Gaming Laptop Vs Mobile Workstation for Video Editing | HP Z Book Studio G5 Vs HP Omen 15
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 มี.ค. 2020
- The HP Z Book Studio G5 vs the HP Omen 15 for video editors, designers, and photographers. Which one is best suited for your creative professional needs? ► Check availability and pricing in the links below!
► HP ZBook Studio G5 hp.Store ( bit.ly/hp-zbook-g5 )
► HP Omen 15 hp.Store ( bit.ly/HP-Omen15 )
► HP Omen 15 ( geni.us/HpOmen15-i79750 - Commission Earned)
These are two very different laptops, but many creative professionals have come to me inquiring about the compatibility of the HP Omen for creators on their search for the perfect laptop. I have done a full review on the HP Omen and I think it makes a great laptop for video editors and designers. So today I want to put these two laptops head to head to help you choose the best laptop for your needs. Now, these laptops may have similar performance but will be suited for different buyers per the budget, build quality, and use case.
Starting out I want to look at the build of each of these models. The HP Omen has a bold aesthetic with the big X on the top cover with a mixed Carbon fiber and plastic design. The laptop is well assembled and the hinge opens and closes smoothly.
The HP Z Book Studio G5 is an all-aluminum, light-weight, thin laptop with a very discreet look. I like the beveled edges and corners, unlike other laptops with sharp janky edges.
Laptop Weights:
Weight: 5.56 Lbs
Weight: 4.4 Lbs
The HP Z Book will also win when it comes to battery life as it can last a lot longer out on the town without a charger.
Battery Life: 9 Hours Web Surfing / 4 - 5 Hours Design and Editing
Battery Life: 2 - 4 hours
The screen is another thing that will set these two laptops apart. The Z Book has better color accuracy than the HP Omen.
Hp Z Book Studio G5 --- Color Accuracy: 96% sRGB - 78% Adobe RGB
HP Omen --- Color Accuracy: 93% sRGB - 57% Adobe RGB
Now for the ports. I am putting the ports up on the screen right now and as you’re observing what each model is spec’d with I want you to consider your day to day operations. What kind of ports do you need as an editor, designer, or photographer? It is important to know your workflow, not just the latest hype.
HP Z Book Studio G5:
Thunderbolt x2
HDMI
USB 3.0 x2
SD Card Slot UHS-II
Headphone Jack
HP Z Book Studio G5:
x3 USB 3.0
SD Card Slot
HDMI & Displayport
USB-C (Not thunderbolt 3)
Network/Ethernet Port
Mic Jack & Headphone Jack
Now we are going to jump into the performance section and see how these two laptops stack up against one another. Due note that these two models are very well equipped for running multiple design programs at the same time and photo editing. So you can be confident in your ability to run the Adobe Creative suite such as Photoshop, Indesign, and Illustrator.
HP Z Book Studio G5 Specs:
Processor: Intel 9th Gen i7-9750H
RAM: 16GB - Single Slot
GPU: NVIDIA Quadro P2000 with 4GB GDDR5
Storage: 512GB SSD
Battery Life: 9 Hours Web Surfing / 4 - 5 Hours Design and Editing
Weight: 4.4 Lbs
HP Omen 15 Specs:
RAM: 32GB
GPU: NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1660 Ti 6GB GDDR6
Storage: 512 PCIe SSD
Weight: 5.56 Lbs
Battery Life: 2 - 4 hours
Refresh Rate: 144Hz
Color Accuracy: 93% sRGB - 57% Adobe RGB
Now for all of my video editing folks we are going to dive into some of the video editing tests to see how well these two laptops handle 4k video editing. I am going to run through my standard video editing test where I take a 9-minute 4k clip put it into Premiere Pro and export it out in full quality 4k TH-cam settings.
HP Z Book Studio G5 Tests:
9 Minute 4k Export to 4k - 10:32.60
9 Minute 4k Export to 1080p - 3:27.89
HP Omen Tests:
9 Minute 4k Export to 4k - 7:26.27
9 Minute 4k Export to 1080p - 3:12
It is also important to note that the Z Book and the HP Omen are able to playback the 4k clip at full quality settings without any lag or stutter.
