MLB | Awful Call
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ก.ย. 2024
- Baseball Sports
►Enjoy the Video
►Thanks for watching, like, share and comment
►SUBSCRIBE
/ baseballsportsyt
►Facebook
bit.ly/34sqPDL
►Instragram
bit.ly/2K1FkF7
►Play List:
bit.ly/2ViiA9b
►Popular Videos:
bit.ly/2wyV4ws
►Thanks for watching, and remember subscribe, like, share and comment
The infield fly rule with Bonds isn’t a bad call. The batter is out automatically but the runners can advance at their own risk. Nobody tagged Bonds and it isn’t a force play.
Exactly
Ironically they could have doubled Bonds up at third if they caught it.
I can't believe Bonds chose to advance. Did not know the rule either?
@@benwakefield93 Or just doubled up by tagging him lol
amen to that
I love that it says awful calls yet there’s a few on here that we’re the right call
Agreed
Right, But, most people and fans don't know any better.
Exactly
*were* not we’re
Just goes to show you how many people still can't comprehend the infield fly rule.
Some of these weren’t bad calls it’s just y’all don’t know the rules
I'm an umpire myself and I was confused about "how was these bad calls"
Except the one with Marquez who touched his hand without the ball on the pirates runner
Lazerboi
An umpire who uploads pokemon go and among us content? I kinda doubt it.
@@SharkBeret I only do it because umpire season ended 4 months ago... i get paid $17 per game and I do 2 games a day... I got $243 this year and bought my first gaming PC
@@lazerboi6607 as a 12 year old I’m confused on how you think that’s good grammar.
Some of these calls were correct; some of the others, while probably wrong, were not as bad as the title would lead you to think.
I was expecting to see Joe West or Angel Hernandez in at least a couple of these.
Angel Hernandez made the call at 8:14.
@@wofoky24 and 3:45
Or CB Bucknor.
THE ONE THAT GOT ME RLY MAD WAS THE ONE AT ABOUT 3:20- THE CATCHER CLEARLY DIDNT DROP THE BALL AND SO HE COULDNT HAVE RUN TO FIRST
@@wofoky24 Angel hernandez got the call at 8:14 right though. AJ came off the bag
3:40, as the late, great Harry Kalas used to say, "Right down the middle for a ball."
Compilation of umpires actually knowing the rules and teams pulling umpires from the local little league.
Would be to short
Clearly the guy that made this knows nothing about the rulebook.
If they had renamed this video _angry at umpires_ it might've worked.
@@marcanderson1575 How is stating the obvious an insult?
Marc anderson but he didn’t call him an idiot. He just pointed out he doesn’t know the rule book. Idiot.
Marc anderson you are the only idiot here
Marc anderson lmfao, what are you on about? I didn’t say that, clearly. Even if I did call him that, it would be a bad start to a trade off for this guy making his 20th copyright video attempting to sh*t all over an entire profession while having absolutely no clue on what he’s talking about or looking for himself.
Someone better tell those baseball players that there's a giant arrow pointing at a big red circle.
Half of these are completely correct calls. WTH is this?
I agree but not all of them were completely correct
None of them were correct I actually play baseball
@@HarrisonSoper Go play baseball, and stay ignorant. One of the many things I've learned after 34 years of umpiring is that players do not know the rules very well. You are proof of that because several of these were correct calls.
Regarding the 2nd play shown, with the run down: The lead runner that originally occupied 3rd base , came off the base.. was not on the base, so the preceding runner was allowed to be there until the lead runner gets back on the base. However, the original lead runner at 3rd base never went back on the base and as he was off the base he was tagged out. So he should be out and that should be the only out. Tagging the preceding runner while on base is not an out, again, because the original lead runner was not on the base and was also put out first. there should only be one out made on that play.
But he tagged the behind runner first so he’s out then the lead runner was off the bag so when he’s tagged he’s out, not questioning you just letting you know that’s how the book says it
@@tsmxlirics_1942 The trail runner would only be out if both runners were in contact with the base. That didn't happen. There is no reason Lawrie would be out.
I was telling my son that some of these baseball missed calls, especially the strikes, or non strikes, are kind of misleading. We haven't seen the whole game to see what Blue's strike zone is. But still, a blatant bad call is still a bad call.
