Hamza Yusuf, Yasir Qadhi, Omar Suleiman, Shamsi & Shillit Hasaballah, by Jalal Abualrub
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 ส.ค. 2024
- Zakatul-Maal Eligible: Donate here to support our Dawah islamlife.com
For e-books and articles visit: islamlife.com
FaceBook: / islamlife2
Free Arabi Classes: / arabicmadesimple
JazakAllahu khairan
Jazaka-Allah Khairan our beloved Sheikh. Watching from Northern Nigeria.
Jazakumu'llahu khairan
Jalal Abualrub wrote: Frankly, I have little sympathy for those who, while asserting that they are 'Muslims', have little regard for the Quran, the Prophet and his Sunnah, and for Islam’s creed, tenets, practices and law. They support and defend shady characters who, while being promoted as ‘Islamic scholars,’ commit massive aggression against Islam. Regardless of what the aggressors do or say, there are those who never criticize the deviants, but who are ready and able, and have the audacity, to be intolerant, obnoxious, rude and abusive towards those who defend Islam and criticize the deviants,. Such people specialize in defending those who are ruining Islam. This strange flock is willing to devastate their akhirah in service of persons who care less about them, or about their Islam or about their own akhirah. We are not interested in ruining our akhirah, for anyone, period. To the defenders of the deviants I say: If you don’t like what I and other students of knowledge say in defense of Islam, go to a Muslim psychoanalyst and let them analyze why you have no feelings for Islam yet have such high tolerance of those who are dismantling Islam one piece at a time, while showing enmity towards those who defend the religion. This type of cheerleaders for scholars of deviant ideas and practices, are a major part of why the ummah is in such weak state. I can't say, “Get Lost” though, because some of them are already lost. However, I can say: How pathetic!
Assalamu Aleikum sheikh - it’s not time for such discussion. We need to be united as Muslims
May Allah preserve you dear Sheikh. We love you for the sake of Allah SWT
How can you love him when he has no adab of our great scholars?
@@hamidankhan8096 well the answer to your question is in a comment under by @IslamLife2. No need to elaborate further. The Ulama have difference of opinion through the all ages. There are hadiths where its stated the sahaba ra used to almost fistfight over issues. Nothing wrong with a critique of youtube so called uthdaths,sheikhs. Somebody have to seperate the haq' from the ba'til
The ones you criticise are calling people to Islam and teaching people to be good Muslims.
Up until Gaza I used to shun Umar Sulaiman completely. But amongst the names mentioned (in the title) I consider him the best out of all of them. His community posts on Palestine have been on point.
Subhanallah, so talking about ghaza is the criteria for assessing a good Muslim? So if someone follows the Quran and sunnah but he doesn’t talk about ghaza he isn’t a good Muslim in your eyes. Omar suleiman is a deviant innovator that must be warned against and it doesn’t matter if he talks about ghaza or not
@@Ermat3
I never mentioned my overall opinion. But for your information:
It isn't my job to determin the good or bad muslim, what is dealt with is the reality of the moment and the opinions presented. Like for example another brother mentioned in the list: I love his dawah to non muslims, may Allah swt accept it and reward him. Yet outside of this particular field it is best he just remains silen, really silent.
As such (as mentioned) I never cared to follow the pro democracy, liberal and whatever ideas known to be propagated by any speaker.
What I do value though is when the circumstance or the issue of the moment requires clarification. Whether it be clarification of a Hukm or relevant information of the reality (or just the action of speaking out against oppression, with the Shar as a yardstick)
As such I have no problem standing by what I said when taking into consideration the priorities and vital issues (matters of life and death) before us today at this exact particular moment. Which isn't a stamp of approval for anything else outside of what was mentioned.
@@Ermat3
Don't know whether my clarification was posted. I assume it is, but it doesn't appear. So if not consider this half an answer to your questions.
I am not convinced any Muslim that is aware of the current situation in Palestine is driven by the Qur'an and Sunnah to neglect the issue.
1. The issue of Palestine is related to our Aqeedah.
2. There are numerous Ahkaam of which the obligation has appeared, basic things:
- Feeding the hungry
- removing munkar
- allegiance to the Muslims
- the protection of honor and dignity, possessions and wealth, soundness and life.
These are common known things.
So please explain how one is following the Qur'an and Sunnah while neglecting basics ? And what would be the cause of that ? And is that cause a valid justification ?
He is a click bait Imam. He will bring to you whatever is in the news at the moment. In his recent past he has supported LBTQ and continues to support inter faith. Pretty clear where he stands for me. Alhamdullilah
@@Ermat3what are his innovations?
You talked about not getting donations from any government. One of the ‘islamic’ universities called Bayan, that Omar Suleiman teaches at, or taught at, was offered $800 000. It was a CVE grant
Assalamualaykum sheikh. I have 2 of your books (Tafsir as Sadi) that you translated. Are you going to translate all of it?
Who said that Hashish is allowed in Islam? Which person is the Shaikh referring to?
Why are you attacking your brothers in Islam?
These old man should keep his unvaluable wahabi opinions to himself
I am always appreciative of your wisdom, Sheikh. We go a long way back.
What wisdom? Criticizing scholars?
كلهم لا يكفرون القبوريين فهم مثلهم
"Everybody is bad I am good, and I am on the right path because I am student of Bin Baaz and Uthaimin". When people are struggling with faith, some people people can't get out of Bin Baaz ans Uthaimin, while living in the countries not where Bin Baz and Uthaimin were born. Throwing mud at others doesn't help you to establish yourself as an esteemed man of knowledge.
Word of truth
The audio volume is low. JazakAllahu khair. Allah bless our beloved Shaikh.
So you are a Muslim" Scholar"?
Wahabi barking as usual
Learn manners you lowly scum of the earth.
Do not speak about our beloved Hamza Yucef, you know nothing! He has devoted his life to Allah! Leave him alone. Same with our sheikhs.
Where is the devotion?
Shaykh Hamza Yusuf’s khidma to the ummah inwest is undeniable… At the age of the colour of your beard… you should not be making TH-cam videos putting the boot into your brothers especially at this time …
Yes you are not “popular” but you are trying to make yourself popular by making TH-cam.. #Hypocrisy
You might want to look up Hamza ibn Abd al-Muttalib (ra) and see his age and what he did. Alhamdullilah
You DO know that most of those "scholars" color their beards to make themselves look more "youthful". Not even using the sunnah color. Look at Ali Khan a few years ago and now. Or Mufti Menk. Alhamdullilah The was was of vanity isn't always directed to the sisters. Alhamdullilah May Allah(swt) allow us to look deeper than the skin, tribe and sex of a believer and see the haqq being presented or not. Amen