FIRST TIME listening to PINK FLOYD - "Us and Them" Emotional REACTION
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 ต.ค. 2024
- #pinkfloydreaction #pinkfloydlive #pinkfloyd
#pinkfloydreaction #pinkfloyd #metalreaction #pinkfloydpulse #pinkfloydlive
#firsttimepinkfloyd #metalreactions
Don't miss out Lilly Jane Gang
Instagram: / its_lillyjane Stay in the Loop (:
Patreon: / lillyjane Join the Fam (:
Cash App:cash.app/$itsl... Support the channel (:
Facebook Group: Coming Soon
Merch: Coming Soon
Reaction Request (Artist Only): $75.00 DM on Instagram
Original Video: • Pink Floyd - Us and Th...
Intro Song: Land of the grey Ryan Caraveo : • Land of the Grey
YALL I HIT A 79,000 SUBS THANK YOU
NEXT GOAL 80,000 SUBS
Also if you don't like how I react or " I pause too much" there is plenty other reaction channels out there, go check em out (:
Thank you for watching my reaction/ breakdown of the song, and please hit that subscribe button !
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS
Imagine that. An entire song without saying anything twice. No pop hooks. No rhyming a word to itself. Just meaningful content.
its a gift from the music gods, that's for sure.
I love how the echo is omitted on the word ‘without’.
Real music
Isn’t RW something
Imagine an entire Album which does that 😊
The Dark Side of the Moon is one of the best albums ever produced! The songs blend from one to another telling a beautiful story of the human experience. It's best to listen all the way through.
Also, the thing about Pink Floyd is when you hear this song for the 155th time, you'll get that same feeling and personally, listening to Pink Floyd always leaves me in a better place.
This is a case, where it’s best to listen to the Dark Side of the Moon in it’a entirety. Great album.
here here!!
it really is.
they are my "go to" when i need hour or two of relaxation. few cold beers, few shots of gin tonic or quality whiskey and pink floyd... cant get any better :D .
Had this on 8track put it on when I went to sleep woke up and still playin
I’m pretty sure it didn’t affect me
What I like most about Floyd is how different they sounded than any other group of their era.
Any era.
They knew what they were doing even if they didn't know it at that moment.
@@perrybarrett I consider myself a bit of a Floyd 'expert,' but never heard of that one. I'll have to check it out.
@Perry Barrett that was a transition period, they honestly didn’t know what they were doing. And it was from a soundtrack to an extremely obscure movie. So while you’re not exactly wrong, it still seems a bit off. Every band went through a period of trying to “sound” like someone else before getting their feet underneath them.
@@perrybarrett Thanks, I will search that out. 👍👍👍
Fun fact: Back in 1985, Junior year in High School, our chorus teacher was SO cool, he allowed us to choose one song (any genre we wanted) to rehearse and sing. We overwhelmingly chose this song. It was for our "Final Concert of the school year", and we nailed it. Granted, the only instrument we had playing it was piano. Someone (a Senior that year) had money, and owned a camcorder. The tape is packed away, but I offered to digitize it if he ever finds it. But this song is very special to me because of that performance.
Edit: The very last part was about a homeless person being brushed off by someone walking by. The reply to asking for a handout was "Out of the way, it's a busy day. I've got things on my mind." The last line.... "For want of the price of tea and a slice" (something to eat and drink) "The old man died." (because someone wouldn't give them just enough change to buy tea and a slice (of bread, presumably)). Which infers that he starved to death.
That story deserves a thumbs up. Not as cool as yours but we played Another Brick in the Wall in marching band. lol. ✌
yes it’s about the futility of war and how young men and women get sucked into jingoism, finally ending up as traumatized veterans (the old man) the rest of his country blithely ignore.
"tea and a slice" tea and toast is so British. I really never understood how a whole nation can be so in love with what is basically deluxe bread & water. Great story, and breakdown.
Mr Stardust1967: did you get a Pink Floyd mental flash when you typed your "Edit:"? Your words bring to mind, very distinctly, PF's song "On the Turning Away," one of my Top10 individual Floyd songs.
With. Without.
Really appreciate that the younger generation feels connected to the music of my youth..