Overall these two laptops handle Video editing, photography, and graphic design very well. The HP Omen slightly edges out the Z Book on the 4k export, but not by a long shot. The HP Omen is going to be the affordable option of these two laptops, but lacks the light-weight, on the go battery life, and all-aluminum body.
Each laptop is a great buy for its own unique user. I wish you the best and can confidently recommend either of these laptops with confidence.
------
DISCLAIMER: ALL LINKS IN DESCRIPTION ARE AFFILIATE LINKS
Thanks for Supporting Our Channel!
![[ไฮไลต์] แบดมินตันชาย SHI Yu Qi (จีน) vs วิว กุลวุฒิ (ไทย) รอบ 8 คน | โอลิมปิก 2024](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/f7z7taforOM/mqdefault.jpg)
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 73 วันนี้!! คู่เอก "วรพล vs พันฤทธิ์"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/rrOljlqse3A/mqdefault.jpg)
Really needed this video right now. Thank you!
Great video, can you make a video explaining the Dell Inspiron 7590?
Cool video, very helpful, we are waiting for your next video, keep healthy and keep spirit uploading
Thank you!
I really want the omen but i heard it gets too hot ,and maybe if the built isnt as good as the zbook it wont last as long
honest review
keep it up
Thank you, I will
Hp zbook g4 16 gb ram 2gb dedicated graphics quadro vs dell latitude 5580 2gb dedicated graphics mx940 24 gb ram which should I go for?
hi Ben, loved the comparison, was very helpful. However, the description stated the specs of the omen as 2070 max Q while the video showed 1660ti. Is that a typo?
Thanks for catching that!
@@BenGKaiser you're welcome!
hello, i am trying to decide a buy laptop. i am not a creator, engineer but i need CPU power and a little GPU power because of the financial trading programs. These programs need H series CPU that have more core for algo trading. But i do not decide a work station or gaming PC . Legion 5 PRo, Dell XPS 15 , HP Zbook G9 or Fury ? can you give an advice? @Ben G Kaiser
@@idealsistem8173 if price is a concern, gp for the legion 5, it's the cheapest for the same specs. The XPS 15 would be great if you don't mind spending a bit more and sacrificing a slight bit of performance for a thinner and lighter laptop. The zbook would not be recommended purely for the fact that they're more expensive, but they do offer quadro graphics and vpro enabled cpu if your company/school requires that.
@@jammaschan thank you , XPS is the most expensive one in our country but fantastic design. Legion 5 and 5 pro price different is not so high so Pro version is better than Legion normal . the programs i use do not need CPU power as video editing or render or gaming but i do not want to suffer from thermal issues, stability and realibity. so i want to decide ; G9 Power, Legion 5 Pro, dell xps 15
But can they Run 2020 with extra high Coronavirus settings.
Can't seem to find any benchmarks on gaming for the zbook
How decent is the comparison between a Quadro and a gtx? I'm into 3d rendering autocad etc and photo editing, should i take a mobile workstation or a gaming laptop?
quardo
@Ben G Kaiser
Hi Ben I have a question and in need of some advice for my next laptop purchase. I am currently a college student majoring in graphic design and I need a little help deciding which laptop would best suit my academic needs. I will be taking a class that requires us to download Adobe Premier After Effects and Adobe photoshop and Ilustrator. I’ve never used any of these programs before and I have very little knowledge regarding tech so I was wondering if you have any recommendations as to what type of laptops/devices would work well with these programs? My budget is around $700-$2k.
Premiere Pro is going to be the program that you need the most power to use.
I would recommend one of these laptops:
► Lenovo Legion Y540 ( geni.us/LegionY540 )
► Acer ConceptD 3 ( geni.us/ConceptD3 )
► HP Spectre x360 ( geni.us/Spectrex360-i7 )
► MSI PRestige 15 ( geni.us/Prestige15-16gb )
► Gigabyte Aero 15 ( amzn.to/2X6Rkx1 )
These will have the power you need to run all of those programs.
Do you know when the next model comes out, the HP ZBook 15 G7?
