It's not the resolutions or graphics detail or the consoles it's the developers. This game doesn't look nextgen at all even on high end pcs. Arkham knight looks better and runs smoothly on a PS4 red dead 2 runs smoothly on a ps4, this game is stuttering and loosing frame rates even when the scenes are full of low res textures and geometry similar to ps2 ,This shows it's not the consoles problem it's the developers bad engineering.
A stable 30fps is always appreciated. I tried playing Jedi Fallen Order with a dynamic frame rate and was all over the place. Then swapped to lock 30fps with dynamic 4K and yeah controller response was way better. Horizon and Spider-Man all felt excellent at a lock 30.
People with mid range or old hardware should definitely consider playing at 30 and cranking settings/resolution up instead of trying in vain to hold 60 despite your game looking like a vaseline smudge. This game is gorgeous and it NEEDS a high resolution to shine, the effects scale like shit with lower resolutions... so yeah, I recommend 30 FPS to most people that don't have 2080 Tis/3070 and up.
Disabling some graphical settings improves the frame rate a lot. And I would rather have the same dynamic resolution but have the lower limit set at 1080p instead.
@@farisakhtar4824 dynamic resolution is great for balancing performance and quality until you’re rendering scenes at noticeably different resolutions. I personally find it much better if it’s less noticeable. They should keep the top and bottom within a certain degree. Maybe they should’ve at least used the PS4 Pro’s res target. It would have looked about the same, but I’m sure it would’ve been an almost perfect 30.
@@traceyates1506 its already noticeable when you're driving and in dense crowds. You don't drop from 1674p to 1224p without noticing. And anyway 1080p is not a bad resolution, at least not to me. It wasn't too long ago games were in 720p and looked good for their time. Frame rate over resolution so it can at least remain above 25fps.
@@andrewsqual CDPR did not give them pre-release copies for consoles, they were only allowed to talk about the PC version. It's the developer who deliberately hid it from us. I don't see it being the reviewer's fault.
If you are still playing on the base Xbox one you seriously need to invest some money, like how is that possible the base Xbox one should be obsolete by now .
@Source Dasher bro calm down. If you actually had a pc, you'd know it's a shitshow on there too. How do I know? Because I have it on a high end rig and it still is ass because of the amd cpu issue. That being said, I'm pretty sure the xbox is based on amd tech, so maybe there is some kind of cpu issue for the xbox too.
@Mr. Firestone * COD might be shit now, but at the very least they let you playa beta. Hell, even the infamous EA allows trials and demos for the public.
@@pzdizzle I feel like the people with really high pc builds or decent pc builds don't go around saying stuff like "buy a pc"if you know the price of a decent rig which a lot of people can't afford but fr fr i think you just have a ass graphics card my 1070 runs this on 50 to 60 butttt this game is still a mess with the bugs etc...
^^^ for the dumbasses above, he was only talking to the guy calling him a pleb. Your opinions about whether or not he had a high end PC weren't really needed
@@pzdizzle cod isn't at its worst now lol I haven't played since ghost played 1 hour of it when it came out on ps3/transition to ps4 came back to modernwarfare/warzone and its obv the best of any not counting nostalgia factors
They probably have a server dedicated to holding their 'backup' apologies and promises. Along with a schedule, and automated system to release specific ones in case of certain events happening. Taking a page from the BP playbook. "Uh oh, another oil spill, get the apology commercials queued up"
They are now accepting refund requests though. So its a come around. Thank god. Otherwise people would have definitely lost all trust. Even the PC requirements are not accurate. The recommended system which i have barely gives over 40 even on low-med preset.
I doubt 100% of people who are unhappy with their console versions will get a refund though. CDPR will probably make more profit this way than if they had warned everybody beforehand in a fair way.
@@stuporman it doesn't run any better, the console renders at a certain resolution and then downscales or upscales depending on the TV/monitor resolution
It’s also possible that they were confident that the day 1 patch would fix all of these problems and they didn’t want to show off the game without the patch (clearly it did not fix the issues.) As a consumer you should wait until the day of release to make your decision to buy the game. I don’t understand why people pre order games. But if you are one of those people that wanted to play it at midnight on release day, you can always get a refund.
Ehh I think they deliberately went for a toss-up on that one. It's like being able to switch between graphics and presentation mode in God of War. One looks better, but the other plays better.
@@Doganderboss I've had a few friends play on Xbox One X, and they can run at 30 FPS, but you might have a different experience and run like total shit.
That's just not true. There would have been more backlash by players who paid the same as the PC version but have to wait months to play it They should have been transparent and tell us the performance is shit, but that it's the players choice whether they want to wait or play it at abysmal performance. Not a perfect compromise but better than making console players weave around social media for months avoiding spoilers
@@schwartzy65 Got too ambitious most likely. Then they forgot the CPU in the ps4 and Xbox are a portable one that was outdated in 2013. This game is one of the hardest ive seen on PC CPU power.
@@schwartzy65 like clownavenger said,they got too ambitious.If you see e3 vs retail,retail version is better.After doing all the improvementes,then they went to do the last gen console ports and were like "oh fck what have we done"
My thoughts exactly. Also lower res for base consoles down to 720p. I will never understand the fixation deva have with resolution to the point of thinking 1800p 20fps is better than 1440p 30fps.
The thing is they’re not GPU limited per se. They’re CPU limited with how the game handle crowd, asset streaming, etc. In my opinion, the only way they can fix this is by increasing (I mean by huge amount) of asset duplication which can ease a little bit the bottleneck created by 5400rpm HDD. Of course this will result in a substantial increase of a game file size (we are talking COD like size here or even bigger). This is one of the problems when you make the games with an SSD-optimised in mind. And to further ease the streaming system especially while driving fast within these high density city they need to at least double the amount of LODs per object which is also going to substantially increase the game file size which can ease both CPU decompression time and system RAM (GDDR). All of these extra resource can be use to handle at least an acceptable amount of crowd present on a per scene basis. If you look at this game the crowd are very dynamic on their own which means this will hurt this weak CPU logic a lot. The way to solve this is to make the dumb-crowd system like in the early 2010-ish style games, where different NPCs move in pack with a noticeable sync-move set if that make sense. And makes only few of them move dynamically (AI like).
@@soraaoixxthebluesky If they have to increase the game size to make it playable, just do it. The game have near 50GB, even if they increased it 3 time, to something like 150GB but making the whole experience beter, i don't see any problem in that(The problem will be that the game will use way more space on the next gen machines until the proper next gen update arrives). RDR2 have more than 100GB and it's not as beautifull on the base machines as it is on the Pro/X, but it is really playable, anyone would sacrifice Storage in benefit of a playable game.
@@michaellitten4538 He's talking about E3 trailer vs Retail, go watch Nick930s comparison video, Cyberpunk 2077 is one of the few games where the final game looks better than the trailers, although its the PC version
@@XxSprayMilkxX It goes to sub 720p on last gen consoles on top of various visual downgrades compared to the PC and PS5 running emulation. So yes it does look like shit on last gen consoles.
As a mid level pc player who has been getting solid performance with tweaks, this puts into perspective the outrage and the unfortunate state of many players.
People keep on bitching at me about how the version I'm playing (PS4 on the Pro) is not much better than the base console version when it usually goes between 25-30fps and rarely hits lower than what the guys in the video get. I just am like '. . . Fuck! What the hell, man! At least the version I'm playing is STABLE and runs decently well with fewer issues than the base console version!' Saying that the Pro/X1X/S is not much better than the PS4/X1when it comes to being able to play Cyberpunk is like saying The Dark Knight is not much better than Batman Begins or that Revenge of the Sith isn't much better than the rest of the Star Wars prequels.
@@tcrpgfan Instead of Sony offering money back for Cyberpunk buyers they should have offered money back for last gen consoles. Both Xbox and SOny failed to deliver last gen, what a total shit show.
Cyberpunk 2077 will most likely be handled exactly like The Witcher 3, which also had a buggy release. CD Projekt Red went on to fix the bugs and even implement some new features (includnig a secondary combat/movement/animation system), while also releasing plenty of free dlc both cosmetic and substantial, such as a couple short single-player quests and a very well implemented New Game Plus mode. Finally, they went on to develop and release two major expansions, and by the time they were done, everyone had forgotten about the buggy release and the Witcher 3 stood tall as one of the greatest games ever...
