ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 มิ.ย. 2024
- The first predator on Earth looked a lot different than predators on Earth today! These huge arthropods, called Anomalocarids, lived in Cambrian seas about 500 million years ago! They reached sizes much larger than other organisms at the time and acted as the apex predators in Earth's very first complex ecosystems. Before the Ediacaran period and Cambrian Explosion, animals did not exist yet. Sure, microbes ate other microbes on this early, 'pre-animal' Earth, but there was no real predation until animals came along. Animals evolved before the Cambrian, in the Ediacaran, but these first animals did not seem to have the complex hierarchy ecosystems that we see later during and after the Cambrian explosion. The Cambrian explosion marked not only a remarkable diversification of animal life, but also an increase in skeletons, shells, and other hard parts. This 'skeletonization' of life was likely in part allowed by changes in ocean chemistry, but the ultimate driver of this increase in organisms with hard parts was predation. Hard parts provide organisms with protection from predation which, until this time, had not been a threat. However, during the Cambrian explosion, Anomalocarids evolved, which changed everything! Hope you enjoy the video ;)
GEO GIRL Website: www.geogirlscience.com/ (visit my website to see all my courses, shop merch, learn more about me, & donate to support the channel if you'd like!)
0:00 Ediacaran Fauna & Cambrian Explosion
1:26 First Predators on Earth
2:14 Their Methods of Predation
4:20 Their Diversity
4:43 Their Surprisingly Short Time Range
5:23 Resulting Evolutionary Adaptations
8:33 Why Did They Go Extinct?
11:35 What Types of Predators Followed?
12:59 Lasting Impact of the First Predators
References:
Prothero, 2013 (Bringing Fossils to Life: An Introduction to Paleobiology), & references therein: amzn.to/3nU0ada
Earth System History: amzn.to/3v1Iy0G
Daley & Edgecombe, 2014 (Morphology of Anomalocaris canadensis from the Burgess Shale): doi.org/10.1666/13-067
Briggs & Fortey, 2005 (Wonderful strife: systematics, stem groups, and the phylogenetic signal of the Cambrian radiation): doi.org/10.1666/0094-8373(200...[0094:WSSSGA]2.0.CO;2
Gaines et al., 2008 (Cambrian Burgess Shale-type deposits share a common mode of fossilization): doi.org/10.1130/G24961A.1
Potin & Daley, 2023 (The significance of Anomalocaris and other Radiodonta for understanding paleoecology and evolution during the Cambrian explosion): doi.org/10.3389/feart.2023.11...
Vannier & Chen, 2000 (Early Cambrian food chain: new evidence from fossil aggregates in the Maotianshan Shale biota, SW China): doi.org/10.2110/palo.2003.p03-40
Vinther et al., 2014 (A suspension-feeding anomalocarid from the early Cambrian. Nature): doi.org/10.1038/nature13010
Yang et al., 2020 (Anomalocaridid trunk limb homology revealed by a giant filter-feeder with paired flaps. Nature): doi.org/10.1038/nature14256
Hey there, Earth enthusiast! Check my favorite Earth-friendly products:
Bamboo toilet paper: shrsl.com/3cvku
Bamboo paper towels: shrsl.com/3cvkw
Compostable tableware: shrsl.com/3cvkz
Compostable trash bags: shrsl.com/3cvl0
Bamboo cutlery + straw! : shrsl.com/3cwfl
Eco-Friendly Tote (great for grocery shopping!): shrsl.com/3cwfp
Reusable straws + cleaning brushes (my fav!): shrsl.com/3cwft
Eco-friendly laundry detergent: shrsl.com/3cwgo
Directly offset your carbon footprint with Wren: shrsl.com/3d0t2
(Just click link, press get started, take the free C footprint quiz, then choose how much you want to reduce your footprint by donating to the C sequestration projects they're funding!)
