Exactly my thoughts. Jeff described her as no ego. That's why she can penetrate well in an all star season and out of the winners, I place my bet on her.
If Charlie should have won, he would have won. His “agency at key points in the game” means nothing if he’s unable to use his social game to secure the votes at the end. He couldn’t even earn the respect of his number one ally
I disagree. Marie was very clearly bitter because she was upset about being voted off. If she voted for Charlie, he would have won as Ben said he would have voted for Charlie
@@jacob4448 I mean clearly Marie was never voting for him from the begining so that ship has sailed clearly thats a relationship he misread and theres failure on both parts, she was defo bitter AF. I was more shocked to learn that about Charlie jury chances. I did not know that both Q and Venus went in looking to vote for him and he was'nt able to get their votes. Charlie was able to convince Hunter, Liz and Soda to switch their votes at FTC but still.....I did not realise how severly low his jury chances were. He was at a 1/2 comparied to Kenzie at a 8/9 for jury chances
Charlie had a really good shot at winning, he kinda messed up at the Venus vote if Kenzie goes there he wins every final 3 without Maria, he also could have asked Ben to put him in fire making and secured the win against Ben Liz. Simply he chose half measures when he should of went all the way
@@jacob4448I don't think anyone should be fully excused for losing at the end just because the jury was "bitter", let alone just one juror. You've still done something wrong in the game if you can't win over your season's jury. As close as it was to being a tie, that tie is pretty much the only scenario where Charlie wins, considering he never had any locked votes. Charlie swaying over 3 people with his speech was the worst case scenario for Kenzie and yet she still got the win fair and square with her sob story whether you like it or not. If you want to discount that, then you kinda also have to consider the scenario where Charlie doesn't do so well at FTC and Kenzie wins unanimously.
I think Gabler's game is very repeatable. To this day most of the Survivor community doesn't realize how strong his game was, if he is on Survivor 50 he will be my winner pick.
I like how to the fanbase at large when men and women play the same game the man is an underrated winner no one respects because they're feminazis (that they just finished terrorizing) and the woman did nothing and didn't deserve to win and DEI yadda yadda. Never change, fanbase
@paintbrush3753 just because his final 3 plans didn’t work doesn’t mean that he stumbled into his win…almost nobodies final 3 plans work out. There’s a lot more to his personality and strategy that helped him win
I would switch Kenzie and Yam Yam. If each of these winners played 5 more times, I think Kenzie would be most likely to win again. She’s a special combination of social skill and strategy. Whereas without Carson, Yam Yam doesn’t get to a winning position (in my opinion). One might argue that it was Yam Yam’s social skill that did that, but I disagree. Carson was looking out for the Tika three, not just Yam Yam. I agree Dee is the best winner in the new era, but I don’t think her way of winning would ever allow her to win again. I think the best player of each season is: Ricard, Omar, Jessie, Carson, Dee, and Charlie. It would be great to see these players in the same season.
I think Yam Yam should be lower. Just rewatched 44 and I think he got incredibly lucky the rest of the cast didnt seem like they even cared about winning. Yam Yam goes earlier any other season. Id put him 5th, or even last.
Gabler getting people half his age to give him votes to win is impressive. If he tried to push the agenda on who’s going home the others would’ve turned on him instantly ala Bruce.
Kenzie knew about the hunter blindside and she was the one who convinced him not to play his idol, like how do you retell the events of what happened completely wrong
I’m definitely biased but I love a twist and an underdog so for me top three is MaryAnne Yam Yam and Gabler in probably any order, and then the last two
Even hearing you explanation I don’t really understand why Kenzie wouldn’t be last for you, but ok. My personal ranking, including remaining 47 castaways based on what I think they’d have to do to win 1: Dee 2: Erika (listen to the exit press) 3: Yam Yam (Caroline) (Genevieve) 4: Gabler (Sam) (Rachel) 5: Maryanne (Andy) (Teeny) 6: Kenzie (Sue)
@Bryce946 yes it is true. If you go watch the tribal council you will see that Maryanne was planning to vote out Drea but then changed her mind because it would be 3 black players voted out in a row and Maryanne did specifically said she did not want to see 3 black players voted out in a row.
I am very offended that anyone disagrees with my rankings. I sound like I'm joking but I'm fully serious as always. Here's my ranking: 1st - Gabler (The best player of the new era) 2nd - Yam Yam (Very strong and dominant winning game) 3rd - Maryanne (An average winner) 4th - Dee (The all time most overrated Survivor player) 5th - Kenzie (Should not have won) 6th - Erika (What did she even do?)
This is my personal ranking 1. Dee 2. Yam yam 3. Erica 4. Maryanne 5. Kenzie 6. Gabler I think rachel is going to win 47 and shed slot in between yam yam and erica.
I have the same exact list but Gabler and Maryanne Switched I feel like if Survivor 43 was edited to 50 minutes, then people would appreciate Gablers win a lot more despite his small flaws, but I think he is a similar winner to Maryanne but better.
