You already know this fellas got the max social credits LOL. What a craftsman. This asiatic style bow is like my mid term goal for bow making. Ive made two bows out of boards, and im working on a maple self bow in the cherokee style, but im slowly gathering the materials for this kinda horn bow
People were still making these bows in rural areas and in secret. When the government went full communism, bow Craftsman became carpenters and construction workers.
@@Intranetusa That is only one component. There are around 4 or five other components which are off. It's fine for target practice but isn't an accurate representation of a historical style. If you're interested in a visual comparison, check out this photo archeryhistorian.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/Manchu-Bow-3.jpg If you want a real in-depth discussion, then consider reading this article on thewayofarchery.com or watch the videos of the co-author Justin Ma. The guys behind the project are recreating/revitalizing Asiatic warbow archery. They are the equivalent of the English Warbow Society basically. sites.google.com/view/beyond-strength/home
@@MarcRitzMD Yes, I've seen Justin Ma's videos. You're talking about heavy draw weight bows shot with military archery techniques....which is one type of historical archery but was not the only type. This guy likely makes lighter "normal" draw weight bows like 98% of bowyers in the world where the bows are between 15-60 lbs. So these are not heavy 100+ lb warbows that require body tilt techniques from military archery. In England and elsewhere after the end of their respective eras of military archery, archery was still practiced as a hobby/sport rather than as a way of war - so new techniques for precision and stability rather than for power were developed. Modern Olympic archery comes from historical western sport archery that uses techniques that would be ineffective for shooting historical military draw weight warbows...but it is still a historical archery technique. These are simply historical techniques for shooting lighter bows and techniques developed after military archery was no longer used.
@@Intranetusa Yeah, then we agree on all points pretty much. What my point of contention is that it is portrayed to be these weapons of our history with all the romanticism that goes with it. To me, this seemed more like someone interviewing an Olympic fencer about Medieval swordfighting. It just hits a sore spot in me because we've all seen these kinds of videos where they've given people a platform to spread information, and it could have just been better. These documentaries or youtube videos rarely have the humility to admit to gaps in their knowledge or expertise. That guy for sure is a great bowmaker but when he dresses up like a historical warrior and make him shoot in a dramatic fashion, that blurs the line of his expertise.
![[4K] '각궁'(한국 전통 활) 제작 과정 'Gakgung' production process #세종시 #무형유산 #각궁 #전통활 #bow](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/WjgtsGKdhMs/mqdefault.jpg)
![The Wall Song ร้องข้ามกำแพง | EP.213 | กรีน อัษฎาพร | 3 ต.ค. 67 [1/5]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3KrlLbCsadI/mqdefault.jpg)
he even has the topknot hair too. great respect to this man
Funny thing is the topknot wouldve been outlawed by the Qing.
@@Jake-dh9qk yeah. And they were forced to wear those ugly queues.
@sei.tsukino that’s the worst part 😂
How'd he get pass the quee edict
You already know this fellas got the max social credits LOL. What a craftsman. This asiatic style bow is like my mid term goal for bow making. Ive made two bows out of boards, and im working on a maple self bow in the cherokee style, but im slowly gathering the materials for this kinda horn bow
I met Mr Yuan FuXi yearas ago and he let me try one of his 50# bows. Very smooth draw I wish I would have the money to buy a 70# one
Gorgeous work!
enjoyed. good. thank yew.
He even has feather fan like Zhu Ge Liang
Interesting!
Why he mostly make light bows only
Maybe he can't make heavy Qing military bows unlike his ancestors. Love your vids by the way.
Probably a good job he doesn't, otherwise you'd be a few thousand down lol.
FFS Jack, we get it you draw heavy bows.
@@turtleh no I’m genuinely curious I know people who try order a 60lb from him and it’s too heavy for him to make
WOW NICE👌👌👌💖can you teach me how to make a archery and bow I like them
Good 👍
Nice
👍🏻👍🏻💓🙏
May i share some clips of this on tiktok?
No
@@erichuang2553 yes.
Shocked it is not baned at least they have some means of Defense a bow and arrow can go through a soft body armor
Somethings are just too ridiculous to ban.
Started in the 1720s?...how did the workshop survived China's cultural revolution?
People were still making these bows in rural areas and in secret. When the government went full communism, bow Craftsman became carpenters and construction workers.
He doesn't even shoot like historical Chinese archers
What do you mean? He is shooting in the Asiatic thumb draw style with a thumb ring. That is what historical Chinese archers used.
@@Intranetusa That is only one component. There are around 4 or five other components which are off. It's fine for target practice but isn't an accurate representation of a historical style. If you're interested in a visual comparison, check out this photo archeryhistorian.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/Manchu-Bow-3.jpg
If you want a real in-depth discussion, then consider reading this article on thewayofarchery.com or watch the videos of the co-author Justin Ma. The guys behind the project are recreating/revitalizing Asiatic warbow archery. They are the equivalent of the English Warbow Society basically.
sites.google.com/view/beyond-strength/home
@@MarcRitzMD Yes, I've seen Justin Ma's videos. You're talking about heavy draw weight bows shot with military archery techniques....which is one type of historical archery but was not the only type. This guy likely makes lighter "normal" draw weight bows like 98% of bowyers in the world where the bows are between 15-60 lbs. So these are not heavy 100+ lb warbows that require body tilt techniques from military archery. In England and elsewhere after the end of their respective eras of military archery, archery was still practiced as a hobby/sport rather than as a way of war - so new techniques for precision and stability rather than for power were developed. Modern Olympic archery comes from historical western sport archery that uses techniques that would be ineffective for shooting historical military draw weight warbows...but it is still a historical archery technique. These are simply historical techniques for shooting lighter bows and techniques developed after military archery was no longer used.
@@Intranetusa Yeah, then we agree on all points pretty much. What my point of contention is that it is portrayed to be these weapons of our history with all the romanticism that goes with it.
To me, this seemed more like someone interviewing an Olympic fencer about Medieval swordfighting. It just hits a sore spot in me because we've all seen these kinds of videos where they've given people a platform to spread information, and it could have just been better.
These documentaries or youtube videos rarely have the humility to admit to gaps in their knowledge or expertise. That guy for sure is a great bowmaker but when he dresses up like a historical warrior and make him shoot in a dramatic fashion, that blurs the line of his expertise.
@@MarcRitzMD Gotcha, yeh I know what you mean. Where did you see him dress up like a historical warrior - was that a different video?