Celine is way more confident and she has done a better job at preserving her voice, she is very fluid. But let's not discredit Mariah's improvement. She still needs to be more confident cause she doesnt attempt much and she is very uncomfortable on stage.
Mariah is way more talented and more gifted vocally and artistrically than Céline. Mariah still outsing Céline even when she get nervous onstage . Confidence doesn't mean so much when your talent is basic
@@lizatsurkan4323 check Billboard and Eurochart last updates. They prove you're wrong. Céline is nowhere in these charts. She forgets what is entered a music chart since 1997
No, Taking Chances was in the charts and the reason her last album wasn’t was because of Rene’s illness - she couldn’t promote it properly. Btw the only reason Mariah is on the most streamed list is because of Christmas - her other stuff didn’t make it. Sir Elton however has 4 songs there
l was so lucky l watched both of their Asian Tour this year....l still can't believe to this day like wow both are my dream bucket list concert... They are my favorite singer of all time... but tbh celine's concert left a deeper impression because l can feel her energy and her passion on every song eventhough l watched her from faraway ...as for Mariah's her band energy was the best... Who sing the best? l personally think this video give a fine example of their performance
Let’s be honest, the people saying who is better depends on who posted the video. If this were a Mariah channel, it’d be mostly Mariah probably. They are both doing great, and shouldn’t be treated like Pokémon cards haha. Celine is my favorite in this tho :)
ChrisTheAppleOne I have high respect of celine as she earned her rightful place in the music industry without chart maniplation and kept her integrity in the lat 4 solid decades.
Two of the GREATEST and most respected female vocalist ever, both queens and perfect on their own style and both... LIVING LEGENDS, but if you want me to choose, I will go all the way for Céline!! 🤗😊😍❤️❤️❤️
Mariah >>>> Celine in terms of studio output for their most recent projects Celine >> Mariah in terms of consistency of LIVE vocals recently Mariah >>> Celine in terms of tone especially if you look at MCS Christmas concert ( this ones purely my opinion ) Celine currently for me doesn’t sound like the better singer. They are both too different to compare. However Celine has been waaayyyy more consistent imo. In saying that Mariah has been finally giving me some quality singing this year and I’m so proud. Both legends only love and support for both.
Irishrugbyfan 03 Celine has not lipped longer than Mariah that’s bullshit. If you ask me they both have lipped there fair share of times. Celine has been singing since the age of 5 or 6. Celine also has taken better care of her instrument as well.
@@joshbonner9409 Mariah choose to keep her out of nodules surgery because its very risky. She could have the the chance to lost completely her voice. That why she have to live and sing with the nodules. But she is still relevant and powerfully consistent with her singing.
Wow, my request came quick! It's like an early Christmas gift lol! Okay, I'll say this. Mariah definitely gets her props from me. She sounds great. These last few months have been some of the best vocal moments that she's had in a while and she looks to be actually having fun! I think she's finally found her groove. Now with that being said, Celine absolutely demolished Mimi here lol. With all due respect though, I knew that she would. Celine's Oceania tour was something else. It was almost reminiscent to the "Taking Chances" era of Celine's career. This compilation only scratched the surface of the savagery that I witnessed over the summer as it pertains to Celine. So I say, thank you for making THIS video lol.
You are right, the honey ones were not live. Mariahxlambily (the channel that made the video this channel used a clip of) puts some lipped clips to make the video longer, but we lambs know.
I'd just like to point something out too to some of Mariah's fans who are saying she's more active. Let's face it you're wrong. Celine has such a high demand. Touring, plus vegas shows. None-stop. Even during back pains, ear surgeries. I love both, but Celine really has been way more active than Mariah when it comes to shows. And she has great discipline to keep her voice so well in such LARGE demand. Also people are saying they chose 'bad' clips for mariah. I would also add out, Celine's tour was long, and there're so much better clips that could have been chosen. So please, respect them both. Mariah's fans (SOME) loves to hate on Celine and vice versa. Where most of us adore the other. That's all
Bitch please... Mariah also runs her vegas residency and got more wealth than Celine. She also producing studio album in 2018, touring, doing tv shows, new year shows. What else could you want?
@@jamestanap5031 Because Mariah voice sound smoother, silkier and remain more resonance and power than Céline's. Mariah also has much more range, her vocals can get lower and much higher than Céline. Her vocal versatility is unmatchable. Céline sound the same predictable, basic, generic, straining and nasal in her entire whole catalog discography
It's funny bc this video is from a Céline fan channel and the comments are "Céline all the way" "i prefere celines sound" "Céline is better let's face it" but if the video was by a Mariah fan channel the comments would be like "Mariah's tone is so muche better" "i cant stand celine's nasal tone" "Mariah forever" 😂😂
Okay I feel like going to be destroyed if I state my opinion but here it is: in the 90s I prefer Mariah's voice especially her upper belts(I wasn't a fan of celine's tone during the 90s) it was apparent that after the charmbracelet era( 2002-2004),her upper belting register was never really the same Celine on the other hand I thought her mid belts and upper belts really started to shine during a new day era and her upper belts during The Taking Chances tour we're crazy! Don't get me wrong I love both Mariah and Celine as artists and performers, but after the 90s I've kind of preferred Celine voice, I just think her voice aged a lot better compared to Mariah's which some people might wonder why Mariah's voice deteriorated a lot quicker compared to celine's and I came to conclusion that it's probably a combination of nodules lack of rest(during her prime she was very overworked and rarely lip synced) and after the Daydream era she wasn't as consistent with her routine of keeping her voice in check if you look at Celine voice she's still hitting some of her highest belts yet you look at Mariah and she can't consistently hit past d5-Eb5 at best, which is kinda disappointing but at the end of the day I love them both but I have to admit Celine destroys Mariah nowadays don't get me wrong I'm fans of both but it's really not that hard to see and yes I know some people may make the excuse that Celine Dion has lip-synced more than Mariah but then at the same time, after the 90s Celine schedule has almost always been more way more demanding then mariah's and some people might use age as an excuse but keep in mind Celine is 2 years older than her I just think vocal exercises, rest and maybe just being born with a more resistant voice has made her voice stand the test of time, still love mariah though😊
well i somehow agree.. but in this new era when mariah's voice became more deteriorated and darker her low notes just suddenly become her biggest strength... and her mid belts also just became better compared to 90s. but yeah mostly she sang song in upper register and thats why it was mostly cracked and raspier.
