASE GO OUT TO VOTE BJP, let us keep the security and prosperity of our nation in the efficient administration of the Sri Modi Ji's Govt. We deserve our own nation to feel secure and safe as we have nowhere else to go unlike the muslims or christians who can easily go to tens of countries of their choice (good for them). JPLEASE GO TO VOTE B.J.P. and save our nation from the internal and the external enemies. JAI BHARATH.
One of the best program, I really enjoyed and was left flabbergasted... I of the many want Modi Ji forever in power in India. Best wishes to my motherland from Australia..
Come back from Australia and have your future generations live in India. Then start dishing out these farcical statements.
Good journalism and Excellent work! Rahul Shivshankar
Your observation is truly laughable 😂
@@milkywhitex5128TRUTH HURTS
@@angelbaybi997 you modi supporters must be the most hurt then.
Amit shah showed Modji's BA and MA degree.
Modi ji said many times he did not study after high school and left home at 17
TRUTH HURTS BUDDY TERA NETA JHOOTA HAI
@milkywhitex5128 so the school gave him a fake document right?...n its uploaded on the school website long before shah showed them...n like who even cares?...at least he's not a jihadi like the J.I.H.A.D.I REGIME...it's not his vote bank that preplanned every major riot since he has been in power...incited to violence by the J.I.H.A.D.I REGIME
Nobody needs proof of Modiji's performance. He is always on social media with the public and everybody knows how much development has been done. He has changed India to a superpower.
Lol
Not a superpower yet. But yes, the current govt has set a good trajectory for sure.
*The cherry on the top of this performance cake is the absence of any scam.* If only the runner at the bottom was absent, and larger charts were shown instead of faces.
What about electoral bonds, PM CARESFUND, and no tabling of CAG report for the last 10 years.
No comparisons at all .Modi Sarkar is ahead in all aspects.
I do hope Modiji takes full interest in freeing all our temples from the clutches of Communists, Christians, and anti-Hindu forces. Modiji, please make Bharat truly SECULAR. We, the Hindu diaspora all over the world, have only our Bharat to call our Hindu Rajya.🙏
👍🕉️🇮🇳🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
How do we get this excellent study in different languages so that all Indians can see the excellent work done by Modiji .? Mr. Shivshankar please do think about it
@@g2032tell your Indi alliance baaps to prove any falsification in above data.😂 let's expose the media, right😂
A fantastic segment, good work, Rahul! Brilliant work in summarizing the analysis, Ms. Shamika Ravi!!! I think this type of analysis was not available in 2019, hence all the brouhaha that PM Modi will loose. But there was on article in economic time..that have provide this data point but more in a anecdotical manner which you could glean the same and I was confident about the win then. I think this time it will be the brouhaha about if PM Modi will get 400+ for the NDA or not. What a change in the narrative and discussions by this govt. and in particular by the once in many centuries.. PM!!!!
Oh yes absolutely! Once in many centuries PM (by the way concept of PM is just about a century old lol!) who as soon as took over in 2014, waved a magic wand and things like 5G instantly appeared on the earth of India. Within a blink of an eye Internet evolved from 1g, 2g, 3g, 4g to 5g like overnight! Within a night, Satellites automatically appeared around the orbit of Earth. Everyone got satellite signals working for all mobile services, like within a night! What a magical man who could anticipate "Time before Time" and therefore predicted Corona and saved millions of Indian lives from Corona like overnight!
Incredibly interesting perspective driven by new data acquisition mechanisms.
Both of you are superb.. content & presentation & relevence & novelty & authenticity: 👍🙏🙏
Very gratifying to learn about the progress Bharat has made under stewardship of Modiji.
This can be attributed to the competence and ability of the people who are heading the various ministries. This is very much unlike earlier regimes in which political heavyweights were at the helm of affairs. Kudos to Modiji and his team. Jai Hind and Bharat Mathaki Jai.
Rahul this was very innovative. I love graphs, you should make it a regular.
