It was not China that colonized Mongolia for 200 years, it was Manchuria (Qing Dynasty) which colonized China and Mongolia for over 200 years. But during Qing Dynasty, Mongolians were ruling class, enjoying a much higher social status / better treatment than Han people. That is why the banner by the founding fathers of the Republic of China ( ROC ) was : " to drive away the Manchu invaders, restore the Chinese sovereignty, ......"
@@HaiLe-xk9qwIt's only considered a Chinese dynasty because it happened in China. But you have to understand that it was led by the Manchu people, an ethnic minority group in China, and not the Han people, another ethnic group. So Manchuria is NOT China but A PART of China. There's a difference. And how do you expect textbooks to fit in all the history of China in detail when there are thousands of years worth of events?
Funny thing about this guy is he would only ask what Mongolians think about Russia and USA. But for the question on China, he would ask why people hate China instead of what people think of. He should also ask why Mongolians can't read/write in Mongolian script.
Dude, this is just 2nd part of the interview. There is a whole another video of Mongolians talking about things they like about China. Dont be silly. th-cam.com/video/20S5xAOXjGA/w-d-xo.htmlsi=RPpONksWKLimtPf5
The Mongols and Manchus are nomadic peoples. The Han nationality is an agricultural civilization. Their history is that of Mongols and Manchus invading the Han. But it was eventually conquered by Han culture. All 52 ethnic groups merge into the Chinese nation.
Seeing some of the malicious remarks from Mongolians in the comments section, I have to speak out.The Mongols destroyed the Southern Song Dynasty, and the emperors of the Yuan Dynasty condoned Mongol nobles and Semu people. Some Tibetan monks in Han territory engaged in corruption and extortion, emptying the wealth of the entire Southern Song Dynasty. Combined with various natural disasters and misguided governance, the land of the entire Southern Song Dynasty became a land of death during the decades of Mongol rule. The people of southern China harbored extreme hatred towards the Mongols. How do Mongols who clamor about the evil of the Han people in the comments section view this? At that time, the Mongol army slaughtered a million people in Sichuan in order to coerce the Song state to surrender. What do the Mongols think about this? Not to mention that the Mongols directly caused a discontinuation in Chinese history, leading to a great regression in civilization. How many Chinese people today seriously hold you accountable for this unprecedented loss? If you truly feel that we have wronged you, remember that historically it was you who repeatedly initiated aggression against the Chinese, and you have always taken pride in it, causing countless injuries to the Chinese, almost several times more than Japan. Yet how many Han people seriously hold onto past hatred, regarding you Mongols as true enemies? You yourselves allied with the Manchus for your own interests, wanting to jointly rule China like the Manchus did, thinking you could still be as glorious as before, but you were ultimately manipulated by Manchu emperors using Buddhism and Shanxi merchants, leading to a sharp decline in population and loss of combat capability. Aren't these all the evil consequences you brought upon yourselves? Did Han people force you to hand over Inner Mongolia to the Manchus so you could attack the Ming Dynasty smoothly? And don't you realize that your experiences in the late Qing Dynasty are almost identical to those of the Chinese throughout the entire Yuan Dynasty? It's truly ironic.
@@Twodime4032 Manchu are not Chinese at first like Japanese were not Jomon first. Japanese are Japanese and Chinese are Chinese. Manchu is not a genetic identity. They just are Chinese genetically.
@@zorighongatan7476 In fact, Mongolia's independence was due to the Soviet Union's invasion of China. Have you forgotten everything the Soviet Union did to Mongolia
Very divided. Older generations generally like the Soviet Union (due to factories providing jobs and Soviet allies joining the Mongol military to protect the Mongol homeland against potential Japanese and Chinese occupation), have good/neutral sentiments about modern Russia (because of our people there) while the youth doesn't think much about Russia nor the Soviet Union. USA sentiments vary but Mongolia wants to work with USA just like China worked with the USA to become billionaires and millionaires. Mongolia views USA as a third neighbor with lots of avenues for trade and military cooperation. Thousands of Mongolians allied with the West to protect Afghanistan before, even gaining a reputation for being fierce and alert soldiers amongst their international soldiers and peers.
Its very impressive that young gens in Mongolia r so wise and open to their neighboring country. Although there r some passive sounds for Chinese, more young ppl r think about relationships with other countries more positively and forward. Plus, young ppl look so fashionable and good look. : ) Like ur work.
Out of all the interviews I've seen, this is the most reasonable one. They actually gave specific reasons (historical or cultural). In other videos, 95% of Mongolians that were interviewed could never explain why they hate Chinese people! It's almost like they were born to naturally hate Chinese people. From an outsider's perspective, it should be the Chinese that should hate the Mongolians, because the Mongols and their ancestors (the Xiongnus) have tried to invade China for almost 3,000 years, and succeeded once with Genghis/Kublai Khan.
Mongolians hate China because Chinese are easily hateable and it's socially encouraged. This can be due to a lot of reasons, but for Mongolians who take pride in their Empire, of course it tastes like shit if they were colonised by the Chinese.
In addition, most generations from the golden family (their family) currently live in inner mongolia which is in China🤣 This video makes me very confused as a mongolian having some direct link to those who ruled China in Yuan Dynasty. 😧
@@sinakethunder5191how much of that Mongol DNA is intact? 5%? It’s mostly Chinese blood at this point. If Kazakhs see Mongolians as a bunch of Chinese imposters, I can guarantee you for a fact that they will see you Inner Mongols as straight up Chinese, no doubt about it.
I mean there is no such thing as stealing culture.. you cannot deny that there are 4 million Mongolians living in china, which is even more than mongolians in Mongolia. These Mongolian-Chinese deserve to get recognized of their culture and tradition.
The tortilla came from Mesoamerican natives, yet many think it is Mexican. However it is more often for it to be simply an exchange of culture and not so much stealing culture.
Most of the Mongols are ------ What's your favorite country? Korea Japan USA France Greece Spain Turkey Canada Morocco Russia singapore Norway Deautch land Denmark Swiss Netherlands Australia UK ..... Most of the Mongols are ------- Which country do you hate?? China China China China China China ..... its real
Russia used hate towards china to be his puppet. But now new generation have different view. People who where raised during soviet regime is so brainwashed they will die with their belief. But any country who is neighbors are not always friendly. But most important thing is that even Mongolia is a small country sandwiched between 2 world giants communist dictatorship country is still democratic and free.
Mongolia colonized China for a 100 years, then Manchu colonized both Han Chinese and Mongolia for more than 200 years. So, you have to know very little about history to hate China.
I think the owner of this channel gave this name to show the authentic side of mongolia to the world as a mongolian. If you search mongolia on youtube, you might only find videos of tourists showing their experience of 1-2 weeks of trips which might not showcase the everyday life of mongolia and its citizens
@@odnuu ...... Though, You still didn't answer the question about, Why use "Real mongolia" name on the channel ? We know who you are ! The mongols. i asked, are there more pretenders or fake mongolians ? i didn't asked authenticity... i asked are there more mongols than "inner mongolians" and the "Central mongolians"? Are they the real mongolians ? So who is the fake one ?... that's what i asked... Why say "The Real Mongolians" ? When there is only 2 country with that name on the google ? Sounds like you guys are the ones who have ownership problem ? 😂
@@Smiley-ps1yc I guess i misinterpreted your statement in your first comment. i thought you were genuinely curious as to why the author named the channel ' Real Mongolia" and tried to give my own interpretation of the name of the channel. But I guess you wish to misinterpret the name in your own condensending way. There is no real or fake Mongolia as far as I know. It's not as the author named their channel "Only real Mongolia" which incase your interpretation could be justified.
The people in the video say positive things about china and its people while criticising elder generation for being blind and judgemental. Then I go to the comment section and read how Mongolians are poor and impoverished dissapearing nation written by the citizens of the developed neighbor. What's up with that. Who has more resentment and hatred? I am confused.
Of course they won't be honest with you on camera, but why would the Chinese prefer to travel to Southeast Asia instead of Mongolia? It is that the Mongols attack Chinese tourists who go to travel, resulting in no one willing to go to Mongolia, investment and tourists are not willing to go to Mongolia, otherwise why next to China and Russia, Mongolia's economy will be so poor
@@user-jq3xn4iy1t because no one other than Sea asians want Chinese to come in as a guest. 😂😂 That's why Chinese only can go to Vietnam or laos... made in China!!!!
@@i-eat-youyou are the type of hater that I respect, because atleast you don't put on the facade of just hating the Chinese government, you hate the Chinese people as well, which quite a lot of the Chinese govt. haters secretly do but they don't say so. You are from Germany right? I don't understand why there would be a reason for you to have enmity with the Chinese but maybe it's a personal reason? Who knows
china also has Inner Mongolia so many overlapping of cultural claim, I don't think its that much of a horrible thing, America and Britain share huge chunk of history together why that's a matter? it can be seen as a bridge between two countries cos we have shared culture.
PRC(People’s Republic of China): recognizes Mongolia as an independent country ROC(Republic of China，Now has fled to Tai**wan proviince) : does not recognize Mongolia as an independent country
The question should be why the chinese shouldnt hate Mongolian after they grand father had invaded and murdered so many chinese during the period of yuan dynasty?
In fact, in the eyes of the Mongolian people, Inner Mongolia is the core region of Mongolia. Mongolia belongs to the border area, and there are many more Mongolians in China than Mongolia, so the history of China and Mongolia blend together
@@walhdamaskus2408Arab and Persian culture already existed in China during Tang Dynasty. The oldest mosque is in Guangzhou, when Arab trader went to China by sea 1300 years ago. In Xi'an, there's a Muslim quarter dedicated to Muslim Chinese. The Hui people are the descendants of Arab/Persian traders who married into the locals from the 7th - 10th century (Tang Dynasty). Mongols, on the other hand, pillage and sacked Baghdad - the center of Islamic world.
I’m Korean and Mongolia and Korea are quite good political partners Maybe we can share a lot of things in that we have the same opponents to be wary of
A traitor who fully embraces Russian culture and a traitor who completely accepts American culture-when it comes to cultural identity, Japan surpasses both of you.
You Koreans are just puppets of America and the west. All of you talk so tough online but when a white person comes to your land you quickly get on your knees and beg for approval like lapdogs. I hope one day Koreans have the dignity to not be a colony of America
@@user-ru3mp7cz5u Calm down. China has a lot of influence in Asia Sometimes your great influence makes neighboring countries uneasy We have no choice but to be dragged by your influence But every country has a culture and an identity But the Chinese always ignore it Koreans feel a sense of opposition to this remark China has been semi-colonialized by Japan, including the Nanjing Massacre Even if they became Japanese colonies, it is not without their identity In some ways, Korea and China share the same historical scars But why do you want to give back to Koreans the hurt you have suffered? Be humble China's influence is great, but it is possible when the surrounding countries agree with you I hope China will be qualified as a leader in Asia
@@frankhill4358 Calm down. China has a lot of influence in Asia Sometimes your great influence makes neighboring countries uneasy We have no choice but to be dragged by your influence But every country has a culture and an identity But the Chinese always ignore it Koreans feel a sense of opposition to this remark China has been semi-colonialized by Japan, including the Nanjing Massacre Even if they became Japanese colonies, it is not without their identity In some ways, Korea and China share the same historical scars But why do you want to give back to Koreans the hurt you have suffered? Be humble China's influence is great, but it is possible when the surrounding countries agree with you I hope China will be qualified as a leader in Asia
I am Mongolian and want to reunite with my Buryat/Tuva sisters in Russia-occupied Mongolia and Uzemchin/Barga brothers in China-occupied Mongolia with help from our Kazakh/Uyghur cousins in Kazakhstan/Turkestan. I want to see our work boost the Mongolia GDP instead of rushing into Russia or China. Our land is rich. Our people are strategic. Our unity will cause the largest shift in Asia anybody has ever seen. Mongol Turge humuus negdej l uursduu huvtas hunsee hiij l oros hyatadiin door orohgui gedgiig sain oilgoiroi.
