I love the Marylin Monroe meets Betty Boop Concept that they did❤️🔥I've never seen another group do concepts like G-IDLE! They used Yuqi's deep voice to perfection in this song. Never been able to pick a bias but I think I might have this comeback... and Shuhua?!?! I've never heard her like this. The vocals? The presence? They all dominated this comeback ❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥
"I'm born nude. You just got a dirty mind." "Think outside the box." "Cause ur views so rude." Yup, you know what it is all about. It is clear. THESE GIRLS SLAYEDD!!!!
This might be one of my favorite idle concepts in awhile. The message reminds me a lot of Chanmina's Bijin - the 'spectacle' and expectations and sort of making fun of that whole celebrity culture especially as it pertains to and harms women. Idle don't come across as furious as Chanmina, but i really like that because their audience is different - they instead make it clear they'll just do what they want anyway.
When you paused the video on Soyeon at 12:27, I never noticed the oversized baubles on her. IMO they made her look like a giant accessory or piece of jewelry. Everything she chooses to show and wear has meaning, so it made me think there has to be a reason she dressed this way. Thanks for the deep analysis and insight.
If you watch carefully and look at animated woman she has soojin's beauty mark under her eye. Sort of their way of still havign Soojin there with them. You did a really excellent job catchign all the concept points. The (G)I-dle Self Love Era has been epic!
listen to their entire album! Dark is a crazy track The mv, the comments, things, her story i love it Miyeon Yuqi and Shuhua's voices killed me Miss Soojin here
The best of it all? It's just that it was probably ingeniously thought out. In Korea it is very common for men to take pictures of nude women without their consent, so there is a lot of research for these nudes there, and with gidle nxde they made all the research go to their music and fought the sharing of these images. Besides that in Korea, "IDLE" is like a "child", so if someone searches for images of children, they'll give it to their music. I don't know if that was intentional or not, but either way it was fucking brilliant and amazing. For me, the best comeback of the YEAR, and I don't say that just because I'm a fan and they are my favorite group in all of kpop. They didn't just bring a concept and a message behind the song like they always do, this time they went further and that's very significant. These girls are so genius it's amazing. I love them so much. 💜
Hi! Thank you so much for your reaction! I am honestly blown away by this concept! GIDLE Nxde’s concept of the music video was inspired by the actress Marilyn Monroe and old Hollywood Glamour era. •There were alot of historical references in the music video and the song lyrics about Marilyn Monroe,literary references,and messaging of women empowerment. •I am not sure if the song sampled a classical song. The instrumentals seem similar to me.Can anyone please let me know. Thank you. •All of the girls look stunning, but Shu-hua is really standing out to me..
The chorus has a modified sample of the theme "Habanera" from Bizet's opera Carmen. The cone bra worn by Soyeon is a design by Jean-Paul Gaultier made for Madonna's Blonde Ambition tour which started April 1990. (Madonna's was a pink corset design with not as large cones!!) The shredded artwork is a reference to Banksy who through a piece of peformance art shredded his "Girl with Balloon" piece which had sold for £1million prior to shredding. It was then sold as a piece named "Love is in the Bin" for £18.5million !!
Idle has always been my fav kpop group and honestly after i saw this vid and heard the song OMG THEYRE SO FREAKING GOOD AND I LOVE THEM EVEN MORE THE VIBE THEY GIVE IS SO SPECIAL AND SO EMPOWERED 😫
They came to my state but I couldn't go and it made me sad they are so amazing and beautiful and so many wonderful things I've been a Neverland since Uh huh and I will always support my ladies💖
It's official! K-pop is diving deep into the 90's. So many referrences (musically, visually, lyrically) in so many videos by so many groups or solo idols. I LOVE IT! p.s. who, under the age of 35, would recognize Madona's "Vogue" bra that Soyeon wears?💝
i love your reaction and all the connections and commentary you made throughout!! i literally watched other reactions and men were so intimidated and taken aback by this they just stuttered "this is like... important because like... women" 😂 girl pls shuha shone so bright in this and not only brcause of the platinum hair hehe finally!!! and man im gonna go rewatch moulin rouge now i also totally agree with your commentry on blonde
Since getting into k-pop a few years ago I've primarily been an Army and Neverland, and I still can't pick a bias in I-DLE either. 😂 They're all so freaking individually talented. And this comeback is everything... the message, the concept, and the b-sides are fantastic too.