They are not in any way connected. They do it for money. You really believe all these "reactors" like the music they have to listen to? It's an act. Most people are easy to fool.
I am an old man who was steeped in this music in the 1970's. I'm in the middle of your reaction and find myself crying like a baby at the shocking notion that young people are hearing music such as this for the first time.
Master musicians competent of critical thought and social commentary is why Pink Floyd is still resonate
This album is such a masterpiece. I'm a total thrash metal head but have always enjoyed Pink Floyd.
There are universal themes of pink Floyd like Metallica that transcend genre.
This album was on the Billboard Top 200 Albums chart for over 17 YEARS straight! Far longer than any other album was on the chart without a break. That is because of how many people recognized the genius of the album and the feelings it inspired.
When you look at that list of top ten-30 it’s astounding!! The difference between this lp and the rest..
@@daveburns3886 It was on Billboard's Top 200 for 33 years
And when sale at Christmas time
when it gets into the top 200 it's time is still counting
I'm 63 and I was 12 when this album came out. I still listen to it.
"War is when the government tells you who the enemy is...Revolution is when you decide that for yourself"- Ben Franklin
✊
He never said this.
@@ibuprofenPill stop assuming and look it up...
@@Tune-O-maticI don’t have to. To prove someone said something, you have to cite a *credible* source. Let me know where you find it. He never said that.
@@ibuprofenPill It doesn't matter what you say...A simple google search will prove he said it...Don't be lazy and do your OWN research...then prove he never said that..
This is one of those albums that you can simply enjoy all of the songs. And all of them will give you a different feeling. Amazing work so many years later people are still taking this journey of a band that doesn't even exist anymore.
Pink Floyd and their music is immortal
Same with The Beatles, Led Zeppelin etc.
Pink Floyd, The Dark Side of the Moon. Honey, you are experiencing what is nearly universally considered to be the Holy Grail apex of artistic, progressive rock. There's a damn good reason this album spent 14 consecutive YEARS on the charts!
Such a peaceful sounding song about such a horrible event. Took a few times listening to get the meanings behind the music. We didn't have lyric videos back in the 70s
and not all albums came with lyrics
@Chuck Drennen my first copy was on 8 track tape. I didn't buy a LP record until later.
EVERY interpretation is 'right'.... that is the genius of FLOYD ;)
This song is forever on my playlist.
This song actually melts right into the next one, an instrumental called Any Color You Like. Just so you know, the last two songs on the album also run together and they should be listened to that way. Brain Damage and Eclipse.
Any Colour You Like: possibly my favourite piece of music ever. Not just Floyd.
Nice reaction! That sax solo really hits deep. To me the end of the song could be about ex-soldiers living on the street (down and out) after struggling to re-join society because of the horrors of war they've experienced. They are invisible to the busy people going about their day, wrapped up in their own, safe lives. DSOTM is just a masterpiece.
This song needs to be played on super loud sound speakers over all of Russia. Now!
Jesus christ ukrotards do the absolute most.
Maybe you should try a little harder. It is NOT about condemnation, moral superiority or any of that. Get off your high horse, it’s about humility and embracing all, not about choosing sides.
Not to people but to governments.................."War is not the results of peoples but of individuals" - Sir Patrick Hastings
This tune has never left my mind since I first heard it in 1973. Thank you, Pink Floyd and Alan Parsons. Thank you, Lilly Jane Reacts.
For a song about war this gives me the most peaceful feeling of all songs in the dark side of the moon. Thanx for listening to pink floyd. Experiencing this again through other people's perspective is awesome.
This song is just as relevant today as it was back in the 70s.
It's so fun to watch young people like you react to Pink Floyd for the first time. It takes me back to my college years in the 70's reacting the same way. Enjoy!
Her reactions were very nuanced and genuine (it matters), and that made it fun.
Pink Floyd is not music that you JUST listen to. You feel it and experience it. I like the way you feel Pink Floyd. It's a journey through every album. Think about 3 albums in a row. Dark side of the moon, Wish you were here and THE WALL
You missed Animals in between WYWH and The Wall but it fits that description as well.
(and Meddle)
It's OK to cry. The whole album brought me to tears in 1978 and changed my life. So did their next album, Wish You Were Here. Neil Young can do it, too. I suggest his song, Thrasher.