Celine's voice still powerfull.. I saw her concert in Jakarta on July 2018. But Mariah has trying give best performance. Their both still our idol... Love them ❤
A big fan of both. If we are talking about power, Celine definitely slays Mariah. Celine has always been consistent in reaching the high notes. But one thing i dont like is how nasal she sounds. Every Celine fan knows how much different her voice changed (her tone, not the power). Mariah on the other hand, has been very inconsistent with her voice (she has nodule) but you can actually hear her 90’s tone on her 2018 vocals. Her tone has been there. She doesn’t have the power she had before but she can still hit a lot of notes this day. Celine - Very powerful but her tone is bad Mariah - Struggles to hit some of the high notes but her tone (when she’s in a good vocal condition) can be compared to her tone during the 90’s
Ceine's voice sounds way more in shape. I'm not sure how she does it with her demand. Well done to her for that. She gets little rest and keeps her voice more in shape. Mariah's lows has always been amazing, I love them. Celine lows also shocked me, which is nice. The belts I'd give it to Celine due to her technique and it's more resonated than Mariah's at this time. She doesn't seem to have any problems reaching up there, oppose to Mariah. Mariah's belts were nice, just didn't sound that power. The head voice I can't decide. Celine has an underrated headvoice, it's angelic. Mariah seems to had some issues with it, but I think they sounded amazing. Overall, two great singers. Celine doing great, her demand is out of control and she handles it well, her voice and energy. Mariah's voice was nice, only is it sounds unhealthy compared to Celine's. I adore them both :)
i really like this video! you chose great clips for both of them! its one of the few truly fair vocal battles ive seen. but this comment section is giving me second hand embarassment u must have a headache by now😭😭😭😭😭
thanks for the concept. never heard of celine's vocals this decade and i didn't know that she could go that low too, glad she's doing great. they both did well, but i like mariah's mid belts more because they sound more open, fuller and more resonant than celine's. just my preference. i enjoyed the video!
but celine singing alot than mariah she sing in vegas 2003-2007 (vegas) 2008-2009 (world tour) 2015-2019 (vegas ) she sing every night in vegas but her voice still healt than mariah,,and she star made a record album in 80 s (celine start her career so far before mariah become a profesional singer) and celine is touring singer
Lows: Celine (I can barely hear Mariah) Midbelts: tie, depending on the note. but overall a tie. like Mariah for the G4-Bb4 zone and Celine for the B4-D5 zone. upperbelts/mix: Celine Head voice: Celine
I appreciate and respect both but Mariah does it for me. Admittedly, Mariah's voice is more inconsistent than Celine's but she can still deliver impressive vocals and she has a much more prettier, feminine and youthful tone. Celine has become extremely nasal.
My fellow Lambily do not disrespect Celine to elevate Mariah. Mariah is my favourite singer but Celine as of today has a healthier voice with more ease. But i still prefer Mariah's tone and lows. Celine wins here.
@ivanchu0509 we lambs do it too... i see it here and other videos. And not all Celine fans hate Mariah. Alot of them were praising her new material....
@ivanchu0509 alot of lambs toxic, your index finger is pointing but your thumb is exposing you. What you mean lambs dont care for Celine? How can you speak for the millions of lambs? Selfcentered much, i am a real lamb but it doesnt means i dont have secondary artistes that i listen to from other Genres. Dont bring down other artistes/fanbases. if you think negative of them then dont watch videoz with them. Mariah is my favourite but she isnt perfect either.... i just prefer her.... and people have the right to opinions, if someone says jlo Selena and Taylor are the best singers in the world, why should we stone them😒
For sure i think In Lower notes and mid belt = mariah wins... So much resonance and clearly But in upper belt and head voice = for sure Celine is the winner! So strong and Much power, when mariahs upper belt is peak in D5-F#5 (But no in Always be my baby and Make it happen) For me mariah wins in A2-C5 Celine wins in D5-C6 In C#5 Both is better Celine had voice is amazing.. Like a opera singer!
technically speaking, Celine's voice is in a way better condition, however Mariah deserves major props because im sure that if Celine had her voice as damaged as Mariah's, she wouldn't be able to do half of what Mariah's doing, she's really doing the best she can with what she got, and that's really admirable. Celine wins the vocal battle hands down, does that mean she's a better artist? not really, it just means she preserved her voice better.