Video on accident loved it to death now I now I am a fan of this girl group officially and I bought 2 of the versions of the new album with this song on it I need one more and then I'll have the entire collection of this album with this song on it lol
I love this concept and message! You should see their episode of Street Alcohol Fighter. I love how they tell on each other, are honest, and have a good time. I can't wait for part 2!
havent seen a lot of burlesque concepts since sistar and brown eyed girls....but (g)idle defo ate this up! Love the golden 20s glam era look....soyeon intro was just immaculate!
As a Dutch person, Iris Van Herpen is pronounced as E-ris (think Anne with an E) Van (the an sound is a lot like the ann in annyeonghaseyo) Hare (as in those rabbit-like animals) - p- un (the Dutch 'En' is vocally somewhere between the English An and the Chinese Un you hear in names like Jun. Try for a sound that sounds like the gray area between those two).
The animated woman? It’s blonde Soojin. People have tried to argue with me that it’s Marilyn Monroe. It’s not. Marilyn stuck with her iconic above the shoulder hairstyle throughout her career. The animated character did not have that hair. Also, Marilyn did not have her birthmark near her eye. It was off to the side equidistant between her left nostril and lips. The animated woman has the birthmark under her left eye. You know who else has a birthmark under her left eye? Soojin.
@@lene7793 The video as a whole was inspired by Marilyn and Banksy. That statement didn’t specify the animated character was inspired by Marilyn. Besides, facts are facts and if it was inspired by Marilyn then the birthmark would be in the correct place and gave her the iconic hair.
In my personal opinion & I love Soyeon I do wish instead of the ‘first’ rap in the beginning I wish she JUST did the second rap in the middle of the song. I think it would’ve flowed better personally & the second rap is def my favorite I think if the 1st rap was taken out the line distribution would’ve been better because then the other girls could’ve gotten to sing some other lines in the song instead but that’s just my opinion still love the song
@@CarterLa_14 nah not passive aggressive at all! I just wanted to clarify😅 in my previous videos of them, Neverlands were informing me that the G was dropped so I’m learning to use IDLE now, but people still call them GIDLE so I just acknowledge both😁
Not sure how I feel about a Korean girl group invoking the culture and struggles of woman from the west (my culture). Different cultures, values, norms and different levels of progress leading up to fair treatment and rights of woman. In Korea today and Japan, these countries are much more masculine driven compared to the west. Additionally, Korea and Japan are collective societies and not individualistic societies... so ya, wrong message for a beautiful Kpop group if they are trying to portray this kind of message to a fan like me who is married into a Korean family, educated and has been all around the world and knows Asian cultures extremely well.. and the history of those countries. (But that is just my opinion). That said, yes all woman were expected to conform to cultural norms in their society for the time but in todays society.... no group places more "expectations" on woman more so than... woman themselves. Think about it. I grew up w/ a lot of sisters... they were so competitive w/ one another. Today I work in the Corporate/Sr. Gov sector, I can honestly say, no group hates to see woman succeed like other executive woman because they are competing. Its weird.. but this song is no longer emblematic of the struggles of woman in the west. P.S. love you OG.. keep the reviews coming. P.S.S. Marylin Monroe was absolutely no saint... lol. Ya, big miss understanding of who she was and what she did.