Agree
This is something which i have never seen in TV news, amazing. Keep it up
Congrats for the innovative approach in evaluating the development activities happening in our nation in its pursuit to be Viksit Bharat @2047🧡🧡🧡🧡🧡💛💛💛💛💛💚💚💚💚💚💖💖💖💖💖🧡🧡🧡
High quality journalism ❤
Will again vote for BJP ❤❤
Good work and is very visible all over India that the country is moving up
Fantastic study, people can see the growth visible at ground level.
Outstanding
Statics is a kind of numerical analysis which is beyond common man's orbit. I had physically witnessed by travelling all over India the sea changes the government brought for common people especially in north india
Beautiful assessment 👍👌😊😊
Awesome work
Excellent objective analysis to assess India efforts. We should use this analysis at district level to apprise the MP and State government to work on improvement area and also resource allocation. Too much Red (high growth) should also trigger the government to balance out activities to other tier 2 cities/ towns in the country.
Wish all MP, State governments and beuraucrats use the information from such analysis as per interpretation from experts.
Fabulous data Shamika Ravi !... really amazed.
I am from Tamilnadu, feeling really ashamed our people has elected useless 39 bunch of jokers as MPs 🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️
Such programs should also be conducted in Hindi so that more people get to watch and understand this.
Thanks to Rahul for such an insight
Definitely thank Rahul Gandhi, that BJP at least started talking about development indicators regardless of the fact that the real indicators were not displayed!
Great work
Your survey is amazing and proves, India is moving forward at fast speed. The reason behind all this is better use of funds and less corruption. No major scams like UPA. Although still lots has to be done. To develop fast Modi needs to reduce wastage on free food to 81 Crores. Which is not going to the deserving people but wasting lots of money.
Third class camera work. The data board is hardly readable for the TV viewer.
Great! Curious to hear what the opposition is going to tell about this.
Rahul Baba will call a five year old and say "Dekho, Modi ne aapka red color crayon leke map mein rang bhar diye aur bol rahe hai- ye humne progress kiya!"
Saw it yesterday....brilliant segment..just what was needed before elections
Wonderful work and amazing analysis. An eye opener for all of us.congratulations. Please keep come out with transparent analysis ona regular basis.
This will stop stupid politicians who comment about the Present Government performance irrationally.👍👍👍
Very informative data analysis. Thanks.
Cool, a scientific approach of satellite imaging to back the story of strong economic growth and development during PM Modi government.
Great work and report. Please get nation’s map correct
OUTSTANDING WORK AND THIS REPORT MUST BE SHARED WITH ALL STUDENTS ALL OVER THE COUNTRY
JUST TRAVAL THROUGH INDIA AND WITNESS CHANGES
IMPROVING OUR WAY OF MATERIAL SOCIAL LIFE
India grew in population as well, making it most populated country in the world.
Reason:
Muslims and Christian’s
@@VedikHomenot Christians only muz.
Interesting way of looking Development..
Amazing data sets and comparisons based on actual ground development. Brilliant as usual by Shamika ji.
Awesome ❤
She started with Kolkata, but what is preventing momota from claiming her government effort for the growth? How can we attribute it to Modi only.
Awesome Growth and Let it CONTINUE
Good way to analyse. A suggestion, should be used to ensure development is sustainable development. Environment must be kept in mind. Animals are suffering. We need to be sensitive about their habitats. Kindly use it to plan a balanced growth plan. Revive tree plantation drives that are scientifically viable.
❤❤❤❤
Do think this kind of data needs to be published monthly. Afterall some govt is starting to publish these like a corporate. May be they need to start publishing an year end financials too similarly
Can you show satelite pictures of highways and railways and Metros
Haha.. Mooh band for anti Modi brigade..
They may say Even the satallite is biased. 😂😂
Very convincing data presented by Shamika and Rahul. Kudos to both of you.
Excellent analysis
I just want to ask one qn? If the India map is misrepresented at 10.25. If yes please change it
Great analyses
Undoubtedly, a brilliant analysis
Very good analysis ❤
ShamikaRavi 's work is very much appreciated
Excellent Rahul Shivshankar we need to know this. Thank you
I hope and wish the opposition, so called well educated economic experts and others who criticize the Government to understand this data. well, when time is used to immerse themselves in petty statements, oppose anything and everything of the Govt, understanding this kind of data is a tall expectation, I think.