@@acpzt i didn't mention anything about technique bc i didn't want to pit them against each other, but since you brought it up... Celine's technique has always been inferior to Whitney's or Mariah's, she's consistently throaty, nasal and unstable on upper belts; a problem that Mariah and Whitney never had. Now more specifically, Celine doesn't have anything to distinguish her from another A+ vocalist, Whitney has the power and Mariah has the unparalleled agility, although Celine gets an A as a vocalist, she never had what it takes to jump above that, Mariah had (and still has) the tone, the range, the beautiful and diverse whistles, the powerful low notes, and although she lost most of her upper range, her mid notes are still the best. Remember she has had nodules since she is a little girl and her songs are incredibly more vocally demanding. Also note the fact that Mariah lips a lot less than Celine, especially during the first 10 years of their careers, Mariah wasn't lipping a single word while Celine lipped the entirety of her most difficult songs. She was smarter in that regard, that doesn't place her higher than the legendary Songbird Supreme OR The Voice.
@@acpzt okay you're delusional. the media really does a good job at putting down great black women to catapult a tall white woman. even though Celine has had multiple lip sync fails and vocal fails throughout her career, they always bring her up, and bring down the fewer fails Mariah and Whitney had for completely valid reasons.
@@acpzt I don't know why you are being so hateful. Yes technically Celine's voice today is healthier, but Mariah is still capable of producing great vocals and has an amazing tone (not saying that Celine isn't). However, I disagree with TouchMyRainbow's comment that Celine was never on par with Mariah and Whitney. I don't blame her for having that opinion, as Celine's vocal peak (90-92 in my opinion, when she had crazy ease with her upper chest) was when she wasn't that popular. And at her popularity peak (96-99) her voice was pretty weak. In regards to lipping, they have both done their fair share and so I think its equal in that regard.
They both sounded amazing this year! Celine is a master of mixed vocals so the ease and fluidity is very evident. Mariah seems to stick to more chesty vocals so it can reduce the ease of hitting notes but overall her tone is amazing and she has been attempting more complex runs with an open voice (example: my all in Singapore 2018) which she usually avoids or hits with a more closed throat and ens up sounding nasal (example: my all in Cardiff 2016).
MARIAH CAREY Has Thrones As THE SONG BIRDS SUPREMES, By The Guinness Book Of The World Records, & Till These Days No Other Human Had That Title 🕊🕊🕊💖💖💖🦋🦋🦋
im a lamb but i should give credit to my other favorite vocalist celine. in asian tour celine's voice is healthy, clear upper belt notes, and beautiful stage performance but the only thing that i think mariah's triumph from her was that during that tour mariah's low notes was just really that beautiful and attemp more whistle.
People will say Mariah singing lip sycn when mariah sing high notes but actually she's not lip sycn she singing live ,Mariah really understand how to make her voice really good to singing a few of her song needed to high notes ,and people or mariah haters will say Mariah lip sycn ,eghhh fuck !!!
I’ve never been a fan of Celine’s singing style but there is no denying her talents. Mariah on the other hand, is my personal goddess. Both women sound amazing either way.
I have to say that im a fan of mariah carey, but i have to say that celine dions music and voice is great, and everybody are saying that Celine dion voice has a better shape just because she reach higher notes lol, i have to say thay i live in las vegas and i went to mariahs and celines shows in las vegas and celine was very nasal and she used playback in some notes and everybody stand up and start aplause , and mariahs show she was very rasp voice and as same as celine she used play back and everybody was like okay thats great so i think that everybody critizes mariah for her mistakes
Go to hell worthless piece of shit. Mariah’s deluded, bitter, desperate cult can only wish that Mariah had even a small fraction of Queen Dion’s gorgeous tone
@@lizatsurkan4323 Céline is just an illuminati queen nothing else. Her soul is already in hell and you gonna find her there. As everybody knows, Céline sold out her soul to satan . As artist she has zero talent. As singer she's nowhere in Mariah's league
LMFAO, you’re so pathetic thinking that people actually believe what you say. So pressed and delusional. Even repeating your own delusions as if that will make it better. Enjoy the whore’s croaking, I will enjoy my queen’s singing -Shitriah could never
@@lizatsurkan4323 "Thinking that people actually believe what you say" Lol. In which world do you live ? In Céline's nose hole ? Go check on Billboard Hot 100 and Billboard Holiday 100 songs . Go check on Global Charts updates. Then come back talking with me about your Céline if she is part in these charts
Mariah does not fill big stadiums .... I wipe my ass with her #1 Billboards.... just nationalism... that's all....everybody knows that Celine Dion is like Jupiter.
