End Grain Glue Myth Busted | What does it mean? (Surprise Ending)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ก.ค. 2024
- End Grain Glue Myth Busted - What does it Mean? In this video Rob Cosman discusses and demonstrates what the real world joinery effects are of Patrick Sullivan's revelation that end grain glue joints are strong. SURPRISE ENDING
00:00 Introduction
03:43 Mortise & Tenon Joint
09:46 Dado Joint
15:49 Dovetail Joints
21:28 Rabbet Joints
24:42 Joint Tests & Results
----------
If you like our content please LIKE us, SUBSCRIBE to our TH-cam channel, and RING THE BELL to be notified whenever we release a new video.
_______
VIDEOS ROB MENTIONS:
- Glue Myths (Patrick Sullivan): • Glue Myths: 1. End grain
- End grain glue myths (Wood Whisperer): • End Grain Glue Myths |...
- A misunderstanding of glue myths (Stumpy Nubs): • A misunderstanding of ...
* SUBSCRIBE TO ROB"S MONTHLY WOODWORKING TIPS NEWSLETTER - lp.constantcontactpages.com/s...
* SUBSCRIBE TO ROB'S TH-cam CHANNEL TO TAKE YOUR WOODWORKING TO THE NEXT LEVEL: / robcosmancom
* SUBSCRIBE TO ROB'S ONLINE WORKSHOP - robcosman.com/pages/rob-s-onl...
* LIVE TH-cam WORSHOPS - Every other Saturday at 6:00pm Eastern Time
* QUESTIONS - Have a question about the Tools, Techniques, or Anything Else you saw in this video? Post your question in the comments section of this video!
* VISIT OUR STORE - To learn more or purchase any of the tools you saw Rob use in this video, please visit our retail store at www.robcosman.com
* LEARN ABOUT ROB'S PURPLE HEART PROJECT: robcosman.com/pages/php-what-...
* DONATE TO THE PURPLE HEART PROJECT: robcosman.com/products/how-to...
* FOLLOW US ON SOCIAL MEDIA:
FACEBOOK - / robcosman
INSTAGRAM - / robcosman_handtoolwood... - แนวปฏิบัติและการใช้ชีวิต
![ฉันจะ "แพรี่" ให้หมด - ผู้แข็งแกร่งที่สุดในโลกอยากจะเป็นนักผจญภัยให้ได้ - ตอนที่ 04 [ซับไทย]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/PvmuP8y9IPk/mqdefault.jpg)
If you have not seen the other videos on this subject the links are in the description section of this video.
Rob, I can't help it. The Engineer in me wants to know how long an end grain joint will last compared to a dovetail joint. Remember a glue joint is a chemical reaction that can be affected by time and temperature. I would suggest sending both of your example joints to Texas and let them stay in an attic for a year. My attic can hit 120F easily on most summer days. I know you have a friend in San Antonio who would probably be willing to help. If not, I would gladly do the experiment here in Austin.
Great idea
end grain gluing for the win.
Keep making stuff with old world craftsmanship joints, but for items used for shop space you always have the shortcuts.
Its kinda no different then people swearing by pocket holes and screws. Most tradesmen use pocket hole joints because they are fast and stand up fairly well.
But you won't see a pocket hole jig in my shop. Its a shortcut.
I have a 16x7 garage door all wood but its finger jointed short pieces.
The glue joints over the 22 years have failed on the finger joints
I think had it all been 1/2 laps they would not have failed or the bottom
Rail is 1 1/2 × 16' x4" if it had been made out of a stack or wood plywood and wood with stager joints it would still be a solid beam.
But no over its 22 years it smiles from tension of the lift springs.
The only reason it doesn't pull apart is the metal brace.
One of these days i remake each panel out of better wood.
When the teacher is willing to become the student it shows tremendous quality in character. Thanks Rob.
I also love how after all his decades of experience, he still gets excited and amused by new discoveries.