@@voido68 I am hopeful. No one is crying. You are the one who will be crying when the Western warplanes come teach you a lesson like they did with Japan.
The relationship between the Han and Mongolians should be good. My family was once Mongolian and settled in southern China after Kublai Khan became emperor of China. Mongolia's military system is very backward. Military households are permanently military households and are not allowed to engage in business. Every time they go on an expedition, they have to provide their own weapons and food. The spoils and expenditures are unbalanced. Many Mongolian military households have become slaves. In the Mongolian Empire for less than two hundred years In the history of the empire, rebellions by Mongolian military households have been suppressed everywhere. However, due to the small population of Mongolia, the uprisings ended in failure. It was not until the end of the empire that the Han people joined the uprising and relied on their huge population to defeat the Mongolian nobles. The failure of the Mongol Empire was caused by the internal killings of the golden families and their neglect of the living conditions of the middle and lower-class Mongolian military households. After the Golden Family fled South China, 200,000 military households in North China and Khalkha Mongolia also refused to be loyal. The steppes were locked in a war for the succession to the empire. In the southern farming areas, after the unification of South China and North China, the Han emperor established the Ming Empire. The Mongolian military households who were the main force of his army also received awards and settled in China as military households of the Ming Empire, but they had to change their Mongolian names. It is a Han name. In order to stabilize the Mongolian military households in the army, the Ming Empire also required the royal family to marry Mongolians. The resentment of the Khalkha Mongols came from the fact that Kublai Khan favored the Chinese region and favored the Inner Mongolians when the Manchus ruled Mongolia. As the ruler of the country, Kublai Khan could not be biased towards the politically hostile Khalkha Mongols, and the Manchus would definitely be biased towards the Inner Mongolians who firmly supported them. These two points made the Outer Mongolians feel ostracized by the entire empire and promoted hostility to China by Soviet Union. The current hostility of Outer Mongolians towards the Chinese is mainly due to the huge gap between the rich and the poor. They believe that the rulers ignore the lower-class Mongolians, make secret deals with the Chinese, and vent their emotions on China-related affairs.
It is true that Mongolia is poorer than China, actually China is richer than lot of counties not only Mongolia, but Mongolia is not a poor country compared to other countries, maybe this period is just a period of our decline and a mistake in the system.
In the midst of civil war in china mongollians ciezed the chance founded they're own country freeing themselves from centuries of occupation. The chinese tried and failed to convince the soviets to give up Mongollia.. They failed and then again when they "supported" our development by giving in chinese workers about 8000 of them to work for Mongolia. These workers used the chinese embassy in mongolia to spread leaflets to the youth to try and sway public opinion of proposal for occupation, it failed. Again they visited Mongolia with theyre ambassador to try threaten the Mongols to give in by using the 8000 workers as leverage and said they pull them back if they didnt oblige to Chinese occupation the Choibalsan flatly declined and nearly got into a fist fight ( this part might be exagerated). The Chinese recognised us as an independent country 1940 only because the soviets forced them to. They rejected our proposal to enter the UN Multiple times arguing mongolia was "a part of China and not a legitimate country" they again got pressured by the soviets to accept our entry. If you think were fools or somehow stupid and dont know the history then your clearly dont know anything.
Didn't mention how Mongolian ruled China in the 12th century and seems to be a failure if not one of the darkest times in China history? Only depends on how far back you want to trace history.
Do these people know that Northern Han Chinese people have similar genetic makeup to them? There's been many Turkic Mongol dynasty in the land of China, they've always used Han culture to administer and govern the lands and over time integrated into China's population. Why do you think there's so many people in China? Coz they came and migrated and benefited from Han culture.
As a Chinese I must say, please ignore those toxic comments. In real life most people are kind and have no time to be an online warrior. I love Mongolia and I'm learning Khoomei right now. хайр ба амар тайван❤
Just make business and have friendly cultural exchanges and when one or the other is in trouble come and help one another (for example a natural disaster).
China is a country of cultural tolerance. In history, Genghis Khan used to brutally exploit and oppress China. Here I would like to point out that the Manchus once ruled China, but in the early days of their conquest, they adopted cruel means of repression, but gradually, they managed China with the idea of governance, that is, they regarded China as their own territory and ruled it for the purpose of long-term governance, and they had a certain vision of development. However, during the reign of Genghis Khan, the Mongols were always treated by China as the object of exploitation. That is to say, during the Yuan Empire, the Mongols never regarded China as their own territory and people, they only ruthlessly exploited and robbed China, without considering how to govern it for a long time and make the local people live a stable life, so the Yuan Empire did not exist for a long time. But as time went by, the Chinese never hated the Mongols or the Manchus. Instead, we set aside hatred and prejudice to live in harmony with our people. But I know people in Mongolia are very biased and hateful towards Chinese people, I don't know why. From my personal point of view, it may be because the Mongols have conquered many countries and nations in history, so they are immersed in the past pride. As soon as others develop better than they do, their fragile self-esteem turns into jealousy and hatred, attempting to achieve the self-comforting effect of inner balance through psychological contempt for the other person.
If you "love life" then why do you speak with prejudice? The history of mankind is the same all over the world, except for the details. Truth, and looking at past real events, has value and merit, but not when spoken with contempt. You have your present day challenges, I have mine. Mongolians have theirs. If we are speaking truth, as we should, is it possible you are jealous of Mongolians because their freedom reaches a wider degree than yours? I enjoy listening to these Mongolians express their heartfelt beliefs and opinions openly, on all matters, without fear. Are you good with that?
@@gregb3457 Friend, do you think I have any fear in expressing any opinion here? If I have fears, if I can't express them freely, how can you read my messages? I'm free to say anything, I don't have any fear. The government has a phone number, 12345. I called this government hotline to abuse the country's leaders and the ruling party with profanities for a long time, yet months passed without any fear. I am also here to post comments and discuss issues with you!!
@@gregb3457 I like to emphasize the idea that people with low self-esteem can be very sensitive. It is an objective fact confirmed by psychology, I only speak objective facts, how is this contemptuous and insulting? A rich man is not afraid of being called poor, only poor people care about being called poor. This is definitely real mental activity.
@@lovelife5783 The worst poverty of all has nothing to do with money. And on the inside of apparent external poverty there can reside the greatest of wealth.
Though not Mongolian nationally, I am Buyat Mongol, and I think it is very stupid for anyone to be against China, especially Mongols. Most "Northern Chinese" are very likely genetically Mongol whether they like that or not, so being against them, is like being against your distant cousin. Manchus didn't "colonise" Mongolia, they conquered it and they held such honour and love for Chinghis that only Mongol and Manchu Princesses were allowed to marry the Qing Emperors and Nobility, until centuries later, they allowed Han Chinese to marry too. Many Mongol traditions were practiced by the Qing as well, they even held the Ger as their ceremony house when welcoming guests outside of a palace. Regardless, we should not be against Chinese, they are not like Europeans, who, if anyone bothered to study world history, were responsible for flooding the entire Qing Empire with narcotics to destroy it's vast wealth, cultural, technological and military power. They colonised most of the world and committed the worst genocides. Would you take such a pack of hyenas as a friend? or the dragon and the bear, who has already had their fill.
Mongolia's anti-China stance is politically correct. Caused by state guidance. We start with the Mongol Empire and see who hurt whom more. Today, they do not recognize the Qing Dynasty as a Chinese dynasty, but they use China's invasion of them during the Qing Dynasty as an excuse to hate China.
I have to say we never disagree with the first man opinion. We accept Yuan as a dynasty and we learn this history. About culture stealing, idk so I won’t say anything.
@@lyhthegreat Try to imagine u are the China Mongolia in China land. Ur grandparents also. They still keep this traditional musical instrument and they think they are Chinese. Can u say it is not a part of Chinese cultures? But if they still think we stole their cultures, I will just respect them and say yes.
Educational videos,I really learnt a lot from your channel. As a northern han Chinese,I used to think that mongolians were all rude and ugly.After learning about mongolians,now I find that kind of view was unappropriate and narrow🙁. Towards your unique facial features,people shouldn't think that's ugly because of our twisted western aesthetic. Beauty shouldn't be defined by only one standard,you are beautiful if you are a confident person,always love what we are born with,this is true us. You have your own faith and living style,you are strong and respectful.we shouldn't always take historical stuff which happened hundreds of years ago as the reason we hate each other today.We are neighbours,and we are all estern asians,we influenced each other in history. My mindset turned from hate to being friendly. Love mongolian😘
And sorry for bad behaviors done by CCP, han Chinese don't want to steal mongolian instruments,and I admit that our current historical education is wrong.I hope communcation can solve more things.Hostile only brings more hostile,we han Chinese should not be arrogant or misguided too.
Mongolia with it's vast land and resources. While mineral resources can be used as a baseline for economy, other natural resources such as wind and solar can also be use as economy power house. Use those natural wealth to invest on the people's education, public services and further economy development is vital.
적어도 동아시아 국가에서 좋아할 국가가 어디 있겠어? 21세기에도 옛날의 중국을 그리워하며 그저 군림하고 싶어하는데..내몽골도 동화시키려고 한족 이주시키고 몽골어교육도 축소시키고 내몽골을 중국의 역사로 편입시키는 등등 하는 짓들이 역겹다. 만리장성 왜 쌓았는지 잊음? 역사를 지금의 정치로 새로 해석하니 니들이 대접을 못받는거다. 중국이 얼른 쪼개졌으면 좋겠다. 몽골도 내몽골 통일하고 우리도 간도 되찾고 티벳,위구르 독립하고 다른 소수민족들은 독립할지 아니면 중국에 동화될지 알아서들 결정하고 아무튼 중국은 자초하는거야 계속 적을 만들어 안중근의 동양평화론을 지지하는데 그럴 일은 없어 보인다. 동아시아도 한번 eu처럼 뭉쳐야하는데 지금의 중국이 따거역할 제대로 할수나 있겠어?
@@manduul.bakhdal You Mongolians don’t talk about the Mongol Empire except in your mouth. Everything else talks about the Mongol Empire. Your Mongol Empire has been destroyed for 700 years, but you have never come out.
Mongolia was once within the Soviet sphere of influence. It's current borders were designed to provide a good enough buffer between China and the former USSR. So the Sino-Soviet conflict also probably played a part with regards to the negative perception of older Mongolians against the Chinese. Today, Mongolia's economy is highly dependent on trade with China. It's a landlocked country with a small population that's increasingly urbanizing. People and goods cannot go out without passing through Chinese or Russian territory. It is a nation whose glory has long faded hundreds of years ago. So it doesn't really make sense for the younger generation to even cultivate relation-breaking hatred against the Chinese.
Main problem 7.3 million Mongolians live in China (70% of the world's Mongolians) Gdp Inner Mongolia is 23 times higher than that of Outer Mongolia, Mongolian population's rapprochement towards China scares Mongolian politicians, Mongolian politicians need to grow hostility towards China to maintain their government, becoming a Chinese province again is a nightmare for them
@@user-gq4fy6fh7z What did lie about exactly? You’re the one who’s lying without knowing what you’re talking about . Typical arrogant Chinese who sees everything as part of China .
I think Mongolian must be honoured Han Chinese about the barbaric historical of Mongol that invade China, by blessing Chinese all of Mongolians still exists today
Firstly, most barbaric history that in Asia is not Mongolian empire,it is the event called:” the great purge of inner Mongolian party “made by mao ze dong and teng hai qing.han Chinese are more barbaric.