Hi Lily Jane - I love your reactions. When it comes to Pink Floyd and the Dark Side album in particular.... The thing is, I am a 66 year old guy from London in the UK. I still love Dark Side of the Moon today as much as i did when I was a teenager back in 1973 when the album first came out. What struck me about your reaction to 'Us and Them' was your insight into the after effects of war and the lasting affect it has on veterans of wars and how the horror of what they witnessed in combat never really leaves them. To have that level of insight at your young age is truly of great credit to you. I can tell that you are a very intelligent and thoughtful young lady. I wish that i'd had the same degree of integrity and insightfulness when i was your age. I always look out for your latest YT content. Peace and harmony to you Lily Jane. 🙏🏼♥
Your own opinion and your own emotions from this music is what matters. It’s truly personal.
As a Pink Floyd fan for the last 30 years and a fellow streamer I will say your comments about this song and your perception were spot on. The song is about war and how pointless it is, great job
Yep it's about war but still a beautiful piece of music and my favorite from this album.
Soothing melody, passionate words
My daughters liked Wham. I discovered Pink Floyd along with the rest of my generation, early 1970's for me.
I find it fascinating how this music once again resonates with this generation. I find your generation as a whole to be greatly encouraging. You are bright, inciteful; you get what is in these songs, written at a time we were driven by the circumstance to consciously decide who we would be, and stand for.
Therefore, as art IS a reflection of the times in which it's created; you, my grandchildren's generation, are at that place now; I never saw my children's generation as making a choice, they sort of went back to the 1950's- big hair, pop music Wake Me Up Before You Go- Go (ha!) Pep rallies, etc.
I think you guys are great! As a whole aware and inciteful, very smart. I'm probably not the only Boomer who hears you that thinks this. Think outside the bubble folks- life is so much more interesting that way- I think you get that.
One of the greatest pieces of the sonic art form. This entire LP is a true masterpiece, The Mona Lisa of sound…..
I get what you said
Did you notice at the end when they sang: “With (with, with, with, with) without. “ The without was the only time there was no echo or, continuation. Without. It’s final.
The echo was achieved by spacing five or six tape decks around a room and passing the recording tape through each of them in turn. That would be so easy today with modern technology!
The mark of any great work of music is that you never tire of hearing it no matter how many times you've heard it. Dark Side of the Moon easily passes this test, and then some. What's even more impressive is that it's hardly the only Pink Floyd album of which this is true. It's their Abbey Road, which is fitting because that's where it was recorded, and engineered by Alan Parson who of course worked on that album.
When I was in college in the 80's there were two albums that I played repeatedly on my Sony Walkman (Dolby C, of course), this, and Miles Davis' Kind of Blue. Never got tired of listening to them, especially late at night on solitary walks around campus. They are perhaps the two most perfect works of art in each of their respective music genres. I wonder what Miles Davis thought of Dark Side of the Moon.
And I just found out that the keyboard part of another cut from this album, Breathe, composed by Pink Floyd keyboardist Richard Wright, was inspired by Kind of Blue. I had no idea.
It's not always a moving guitar solo, love it when they throw in an emotional Sax solo.
It's one spicy meatball!
I love your intelligence and your willing to learn from this great art piece. Keep doing you!
Thank you! Cheers!
Thank you. As a long-time fan of Pink Floyd it brings me great joy to witness another person experience thier work for the first time with an open mind and ready heart. It's been really nice to run into someone who gets it.
Dark Side of the Moon came out in 72, I was 10 and would listen to my older brothers and sisters music. They had this album and I would listen to it as well. I always love this song.
First Heard this album in 1976, since then I've listened to DSOTM hundreds of times. Us and Them still makes me emotional and the way it goes back and forth between in close and intimate to Big and wide, it is a Masterpiece within a Masterpiece.
It's impossible to listen to this album without crying at some point.....just let it out.
Incedently this album has been voted #1 rock album, ever.
I hope. LJ., that this song will flood your soul once and again, as a few generations prior to this night.. Peace...always.
Good reaction Lily Jane! You know, this song was always in the set. Whether they did the Dark Side album or not. I always enjoyed the movie on the oval screen during this one. I think it set the tone for the song beautifully. The version from Pulse is quite good. And, thx for your journey through Floyd.
