Why was Islamic country carved out of India when Muslims stayed behind. Partion was done on basis of religion as in ACT OF PARTITION Where Muslims wanted a Islamic nation for themselves . Today minorities have been persecuted in Pakistan and Bangladesh. From 23% to 2%in Pakistan . From 28% to early 8% left in Bangladesh. Yet in India Muslim community gre from around 30million to more than 200 million. This needs to be acknowledged that Partition was done on religious basis . And We are suffering huge consequences from it.
Partition was done between Muslim party Muslim league and secular Congress. It has nothing to do with Hindu religion, The name Hindu/Hindu Mahasabha were used by Congress and it's pet academicians to hide their crime .Hindu nationalist organisation were never strong at that time all hindus blindly followed Congress and Gandhi.Infact Hindus,Sikhs and other dharmic faiths are cheated and India was made secular and today we are facing the same problem of Muslim appeasement and once again Hindus are blamed for everything wrong. Many Hindu princely states joined India in the hope that India will become a Hindu nation and their native culture will be protected , but it never happened. Infact partion is the biggest cruelty and cheating with people of Dharmic faith....
My both set of grandparents were children when they moved in this part of India with their families. Most people living here cannot understand that those people lived without money for many years. It was my grandfather who was a hardworking young teenager in those days and he belonged to family of industrialist, yet he worked hard as a tailor during day and studied during night and earned himself masters degree in english, even though he was all rounder in studies but couldn't afford to go to abroad to study engineering. He even taught me maths and science in till my middle school. He's no longer with us but many people remember him in our community because he gave free english tutions to many students who later on became doctors, engineers, IAS officers. Later on, when his father died (even though he was angry with my father because he refused to run his factories and business and instead want to immerge himself in social causes and field of teaching) he left some letters for my grandfather (my family always believed that no matter what you do later in life education is the foremost foundation for successful human being) he wrote that even though he could never express how proud of Manu (my grandfather) he was. On the other side, my grandmother was equally well qualified lady, she also done her bachelor's in nursing and even got accepted in government school but due to her father in laws objection couldn't join. She also comes from the family of traders of dry fruits and came quiet early (a year before partition). One of her brother owns Lakhani company (if you live in North India you must have heard about it). She was really talented women too. Due to her managing the household we are today living more than a decent life. She never complained that money was less and she can't serve any guest, she was creative and even could make delicacies from barely two ingredient. I was raised by my grandparents my whole life that is why I know so much about them. They sacrificed a lot (a story from riches to rags and then riches) and it was there good karma and philanthropist nature that they lived a good life in their later stage and may RIP.
O my God! 【George Santayana, a philosopher, essayist, poet, and novelist said】: "Those who do not remember the past are condemned to repeat it." "Only the dead have seen the end of the war".
It’s sad that people think it’s only partition victims that have lost many things, when Gandhi was killed, Brahmins across the country were butchered, I am not Brahmin, but from baniya community, my ancestors had to flee Maharashtra, leaving overnight. Nobody even talks about us. We are the wrong people. Because we were born in a community that lived closer or Brahmin zone in villages. It’s ironic how Gandhi actually wanted to continue varna system, but his followers hated brahmins and baniya. Even today if we go to native place, any SC ST person in tehsildar office doesn’t treat us equal. He in fact abused my dad for having lighter skin. It’s funny because most of my uncle aunts have married in other lower castes, without any inhibition, yet we because of our skin colour are considered casteist. This country is doomed. It will doom in social space. I am done with hope for better India. Because In the end, someone will be victim.
Actually partition victims should have been given reservation benefits for 3 generations. But because they belonged to so called Majority community they dint get Minority benefits. Even some Muslims who came / returned to India in 1947 are given Minority Rights but minority Hindus from Pakistan are treated as Majority people once they reach India. What an irony.