I love how you are able to accept changes even though you have spent all you woodworking life "knowing" that end grain glueing is no good to finding out that it actually is good and immediately incorporating it into your work
Excellent video thanks for sharing 👍
Yes I was surprised, but it has already changed my woodworking. Thanks for the comment
That’s a great sign of someone who is open minded. Despite decades of doing it a certain way and listening to dogma, the guy is able to analyze new data, test the validity himself and make changes to his practice. Wicked job as usual Rob.
I love that you took Patrick's experiments and put them to the practical test. I also love that all of your channels are referencing each other. That is a strength of community not found in mainstream media. Well done again!!
Excellent and useful video, Rob! I really appreciate how, as experienced as you are, you’re still able to be “blown away” by new evidence. You are a great craftsman with great character.
Life long learner - right? Thanks for the comment
Very interesting! My methodology, whenever using glue, has always been that any surfaces that touch should get glue on them. 👍
In most cases I agree with you
I have to agree with Rob that cleaning up squeeze out needs to be considered in all cases. There's few things worse than squeeze out glue that defies cleaning up, in how it affects the appearance of the piece after being finished. Perhaps you're better at glue clean up than I, though, but I just haven't had much luck, regardless of the various methodologies I've tried over the many years I've been doing this.
@@ApexWoodworks Clean up can be a pain, yes!
As a segmented woodturner I have always had to glue end grain to end grain to make my rings. Woodturners always thought the strength was in gluing the long grain of the rings together and using a brick lay pattern. Patrick's video demonstrated to me that my segmented bowls were very strong if the glue was applied correctly and the rings are flat. I shared his video with my woodturning friends because it just verified what we're doing on a segmented turning. With flat work the issues are different and you've done a great job of demonstrating the impact to your joinery. Thanks Rob!
I first encountered this phenomenon in 1970, when white glue was still commonly used in woodworking, even by professionals. Titebond glue was a revelation to me, as the breaking strength of the glue was so much higher than that of white glue. I bet that performing these tests with older glues will that end grain joints are indeed inherently weak, depending on the kind of glue used.
An interesting point, and that would make sense to be true.
White glue is significantly different, and it may even be that the end grain wicked out the moisture from the glue so fast that it didn't properly polymerize as it set?
It's really just a testament to how far glue technology has come over the years.. easy to forget how much chemistry and science has gone into these products.
No, hide glue is stronger than any of the glues we regularly use in woodworking, some of it is used to chip glass to make fancy designs, try that with titebond.
But dont be fooled by a scientific experiment tailored to get a result that bears no meaning on practical woodworking! . It doesnt matter how superior the wood glue is today, the lignum that bonds wood fibres together is the key factor in strength (demonstrated by Mr Sullivan) and centuries of wood jointing respect that overlapping/extending fibres give strength. Wood is not like metal.
Funnily enough I started woodworking when I retired and made some cabinet drawers with glued rebated corners not knowing that this was not a thing to do. My drawers are still hanging together solidly so my estimated necessary rigidity for my drawers is now borne out scientifically. Thanks Rob, Stumpy and Patrick.
Thanks....how old is that joint that is still holding up?
Awesome video Rob! I too couldn't believe how strong that rabbeted joint held up. As you mentioned, the dovetail joint is more aesthetically pleasing, but for a rabbet glue up to be that strong is mind blowing! Makes me ponder things moving forward!
The mark of wisdom is humility. Humility facilitates curiosity and curiosity can inspire critique and constructive change. Thanks!
Thanks Rob, I watched Patrick's video and his reasoning made sense, the tests he did fortified the reasoning. You've added to it with real project application. Pretty cool.
That was my goal. Glad you liked it
Great video ! Really shows the practical uses ! Awesome job Rob :)
Thanks, thats what we were trying to do
Thanks Rob, I had watched all the other videos earlier but I admire your honest, unbiased demonstration on practical applications.
Thanks Stan and thanks for the comment
In addition to your expertise, I've always enjoyed your clear and precise way of explaining your concepts. This was a great transition from scientific to practical.