@@user-cm3kz1sh9u Did Kublai Khan develop China? In the Yuan Dynasty, even the basic administrative and taxation capabilities of China were paralyzed. Except for changing the Mongolian White Festival to the first day of the lunar calendar, he had no political achievements.
That is because Japanese and Korean are from the same language family as Mongolian, called the Altaic languages. The family includes Turkic, Mongolic, Koreanic, Japonic, and a few more. Although Japonic and Koreanic are rarely included in the list, they are still considered a part of the Altaic family.
Well, chinese dynasties always wanted mongolian tribes to infight each other and it worked well for hundreds of years until Chingis Khaan united all tribes. So it means chinese dynasties created their own enemy. Thanks for infighting between mongolian tribes that turned mongolia to war juggernaut. Eventually backfired to chinese dynasties.
The Great Wall of China, built by the ancient Chinese, was expanded over thousands of years to prevent invasions by northern nomadic peoples (Manchurians, Jurchens, Mongols, and Koreans). This means that the ancient Chinese perceived the peoples of Manchuria, Liaodong, and the Korean Peninsula as other ethnic groups, barbarians, and enemies. Of course, this means that ancient China had no control over this land until it was conquered by the peoples of Manchuria and Liaodong outside the Great Wall of China.
It's civil war of China! China is not belong to Han people only. It's belong to all race live in this land. Do you know when yuan dynasty our Mongolian use han character write the imperial edict to other country? We used the han's political system. We create the capital of China ''beijing" be used until today. We fight for be the king of China, like other Chinese. only khan of China is the real khan! We named the dynasty "yuan" not han people.
You only mention the colonial history of Mongolia, but not the colonization of China, the invasion of Asia by Mongolia, M3, too hypocritical. No one's forcing you to like anyone.
80-90% of the Manchus in 1600s and 1700s are actually Han Chinese though, Jurchen and Mongol banners never comprised more than 20% of the total Manchu population, remaining 80% of the Manchus are Han Chinese.
@@bowong422I am from Mongolia,in 1644 southern mongols helped manchus to occupy China.Now many manchus are assimilated.Mongols love Soviet Union and russians which saved Outer Mongolia from cruel chinese occupation.Most mongols dislike China and believe that one day chinese cruel soldiers will invade our lovely country and will exterminate native people.I will be happen and will most dark day in mongol history.
@@bowong422 Manchu are very Chinese genetically. So close they are genetically indistinguishable. I don't know why people think Manchu are just straight up Tungusic.
Khalkha Mongols were among the first people to join the Jurchen's (aka Manchu's) conquest of the rest of China and were very much part of the ruling elite of the Qing empire. They were pivotal in the Manchus' conquests and subjugation of both the Han Chinese and Oirat Mongols and among the most loyal defenders of the late empire during the rebellions and foreign invasions of the 19th century. To say "the Manchus and the Khalkha Mongols occupied China for 200 (sic) years" would be closer to the truth.
@@khuslennnnnnn yes, Khalkha Mongols of that time remind me of the moment when the British joined the Americans to conquer Iraq in 2003, a pathetic attempt to relive the faded glory days of empire off the backs of a great power, like a little monkey riding on the back of a massive gorilla.
Just wanna point out that they are all speaking their own language in the video. In inner mongolia young people don't speak mongolian anymore. China is rich but don't repect culture of other people.
Every sign in inner Mongolian are written in two languages: Chinese and traditional Mongolian, however in Mongolian they would like to use Russia characters rather than their traditional characters. Now just tell me which country’s culture are closed to the history
@@myhugeairpotMongolia,china is famous genocide nation.mao ze dong is genocide expert.he invaded Korea and let 20m Korean live in hell still today,but Chinese still have no apologize to Koreans,they do not respect Korean sovereignty.china is totally genocide nation.world all know that
Looking at world map, there is no point to hate China. For those of you who thinks my government is evil or sth are extremely naive on geopolitic. People remember history for preventing same mistake but not for being unrealistic. Peace tho
There's so many misinformation here. Under the Qing Dynasty, Mongols were better treated than Han Chinese. I don't know where these people get their info from. The Han wanted to overthrow the Qing government. That's why there was the Taiping Rebellion and other rebellions in the South against the Qing. Manchus overthrew the Ming Dynasty, which was a real Chinese dynasty. Genghis and Kublai Khan invaded and ruled China for 100 years, so should the Chinese hate the Mongols for that too? These are silly misguided people.
Yeah they were treated so much better you know? Dzungar genocide; being banned from leaving your banners; being forced to wear Manchu queue; Jindangdao massacre; population decline; ban on archery; forced immigration of Han Chinese farmers with the aim of total assimilation. Such preferential treatments…
@@manduul.bakhdalDzungar genocide had Khalkha and Chahar Mongols involved. It was not a decision by Han Chinese. My point here is that the hate against Chinese but which ones? Manchu Chinese, Han Chinese, Mongol Chinese?
Mongolia is a great country with many kind and hardworking people. However, over the years, many Mongolians have damaged this beautiful land in pursuit of wealth, resulting in severe pollution, poor transportation, and inadequate urban development. Despite the appearance of democratic elections, corruption remains rampant, with even the airport being owned by Japanese interests. Some Mongolians hold biases and display arrogance towards China, even fostering baseless fears, yet they exhibit reluctance to engage in their own country's development. Unfortunately, in China, Mongolia's concerns are often overlooked. Chinese people hope for Mongolia to achieve better development, raise living standards, improve environmental protection, and take pride in their own culture rather than simply imitating Korean or Hollywood culture. They hope that young Mongolians studying abroad will return home to contribute to the progress of their homeland. Let's look forward to a future of friendly relations between our two countries. Every country should have the opportunity for development, rather than being solely manipulated by international geopolitics
lmao, North Koreans respect China, you South Koreans hate China because your country is a colonial possession of the United States and so is Japan, wake up to the propaganda that your US overlords who forced bases to be installed in your country, own and control all your conglomerates and bed your women. China is not your enemy we are the same people with the same ethnic ancestors thousands of years ago, we have a very similar culture and face many of the same problems. Grow a spine and recognize the Americans are using you, they would ditch you in a heartbeat when you become useless.
@@lutherschultz4725 I'm sorry, but our northern brothers don't support China Kim Jong-un said Japan is a 100-year enemy, China is a 1,000-year enemy Kim Jong-il said he doesn't trust China more than the U.S Koreans in North and South Korea do not support China It's harsh, but it's true You Chinese are hated and isolated by Asians
@@lutherschultz4725 Nope. North Koreans really really hate Chinese. Now there are quite many youtube channels run by North Korean defectors. That's what they said about how much they and North Koreans hate C. Because they know how badly Chinese treated North Korean defectors and factory workers. They know China more by extreme experience.
@@GjFl-ue1ff kick the American masters out of your country first before you pretend like you know anything, I have actually been to North Korea, have you? Millions of North Koreans live in China and have Chinese citizenship, they are one of the 56 nationalities of China 朝鲜族. You only hear what your overlord wants you to hear, your country is literally owned by them, US investors own more than 50% of Samsung and your other large conglomerates, the senior leadership are all Americans, when your country wants to pass a law they have to consult the Americans first. The US are bleeding your people dry and you can't do anything about it. Btw just because I point out flaws with your society doesn't mean I don't respect Koreans, Koreans are intelligent and hard working, I also like how strong your people are culturally bounded to your Korean heritage, I hope this doesn't change in the future and you guys don't get too westernized by US influence. Do not see China as your enemy, we only want our Asian neighbors to be able to act independently outside of European/US imperialistic influence, Chinese people see other East Asians as close relatives who come from the same ancestral lineage and wish them well. At the rate it's going in Japan with it's low birthrates and liberal foreign immigration(invasion) supported by the US, it's going to become a mixed country like Mexico or the Philippines, if you don't want this to happen to Korea you need to get the united states out of your government and your corporations.
It was not China that colonized Mongolia for 200 years, it was Manchuria (Qing Dynasty) which colonized China and Mongolia for over 200 years. But during Qing Dynasty, Mongolians were ruling class, enjoying a much higher social status / better treatment than Han people. That is why the banner by the founding fathers of the Republic of China ( ROC ) was : " to drive away the Manchu invaders, restore the Chinese sovereignty, ......"
不要搭理解外蒙古了，一个卖逼的国家有什么用？
更何况蒙古正统在中国
The problem is China's textbook says Qing Dynasty is a Chinese dynasty and Manchuria is China!
@@HaiLe-xk9qw 因为清朝完全承接了明朝的统治制度，并且最终完全汉化，更重要是清朝很大程度拓展了汉人的生存空间。在中国历史上，有很多与少数民族关系密切的朝代，老百姓对于皇帝是不是汉人，没有那么在意，他们更关心自己的生活，汉人当皇帝同样会压迫底层百姓，甚至更加严酷。
@@user-pd4yp9jm2c You didn't answer my question. Is Qing a China's dynasty or not? Is Manchuria China or not? Yes or No?
@@HaiLe-xk9qwIt's only considered a Chinese dynasty because it happened in China. But you have to understand that it was led by the Manchu people, an ethnic minority group in China, and not the Han people, another ethnic group. So Manchuria is NOT China but A PART of China. There's a difference. And how do you expect textbooks to fit in all the history of China in detail when there are thousands of years worth of events?
Nice video! Greetings from northwest Alaska!
Keep up these great street interviews
Funny thing about this guy is he would only ask what Mongolians think about Russia and USA. But for the question on China, he would ask why people hate China instead of what people think of. He should also ask why Mongolians can't read/write in Mongolian script.
Sad fact, Mongols are more literated than China.