@@property_tommorow9918 both sides of my family left our lands and properties in India. Indians weren't the only ones who lost everything in partition and rebuilt themselves
@@muhammadhaque3448 what you say is true. But you have to look @ percentages and numbers. West pakistan has maybe 2% hindus mostly poor. East pakistan 10% population mostly poor. India still has special schemes - education, scholarship, loans@ nominal interest for all minorities. Since Muslims largest minority- they benefit more than Christian or Sikhs. By population Muslims 22% or so India's population. Rich Muslim families half went Pakistan- half stayed and retained property. Pataudis, Bhopal Nawab example. Even prominent Hindus like JNMandal, cabinet Minister Pak had to run away, 1st person (hindu) to write Pak national anthem ( since replaced) also had to run away from pak. JINNAH nor Liaquat Ali never came out on streets to help Hindus but Gandhi and Nehru came out on streets to help Muslims. Even occupied mosques by destitute hindus/ Sikhs in Delhi 1947 48 were vacated and handed back to Muslim community. AMU Aligarh still continues same name same management but DAV Lahore and Dayal Singh College, Lahore are Islamic institutions since 1947. Only sir Ganga Ram Hospital , Lahore retains its old name. But Delhi is full of Aurangazeb Road, humayan lane, Akbar road etc. Now India Muslim males have mostly Hindu girlfriends and sometimes the Hindu girls driven to suicide, sometimes they chopped up and bodies disposed. Can a Hindu in Pakistan openly have Muslim girlfriends ??
Followers of muhmmd klld lakhs of non believers during 1947 partition. But one must not be amazed, since they have been doing it from last 1400yrs on name of imaginary yalla who didn't existed before muhmmod imagined him!
No we aren’t... no more illusions about Gangs-Jamuni Tehzeeb.. btw.. this 1947 partition as it is called, was created long back with Bang-Bhang in 1905.. and script of Islamic separatism was written much before Khilaft movement
That's why Government of India has decided to observe 16 th August as the Partition Horror Remembrance Day..... Each and every India has the right to know what happened to their forefathers in the name of Plan Balkan .....
I can understand there feelings as my family too migrated to india....ive grown up listening to such stories.... all of this happened due to the BRITISH
Sigh...if only India and Pakistan, China and Taiwan, North and South Korea, could ALL be reunited someday under free and democratic governments, bringing Asia into a new age of harmony and peace. :)
Sorry Bhaijee I DISAGREE with you in your wish for INDIA/BHARAT to unite with those nations you had quoted. Bear in mind that INDIA/BHARAT is a totally different nation compared o those nations RELIGIOUSLY, CULTURALLY AND DEMOCRATICALLY. Moreover my HINDU BROTHERS and SISTERS had SUFFERED enough at the hands of FOREIGNERS (MUSLIMS, CHRISTIANS and others). Please allow HINDU'S the space and time to heal the wounds that was inflicted upon them. HINDU belief and practice of secularism had made them pay a bitter price even until this day. JAI HINDUSTAN. . . . JAI HIND
Hearing about the partition is always painful. People blame the British but I blame our so called leaders who failed to lead. One doesn't expect anything better from the British. They were only interested in looting the country and once the country was drained of all wealth they were no longer bothered what happened to us. The Muslim league was only interested in implementing their agenda of Ghazwa-I-hind. The real fault lies with Gandhi for endlessly appeasing the muslims at the cost of the larger interests of our country. As for Nehru, a petty man with a large ego, he was only interested in getting power. He knew he could never become PM on his own merit so long as leaders like Bose and Sardar Patel existed. So he staked the lives and well being of millions of his countrymen to pander to the British and Muslim league. After partition he let the Muslims stay in India. Patel wanted an exchange of population but Nehru wanted his vote bank. We are paying the price of his stupidity and selfish ambition to this day. Millions were massacred during the partition and 1971 Bangladesh freedom struggle. Even today not a day goes by when a hindu is not raped or killed somewhere in the subcontinent.
History gives us the opportunity to learn from past mistakes. It helps us understand the many reasons why people may behave the way they do. As a result, it helps us become more compassionate as people and more impartial as decision makers.
@@anmolpatelfifa relating everything o secularism has become a defence mechanism.... Is it not true Ind housed all religion post partitions? And Pak only with Muslims? ... What was told was in the benefits of there own instresting and may not be the truth
I am glad that the citizens of India broke the chains of colonization, my people over here in the States and other places are currently still bound by the same people (white america are their "British" descendants). This is some good history to reflect upon before jumping into the bed with these people that has become so humanitarian these days when their own are threaten.
Appeasement Appeasement By Gandhi Nehru of jinna consented devision of this country. Lakh of people died. Appeasement continues by those people. Unpardonable
They destroyed themselves. So called Ottoman Caliphate was a weakling relic and later Mughals and sultanates were degenerate alcoholics who would've been toppled once their Ottoman military support stopped coming.