You are great Rob. You did this video, challenging yourself and investing your valuable time and materials. The Best of this, is that you did not do the video trying to "explain" Mr Sullivan's work. You earned my subscription Rob!
More than 50 years ago I was taught basic woodworking by my uncle. Every joint, no matter what the orientation was, GLUE IT. My uncle learned from old masters. It was hide glue or some form of glue, but, he said you can clean area after so DO IT.
Thanks for the info Professor Cos, my uncle would be proud.
Will I hate cleaning up glue but I do GLUE IT
Nice to see you make this video Rob....three of my favourite youtube woodworkers all giving comment and now a practical application test too.....best thing to see here?.....you still being able to be surprised by a result you in all honesty did not expect....a day with learning something is always a good day :)..weldone mate and thanks for taking the time to do this :)
Thank you for watching and commenting
Rob, I always say that the best thing that can happen to me is to find out I have been wrong about something, because two wonderful things have happened. I have learned something new and I have been given the opportunity to stop being wrong. I love both.
I watched all three of the other videos before I watched yours-I actually sent you an email about the issue. Other than the original, your was the most useful.
Wow. Thanks. I love your philosophy
Your practical application & testing of Patrick's results are the perfect pairing and demonstrates the possibilities. I really like how you describe exactly how and why you do things.
Thanks for watching and commenting
I really enjoyed this video. Very informative. A big thanks to Patrick and yourself for an eye-opening tests.👍❤
glad you found it useful
Your skill level is very advanced. Thanks alot for your insight on the use of simple joints and the more complex ones with the proper use of glue.
You are so welcome. Thanks for watching
Absolutely brilliant video Rob and Co. 🙌✌🤘 you guys rock, please keep up the great work🙌✌😀
Keep watching and we will keep posting
The fact you give a fair thought is what I really apreciate, old habits or ways we use to work are hard to disregard or change, nice done Rob!
Thanks, I really didn't expect the rabbet to hold. I would have bet anything it would have broken under my weight
Thanks Rob. A great video which wonderfully complements the videos from Stumpy Nubs and the Wood Whisperer. Between the three of you, you have covered the topic comprehensively.
Yes I think so too. I was a little worried about piling on, but I think mine was different enough to be additive verses repetitive
Rob I love your content. I really love your tools. Thank you!
Love to see an honest test with an honest response. I agree and I also spent years thinking you need extra support. Nice Rob !!!
I know right. Think of how much effort I spent reinforcing the joint that was probably strong enough
Awesome video Rob. I myself always make little test when I'm curious about the strength of a joint. Most of the time I'm pleasantly surprised at how little it takes to be be structurally strong "enough" for my application
It is great to see the responses to Mr Sullivan's video being respectful and professional. Kudos to the woodworking community!
I agree with you. I love how its all been a learning and informative debate. Politicians should take our lead!!!!
Another great response to Patrick's great video. If anything it just shows how lucky we are that we have the glues that we have that are stronger than the wood and it is just sitting on your shelf ready to be used whenever.
Yes I am so glad the only option is just hide glue!
there will always be a need for proper joinery, but with these revelations that have come forward from not only yourself, but some of the other channels that I subscribe to as well....this, for some applications, is going to be a game changer. I appreciate the effort put forth with a few various types of joint you did and "tested", its easy to see that in certain spots with end grain versus long/face grain, a little glue will absolutely help with strength even if it is on already classically strong joints to begin with.
Everyone's been talking about glue surface and wood properties, glue properties the science of wood joints. Throwing around terms like strong, stronger and strongest. Rob is the only woodworker to post a video checking on strong enough.
Jaw dropping. Excellent video, practical application of the "end grain theory. Thank you!
Thanks, Rob! Fascinating
Excellent video thanks for the good work.
Thanks for watching as usual......and commenting
Great video to add to the analysis by showing practical implications. I dont think this will be a game changer, but it may change how we play some matches. Loved those ultra thin half blinds.