So if the umpire is calling pitches wrong the whole game it’s ok?
@@steveswangler6373 Of course not, Steve, but the short clips we see of Blue's calls might not be indicative of how his strike zone is that given day. I'm a Blue Jays fan, how about you, who is your team ? 🇨🇦⚾️⚾️🇨🇦
0:44 where is the awful call, I might just be dumb but that seems like a pretty good call
1:53 - the call is correct. Infield fly, runner going to 1st is out, runner from 3rd can advance at his own risk. He's safe and call is correct.
Im so confused. Kind of new to baseball and don’t fully understand. I thought the runner from 3rd was out because the catcher was given the ball and stepped on home base. I always thought this was immediately an out. What allowed him to keep running and get to home safe if the catcher had already touched base with the ball in hand? Sorry I’m just trying to understand this rule cause now I’m really curious.
@@lizvargas9905 Since the batter was called out on an infield fly rule there was no force out because nobody had to advance. For him to be out from third on this play they would have had to tag him out.
The Ron Kulpa one is so gross. Dude was literally bragging about how he can do anything he wants. That kinda arrogance man.
At 1:00,
I disagree with the ump’s call.
I’d like to hear what you all think.
Here’s my thought, and I admit with limited knowledge on rules associated with two runners on same base.
My understanding:
When two runners are on the same base (at the same time), lead runner has priority so is considered to occupy the base legit. Following runner is considered not touching a base bag, even if he is physically touching that base bag.
Here what happened: during the run down, lead runner had no idea his following runner was coming to 3rd.
The lead runner rushes back to 3rd seeking safety, touches his hand on the base bag.
Immediately he realizes what happened: his team mate ran up to 3rd base and is standing on the bag.
Lead runner decides to sacrifice himself so removes his hand from base bag.
At this instant, no more “two runners on same base”. The lead runner is now technically not on base bag, and is in between 3rd & home.
NOW the defense tags the following runner standing on the base bag. This tag has no effect. Because at the moment of that tag, that runner was the ONLY runner on that base bag.
So the follow-runner is safe, not out.
Defense then tags the lead runner. Lead runner not touching base bag. Lead runner is legit out.
This is not a double play.
Ump made the wrong call.
Again, that’s my interpretation based on understanding of the “two runners on base bag AT THE SAME TIME” rule.
Your thoughts?
You're absolutely right, with one minor clarification, when two runners are on the same base the lead runner has priority, unless he is forced. For example, runners at first and second and a grounder to the shortstop. The runner at second decides not to run to 3rd because he might get tagged out, so he stays on 2nd. The runner that was on first gets to 2nd because he was forced by the batter-runner. The runner going from 1st to 2nd now has priority since the runner at 2nd was forced to go to 3rd.
I disagree, the lead runner has priority to the bag. Since the trail runner came to the bag, he got tagged and is out. The lead runner went off the bag so he is out. If you see he actually tagged the trail runner first. I think it was correct.
So I'd say 1/3 of these were actually the right call, 1/3 of these you can't even tell what the call was because the editing is so bad, and 1/3 are the wrong call (but most are close enough that you can't call them "awful")
Regarding the infield fly rule called at 1:56, I see several comments saying the runner from 3rd base does not need to tag-up (go back to 3rd base and step on 3rd base), which is completely irrelevant.
What is relevant is that the batter-runner was called out very quickly according to the infield fly rule so the other runners are not forced to advance; therefore a force out cannot be made on any of the other runners. To get any of the other runners out, somebody from the other team needs to tag (touch) one of the other runners with either the ball in hand or ball in glove, which did not happen. The home plate umpire made the correct call on both infield fly rule (batter-runner Bonds) out and the runner from 3rd (Perez) safe at home.
You are right, I'm not sure why this is in the video. Unless the title is Awful Call by Umpire/Players
Bonds not needing to tag up actually is relevant. He did not, which is why he was safe.
If they made the catch, he would have had to tag up, even after the batter was called out.
@@thejerminator877 He would have to tag up after the fielder touched the ball, just like any other fly ball.
@@alanhess9306 Runners only have to tag up if the ball is caught.
@@thejerminator877 Yes, I never said anything different.