It’s heartbreaking to hear their pain… god bless them 🙏🏽
Peaceful community as always spreading peace since 6th century
Let them go to hell
The all time brave n great warriors muslims
@@kishwarsakina5173 So you support killing of Hindu right by Muslim so called brave.
Lol and you were the ones proud of killing innocents and sending two trains of dead people. So much peace you lendus spread.
Wion never disappointed us ... Always speak truth and give an absolute and understandable news with facts and highlighted incident. Great work..👍👍
Why was Islamic country carved out of India when Muslims stayed behind. Partion was done on basis of religion as in ACT OF PARTITION Where Muslims wanted a Islamic nation for themselves .
Today minorities have been persecuted in Pakistan and Bangladesh. From 23% to 2%in Pakistan . From 28% to early 8% left in Bangladesh. Yet in India Muslim community gre from around 30million to more than 200 million.
This needs to be acknowledged that Partition was done on religious basis . And We are suffering huge consequences from it.
I totally agree with you Bhaijee and its never too late for OUR HINDU'S to take back into our fold what we were ROBBED of.
@JPREET Dhillon yes... Chutya those killed by mulls were mostly Sikhs..
Partition was done between Muslim party Muslim league and secular Congress. It has nothing to do with Hindu religion, The name Hindu/Hindu Mahasabha were used by Congress and it's pet academicians to hide their crime .Hindu nationalist organisation were never strong at that time all hindus blindly followed Congress and Gandhi.Infact Hindus,Sikhs and other dharmic faiths are cheated and India was made secular and today we are facing the same problem of Muslim appeasement and once again Hindus are blamed for everything wrong. Many Hindu princely states joined India in the hope that India will become a Hindu nation and their native culture will be protected , but it never happened. Infact partion is the biggest cruelty and cheating with people of Dharmic faith....
Thank you so much for this. Please bring more and more of these stories. We would love to know our "ACTUAL HISTORY".
Yet today society gives respect to the Royal Family..... ridiculous
Britain will one day definitely pay the price for dividing Bharat
It's coming to the british courtesy of indians/pakistanis.
@@zarty8121 yes majesty
My both set of grandparents were children when they moved in this part of India with their families. Most people living here cannot understand that those people lived without money for many years. It was my grandfather who was a hardworking young teenager in those days and he belonged to family of industrialist, yet he worked hard as a tailor during day and studied during night and earned himself masters degree in english, even though he was all rounder in studies but couldn't afford to go to abroad to study engineering. He even taught me maths and science in till my middle school. He's no longer with us but many people remember him in our community because he gave free english tutions to many students who later on became doctors, engineers, IAS officers. Later on, when his father died (even though he was angry with my father because he refused to run his factories and business and instead want to immerge himself in social causes and field of teaching) he left some letters for my grandfather (my family always believed that no matter what you do later in life education is the foremost foundation for successful human being) he wrote that even though he could never express how proud of Manu (my grandfather) he was.
On the other side, my grandmother was equally well qualified lady, she also done her bachelor's in nursing and even got accepted in government school but due to her father in laws objection couldn't join. She also comes from the family of traders of dry fruits and came quiet early (a year before partition). One of her brother owns Lakhani company (if you live in North India you must have heard about it). She was really talented women too. Due to her managing the household we are today living more than a decent life. She never complained that money was less and she can't serve any guest, she was creative and even could make delicacies from barely two ingredient.
I was raised by my grandparents my whole life that is why I know so much about them.
They sacrificed a lot (a story from riches to rags and then riches) and it was there good karma and philanthropist nature that they lived a good life in their later stage and may RIP.
O my God!
【George Santayana, a philosopher, essayist, poet, and novelist said】:
"Those who do not remember the past are condemned to repeat it."
"Only the dead have seen the end of the war".
It’s sad that people think it’s only partition victims that have lost many things, when Gandhi was killed, Brahmins across the country were butchered, I am not Brahmin, but from baniya community, my ancestors had to flee Maharashtra, leaving overnight.
Nobody even talks about us. We are the wrong people. Because we were born in a community that lived closer or Brahmin zone in villages.
It’s ironic how Gandhi actually wanted to continue varna system, but his followers hated brahmins and baniya.
Even today if we go to native place, any SC ST person in tehsildar office doesn’t treat us equal. He in fact abused my dad for having lighter skin. It’s funny because most of my uncle aunts have married in other lower castes, without any inhibition, yet we because of our skin colour are considered casteist.
This country is doomed. It will doom in social space.
I am done with hope for better India.
Because In the end, someone will be victim.
