Thanks for the vid! I don't know what I was thinking with those initial placements and going for a city so late. I was putting way too much value on army but ironically didn't even end up getting it, this was painful to watch lol
Sometimes you can play a knight to try and pluck a card in a jam, you had a few spots where you didn’t want to hold or trade in all your ores, and wheat was out there. That way you also get going towards 3 knights sooner. Also think you were too generous with your trade offers, try the 1 for 1s first.
Lol, yes. Blue and Red should have been "natural" trading partners (Blue without Brick, Red without Wood) but Blue's counters were so piggish, I noticed later in the game Blue accepted Red's trade offer, but Red chose rather to trade with Grey. Says something about human nature...
18:22 Going to the Bank with 4 wool, 1 grain and 2 ore to save for a City....Red's odd-on play was to trade the 3 wool for 1 ore, not for 1 grain. To get the missing resource for a city, you'd rather count on an 8 being rolled (5 pips) instead of a 10 (3 pips). Sure enough, next roll was an 8.
That was painful to watch. Red should have played knights as soon as Gray started buying D cards. The game even tried to hand him the win with an unusually high number of 10s being rolled.
Thanks for the great video and advice on what to do in basically every situation. Your videos have really helped me win a lot more games online and with friends
Honestly, I haven't finished the video, so not sure who wins exactly, but at 20:40 into the game I can say that Red hasn't made one good move the entire game.
Thank you Neonate! I really needed a way to work out some strategies, because im playing in the Polish Championships this year, and I don't have the settlers to practice on :P
Great video and advice. Yikes on those initial settlement placements, the game was decided there. Red couldn't even win it despite the extremely plentiful 10 rolls.
Thanks! Yes, his initial picks made me realize rules like "Ore Wins" are simplifications. A beginner needs further experience to decided whether to pick a spot without Sheep or a spot without Wood. In this case, he should skip Sheep.
Thank you. The ratio is based loosely on the resources you need to build cities (three ore/two wheat) and buy development cards (ore/wheat/sheep). In practice, I found having 6/4/3 or 8/10/11 (ore/wheat/sheep) spots to be fairly reliable for building cities and buying development cards. Such spots have a ratio of 5:3:2.
Rule #11 When Third, Take Rare Resources. Rare in this situation means if you are third, and there is only one good producing spot (10+pts) next to the only good producing (3+pts) wood, brick, wheat, or ore, you should strongly consider taking it.
As absolutely atrocious as this guy played, he STILL could have won if he had just used his Knights. He DID realize that the Knights had to be used in order to count for largest army, right? That's the only possible explanation I can see for holding all those Knights for so long, especially since he could have used one early on when Blue and Green hit on the 6 and Green had an extra Wheat that Red had been trying to get for ages for the 3rd settlement.......
Im going to be honest, these videos aren’t nearly as enjoyable as your gameplays. It seems that there is a lot of effort going into this video (you have to edit out all the time in between player’s actions). I just feel that I don’t want to watch a novice play the game and hear you disagree with a lot of it. I feel like a live commentary is way easier to produce and higher in game quality. Thank you for keeping up with the uploads though!
I usually like your videos, but...this guy was painful to watch. He needs so much coaching. I mean, I not always follow your advices, but those trades hurt a little inside. He was lucky to get those victory points, but buying development cards doesn´t give you a boosting advantage (monopoly may give you resources, but it is a rare card and it is mostly used as a punishment for other players, and the 2 free resources card is not a great deal, as you are trading 3 resources [one of them being ore and the other being wheat] for just any 2 resources). Hope he gets better
Thanks for the vid! I don't know what I was thinking with those initial placements and going for a city so late. I was putting way too much value on army but ironically didn't even end up getting it, this was painful to watch lol
You're welcome! Thank you! The pain shows how much progress you've made since then! :-) Good luck!
Sometimes you can play a knight to try and pluck a card in a jam, you had a few spots where you didn’t want to hold or trade in all your ores, and wheat was out there. That way you also get going towards 3 knights sooner. Also think you were too generous with your trade offers, try the 1 for 1s first.
neonate come baaack
“Blue, being a little bit of a pig.” I choked on my soda.
Lol, yes. Blue and Red should have been "natural" trading partners (Blue without Brick, Red without Wood) but Blue's counters were so piggish, I noticed later in the game Blue accepted Red's trade offer, but Red chose rather to trade with Grey. Says something about human nature...
Another video! Another smile! Thank you for making these, Neonate! You inspire so much :)
Ditto (Is Ghost the movie before your time?)
@@NeonateGaming Hm, I don't think I've heard of it before. Why do you ask?