@@paoloadam "greates games ever" waifu baiting ubisoft like openworld with thousands of bandit camps, but devoid of anything meaningful, like Skyrim oder Assassins Creed consolefied controls boring combat definitely not one of the best games ever
Finally got myself physical copy of Cyberpunk on PS4 Pro. I wanted to see 1.0 version and if it's really that bad. And it was indeed. Buggy as hell with messy graphics. I patched the game and really have to say that I'm quite impressed. Totally different game. Even the framerate feels stable now. Didn't expect that but I'm really enjoying the game.
Imagine being a casual type of gamer who doesn’t visit gaming websites, doesn’t watch video game TH-cam content, and you just decided to pick this game up because you thought the marketing was awesome, or you heard about the hype randomly from someone at work. That’s who I feel for. This is indefensible. Shame on CD Projekt Red. What a way to ruin your reputation.
Even if people did pay attention and followed the news closely.. if they pre ordered or bought it early on, there was no footage of last gen consoles at all.
I talked to one of them. He played on a base Xbox and was super happy, raved about how great the story is and how he was having a fantastic time. I asked him about glitches and bugs, and he said it was the same way with RDR2 so he figured it'd be fixed with updates and wasn't concerned. I was surprised, a very different response to what I expected, and on top of it he was playing on the worst system.
"Bit of disappointing..." Love the british understatement. Leadbetter was one of my fav writer/editor back in the Amiga days. Was an avid reader of UK Amiga mags.
I also like his accent. He doesn't speak a posh RP accent which I have no problem with due to my being Chinese, but he sounds well spoken and very clear.
@@friedrichnietzsche7736 I just remember him from c&vg and mainly mean machines. Who read saturn magazine, the machine was an okay import machine but otherwise PS1 all the way.
@@friedrichnietzsche7736 I remember Gary Cutlack working for PSW who was a Sega afficiando who lamented their sad demise. Just like to point out Friedrich that I've read and enjoyed most of your books. Good to see you've reanimated yourself!!!
If it's a singleplayer game, I can wait even longer and wait for a sale, DLC, and patches. Not like there's a multiplayer community I'm missing out on.
That car will blow the doors off of most of the S1 class cars in Forza Horizon 4... I was very surprised. I'm glad I beat it in the head to head so that I can really take advantage of it in future races.
Even though I have a One X I feel like the resolution should have been locked at 1080 to help with frame drops during gunfights and exploration in the city. The hotfix helped a lot with frame drops and crashes but I feel like they can do more
@@kresimircosic9035 PSP was so bad with games being slide shows at points... : ikeAcecombat X the game was a slide show at a few points but it made the cannon run at the end a lot easier in fact,.
I'm starting to feel that the Xbox One cannot be fully optimised for this game. I was hopeful before as I know miracles can happen with games being ported. Witcher 3 on switch looks phenomenal now, nobody ever expected that.
@@dudeletsplay4792 People like us that could never afford super expensive PC parts until later in life, are usually pretty happy with anything over 40fps haha.
I really hope the devs made a real NPC AI system and a real vehicle AI system, but they just commented them out and made placeholders because they ran out of time.
@@iskamag Keep in mind, the first 3 years (until late 2015) the studio was still working on the Witcher 3. Cyberpunk was little more than a little side-project in pre-planning at that time
I'm guessing the issue in the alley is related to Vik's shop getting loaded into memory. Since it's a pretty detailed indoor area it's probably not a part of the "open world" to save on memory. So when you turn rapidly into that alley there is probably a trigger to load those assets, but some component in the old systems simply can't handle streaming the open world and loading "indoor" assets at the same time so the system just hangs or performance tanks.
You'd probably have to drop to near 720 to get a reliable 60fps from the xbonks. Even the better clocked polaris GPU in this system can't do 1080/60 on PC.
They deserve the hate tbh. There is only so high and so much your company can be praised u till you fuck up, bad. Even if it happened with a totally new game for them I am happy. They deserve the hate both the devs and the executives but I don't wish them any harm like other apes on the Internet have done. Let's hope they manage to not fix but at least help the situation.
CDPR really should've saved face and cancelled the XOne/PS4 versions of the game. Either that or delayed it till next year and just release the PC version.
@@Channel9iNE Not necessarily. I'm finding the game incredibly enjoyable on XB1X, even with all the crashes that I had on day one until the second patch came out (still crashes occasionally, but much more rarely now). Games in this genre that nail the aesthetic are so rare that even with the technical issues it's one of my favorite games in recent memory.
If the base PS4 can run game like The Last of Us Part 2, Red Dead Redemption 2, Ghost of Tsushima at a stable 1080p30fps, all of which have really gorgeous graphics, CDPR really don't have any excuse for their game running at 720p20fps on base PS4.
Cdpr make games for high end pc's and scales them down for consoles, that's the reason why. It still doesn't excuse the state of the game, but there you go...
cdpr CEO said that the game is running surprisingly well on current gen, they knew that the game is too demanding for the systems but decided to lie and promote as if there was nothing wrong to get those precious current gen preorders, shame on them
FYI ‘current gen’ is PS5 and Xbox Series (plus Switch). PS4 and Xbox One (plus Wii U) are now last gen. Now that PS3, 360 and Wii are 2 generations back they’re now retro consoles. Glad to clear things up.
Its a shoddy release, the game is not launch ready, all defense of CDPR has to stop - both base consoles are running other openworld games with more going on and higher definition textures at a locked 30fps - GTA V for instance is packed with more traffic and npcs with longer draw distances, easily more demanding. A quick google search shows just as many PC gamers with i9 cpu's and 3000 series GPU's running off NVMe suffering from just as many framerate issues, hitches and glitches.
@@MrPedrogiorgi it's also a linear shooter which is one of the only pc games that are so ridiculously well optimized for compute that it can play in 8K ultra on modern hardware. This is a dumb comparison imo.
It’s painfully obvious it was developed primarily for PC, and within the last stretch they shifted focus to make it playable on consoles. Unsurprisingly, their approach failed.
Bryce F You mean to tell me a game designed for PCs being ported to last gen base model consoles did not result in an optimal gaming experience? Who would have known!
If you like the immersive sim, great level design, slowpace, political and conspiracy, deus ex is for you. While the Cyberpunk 2077 gameplay mechanics feel outdated, many things are not well thought and many issues we already known, good things is the writing, great character, the story are more personal, depressing than the commercial make its look.
Umm, I just downloaded it today on PRO. 5 Hours of playtime, 0 crashes. Visuals? Looks good. Not like PC or PS5 but...DUH. Bugs? Only two that I really noticed. One, couldnt switch camera view in my car. Two, Jackie had no guns in his hands, when he clearly shud have. FPS drops? MMM not really, i think a couple times in the car, one during a gun fight. All in all, I'm having fun, lots.
Yeah the pro version is doing well. Before the 1.04 patch I was getting a couple of frame drops here and there but now it's almost a solid 30 with some nice visuals. Wish I could say the same about the base consoles though
@MrLeonthepro They never said that nobody else was having problems, just that they hadn't seen many themselves. Giving their experience just like those who have seen many problems. That said, I believe OP has a very high tolerance for low framerates or just doesn't perceive drops very well because I'm getting lots of them. It feels very much like a ps360 era game in terms of framerate. Lots of bugs too. Janky animations, things falling through the world, many NPCs holding invisible objects etc etc. It's also really low res most of the time. Blurry as hell on a large 4k screen. That's my personal experience.
I feel bad for anyone playing this on a base ps4/xbox. I have been very lucky since the game has been running near perfect on ps4 pro, but this cannot be acceptable. Game companies should simply not release an unfinished game
My friend was playing on Xbox One S and said there was no problem with the framerate. I grabbed the controller and tried playing it and holy shit, it was so choppy. I guess casuals can't really notice fps issues as much as enthusiasts do.
Got my refund today. Even in my series X it plays and looks like crap. May buy next year when everything its patched and for half the price. I lost all the hype after the 3 or 4 hours I played anyways, so might as well just pass on it. Will be waiting for the Witcher 3 path for the series X
@@mikepayns9586 Exact same thing happened to me with the hype, now I feel that I can just simply wait till they actually finish their game to play it lol
The low consoles are weak sauce Developers will have to lower the res, and other graphics to increase framerate. The game is bad textures as it is. Go for the Gold 🥇 and get an upgraded console, or join the PC MasterRace 💻🌎🗿
Maybe it's just me, but I've had a very exciting and enjoyable experience on the One X. No freezing or crashing. Minor bugs, but I'm none worth griping about
Had some NPCs run across a highway, but otherwise it was shockingly good for me, esp compared to this video. Was kind of bummed, wanted the game to be a bit more broken.