Celine's voice is no type of damaged or nasilic at all her voice is just exhausted because of the loss of her husband. Celine & Mariah are both incredible singers in their own way but Celine is a better one because she knew & still knows how to take care of her voice Mariah doesn't that why Celine can still belt multiple Bb5's & C6's & a bunch of other notes that are out of Mariah's range. Plus Celine's voice is metallic that's why she can still belt the way she does back in days like 2008-2009 Mariah doesn't have metallic voice which is why her voice is so weak. And lastly Celine can actually improve her voice over the years. For example (river deep mountain high) she used to strain like crazy hitting those F5's back in the 90's 10-20 years later hitting several resonate G#5's & Bb5's with & without vibrato Mariah could never do anything like that because her voice is weak and no where near metallic. That's why Celine is the better vocalist. But to you all lambs that are dumb as shit Celine doesn't & has never sung out of her nose so do yourself a favor get your ears checked before you talk about someone else's singing because half of you lambs are just like Mariah y'all can't even hit a note or adlib for shit.
celine is better she sing in the way of nasal its very poor to make a highnotes if you are in the way of singing ,she sing in the way in english without influence of french, mariah is good on technically,thats why mariah loss her voice, celine is a natural singer
mariah's vocal win 1990-1998 - celine vocal win 1998 until now,, only 2 years older than mariah celine's voice more better than mariah ,even celine more intense use her vocal instrument to sing,,getting older celine's voice more better not like mc she can't beat celine like 90's era
Celine’s voice seems so fresh, healthy and strong!!!
Celine is way more confident and she has done a better job at preserving her voice, she is very fluid. But let's not discredit Mariah's improvement. She still needs to be more confident cause she doesnt attempt much and she is very uncomfortable on stage.
I agree with you.
Mariah is way more talented and more gifted vocally and artistrically than Céline. Mariah still outsing Céline even when she get nervous onstage . Confidence doesn't mean so much when your talent is basic
Shitriah could never do even a small fraction of what Goddess Dion does - she’d only embarrass herself
@@lizatsurkan4323 check Billboard and Eurochart last updates. They prove you're wrong. Céline is nowhere in these charts. She forgets what is entered a music chart since 1997
No, Taking Chances was in the charts and the reason her last album wasn’t was because of Rene’s illness - she couldn’t promote it properly. Btw the only reason Mariah is on the most streamed list is because of Christmas - her other stuff didn’t make it. Sir Elton however has 4 songs there
Celine all the way
Celine Dion!🥰🥰🥰🥰 the power chest belting never fades!
l was so lucky l watched both of their Asian Tour this year....l still can't believe to this day like wow both are my dream bucket list concert... They are my favorite singer of all time...
but tbh celine's concert left a deeper impression because l can feel her energy and her passion on every song eventhough l watched her from faraway ...as for Mariah's her band energy was the best...
Who sing the best? l personally think this video give a fine example of their performance
Céline of course and each song seems to feel like she’s feeling them as she sings them!!! The one and only Céline Dion!!!
Celine for suuuuureeee
Let’s be honest, the people saying who is better depends on who posted the video. If this were a Mariah channel, it’d be mostly Mariah probably. They are both doing great, and shouldn’t be treated like Pokémon cards haha. Celine is my favorite in this tho :)
Yup youre right.
ChrisTheAppleOne I have high respect of celine as she earned her rightful place in the music industry without chart maniplation and kept her integrity in the lat 4 solid decades.
@@popinsider450 hart manipulation lmao🤣 girl go away
@@popinsider450chart manipulation while mariah was far more successful without tommy
Two of the GREATEST and most respected female vocalist ever, both queens and perfect on their own style and both... LIVING LEGENDS, but if you want me to choose, I will go all the way for Céline!! 🤗😊😍❤️❤️❤️
Celine got my wig snatched !!!
Celine all the way 🤩🤩
Celine 🤩
Mariah >>>> Celine in terms of studio output for their most recent projects
Celine >> Mariah in terms of consistency of LIVE vocals recently
Mariah >>> Celine in terms of tone especially if you look at MCS Christmas concert ( this ones purely my opinion )
Celine currently for me doesn’t sound like the better singer. They are both too different to compare. However Celine has been waaayyyy more consistent imo. In saying that Mariah has been finally giving me some quality singing this year and I’m so proud.
Both legends only love and support for both.
Two queens. Both different, both unique, both LEGENDS!
Even though I'm a Celine fan, we have to admit both have a very good year! They both slayed in Asia!!!
Finally i've found the most positive comment
but celine's tiket in indonesia-jakarta more expensive than mc hahaha
Celine Dion 😍😍
Céline’s voice sounds so much healthier than Mariah’s. Thats my only critique.
Jake Watson that’s probably cause it is healthier Celine has lipped longer than Mariah which means her voice has been more rested than Mariah’s
Irishrugbyfan 03 Celine has not lipped longer than Mariah that’s bullshit. If you ask me they both have lipped there fair share of times. Celine has been singing since the age of 5 or 6. Celine also has taken better care of her instrument as well.
Irishrugbyfan 03 oh.. no baby lol sorry.
Morgan Anexi than why didn’t Mariah get them sergically removed
@@joshbonner9409 Mariah choose to keep her out of nodules surgery because its very risky. She could have the the chance to lost completely her voice. That why she have to live and sing with the nodules.
But she is still relevant and powerfully consistent with her singing.
Celine is the winner of the pop
Definitely Celine. Her voice is still in great shape. She’s really fighting against her illness and winning
Love the two, but Celine wins
Low - Mariah
A4 - Mariah
Bb4 - Celine
B4 - Mariah
C5 - Celine
C#5 - Celine
D5 - Mariah
Eb5 - Celine
E5 - Mariah
F5 - Celine
Hv/fal - Celine
Whistle - Mariah
Wow, my request came quick! It's like an early Christmas gift lol! Okay, I'll say this. Mariah definitely gets her props from me. She sounds great. These last few months have been some of the best vocal moments that she's had in a while and she looks to be actually having fun! I think she's finally found her groove. Now with that being said, Celine absolutely demolished Mimi here lol. With all due respect though, I knew that she would. Celine's Oceania tour was something else. It was almost reminiscent to the "Taking Chances" era of Celine's career. This compilation only scratched the surface of the savagery that I witnessed over the summer as it pertains to Celine. So I say, thank you for making THIS video lol.