Non-textbook books I recommend:
Oxygen by D. Canfield: amzn.to/3gffbCL
Brief history of Earth by A. Knoll: amzn.to/3w3hC1I
Life on young planet by A. Knoll: amzn.to/2RBMpny
Some assembly required by N. Shubin: amzn.to/3w1Ezm2
Your inner fish by N. Shubin: amzn.to/3cpw3Wb
Oxygen by N. Lane: amzn.to/3z4FgwZ
Alien Oceans by K. Hand: amzn.to/3clMx1l
Life's Engines: amzn.to/3w1Nhke
Tools I use as a geologist/teacher/student:
Geology field notebook: amzn.to/3lb6dJf
Geology rock hammer: amzn.to/3DZw8MA
Geological compass: amzn.to/3hfbdLu
Geological hand lens: amzn.to/3jXysM5
Camera: amzn.to/3l6fGRT
Carbon-neutral pencil bag: shrsl.com/3cvjv
Carbon-neutral backpack: shrsl.com/3cvkc
Disclaimer: Links included in this description might be affiliate links. If you purchase a product or service with the links that I provide I may receive a small commission, but there is no additional charge to you! Thank you for supporting my channel so I can continue to provide you with free content each week! And as always, let me know your topic suggestions in the comments down below! - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
![[LIVE] ย้อนวันวานกับนางเอกยุค 90's #คุยให้เด็กมันฟัง EP.42 (8/6/67)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/MslQDdFwULE/mqdefault.jpg)
Correction/Clarification: I mentioned they may have fed on arthropods like trilobites, but more recent research suggests that they probably preyed more so on worms and potentially non-shelled worm-like mollusks rather than trilobites. But this targetting of soft-bodied prey even more so indicates their role in pressuring organisms to produce hard parts, and it also suggests this is one of the reasons trilobites weren't that affected by them! ;) Thanks to the commenters who pointed this out! Hope you all enjoy the video :D
Also, Remember: I don't normally state this out loud, but every time I discuss things that happened in Earth's history or ancient extinct organisms, it should be noted that although I say things as though they are facts like "this happened" or "this organism was the first 'fill in blank'", it is always of course only hypotheses. Some hypotheses about events or organisms in Earth's past are more backed up than others, but if you want to learn more about how we study Earth's past, check out this video: th-cam.com/video/J9Te_sGZ_c0/w-d-xo.html ;)
I remember seeing somewhere that there was a fossil trilobite that had a bite taken out that closely matched the circular mouth shape of Anomalocaris. Someone sketched it.
There are trilobite fossils with bites possibly from Anomalocaris so the issue is not settled. But yeah it probably fed on soft-bodied animals the most.
I wonder if Trilobites could be vulnerable to attacks from Anomalocarids during the periods when they molted their exoskeletons and their new exoskeleton was still soft and hadn't finished hardening. That could potentially explain both the fossils of trilobites with bite marks in them that look like they were made by Anomalocarid mouthparts and the analyses that showed that trilobite armor was more mineralized than anomalocarid mouth-plates and thus could not be broken or penetrated by them.
Were the remains silicates?
Rachel, from what I understand the eyes of Anomalocaris cement the creature as the probable top predator of its day. Apparently, Anomalocaris had some of the largest and most sophisticated compound eyes ever known. It is proposed that only a few arthropods have similar or better resolution, such as modern predatory dragonflies. It’s fascinating to contemplate the early evolution of such complex visual organs.
🤘🪩🌈
Sorry guys, I made a last minute edit on this video, so it's still processing and it may not include all the cards and end screen pop ups that I refer to until after it's processed, so those are coming, but it's gonne be a bit delayed ;)
The format of your videos is perfect. It feels like a "Friendly Informal University Intro Class". You don't shy away from using scientific descriptive terms, but it's set in an upbeat and fun way that I think really stimulates learning.
This is good stuff and I hope your channel and viewership grows.
Thank you so much! This means so much! That is exactly the vibe I am going for lol ;D
@@GEOGIRL I also like the fact that when you do use those so-called scientific descriptive terms, you often then rephrase them to explain what you mean. Really good pedagogy!
I definitely like the graphic of the Paleozoic Era at the bottom of the screen from 8:34 to 9:00. It reinforces the periods' ages, their dates, and what was generally happening during the periods - helping out the newcomer. But it also runs along the bottom of the screen, like a chyron during a news broadcast - so someone more experienced can easily ignore it. It seems like a very handy tool! Will you be using it in the future? I've always noticed that you very often reinforce the historical geology knowledge - saying things like "the end-Permian extinction - or the Great Dying - approximately 252 million years ago...", instead of simply "the end-Permian extinction..." I appreciate that effort to emphasize the basics often. That's the sign of a great teacher!