Thanks for the support and sharing your opinion! I think you got me mixed up about my comment on Marilyn though. I’m American, and I know the history of what goes on here, and I know that she was definitely no saint. I just stated that I wasn’t keen on watching Blonde b/c I’m not interested in seeing r*pe scenes. They make me uncomfortable.😣
@@ogkpopstan I understand now. I didn't see the movie Blonde... perhaps I should go watch and see how they portray her. I love watching your reviews and I'm so happy to be a Patreon contributor to your effort. Keep up the great work.. you are amazing! OH did you know KARA is coming back w/ a song together for their 15th? PLEASE watch and review when it drops. I'm a 1st gen and 2nd gen Kpop fan. My groups are SES/FIN KL/BabyVox and Second Gen such as Girls Generation/KARA/TARA and way to many more to list. Thanks OG!
The choreography wasn’t out when the M/V was, I will analyze the choreography once it’s out and when I’m able to. I keep my titles the same for consistency. I hope that’s not hard to understand.😀
@@ssua3035 I don’t react to live stages or showcase stages due to the copyright ways with the big companies, due to being copyright-striked twice in the past. Plus, I react to dance practices versus stages because of it being a full focus one shot video versus a stage that has transition cuts and zooming in and out. I’m being serious.👍🏼
@@ogkpopstan even if the practice video isn't out, the full choreo is shown in the fist stage/fancam, so... two different things. but yeah, makes sense about the copyright stuff.
I realised, when shuhua is in the green dress with blonde hair. It reminded me of the movie scene in Burlesque with Cristina Aguilera in the long green dress on stage
shuhua ate this era and left no crumbs but can we talk about yuqi's voice tho the growl kill me
the growl was sooooooo GOOD
I know!!
Yaa she slayed 💅. I think this is first time she has ever changed hair colour right?
@@suspikachu3110 shuhua or yuqi
the “PEOgina utge PEOgina utge” made me levitate
Fun fact Shuhua is 2nd in terms of line distribution and freaking killed it, it's defenitly her era
I'm so happy for her 😭✨
she ate😭😭😭 I couldnt take my eyes off her
SHES SO BEAHTIFULLLLL
Shushua look very much like Aheye 4Eve.
shuhua ate this concept
I mean all of them, but I did not expect for shushu to do that!!!
I love the Marylin Monroe meets Betty Boop Concept that they did❤️🔥I've never seen another group do concepts like G-IDLE! They used Yuqi's deep voice to perfection in this song. Never been able to pick a bias but I think I might have this comeback... and Shuhua?!?! I've never heard her like this. The vocals? The presence? They all dominated this comeback ❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥
yes and the 1920s cartoon style is soo good
@@just_a_saeu88 It never gets old
And the animated girl is I think it's a Jessica Rabbit sort of like concept?
"I'm born nude. You just got a dirty mind."
"Think outside the box."
"Cause ur views so rude."
Yup, you know what it is all about. It is clear. THESE GIRLS SLAYEDD!!!!
Only soyeon can think of such concept, gidle always always 💅. They have freaking unique concept everytime
@@suspikachu3110 Soyeon and this group is a gem. Must protecc at all costs
@@yoobeepedmeinthebeep fr !!
This might be one of my favorite idle concepts in awhile. The message reminds me a lot of Chanmina's Bijin - the 'spectacle' and expectations and sort of making fun of that whole celebrity culture especially as it pertains to and harms women. Idle don't come across as furious as Chanmina, but i really like that because their audience is different - they instead make it clear they'll just do what they want anyway.
When you paused the video on Soyeon at 12:27, I never noticed the oversized baubles on her. IMO they made her look like a giant accessory or piece of jewelry. Everything she chooses to show and wear has meaning, so it made me think there has to be a reason she dressed this way. Thanks for the deep analysis and insight.
If you watch carefully and look at animated woman she has soojin's beauty mark under her eye. Sort of their way of still havign Soojin there with them.
You did a really excellent job catchign all the concept points. The (G)I-dle Self Love Era has been epic!
Yup, I love it that she actually mentioned Jessica Rabbit though.
The animated girl having the aura of soojin and same mole as soojin
listen to their entire album!