I agree....good analogy with matches
Someone showed me years ago a wonderful trick for cleaning wet glue out of those tight corners. The opening of a regular plastic straw can be easily pressed tightly into the corner edge and scoops the glue out cleanly. When the opening fills up, snip the end off and repeat. A single straw will remove a lot of squeeze out glue.
"Almost speechless" is not a term I've heard you use before. Great demonstration Rob, thanks.
What I most like about your videos is that you are one of the most real-world woodworkers if not the most of any on TH-cam.
Wow thanks so much. Thats where I want to be
Excellent follow on from Patrick's video.
Most traditional woodworking was developed prior to the development of the excellent adhesives we now use. I can't think of a PVA glue joint I have made that has failed in 'normal' use.
Love it. Thank you Rob.
Kudos for addressing this as a gentleman not being arrogant
It's an old tale, based on older glues. Modern PVA glues are exceptionally strong on end grain.
I like the application of his testing. Nice work!
Patrick’s testing showed the end grain glue joint is a bit stronger than wood in its weakest direction. This gives a practical application of this. I have always glued end grain since it did add some strength and is easy to do. I was surprised with the results that it is stronger than I had assumed. As you indicate it doesn’t change most joinery methods but it’s good to see there is some change in applications and this bit of joining knowledge makes us all a little better.
Just be careful of your first test with the dovetail and rabbet joint, if you hit the rabbit joint with a mallet (like the dado test) it does in fact fail. The dovetail does not.
I was after something that was consistent so the test I performed was as follows:
1) Clamp the job to a post so that the part to be put under load is poking out.
2) Using two house bricks taped together drop them onto the section poking out as the same distance out from the job and at the same height (I used 8 ft).
3) Record results.
My result may be slightly different to yours but you could very well find that the weakest joint is not the dado.
I saw the Wood Whisperer's video, which was interesting and informative, and seeing your methodologies and explanations were just awesome as always! Interesting results, for sure.
Awesome, thank you!
Very thorough great job
All that time wasted learning how to cut dovetail joints.... seriously cracking video Rob, very informative and real world applications. Many thanks.
That's what Luther said too!!!! I wont be throwing out dovetails for rabbets.....There is just something about the pleasure of cutting dovetails and the look of quality about them
This whole knowledge of connecting the long grain end to the long grain end is actually incorporated into some Japanese joinery like a sleeve I think is the name of what I'm thinking of it's a long cut construction joint to connect two beams together then forced into each other with a wedge but it's connecting end to end and it's one of their strongest joints used in traditional construction edit:after thinking about it then finally just googling they use a ton of end to end joinery in traditional Japanese wood work they even have wats of turning a joint into ends touching ends when it doesn't have to be they go out if the way to join end grain I had never thought about it before. I know their whole culture and mindset in making anything is to use physics and nature to your advantage and work with it instead of fighting against those forces as we see it in the western world and those two different schools of thought are so obvious in everything we do honestly. I can help but look at some of their incredibly complex end to end joints and think God that's smart but it mimicks the tree itself by joint a long grain interlocking with another long grain then forcing them into each other as gravity would and giving them some flexibility you've mimicked the tree and maintained it's strength. We cut stuff apart then try to force it to have some strength again by glueing it to a strong piece we haven't cut through yet. We fight nature they use it.
It always amazes me the way Rob attacks woodworking with the skill of a heart surgeon.
I know tools can play a part, but his skill is the main tool in his arsenal.
Never would i ever built a corner and not put some nails in it. I glued everything before, now no nails or screws. I have to build a bookshelf with only glue, even the back panel, i need to know. Thank you for this eye opening day Rob and Mr. Sullivan! Holly ....!
Yes I was surprised. But I am not throwing away my dovetails
I was waiting for your video on this!
How did you like it?
@@RobCosmanWoodworking my big question is will time and changes in climate affect change the results? Will those glue joints be just as strong in 100 years.