Haha thank you but I haven't always been great at that, you probably remember early videos where I didn't add much context, well it was commenters that helped me learn where I need to add context every time I say that thing and I have started to get better at that :) But yes, I love that graphic as well, I didn't initially realize how helpful it may be to a newcomer since I know the general timing and what happened in thes time ranges but since you mention it that is a great idea! I think I will try to incorporate some sort of version of this in future historical geo videos to give more context. If not the full graphic, maybe at least a timeline for proportional context in geologic time.
I think that is a great idea because whenever I say 250 million years ago, I can picture the timescale in my head to scale and understand what that means with regards to how long ago that was (I mean to the extent that a human can 'understand' that haha), but you commenting this made me remember that not everybody can just picture the timescale in their head at any given moment lol, so thank you for reminding me that! ;)
Good listen for my walk this morning, thanks👍🏼❤️😊
Thanks geo girl for excellent presentation
Hi Rachel,
Very nice lecture. A lot of new material. Very interesting. Thank you.
Thank you! So glad you enjoyed it ;D
Cool video, thanks! My interpretation of Anomalocarids' mouth parts is that they look like they were specialized in eating worms. The appendages would wrap around tubular shapes and the spikes would grasp and eviscerate the slimy worm (gross!) Their flat body shape would be suited to gliding along the ocean floor digging up worms and maybe that's why Anomalocarids didn't have much of an effect on Trilobites. I'd be down for a video all about ancient worms haha XD
Thanks for the video! Anomalocaris is my favorite prehistoric animal. Not bad for Evolution's first attempt at a predator. The story of how the first fossil was discovered is creepy but also really cool. If multicellular life has evolved in the oceans of Europa, I wonder if it might look anything like this.
Ooo great question! I wouldn’t that be cool a complete underworld of arthropods on Europa! 😍
Terrific video and a really fascinating era.
Rachel -- Partway through this week's talk the song "New Kid In Town" by the Eagles started playing in my head (New Anomalocarid In Town doesn't quite scan...). My only quibble is that the "first" predators were most likely microbial and started a good deal earlier than these multi-cellular johnny-come-lately's of the Cambrian. Microbes! Microbes! Rah! Rah! Rah! (Hope you got the vid I sent to your email re microbes and tectonics.)
I was waiting for a video like this. Thank you!
You're welcome! I hope you enjoy ;D
@@GEOGIRL Indeed I did. Ir was a pleasure to watch.
Yes! Wondered about it multiple times.
this is a good video but even better is that thumbnail
i think it's my favourite on the entire platform
So basically this was the wild west of times for evolution. Some lived fast and died hard. 👍 love your work and keep it coming. Thanks
Exactly ;)
How about a video on eyes and vision, or generally, detection of light. How did changing ocean chemistry effect light detection? How does Earth's largest migration know when to rise during dark, and descend into the depths during the day? What minerals and chemistry is needed for detecting and focusing light? Why are our lenses squishy when trilobite lenses were hard, and which is better? Are multi-faceted eyes better than our single-lens fish-derived eyes, and does one scale larger or smaller better than the other? What was the first focusing eye, and was that sighted critter the ruling animal in the kingdom of the semi-blind? Why is animal vision limited to near-ultraviolet through near-infra-red, with no animals seeing radio waves or gamma-rays? When did the earliest bioluminescence evolve? Why does some prawn have 16 primary colors in its vision when I am only allowed to have 3 primary colors, plus it can see polarizations when I can't see any? How do starfish see their prey or see for traveling in groups, when they don't have focusing eyes and don't have brains? Evolution of light detection would be a good topic.
I have read that the evolution of eyes was a major instigator of the Cambrian explosion, as eyes became extremely important both for seeking out prey and for avoiding becoming prey. It's certainly an interesting theory.
Great video. Anomalocarids were fascinating animals. One other group of apex predators that followed them, besides the sea scorpions, were the large cephalopods that ruled in the Ordovician.
Thank you again for another awesome presentation.
I've enjoyed Natural History all my life, focusing on ecology, plant and animal relationships between species and the environments they live in. You really bring geology to life and add a whole new depth to my understanding of time and evolution.
Much love, wonderful lady.
Thanks so much! I am so glad you enjoy my geo content! ;D
I love the stuff you've been covering lately! Between the geo and the bio content, this is becoming one of my favorite channels.