Dark is a crazy track
The mv, the comments, things, her story i love it
Miyeon Yuqi and Shuhua's voices killed me
Miss Soojin here
The best of it all? It's just that it was probably ingeniously thought out. In Korea it is very common for men to take pictures of nude women without their consent, so there is a lot of research for these nudes there, and with gidle nxde they made all the research go to their music and fought the sharing of these images. Besides that in Korea, "IDLE" is like a "child", so if someone searches for images of children, they'll give it to their music. I don't know if that was intentional or not, but either way it was fucking brilliant and amazing.
For me, the best comeback of the YEAR, and I don't say that just because I'm a fan and they are my favorite group in all of kpop. They didn't just bring a concept and a message behind the song like they always do, this time they went further and that's very significant. These girls are so genius it's amazing. I love them so much. 💜
I agree totally with you about the movie Blonde, this mv did so much better in doing right to Marilyn. I hope more people see the video
This concept would have really suited soojin. She has the natural sexiness to her charisma. I miss her
I was also at their concert in Houston & it was definitely one of the best concerts I’ve ever been to, they definitely deserve everything!!🫶
Hi! Thank you so much for your reaction! I am honestly blown away by this concept! GIDLE Nxde’s concept of the music video was inspired by the actress Marilyn Monroe and old Hollywood Glamour era.
•There were alot of historical references in the music video and the song lyrics about Marilyn Monroe,literary references,and messaging of women empowerment.
•I am not sure if the song sampled a classical song. The instrumentals seem similar to me.Can anyone please let me know. Thank you.
•All of the girls look stunning, but Shu-hua is really standing out to me..
Its the Habanera aria from the opera Carmen
@@chillaura Hi thank you for sharing! I had a feeling the song was sampling Classical music.
The chorus has a modified sample of the theme "Habanera" from Bizet's opera Carmen.
The cone bra worn by Soyeon is a design by Jean-Paul Gaultier made for Madonna's Blonde Ambition tour which started April 1990. (Madonna's was a pink corset design with not as large cones!!)
The shredded artwork is a reference to Banksy who through a piece of peformance art shredded his "Girl with Balloon" piece which had sold for £1million prior to shredding. It was then sold as a piece named "Love is in the Bin" for £18.5million !!
That's why it kind of felt like sanorita era
I LOVE G-IDLE'S UNIQUE CONCEPTS SO MUCH!!! AND SOYEON'S LYRICISM AND MUSIC TASTE!! 😭😭😭
Idle has always been my fav kpop group and honestly after i saw this vid and heard the song
OMG
THEYRE SO FREAKING GOOD AND I LOVE THEM EVEN MORE
THE VIBE THEY GIVE IS SO SPECIAL AND SO EMPOWERED 😫
yuqi's era imo, her voice wreck me and her outfits are freaking🥵damn.
When I first listen to Nxde the first thing on my mind is that Soojin really suit the song anyways it's a bop and Shuhua shined so bright 💖
I love the fact that they created a cartoon version of Soojin
They came to my state but I couldn't go and it made me sad they are so amazing and beautiful and so many wonderful things I've been a Neverland since Uh huh and I will always support my ladies💖
shuhua!!!!! this. is. her. eraaaa!!!!
Yes I couldn’t stop staring at Shuhua in the music video!
People noticed that the drawn girl is Soojin 🥹😭
I don't like everything that Idle puts out, but I love them for always putting out something new.
it's funny how you can't finish your comment to a certain scene because every scene's getting your attention HAHAHAHAHA, VERY RELATABLE
true😭😭😭😭
OG (G)I-DLE fans probably feel like this comeback is for a specific person and she feels SOOO included.
I always like G-idle this song made them my top girl group
The cartoon is Soojin. I’m so glad she’s still coming to us in a way 😭💗
🤯🤯🤯
OVERLOAD VISUALS ESPECIALLY SHUHUA'S ERA WAS SO GOOODD
Shuhua ate this, I really missed soojin for this concept thought, I think they did this for her
G idle is CRAZY 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥😍😍😍
As soon as she said I really love the message of the song I liked the video so hard you have no idea
Also, as a fellow OG Neverland, this song proves they are only getting better and more legendary with each comeback.