Pressure and influence from Russia during the last century. We had to ask them to leave in 1990s. Now we’re re learning Mongolian script in schools
Dude, this is just 2nd part of the interview. There is a whole another video of Mongolians talking about things they like about China. Dont be silly. th-cam.com/video/20S5xAOXjGA/w-d-xo.htmlsi=RPpONksWKLimtPf5
@@realmongolia101 Chinese people love to play the victim and pity themselves. 😉
@@realmongolia101ᠴᠢᠩᠭᠢᠰ ᠬᠠᠭᠠᠨ ᠤ ᠦᠯᠡᠳᠡᠭᠡᠭᠰᠡᠨ ᠦᠰᠦᠭ ᠪᠢᠴᠢᠭ ᠢ ᠤᠷᠬᠢᠵᠤ᠂ ᠳᠤᠷᠠᠲᠠᠶᠠ ᠮᠠᠨᠤᠤᠯ ᠪᠣᠯᠤᠨᠠ; ᠵᠠᠭᠤᠨ ᠵᠢᠯ ᠦᠨ ᠭᠤᠲᠤᠮᠰᠢᠭ ᠤᠨ ᠤᠴᠠᠷᠠᠭᠤᠯᠤᠭᠰᠠᠨ ᠭᠠᠰᠠᠯᠠᠩ ᠵᠣᠪᠠᠯᠠᠩ ᠢ ᠲᠠᠶᠠᠭᠳᠠᠵᠤ᠂ ᠪᠠᠶᠢᠭᠤᠯᠤᠭᠰᠠᠨ ᠬᠠᠭᠠᠴᠠᠭᠤᠯᠤᠭᠴᠢ ᠵᠠᠰᠠᠭ ᠤᠨ ᠡᠷᠬᠡ᠃ ᠴᠢᠨᠦ ᠮᠡᠳᠡᠬᠦ ᠴᠢᠬᠤᠯᠠ ᠲᠠᠶ ᠵᠦᠢᠯ ᠭᠡᠪᠡᠯ᠂ ᠮᠣᠩᠭᠣᠯ ᠤᠯᠤᠰ ᠢ ᠪᠠᠶᠢᠭᠤᠯᠤᠭᠰᠠᠳ ᠨᠢ ᠺᠣᠷᠢᠶᠠ ᠶᠢ ᠪᠠᠶᠢᠭᠤᠯᠤᠭᠰᠠᠳ ᠲᠠᠶ ᠠᠳᠠᠯᠢ ᠪᠠᠷ᠂ ᠪᠦᠷ ᠬᠣᠶᠠᠳᠤᠭᠠᠷ ᠳᠠᠶᠢᠨ ᠦ ᠦᠶᠡ ᠶᠢᠨ ᠶᠠᠫᠣᠨ ᠤ ᠵᠢᠷᠤᠭᠠ ᠨᠣᠬᠠᠳ ᠪᠣᠯᠤᠨᠠ᠂ ᠵᠢᠩᠬᠢᠨᠢ ᠴᠢᠩᠭᠢᠰ ᠬᠠᠭᠠᠨ ᠤ ᠴᠢᠰᠤᠨ ᠰᠤᠳᠠᠰᠤ ᠤᠷᠤᠰᠴᠤ ᠪᠠᠶᠢᠭᠠ ᠮᠣᠩᠭᠣᠯ ᠦᠨᠳᠦᠰᠦᠲᠡᠨ ᠥᠪᠥᠷ ᠮᠣᠩᠭᠣᠯ ᠳᠤ ᠪᠠᠶᠢᠨᠠ᠂ ᠮᠣᠩᠭᠣᠯ ᠤᠯᠤᠰ ᠢ ᠵᠢᠭᠰᠢᠳᠡᠭ ᠬᠥᠮᠦᠨ ᠪᠣᠯ ᠳᠤᠮᠳᠠᠳᠤ ᠤᠯᠤᠰ ᠪᠢᠰᠢ᠂ ᠪᠦᠷ ᠵᠢᠩᠬᠢᠨᠢ ᠮᠣᠩᠭᠣᠯ ᠦᠨᠳᠦᠰᠦᠲᠡᠨ ᠪᠣᠯᠤᠨᠠ
我建议评论里面的中国人少点拉仇恨，蒙古并不是什么anti-china的国家，多一些历史沟通更好，而不是嘲讽发展中国家。中国人不应该因为这些年的发展而形成帝国主义思维
为什么中国人掩盖自己的数次种族屠杀行为？对蒙古族 回族 藏族 维族 满族都施行过灭绝人性的大屠杀，并且美化毛泽东这个人类历史最大的罪人和刽子手？毛泽东杀的人可比希特勒和日本加起来还要多
@@halaga-kb8ez滚
@@halaga-kb8ez毛泽东杀少了，应该多图图你这种人
@@myhugeairpot毛泽东不光屠杀少数民族。毛泽东领导的政权有大饥荒死千百万人的伟大成就，韩战冰雕连、文革批斗迫害功等伟大成就。别生气，冻个冰雕连吃个蛋炒饭压压惊
@@halaga-kb8ez你们港台蛙人或者轮子能不能换套词，我本人就是满族人全家都是党员觉得你们真的很脑瘫，图你真的属于净化空气是环保措施了属于
The Mongols and Manchus are nomadic peoples. The Han nationality is an agricultural civilization. Their history is that of Mongols and Manchus invading the Han. But it was eventually conquered by Han culture. All 52 ethnic groups merge into the Chinese nation.
Even Russia among chinese 52 nations haha
56
@@angsern8455 My mistake. Thanks
@@tianxu6611 There are 195 countries in the world, but 56 belong to China? haha
Chinese are Manchu and Manchu are Chinese. When Manchus formed together they had 99% Chinese blood. Stop the larp.
Really thoughtful answers!
Seeing some of the malicious remarks from Mongolians in the comments section, I have to speak out.The Mongols destroyed the Southern Song Dynasty, and the emperors of the Yuan Dynasty condoned Mongol nobles and Semu people. Some Tibetan monks in Han territory engaged in corruption and extortion, emptying the wealth of the entire Southern Song Dynasty. Combined with various natural disasters and misguided governance, the land of the entire Southern Song Dynasty became a land of death during the decades of Mongol rule. The people of southern China harbored extreme hatred towards the Mongols. How do Mongols who clamor about the evil of the Han people in the comments section view this? At that time, the Mongol army slaughtered a million people in Sichuan in order to coerce the Song state to surrender. What do the Mongols think about this? Not to mention that the Mongols directly caused a discontinuation in Chinese history, leading to a great regression in civilization. How many Chinese people today seriously hold you accountable for this unprecedented loss? If you truly feel that we have wronged you, remember that historically it was you who repeatedly initiated aggression against the Chinese, and you have always taken pride in it, causing countless injuries to the Chinese, almost several times more than Japan. Yet how many Han people seriously hold onto past hatred, regarding you Mongols as true enemies? You yourselves allied with the Manchus for your own interests, wanting to jointly rule China like the Manchus did, thinking you could still be as glorious as before, but you were ultimately manipulated by Manchu emperors using Buddhism and Shanxi merchants, leading to a sharp decline in population and loss of combat capability. Aren't these all the evil consequences you brought upon yourselves? Did Han people force you to hand over Inner Mongolia to the Manchus so you could attack the Ming Dynasty smoothly? And don't you realize that your experiences in the late Qing Dynasty are almost identical to those of the Chinese throughout the entire Yuan Dynasty? It's truly ironic.
The Qing genocided the Dzungars....
@@oh.s The entire Chinese nationalism is built on a victim mindset. Just like Israel. They’ll always see themselves as victims no matter what they do.
@@oh.s Manchus are not Chinese at first
@@Twodime4032 Manchu are not Chinese at first like Japanese were not Jomon first. Japanese are Japanese and Chinese are Chinese. Manchu is not a genetic identity. They just are Chinese genetically.
It's backed by the USA so it is right to do, LOL joke aside, I think it's always important to see both sides before making quick judgement
蒙古🇲🇳是俄罗斯从中国剥离出去的，大家要记住历史
放屁，汉国才是从蒙古国分裂出去的叛乱省份。
😂
@@zhangjack-un9we Nothing to be crying. The fact was that Mongolia became independent in 1911 when China was ruled by the Manchu Qing Empire.
@@zorighongatan7476 In fact, Mongolia's independence was due to the Soviet Union's invasion of China. Have you forgotten everything the Soviet Union did to Mongolia
@@zorighongatan7476 Cruel assimilation policies
蒙古人讨厌中国可能没人在乎，问题是如果中国人讨厌蒙古人的时候蒙古人还有没有活路？
蒙古政府实际上在做幕后推手，其实很愚蠢
精英并不在乎 他们需要这么做来转移对统治阶层的矛盾
刚好相反，蒙古政府努力跟中国搞好关系，民间有反华情绪
蒙古人民知道怎么救蒙古@@marcello8129
蒙古人不喜歡中國人, 日本人也不喜歡中國人, 韓國人也不喜歡中國人, 台灣人也不喜歡中國人, 香港人也不喜歡中國人, 菲律賓人也不喜歡中國人, 越南人也不喜歡中國人, 印度人也不喜歡中國人, 泰國人也不喜歡中國人, 美國人也不喜歡中國人, 歐洲人也不喜歡中國人, 澳洲人也不喜歡中國人
中國人可以讓全世界這麼多國的人, 尤其中國附近的亞洲鄰居, 討厭他們討厭成這樣, 代表中國人的行為的確讓大家都討厭, 而中國人沒有改善的跡象, 還惡化, 所以大家才越來越討厭中國, 我講到這裡, 你大概只會反駁, 而不願意檢討自己, 因為中國人就是這樣, 自己都是對的, 別人檢討中國人一定是因為對方是種族歧視, 接受不了批評, 還要當作惡意來拉高自己對其他國家的仇恨值
中國人完全體現了為何全世界都討厭你們, 你們最好都待在中國, 要不然我擔心你們出國會被打
@@yaya5tim 韩国人尤其喜欢蒙古国。因为那是韩国妓院。
Learned many real history here, very grateful ❤and I really like Mongolian and Mongolia 🇲🇳
Very informative. Maybe make a video on how Mongolians feel about Russia or the US?
Very divided. Older generations generally like the Soviet Union (due to factories providing jobs and Soviet allies joining the Mongol military to protect the Mongol homeland against potential Japanese and Chinese occupation), have good/neutral sentiments about modern Russia (because of our people there) while the youth doesn't think much about Russia nor the Soviet Union. USA sentiments vary but Mongolia wants to work with USA just like China worked with the USA to become billionaires and millionaires. Mongolia views USA as a third neighbor with lots of avenues for trade and military cooperation. Thousands of Mongolians allied with the West to protect Afghanistan before, even gaining a reputation for being fierce and alert soldiers amongst their international soldiers and peers.
Actually, Mongolians had colonised China for around 200 years, and Russia.
60year
Its very impressive that young gens in Mongolia r so wise and open to their neighboring country. Although there r some passive sounds for Chinese, more young ppl r think about relationships with other countries more positively and forward. Plus, young ppl look so fashionable and good look. : ) Like ur work.
Anyway, just ignore the Chinese comments, that means most of them cant understand this video. Pity.
Japanese don’t like Chinese, I agree with them. Just look at your arrogant attitude.
@@baatarI think the Chinese despise Japanese too, with the rape of Nanking and all
I love learning new things ❤
The last lady who spoke in the video has such a lovely melodious voice ❤
Out of all the interviews I've seen, this is the most reasonable one. They actually gave specific reasons (historical or cultural). In other videos, 95% of Mongolians that were interviewed could never explain why they hate Chinese people! It's almost like they were born to naturally hate Chinese people.
From an outsider's perspective, it should be the Chinese that should hate the Mongolians, because the Mongols and their ancestors (the Xiongnus) have tried to invade China for almost 3,000 years, and succeeded once with Genghis/Kublai Khan.
Mongolians hate China because Chinese are easily hateable and it's socially encouraged. This can be due to a lot of reasons, but for Mongolians who take pride in their Empire, of course it tastes like shit if they were colonised by the Chinese.
Everybody outside China hates Xi Jinping. Got it?
Nobody likes Chinese except maybe North Koreans, and some Pakistanis
In addition, most generations from the golden family (their family) currently live in inner mongolia which is in China🤣 This video makes me very confused as a mongolian having some direct link to those who ruled China in Yuan Dynasty. 😧
@@sinakethunder5191how much of that Mongol DNA is intact? 5%? It’s mostly Chinese blood at this point. If Kazakhs see Mongolians as a bunch of Chinese imposters, I can guarantee you for a fact that they will see you Inner Mongols as straight up Chinese, no doubt about it.
说的好像真的有人在乎蒙古人怎么想的 ， 管好韩国人在你们土地上的矿区吧，黄沙真的很讨厌
就…..他们好像很在乎中国人怎么看😂我是南方人，对蒙古🇲🇳根本不在意也没兴趣，🤷不知道为什么莫名其妙恨中国，搞笑的是他们甚至放弃了自己的文字，而我的内蒙同学反而能够熟练使用回鹘文。
除了那边出来的沙尘，没人会想起任何关于外蒙古的事，都是屁事。
Hello brother i had question and i hope you have a answer to my question my question is that is there any hazaras in mongolia
Geopolitics aside, I love how the Mongolian language sounds :)
I'm Mongolian, and I'm curious what language Mongolian sounds like?
to me like a lisping Turk
@@user-uf1to7fx1p To me, Mongolian sounds like the middle between European and Asian languages.
It sounds like Russian and Turkish mixed with the same little mannerisms of Korean and Japanese.
burden of history in the past in the end only brings hate and misunderstanding
I mean there is no such thing as stealing culture.. you cannot deny that there are 4 million Mongolians living in china, which is even more than mongolians in Mongolia. These Mongolian-Chinese deserve to get recognized of their culture and tradition.