I gotta share something that just blows me away with the Cambrian explosion, the incredible diversity of body plans. Most living things today are similar to eachother by comparison. We see mostly segmented, sagittal symmetry with largely predictable apendages, various outliers not withstanding. But during the Cambrian, there were so many unusual body plans. Most of them went extinct and we were left with a tiny sample from to build from. But consider if they hadn't gone extinct. The life we see today would be absolutely alien and bizarre to our eyes. Just look at anomalocaris. Then you have guys like opabinia, halucigenia, wiwaxia and marrella. They looked more like pokemon than real creatures.
You are so right! Their body plans are insanely diverse! It is so crazy I wish I could’ve seen them for real!
Also thank you so much for the kind words! I am so happy you are enjoying the content :)
If you ever have an urge to hear about something specific just comment a suggestion! I’d be happy to cover it :)
@@GEOGIRL you're welcome, and I will certainly keep that in mind 😊
Actually, I already knew, but I'm watching it anyway because I like your videos and I'm sure I'll learn more in the process. Thanks.
That's awesome! I hope you learn something new or at the very least enjoy hearing about things you already knew! ;D
Excellent as always.
I have never figured out what nature values more heavily; scavenging, salvaging, or predation.
Thanks for showcasing the pressure to evolve.
The next stage would have been more chances for commensalism, as evolution tamped down on predation risks of 'over grazing.'
One of my very favorite ancient creatures.
This is a lovely channel. I love learning about early animals and their diversity, it's so interesting
Thank you so much, I am so glad you enjoy it! ;D
Thanks for an enjoyable video. I thought I could find a sketch of that worm you were having problems finding, so I pulled out Stephen Jay Gould’s book, ‘Wonderful Life’ which has some great sketches but black and white. I got sidetracked and forgot what I was looking for. I haven’t leafed through this book in years. Got to Pikaia, first known chordate and our phylum then realized I had no idea what I was looking for. Some time had passed and decided I had to get on with my day. I enjoyed Stephen Jay Gould’s essays in Natural History magazine years ago (last century), was it an illustration of a worm you were looking for?
Thanks again!
The adventure and thoroughness of Wonderful Life are the best features of the book and should still be required reading for anyone interested in biological origins and paleontological methods, even if some of the science and interpretations have changed since the time the book was published.
very cool thanks for video :)
Great video GEO GIRL! I LOVE your channel!
Thank you so much! :D
As always, a fun video. Can you imagine coming face to face with one of those 6 foot critters? Probably ruin my day.
Haha, yea but I bet they would be less threatening to humans than modern day predators (aka: sharks that have big mouths and jaw bones lol) ;)
@@GEOGIRL And maybe they would be tasty on the grill. You think?
@@Grumpyoldman037 Oh yea, if they were still around I am sure there would be a "red anomalocarid" equivalent of red lobster lol! ;)
Reminds me of the first Rodan movie, where the Japanese mine workers were attacked by 12 foot "bugs", that turned out to be the "small" food that Rodan fed on.
It would make a great "monster" for a SiFi "B" movie.
I love the way you bust the old school rhymes. ❤🎙️
The captions keep saying "anomaly carrots" 😂
Little off subject, but as you were talking about the predator/prey relationship, I was thinking about flowering plants. Could the large herbavores of the cretacious have spurred the evolution of flowering/fruiting bodies? I know flowers are largley associated with insects, but as multidimensional as the natural world is, the pressure to produce fruit could be explained away by thier predation, while insects helped drive the reproduction structures of the flower itself. Love the natural history videos btw, geochemistry ties it together Geo Girl Rocks!
Oh that would be super interesting to investigate! Nice point!
Flowering and fruiting evolved primarily in cooperation with different animal species. In trade for the reward of nectar, insects and such greatly improved on the wind blown pollination process of gymnosperms. Some fruiting plants made fruit that attracted consumers who in turn dispersed the seeds. Other fruit, like the foxtail for example did not attract consumers, but used animals for dispersal in other ways. Still other fruit dispersed seeds without any help from animals, such as modern cottonwood and dandelion fruit do.
@@reidflemingworldstoughestm1394 That sounds so solid man, thanks!
@reidflemingworldstoughestm1394 yup, PBS EONS had a great episode explaining just what your talking about, and more!
@@christianhunt7382 Freshman botany had it too. :)
I thought "bones" started to maintain stable PH.