u cant just say sy is flirtatious and not expand on it 🤣🤣🤣🤣i love ur reaction
i 100% agree on your take on the blonde movie
It's official! K-pop is diving deep into the 90's. So many referrences (musically, visually, lyrically) in so many videos by so many groups or solo idols. I LOVE IT!
p.s. who, under the age of 35, would recognize Madona's "Vogue" bra that Soyeon wears?💝
it's the first time I watch you're videos and, omg, i really loved all the things you said and the way you interpreted the mv, thanks for this.
the advertisment is rlly nxde MV ofcourse i didnt skip HAHA
NEVIES UNITE! I super duper love this era, it's so inspirational!
i love your reaction and all the connections and commentary you made throughout!! i literally watched other reactions and men were so intimidated and taken aback by this they just stuttered "this is like... important because like... women" 😂 girl pls
shuha shone so bright in this and not only brcause of the platinum hair hehe finally!!! and man im gonna go rewatch moulin rouge now
i also totally agree with your commentry on blonde
Since getting into k-pop a few years ago I've primarily been an Army and Neverland, and I still can't pick a bias in I-DLE either. 😂 They're all so freaking individually talented. And this comeback is everything... the message, the concept, and the b-sides are fantastic too.
Video on accident loved it to death now I now I am a fan of this girl group officially and I bought 2 of the versions of the new album with this song on it I need one more and then I'll have the entire collection of this album with this song on it lol
I love this concept and message!
You should see their episode of Street Alcohol Fighter. I love how they tell on each other, are honest, and have a good time. I can't wait for part 2!
I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR YOUR REACTION TO THIS. & I REALIZED THAT U'RE 1 OF MY FAV REACTORS :))
havent seen a lot of burlesque concepts since sistar and brown eyed girls....but (g)idle defo ate this up!
Love the golden 20s glam era look....soyeon intro was just immaculate!
concept queens
Love them 😍 reminds me of Christina in Moulin Rouge..
love your reactions especially how speechless you are every scene 😂
subscribing you rn as a support for my co-ahganevie 💚💜
Violin is actually sampled part from Carmen opera
As a Dutch person, Iris Van Herpen is pronounced as E-ris (think Anne with an E)
Van (the an sound is a lot like the ann in annyeonghaseyo)
Hare (as in those rabbit-like animals) - p- un (the Dutch 'En' is vocally somewhere between the English An and the Chinese Un you hear in names like Jun. Try for a sound that sounds like the gray area between those two).
The animated woman? It’s blonde Soojin.
People have tried to argue with me that it’s Marilyn Monroe. It’s not. Marilyn stuck with her iconic above the shoulder hairstyle throughout her career. The animated character did not have that hair.
Also, Marilyn did not have her birthmark near her eye. It was off to the side equidistant between her left nostril and lips. The animated woman has the birthmark under her left eye. You know who else has a birthmark under her left eye?
Soojin.
At the end of the music video, it says that she was inspired by Marilyn and Banksy
@@lene7793 The video as a whole was inspired by Marilyn and Banksy. That statement didn’t specify the animated character was inspired by Marilyn.
Besides, facts are facts and if it was inspired by Marilyn then the birthmark would be in the correct place and gave her the iconic hair.
In This song they were referencing Marilyn Monroe
Shuhua coming for your biases, y'all.
Best cute reaction ever... 🥰🥰🥰🥰🤩🤩🤩✌️✌️new subscriber here..
Really wanted to see you critique their Showcase version of "Nxde", too =)
Just imagine this concept with Soojin. I rest my case...😔😔😔
This song is a bop! 🔥
On a side note, hope you can react to Billlie's Ring ma Bell! Awesome song as well!
Yes please react to Billlie’s last comeback Ring Ma Bell. Thank you.
you can see here the Twice concept from their japan album 🥰🥰 just saying
can you react to lapillus gratata and burn with love.