The tortilla came from Mesoamerican natives, yet many think it is Mexican. However it is more often for it to be simply an exchange of culture and not so much stealing culture.
as for culture they say, Inner Mongolia is a part of Mongolian culture
Gdp Inner Mongolia is 23 times higher than that of Outer Mongolia
The ending says a lot
Most of the Mongols are ------ What's your favorite country? Korea Japan USA France Greece Spain Turkey Canada Morocco Russia singapore Norway Deautch land Denmark Swiss Netherlands Australia UK .....
Most of the Mongols are ------- Which country do you hate?? China China China China China China .....
its real
I wonder what Mongolians think of Russia, considering the relationship between the USSR and Choibalsan in the MPR. Great interview!
The over 40s think of the Russians as their brothers.
Because of the war between Russia and Ukraine. We’ve lost respect
Russia used hate towards china to be his puppet. But now new generation have different view. People who where raised during soviet regime is so brainwashed they will die with their belief. But any country who is neighbors are not always friendly. But most important thing is that even Mongolia is a small country sandwiched between 2 world giants communist dictatorship country is still democratic and free.
It's good to know that Mongolian youth are much more rational than their elder
Thank you!
Mongolia colonized China for a 100 years, then Manchu colonized both Han Chinese and Mongolia for more than 200 years. So, you have to know very little about history to hate China.
Technically non of them colonized china they just changed a dynasty
so the Qing dynasty isn't a Chinese dynasty? Why does China textbook say it is?!
@@HaiLe-xk9qw 所以，你们外蒙人应该考虑去找满族人要答案。不过现在你们硬要把你们历史上所遭受的放在其他无辜的民族身上，我觉得大多数的人应该也不会抗拒你们来实质性的侵犯我们的领土，甚至有点希望你们这么去做。懂？🤤
@@HaiLe-xk9qw 不过，翻开历史来看，蒙古人手上可是沾满了欧亚大陆人民的鲜血。满脸麻子的人就别不害臊地指着别人的脸说有个污点。
the chinese give us all the poisons
别吃中国人的毒药不就行了，最好就是和中国断交，我倒要看看你们蒙古人是怎么用飞机运煤矿和铜矿的？看看和中国断交后你们能撑几天。你们也别想指望俄罗斯的帮助，没有中国的帮助，俄罗斯自己都难保。
别吃中国人的毒药不就行了，最好就是和中国断交，我倒要看看你们蒙古人是怎么用飞机运煤矿和铜矿的？看看和中国断交后你们能撑几天。你们也别想指望俄罗斯的帮助，没有中国的帮助，俄罗斯自己都难保。
The youtube channels name is the "Real Mongolia"... is there a fake mongolia too ? cause i can't see it on the map. 😂
I think the owner of this channel gave this name to show the authentic side of mongolia to the world as a mongolian. If you search mongolia on youtube, you might only find videos of tourists showing their experience of 1-2 weeks of trips which might not showcase the everyday life of mongolia and its citizens
@@odnuu ...... Though, You still didn't answer the question about, Why use "Real mongolia" name on the channel ? We know who you are ! The mongols.
i asked, are there more pretenders or fake mongolians ?
i didn't asked authenticity... i asked are there more mongols than "inner mongolians" and the "Central mongolians"? Are they the real mongolians ? So who is the fake one ?... that's what i asked...
Why say "The Real Mongolians" ? When there is only 2 country with that name on the google ?
Sounds like you guys are the ones who have ownership problem ? 😂
@@odnuu i replied to you, But That "Real Mongolia" is keep deleting my comments ! lol, Afraid of the youtube or the china ?
@@Smiley-ps1yc I guess i misinterpreted your statement in your first comment. i thought you were genuinely curious as to why the author named the channel ' Real Mongolia" and tried to give my own interpretation of the name of the channel. But I guess you wish to misinterpret the name in your own condensending way. There is no real or fake Mongolia as far as I know. It's not as the author named their channel "Only real Mongolia" which incase your interpretation could be justified.
I'm Korean 🇰🇷 I like Mongolia and China. 🇲🇳 🇨🇳
我是韓國人。 我喜歡蒙古國和中國。
전 한국인입니다. 전 몽골국과 중국을 좋아합니다.
Mongolia is great Country with population around 3 and half million and wasted Gobi resert lands
The people in the video say positive things about china and its people while criticising elder generation for being blind and judgemental. Then I go to the comment section and read how Mongolians are poor and impoverished dissapearing nation written by the citizens of the developed neighbor. What's up with that. Who has more resentment and hatred? I am confused.
Of course they won't be honest with you on camera, but why would the Chinese prefer to travel to Southeast Asia instead of Mongolia? It is that the Mongols attack Chinese tourists who go to travel, resulting in no one willing to go to Mongolia, investment and tourists are not willing to go to Mongolia, otherwise why next to China and Russia, Mongolia's economy will be so poor
@@user-jq3xn4iy1t because no one other than Sea asians want Chinese to come in as a guest. 😂😂 That's why Chinese only can go to Vietnam or laos... made in China!!!!
@@user-jq3xn4iy1tah so chinese love south east asi thats why your ccp gov. stealing our island in west philippine sea.
Chinese on TH-cam are very annoying. Maybe paid by their government. They seem to hate every country except their own.
@@i-eat-youyou are the type of hater that I respect, because atleast you don't put on the facade of just hating the Chinese government, you hate the Chinese people as well, which quite a lot of the Chinese govt. haters secretly do but they don't say so. You are from Germany right? I don't understand why there would be a reason for you to have enmity with the Chinese but maybe it's a personal reason? Who knows
china also has Inner Mongolia so many overlapping of cultural claim, I don't think its that much of a horrible thing, America and Britain share huge chunk of history together why that's a matter? it can be seen as a bridge between two countries cos we have shared culture.
PRC(People’s Republic of China): recognizes Mongolia as an independent country
ROC(Republic of China，Now has fled to Tai**wan proviince) : does not recognize Mongolia as an independent country
Well, fyi Taiwan recognized us in 2002.
所有中国人都知道蒙古国人仇恨中国，但我们并不关心。因为蒙古国只是一个无人在意、毫无前途的欠发达国家，原谅我的直白，但这就是事实。他们全国的人口加起来没有中国的一个县多，他们的国土大部分是不适合人类生存的荒漠，反华议程是他们维持自身独立性和骄傲的唯一手段。喀尔喀人试图把整个蒙古帝国的历史纳为己有，但我们都知道他们的祖先只是漠北草原上的几个弱小部落，并不能代表所有蒙古人。忽必烈曾带领汉族军队多次攻占哈拉和林并把漠北蒙古视为野蛮人。
You lied about history.
既然你不关心不在意蒙古国，你为啥看这个视频？为啥挠了这么多字😂
@@marcello8129 告诉我忽必烈是如何打败阿里不哥并设置和林宣慰司的，Truth hurts, right? 我们不在乎蒙古国不意味着我们不清楚历史。
@@marcello8129因为youtube推给我的，而且封面展示着国旗才点进来，不然有谁会去关注蒙古？
Are your parents have been run over by tank in Tianmen square? Your brain is not working properly with that CCP chip
评论当中，恶意的评论很多，而善意的评论很少。这的情况更能反映两个国家老百姓之间的态度。
事实上，大多数中国人不了解蒙古，蒙古人也不了解中国，人们都是被告诉对方国家有多坏。人们之间的没有理由仇恨是不理智的。
我作为中国人，我对蒙古的认识很少，中国政府也没有宣传蒙古国有什么不好的，中国人会因为蒙古穷而看不起蒙古，现在没有中国人因为历史去敌视蒙古。
另外，随着普通中国人通过互联网越来越多的了解蒙古人对中国人的态度很不好，所以现在中国人普遍认为蒙古人仇视中国人，这是个现实，我认为中国人对蒙古人的态度比之前变坏了很多（因为以前中国人不知道蒙古人仇视中国人）
你錯了, 蒙古人不喜歡中國人, 日本人也不喜歡中國人, 韓國人也不喜歡中國人, 台灣人也不喜歡中國人, 香港人也不喜歡中國人, 菲律賓人也不喜歡中國人, 越南人也不喜歡中國人, 印度人也不喜歡中國人, 泰國人也不喜歡中國人, 美國人也不喜歡中國人, 歐洲人也不喜歡中國人, 澳洲人也不喜歡中國人
中國人可以讓全世界這麼多國的人, 尤其中國附近的亞洲鄰居, 討厭他們討厭成這樣, 代表中國人的行為的確讓大家都討厭, 而中國人沒有改善的跡象, 還惡化, 所以大家才越來越討厭中國, 我講到這裡, 你大概只會反駁, 而不願意檢討自己, 因為中國人就是這樣, 自己都是對的, 別人檢討中國人一定是因為對方是種族歧視, 接受不了批評, 還要當作惡意來拉高自己對其他國家的仇恨值
@@yaya5timwhere do you come from? TW?
He's Mainland Chinese 😊 @@FlSl-pb9kf
@@yaya5tim 呆蛙这么恨中国人，也改变不了走遍全世界被人叫中国人的现实，幼稚，巨婴😀
@@i-eat-you No, He is from Taiwan Province of China
The question should be why the chinese shouldnt hate Mongolian after they grand father had invaded and murdered so many chinese during the period of yuan dynasty?
The Chinese have forgotten the damage caused by the Mongol Empire. After all, look at what they are like now.
@@user-yq5he3rg8oBecause 7.3 million Mongolians live in China, 70% of the world's Mongolians, for the Chinese the Yuan dynasty belongs to both sides
In fact, in the eyes of the Mongolian people, Inner Mongolia is the core region of Mongolia. Mongolia belongs to the border area, and there are many more Mongolians in China than Mongolia, so the history of China and Mongolia blend together
@@00jack80 , also the chinese should thank to mongolian by bringing much arab's cultural treasure in to chinese civilisation.
@@walhdamaskus2408Arab and Persian culture already existed in China during Tang Dynasty. The oldest mosque is in Guangzhou, when Arab trader went to China by sea 1300 years ago. In Xi'an, there's a Muslim quarter dedicated to Muslim Chinese. The Hui people are the descendants of Arab/Persian traders who married into the locals from the 7th - 10th century (Tang Dynasty). Mongols, on the other hand, pillage and sacked Baghdad - the center of Islamic world.
For me its about beauty standard and history.
When the kavaleri era replaced by vehicles, the advantage Also replaced
Genghis Khan laughing at the corner 😂😂😂
中國沒有幫助其他國家的義務
如果有些國家一直視中國為敵人 那麼中國應該停止對他們的幫助 直到他們學會什麼叫做尊重
Hello chinas bot😊
Your a chinese kid
I’m Korean and Mongolia and Korea are quite good political partners
Maybe we can share a lot of things in that we have the same opponents to be wary of
A traitor who fully embraces Russian culture and a traitor who completely accepts American culture-when it comes to cultural identity, Japan surpasses both of you.
You Koreans are just puppets of America and the west. All of you talk so tough online but when a white person comes to your land you quickly get on your knees and beg for approval like lapdogs.
I hope one day Koreans have the dignity to not be a colony of America
@@user-ru3mp7cz5u Calm down.
China has a lot of influence in Asia
Sometimes your great influence makes neighboring countries uneasy
We have no choice but to be dragged by your influence
But every country has a culture and an identity
But the Chinese always ignore it
Koreans feel a sense of opposition to this remark
China has been semi-colonialized by Japan, including the Nanjing Massacre
Even if they became Japanese colonies, it is not without their identity
In some ways, Korea and China share the same historical scars
But why do you want to give back to Koreans the hurt you have suffered?
Be humble
China's influence is great, but it is possible when the surrounding countries agree with you
I hope China will be qualified as a leader in Asia
@@frankhill4358 Calm down.