Fun fact:not three people can be first
can we appreciate the smarts of the umpire in the second clip. knowing the rule well and executing it, great call
No shut up
Yeah pretty smart call ngl
@@arthurwg4898 it was the correct call
It wasn't the correct call, yes Reyes had rights to third base but he was tagged while being off base and that allowed Lawrie to advance to third.
@@Reexys no that's not what happened lawrie got tagged out with reyes on the bag then reyes got off the bag then got tagged out
4:45 umpires having a conference to get it right is.... awful? Okay...
The original call was awful, it’s so obvious it shouldn’t require a conference
Some umps are just completely out to lunch sometimes, like they’re at the game physically but definitely not mentally
4:25 Where's the awful call? Great job by the crew here. The umpire had a brain fart, knew he screwed up, then they conferenced and made the right call.
2:43 thats ball its not strike is this umpire paid by the Min?
Half of these are the right call
The infield fly rule clip was the correct call. The batter is immediately out because of the infield fly, removing all force plays. Since the pop-up was not caught, the runners do not need to tag up, and since there was no force play, you must tag the runner, not just step on home plate.
The infield fly call on the giants was the right call
So was the Yankees double play near the beginning-unless there was something I missed.
@@chaosawaits I thought so, but I didn't spend a lot of time analyzing the play.
@@almostfm You missed the rule that says the trail runner would only be out if two runners are touching the same base. This was the wrong call, Lawrie should not be out.
2nd clip is correct. The runner going back to the bag "owns" that bag, he wasn't on base and was tagged so he is out, the other runner cannot occupy that base therefore he is out.
But doesn’t the ahead runner have to be on the base to occupy it in the first place?
@@austinluszcz1426 Yes, you are correct and Joel is wrong.
@@clintfowler3856 It's still the lead runner's base. That's why they tagged the other guy first. If they tagged the lead runner first, the guy from 2nd would be entitled to take 3rd, and he'd be safe.
@@austinluszcz1426 no. As long as he is a live runner he is deemed to be occupying the base.
@@clintfowler3856 Again, you are incorrect.
My boy.... I/we appreciate the videos n uploads definitely, but seeing what the final ruling is on some of these is half of the enjoyment. Include em next time if possible. And if I'm alone in that sentiment, by all means disregard my nonsense.
If this was a video of awful calls it would be 69420 days long
And then you watch a baseball game and see how good umpires are most of the time.
not nearly good enough or enough of the time. the fix is easy and has been around for over a decade.
@@markeyfarrell what is this fix?
Where's the bad call on Arnaud at @7:25? Wieters drops the third strike, the bases are loaded, he steps on home plate, game is over.
1st base is occupied so the batter is automatically out and the guy on 3rd can stay on 3rd
@@BlakeHardisonMMA You are wrong. There were two outs so the batter can run even if first base is occupied. The catcher stepping on the plate is a force on the runner from third base.
@4:10 (Houston Astrisks) White wasn’t looking back at the dugout because a ball was called a strike... he was looking at the dugout wondering where his trash can bangings where!
Goddamn dude I used this video to learn how this game works and now I have bunch of angry parents calling me with death threats. This video has ruined my life.
How was 1:55 awful? It was an infield fly rule, batter was out therefore no force at any base you had to tag the runner
I still think that with the technology that we have today that the home plate umpire should be wearing a headset that is in communication with the broadcasting booth and giving him real time feed that is telling him the right call. The amount of headaches, and wrong calls made on the field would end and that would stop all this crap of players being thrown out. Fans used to pay good hard earned money to come see their favorite player's play not get thrown out by some idiot umpire that is having a bad day. This is ridiculous when a call is wrong and then the player start's to argue and gets thrown out of the game because of it. I umped a lot of games and I always told the crew that if they had a better angle at a call to call a conference and we would make the right call. Ya some of our games might have taken a little longer but the teams I believe appreciated that we did our best to get the calls right. I think that I only through out two people the entire time I umped, and that was five or six seasons.
At 9:11 bro who cares like look at the score 😂
I’ve always wondered that. Why do you complain when you’re getting blown out with 1 out left in the 9th inning?
The run down with the 2 players at third is the correct call. The player that was off the base has the right to the base. The one who is on the bag has a right to second base but not third. If he tagged the guy off the base first then third base would be open and only 1 out would have been called.