Actually partition victims should have been given reservation benefits for 3 generations. But because they belonged to so called Majority community they dint get Minority benefits. Even some Muslims who came / returned to India in 1947 are given Minority Rights but minority Hindus from Pakistan are treated as Majority people once they reach India. What an irony.
@@property_tommorow9918 both sides of my family left our lands and properties in India. Indians weren't the only ones who lost everything in partition and rebuilt themselves
@@muhammadhaque3448 what you say is true. But you have to look @ percentages and numbers. West pakistan has maybe 2% hindus mostly poor. East pakistan 10% population mostly poor. India still has special schemes - education, scholarship, loans@ nominal interest for all minorities. Since Muslims largest minority- they benefit more than Christian or Sikhs. By population Muslims 22% or so India's population. Rich Muslim families half went Pakistan- half stayed and retained property. Pataudis, Bhopal Nawab example.
Even prominent Hindus like JNMandal, cabinet Minister Pak had
to run away, 1st person (hindu) to write Pak national anthem ( since replaced) also had to run away from pak. JINNAH nor Liaquat Ali never came out on streets to help Hindus but Gandhi and Nehru came out on streets to help Muslims. Even occupied mosques by destitute hindus/ Sikhs in Delhi 1947 48 were vacated and handed back to Muslim community. AMU Aligarh still continues same name same management but DAV Lahore and Dayal Singh College, Lahore are Islamic institutions since 1947. Only sir Ganga Ram Hospital , Lahore retains its old name. But Delhi is full of Aurangazeb Road, humayan lane, Akbar road etc.
Now India Muslim males have mostly Hindu girlfriends and sometimes the Hindu girls driven to suicide, sometimes they chopped up and bodies disposed. Can a Hindu in Pakistan openly have Muslim girlfriends ??
Followers of muhmmd klld lakhs of non believers during 1947 partition. But one must not be amazed, since they have been doing it from last 1400yrs on name of imaginary yalla who didn't existed before muhmmod imagined him!
Some of the darkest days in our History.
Best day for Bangladesh.
I am a Pakistani German 🇩🇪
I love my India 🇮🇳 as much as i love my Pakistan 🇵🇰 We are one ❤️
True brother, respect & love from India 🇮🇳🇵🇰
India was never yours . Never will be.
No we aren’t... no more illusions about Gangs-Jamuni Tehzeeb.. btw.. this 1947 partition as it is called, was created long back with Bang-Bhang in 1905.. and script of Islamic separatism was written much before Khilaft movement
@@appumini gand me kisne de dia tere gandu?
Our United Panjab Was divided 💔
All of India was divided not just Punjab
That's why Government of India has decided to observe 16 th August as the Partition Horror Remembrance Day.....
Each and every India has the right to know what happened to their forefathers in the name of Plan Balkan .....
It should be declared as "Lest We Forget Day" or "Hindu Holocaust Day"
Good Work WION never cease to amaze us 👍
What a disgracefull action by the british politicians....
Jai Hind 🥺🇮🇳 Happy Independence Day
This forced human migration,Blood bath and mass killings, Thank You Nehru,Jinnah ,Gandhi ,Thou Spirit shall never be left with the crime
I can understand there feelings as my family too migrated to india....ive grown up listening to such stories....
all of this happened due to the BRITISH
Sigh...if only India and Pakistan, China and Taiwan, North and South Korea, could ALL be reunited someday under free and democratic governments, bringing Asia into a new age of harmony and peace. :)
This is what everybody on this planet is hoping for.
That is impossible with communist and Islamic Governments.
Sorry Bhaijee I DISAGREE with you in your wish for INDIA/BHARAT to unite with those nations you had quoted. Bear in mind that INDIA/BHARAT is a totally different nation compared o those nations RELIGIOUSLY, CULTURALLY AND DEMOCRATICALLY. Moreover my HINDU BROTHERS and SISTERS had SUFFERED enough at the hands of FOREIGNERS (MUSLIMS, CHRISTIANS and others). Please allow HINDU'S the space and time to heal the wounds that was inflicted upon them. HINDU belief and practice of secularism had made them pay a bitter price even until this day. JAI HINDUSTAN. . . . JAI HIND
We dont dream
ಇದು ಶಾಂತಿದೂತರಕೊಡುಗೆ.
ಇದು ನಮ್ಮ ಯಾವ ಇತಿಹಾಸ ಪುಸ್ತಕ ದಲ್ಲಿ ಓದಿದ ನೆನಪಿದೆಯೇ.