Millions of craftsmen working the same wood for thousands of years with nearly the same tools and we are still learning new things. One of the true joys of wood working.
Lifelong learners!
Excellent on many levels. Thanks. 👍
Excellent Video
Another useful and enjoyable video. It was intriguing to see you gobsmacked at the end.
Rob, thanks for sharing this important revelation with us. I think that it would be unrealistic to believe that the 1/4" deep dado joint could be as strong as the much more complete glueing surface of the rabbet joint. Very well done, Sir.
I have to wonder if a 1/2” or even 3/8” deep dado would make a difference. If you look at his rabbet, it was effectively at least 1/2” deep.
These videos are amazing and super helpful. I watched all the linked videos before yours including Patrick's original. It's very scientific. I'm wondering, though, if the end grain to long grain glue join would be effective using somewhat oily exotic wood, especially on that carcass rabbet join.
Oily wood would cause the joint to less effect, I suspect
Thanks for a sincere and through video.
I'm impressed you are so thoughtful which faces get glue in a joint. A true master is in the details.
It seems you'd have to intentionally not glue the end lap. Was there ever any reason not to glue it?
Awesome!
Hey Rob, regarding glue cleanup from difficult places: a little bit of diluted shellack (or any other finish that is planned) on potential squeeze out areas will make cleanup a breeze. A plastic pick or something will make glue just pop off. The downside is a very careful application is required so that glue surfaces are not affected, but after a bit of practice padding some shellack is quick. Shellack is also easily removed, almost completely.
Great video Rob. I really appreciate the practical application of the information from Patrick’s video. With respect to the dado joint I have always used a sliding, tapered dovetail to provide the mechanical strength because I assumed the end grain to long grain connection would be too weak to prevent the sides from bowing out. I guess I will have to re-evaluate whether I still want to do the tapered, sliding dovetail. It is more work and more time. It would be interesting to figure out a way to measure the difference between a regular dado and a sliding dovetail. When my new shop is completed I would like to see if I can figure out a way to do that test and film it.
You and I are the same I just used a through wedged tenons instead of a sliding dovetail. Not anymore its glue only for me
It's AMAZING how readily everyone changes the way they've done things for decades in the face of science. I love it!
Your reaction was priceless, btw.😁
yes I was blown away
Love the text and surprised with the results.
I was totally surprised
I always respect experts, especially in industries with literally ancient wisdom that works, willing to try something different.
You have to be open to new ideas
Mr. Sullivan blew up woodworkers youtube! This has been informative and entertaining. I think Mr. Sullivan has explained why scarf joints are so strong
Thanks for the comment
Another great video! Will this change the way tthat you do the backs of drawers now?
I took it for granted that people had already tried Rob's experiments over the years and found them lacking. Its more surprising to me that these ideas have just been accepted as fact by the general community without verification. I can only assume that this is partly attributable to the quality of modern glue and the amount of time that its been available to woodworkers...
Something I've always done, now proven to work as good as "fancy" dovetails. Thanks for addressing this. Now I can show my woodworking buddy's there is more proof.
But dovetails are bees knees
Great to see after all your experiance you are still willing to adapt to new ideas. That is how you progress in the craft.
Its the only way to be if you are life long learner
@@RobCosmanWoodworking Do you think the rabit joint would break with the small impact?. This would show just how strong the dovetail joint really is. I dont think the endgrain joint has much impact (real world use ) strength.
Truth be known, the rabbet joint felt stronger under my weight than the dovetails......Another reason I was so dumb founded. I am not going to stop doing dovetails though....
Thank you very much, watching this video was a pleasure.
It would be nice if you broke two similar-sized joints (rebate and dovetail) and compared their strength (simple lever and a water can works just fine for this).
I wonder if Patrick Sullivan realised when he uploaded that video what effect it would have. I’ll still be reinforcing my glue joints when dealing with end grain.
Interesting question, my guess is no, but its all good and we have all learned a lot.