That also fits with the "explosion" coming as that advantage was settling in and different mutations in those early stages provided very significant advantage for a variety of reasons which in turn provided a lot of branching in different directions built around the very different advantages provided by the different mutations of the initial calcium pellet that gave the whole group the metabolism advantage provided by the ability to buffer PH. Or something like that. :)
very cool video i liked watching this video alot thank you for a really great video
Very interesting. By the way, I have difficulty communicating because I had a stroke in Broca’s area, the part of the brain that controls speech. 2/8/2021 but I lived again. (My wife helped me compose this.)
Even today, there are predatory annelids, like the horse-leech, and some annelids grow up to 10 feet length, like the Giant Gippsland earthworm.
interesting. I've wondered about that guy. I'd like to see you take on the First Animal.
That is a brilliant idea! I don't know how I didn't think of that, thank you so much! ;D
Was there a key biological evolutionary event that allowed digestive systems to use other life forms for energy/food?
🎵🎶This ain't a [sea], it's a goddamn arms race, but I digress 🎶🎵
I first heard of anomalocarids many years ago but found it almost impossible to research them as I constantly misspelled it, as I suspect a lot of people still do.
Can you do an episode on Auroralumina attenbouroughi? The Cnidarian predator that dethroned Anomalocaris as the first predator last August? I feel it is still not widely known.
Oh cool I didn’t know about that, I will look into it for a future video, of course! 😃 thanks so much!
Isn't their also evidence of predation on Cloudina from later in the Ediacaran? I'd like to see a video on that, or maybe Timorebestia, the recently described giant Cambrian arrow worm.
Maybe the extinction of Anomalocaris species has something to do with their exoskeletons.
The Anomalocarids did not completely go extinct at the end of the Cambrian. There is at least one known Ordovician species from about 480 million years ago, and one from the Devonian from 390 million years ago. So that actually extends their tenure on Earth to a pretty respectable 120 million years or so (compare that to the non-avian Dinosaurs' 180-ish million year span, and the 65 million years of the entire Cenozoic).
Granted the Ordovician species was apparently a filter feeder, and the Devonian species was pretty small, so they did lose their spot as apex predators after the Cambrian.
The artist didn't shy away from making the Anomalocarus look evil. Are the eyes supposed to glow red?
Haha you know I have no clue lol😅
My inkling is protazoa, archaea and bacteria would have engaged in predation, scavenging and autotrophic activities - thereby engendering hierarchical ecological communities long before the anomalocarids came by. I assume lacking direct evidence and the semantics in what constitutes 'true predation' is the reason for this interpretation. That being said, if we are discussing first animal predators - Auroralumina is first.
Great discussion on factors bringing about Anomalocarids and the Cambrian evoloutionary arms race.
I agree with you. Some do not define what bacteria and archaea and other microbes do as predation; but others have actually made a whole group called ‘predatory bacteria’ so it depends who you ask. I honestly just needed a catchy title lol ;)
@@GEOGIRL Well, the title worked a charm. I'm hooked to all things geoscience (besides petrology admittedly), so I appreciate the ability of your videos to generate discussions around, some would say, niche topics.
The first cell that ate other cells #1predator!
But is that predation??? I don’t know I have found multiple definitions so you could very well be right, but I needed a catchy title and saying the first animal apex predator really took away the magic lol ;)
I remember how Stephen Jay Gould, in his book "Wonderful Life", describes how it too decades to properly describe anomalocaris, whose parts are preserved in the Burgess Shale but which for a long time were attributed to different animals. The bulk of the animal was soft bodied and preservation of the animal as a whole was not a likely occurrence. Fascinating to speculate how much of the perceived "Cambrian Explosion" following the Ediacaran period may be due to the evolution of hard body parts with the increased likelihood of preservation.
In describing Paleozoic predators of the Paleozoic following the Cambrian and Ordovician the cephalopod mollusks such as squids, octopi, and their kin and certainly the nautiloids must be mentioned. The nautilus is with us to this day although it is a rare animal with its few species restricted to certain region. Hopefully the current episode of climate change will not drive these splendid animals to extinction but even if it doesn't it's not clear how much longer they will be around. Trilobites may have had a 300+ million year evolutionary history but by the end of the Permian they were hanging by a thread, having dwindled down to just a few species. Maybe the nautilus is headed for the same fate in geologic time, however much we want them to remain.
Yeah, what animal was out there doing all that predating...