China has a lot of influence in Asia
Sometimes your great influence makes neighboring countries uneasy
We have no choice but to be dragged by your influence
But every country has a culture and an identity
But the Chinese always ignore it
Koreans feel a sense of opposition to this remark
China has been semi-colonialized by Japan, including the Nanjing Massacre
Even if they became Japanese colonies, it is not without their identity
In some ways, Korea and China share the same historical scars
But why do you want to give back to Koreans the hurt you have suffered?
Be humble
China's influence is great, but it is possible when the surrounding countries agree with you
I hope China will be qualified as a leader in Asia
作為中國的鄰居 把中國視為敵人只會讓中國人更忽視你
I am Mongolian and want to reunite with my Buryat/Tuva sisters in Russia-occupied Mongolia and Uzemchin/Barga brothers in China-occupied Mongolia with help from our Kazakh/Uyghur cousins in Kazakhstan/Turkestan. I want to see our work boost the Mongolia GDP instead of rushing into Russia or China. Our land is rich. Our people are strategic. Our unity will cause the largest shift in Asia anybody has ever seen. Mongol Turge humuus negdej l uursduu huvtas hunsee hiij l oros hyatadiin door orohgui gedgiig sain oilgoiroi.
Oh BTW I am half Manchu heritage so basically your ancestors were our slaves in the past.
@@songhanshan9843 Who asked?
Cry more
@@voido68 I am hopeful. No one is crying. You are the one who will be crying when the Western warplanes come teach you a lesson like they did with Japan.
You Khalkha slaves should come to Beijing and lick our ass.
inner Mongolia gdp has almost 3 times greater than Mongolia
In return, they have to give up their culture
The relationship between the Han and Mongolians should be good. My family was once Mongolian and settled in southern China after Kublai Khan became emperor of China. Mongolia's military system is very backward. Military households are permanently military households and are not allowed to engage in business. Every time they go on an expedition, they have to provide their own weapons and food. The spoils and expenditures are unbalanced. Many Mongolian military households have become slaves. In the Mongolian Empire for less than two hundred years In the history of the empire, rebellions by Mongolian military households have been suppressed everywhere. However, due to the small population of Mongolia, the uprisings ended in failure. It was not until the end of the empire that the Han people joined the uprising and relied on their huge population to defeat the Mongolian nobles. The failure of the Mongol Empire was caused by the internal killings of the golden families and their neglect of the living conditions of the middle and lower-class Mongolian military households. After the Golden Family fled South China, 200,000 military households in North China and Khalkha Mongolia also refused to be loyal. The steppes were locked in a war for the succession to the empire. In the southern farming areas, after the unification of South China and North China, the Han emperor established the Ming Empire. The Mongolian military households who were the main force of his army also received awards and settled in China as military households of the Ming Empire, but they had to change their Mongolian names. It is a Han name. In order to stabilize the Mongolian military households in the army, the Ming Empire also required the royal family to marry Mongolians. The resentment of the Khalkha Mongols came from the fact that Kublai Khan favored the Chinese region and favored the Inner Mongolians when the Manchus ruled Mongolia. As the ruler of the country, Kublai Khan could not be biased towards the politically hostile Khalkha Mongols, and the Manchus would definitely be biased towards the Inner Mongolians who firmly supported them. These two points made the Outer Mongolians feel ostracized by the entire empire and promoted hostility to China by Soviet Union. The current hostility of Outer Mongolians towards the Chinese is mainly due to the huge gap between the rich and the poor. They believe that the rulers ignore the lower-class Mongolians, make secret deals with the Chinese, and vent their emotions on China-related affairs.
You are correct.
It is true that Mongolia is poorer than China, actually China is richer than lot of counties not only Mongolia, but Mongolia is not a poor country compared to other countries, maybe this period is just a period of our decline and a mistake in the system.
compared to which countries? african countries?
@@lyhthegreat No If you find the right way, Mongolia is a richer country than China
African countries rich Dont be judge
Outer Mongolia was a much poorer country than modern day independent Mongolia.
是是是，蒙古国最rich……这个不争辩，你开心就好。
少放点羊多种点树。别老往别人家洒黄土。烦。
Yagad iim bichleg hiij humuusiig herelduuled bdg ymbe? Ugasa hun bolgon oor bodoltoi bga. Iimerhu utgagui sedveer click avh gej ydhima
俄羅斯和西方國家在蒙古的影響力應大幅提升。過去，蘇聯軍隊駐紮在蒙古。屆時，俄羅斯聯邦軍隊的部隊應納入蒙古境內。然而，目前這只能透過蒙古和俄羅斯軍隊透過聯合演習進行合作來實現。應該大量進口
丑人多作怪，穷鬼多怨人
Guts aa guts gichi min
In the midst of civil war in china mongollians ciezed the chance founded they're own country freeing themselves from centuries of occupation. The chinese tried and failed to convince the soviets to give up Mongollia.. They failed and then again when they "supported" our development by giving in chinese workers about 8000 of them to work for Mongolia. These workers used the chinese embassy in mongolia to spread leaflets to the youth to try and sway public opinion of proposal for occupation, it failed. Again they visited Mongolia with theyre ambassador to try threaten the Mongols to give in by using the 8000 workers as leverage and said they pull them back if they didnt oblige to Chinese occupation the Choibalsan flatly declined and nearly got into a fist fight ( this part might be exagerated). The Chinese recognised us as an independent country 1940 only because the soviets forced them to. They rejected our proposal to enter the UN Multiple times arguing mongolia was "a part of China and not a legitimate country" they again got pressured by the soviets to accept our entry. If you think were fools or somehow stupid and dont know the history then your clearly dont know anything.
That called opinion. Its actually common sense.
蒙古人不喜歡中國人, 日本人也不喜歡中國人, 韓國人也不喜歡中國人, 台灣人也不喜歡中國人, 香港人也不喜歡中國人, 菲律賓人也不喜歡中國人, 越南人也不喜歡中國人, 印度人也不喜歡中國人, 泰國人也不喜歡中國人, 美國人也不喜歡中國人, 歐洲人也不喜歡中國人, 澳洲人也不喜歡中國人
中國人可以讓全世界這麼多國的人, 尤其中國附近的亞洲鄰居, 討厭他們討厭成這樣, 代表中國人的行為的確讓大家都討厭, 而中國人沒有改善的跡象, 還惡化, 所以大家才越來越討厭中國, 我講到這裡, 你大概只會反駁, 而不願意檢討自己, 因為中國人就是這樣, 自己都是對的, 別人檢討中國人一定是因為對方是種族歧視, 接受不了批評, 還要當作惡意來拉高自己對其他國家的仇恨值
你是真正的中國人, 你完全體現了為何全世界都討厭你們, 你最好都待在中國, 要不然我擔心你出國會被打
inner mongolia is part of china, so mongolian culture can also be seen in china, we two country can share the culture together
Inner mongolia in Mongolian word called ovor mongol.in Mongolian word ovor mean south.so why Chinese translate it in inner?
@@halaga-kb8ezdidn’t you see how friendly those Mongolian youths to Chinese are. Mongolia will be a part of China soon 😂
@@marcello8129 蒙古人不喜欢中国。free uighur free tibet free Hong Kong free taiwan free Manchuria free south Mongol
Ew pls no
@@halaga-kb8ez 换点话术吧大殖子，看多了还以为是土共请来反串的滞涨。
蒙古已经独立了！内忧外患的清末没能力，还有后来中华民国没有守护好这片领土，新中国大陆也已经承认和建交了，就不会对外蒙古有任何想法了，蒙古自己好好发展，中国也不会为难你发展，兄弟登山各自努力。对中国友善，中国也就对你投桃报李。不友善也不会为难你因为你就是一个普通邻居。
Хуц
但是他会为难你啊😂，一点新闻不看吗
真要这样就好了 各过各的不需要再去管它了 能友善相处当然最好 不友善肯定是要有所应对的
@@ski-mt4fo 怎么为难了？是中国在为难蒙古国吧，自古以来本来就不是一个国家，你们中国人非要说成一个国家，全世界都知道满蒙非支那，支那人真正的国土是长城以南的地方。连孙中山都说驱逐鞑虏，恢复中华。中国人请还给蒙古人自古以来的土地
@@halaga-kb8ez人家把鞑虏驱逐出自己的家乡没毛病呀，你一边大骂中国一边赖在中国不走，你人格分裂
China is funny lol from Philippines 😂
dont forget eating pagpag❤❤❤
Go! Eat your bananas and stay on trees!🙊🙉
Philippines people control by Spanish for hundreds years ，you don’t have own civilization
why Philippines called Philippines? is that the name of a guy on that land ?
@@Exp-se9rs😂😂😂Spanish name ，they don’t have civilization
true
Didn't mention how Mongolian ruled China in the 12th century and seems to be a failure if not one of the darkest times in China history? Only depends on how far back you want to trace history.
Do these people know that Northern Han Chinese people have similar genetic makeup to them? There's been many Turkic Mongol dynasty in the land of China, they've always used Han culture to administer and govern the lands and over time integrated into China's population. Why do you think there's so many people in China? Coz they came and migrated and benefited from Han culture.
As a Chinese I must say, please ignore those toxic comments. In real life most people are kind and have no time to be an online warrior. I love Mongolia and I'm learning Khoomei right now. хайр ба амар тайван❤
Thanks. Most ordinary Chinese people are alright. But these 50c armies are just embarassing for China
Just make business and have friendly cultural exchanges and when one or the other is in trouble come and help one another (for example a natural disaster).
Yep. I agree. There are some Internet trolls. But most Mongolians aren't hateful like that.
Love the positivity brother, if only more people in the comments were as chill as you
China is a country of cultural tolerance. In history, Genghis Khan used to brutally exploit and oppress China. Here I would like to point out that the Manchus once ruled China, but in the early days of their conquest, they adopted cruel means of repression, but gradually, they managed China with the idea of governance, that is, they regarded China as their own territory and ruled it for the purpose of long-term governance, and they had a certain vision of development. However, during the reign of Genghis Khan, the Mongols were always treated by China as the object of exploitation. That is to say, during the Yuan Empire, the Mongols never regarded China as their own territory and people, they only ruthlessly exploited and robbed China, without considering how to govern it for a long time and make the local people live a stable life, so the Yuan Empire did not exist for a long time. But as time went by, the Chinese never hated the Mongols or the Manchus. Instead, we set aside hatred and prejudice to live in harmony with our people. But I know people in Mongolia are very biased and hateful towards Chinese people, I don't know why. From my personal point of view, it may be because the Mongols have conquered many countries and nations in history, so they are immersed in the past pride. As soon as others develop better than they do, their fragile self-esteem turns into jealousy and hatred, attempting to achieve the self-comforting effect of inner balance through psychological contempt for the other person.
country of cultural tolerance that imprison people for their religious belief and snitch on people for smoking weed?
If you "love life" then why do you speak with prejudice? The history of mankind is the same all over the world, except for the details. Truth, and looking at past real events, has value and merit, but not when spoken with contempt. You have your present day challenges, I have mine. Mongolians have theirs. If we are speaking truth, as we should, is it possible you are jealous of Mongolians because their freedom reaches a wider degree than yours? I enjoy listening to these Mongolians express their heartfelt beliefs and opinions openly, on all matters, without fear. Are you good with that?
@@gregb3457 Friend, do you think I have any fear in expressing any opinion here? If I have fears, if I can't express them freely, how can you read my messages? I'm free to say anything, I don't have any fear. The government has a phone number, 12345. I called this government hotline to abuse the country's leaders and the ruling party with profanities for a long time, yet months passed without any fear. I am also here to post comments and discuss issues with you!!