It's an great proof of performance of MODI's GOI based on latest technology.
Amazing
Good analysis. 👍👏👌
Great innovation for governance performance
Why are you allowing maps of India without POK and Aksai Chin that belong to us
Because they are under the control of Pakistan and China. This is not a political map. It's captured data.
Please share as much as possible
Great data .. Can the raw data be shared ?
Vow! Fantastic scientific data and future idea of daily monitoring is absolutely wonderful
Keep it up
This is very useful data. Reason why most of the central part is not developed is because these are highly forested areas- the source of Narmada and Godavari. Better not to build too much there. Chhattisgarh is not developed is because of Maoist activity, This is a good program Rahul better than the screaming nonsense from people like Jha and Jindal.
The map of India is not complete.
please use the correct map
Nice to know! Great Analysis by Shamikaji and Rahul’s as usual!
I saw the original discussion on the India Today Conclave with Rahul as moderator. The discussion was interesting.
Let me begin my noting that I spent more than three decades at the IMF before retiring in 2005. I then joined Global Financial Integrity, a think tank in Washington DC where I am now the Chief Economist Emeritus.
I am confused by Shamika's arguments that satellite images of construction activity during the UPA and NDA governments is evidence of the latter's superior economic performance. That, in a nutshell, is her argument. However, it is seriously flawed for the following reasons.
First, the satellite is a dumb machine--it can take pictures but it is up to human beings to interpret them correctly. The fact of the matter is that while economic growth tends to drive construction activity, the converse is not true, particularly if, as in India's case, it accounts for just around 8 percent of Gross Value Added. In other words, a dog wags its tail but the tail cannot wag the dog. One cannot start with satellite images and say "See, this is why the Modi government performed better." To cite satellite pictures of greater construction activity as evidence of better economic performance is misleading and disingenuous.
Second, the greater construction boom of the NDA over the UPA period itself needs to be shorn of (1) population growth (2) rising inequality and (3) greater rural-urban migration which may be driving some of the private sector investment in construction. The government has not proved the theory that overall construction has boomed despite these factors.
I agree that economists need to be non-partisan in their analysis. In that light, I am disappointed that the discussion of satellite pictures as evidence of better economic performance passed off as "research".
Amazing.
Excellent 👍 🎉🎉🎉
Great work, remember this is a proxy data and we all know that hard infrastructure development has happened at much faster pace under Modi govt.
What’s disappointing is still rampant corruption in government offices, poor conditions of govt schools and hospitals and slow pace of industrialisation!
Sorry I missed something, I think. What parameters were observed via satellite to show growth numbers. It seems data is impressive but not sure how you got these 2% 6% numbers out of imaging. Can somebody comment.
Very refreshing to see new way of measuring Bharath growth
Shamika ji needs to be on the PM advisers panel.
Jai Bjp Jai modiji ❤❤🎉🎉🙏🏻🙏🏻
Great summary
Very interesting. Just sed how intelligently this has been prepared,
So our EA to PM when ever speak, he has support from these data. We very much appreciated by his beck office team. Thanks
Can we see the forest cover info also for these districts??
We need high quality, hard ,science, and data based analysis ,and explained by professionals who make it easy comprehensible terms. Keep the good work. Remain objective and hence credible. Fine job.
Human settlement is directionaly proportional to Economic activity? Is that a correct assumption ?
This works well for China which have manufacturing or IT / ITES. India has significant economic contribution from agriculture.
How will we pickup agricultural growth, fisheries or growth in industries where we dont need increased human settlement.
Zzz go learn basic economics.. maybe go re read mazlowes hierarchy of needs.. they are literally talking about rural underdeveloped regions growing rapidly and they clearly showed that city growth has slowed down
More data should be mined and used for further development and the areas needing extra attention..
Data is not used for development but is used for gaining information, insights, intelligence and can also be manipulated to mislead voters. The logic of this electoral bloc!
Why only 5 years and 10 years. Shouldn't comparison be 10 to 10 yrs guys ?