They wouldn't be able to do 60fps regardless and 35-60fps is choppy as hell. The best they could do is 1080p/30fps. Or maybe even 900p/30fps if 1080p wouldn't lock to 30fps. X1X is simply not powerful enough for 60fps at all.
Something I heard is that the graphic cards on both One X and Ps4 pro can't get to their 100% potential because of lack of CPU which Cyberpunk is very heavily relying on. considering both CPU's are wack...
Really love the standardization of the Alley Shootout. Earlier the game bugged and you missed the turn and careened into civilians, now it is the only framework for true science of any kind. All hail the Alley Shootout method!
On Series X you get a locked 30FPS mode at alot higher than 1080p, with significantly more settings (like denser crowds) or a near 60 FPS at 1080p. Honestly, it runs as well as you could hope for from a 450 pound console. I'm really enjoying it so far. The Only time I've managed to make it consotantly Chug on Series X is Arasaka plaza, where there are HUGE crowds. and even then, only standing in one part of the plaza, looking in a certain direction.
Last gen consoles are still good enough, look how good games like Ghost of Tsushima, RDR2 and Death Stranding looked on last gen. In this case it's because cyberpunk was optimized so poorly, don't blame the hardware.
the police ai in this game is something else. i don't think they can actually aggro anyone but the player. Even if the terrible ai drivers run over a cop, they will get mad at you and give you a wanted level
The last gen cyberpunk version is like getting the switch port treatment from poor fps, muddy textures, to dynamic resolution. Unlike Switch though, they can't tout portability on the ps4/xbone.
@Lov Mir while there is optimization and bug patching to be done i think for the most part the consoles have just hit their physical limit, also are you ok?, you seem to have had a stroke writing that
@@adamrasmussen7379 This game was seems to have been designed to be futureproofed on PC. So, the last gen systems just cannot handle all of the detail the game throws at it. They would probably have remake it completely to make it run properly or gut it to the point where it is no longer the same game.
@@adamrasmussen7379 i think there is **some** optimization that can be done to make things perform better than low 20 fps (and mid-low10s) but overall the consoles have just reached their limit, there were games that were hitting that 30fps mark long ago and this is just beyond what these consoles can reasonably handle. running 2020s most demanding game on $300 7 year old hardware just isn't gonna reasonably happen no matter how much optimization goes into it. even though some games look really pretty good even for running that hardware what i think differentiates cyberpunk is for one thing the amount of detail in the world but mainly that there are just so so many lights, for the most part GPUs are just machines that calculate light, the more lights you have the more taxing it is
@@ErlantzOnigaOuro stadia is literally a pc running linux using a vulkan renderer, even if it's not exactly the pc version it's very close, I don't know if that one supports raytracing though, the geforce now version for sure
PS5 is using the BC+ mode with preset profiles operating in PS4 Pro compatibility tier; the "+" part is the backwards compatibility flag that removes the 30fps cap and inserts an unlocked refresh towards 60hz target. You will need to re-download pretty much the entire game package next year when the native PS5 version arrives. It's a delta code path -- it's NOT a patched up extension of the current BC+ version on PS5. So what you see now on PS5 (and Series X) is basically a placeholder backwards compatible PS4 Pro version (and One X on Series X) with minor tweaks to compatibility flags. Dynamic elements of the engine can benefit from the BC+ extensions in terms of harnessing superior clocks -- but those aren't optimal frequency profiles, they can't employ specific next-gen GPU features, they aren't parceling out full PS5 memory, and the excellent SSD/IO is strictly providing 'passive' perks based on raw sequ. speeds -- but doesn't use any of the specialized IO co-processors or unique caching. There's much to exploit in the proper PS5/Series X versions coming next year. The backwards compatible versions you see now will be disappearing when the native code arrives.
So in short for people who want a TLDR : Xbox One X / PS4 Pro is the bare minimum needed for a fair playing experience, base consoles are total no-goes.
And even those occasionaly drop below 20 fps. A competent PC or the newest gen consoles would be the only viable options for me. If I wouldn't have had ons of those at this moment, I would wait for them either to fix it, or till I've bought a new console/competent pc
@@ThatSuckzz i feel gamers today expect so much from companies. Back in the 0s2 days no one really cared about frames per second. It wasnt ever a thing that was talked about. I feel this game runs great on my ps4 pro, my only problem is the draw distance for some of the items but i hope some updates fix this.
@@jeffminn5251 If you feel it runs good enough, that's good for you! Personally I'm a pc gamer and on a monitor I can't really play comfortably below 50/60 fps. For consoles on a tv, that's a minimum of 30 fps for me. But as you say, it's different for everyone. The above is my personal opinion
but it looks like Control and there are no NPCs, not mentioning that the gun shooting feels floaty and there are no upgrades worthwhile, it's always about the highest DPS possible.
@@Thai101full what does Control have to do with this? There are plenty of NPCs in the One X, gun shooting is fine, guns have that oomph & actually feels like you're damaging the enemies, no worthwhile upgrades? Really? Because the stealth, netrunning, combat perks have significantly improved the experience & not really, so far, I'm sticking with only 1 handgun I got from Yorinobu penthouse, been upgrading it, haven't switch to any other handguns so no it's not always about highest dps.
@@CommodoreMudkip I dunno about that, but I will say, there's SIGNIFICANT frame rate drops on my One X. It's disgraceful, I'm talking like 15 FPS, that's atrocious.
@@noahstevens1886 Crashes can be fixed. I'm talking about hardware issues like bricking, coil whine, artifacting, storage issues... I don't have one but I'd wait until a slim version in 2 years because all the games are gonna be cross-gen (according to Jim Ryan). That's my viewpoint btw.
its actually very decent on ps5. obviously the next version will have more benefits. but ps4 version runs good on ps5.. 60fps and a decently sharp resolution considering its the ps4 version
@@dec3142 Right? This is definitely one of those games you will appreciate more by waiting on the "GOTY" or Complete Edition. I have a feeling that after a year or so it will be a completely different experience. Probably do a relaunch next year too, once the "next gen" patches are ready for the ps5 and s/x.
Just wait for the PS5 version when it comes out. It's not worth it to go through all this shit when the game still has serious issues in all Platforms including PC. By then they would release a lot of patches of improvement and you'll have a next gen experience.
9:33 "You want 60 frames per second? How about 60 seconds per frame?"
haha underrated gem of a comment!
Only on Xbox "Dynamic auto-photo mode"
Underrated comment, made me laugh out loud
Nice to see it pushing 60SPF
🤣
Frames: *"where we droppin?"*
this was good
Dropping fast.
Most other frames:"yes"
Finally , an original joke
@@XZ-III no. Maybe I don’t spend enough time on this site reading comments.
Base Xbox one: “just kill me already”
🤣
lol, now i kind of feel bad.
End my suffering.
Hahahaha
Lol put that console out of its misery
Johnny Silverhand: We have a city to burn!
The city: doesn't load
🤣🤣
Flame textures to come in upcoming patch in February.
The city already burned itself.
"Welcome to Bug City!"
we've got an xbox to burn
They should have dropped resolution to 360p with VHS post-effect for a true cyberpunk experience on base consoles.
Genius!
Fine idea! John Linneman would have a ball playing it on his CRT TV. :)
Let's be generous , say 480p
480 upscale to 720p lol
It's not the resolutions or graphics detail or the consoles it's the developers. This game doesn't look nextgen at all even on high end pcs. Arkham knight looks better and runs smoothly on a PS4 red dead 2 runs smoothly on a ps4, this game is stuttering and loosing frame rates even when the scenes are full of low res textures and geometry similar to ps2 ,This shows it's not the consoles problem it's the developers bad engineering.
This game makes me appreciate 30fps.
30fps is the new 60! lol
A stable 30fps is always appreciated. I tried playing Jedi Fallen Order with a dynamic frame rate and was all over the place. Then swapped to lock 30fps with dynamic 4K and yeah controller response was way better. Horizon and Spider-Man all felt excellent at a lock 30.
People with mid range or old hardware should definitely consider playing at 30 and cranking settings/resolution up instead of trying in vain to hold 60 despite your game looking like a vaseline smudge.
This game is gorgeous and it NEEDS a high resolution to shine, the effects scale like shit with lower resolutions... so yeah, I recommend 30 FPS to most people that don't have 2080 Tis/3070 and up.
@@SilverInterpolFire Let's hope VRR sees wide support soon. That should make dynamic framerates way nicer
When they said "Cinematic" no one thought they meant fps too.
The horrible launch of cyberpunk really gives digital foundry a time to shine. The most important gaming channel on TH-cam
modern vintage gamer, review tech USA to name a few.