@@gregb3457 I like to emphasize the idea that people with low self-esteem can be very sensitive. It is an objective fact confirmed by psychology, I only speak objective facts, how is this contemptuous and insulting? A rich man is not afraid of being called poor, only poor people care about being called poor. This is definitely real mental activity.
@@lovelife5783 The worst poverty of all has nothing to do with money. And on the inside of apparent external poverty there can reside the greatest of wealth.
Though not Mongolian nationally, I am Buyat Mongol, and I think it is very stupid for anyone to be against China, especially Mongols. Most "Northern Chinese" are very likely genetically Mongol whether they like that or not, so being against them, is like being against your distant cousin. Manchus didn't "colonise" Mongolia, they conquered it and they held such honour and love for Chinghis that only Mongol and Manchu Princesses were allowed to marry the Qing Emperors and Nobility, until centuries later, they allowed Han Chinese to marry too. Many Mongol traditions were practiced by the Qing as well, they even held the Ger as their ceremony house when welcoming guests outside of a palace.
Regardless, we should not be against Chinese, they are not like Europeans, who, if anyone bothered to study world history, were responsible for flooding the entire Qing Empire with narcotics to destroy it's vast wealth, cultural, technological and military power. They colonised most of the world and committed the worst genocides. Would you take such a pack of hyenas as a friend? or the dragon and the bear, who has already had their fill.
有没有一种可能，汉人在两千年前就出现了，蒙古人反而是几千年汉人逃往草原和游牧民混居的？匈奴是印欧游牧民族，不是东亚人种
Mongolia's anti-China stance is politically correct. Caused by state guidance. We start with the Mongol Empire and see who hurt whom more. Today, they do not recognize the Qing Dynasty as a Chinese dynasty, but they use China's invasion of them during the Qing Dynasty as an excuse to hate China.
Love you, bro.
From a Chinese.
actually mongolia government is not anti-china, many cooperation@@user-yq5he3rg8o
@@user-yj1zy2bz8n 不可能，不然基因不会完全不一样
I have to say we never disagree with the first man opinion. We accept Yuan as a dynasty and we learn this history. About culture stealing, idk so I won’t say anything.
they say u guys stole their musical instruments.
@@lyhthegreat Try to imagine u are the China Mongolia in China land. Ur grandparents also. They still keep this traditional musical instrument and they think they are Chinese. Can u say it is not a part of Chinese cultures? But if they still think we stole their cultures, I will just respect them and say yes.
Educational videos,I really learnt a lot from your channel.
As a northern han Chinese,I used to think that mongolians were all rude and ugly.After learning about mongolians,now I find that kind of view was unappropriate and narrow🙁.
Towards your unique facial features,people shouldn't think that's ugly because of our twisted western aesthetic. Beauty shouldn't be defined by only one standard,you are beautiful if you are a confident person,always love what we are born with,this is true us.
You have your own faith and living style,you are strong and respectful.we shouldn't always take historical stuff which happened hundreds of years ago as the reason we hate each other today.We are neighbours,and we are all estern asians,we influenced each other in history. My mindset turned from hate to being friendly. Love mongolian😘
And sorry for bad behaviors done by CCP, han Chinese don't want to steal mongolian instruments,and I admit that our current historical education is wrong.I hope communcation can solve more things.Hostile only brings more hostile,we han Chinese should not be arrogant or misguided too.
It’s funny because Mongolians find Chinese to be rude and ugly too!
Love Mongolia from Romania! ❤
The first guy is wrong. Manchuria and Mongolia were allies fighting together.
haha
Mongolia with it's vast land and resources. While mineral resources can be used as a baseline for economy, other natural resources such as wind and solar can also be use as economy power house. Use those natural wealth to invest on the people's education, public services and further economy development is vital.
적어도 동아시아 국가에서 좋아할 국가가 어디 있겠어? 21세기에도 옛날의 중국을 그리워하며 그저 군림하고 싶어하는데..내몽골도 동화시키려고 한족 이주시키고 몽골어교육도 축소시키고 내몽골을 중국의 역사로 편입시키는 등등 하는 짓들이 역겹다. 만리장성 왜 쌓았는지 잊음? 역사를 지금의 정치로 새로 해석하니 니들이 대접을 못받는거다. 중국이 얼른 쪼개졌으면 좋겠다. 몽골도 내몽골 통일하고 우리도 간도 되찾고 티벳,위구르 독립하고 다른 소수민족들은 독립할지 아니면 중국에 동화될지 알아서들 결정하고 아무튼 중국은 자초하는거야 계속 적을 만들어 안중근의 동양평화론을 지지하는데 그럴 일은 없어 보인다. 동아시아도 한번 eu처럼 뭉쳐야하는데 지금의 중국이 따거역할 제대로 할수나 있겠어?
🇲🇳 🤝 🇰🇷 🇰🇵
Continue to indulge in your dream of the Mongol Empire. Did you drink a lot of bars last night?
@@user-yq5he3rg8o Was anyone talking about the Mongol empire lmao?
@@manduul.bakhdal You Mongolians don’t talk about the Mongol Empire except in your mouth. Everything else talks about the Mongol Empire. Your Mongol Empire has been destroyed for 700 years, but you have never come out.
For millennia, China is Korea's father, in the 21st century Korea has found a new father, why so much hostility towards old fathers lol
uhsen balainiihaa buruu oilgolt geed hutsaad bgaa malnuud ve ene zaluuchuud. naad hujaa nar chn davarhaaraa aimar. ta nariin gazar nutagt urgelj sanaarhaj ovog deedsiig chn horloj irsen. odoo ch buh zuileeree horloj bna. hamgiin muu buteegdehnuunee hurtel yvuulna. Mongold bgaa hurliiz novshnuud chn ter hujaad hamag uls orniig unegui ogch bna
mongol ruu muu ym ywuuldaggu shu. hujaanud uursdiigu ch muu yumar shahdag. tgd ch bid nar uursduu nogoogo tarij bolno bizde albatai ym shg awch idej heregleched muulaa shaagd sda
good morning brother sister ❤
Go to China Long life
Why hate a person we haven’t seen?
Even if we need to defend ourselves it's better to do so without hatred or anger eating at us from the inside out, right?
Одоогийн залуус ийм болчимгүй бодолтой, улсынхаа түүхийг ч мэддэггүй богино ухаантай, харалган болцгоожээ.
乌兰巴托的年轻人气质很好，普遍说英语，不吵闹，交往时觉得比北京舒适。
Thank you for the videos. God bless Mongolia and China. May Тэнгри bless China and Mongolia.
我觉得邻国互相仇恨是没必要的，欢迎蒙古人民来中国玩，了解彼此才能和睦相处
the cheese is crying between china and mongolia!
Chinese are much more attractive than the average Korean/Mongolian face.
@@marioplayer1410Korean faces are good tho, after all their skincare and plastic surgery is famous around the world
Mongolia was once within the Soviet sphere of influence. It's current borders were designed to provide a good enough buffer between China and the former USSR. So the Sino-Soviet conflict also probably played a part with regards to the negative perception of older Mongolians against the Chinese. Today, Mongolia's economy is highly dependent on trade with China. It's a landlocked country with a small population that's increasingly urbanizing. People and goods cannot go out without passing through Chinese or Russian territory. It is a nation whose glory has long faded hundreds of years ago. So it doesn't really make sense for the younger generation to even cultivate relation-breaking hatred against the Chinese.
Main problem 7.3 million Mongolians live in China (70% of the world's Mongolians) Gdp Inner Mongolia is 23 times higher than that of Outer Mongolia, Mongolian population's rapprochement towards China scares Mongolian politicians, Mongolian politicians need to grow hostility towards China to maintain their government, becoming a Chinese province again is a nightmare for them
Mongol Empire had their days in 13th & 14th centuries, almost conquered the world. Countless tribes & nationalities was decimated & wiped out.
Unlike Chinese Mongols didn’t kill them because of their race and ethnicity
@@EchoVortex713 mongols killed over 70 million people
@@EchoVortex713 Please open your eyes when you lie
@@user-gq4fy6fh7z What did lie about exactly? You’re the one who’s lying without knowing what you’re talking about . Typical arrogant Chinese who sees everything as part of China .
😂 Mongolia live because China and Russia want😂😂😂 Both were parts of Great Mongolia and to serve peace of her crudle.
I think Mongolian must be honoured Han Chinese about the barbaric historical of Mongol that invade China, by blessing Chinese all of Mongolians still exists today
Barbaric? Didn't Khublai Khan a Barbaric king developed your shitty country?
Firstly, most barbaric history that in Asia is not Mongolian empire,it is the event called:” the great purge of inner Mongolian party “made by mao ze dong and teng hai qing.han Chinese are more barbaric.
Made no sense...go learn how to write english properly...dumb little han peasant
@@user-cm3kz1sh9u Did Kublai Khan develop China? In the Yuan Dynasty, even the basic administrative and taxation capabilities of China were paralyzed. Except for changing the Mongolian White Festival to the first day of the lunar calendar, he had no political achievements.
@@halaga-kb8ez Every country is purging you, the Soviet Union, China, the Qing Dynasty, Persia, why don't you ask yourself?
Ask Mongolians what they think of Inuit people 👀
I personally like some Greenlandic rock artists like Nanook, Sume and Malik. But most Mongolians don’t know much about Inuit people.
I think the Inuits are more like the Ewinks and Sakha people in Siberia.
They sound like Koreans mixed with Japanese
That is because Japanese and Korean are from the same language family as Mongolian, called the Altaic languages. The family includes Turkic, Mongolic, Koreanic, Japonic, and a few more. Although Japonic and Koreanic are rarely included in the list, they are still considered a part of the Altaic family.
@@vonsterb7065No
@@vonsterb7065many scientists have admitted that the Altaic language family is a myth
@@vonsterb7065 thanks! I'm just knowing of this for the first time.
It’s because the only Asian languages you know are Korean and Japanese.
Well, the Mongolians should think about what Genghis Khan and his dynasty did to China.
Well, chinese dynasties always wanted mongolian tribes to infight each other and it worked well for hundreds of years until Chingis Khaan united all tribes. So it means chinese dynasties created their own enemy. Thanks for infighting between mongolian tribes that turned mongolia to war juggernaut. Eventually backfired to chinese dynasties.
The Chinese say Genghis Khan is a fk Han Chinese by DNA so why do Mongolians have anything to do with whatever he’s done to China?!
Love china from Iran
Fully my supports goes to Mongolia♥️Guess which Turkic country am I from :D
@@ddidol2840 Why do u think Azerbaijan🤔
@@ddidol2840 So u got right!🇦🇿
thanks allaayta
The Great Wall of China, built by the ancient Chinese, was expanded over thousands of years to prevent invasions by northern nomadic peoples (Manchurians, Jurchens, Mongols, and Koreans).
This means that the ancient Chinese perceived the peoples of Manchuria, Liaodong, and the Korean Peninsula as other ethnic groups, barbarians, and enemies.
Of course, this means that ancient China had no control over this land until it was conquered by the peoples of Manchuria and Liaodong outside the Great Wall of China.
It's civil war of China! China is not belong to Han people only. It's belong to all race live in this land. Do you know when yuan dynasty our Mongolian use han character write the imperial edict to other country? We used the han's political system. We create the capital of China ''beijing" be used until today. We fight for be the king of China, like other Chinese. only khan of China
is the real khan! We named the dynasty "yuan" not han people.
@@user-sy7pl2fi5v as a Han Chinese I 100% agree with you . the real China was founded by ancient Mongolian .
You only mention the colonial history of Mongolia, but not the colonization of China, the invasion of Asia by Mongolia, M3, too hypocritical. No one's forcing you to like anyone.
chinese and manchus didnt colonize mongolia. its manchu people conquered china later on around 1720's mongols submitted as vassals of manchu dynasty.