I think too many types of plays are reviewable. Out or safe, and arguably balls and strikes, are most often judgment calls. IMHO, the only calls that should be able to be reviewed are "fair or foul" calls (especially with home runs), questions of whether a ball went over the fence or not, fan interference calls, player interference, or "did he touch home plate" calls. It shouldn't be every little thing.
Of all the truly awful calls that have been made in the past decade alone, none were included in this video. If anything, this shows how hard it is to be an umpire, especially at the pro level.
On the bases, it’s pretty hard to get a perfect angle to see the whole play without missing any important parts while players are going all out to touch the base/ make the tag.
Behind the plate, it’s near impossible to make the right call on every pitch/swing when you’re dealing with fastballs that top out well over 100mph and breaking balls that defy the laws of physics, with a huge blind spot on any ball that ends up below the catchers knees.
Umpires are human, they make mistakes sometimes, but their truly awful calls come when they let their egos best them and make the games about themselves.
@@MO_Outdoorsman Who?
@@tankinator451 asked
@@MO_Outdoorsman The same people who are gonna read my comment
@@MO_OutdoorsmanI read his comment
I was expecting 10 minutes of just Angel Hernandez
These ads in the middle of the videos are getting ridiculous.
Honestly
really hate to admit it, but Angel might be right on this one 8:15 . Perzynski's left hand hits the Mariners glove as he is reaching back to touch second base. he is out ONLY if his right foot is not on the bag which i cant tell. Looks like his right foot is still on the bag. (i cant stand Angel Hernandez BTW)
Can you do Derek Jeter best plays love your videos
4:30 I think the umpire jenuinly couldn't see if he touched the bag or not because you can see him stuttering before making the call
On the tag at second where bogarts was called out on “the transfer” it was accidentally the right call as bogart slapped the hall out with his hand which is against the rules meaning it should’ve been an out
It looked to me like the runner swatted the glove in the Red Sox/Yankees clip
Maybe I am misreading the body language here but, in the first play, is Norris even making any attempt to act as though he "believes" he foul tipped the ball? I mean, it appears that he thinks he's struck out himself?
4:54 Time for me to be unbiased with my umpiring knowledge. There are 3 things that contribute to a catch; Secure possession, transfer and intentional release. Yes the catcher caught the ball, but he did not intentionally release the ball, therefore not having secure possession either. Before you guys come at my throat in the replies, don't shoot me, I'm just the messenger. I'll be more than happy to answer the questions.
I'll never forget the strike 3 call on Zobrist in the Rays vs Rangers to end the game. That was the worst I've ever seen. How is that not on here?
Whoever made this video doesn't understand the rules very well. At least a couple of these calls are correct. A lot of others are super close.
I love this Baseball channel is Baseball channel is the best🤩
Angel Hernandez would be saying how delicious the burger is all the while we’re watching him eat a hotdog.
0:51 wasn’t a bad call
The more there are of these titles I think it’s a bot account
I swear some of them are. Like "Baseball Throne". One of the worst titles is "Expulsion after strikeout". What the fuck does that even mean
I AM FROM ANCIENT GREECE there is one called crazing hit. WTF is that
@@jonathonenglebert1927 I'm gonna start reporting them for bots and see if anything happens
I AM FROM ANCIENT GREECE 😂😂
The Yankees and Blue Jays call was also correct the man on third base did not go home so third base was not open for the man on second to progress.
Nope, that was the wrong call. When Lawrie was tagged he was the only runner on the base. There is no reason Lawrie should have been called out.
2:00 was not a bad call. If the fly rule was in play it's not a force out at home. The batter was already out so the runners don't have to move. Since the ball was not caught he did not have to tag up either.
Watching this makes me sooooo mad
1:54 Is the correct call
Dude some of the
ones about the dropped third strikes are serious over reactions. You’re trying to tell me that if Gary Sánchez heard the the ball was called a dropped third, he wouldn’t just tag the hitter???? It’s not like those balls are getting to the backstop, they’re Outs anyways
Broadcasters using slow motion cameras and multiple replays: “yeah the umpire is completely wrong and I don’t know how he can miss that”
I had an ump in little league call a strike on me when the ball literally hit home plate.
The game was dead to me at that point.