I love both, but I prefer Céline in this clip, not sure that some of the mariah's falsetto notes are live
You are right, the honey ones were not live. Mariahxlambily (the channel that made the video this channel used a clip of) puts some lipped clips to make the video longer, but we lambs know.
@@flylikealamb9260 oh I see, well thank you Daahling 🤣
@@flylikealamb9260 BTW thank you for the answer I know your account I watched a lot of videos 😊
@@rayoflight9442 Thank you
I'd just like to point something out too to some of Mariah's fans who are saying she's more active. Let's face it you're wrong. Celine has such a high demand. Touring, plus vegas shows. None-stop. Even during back pains, ear surgeries. I love both, but Celine really has been way more active than Mariah when it comes to shows. And she has great discipline to keep her voice so well in such LARGE demand. Also people are saying they chose 'bad' clips for mariah. I would also add out, Celine's tour was long, and there're so much better clips that could have been chosen. So please, respect them both. Mariah's fans (SOME) loves to hate on Celine and vice versa. Where most of us adore the other. That's all
Mariah has never been very active in terms of shows. Her longest tour was only 62 shows!
Mariah was never really a tour artist. At TV promo ofc Mimj is more active
Mariah is a great Hitmaker unlike Céline
@@MusicLover-nz6ee and this is whats being evaluated here, right?
Bitch please... Mariah also runs her vegas residency and got more wealth than Celine. She also producing studio album in 2018, touring, doing tv shows, new year shows. What else could you want?
Céline all the way! I love Mariah, but Céline is better! Let's face it!
"I love X, but Y is better". This isn't opinion, is ofensive.
saying who's better is subjective girl. that's just your opinion.
Céline is not even in Mariah's shoes.
Croaking, whispering, meowing and lipping which is all that Shitriah does these days does not equal singing
@@lizatsurkan4323 You're so right ! Mariah is billion time better and greater than Celilluminatine nasalion
mariah wins in terms of tone. But celine voice is more healthy
Celine is so wonderful.
Celine is the best singer in the world.
So touching
I'm happy to have the same mind with you.
Both are amazing legends but Celine have always been a better vocalist and she took better care of her voice .
well the second one is true
Mariah was definitely the superior vocalist in the 90s, but Celine has preserved her voice better.
Mariah always been the superior vocalist , now she still outsing Céline nasal growls
@@MusicLover-nz6ee oh pls. put ur emotions aside for a moment and get real .
@@MusicLover-nz6ee hahahahhaha , you trying to be offensive. You need to get a life now .
Those are Mariah's fine/good vocals in 2018. Not her best vocals
Just the first C#5 and maybe the first Eb5 maybe are the best.
Shame mariah's voice is quite damaged. Celine sounded amazing as usual
Your ass is damaged bitch, Mariah's voice is still way better than nasaline's
@@MusicLover-nz6ee Hmm I disagree, especially after watching this video
@@jamestanap5031 You may have a serious ears problem. Do you think that Donald Duck sound better than Ariel the Mernaid ? Lol
@@MusicLover-nz6ee Very funny, could you please explain why you think mariah's voice is better than Celine's?
@@jamestanap5031 Because Mariah voice sound smoother, silkier and remain more resonance and power than Céline's. Mariah also has much more range, her vocals can get lower and much higher than Céline. Her vocal versatility is unmatchable.
Céline sound the same predictable, basic, generic, straining and nasal in her entire whole catalog discography
It's funny bc this video is from a Céline fan channel and the comments are "Céline all the way" "i prefere celines sound" "Céline is better let's face it" but if the video was by a Mariah fan channel the comments would be like "Mariah's tone is so muche better" "i cant stand celine's nasal tone" "Mariah forever"
😂😂
Lol face it mariah wasnt like before.
@@rowellvelasco4603 Both artist's voices are damaged and that's the tea. Celine preserved her voice more tho
Céline sounds like Donald Duck
Mariah voice damage because of alcohol
@@tedypermana5723 Céline's voice is damaged because she was à basic singer and her nasal cavity is exhausted
Okay I feel like going to be destroyed if I state my opinion but here it is: in the 90s I prefer Mariah's voice especially her upper belts(I wasn't a fan of celine's tone during the 90s) it was apparent that after the charmbracelet era( 2002-2004),her upper belting register was never really the same Celine on the other hand I thought her mid belts and upper belts really started to shine during a new day era and her upper belts during The Taking Chances tour we're crazy! Don't get me wrong I love both Mariah and Celine as artists and performers, but after the 90s I've kind of preferred Celine voice, I just think her voice aged a lot better compared to Mariah's which some people might wonder why Mariah's voice deteriorated a lot quicker compared to celine's and I came to conclusion that it's probably a combination of nodules lack of rest(during her prime she was very overworked and rarely lip synced) and after the Daydream era she wasn't as consistent with her routine of keeping her voice in check if you look at Celine voice she's still hitting some of her highest belts yet you look at Mariah and she can't consistently hit past d5-Eb5 at best, which is kinda disappointing but at the end of the day I love them both but I have to admit Celine destroys Mariah nowadays don't get me wrong I'm fans of both but it's really not that hard to see and yes I know some people may make the excuse that Celine Dion has lip-synced more than Mariah but then at the same time, after the 90s Celine schedule has almost always been more way more demanding then mariah's and some people might use age as an excuse but keep in mind Celine is 2 years older than her I just think vocal exercises, rest and maybe just being born with a more resistant voice has made her voice stand the test of time, still love mariah though😊
well i somehow agree.. but in this new era when mariah's voice became more deteriorated and darker her low notes just suddenly become her biggest strength... and her mid belts also just became better compared to 90s. but yeah mostly she sang song in upper register and thats why it was mostly cracked and raspier.