My favorite one of your rules:
- When behind, build cities.
- When ahead, buy cards.
Thanks, it's one of my favorites too. Simple, logical.
18:22 Going to the Bank with 4 wool, 1 grain and 2 ore to save for a City....Red's odd-on play was to trade the 3 wool for 1 ore, not for 1 grain. To get the missing resource for a city, you'd rather count on an 8 being rolled (5 pips) instead of a 10 (3 pips). Sure enough, next roll was an 8.
Agreed! Good one!
Thanks for another great vid! You and Dylighted are killing it!
Thanks for your continued support!
That was painful to watch. Red should have played knights as soon as Gray started buying D cards. The game even tried to hand him the win with an unusually high number of 10s being rolled.
Agreed, that was a fatal mistake!
Thanks for the great video and advice on what to do in basically every situation. Your videos have really helped me win a lot more games online and with friends
Thank you and I'm glad to hear they've helped! Good luck!
Red Player: *does any action at all*
Neonate: 'I disagree'
Honestly, I haven't finished the video, so not sure who wins exactly, but at 20:40 into the game I can say that Red hasn't made one good move the entire game.
Another brilliant video 😊 thanks Neonate!
Thank you very much!
Thank you Neonate! I really needed a way to work out some strategies, because im playing in the Polish Championships this year, and I don't have the settlers to practice on :P
Thanks - good luck in your tournament! Have you played any before?
Great video and advice. Yikes on those initial settlement placements, the game was decided there. Red couldn't even win it despite the extremely plentiful 10 rolls.
Thanks! Yes, his initial picks made me realize rules like "Ore Wins" are simplifications. A beginner needs further experience to decided whether to pick a spot without Sheep or a spot without Wood. In this case, he should skip Sheep.
This channel is amazing
You're amazing, thanks!
Great video! When are you going to make another gameplay and commentary?
Thanks! What do you think about the live streams?
Hey nice video man! I was wondering how you came up with the ratio of 5:3:2 for ore:wheat:sheep in rule 7 of your guide. Thanks man!
Thank you. The ratio is based loosely on the resources you need to build cities (three ore/two wheat) and buy development cards (ore/wheat/sheep). In practice, I found having 6/4/3 or 8/10/11 (ore/wheat/sheep) spots to be fairly reliable for building cities and buying development cards. Such spots have a ratio of 5:3:2.
Blue had the best initial placements, but red and green together gave the game to red. I felt blue's pain...
Agreed, Blue looked the strongest from the initial placements. Only two 9s rolled and thirteen 10s, so yes, bad luck!
is there a whole list of your rules i can find?
Check the video description FAQ for an explanation. Thanks!
Finally another video! How do you communicate this to the user you coached? Are you have kind of a debrief after the game or is it just this video?
Thanks - I post the video and send them an email. It's not a personal debrief, but I do put a lot of time/effort in.
How are you valuing points? I assume you aren't talking about victory points
Thanks! Check my FAQs in the video description for an explanation and a draft of my "rules".
How do u know which resource is the rarest?
Rule #11 When Third, Take Rare Resources. Rare in this situation means if you are third, and there is only one good producing spot (10+pts) next to the only good producing (3+pts) wood, brick, wheat, or ore, you should strongly consider taking it.
As absolutely atrocious as this guy played, he STILL could have won if he had just used his Knights. He DID realize that the Knights had to be used in order to count for largest army, right? That's the only possible explanation I can see for holding all those Knights for so long, especially since he could have used one early on when Blue and Green hit on the 6 and Green had an extra Wheat that Red had been trying to get for ages for the 3rd settlement.......
Im going to be honest, these videos aren’t nearly as enjoyable as your gameplays. It seems that there is a lot of effort going into this video (you have to edit out all the time in between player’s actions). I just feel that I don’t want to watch a novice play the game and hear you disagree with a lot of it. I feel like a live commentary is way easier to produce and higher in game quality. Thank you for keeping up with the uploads though!
Thanks for the feedback! I finally got this one out, and I'll take a break on further coaching videos. Do you like the live streams?
Neonate Gaming love the live streams! I only managed to watch one of them but they are great!
I usually like your videos, but...this guy was painful to watch.
He needs so much coaching.
I mean, I not always follow your advices, but those trades hurt a little inside.
He was lucky to get those victory points, but buying development cards doesn´t give you a boosting advantage (monopoly may give you resources, but it is a rare card and it is mostly used as a punishment for other players, and the 2 free resources card is not a great deal, as you are trading 3 resources [one of them being ore and the other being wheat] for just any 2 resources).
Hope he gets better
Yes, I disagreed with almost every decision, but perhaps it was more educational that way!