Predating...?
Is that a word? Sounds like something you do before a night out.
Good video! I was wondering, does anyone know how the concept of predation appeared? i'm imagining that at first, it was very diffuse. Like, for example the way zooids behave where they add/or remove themselves from the main body(colony). And what is up with the endosymbiosis, does it count as predation?
What a great question! I don't think so, because although early microbes were eating and sometimes engulfing one another, they were not actively hunting down and capturing prey like modern predators, but I am sure the term has undergone some changes through time so who knows! haha ;)
@@GEOGIRL Thank you for the answer!
Will there be video on the animal called the "Alien Goldfish," Typhloesus wellsi?
I'll put it on the list ;)
@@GEOGIRL Thank you!
GEO GIRL saying: "their time range [...] which is not that long..." and talking about a span of time that is about as long as the time passed between the extinction of the non-avian dinosaurs and today.
pleas apply the kea word palaeopetrology 🙏its not finding me anything in your search bar AND I LOVE YOUR VIDOS 💖💖💖😇 YOUR A GRATE TEACHER
As a rule apex predators don't last for long. Makes you think about us. We may be the ultimate apex predator that lived the shortest amount of time with all the weapons of mass destruction waiting to be used
I have no basis or evidence but anomolocaris evolved into the eurypterids and eventually went land bound.
So, Rachel, did you like the portrayal of the Anomalocaris in the BBC's 2005 "Walking with Monsters"?
Just seeing this thing -It just gets your imagination going. You have to remember how rare fossilized remains are & then finding them is another thing.
There are other related animals we aren't even seeing. So larger and smaller species had to be around. We are only seeing a small snapshot.
Life is stranger than anything you can imagine.
Wouldn't it make sense, that the first predator lved in the ediacaran as a soft bodied animal and forced the other animals to develop hard shells?
Absolutely, that’s why I changed the title to (that we know of) hahaha ;)
@@GEOGIRL nice change. Now I'm wondering, which predator made anomalocaris develop a hard shell 😬
Great video, as always well researched and presented. Thanks a lot! Just watching your channel for entertainment, but it is really very informative👌
@@MrX-nv8kp hahaha that is a great question! Well skeletons serve two major purposes: protection and structural support so it could’ve been for support but who knows there very well could’ve been a previous predator that caused that ;)
predation is an alternative strategy to direct competition for resources. it achieves same outcome. predation has been around since the tiniest eukaryotes. our macro centric focus gives special attention to multi-cellular larger life forms exhibiting predation.
The first predators def ate microbes...
NO. The largest anomalcaris did NOT measure 2 meters, just two feet. The latest known anomalocarid, shinderhannes, lived in the Ordoviician.
This article from 1994 and others since then have argued that some fossil anomalocarids preserved in China may have reached 2m (Chen et al., 1994)- doi.org/10.1126/science.264.5163.1304 :)
😀 I remained patiently benthic this whole time.
😎
My two favorite early Cambrian life forms are Hallucigenia and Opabinia, the latter being, I believe, also an Anomalocarid. The former had a truly hilarious history of reconstruction, when it was made to walk on her spines for nearly a century-albeit they are obviously as good for walking as hedgehog's spines. And in addition to the Great up/down debate, there was the Great front/back debate... And it's aptly name what makes it-the both, in fact-even more weird and beautiful at the same time. An animal with five eye pods (were they all eyes?) and a proboscis ending in a claw... I'm at a loss for words trying to express this feeling of dreaminess and beauty of the life forms produced by Nature...
Except the blobfish, _P. marcidus,_ of course-but Nature also has to have her bad days!
Opabinia is not an anomalocarid, but they are a dinocaridid, part of a wider group containing both the Radiodonts (Anomalocarids, Hurdiids, Amplectobeluids, Tamisiocarids) and their close relatives like the filled lobopods.
@@trilobite3120 Thank you for the correction, appreciate it!
Can't help but hear evanescence
Question: large Anomalocids logically from smaller ones predating smaller prey. Probably the ancestral forms were less skeletal. As far as you know, what evidence have we of those progenitors?
👏👏👏👍
What do we know about anomalocaris eggs and life cycle? Sometimes a biotic or abiotic factor attacks a specific stage of the cycle and explains why it went extinct.
Wow I wonder if there is any fossil evidence of anomalocaris eggs or if it is just assumed that they laid eggs
Would you say it's difficult to find a job in either seismology, volcanology, or planetary science?