Sorry ,it is 5 yrs to 5 .my mistake
Apple to Apple comparison will expose the misery and the mess that these fundamentalists have created in India. The whole reason why this creative chart.
జై హో భారత్ !
Just 6 months ago she said "Statisticians can be wrong. Sampling methodology of our surveys requires urgent upgradation to keep up with the needs of India’s dynamic economy". Now she says contrary to what she said earlier.
Brilliant analyst . Some of the madrasa educated panel participants on various debates will have a hard time understanding these data or even debating . They will start screaming louder !
The difference between being brilliant and being manipulative cannot be easily worked out. In case you have the IQ, do go through the real indicators that I have provided in the comments below. Data does not need to scream loud, it just need to bring forth the ground level reality to the people.
@neerajk5212 In a hugely populated country , data is the indicator of which way things are headed , not your screamers on panels . Subjective versus Objective analysis . Science with metrics are needed to evaluate objectively . Your or my opinions are irrelevant .
@@narayanprasad4008 Suddenly, it became a hugely populated country is it? Does it mean that your party has been underestimating the size of it so far? I do not need a lesson from you on data analysis and its applications. It is evident that the fundamentalists do, otherwise, they would not have devised a deceptive chart to mask their incompetence. I will also let you know another secret of the real success free of charge here and it will not be a psychic skill like "Time before Time". The fundamental disparity between the fundamentalists and the Congress party's approach lies in the fact that the Congress party tackled issues at their core, initiating implementation from grassroots levels. Hence, their results took time but were substantial and long term. In contrast, the fundamentalists always sought shortcuts and quick victories, failing to address root causes and resorting to numbers to camouflage their shortcomings. A prime example is the handling of poverty rates, GDP per capita, and GDP. The Congress party combated poverty through comprehensive plans that positively impacted GDP per capita and subsequently, GDP. Consequently, despite the gradual pace, poverty rates declined rapidly and GDP per capita saw significant improvement under Congress governance. On the other hand, the fundamentalists prioritized GDP by focusing on random infrastructural projects and investments. While this led to an increase in GDP, it came at the cost of a significant decline in GDP per capita! In turn, the prestigious Yogiji's state failed to reduce its poverty rates as per the expectation in the last decade even trailing behind some African nations. Always bear in mind, the rich, the affluent can navigate without much reliance on the government; it's the impoverished who need its support. The affluent possess their own avenues irrespective of who leads the government, which is why even dictator-led countries have billionaires. May be your opinions are irrelevant, but mine is certainly not, I can definitely promise you that. Your stories pale in comparison to the concrete data available. So, next time, present something substantial rather than mere narratives.
They are parasites.
@@asbmbs5530 So people who are not buying into your stories are parasites? UP gets Rs 273 back from the center against every Rs 100 paid as taxes. Where do you think UP gets the additional Rs 173 from? So who is in reality the parasite?
Educated Indians, sooner or later, when you children will start asking questions, these fundamentalists will label your children as either Anti-Nationals, or Parasites and so on. Keep this in mind.
excellent analysis based on data
Mam innovative scientific presentation of development data. Very much impressed with your work. Where do we get the report. Amused.
Pls let the person who made the data, talk.
I am not denying that India is developing but is construction and infrastructure the right way to measure growth? Won't that miss agriculture and services?
Lol it's the best way.. people who are prosperous build more housing.. shelter is a critical requirement in the Mazlowes hierarchy of needs .. people who eat well put that money into permanent housing and then luxuries
The presentation of growth is novel fr the first time
However, I feel this shd be shown in TV channel for better view of performance. This is a request to Rahul whom I like & respect most.
Rahul Gandhi must study this report understand progress upa and NDA.
Today I went to a village about 92 kms from Hyderabad. The drive was on the national highway for about 80kms. The remaining 12 kms was on state roads. Of this about 4-5kms was good tar road and the remaining was poor pot hole riddled roads. It is clear to me that most of Telangana's growth has been in some pockets around Hyderabad and immediate surrounding areas and some districts represented by CMs and their family members. Rest of constituencies have been neglected.
Covid years also to be factored in