Life is going to be really difficult for you
みんなちゃんとアピールするの凄い
This video should be called “umpires are human and make errors too”
That second clip, he forgot the rules of baseball.
Bogartes should have been out in the first place, he came down from the slide and slapped the infielders glove causing the ball to come out.
5:36
Umpires are so overly sensitive and they all have such big egos. How can someone like Joe West or Angel Hernandez still have their jobs? If I messed up my job as much as they do I would’ve been fired YEARS ago
That Xander Boegarts slide has me disliking his entire game now..
0:38 is the right call - Reyes is on their when Lawrie gets tag also on third. The rule is if two players are in the same base, who ever originally occupied it is safe. At that point, Lawrie is out and eliminated from the play. Then Reyes comes off the bag and is tagged out.
Reyes was not on the base. He would still be considered as not on it when lawrie is tagged. Therefore Lawrie is safe and reyes is out not both of them a\are out
I thought I would get laughs and giggles from this video. I left this video anoid
I love players getting mad 😂😂
I feel bad for the umpire around 4:35, you can tell he was confused when he called him safe.
Suzuki spelt it into the garage was an out because basically it was in the air when he caught it and never hit the ground
Some of these are awfully correct
There were a few calls in here that were fantastic. Some were bad, but....
I was so great full for the first Yankees one I was watching it on tv and I’m like yessssss and I threw a popcorn at the tv in excitement
I’ll be honest, I umpired a few little league games and I blew a couple really bad calls and got chewed out bad for it. Ever since I’ve gone a little easier on the umps. Except for angel Hernandez of course
So are most mlb umpires/refs just bad quality or is it just the odd thing here and there
6:13 How is that safe? I thought you were out the instant you were tagged.
Only if the fielder is in control of the ball. If the ball is knocked out of his glove by the runner making a legal move then the fielder is not in control of the ball
2:11 I spy Fernando Tatis Sr.
Isn’t 6:19 out regardless if he catches it or gets it off the bounce? There are runners on 1st and 2nd (if I’m wrong, I take responsibility lol)
Denorfia was arguing for a foul tip.
Odd how Pierzinski was allowed to reach first after you saw the umpire clench the fist saying he's out.
The angels got jobbed that game
Many of them are bad calls, but very tough to make. Especially those ball tip/bounced pitches calls, for which umpires rely as much on noise as on sight, and which happen in milli-seconds, with a catcher standing in your way. The ump cannot see the ball bouncing just before the catcher's glove, he has to really on noise and his own prediction of the ball's movement. They are expert in that, but still human. And for many of those plays on the bases, their angle of view was not optimal to make the right call. That's why camera reviews use multiple angles...
the reason why he hit him with his hand is probably so they could think he got tagged out and that is it looked liked they tagged him
I cant stand how little the tv guys know....SORRY Tim, its not how long you have it...the ball must survive the transfer...a bunch of these were the right calls....learn the rules
At 1:04 number 35 you have gotta get him credit for jumping over the guys arm
One time in one of my games the ball was in the dirt and the ump called it a strike
4:10 that is a good call now
God damnit I watch these videos for obviously bad calls but some of these are borderline if not good calls.
i dont know if you guys knew but 10:26 was the crasiest part
What's the problem with the Blue Jay's not knowing what happens on an infield fly and letting Bonds score? Is that a bad call?
I like to think that the catchers are good framers
They should change the replay rules so that foul tips are reviewable. The umpire can't possibly see the ones that are in or near the dirt - he can only go by sound.
I was surprised that all these clips weren’t just angel hernandez
7:26 is the right call. The runner from third is forced.
It's not the right call though. Although this play should result in an out, he calls the incorrect out. Umpire is calling a strikeout and catch. Even though the catcher does the right thing and tags home for the force, the ump missed that call. So not only did this ump get one call wrong, he got two wrong in mere seconds!!
@@TehGamesaver It is absolutely the correct call. The catcher did not catch the pitch, so the runner can attempt to advance which ends up being a force play at the plate.
umpires on the take should be called this video
The ads screwed this vid
1:21 as a Padres fan he’s safe
but wasn't the first one a drop 3rd
The one with bonds is undeniably the right call, a one or two were probably right, and about half are just hard calls to make because the ump can't see. A Lot of these aren't awful at all
1:37 he is safe