@@michaelhart5087 review tech usa just click baits and makes any video on literally any topic possible
😏 mhm
Rich tomorrow
Deadass. I always wanna see that little performance bar before I buy PS4 games.
The Xbox One quality is what the real world looks like to me without my glasses on.
Not horrible, but not good, either.
I know I shouldn't be laughing, but I just couldn't help myself when he said it froze for 1 minute and the timer came up.
Same
1 frame per minute type beat
@@jaysanchez4407 Or 60 seconds per Frame
The Pro and X should’ve just locked to 1080p to remain consistent.
yeah. im on one x. it looks crisp but framerate stutters. i'd be fine with 1080 locked.
They forget to mention npc count is also higher on the x than ps4. The slowdowns are for higher res and more detail
Disabling some graphical settings improves the frame rate a lot. And I would rather have the same dynamic resolution but have the lower limit set at 1080p instead.
@@farisakhtar4824 dynamic resolution is great for balancing performance and quality until you’re rendering scenes at noticeably different resolutions. I personally find it much better if it’s less noticeable. They should keep the top and bottom within a certain degree. Maybe they should’ve at least used the PS4 Pro’s res target. It would have looked about the same, but I’m sure it would’ve been an almost perfect 30.
@@traceyates1506 its already noticeable when you're driving and in dense crowds. You don't drop from 1674p to 1224p without noticing. And anyway 1080p is not a bad resolution, at least not to me. It wasn't too long ago games were in 720p and looked good for their time. Frame rate over resolution so it can at least remain above 25fps.
This game is a godsend for Digital Foundry, they can analyze this game for the next few months :D
Yeah. Just wait until the Next Gen upgrades are out.
Shame they wouldn't talk about it when they should have. They are part of the problem now.
@@andrewsqual CDPR did not give them pre-release copies for consoles, they were only allowed to talk about the PC version. It's the developer who deliberately hid it from us. I don't see it being the reviewer's fault.
+TheCivildecay I was sitting there thinking, I hope they do 2 videos for each patch.
If you are still playing on the base Xbox one you seriously need to invest some money, like how is that possible the base Xbox one should be obsolete by now .
Games like this are why we need demos
@Source Dasher bro calm down. If you actually had a pc, you'd know it's a shitshow on there too. How do I know? Because I have it on a high end rig and it still is ass because of the amd cpu issue.
That being said, I'm pretty sure the xbox is based on amd tech, so maybe there is some kind of cpu issue for the xbox too.
@Mr. Firestone * COD might be shit now, but at the very least they let you playa beta. Hell, even the infamous EA allows trials and demos for the public.
@@pzdizzle I feel like the people with really high pc builds or decent pc builds don't go around saying stuff like "buy a pc"if you know the price of a decent rig which a lot of people can't afford but fr fr i think you just have a ass graphics card my 1070 runs this on 50 to 60 butttt this game is still a mess with the bugs etc...
^^^ for the dumbasses above, he was only talking to the guy calling him a pleb. Your opinions about whether or not he had a high end PC weren't really needed
@@pzdizzle cod isn't at its worst now lol I haven't played since ghost played 1 hour of it when it came out on ps3/transition to ps4 came back to modernwarfare/warzone and its obv the best of any not counting nostalgia factors
Go back to sleep Samurai, the city hasn't rendered yet.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I wonder how many people stole this comment before you
@@alexradice8163 ok, but i liked it. HAVE A NICE DAY SIR😄
Hahahahahahhahaa
Overusee comment
That apology was probably drafted in a board room about a month ago.
just in case people get upset
hah! totally dude
They probably have a server dedicated to holding their 'backup' apologies and promises. Along with a schedule, and automated system to release specific ones in case of certain events happening. Taking a page from the BP playbook. "Uh oh, another oil spill, get the apology commercials queued up"
So true. Let it be lesson for all poor naive souls to never buy games at launch.
The apology was made at the same time they said "it run on old console pretty good to their investors"
It’s painfully obvious that they didn’t allow console reviews to hide this so as many people can buy the broken console versions as possible.
It's pretty disgusting.
They are now accepting refund requests though. So its a come around. Thank god. Otherwise people would have definitely lost all trust. Even the PC requirements are not accurate. The recommended system which i have barely gives over 40 even on low-med preset.
I doubt 100% of people who are unhappy with their console versions will get a refund though. CDPR will probably make more profit this way than if they had warned everybody beforehand in a fair way.
@@stuporman it doesn't run any better, the console renders at a certain resolution and then downscales or upscales depending on the TV/monitor resolution
It’s also possible that they were confident that the day 1 patch would fix all of these problems and they didn’t want to show off the game without the patch (clearly it did not fix the issues.) As a consumer you should wait until the day of release to make your decision to buy the game. I don’t understand why people pre order games. But if you are one of those people that wanted to play it at midnight on release day, you can always get a refund.
Pfft, N64 Goldeneye players will be right at home here.
LOL I was gonna say... Looks like it runs better than Conker's Bad Fur Day?
That was a great game, i will buy
N64 "007 Goldeneye" what a legendary game!! 👍
Jailbreak your xb360 and run the leaked xlba goldeneye then
I’ve already prepared myself to watch 10 Digital Foundry videos on Cyberpunk 2077 for the week , keep em coning 🍿.
🤣🤣🤣🤣 yep extra butter 🍿🧈
Hope you guys continue covering Cyberpunk. Would love to follow the patches and comparisons as they go.
When Richard said "1 minute!?" I nearly fell off my chair laughing.
same loool
I was expecting to see/hear a crash... Not locking up for a minute. Since the game is so breathtaking guess the CPU took a break to catch his breath 🤣
That’s loading time. Shit game was loading at that moment.
Some of that timer was cut and also running while the guide was up, so not a solid minute but still really bad.
lol
"Xbox One the weakest of all"
Xbox Series X: Oh how the turnables
Ehh I think they deliberately went for a toss-up on that one. It's like being able to switch between graphics and presentation mode in God of War. One looks better, but the other plays better.
How does the Xbox one X, being the most capable last gen console, make the xbox one any better?
@@Doganderboss I've had a few friends play on Xbox One X, and they can run at 30 FPS, but you might have a different experience and run like total shit.
That doesn't remove the shit show of last gen form both Sony and MS. Last gen was a total disaster when it comes to hardware
@@peripateticguy55 fyi 30fps is considered total shit
In hindsight releasing this on PC first would have reduced the backlash so much.
Do a 2021 console release after the major bugs had been ironed out.
Why is the game still so unfinished? They have had atleast 5 years on full development and this game looks like they started this year...
@@schwartzy65 Apparently you don't know how game development works
That's just not true. There would have been more backlash by players who paid the same as the PC version but have to wait months to play it
They should have been transparent and tell us the performance is shit, but that it's the players choice whether they want to wait or play it at abysmal performance. Not a perfect compromise but better than making console players weave around social media for months avoiding spoilers
@@schwartzy65 Got too ambitious most likely. Then they forgot the CPU in the ps4 and Xbox are a portable one that was outdated in 2013. This game is one of the hardest ive seen on PC CPU power.
@@schwartzy65 like clownavenger said,they got too ambitious.If you see e3 vs retail,retail version is better.After doing all the improvementes,then they went to do the last gen console ports and were like "oh fck what have we done"
Sounds like they should’ve limited the One X’s resolution to 1440p and just let it hit a consistent 30fps.
My thoughts exactly. Also lower res for base consoles down to 720p. I will never understand the fixation deva have with resolution to the point of thinking 1800p 20fps is better than 1440p 30fps.
Almost everywhere you see a 20-ish fps experience the CPU is the problem, no point in going lower res, only CDPR can do something...
The thing is they’re not GPU limited per se. They’re CPU limited with how the game handle crowd, asset streaming, etc. In my opinion, the only way they can fix this is by increasing (I mean by huge amount) of asset duplication which can ease a little bit the bottleneck created by 5400rpm HDD. Of course this will result in a substantial increase of a game file size (we are talking COD like size here or even bigger). This is one of the problems when you make the games with an SSD-optimised in mind.
And to further ease the streaming system especially while driving fast within these high density city they need to at least double the amount of LODs per object which is also going to substantially increase the game file size which can ease both CPU decompression time and system RAM (GDDR).
All of these extra resource can be use to handle at least an acceptable amount of crowd present on a per scene basis. If you look at this game the crowd are very dynamic on their own which means this will hurt this weak CPU logic a lot. The way to solve this is to make the dumb-crowd system like in the early 2010-ish style games, where different NPCs move in pack with a noticeable sync-move set if that make sense. And makes only few of them move dynamically (AI like).