80-90% of the Manchus in 1600s and 1700s are actually Han Chinese though, Jurchen and Mongol banners never comprised more than 20% of the total Manchu population, remaining 80% of the Manchus are Han Chinese.
@@bowong422I am from Mongolia,in 1644 southern mongols helped manchus to occupy China.Now many manchus are assimilated.Mongols love Soviet Union and russians which saved Outer Mongolia from cruel chinese occupation.Most mongols dislike China and believe that one day chinese cruel soldiers will invade our lovely country and will exterminate native people.I will be happen and will most dark day in mongol history.
@@bowong422 Manchu are very Chinese genetically. So close they are genetically indistinguishable. I don't know why people think Manchu are just straight up Tungusic.
@@marioplayer1410also Koreans and Japanese are genetically very close to the Chinese
@@marioplayer1410 I mean, Koreans and Japanese are genetically the same as Chinese so does that make them Chinese?
tanariin eleg niget ahanduus uvermongolchuudiin suyuliini mohooj xeliini taslaj,ter olan mongol ur ach nariinchin mongol xeleen surah erxiini usadxaj bn yg odoo,obog dedesees ulbalsan mongol nutaginchni uurxai gin
maltaj,nutag chin zasagiin noydoos xuldaj avch bn.tanar bas hytad hund durtai yumuu?-jiriin uver Mongolos
hytad humuusiig bi yasnaasaa uzen yaddag
The thing is Manchu aren’t Han Chinese and are technically some kind of other Mongol tribe.
Manchus are cousins of Mongols but not the same. I'm Mongol and Manchus write the same script as us, the script given to us by the Uyghurs
Manchus is chinese absolutely.mongolian is too.but outer mongolian is not chinese.
@@user-jc5jk1qq4owdym all the mongolians is not chinese its only under control of china
@@sansaramgalan7213 Only Outer Mongolians are not Chinese. They are controlled by corrupt officials
@@user-jc5jk1qq4o chinese are crazy
Khalkha Mongols were among the first people to join the Jurchen's (aka Manchu's) conquest of the rest of China and were very much part of the ruling elite of the Qing empire. They were pivotal in the Manchus' conquests and subjugation of both the Han Chinese and Oirat Mongols and among the most loyal defenders of the late empire during the rebellions and foreign invasions of the 19th century.
To say "the Manchus and the Khalkha Mongols occupied China for 200 (sic) years" would be closer to the truth.
Khalkha Mongols were fools, the Oirats were the true Mongols.
@@khuslennnnnnn yes, Khalkha Mongols of that time remind me of the moment when the British joined the Americans to conquer Iraq in 2003, a pathetic attempt to relive the faded glory days of empire off the backs of a great power, like a little monkey riding on the back of a massive gorilla.
Just wanna point out that they are all speaking their own language in the video. In inner mongolia young people don't speak mongolian anymore. China is rich but don't repect culture of other people.
Every sign in inner Mongolian are written in two languages: Chinese and traditional Mongolian, however in Mongolian they would like to use Russia characters rather than their traditional characters. Now just tell me which country’s culture are closed to the history
@@myhugeairpotMongolia,china is famous genocide nation.mao ze dong is genocide expert.he invaded Korea and let 20m Korean live in hell still today,but Chinese still have no apologize to Koreans,they do not respect Korean sovereignty.china is totally genocide nation.world all know that
@@halaga-kb8ez
mad dog
@@halaga-kb8ez🤣
Inner Mongolia kept Script writing.
Outter Mongolia used the white people cyrillic.
Disgusting no shame.
몽골인들은 강인하고 위대한 역사를 가졌습니다. 넓은 영토를 가졌기에 사막화 된 국토를 비옥하게 만들고 인구만 많아지면 세계 주요 국가로 발돋움할 수 있는 기회를 가질 것 입니다.
Isn’t Mongolia the back garden of S.Korean sexual experience in recent years?
Mongolians , don't hate China because you will live happily.
Its honestly because the chinese government steals resources from mongolia causing it to be poor
Looking at world map, there is no point to hate China. For those of you who thinks my government is evil or sth are extremely naive on geopolitic. People remember history for preventing same mistake but not for being unrealistic. Peace tho
There's so many misinformation here. Under the Qing Dynasty, Mongols were better treated than Han Chinese. I don't know where these people get their info from. The Han wanted to overthrow the Qing government. That's why there was the Taiping Rebellion and other rebellions in the South against the Qing. Manchus overthrew the Ming Dynasty, which was a real Chinese dynasty. Genghis and Kublai Khan invaded and ruled China for 100 years, so should the Chinese hate the Mongols for that too? These are silly misguided people.
其实清朝时期，满族人拉拢东蒙古人，优待部分蒙古贵族，但是对蒙古民族就非常残暴了，下面的蒙古族只是奴隶罢了。更别说满族人带领中国军队，种族灭绝西蒙古人，然后还对蒙古人进行人口控制。1921年，清朝灭亡时，蒙古族只剩下一百多万人口，同样是游牧民族，满族人知道蒙古人的威胁，也达到了以前中国王朝没有达到的成果，彻底消灭了北方的游牧民族威胁，因为那些有威胁的游牧民族不在这个世界诞生了
@@user-yj1zy2bz8n 准噶尔是喀尔喀蒙古人跟维吾尔人屠杀的。你觉得带汉军腿过去得多少粮食。其实跟汉人还好，毕竟是钱袋子，就靠赏赐跟通婚就把蒙古人忽悠住了，基本就是雇佣兵到处打仗，蛮惨的。
Yeah they were treated so much better you know? Dzungar genocide; being banned from leaving your banners; being forced to wear Manchu queue; Jindangdao massacre; population decline; ban on archery; forced immigration of Han Chinese farmers with the aim of total assimilation. Such preferential treatments…
Come on, they know their history better, so kindly use your brain before dropping a comment and saying this or that! Nobody cares about your opinion.
@@manduul.bakhdalDzungar genocide had Khalkha and Chahar Mongols involved. It was not a decision by Han Chinese. My point here is that the hate against Chinese but which ones? Manchu Chinese, Han Chinese, Mongol Chinese?
Please guys, don’t hate, Ok!
Asian people should form a strong bond!
No hate, only love from China, love you guys ❤
Mongolia is a great country with many kind and hardworking people. However, over the years, many Mongolians have damaged this beautiful land in pursuit of wealth, resulting in severe pollution, poor transportation, and inadequate urban development. Despite the appearance of democratic elections, corruption remains rampant, with even the airport being owned by Japanese interests. Some Mongolians hold biases and display arrogance towards China, even fostering baseless fears, yet they exhibit reluctance to engage in their own country's development. Unfortunately, in China, Mongolia's concerns are often overlooked. Chinese people hope for Mongolia to achieve better development, raise living standards, improve environmental protection, and take pride in their own culture rather than simply imitating Korean or Hollywood culture. They hope that young Mongolians studying abroad will return home to contribute to the progress of their homeland. Let's look forward to a future of friendly relations between our two countries. Every country should have the opportunity for development, rather than being solely manipulated by international geopolitics
Mongolians look Korean maybe they feel that connection. Of course, they will die with their below average face.
hardworking what？不是韩国妓院吗？
Beautiful language
Sounds like theyre spitting
@Techtalk2030 Arabic sounds like they are about to spit
Koreans respect Mongolia and Japan, which dominated Korea
But why aren't Chinese respected by Koreans? Think carefully
lmao, North Koreans respect China, you South Koreans hate China because your country is a colonial possession of the United States and so is Japan, wake up to the propaganda that your US overlords who forced bases to be installed in your country, own and control all your conglomerates and bed your women. China is not your enemy we are the same people with the same ethnic ancestors thousands of years ago, we have a very similar culture and face many of the same problems. Grow a spine and recognize the Americans are using you, they would ditch you in a heartbeat when you become useless.
@@lutherschultz4725 I'm sorry, but our northern brothers don't support China
Kim Jong-un said Japan is a 100-year enemy, China is a 1,000-year enemy
Kim Jong-il said he doesn't trust China more than the U.S
Koreans in North and South Korea do not support China
It's harsh, but it's true
You Chinese are hated and isolated by Asians
@@lutherschultz4725 Nope. North Koreans really really hate Chinese. Now there are quite many youtube channels run by North Korean defectors. That's what they said about how much they and North Koreans hate C. Because they know how badly Chinese treated North Korean defectors and factory workers. They know China more by extreme experience.
because you people 畏威而不怀德. hope you can understand your ancestors' language❤
@@GjFl-ue1ff kick the American masters out of your country first before you pretend like you know anything, I have actually been to North Korea, have you? Millions of North Koreans live in China and have Chinese citizenship, they are one of the 56 nationalities of China 朝鲜族. You only hear what your overlord wants you to hear, your country is literally owned by them, US investors own more than 50% of Samsung and your other large conglomerates, the senior leadership are all Americans, when your country wants to pass a law they have to consult the Americans first. The US are bleeding your people dry and you can't do anything about it.
Btw just because I point out flaws with your society doesn't mean I don't respect Koreans, Koreans are intelligent and hard working, I also like how strong your people are culturally bounded to your Korean heritage, I hope this doesn't change in the future and you guys don't get too westernized by US influence.
Do not see China as your enemy, we only want our Asian neighbors to be able to act independently outside of European/US imperialistic influence, Chinese people see other East Asians as close relatives who come from the same ancestral lineage and wish them well. At the rate it's going in Japan with it's low birthrates and liberal foreign immigration(invasion) supported by the US, it's going to become a mixed country like Mexico or the Philippines, if you don't want this to happen to Korea you need to get the united states out of your government and your corporations.
Umnugovid enmuu hujaa lalruud yamr tom baidag gej bodoj bain yag uuriinhuu nutagt baigaa yumshig ayglana tend baidag mongol jolooch nariig zugeer jijken yuman deer zodoj deerelhn huuhnuudiig ni huchindej mongoliig buzarlana tegeed boloogui tendhiin tsagdaa nar ni yaj ch chadadgui guliigeed zogschin
Arail davraad baigaashuu ene mongolruu orj irj bga hujaa lalruud
Хятадууд Монголыг эзлэхийг хүсэх нь тэдний өөрсдийн асуудал. Харин тэдэнд эзлэгдэх эсвэл газар нутгаа хамгаалах эсэх нь Монголчуудын асуудал. Эзлэн түрэмгийлэл бол түрэмгийлэгч орны хувьд зөв зүйл. Тэд эзлэхийг хүсвэл эзлэх л хэрэгтэй. Нөгөө тал нь өөрсдийгөө хамгаалахгүй, сурч хөгжих хүсэлгүй байж биднийг эзлэх гээд байна гээд гоншигоноод хэвтээд байвал юу ч өөрчлөгдөхгүй. Сонирхуулахад Хятадын өндөр хөгжилтэй бүсийн хүмүүс Монгол гэж улс байдаг ч гэж сонсож байгаагүй, бүр Өвөр Монголыг ч мэддэггүй. Тэд зөвхөн өөрсдийнхөө тухай бодож, өөрсдийгөө л хөгжүүлдэг. Бүгд дор бүрнээ өөрсдийгөө хөгжүүлдэг нь нийлээд улсаараа хөгждөг. Харин Монголчууд үргэлж зугаацаж, архидаж самуурч, зовлонгоо тоолж, тэр нь нийлээд нийтээрээ зовлонгоо манаж, зугаацаж амьдардаг. Шинжлэх ухааны нээлтийг цөөн хүн сонирхож, инженер, багш, эмчийн мэргэжлийг голж, бүгд эдийн засаг, бизнес, хуулийн салбарт орж ажилгүй дипломнууд л үлддэг
@@awedsa7004unen2
halhchuud bol orosin nohoi
@@giorozaitien646 nice try, udahgv tanai oros butarna :*