I suggest he is beginning to realize this as he states clearly and emphatically that end grain bonding is about twice as strong as side grain bonding (which is clearly click bait!) and then he and others now are trying to say he didnt actually mean this! How can a guy who is in a league of his own in filming and presenting such micro analysis in such a graphically convincing way , then say he may have confused some people? Thousands (who now think the experts are wrong)? His presentations are full of flaws and contradictions! But captivating viewing!!
Rob, for me the critical problem is “TIME”. I’m Italian, in my home I have some 16th and 17th century pieces of furniture. Dovetails, dovetails and dovetails. Sometimes some rabbet or dados with forged nails. Do you think that in the centuries the rabbet joint that you tested can resists? Large pieces like these have a big tendency tu cup and no way for the glue joint. Dovetails last forever.
Well I will still be using dovetails in my carcasses. I will now just put glue on some end grain to gain extra strentgh
This was my thought too.
The benefit of dovetails is that they function even without glue. The rabbet lasts only until the glue fails, so it really just depends on how long we think the glue will hold before it becomes brittle and breaks.
@@nickglover exactly. Sincerely I have no idea how long glue can performs. I suppose it depends on the environment, moisture, exposure particular situation...a chest of drawers near a fireplace can be stressed a lot in the wintertime. UV is another important fact in some regions.
Best explanation of all the videos I have seen. And yeah contractors won't be lenghthening 2.4's.
Thanks for watching and commenting
As I was watching, two questions came to mind. One, you addressed by shooting the end grain versus leaving it rough from a tablesaw. Two, I wonder if sizing, and /or, applying thin amount of glue to end grain, let it dry, then apply more glue before finally assembling and clamping? Hmmm...great video Mr. Cosman. Thank you.
Wood glue essentially is pulled into the fibers of the wood and solidifies to itself. So it's bonding to itself, not the wood. If you let a layer dry it can't "seep" into the wood so you'll have an extremely weak joint. In this case it seems it had a pretty deep penetration. So the results may vary depending on the type of wood itself. The more porous the wood, the better the bonding.
thank you sir
Absolutely great video!!! Well thought out and extremely useful. The one joint in my mind is the 45 degree mitre end grain to end grain. It still needs reinforcement? Thoughts??? 💭
Yea I should have done that. I will still spline mine
@@RobCosmanWoodworking we could definitely use more real life end grain experiments like this😉
Love your show and all you guy's do but Rob almost speechless Wow. LOL
I really was
As a Materials Engineer, I remain skeptical. In my opinion these one time static tests are only part of the equation. We need to assess this in a more comprehensive scenario by including cyclical racking and fatigue to see if the durability of these joints across the system of joints used in a piece is sufficient long term. Mechanical locking combined with glue surfaces of all types has the best chance of surviving long term use, wood movement, and the ubiquitous moving of furniture from room to room and house to truck to house over the course of generations. In the design of a piece use this knowledge appropriately by having critical joints absorb the racking forces with mechanical aid and other joints that typically do not see raking to use only glue surfaces (i.e. outside corners of a book shelf using dovetails and all the non-moving shelves using dados only). I am also one of those people who spends way too much time scraping glue out of my damn corners...
Sounds like you are the right guy to do all that testing and it would be interesting to see the results
"I am also one of those people who spends way too much time scraping glue out of my damn corners..."
What about masking tape?
Of course you will also have to test several differnt types of glues. Looks like Rob is using something other than Titebond III which is very popular with many other woodworkers.
You better get working on it. Cant wait to see the video
That was completely unexpected!
I built a display case in the Barrister fashion for my T-rex jaw piece and I used a rabbit joint on the two sides of that oak case to fix the sides to the base. For years I've regretted not using a locking rabbit joint. Now, I know it's a cosmetic choice I'm regretting, not a structural choice I neglected.
Like most, I've always believed end grain glue joints to be weak. I think what Patrick's video (and the subsequent follow up videos such as yours), has emphasized is that a joint is only strong as it's weakest link. What's become apparent is that most of the time, It's not the end grain glue joint itself that's weak, it's the lignin bond that hold the fibers together. In cases where an end grain glue joint does fail, it's only because cross grain is incredibly strong.