Make sure to check out Idolplays for some MASSIVE deals! idolplays.com/en-us/products/bandits-locker-1 with "Survivor30"
These are my exact rankings as well. Thank you for being able to say why everyone is where they are. You have earned a new subscriber King Bandit.
I actually completely disagree
Thanks for the sub!
I'm not a big erika fan but i have a feeling that if she plays again for a 2nd time, she could win again.
She may very well be underestimated!
Exactly my thoughts. Jeff described her as no ego. That's why she can penetrate well in an all star season and out of the winners, I place my bet on her.
If Charlie should have won, he would have won. His “agency at key points in the game” means nothing if he’s unable to use his social game to secure the votes at the end. He couldn’t even earn the respect of his number one ally
I disagree. Marie was very clearly bitter because she was upset about being voted off. If she voted for Charlie, he would have won as Ben said he would have voted for Charlie
@@jacob4448 I mean clearly Marie was never voting for him from the begining so that ship has sailed clearly thats a relationship he misread and theres failure on both parts, she was defo bitter AF. I was more shocked to learn that about Charlie jury chances. I did not know that both Q and Venus went in looking to vote for him and he was'nt able to get their votes. Charlie was able to convince Hunter, Liz and Soda to switch their votes at FTC but still.....I did not realise how severly low his jury chances were. He was at a 1/2 comparied to Kenzie at a 8/9 for jury chances
Charlie had a really good shot at winning, he kinda messed up at the Venus vote if Kenzie goes there he wins every final 3 without Maria, he also could have asked Ben to put him in fire making and secured the win against Ben Liz. Simply he chose half measures when he should of went all the way
@@jacob4448I don't think anyone should be fully excused for losing at the end just because the jury was "bitter", let alone just one juror. You've still done something wrong in the game if you can't win over your season's jury. As close as it was to being a tie, that tie is pretty much the only scenario where Charlie wins, considering he never had any locked votes. Charlie swaying over 3 people with his speech was the worst case scenario for Kenzie and yet she still got the win fair and square with her sob story whether you like it or not. If you want to discount that, then you kinda also have to consider the scenario where Charlie doesn't do so well at FTC and Kenzie wins unanimously.
@jacob4448 soooo he couldnt earn the respect of his number one ally like the OP said. What exactly are you disagreeing with?
These are my exact rankings, and you did a great job explaining their game.
Finally someone that credits BOTH Cassidy and Gabler with taking out Jesse. I have to give this video a like for all the effort that went into it.
THANKSS :)
Thank you for posting the video.
You're welcome!
Personal Ranking
1. Erika
2. Dee
3. Yam Yam
4 Maryanne
5 Gabler
6 Kenzie
nearly the same but swap gabler and kenzie, erika played a phenomenal game and got one of the worst edits of all time
Totally agree! 💯
Personal ranking:
1. Dee
2. Erika
3. Gabler
4. Rachel
5. Yamyam
6. Kenzie
7. Maryanne
Dee. Dee. Dee any day. She's the best winner of new era
I think Gabler's game is very repeatable. To this day most of the Survivor community doesn't realize how strong his game was, if he is on Survivor 50 he will be my winner pick.
He stumbled into his win, objectively. He wanted to bring Jesse and Cody to the end. He’s a trash tier winner.
@@paintbrush3753 Educate yourself.
I like how to the fanbase at large when men and women play the same game the man is an underrated winner no one respects because they're feminazis (that they just finished terrorizing) and the woman did nothing and didn't deserve to win and DEI yadda yadda. Never change, fanbase
@paintbrush3753 just because his final 3 plans didn’t work doesn’t mean that he stumbled into his win…almost nobodies final 3 plans work out. There’s a lot more to his personality and strategy that helped him win
@@jaykay1899I think the point is that he wanted to bring 2 people who WOULD have beaten him
I would switch Kenzie and Yam Yam.
If each of these winners played 5 more times, I think Kenzie would be most likely to win again. She’s a special combination of social skill and strategy. Whereas without Carson, Yam Yam doesn’t get to a winning position (in my opinion). One might argue that it was Yam Yam’s social skill that did that, but I disagree. Carson was looking out for the Tika three, not just Yam Yam.
I agree Dee is the best winner in the new era, but I don’t think her way of winning would ever allow her to win again.
I think the best player of each season is: Ricard, Omar, Jessie, Carson, Dee, and Charlie. It would be great to see these players in the same season.
Gabler’s winning game is way too under appreciated. No way he should be last
Haven’t even gotten past the pre vid ad and I agree that is an absurd placement
yes he should. his game was horrific done even start with that bs
I would put gabler above kenzie and maryanne
@@tomiharv No it wasn’t lol. His edit could’ve been better though
He played a horrific game for a winner.
My list:
1. Dee
2. Erika
3. Yam Yam
4. Maryanne
5. Kenzie
6. Gabler
My order
1. Dee
2. YamYam
3. Kenzie
4. Maryanne
5. Erika
6. Gabler
I think Yam Yam should be lower. Just rewatched 44 and I think he got incredibly lucky the rest of the cast didnt seem like they even cared about winning. Yam Yam goes earlier any other season. Id put him 5th, or even last.