Aw im still hoping you'll react to Lapillus GRATATA mv and their dance practice 🥺😔❤️🙏
First. 🥰
YOU ARE 39?!??
can you react new release of lee chaeyeon
In my personal opinion & I love Soyeon I do wish instead of the ‘first’ rap in the beginning I wish she JUST did the second rap in the middle of the song. I think it would’ve flowed better personally & the second rap is def my favorite
I think if the 1st rap was taken out the line distribution would’ve been better because then the other girls could’ve gotten to sing some other lines in the song instead but that’s just my opinion still love the song
it’s idle not Gidle
That’s why I mainly call them IDLE, I just make recognition of GIDLE bc of that being their debut name👍🏼
@@ogkpopstan ahhh i see, sorry abt my comment kinda passive aggressive of me. loved the video
@@CarterLa_14 nah not passive aggressive at all! I just wanted to clarify😅 in my previous videos of them, Neverlands were informing me that the G was dropped so I’m learning to use IDLE now, but people still call them GIDLE so I just acknowledge both😁
@@ogkpopstan yeah ofc! That’s really smart and inclusive of you!
wdym, the G is still there, it was just not present in Tomboy promo images cause it stands for girl and tomboy is gender neutral
you sure you are not 1993？
Not sure how I feel about a Korean girl group invoking the culture and struggles of woman from the west (my culture). Different cultures, values, norms and different levels of progress leading up to fair treatment and rights of woman. In Korea today and Japan, these countries are much more masculine driven compared to the west. Additionally, Korea and Japan are collective societies and not individualistic societies... so ya, wrong message for a beautiful Kpop group if they are trying to portray this kind of message to a fan like me who is married into a Korean family, educated and has been all around the world and knows Asian cultures extremely well.. and the history of those countries. (But that is just my opinion). That said, yes all woman were expected to conform to cultural norms in their society for the time but in todays society.... no group places more "expectations" on woman more so than... woman themselves. Think about it. I grew up w/ a lot of sisters... they were so competitive w/ one another. Today I work in the Corporate/Sr. Gov sector, I can honestly say, no group hates to see woman succeed like other executive woman because they are competing. Its weird.. but this song is no longer emblematic of the struggles of woman in the west. P.S. love you OG.. keep the reviews coming. P.S.S. Marylin Monroe was absolutely no saint... lol. Ya, big miss understanding of who she was and what she did.
Thanks for the support and sharing your opinion! I think you got me mixed up about my comment on Marilyn though. I’m American, and I know the history of what goes on here, and I know that she was definitely no saint. I just stated that I wasn’t keen on watching Blonde b/c I’m not interested in seeing r*pe scenes. They make me uncomfortable.😣
@@ogkpopstan I understand now. I didn't see the movie Blonde... perhaps I should go watch and see how they portray her. I love watching your reviews and I'm so happy to be a Patreon contributor to your effort. Keep up the great work.. you are amazing! OH did you know KARA is coming back w/ a song together for their 15th? PLEASE watch and review when it drops. I'm a 1st gen and 2nd gen Kpop fan. My groups are SES/FIN KL/BabyVox and Second Gen such as Girls Generation/KARA/TARA and way to many more to list. Thanks OG!
The company is sabotaging them with the lyrics that don’t make sense 💀 be sounding dumb as hell lmao
watched this thinking it would be an analysis of the choreo but it was just another reaction. the title is so misleading
The choreography wasn’t out when the M/V was, I will analyze the choreography once it’s out and when I’m able to. I keep my titles the same for consistency. I hope that’s not hard to understand.😀
ummm the choreo isn’t even out
@@sehunismm the showcase stage has been out since the mv dropped be serious
@@ssua3035 I don’t react to live stages or showcase stages due to the copyright ways with the big companies, due to being copyright-striked twice in the past. Plus, I react to dance practices versus stages because of it being a full focus one shot video versus a stage that has transition cuts and zooming in and out. I’m being serious.👍🏼
@@ogkpopstan even if the practice video isn't out, the full choreo is shown in the fist stage/fancam, so... two different things. but yeah, makes sense about the copyright stuff.
I realised, when shuhua is in the green dress with blonde hair. It reminded me of the movie scene in Burlesque with Cristina Aguilera in the long green dress on stage