Isn't it prounounced a-NAH-mo-lo-KAH-is? No long A.
If that's the first predator, the you must think all those jellyfish and worms that preceded the Cambrian were vegetarian?
Haha well I tried to stick with the definition of predation that necessitates the hunting capturing and eating of prey but yes before this there were many animals and microbes that ate other animals and microbes, but I am not sure I’d call them predators. I did update the title though to ‘apex’ predators to be more specific just in case ;)
@@GEOGIRL come to think of it I'm sure there's plenty of biologists who'll say herbivores like cows actually are predators. Apex predators are cooler anyway.
You left out an ordivician anomalacarid : en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schinderhannes_bartelsi
Chris Hansen wasn't there to protect us!
I have a bizarre question: Would a meteor shower of elemental calcium and magnesium remove enough CO2 from the atmosphere to stop climate change? My train of thought was the following:
Ca and Mg lower the pH of the oceans, allowing it to absorb more CO2. Is that the case at all? After that, the two ions would precipitate with CO2 as limestone. Or dolomite.
I know that the probability of such a meteor shower is rather small, but would that work purely hypothetically?
Is not predation mainly about securing fuel? I wonder why no animals consume coal or uranium for energy.
A better way to say same title, is first animal that decided to be a total douchbag to all the other friendly animals..😂
Aren't there one-cell predators? I would think those would be earlier.
Not sure why we say these were the first predators, there is evidence of single-celled predation nearly a billion years older (jumping genes, phagocytosis, etc). Or is this only considering eukaryotic predation as predation?
The formal definition of predator refers to eating animals, so that doesn't count. You probably wouldn't consider something that eats plants a "predator".
What "predator" stands for?
I thought we can call it any animal, bacteria, who ate another bacteria (it was animal, when I was in school)))
I'm not native speaker, so be understanding, if I can say so.
That's a great question and something I should've explained in the video, but to my understanding predation requires an animal or organism to hunt and capture prey. So, although early microbes were eating one another, they were not actively hunting down and capturing prey like modern predators, but I am sure the term is used differently in some cases so who knows! haha ;)
@@GEOGIRL actually, I thought it's kind of my misunderstanding of the terminology, due to all russian occupied countries stopped in development and it reflected on our languages (same as with russian - they modern science language is even less developed than Ukrainian in lot of science activity branches).
I have a lot of examples in architecture or project management, where there is a new term or the old one has changed its meaning.
Calling someone's 15My time range 'short' with our what? 200ky? is a bit strong. (Just kidding, I know you're referencing other species.)
Haha Yea as a geologist everything under like 50 million years seems short to me, especially humans time range! lol 😂
I argued with a creationist online quite a while ago who could not believe that the Cambrian explosion actually happened because all of a sudden life just exploded.
Life In this period developed the tiered predator and prey ecosystems and predators became fast moving animals with limbs designed to attack.
(Thanks to @GEOGIRL for correcting an earlier mistake in this comment.)
. Pray animals developed developed defenses the first armor and other strategies.
You either changed or were eaten.
Those factors along probably with the three major contributors.
Well jaws didn’t come about til later but yes I see your point :)
@@GEOGIRL♥️ thank you for correcting that I will edit and credit my comment.
"This CHANGES EVERYTHING!" "That CHANGES EVERYTHING!" "This will leave you SPEECHLESS!" "That will leave you SPEECHLESS!" These mega-overused manipulative clickbait statements lead me to delete videos from my feed, sight-unseen, regardless of whatever merit they may actually have. What a waste.
I am sorry you feel that way. My thumbnail text of “this changed everything” was completely genuine as I feel that the first predators did change everything by setting life on a rapid course of evolutionary advancement and diversification. It was not meant as clickbait but rather to emphasize the importance of these animals and my genuine excitement about their impact ;)
Algorithm gods like this comment, can you too?
Hlo mam can i get next video in sequences stratigraphy.
I am unable to found any materia and topics in seq stratigraphy
How did that "change everything"? What does "everything" stand for? 🤔
I don't agree with this at all.
Anomalocaris is the first predator that we KNOW, not the FIRST.
Very deceptive title.
Well I thought this would be implied, but I completely agree, I will edit the title :)
@@GEOGIRL Awesome. Keep it up, Rachel!