Thomas McAdams. It's out now. Not much difference from the G5. The G7 loses the option for Xeon processor and privacy shutter for the Webcam, while gaining 10th gen CPU and slimmer bezels. Ports are almost the same.
@@chelious1973 also no 2-in-1 version!
masyaallah bgus bnget videox, jal
nasihat untuk kdpanx, prbaiki kualitas vdeox. kerja bagus
Which Laptop can I buy for music and video,photography
Honestly, Either one of these would work great. Although the ZBook will be much better if you have an on the go lifestyle.
❤️♥️ Nice video.❤️♥️
Can you please tell is the base MBP 16" (i7 6‑core 4.5GHz+AMD Radeon Pro 5300M with 4GB ram +16GB 2666MHz DDR4 memory +512gb SSD)
is good enough for video editing at 1080p and coding as a computer science major.
Or what about
MBP 16" (i7/i9 8‑core 5.0 GHz+AMD Radeon Pro 5500M with 8GB ram +32GB 2666MHz DDR4 memory +1 TB SSD)
I study in Germany so I will buy there on student discount
Please recommed some updates if necessary because I want to regret later
Please do reply
Yep, even a new Macbook air can do it well (apart from long hours-no ventilation)
Thanks ben
You're most welcome!
I am a VFX & 3d solidworks student which laptop is best for me ?? Plzz answer sir ?
workstation
Thank you for comparing these two laptops. It shows that we should not pay attention to manufacture's labels because in many cases we don't need a machine that says pro or workstation, or that has a Xeon processor, ECC Memory, and a Nvidia Quadro GPU to create content. There is a typo at 3:37 since the Zbook has actually two USB type c ports with Thunderbolt 3 capability. You can see clearly the Thunderbolt logo on both ports at 3:49. I wish you would have included some After Effects and Photoshop tests since the video is also aimed at motion designers. I've noticed that most reviewers focus mainly on the video editing performance. It was a very informative video overall. Keep up the good work.
Thank you for the comment!
What type of Photoshop tests could I do that would help you out. I want to do more tests to be helpful, sometime I just don't know how to approach that aspect.
@@BenGKaiser I don't use Photoshop as much as I do Premiere Pro, After Effects, and Blender. There are benchmark tools for all those programs but with the exemption of Blender, they are not only paid but can also get quite expensive. I prefer real-life tests. Open the Fusion page in Davinci Resolve and create some animated titles and effects and check if the computer can handle it without hiccups. Stabilize footage in After Effects and create a multi-layer composition in 3d space, then move the orbit camera around extruded objects at the highest quality setting. Check if you can RAM preview it in real-time or close to it. Stitch (merge) some high megapixel photos in Photoshop and add some processing intensive filters and see if the computer has to stop a lot to think. Create a scene in Blender with physics simulation like smoke or fire using the Cycles render engine, move the camera around to check the viewport refresh time and then see if it can play the animation back without dropping frames. Finally, export the animation out to PNG files and h.264 video and see how long it takes.
Thank you!
@Ben G Kaiser , i am trying to decide a buy laptop. i am not a creator, engineer but i need CPU power and a little GPU power because of the financial trading programs. These programs need H series CPU that have more core for algo trading. But i do not decide a work station or gaming PC . Legion 5 PRo, Dell XPS 15 , HP Zbook G9 or Fury ? can you give an advice? @Ben G Kaiser
Ben I find alot of gaming pcs don't have sd card slots :/
Yeah, it is rather annoying, for sure!
Can the zbook still play game
Buy this in 2022😋
Is Linux can support on mobile workstation?
😢
Is the zbook studio g5 screen 4k
Yes
57% Adobe RGB ? that's not correct mate.
Why they are so many hp omen laptops with different prices?! I don't know which i have to buy
Been using hp zbook at work for 2 years now. And it's nothing but a ugly, bulky, heavy box of metal. It has managed to hit the final nail in my windows coffin.
And it's 32 GB Ram, i7 11850. Had to let go of Mac option initially coz I am so much more used to Corel draw for my workflow, and it's still not as effecient on macbook as Adobe counterpart.
lol i have a OMEN 15
You liking it?