One of the darkest time of our Indian History.
Some of them went to Hong Kong and they shared their very bitter experience with us.
hum pakistani or indian aj bhe ya chez dekh ka dukh karta he kese logon na migration ki huge
Hearing about the partition is always painful. People blame the British but I blame our so called leaders who failed to lead. One doesn't expect anything better from the British. They were only interested in looting the country and once the country was drained of all wealth they were no longer bothered what happened to us. The Muslim league was only interested in implementing their agenda of Ghazwa-I-hind. The real fault lies with Gandhi for endlessly appeasing the muslims at the cost of the larger interests of our country. As for Nehru, a petty man with a large ego, he was only interested in getting power. He knew he could never become PM on his own merit so long as leaders like Bose and Sardar Patel existed. So he staked the lives and well being of millions of his countrymen to pander to the British and Muslim league. After partition he let the Muslims stay in India. Patel wanted an exchange of population but Nehru wanted his vote bank. We are paying the price of his stupidity and selfish ambition to this day. Millions were massacred during the partition and 1971 Bangladesh freedom struggle. Even today not a day goes by when a hindu is not raped or killed somewhere in the subcontinent.
History gives us the opportunity to learn from past mistakes. It helps us understand the many reasons why people may behave the way they do. As a result, it helps us become more compassionate as people and more impartial as decision makers.
Well explained
India, Pakistan , Bangladesh , Sri Lanka , Maldives and Nepal Should Reunite Into a Single Secular Country.
Kyo bhai? Kya muslimo ka kum problem hai jo tum usko add kana chahete ho!
@@ketanshah2314
ماذا يعني ذلك باللغة العربية أو الإنجليزية؟
Not possible at all
@@saddamhussein4480 he said "are the Muslims we already have not enough of a problem, that you want to add more?"
@@muhammadhaque3448 Thanks for The Translation.
unfortunately told incorrect. The partition was btw Muslims into Pak and Rest of the Religions(incl. Muslims) into India...
Partition was based on two nation theory ....ie hindus and muslims are two different nations ...So stop secularising every thing
@@anmolpatelfifa relating everything o secularism has become a defence mechanism.... Is it not true Ind housed all religion post partitions? And Pak only with Muslims? ... What was told was in the benefits of there own instresting and may not be the truth
This could've been entirely prevented if the shameless British Raj put the Military there during the Partition.
Thank god for partition, now I can live in peace and eat my beef steak.
Ise hindi me bana ke zee news pe bhi daalo. Wion jitna badhiya content zee news pe nahi hota
I am glad that the citizens of India broke the chains of colonization, my people over here in the States and other places are currently still bound by the same people (white america are their "British" descendants). This is some good history to reflect upon before jumping into the bed with these people that has become so humanitarian these days when their own are threaten.
Wea re yet to get our homeland .
One of my ancestors was beheaded 😡😡😡😡😭😭😭
😭😭😭😭
In trains imagine the plight of toilets
Appeasement
Appeasement
By Gandhi Nehru of jinna consented devision of this country. Lakh of people died. Appeasement continues by those people. Unpardonable
India was no stranger to colonization or colonialism before the 16th century CE
My fore father's were from east bengal then turned into east Pakistan 🤬🥺🥺
I have uploaded a video on Iranian military and why Israel must fear us
Iran should fix their economy and degenerate, corrupt government first.
after what happened, many British-occupied countries still love their master via Commonwealth of Nations and Commonwealth Games 😚💩
Stop blaming British for Muslim Separatism
WELL THEY FUELED MUSLIM FUNDAMENTALIST IT SO BRITISHERS ARE NOT INNOCENT EITHER.
READ HISTORY KID
Yeah, coz they only took advantage of what they saw was an easier target and they did exactly that - DIVIDE AND RULE!
We don't have to blame British, history speaks itself...they are the reason for separatism .. end of story.
leechad muslamaan
The British always destroyed muslims by dividing whether it was a turkey caliphate or indian subcontinent
Muslims 🤦♀️🤦♀️ than you don't know history of indian subcontinent..
They destroyed themselves. So called Ottoman Caliphate was a weakling relic and later Mughals and sultanates were degenerate alcoholics who would've been toppled once their Ottoman military support stopped coming.
British sided with Muslims to destroy Hindus and create Pakistan,otherwise India would never have been divided