Celine voice has the same magic and power...gotta give it to her. Mariah is trying to bring it back. Those C5s where amazing
Stop comparing legends who in their prime were the epitome of perfection.
Both slay in their own way.. that’s it
Celine dion is the best powerful voice 100% with no doubt
Celine's voice still powerfull.. I saw her concert in Jakarta on July 2018. But Mariah has trying give best performance. Their both still our idol... Love them ❤
A big fan of both. If we are talking about power, Celine definitely slays Mariah. Celine has always been consistent in reaching the high notes. But one thing i dont like is how nasal she sounds. Every Celine fan knows how much different her voice changed (her tone, not the power). Mariah on the other hand, has been very inconsistent with her voice (she has nodule) but you can actually hear her 90’s tone on her 2018 vocals. Her tone has been there. She doesn’t have the power she had before but she can still hit a lot of notes this day.
Celine - Very powerful but her tone is bad
Mariah - Struggles to hit some of the high notes but her tone (when she’s in a good vocal condition) can be compared to her tone during the 90’s
[6:55 to 7:01] sounds like its from another world - unNaturally Beautiful....It's Everything.
Celine Dion ❤❤❤
Why seems to me that those notes are really uncomfortable to Mariah?
because her nodules make her pain.
@@flylikealamb9260 I didn't know that. Thanks!
@@natanrodrigues2335 It's tragic, really but she's been massively improving this year.
STREAM GTFO - Hi Hello dude how can u be on every Mariah vids LMAOO. Love u anyway
Ceine's voice sounds way more in shape. I'm not sure how she does it with her demand. Well done to her for that. She gets little rest and keeps her voice more in shape. Mariah's lows has always been amazing, I love them. Celine lows also shocked me, which is nice. The belts I'd give it to Celine due to her technique and it's more resonated than Mariah's at this time. She doesn't seem to have any problems reaching up there, oppose to Mariah. Mariah's belts were nice, just didn't sound that power. The head voice I can't decide. Celine has an underrated headvoice, it's angelic. Mariah seems to had some issues with it, but I think they sounded amazing. Overall, two great singers. Celine doing great, her demand is out of control and she handles it well, her voice and energy. Mariah's voice was nice, only is it sounds unhealthy compared to Celine's. I adore them both :)
i really like this video! you chose great clips for both of them! its one of the few truly fair vocal battles ive seen. but this comment section is giving me second hand embarassment u must have a headache by now😭😭😭😭😭
Celine is BETTER!!! Celine WINS...
thanks for the concept. never heard of celine's vocals this decade and i didn't know that she could go that low too, glad she's doing great. they both did well, but i like mariah's mid belts more because they sound more open, fuller and more resonant than celine's. just my preference. i enjoyed the video!
celine
where is Celine's fan like my coment
Celine Dion Forever she is the QUEEN OF SINGING
but celine singing alot than mariah she sing in vegas 2003-2007 (vegas) 2008-2009 (world tour) 2015-2019 (vegas ) she sing every night in vegas but her voice still healt than mariah,,and she star made a record album in 80 s (celine start her career so far before mariah become a profesional singer) and celine is touring singer
Mariah Carey The Songbirds Supremes 🕊🕊🦋🦋
Love Celine Dion Voice
Lows: Celine (I can barely hear Mariah)
Midbelts: tie, depending on the note. but overall a tie.
like Mariah for the G4-Bb4 zone and Celine for the B4-D5 zone.
upperbelts/mix: Celine
Head voice: Celine
I appreciate and respect both but Mariah does it for me. Admittedly, Mariah's voice is more inconsistent than Celine's but she can still deliver impressive vocals and she has a much more prettier, feminine and youthful tone. Celine has become extremely nasal.
Céline. Versatil voice. xxx
1 Celine
Congratulations Céline🎉 4th top grossing 2018 summer tour. Does not include her Las Vegas residency revenue for 2018.
♥️🎶🎵🎶🎵🎶🎵♥️Living Legend Icon
C e l i n e Di o n
Celines f5 to c6 she is using falsetto
Celine is queen of everything
Mariahh 🔥🔥
My fellow Lambily do not disrespect Celine to elevate Mariah. Mariah is my favourite singer but Celine as of today has a healthier voice with more ease. But i still prefer Mariah's tone and lows. Celine wins here.
@ivanchu0509 thats fine. We dont have to be like them. What are we proving? That we are bitches too?🤷♀️ We dont do petty, we do pretty.