Totally agree, he’s so overrated, all that he did was made fun of everything. Carson and Carolyn were more strategic
Finally another ranking where Erika is highly ranked. 😊
Gabler getting people half his age to give him votes to win is impressive. If he tried to push the agenda on who’s going home the others would’ve turned on him instantly ala Bruce.
Kenzie knew about the hunter blindside and she was the one who convinced him not to play his idol, like how do you retell the events of what happened completely wrong
Tier 1.
1. Dee
2. Erika
Tier 2.
3. Kenzie
4. Jam Jam
Tier 3.
5. Maryanne
6. Alligabler
I’m definitely biased but I love a twist and an underdog so for me top three is MaryAnne Yam Yam and Gabler in probably any order, and then the last two
Three*
This is the most accurate for me
1. Dee
2. Kenzie
3. Mary Anne
4. Yam Yam
5. Erika
6. Gabler
Even hearing you explanation I don’t really understand why Kenzie wouldn’t be last for you, but ok. My personal ranking, including remaining 47 castaways based on what I think they’d have to do to win
1: Dee
2: Erika (listen to the exit press)
3: Yam Yam
(Caroline)
(Genevieve)
4: Gabler
(Sam)
(Rachel)
5: Maryanne
(Andy)
(Teeny)
6: Kenzie
(Sue)
I agree except I would switch Kenzie and Erika
Gabler last. Yes. Thank you.
Yea that’s what I have too
Maryanne way too low IMO is atleast top 3 with Dee and Yamyam
she really didnt play that good tbh she was on the bottom of her tribe and had no power until the omar move all the way at the final 6
Also Maryanne is racist. She voted against Tori Meehan over Drea Wheeler because Tori was white and Drea was black.
@@AndrewSmith-pn2qcnot true
@Bryce946 yes it is true. If you go watch the tribal council you will see that Maryanne was planning to vote out Drea but then changed her mind because it would be 3 black players voted out in a row and Maryanne did specifically said she did not want to see 3 black players voted out in a row.
@@AndrewSmith-pn2qc how does that make it racist
My rankings would probably be
6. Kenzie
5. Maryanne
4. Gabler
3. Erika
2. YamYam
1.Dee
Interesting. I have Maryanne as the best new era winner
i would switch kenzie & maryanne
Kenzie dead last for me
I got gabler at 1 or 2
Yam yam is last on my list, I don't get why people think he's a great winner😅
But Carolyn though.
Before I watch this video,
Gabler, Maryanne, Kenzie, Erika, yam yam, Dee.
How’d i do?
I am very offended that anyone disagrees with my rankings. I sound like I'm joking but I'm fully serious as always. Here's my ranking:
1st - Gabler (The best player of the new era)
2nd - Yam Yam (Very strong and dominant winning game)
3rd - Maryanne (An average winner)
4th - Dee (The all time most overrated Survivor player)
5th - Kenzie (Should not have won)
6th - Erika (What did she even do?)
Garbage ranking
There could be two guy winners in the last 6 and somehow they're the best players ever
@@ashen_roses correct
Don’t agree with Gabler as the top but the others I agree with
@@realteamwall y do u not like girls dont u wanna get with a girl or are u in2 men??? is this a hate sex kink
yam yam 1
This is my personal ranking
1. Dee
2. Yam yam
3. Erica
4. Maryanne
5. Kenzie
6. Gabler
I think rachel is going to win 47 and shed slot in between yam yam and erica.
My Personal ranking
1. Kenzie
2. Dee
3. Yam Yam
4. Maryanne
5. Erika
6. Gabler
My Ranking
1. Dee
2. Charlie
3. Yam Yam
4. Rachel
5. Gabler
6. Maryanne
7. Erika
Charlie not win for 46, Kenzie is the winner. But for me Charlie more deserved to win 46 instead of Kenzie
That’s the point
This made me laugh, thank you 👍
my ranking:
#1 rachel (s47)
#2 charlie (s46)
#3 austin (s45)
#4 xander (s41)
#5 owen (s43)
#6 carolyn (S44)
#7 maryanne (S42)
Saying Austin and xander deserved to win over Dee and Erika is insane
I have the same exact list but Gabler and Maryanne Switched
I feel like if Survivor 43 was edited to 50 minutes, then people would appreciate Gablers win a lot more despite his small flaws, but I think he is a similar winner to Maryanne but better.
1) Yam Yam
2) Dee
3) Maryanne
4) Gabler
5) Kenzie
6) Erica
My list:
1. Gabler
2. Dee
3. Kenzie
4. Yam Yam
5. Maryanne
6. Erika
🤣🤣🤣
@@chickenchicken9072what’s so funny???
@@warriorsa-cash8534 your list🤣🤣
@@chickenchicken9072 still didn’t answer my question, which proves that you were wrong
@@warriorsa-cash8534 🤣🤣🤣👍