I love how at 9:10 you started describing what you were thinking of and what you were picturing. Pink Floyd is the only band that can make me get extremely emotion to the point of tears without saying a single word. That’s so extremely special and it’s something that artists in our generation today lack the ability or discipline to try to achieve
It's the music *industry* that does it to artists, trying to squeeze as many albums out of them as they possibly can. Stifling creativity
6 years old I remember them as a child this music is unspeakably moving sometimes I want to cry sometimes I just sit and wonder Pink Floyd will go down in history as great artist
You're right the song does lend itself to different interpretations, but I must say I like yours. Pink Floyd may not use a lot of words to get their message across but they are almost always the perfect ones. And what you might not pick up from the lyrics, the soul picks up from the amazing instrumentals. Nice job!!
You mostly got all of the meaning of the song, great job and reaction! You did miss the meaning of the last couple of lines because you were focused on the war aspect. The down and out, with/without part was about poverty and homelessness. Down and out was a phrase used often in the 60s, 70s, and 80s to describe someone who had lost their job and home and as a result they were living on the streets. The last two lines sbout a busy day and things on my mind were about someone ignoring or dismissing that homeless person rather than stopping to help, resulting in the old man dying from starvation because he couldn't afford something as simple as a cup of tea and a slice of food. Brilliant writing imo.
yes the lat two lines i feel were about how modern society pushes away the warriors once the war is over.. as is still evident even today
Right on, Lilly. Floyd seems to have a way of evoking deep personal reactions. Thanks for sharing yours. The out-of-the-way, it’s a busy day part reminds me of an old veteran on the streets being ignored by business people and then passing.
I was about 12 or 13 when I first heard Pink Floyd. I'm 49 now. Their music never gets old. Never heard a song from them I didn't like.
It's the beauty and the complexity that helps it stay new.
You’re spot on with your comments great review!
If you felt like crying during this song your ears and mind work perfectly
I'll never forget Roosevelt stadium 1973 they did the entire Dark Side of the Moon - it was mind blowing. The album is really meant to be listened to straight through, as the songs sort of blend into each other without silence between songs. These individual tracks posted have their beginnings and endings cut and cropped, and are different than the original album.
ANIMALS is a sonic MASTERPIECE! 🤞✌
Agreed agreed agreed animals is my favorite of course the wall is amazing and I think it would really be cool if Cirque du Soleil did Pink Floyd to the wall
The members of METALLICA would have been in high school when Pink Floyd released "THE WALL." Pink Floyd definitely influenced bands like TOOL and METALLICA! More Floyd please. 🤞✌
I listen to this when 8 track tapes were in and surround sound first came out, listen to the album in the dark with head phones on...
Only the first part deals directly with war. The last part, "With/without,.... That's what the fighting's all about", and "Out of the way" is about the needy and a homeless person on the street. "Out of the price, of tea and a slice, the old man died".
I think your analysis of the song is spot on Lilly! I think it means us the common people and them the elite who rules the whole world and who are the puppet masters. It also I think as you the insanity of war that never seems to stop. as the song goes, around and around what is the fighting all about.
There is no one better at music emotional bliss than what you find with PF, they are true musicians.
Have just watched your reaction to( brain damage and eclipse, and for one so young you can really understand the meanings in the lyrics, By far the best reactor on here.❤
Wow, thank you
Hey Lilly nice to see you kids today discovering and enjoying Pink Floyd. I’m 75 and first heard this song in 1973 when I was 14. Not only Us And Them but the entire DSOTM is one of the greatest concept albums ever. I’d love to see you react to one of the other greatest concep albums ever Days Of Future Passed from 1967 by The Moody Blues. If you only have time to react to one song on that album then I hope it’s Nights In White Satin a song written by Justin Hayward who wrote it when he was 19. You might also include Late Lament which follows it on the album.
One of the best songs ever recorded.
Great reaction Lilly Jane!
Forty years of listening to this album and I still tear up and, yes, sometimes I even break down. The songs on this album were written by a group of guys in their mid to late twenties, and they have written songs with an emotional punch beyond their years that I swear hits even harder for me at 55 than as the emotional fifteen year old I was when I bought the album. And I'm supposed to be a tough unfeeling old bastard.