@ivanchu0509 good
@ivanchu0509 we lambs do it too... i see it here and other videos. And not all Celine fans hate Mariah. Alot of them were praising her new material....
@ivanchu0509 alot of lambs toxic, your index finger is pointing but your thumb is exposing you. What you mean lambs dont care for Celine? How can you speak for the millions of lambs? Selfcentered much, i am a real lamb but it doesnt means i dont have secondary artistes that i listen to from other Genres. Dont bring down other artistes/fanbases. if you think negative of them then dont watch videoz with them. Mariah is my favourite but she isnt perfect either.... i just prefer her.... and people have the right to opinions, if someone says jlo Selena and Taylor are the best singers in the world, why should we stone them😒
@ivanchu0509
Also include Garage Studio, Ashleys Universe. Very disgusting comment from threads both have started...not defended.
Nice try.
Two queens... I love they so much...
For sure i think
In Lower notes and mid belt = mariah wins... So much resonance and clearly
But in upper belt and head voice = for sure Celine is the winner! So strong and Much power, when mariahs upper belt is peak in D5-F#5 (But no in Always be my baby and Make it happen)
For me mariah wins in A2-C5
Celine wins in D5-C6
In C#5 Both is better
Celine had voice is amazing.. Like a opera singer!
Mariah for a clearer tone, low notes and mid belts.
While Celine for upperbelts and headvoice
technically speaking, Celine's voice is in a way better condition, however Mariah deserves major props because im sure that if Celine had her voice as damaged as Mariah's, she wouldn't be able to do half of what Mariah's doing, she's really doing the best she can with what she got, and that's really admirable. Celine wins the vocal battle hands down, does that mean she's a better artist? not really, it just means she preserved her voice better.
TouchMyRainbow that means that Celine has a better technique. Mariah is a pain to watch lol
@@acpzt i didn't mention anything about technique bc i didn't want to pit them against each other, but since you brought it up... Celine's technique has always been inferior to Whitney's or Mariah's, she's consistently throaty, nasal and unstable on upper belts; a problem that Mariah and Whitney never had. Now more specifically, Celine doesn't have anything to distinguish her from another A+ vocalist, Whitney has the power and Mariah has the unparalleled agility, although Celine gets an A as a vocalist, she never had what it takes to jump above that, Mariah had (and still has) the tone, the range, the beautiful and diverse whistles, the powerful low notes, and although she lost most of her upper range, her mid notes are still the best. Remember she has had nodules since she is a little girl and her songs are incredibly more vocally demanding. Also note the fact that Mariah lips a lot less than Celine, especially during the first 10 years of their careers, Mariah wasn't lipping a single word while Celine lipped the entirety of her most difficult songs. She was smarter in that regard, that doesn't place her higher than the legendary Songbird Supreme OR The Voice.
TouchMyRainbow lol Not even you believe in what you did say. First of all, Mariah needs to sing, then we can compare her to Celine.
@@acpzt okay you're delusional. the media really does a good job at putting down great black women to catapult a tall white woman. even though Celine has had multiple lip sync fails and vocal fails throughout her career, they always bring her up, and bring down the fewer fails Mariah and Whitney had for completely valid reasons.
@@acpzt I don't know why you are being so hateful. Yes technically Celine's voice today is healthier, but Mariah is still capable of producing great vocals and has an amazing tone (not saying that Celine isn't). However, I disagree with TouchMyRainbow's comment that Celine was never on par with Mariah and Whitney. I don't blame her for having that opinion, as Celine's vocal peak (90-92 in my opinion, when she had crazy ease with her upper chest) was when she wasn't that popular. And at her popularity peak (96-99) her voice was pretty weak. In regards to lipping, they have both done their fair share and so I think its equal in that regard.
Low: Mariah
Chest: A4: tie
Bb4: Mariah
B4:Tie
C5:tie
C#5: tie
D5: Mariah
Eb5: tie
E5:tie
F5: celine
Everything above celine!
Head Voice
G5: tie
G#5: celine
A5:celine
Bb5: celine
B5: Mariah
C6: Mariah
Whistle:Mariah
Celine takes head voice lol
They both sounded amazing this year! Celine is a master of mixed vocals so the ease and fluidity is very evident. Mariah seems to stick to more chesty vocals so it can reduce the ease of hitting notes but overall her tone is amazing and she has been attempting more complex runs with an open voice (example: my all in Singapore 2018) which she usually avoids or hits with a more closed throat and ens up sounding nasal (example: my all in Cardiff 2016).
I choose Celine, the voice of Mariach does not have the original color, sounds like hundreds of other similar ones.
polski tyton This is hilarious!! Name one artist who sounds like Mariah 🤣
@@MultiThomasdk jajajaj true! polski dont know what is he talkin! lol
My Queens
MARIAH CAREY Has Thrones As THE SONG BIRDS SUPREMES,
By The Guinness Book Of The World Records, & Till These Days No Other Human Had That Title 🕊🕊🕊💖💖💖🦋🦋🦋
Celine dion of course
im a lamb but i should give credit to my other favorite vocalist celine. in asian tour celine's voice is healthy, clear upper belt notes, and beautiful stage performance but the only thing that i think mariah's triumph from her was that during that tour mariah's low notes was just really that beautiful and attemp more whistle.