@@soraaoixxthebluesky If they have to increase the game size to make it playable, just do it.
The game have near 50GB, even if they increased it 3 time, to something like 150GB but making the whole experience beter, i don't see any problem in that(The problem will be that the game will use way more space on the next gen machines until the proper next gen update arrives).
RDR2 have more than 100GB and it's not as beautifull on the base machines as it is on the Pro/X, but it is really playable, anyone would sacrifice Storage in benefit of a playable game.
That would make frame rate worse, the game already drops way below 1440p on One X when it struggles.
Looks like cdprojekt was afraid of a "downgrade" scandal, so they just decided to let the game run like shit
The game looks like shit, so they missed the mark on that one also.
@@michaellitten4538 Looks pretty damn good to me bud have you played it?
@@michaellitten4538 He's talking about E3 trailer vs Retail, go watch Nick930s comparison video, Cyberpunk 2077 is one of the few games where the final game looks better than the trailers, although its the PC version
@@XxSprayMilkxX It goes to sub 720p on last gen consoles on top of various visual downgrades compared to the PC and PS5 running emulation. So yes it does look like shit on last gen consoles.
this is basically maximum of what all consoles can do, don't expect to see anything better on them.
As a mid level pc player who has been getting solid performance with tweaks, this puts into perspective the outrage and the unfortunate state of many players.
People keep on bitching at me about how the version I'm playing (PS4 on the Pro) is not much better than the base console version when it usually goes between 25-30fps and rarely hits lower than what the guys in the video get. I just am like '. . . Fuck! What the hell, man! At least the version I'm playing is STABLE and runs decently well with fewer issues than the base console version!' Saying that the Pro/X1X/S is not much better than the PS4/X1when it comes to being able to play Cyberpunk is like saying The Dark Knight is not much better than Batman Begins or that Revenge of the Sith isn't much better than the rest of the Star Wars prequels.
@@tcrpgfan Instead of Sony offering money back for Cyberpunk buyers they should have offered money back for last gen consoles. Both Xbox and SOny failed to deliver last gen, what a total shit show.
They really went with the Into the Spiderverse framerate
LOL
haha
Every time one of these comparison vids is posted I'm reminded of how Microsoft needs to overhaul their console naming strategy.
It gets worse every time they announce a new console.
@@vjbd2757 Xbox already sounded like a risqué X-rated games console from some dingy shop in the 80's.
Xbox Alpha and Xbox Omega would have sufficed.
@Classy Ducks and scorpio
Like ps 1,2,3,4 blah blah
So the free DLC is actually this early acces game getting finished
Cyberpunk 2077 will most likely be handled exactly like The Witcher 3, which also had a buggy release. CD Projekt Red went on to fix the bugs and even implement some new features (includnig a secondary combat/movement/animation system), while also releasing plenty of free dlc both cosmetic and substantial, such as a couple short single-player quests and a very well implemented New Game Plus mode. Finally, they went on to develop and release two major expansions, and by the time they were done, everyone had forgotten about the buggy release and the Witcher 3 stood tall as one of the greatest games ever...
@@paoloadam "greates games ever"
waifu baiting
ubisoft like openworld with thousands of bandit camps, but devoid of anything meaningful, like Skyrim oder Assassins Creed
consolefied controls
boring combat
definitely not one of the best games ever
@@Keckegenkai The story and lore is insane and very immersive and the graphics still hold up today, and were amazing when the game first came out.
@@Keckegenkai assassin's creed? 🤣🤣🤣
@@Keckegenkai Waifu baiting in Witcher 3. Are you high lmao
Finally got myself physical copy of Cyberpunk on PS4 Pro. I wanted to see 1.0 version and if it's really that bad. And it was indeed. Buggy as hell with messy graphics. I patched the game and really have to say that I'm quite impressed. Totally different game. Even the framerate feels stable now. Didn't expect that but I'm really enjoying the game.
Same, I saw the Xbox One version at GameStop for 10 bucks and was like "yeah this is worth it to laugh at the unpatched version."
Imagine being a casual type of gamer who doesn’t visit gaming websites, doesn’t watch video game TH-cam content, and you just decided to pick this game up because you thought the marketing was awesome, or you heard about the hype randomly from someone at work.
That’s who I feel for. This is indefensible. Shame on CD Projekt Red. What a way to ruin your reputation.
They should definitely notify them in game about the reimbursement process if they so want to
I have a friend like that and he says the game is great on base ps4, these ppl are mostly clueless.
Even if people did pay attention and followed the news closely.. if they pre ordered or bought it early on, there was no footage of last gen consoles at all.
@@lunator100hd I’m honestly jealous of people like that. Ignorance is bliss.
I talked to one of them.
He played on a base Xbox and was super happy, raved about how great the story is and how he was having a fantastic time. I asked him about glitches and bugs, and he said it was the same way with RDR2 so he figured it'd be fixed with updates and wasn't concerned.
I was surprised, a very different response to what I expected, and on top of it he was playing on the worst system.
"Bit of disappointing..." Love the british understatement. Leadbetter was one of my fav writer/editor back in the Amiga days. Was an avid reader of UK Amiga mags.
I also like his accent. He doesn't speak a posh RP accent which I have no problem with due to my being Chinese, but he sounds well spoken and very clear.
Wasn't he with the PSW magazine too? It was the funniest mag on the market at the time
His work on official Sega Saturn Magazine is the stuff of legend. What a guy.
@@friedrichnietzsche7736
I just remember him from c&vg and mainly mean machines. Who read saturn magazine, the machine was an okay import machine but otherwise PS1 all the way.
@@friedrichnietzsche7736 I remember Gary Cutlack working for PSW who was a Sega afficiando who lamented their sad demise. Just like to point out Friedrich that I've read and enjoyed most of your books. Good to see you've reanimated yourself!!!
IDK why people preorder, when you can always purchase on the launch day by seeing how it is working. It's not like there are limited copies.
Copies are not limited. People's ability to use their brain - are :-)
@@igorthelight True
@@igorthelight Well said
If it's a singleplayer game, I can wait even longer and wait for a sale, DLC, and patches. Not like there's a multiplayer community I'm missing out on.
I think it’s so they can pre download the game ready, to save waiting on launch day
cdpr: "release on every device, dynamic resolution will take care of everything!"
Microsoft: “Release it on every console.”
CDPR: “But last month you said...”
Microsoft: “...release it on every console.”
Studio Wildcard: Hold my Vincent Van Gogh work.
@King Dingeling lmao okay
The best part of cyberpunk is being able to drive the Quadra in Forza4.
Its the best version of that car on consoles, lol.
That car will blow the doors off of most of the S1 class cars in Forza Horizon 4... I was very surprised. I'm glad I beat it in the head to head so that I can really take advantage of it in future races.
@@jackoski__19 It is probably the best version in term of gameplay/driving experience across the board lol.
@@jamesrouse3466 Well considering it was manufactured in the year 2058....
;)
@@jamesrouse3466 is It still available?
It’s actually impressive, runs locked at 20fps!!
Yeah but sadly it’s only when you turn of all the visuals.
with occasional drops to 1fpm
Actually it doesn't even manage to hold stable 20fps.
"Rock Solid 20fps"
@@mousearmy LOL! Who knew we'd ever have to talk about freaking FPM's? 2020... 😂
Digital foundry feels like the absolute authority on all things performance on youtube. Love their content.
@T Boogie Lmao not really.All their Pc videos are pretty good enough,maybe not the best but still good
Even though I have a One X I feel like the resolution should have been locked at 1080 to help with frame drops during gunfights and exploration in the city. The hotfix helped a lot with frame drops and crashes but I feel like they can do more
Bro *Xbox One X Can handle *1440p with locked 30 fps In cyberpunk 2077 that Will be great!!!!!!
@@nemodemolishedgamer7440 with the recent update, cyberpunk on the one x can handle just under 60 fps at 1440p
@@xKillZone99 It's not 1440p It's near 1440p. (1224p-1338p)😅😅😅😅😅😅
@@xKillZone99 lol cyberpunk on the one x will run nowhere near 60fps. The cpu cannot handle rendering the city at 60fps.
I just wish they had the option to choose, they did with Witcher 3 on the One X console...
"Seize the consoles and set them on fire!" -- CyberPunk 20FPS
Wake up samurai, we have a console to burn.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
“Wake up Samurai, We got frame-rates to drop.”