The end to me is very much a reflection of how we all can be. We're so wrapped up in what is going on in our immediate lives that we can forget about other people, even people right there that we see. "For the want of the price/of tea and a slice/the old man died." That hit me extra hard when I was a teen and involved working with the missions for the homeless through my church, because I knew that a couple of bucks (or one or two pop-top cans of soup, stew, and/or beans or veggies) can make it possible for somebody to be living tomorrow instead of dead tonight. And sometimes even the most caring and thoughtful of us need the reminder to take the bucket of "so much going on in my mind" off of our heads and actually see what is going on around us and how we can directly help, even in the smallest ways, to make someone's day a little better. Sometimes all it takes is a kind word to make someone choose to stay alive a little longer.
I love it when they just seem to become even greater than the sum of their parts, as in their synergy. Like birds in flight, or your favorite sports team moving like a well-lubed machine, in perfect synchrony. All One mind.
Sid Barret the original founder wanted a R&B sound, so they took the sounds of blues guitarists Pink
Anderson, and Floyd Counsel. Pink
Floyd got their name. I mentioned the rainbow light shows already.
If you want Pink Floyd with an incredible bell you need High Hopes.
Wow, that was such a good analysis! So here’s the story of the song: It was written by Roger Watters and it’s about his father dying in the Battle of Anzio in World War II. His father did not want to go to war, like any sensible person, but had to go and do his duty for his country. His father gave his life for a greater purpose, but Roger was too young to understand why of course and became really bitter about it. A lot of the songs in The Wall were inspired by this event as well. Listen closely to the lyrics of Being the Boys Back Home, Shen the Tigers Broke Free, and Another Brick in the Wall Part 1 from The Wall.
Believe me, it's not just today's music that all too often is mostly noise. Back in the 1970's when this music was new, it was also standing out against a background of mostly noise. It was just a different style of noise. We appreciate bands like Pink Floyd and a few others, and judge the music of the 1970's by those geniuses, because the noise is forgotten -- the sludge has sunk to the bottom, and the cream remains to be treasured forever. Some day the noise of the 2020's will fade away, and the truly great music of THIS era, which does exist, will take it's place to be listened to by a young adult in 2073, who will say "the music of that era sure was great!"
BRILLIANT!!
Not as familiar with today's pop/rock (all good music is good music actually) bands - any suggestions?
@paulbrinkman5631 Radiohead is good. Try "No Surprises" or "Pyramid Song".
@@braynaguilar8567 I hate to point it out, but No Surprises is 27 years old and Pyramid Song is 23 years old! Not quite what the kids would think of as "today's music"... 😉
Thanx for reacting to this song LillyJane, cuz it is my fav Floyd tune... RogerWaters is an amazing songwriter!
I bought 2 copies of this album when it was released because I thought I was going to wear it out. It's best listened to in the dark ( maybe some light filtering through a window) with no distractions.
Along with TIME this is my favorite song! ❤
Great Commentary LiLLY ! So well thought out and intuitive.....Thanks for sharing
I had a completely new and intense Pink Floyd experience this winter during the polar night, when I looked up at the sky and saw the Northern Lights dancing to these sounds. That was magic at its finest.
Cosmic symphony
The film shown by them gels the feeling of alienation. It’s feet walking as if commanded as being fed into war by generals and politicians.
You are a very wise soul for being so young! More PF please!
You have to remember. Vietnam was ongoing, and growing up in the UK WW2 ended 25 years or so before.
Atom Heart Mother[1970]Shall Blow Ur Bloody Mind Indeed...
Parts of this classic, timeless song reminds me of church, must be the organ music.. I wholeheartedly agree with the person below in how good the production is on this song... I submit to everyone, that this album is one of the BEST EVER!!!! EVER..... Such a head trip! Pink's music tends to make you reflect and ponder. These men are brilliant.. So good!!!!!!!!!!!!!........................... For the record, this album, 8-track was released the same year I graduated from High School. (1973) That and the entire album is near perfect musically!!!
Love this song and dig how you can feel the music. I think your analysis is as good as any.