Celine Queen Dion all the way
Lows:mariah
B4:tie
C5:Celine
C5: tie
C#5:TIE
C#5:tie
D5:MARIAH
D5: Celine
D5: Mariah
Eb5: Celine
Eb5:Mariah
E5:tie
E5:tie
E5:tie
F5: Celine even thi Mariah is good too!
G5:Mariah
G#5:Celine
A5:CELINE
Bb5:Celine
B5:Mariah
C6:Mariah
Whistle: Mariah
People will say Mariah singing lip sycn when mariah sing high notes but actually she's not lip sycn she singing live ,Mariah really understand how to make her voice really good to singing a few of her song needed to high notes ,and people or mariah haters will say Mariah lip sycn ,eghhh fuck !!!
Two men. I among all ppl should recognise that these are two men.
I’ve never been a fan of Celine’s singing style but there is no denying her talents. Mariah on the other hand, is my personal goddess. Both women sound amazing either way.
I love celine dion
I have to say that im a fan of mariah carey, but i have to say that celine dions music and voice is great, and everybody are saying that Celine dion voice has a better shape just because she reach higher notes lol, i have to say thay i live in las vegas and i went to mariahs and celines shows in las vegas and celine was very nasal and she used playback in some notes and everybody stand up and start aplause , and mariahs show she was very rasp voice and as same as celine she used play back and everybody was like okay thats great so i think that everybody critizes mariah for her mistakes
Biased video. the uploader increase Celine's notes and decrease those of Mariah. Cheap cheat ! Celine is under Mariah's feet anyway
Mariah forever wins!
Mariah still got the power... But its getting weaker,
Actually it's getting stronger since she is improving
No one will ever have Mariah's tone. No one. But Celine's voice sounds healthier. Stop comparing. Why to do this? Drama I'm sick
It is obvious that Celine's "healthy life style" kept her voice "in very good shape".....compared to M.C. one.....
Celine è UNICA PERFETTA
I luv them Both But MARIAH I Most Admired
Mariah is good but Celine's voice is great and not getting old
Lol this is just like comparing the quacks of a duck with the amazing melodies of a nightingale.
Go to hell worthless piece of shit. Mariah’s deluded, bitter, desperate cult can only wish that Mariah had even a small fraction of Queen Dion’s gorgeous tone
@@lizatsurkan4323 Céline is just an illuminati queen nothing else. Her soul is already in hell and you gonna find her there. As everybody knows, Céline sold out her soul to satan . As artist she has zero talent. As singer she's nowhere in Mariah's league
LMFAO, you’re so pathetic thinking that people actually believe what you say. So pressed and delusional. Even repeating your own delusions as if that will make it better. Enjoy the whore’s croaking, I will enjoy my queen’s singing -Shitriah could never
@@lizatsurkan4323 "Thinking that people actually believe what you say" Lol. In which world do you live ? In Céline's nose hole ? Go check on Billboard Hot 100 and Billboard Holiday 100 songs . Go check on Global Charts updates.
Then come back talking with me about your Céline if she is part in these charts
Mariah AIWFCIY is topping Holiday Chart since its opening. She also got 4 other songs in that Chart, Céline got zero song in Billboard Holiday 100.
Mariah does not fill big stadiums .... I wipe my ass with her #1 Billboards.... just nationalism... that's all....everybody knows that Celine Dion is like Jupiter.
just did a sold out stadium tour performing in front of crowds of 30,000 people
Celine's voice is no type of damaged or nasilic at all her voice is just exhausted because of the loss of her husband. Celine & Mariah are both incredible singers in their own way but Celine is a better one because she knew & still knows how to take care of her voice Mariah doesn't that why Celine can still belt multiple Bb5's & C6's & a bunch of other notes that are out of Mariah's range. Plus Celine's voice is metallic that's why she can still belt the way she does back in days like 2008-2009 Mariah doesn't have metallic voice which is why her voice is so weak. And lastly Celine can actually improve her voice over the years. For example (river deep mountain high) she used to strain like crazy hitting those F5's back in the 90's 10-20 years later hitting several resonate G#5's & Bb5's with & without vibrato Mariah could never do anything like that because her voice is weak and no where near metallic. That's why Celine is the better vocalist. But to you all lambs that are dumb as shit Celine doesn't & has never sung out of her nose so do yourself a favor get your ears checked before you talk about someone else's singing because half of you lambs are just like Mariah y'all can't even hit a note or adlib for shit.
Mariah has nodules... So it's why her voice a bit matured
Mariah then & now. :)
MARIAH ALWAYS
mariahh
Even when we look back to maria's prime time, she can't hit Bb5-C6 in mix voice..
just bcs she didn’t doesn’t mean she couldn’t, her mix was definitely light enough to do it
5:28 is very strong head voice not mixed.
Is a mix voice with a predominent head voice but is a mix
It’s a mix, there is clearly chest power in there
It's mix
celine is better she sing in the way of nasal its very poor to make a highnotes if you are in the way of singing ,she sing in the way in english without influence of french, mariah is good on technically,thats why mariah loss her voice, celine is a natural singer
mariah's vocal win 1990-1998 - celine vocal win 1998 until now,, only 2 years older than mariah celine's voice more better than mariah ,even celine more intense use her vocal instrument to sing,,getting older celine's voice more better not like mc she can't beat celine like 90's era
I prefer mariah
Could’ve out more of Taipei for Mariah tbh.
I like Mariah’s tone better but Celine obviously preserved her voice.