Wake up samurai we have some consoles to crash
Honestly my experience on ps4 pro has been pretty good so far other than the occasional crashes
@shad yea once I get out of college gonna create a gaming pc
Never seen someone try to hard to not say "unplayable"
Microsoft shill, what do you expect?
I played worse but with a 3090 and Rizen 950 in 8k it would be the same but maxed out... I would play it in 8k.
@@kresimircosic9035 PSP was so bad with games being slide shows at points... : ikeAcecombat X the game was a slide show at a few points but it made the cannon run at the end a lot easier in fact,.
Deadly Premonition 2
@@kresimircosic9035 Found the shill.
I guess that studio that did the witcher 3 port for the Switch might be of use here.
9:35 one minute freezing, is quite simply unforgivable. CDPR really deserve the backlash they got.
100% deserved.
Forza Horizon 3 players on PC: First time?
like AC odyssey?
I'm starting to feel that the Xbox One cannot be fully optimised for this game. I was hopeful before as I know miracles can happen with games being ported. Witcher 3 on switch looks phenomenal now, nobody ever expected that.
@Pixel Domination says the kid
Ah, yes. The Famous Steampunk 1877
Steampunk 1877 coming on your 8k TVs now!!!... at a stunningly smooth 4fps.
This ad was approved by Powepoint
I haven't laughed that hard in a while
Your work is always appreciated, however, it’s appreciated NOW, MORE THAN EVER!
Everytime Rich says "Most powerful Console" take a shot
Stop im drunk already
This was all just CD Projekt Red's attempt to honor the release of Ocarina of Time. By matching the framerate!
Or deadly premonition
Remember when you thought 30fps was bad?🤣🤣🤣
No, but I remember when 20-25fps in GTA 5, PS3 was seen as great.
I enjoyed farcry 3 at 24 fps on my old xbox 360 , its just babies crying
@@dudeletsplay4792 People like us that could never afford super expensive PC parts until later in life, are usually pretty happy with anything over 40fps haha.
@@licensetoshred Those babies couldn't understand that 30fps is roughly where you want it to be if you want to have a stable game in a big world.
@@ZarkowsWorld I mean it still is, it's very impressive that the game could run on that kind of hardware.
Cyberpunk Beta testing: Dec 2020 - June 2021. Register your interest.
"send us 60$ to test it"
I really hope the devs made a real NPC AI system and a real vehicle AI system, but they just commented them out and made placeholders because they ran out of time.
@@SnrubSource when you develop a game for 8 years and still run out of time
@@iskamag Keep in mind, the first 3 years (until late 2015) the studio was still working on the Witcher 3. Cyberpunk was little more than a little side-project in pre-planning at that time
I'm guessing the issue in the alley is related to Vik's shop getting loaded into memory. Since it's a pretty detailed indoor area it's probably not a part of the "open world" to save on memory. So when you turn rapidly into that alley there is probably a trigger to load those assets, but some component in the old systems simply can't handle streaming the open world and loading "indoor" assets at the same time so the system just hangs or performance tanks.
They really thought they could release Cyberpunk 57 years earlier and wouldn't experience a stroke fest
😂
9:20 I guess we can start calling that alley "Tom's infamous alley of DOOM"
Cheers for doing these videos guys, many of us look to you as an authoritative voice on this!
I'll take a 900p/1080p 60fps option on the One X
Old weak CPU can't render so many frames
You'd probably have to drop to near 720 to get a reliable 60fps from the xbonks. Even the better clocked polaris GPU in this system can't do 1080/60 on PC.
Bethesda: We know you love the performance in the Corvega Factory.
CDPR: Here's a game that's nothing but that.
Bethesda is super happy with the console performance of Cyberpunk 2077...... Oh wai....
CDPR should've been more transparent about the console performance.
They didn’t because people would have cancelled their pre orders and they wanted to grab their money before it came out how bad the game runs.
@@davidclixby5840 Yeah but expected more out of them. Now people are losing faith which is more valuable than pre-order money.
In my opinion this is their only real fault at the moment. If they were transparent, it would look a lot better from gamers perspective.
@@Eihei Totally Agreed
They deserve the hate tbh. There is only so high and so much your company can be praised u till you fuck up, bad. Even if it happened with a totally new game for them I am happy. They deserve the hate both the devs and the executives but I don't wish them any harm like other apes on the Internet have done. Let's hope they manage to not fix but at least help the situation.
CDPR really should've saved face and cancelled the XOne/PS4 versions of the game.
Either that or delayed it till next year and just release the PC version.
Money money money
I would've been very salty if they did that
It's impossible to do so, due to contract with MS and Sony to not break the platform base.
@@alexradice8163 bruh your probably still gonna be salty over the games issues
@@Channel9iNE
Not necessarily. I'm finding the game incredibly enjoyable on XB1X, even with all the crashes that I had on day one until the second patch came out (still crashes occasionally, but much more rarely now).
Games in this genre that nail the aesthetic are so rare that even with the technical issues it's one of my favorite games in recent memory.
If the base PS4 can run game like The Last of Us Part 2, Red Dead Redemption 2, Ghost of Tsushima at a stable 1080p30fps, all of which have really gorgeous graphics, CDPR really don't have any excuse for their game running at 720p20fps on base PS4.
Cdpr make games for high end pc's and scales them down for consoles, that's the reason why. It still doesn't excuse the state of the game, but there you go...
@@peters.9371 Yeah, but the game is also just bad. Bad AI, driving, world events, etc.
luckily i bought tlou2 in december 2020
cdpr CEO said that the game is running surprisingly well on current gen, they knew that the game is too demanding for the systems but decided to lie and promote as if there was nothing wrong to get those precious current gen preorders, shame on them
FYI ‘current gen’ is PS5 and Xbox Series (plus Switch). PS4 and Xbox One (plus Wii U) are now last gen. Now that PS3, 360 and Wii are 2 generations back they’re now retro consoles.
Glad to clear things up.
It is running surprisingly well 👀, this was that "well" :P
Its a shoddy release, the game is not launch ready, all defense of CDPR has to stop - both base consoles are running other openworld games with more going on and higher definition textures at a locked 30fps - GTA V for instance is packed with more traffic and npcs with longer draw distances, easily more demanding.
A quick google search shows just as many PC gamers with i9 cpu's and 3000 series GPU's running off NVMe suffering from just as many framerate issues, hitches and glitches.
I think he meant one x and pro versions, technically current gen when he said it
@@XgamerdaveX they said that before current gen was even announced, FYI
They should've had Panic Button handle the last gen versions.
Good shout, considering their work with Switch ports of the DOOM games and Wolfenstein II.
@@JuiKuen yea the games that run at sub hd and lower than the lowest pc settings lol.
@@theanimerapper6351 but they actually work, with stable 30 fps, as opposed to Cyberpunk
@@MrPedrogiorgi it's also a linear shooter which is one of the only pc games that are so ridiculously well optimized for compute that it can play in 8K ultra on modern hardware. This is a dumb comparison imo.
@@fVNzO Open-ended linear shooter mind you.
PS360 Shadow of Mordor: "First time?"
Wtf ps360?
Y guess he means PS/360
@@AlbelSkeith I think he means PS3/360. you know 3 is common number so it just got sliced
@@laughingstar3945 Portmanteau of PS3 and Xbox 360 which people used to call the last gen consoles.
Switch time
I love the cyberpunk 2077 videos from digital foundry keep them coming !!!
1:53 the game is so realistic that even the framerate is groovin in the disco
It looks like one of those triple A titles they try and port to the Switch
Exactly my first thought playing it on PS4 Pro. Damn it looks like blurry low res Switch port.
It’s like a game that was made more for a upcoming ps6 and yet they ported it to a old ps4
When you have to start measuring in Frames Per Minute.
Switch port will be in frames per hour
I want a smooth 3600 Frames per minute
... best I can do is 1, take it or leave it
@@nekroneko If its got Keanu, take my money!!!
It feels like this game was made with SSD in mind.
It’s painfully obvious it was developed primarily for PC, and within the last stretch they shifted focus to make it playable on consoles. Unsurprisingly, their approach failed.
Bryce F plays fine on my PS5
@@pyroghost876 shocker, your PS5 has an SSD
Bryce F You mean to tell me a game designed for PCs being ported to last gen base model consoles did not result in an optimal gaming experience? Who would have known!
@@pyroghost876 I’ve said repeatedly the last gen versions of the game should’ve been cut. So I’m not sure what point you’re trying to make.
"Can Any Last-Gen Console Cut It?"
Spoiler Alert: No
Except this is old information, 1.04 has been out for a while now.