I enjoyed your honest reaction. It's like that every time you listen to Pink.
greatest album EVER
I wish I could listen to this album again for the first time and get the same feeling I got when I first heard it.
There is plenty of time to think later...Mainly let the emotion carry you through this amazing performance.
Us and Them !!! Great. Love that sax. Also from that album is Brain Damage. I don't know if you have done it yet just be sure that you do it with Eclipse which is the ending.
Heads up - These have to go together. - Pink Floyd - Brain Damage / Eclipse - otherwise Brain damage just suddenly stops without the end.
Best concert I ever went to!!! Love their music
Dark Side of the Moon is just pure magic an absolute masterpiece taking you on a magical journey
The music of Floyd has a unique ability to expose a persons heart and soul and most interpret Floyds music in their own way, it means whatever you want it to mean and is the reason why so many fall in love with it. I believe the Dark Side Of The Moon, when listened to in its entirety, is a living, breathing, work of art that etches itself to your soul and never leaves you.
I've watched all of your Pink Floyd reactions, you have a good heart and an honest soul, never change.
The most Powerful Rock Band in Universe!!!!!!! U feel it in ur Heart,Soul, and Mind!!!!!!!!! Takes me Back!!! In Time!!!!!!
Over the last couple of years I have picked up some old quality tube gear and some Pink Floyd master recording LP's - Can't wait to get it all set up and listen.
One of my favorites from Pink Floyd!
I feel you! Peace is the way of the light
I loved your interpretation of this song,it was perfect! You're really intelligent Lilly❤️
Hi, Love Your reactions.
Well thought out.
Really appreciate Your enthusiasm.
Pink Floyd are a great Band.
Keep Rockin'🎸📀🎹
RONNIE 🙂
Scotland 🏴👍
Great reaction. I had 3 step uncles who were sent to Nam. Luckily they made it back.
"Pink Floyd has sent more people to space than NASA." - Kersten Graham
You should check out the Pink Floyd live at Earls court London 1994. It's awesome. Their laser light show. Look up the songs at that concert like Run like hell, Time, Learning to fly, etc.
Saw them do this live on the original tour. New music that blew everyone away.
Dark Side of the moon was the first rock show that I ever saw back in 1973. I just turned 16 at the time and I got hooked on Prog Rock on the spot. 50 years later I still listen to it and still discover new things every time. Truly a masterpiece! You said that there is also great music made today, I agree, but in my mind, this is very hard to top and you have to look hard and out of the commercial mainstream to find some. Maybe I'm just too old to understand new music, but none make me feel like that and other albums of that era.
Very good interpretation of the song! Roger Waters ( lyricist and bass player) lost his father in WW2 who was killed in combat. Obviously, his pain and anger really shows in the lyrics and the power in the music. Enjoyed this and your other reactions to Floyd! Keep 'em coming! 😁
Black Friday at Walmart in 2011 (I was 11), I was given $70 dollars and decided to purchase the newly reissued 'Wall' album along with a t-shirt of the animated characters (Wife, Teacher, Mother, and Pink) from the Concert/Film. Immediately became obsessed with it and began my journey of seeking art in music. I know The Wall (all of Pink Floyd, really) by heart ♥, yet I still remember that primordial emotion and interpretation of the Record after I listen to it. The feeling that album burned into my brain was also etched into my soul (in the best way). Continue your Floyd journey! Even Floyd's worst moments have shreds of creativity, like Point Me at the Sky. 😂❤😊 Cheers!
So good to see you got the meaning of this song so quickly! It is basically about the futility of war and people in power sacrificing the ones doing the fighting. And the general population's ignorance of how much is being sacrificed. This one hits hard and is one of my favourite Floyd tracks!
Yes, they've identified the problem, but what are WE going to do about it?
When you play Pink Floyd I will always give u a thumbs up.
Alan Parsons ( Alan Parsons Project ) produced most of these albums. When he produced his own albums under his name, they also are story arcs. Turn of a Friendly Card is an excellent album, you'd enjoy it.
Thank you for sharing your Pink Floyd experience! You genuinely felt how this song is beautiful and emotional. You also got straightaway the message behind the lyrics and that’s not common. I love your videos about this album and I can’t wait for your next reactions about Pink Floyd amazing music😍