@@tzukishiro It makes little to no difference tbh. We'll need to wait till the major patches in January & February.
I can live with Pro's performance. Wouldn't call it particularly good tho.
@@maranakurippu Actually the PS4 version is running a lot better with the latest patch.
The real question should have been
"can these dev's cut it?"
Spoiler: Obviously not
hey anyone know when theyre gunna port this to the 3ds
2 weeks after the DS Lite version.
text adventure version maybe
That shit would blow up
You can just emulate the pc version on gbc
They mistakenly uploaded the 3Ds version on the ps4 and xbox one that's why it runs and looks like that.
I’d love to see Stadia vs GeForce NOW. Here’s hoping.
Bloody hell!! That transition action shot between PS4 into PS5 in the intro was absolutely insane!!
People could go pick up and play through the entirety of Deus Ex Mankind Divided by the time a texture loads in CP2077
Deus Ex is cursed for all eternity to being the superior cyberpunk experience.
U guys take shit talking to a new level i see
Exactly the game I bought instead of Cyberpunk 2077 this month. Cheers!
Deus Ex>Cloudpunk>Cyberpunk
If you like the immersive sim, great level design, slowpace, political and conspiracy, deus ex is for you.
While the Cyberpunk 2077 gameplay mechanics feel outdated, many things are not well thought and many issues we already known, good things is the writing, great character, the story are more personal, depressing than the commercial make its look.
Umm, I just downloaded it today on PRO. 5 Hours of playtime, 0 crashes. Visuals? Looks good. Not like PC or PS5 but...DUH. Bugs? Only two that I really noticed. One, couldnt switch camera view in my car. Two, Jackie had no guns in his hands, when he clearly shud have.
FPS drops? MMM not really, i think a couple times in the car, one during a gun fight. All in all, I'm having fun, lots.
Yeah the pro version is doing well. Before the 1.04 patch I was getting a couple of frame drops here and there but now it's almost a solid 30 with some nice visuals.
Wish I could say the same about the base consoles though
@MrLeonthepro From my experience PC has been great with a 3080
So because youve had no problems. Nobody has had problems. Keep your head in the sand shill
@MrLeonthepro They never said that nobody else was having problems, just that they hadn't seen many themselves. Giving their experience just like those who have seen many problems.
That said, I believe OP has a very high tolerance for low framerates or just doesn't perceive drops very well because I'm getting lots of them. It feels very much like a ps360 era game in terms of framerate. Lots of bugs too. Janky animations, things falling through the world, many NPCs holding invisible objects etc etc. It's also really low res most of the time. Blurry as hell on a large 4k screen. That's my personal experience.
No. It’s absolute mess of a game that shouldn’t have launched on a console they couldn’t even get it playable on. No excuses.
STFU! Get your refund and never buy this game again!
@@maxchronicler Bro why you so mad?
@@maxchronicler Take your meds, quick!
@@maxchronicler thats exactly what I did. Trash release no excuses
@@elchancho8432 Hoo mad Broo
I feel bad for anyone playing this on a base ps4/xbox. I have been very lucky since the game has been running near perfect on ps4 pro, but this cannot be acceptable. Game companies should simply not release an unfinished game
My friend was playing on Xbox One S and said there was no problem with the framerate. I grabbed the controller and tried playing it and holy shit, it was so choppy. I guess casuals can't really notice fps issues as much as enthusiasts do.
Ask for a refund till December 21 if the game is broken for you.
Got my refund today. Even in my series X it plays and looks like crap. May buy next year when everything its patched and for half the price. I lost all the hype after the 3 or 4 hours I played anyways, so might as well just pass on it. Will be waiting for the Witcher 3 path for the series X
@@mikepayns9586 Exact same thing happened to me with the hype, now I feel that I can just simply wait till they actually finish their game to play it lol
I live in Brazil and they denied every single refund I asked. FUCK SONY.
The low consoles are weak sauce
Developers will have to lower the res, and other graphics to increase framerate. The game is bad textures as it is.
Go for the Gold 🥇 and get an upgraded console, or join the PC MasterRace 💻🌎🗿
@@mikepayns9586 looks amazing on series x maybe your settings? turn off everything apart for lens flare and draw distance
These Digital Foundry analysis videos have been the highlight of my days during this past week .
Ps5 missing hundreds of npcs it better run the game smoother
Npc is annoying
Idgaf anymore. Sending mine back to Amazon without even playing it. The deception from CDPR is inexcusable.
Maybe it's just me, but I've had a very exciting and enjoyable experience on the One X. No freezing or crashing. Minor bugs, but I'm none worth griping about
The same here
Same!! Playing since yesterday on my one X and so far so good
Had some NPCs run across a highway, but otherwise it was shockingly good for me, esp compared to this video. Was kind of bummed, wanted the game to be a bit more broken.
For one x they need to add a performance option. That drops the res to favor performance. Or drop the max res to 2k.
@@seanwfindley its not. Frames are though
They wouldn't be able to do 60fps regardless and 35-60fps is choppy as hell. The best they could do is 1080p/30fps. Or maybe even 900p/30fps if 1080p wouldn't lock to 30fps. X1X is simply not powerful enough for 60fps at all.
@@seanwfindley It has the highest resolution among consoles of its gen.
@@pleasuretokill 1360p30 and 720p60 :D
Something I heard is that the graphic cards on both One X and Ps4 pro can't get to their 100% potential because of lack of CPU which Cyberpunk is very heavily relying on. considering both CPU's are wack...
Really love the standardization of the Alley Shootout. Earlier the game bugged and you missed the turn and careened into civilians, now it is the only framework for true science of any kind. All hail the Alley Shootout method!
I'm so disappointed with the one x frame rate . I'd gladly take 1080p like series s with stable 30fps over higher resolution and janky fps .
On Series X you get a locked 30FPS mode at alot higher than 1080p, with significantly more settings (like denser crowds) or a near 60 FPS at 1080p. Honestly, it runs as well as you could hope for from a 450 pound console. I'm really enjoying it so far.
The Only time I've managed to make it consotantly Chug on Series X is Arasaka plaza, where there are HUGE crowds. and even then, only standing in one part of the plaza, looking in a certain direction.
They should patch it
Turn off all graphical settings apart from lens flare. Performance will increase a lot and the image will look significantly better.
@@farisakhtar4824 I did , not to mention the hdr is wacky as hell too .
@@alexlyster3459 I meant to say series s .
🤣 and my wife ask me why I want a new console for Christmas if my last one still works perfectly. Thanks 🙏 Cyberpunk for fulfilling the answer!!! 😎
Last gen consoles are still good enough, look how good games like Ghost of Tsushima, RDR2 and Death Stranding looked on last gen. In this case it's because cyberpunk was optimized so poorly, don't blame the hardware.
Absolutely 😂..Just say it's an air purifier
Polly have to wait longer heard it's not fully ”optimized” for the ps5
@@Aerith-77x I wouldn't say that for death stranding..
@@Aerith-77x death stranding is extremely easy to run. I can get 80fps at 1080p ultra on a 4 year old mid range gpu.
9:58 lol jackie just stand there in the middle of the shootings
Hes walking away hes had enough of these dam pop ins
Jackie - thats it! I have enough of these mother fucker pop ins in this mother fucker game.
the police ai in this game is something else. i don't think they can actually aggro anyone but the player. Even if the terrible ai drivers run over a cop, they will get mad at you and give you a wanted level
Thinking about his next meal, no doubt
The last gen cyberpunk version is like getting the switch port treatment from poor fps, muddy textures, to dynamic resolution. Unlike Switch though, they can't tout portability on the ps4/xbone.
*ek bok
@Lov Mir while there is optimization and bug patching to be done i think for the most part the consoles have just hit their physical limit, also are you ok?, you seem to have had a stroke writing that
You guys think this can be fixed with patches to at least look decent looking?
@@adamrasmussen7379 This game was seems to have been designed to be futureproofed on PC. So, the last gen systems just cannot handle all of the detail the game throws at it. They would probably have remake it completely to make it run properly or gut it to the point where it is no longer the same game.
@@adamrasmussen7379 i think there is **some** optimization that can be done to make things perform better than low 20 fps (and mid-low10s) but overall the consoles have just reached their limit, there were games that were hitting that 30fps mark long ago and this is just beyond what these consoles can reasonably handle. running 2020s most demanding game on $300 7 year old hardware just isn't gonna reasonably happen no matter how much optimization goes into it. even though some games look really pretty good even for running that hardware what i think differentiates cyberpunk is for one thing the amount of detail in the world but mainly that there are just so so many lights, for the most part GPUs are just machines that calculate light, the more lights you have the more taxing it is
At a time when content creators were mocking the game and ranting about it for easy clicks, DF was remaining objective and discussing facts.
End of November
"The game runs good on all platforms and has very few issues"
The game-..
DRINKING GAME: Down your drink every time one of the team says 'bespoke'
I tried that during John and Alex’s videos with ‘ray tracing’. Needless to say, I had a hangover for days after.
17:06 " Stadia version turned out pretty good"
Stadia version = PC version streamed
@@paulwilson1555 No, Stadia is not like Geforce Now, it's a different platform that requires a port. It's basically a console in the cloud.
^has no idea what he's talking about
@@ErlantzOnigaOuro so are you saying that the game is not run on PC and streamed?
@@ErlantzOnigaOuro stadia is literally a pc running linux using a vulkan renderer, even if it's not exactly the pc version it's very close, I don't know if that one supports raytracing though, the geforce now version for sure
PS5 is using the BC+ mode with preset profiles operating in PS4 Pro compatibility tier; the "+" part is the backwards compatibility flag that removes the 30fps cap and inserts an unlocked refresh towards 60hz target.
You will need to re-download pretty much the entire game package next year when the native PS5 version arrives. It's a delta code path -- it's NOT a patched up extension of the current BC+ version on PS5.
So what you see now on PS5 (and Series X) is basically a placeholder backwards compatible PS4 Pro version (and One X on Series X) with minor tweaks to compatibility flags.
Dynamic elements of the engine can benefit from the BC+ extensions in terms of harnessing superior clocks -- but those aren't optimal frequency profiles, they can't employ specific next-gen GPU features, they aren't parceling out full PS5 memory, and the excellent SSD/IO is strictly providing 'passive' perks based on raw sequ. speeds -- but doesn't use any of the specialized IO co-processors or unique caching.
There's much to exploit in the proper PS5/Series X versions coming next year. The backwards compatible versions you see now will be disappearing when the native code arrives.
So in short for people who want a TLDR : Xbox One X / PS4 Pro is the bare minimum needed for a fair playing experience, base consoles are total no-goes.
And even those occasionaly drop below 20 fps. A competent PC or the newest gen consoles would be the only viable options for me. If I wouldn't have had ons of those at this moment, I would wait for them either to fix it, or till I've bought a new console/competent pc
I've been playing it on base ps4, it's not exactly 100% smooth all the time but it's been fine for the most part.
@@ThatSuckzz i feel gamers today expect so much from companies. Back in the 0s2 days no one really cared about frames per second. It wasnt ever a thing that was talked about. I feel this game runs great on my ps4 pro, my only problem is the draw distance for some of the items but i hope some updates fix this.
@@jeffminn5251 If you feel it runs good enough, that's good for you! Personally I'm a pc gamer and on a monitor I can't really play comfortably below 50/60 fps. For consoles on a tv, that's a minimum of 30 fps for me. But as you say, it's different for everyone. The above is my personal opinion
@ArmenianPepsi I would not want it on one x or ps4 pro from what I saw here. 20FPS, and cities empty of people.
Yea it's running really well on my One X surprisingly. I have film grain and chromatic aberration off. Runs solid with very few crashes for me
but it looks like Control and there are no NPCs, not mentioning that the gun shooting feels floaty and there are no upgrades worthwhile, it's always about the highest DPS possible.
@@Thai101full what does Control have to do with this? There are plenty of NPCs in the One X, gun shooting is fine, guns have that oomph & actually feels like you're damaging the enemies, no worthwhile upgrades? Really? Because the stealth, netrunning, combat perks have significantly improved the experience & not really, so far, I'm sticking with only 1 handgun I got from Yorinobu penthouse, been upgrading it, haven't switch to any other handguns so no it's not always about highest dps.
@@Thai101full turn off aim acceleration and aim is fine
I play on ps4 pro and it is also playing good
"can they cut it" well they're certainly cutting something.
textures/shaders/shadows/ draw distance/framerate/LOD/resolution etc etc etc
Welcome to Night City. Population: loading.
Yes Rich, the Stadia version is really worth a go, can't believe I'm enjoying it more than the Xbox One X version
Me too. Stadia have hit it out of the park with this launch 👍
@Shaka Bono disgrace is harsh, the lock ups and freezes are bad but beyond that its alright.
@@CommodoreMudkip I dunno about that, but I will say, there's SIGNIFICANT frame rate drops on my One X. It's disgraceful, I'm talking like 15 FPS, that's atrocious.
@@maurodudley1338 mine drops to around 20 when driving around but on foot it's fine, I think its salvageable.
@Shaka Bono with the included controller and chromecast, google is basically paying you to buy it lol
Digital foundry made me reconsider buying the game. I'm just going to wait until I can get a PS5 before I buy the game.
Also wait for the PS5 update next year. By then a lot of the bugs will be worked out too.
I would also wait until PS5 get their shit together. We're still seeing issues...
@@Scalene_2 What issues are you having? I haven't heard about much besides occasional crashes.
@@noahstevens1886 Crashes can be fixed. I'm talking about hardware issues like bricking, coil whine, artifacting, storage issues...
I don't have one but I'd wait until a slim version in 2 years because all the games are gonna be cross-gen (according to Jim Ryan). That's my viewpoint btw.
@@Scalene_2 Meanwhile on PC: Stuff just works... (not CP, it's still buggy, but even that works much better, since you can tweak your experience).
I've stopped playin the games until the series X optimised version comes out
Smh knowing cdProjekt history of delays that might be a year from now, the game might be stale by then
Series X runs it at 60 fps, what are you talking about?
@@zokuish it doesn't look great on the series X even in quality mode, don't want to ruin it before playing how it's meant to be played.
Same here, waiting on the ps5 patch. This shit is ridiculous
having a blast on my SX though, but yeah, not the ultimate experience i recon
Can we please have some kind of tag that tells us whether or not Richard's going to be in the video? A "game of two halves" is why I'm here.
The one we've really all been waiting for
*Grabs popcorn*
Oh gawd the lame popcorn joke used by everyone on TH-cam wow
No, I wait for NX Gamer too
I think every one of their videos has comments about popcorn. Lol
@@yoyo-nf1ww NX is fantastic! I always watch all of the tech outlets and their reviews. DF, HUB, NX, etc...I need my fix!
@@aaronz4307 How'd you manage to get triggered over a popcorn joke? You just got done playing this hot garbage on base consoles perchance? 😂
This game on base console should be played on a CRT, lol
A PS3 developer was quoted saying “I kind of wish HD wasn’t a thing. At 640 x 480 we can do anything.”
@@reaktorleak89 He wasn't wrong.
I mean if not for the framerate it would most likely look phenomenal on the CRT
CRT is in many ways superior to LCD
@@shuttzi9878 Should have included a performance option to lock the game at 480i.
Might hit 60fps. Lol
I’ll be getting it on PS4 to play on PS5, but I might wait for the official PS5 version to come out before playing.
Why don't you just wait to buy it? It will probably be cheaper.
its actually very decent on ps5. obviously the next version will have more benefits. but ps4 version runs good on ps5.. 60fps and a decently sharp resolution considering its the ps4 version
@@dec3142 Right? This is definitely one of those games you will appreciate more by waiting on the "GOTY" or Complete Edition. I have a feeling that after a year or so it will be a completely different experience. Probably do a relaunch next year too, once the "next gen" patches are ready for the ps5 and s/x.
Just wait for the PS5 version when it comes out. It's not worth it to go through all this shit when the game still has serious issues in all Platforms including PC. By then they would release a lot of patches of improvement and you'll have a next gen experience.
@@dec3142 Because I’m 95% sure my girlfriend picked it up for Christmas and I’m not gonna tell her to return it.
Not really last gen when hardly anyone can buy the new generation of consoles
Yah I would love to buy a PS5 but I can’t freaking find one at MSRP. :/
@@JakeBritton94 the pro looks the same graphically as the ps5 in general, small differences
@@peenpapi4993 yeah, it’s almost like the PS5 is running the PS4 Pro version of the game.
Because console hardware is an outdated piece of garbage. Even the so-called "next gen" is still worse than a gaming PC
@Lee Sylvester I'm jealous. I wish my parents were as rich as you :/
When staying at 30fps is a miracle.
i know, right? it baffles me how 30fps is still a thing in 2020
@@JohnDoe-nf5fd 30fps isn't too bad for many games, but 60fps minimum is always the better option.