I think it is very important to remember how pathetically rubbish wood glue used to be!
If I had made that exact joint in my woodwork classes at school, it would have broken just by picking it up and shaking it. LOL
So the wisdom of that era was correct and undisputed. But now with glue’s being stronger than the wood itself, it stands to reason that it can make a better joint than back then.
How long that joint remains strong and reliable is to be seen, especially if you take into account environmental conditions and cycles of work or loading, and the position of the joint.
I’d like to thank Mr Sullivan, Stumpy Nubs, The Wisperer and yourself Rob for all the videos and the integrity and character of all of you.
For now at least I will still be reinforcing my joints or using dovetails.
That rebate joint was a surprise. I was surprised as you Rob. I have restored antique and period furniture for 40 plus years and know that time is a big factor that is rarely factored into the equation of these tests. Can I suggest you retest the dovetail and rebate joints periodically over an extended period of time. Regards, Terry Gleeson. Sydney
Keep those around the shop for the next 30 years and keep testing them??? I am not that committed...Besides I am not giving up dovetails
The strength of the rabbit it's nice to know in a situation where you plan to paint. Dovetails or even finger joints would be a lot of work. To do if you don't need it and your painting over it anyway.
If I am painting over it glue it, screw it paint it. I dont use paint
OMG! That rabbet joint bro!!!
With the dado / housing: When cutting these by hand, you cut the sides, clean the middle, and refine with a router. If when cutting the sides, you go past the depth by even the smallest amount, then the bottom of the housing will be short pieces of face grain only as long as the width of the housing because of the fibers being scored along the length of the sides of the housing. Maybe this might be what is limiting the strength in your test? It looked like you had a clean line of torn out face grain fibers adhered to the end grain of the shelf...no ragged edges. That's what made me wonder if the bottom of the housing was really short (face) grain. The torque on the side walls was clearly enormous because it just pried off those pieces below the shelf. Thank you for sharing all these tests. Very interesting. I was sure that rabbeted corner would fail. I'll bet that if you do a pure tensile test on the housing, it is strong enough for tensile loads. The back of the cabinet could take care of the racking loads, perhaps?
Years ago I watch a video of a woodworker who explained that the end grain glue up was weak because the end grain fibers would suck up the glue and starve the joint. At least that was his take on the problem. His solution was to prime the end grain with a little glue first and allow that to be sucked up and then apply the regular amount of glue to the joint.
Add this to the most shocked I've ever been.
You stood on those 2 corners, and I thought for sure you would break the Non-Dovetail one.
Holy crap
I absolutely thought it would break
Why? I thought that the dovetail would break, since the "pins" are much smaller.
I've always believed the myth also. Pretty interesting. As to the lap joint not failing..... pretty good. If the joint had been a butt joint, it would have failed, but the fact that the dado was fairly deep, then the the stress was relieved quite a bit by the "shear" strength of the base of the dado. On the other hand, the dado joint, (for the shelf) was fairly shallow. IF you had made that one deep, it might well have withstood your test. Still though, the possible stress on a shelf is normally pretty directly downward, and thus, even a shallow dado is probably fine, AS LONG AS there is a back on the shelf to prevent racking.. thanks Rob
Never seen someone cut/plane with a marking gauge. Amazing
This video is delightful. Everyone should be as open to new information and to empirical evidence. The thing I most appreciated, though, was the thoughtful analysis of the practical meaning - yes everyone has been wrong about end-grain glue strength, yes it has a few meaningful ramifications for actual work, but no it doesn't mean joinery is obsolete. When we learn, we adapt - we don't simply throw away what we've learned before.
My takeaway from Mr. Sullivan's original video was "PVA glue is stronger than lignin but much weaker than wood grain. If maximum strength is needed (and due to leverage it often is), try to make a joint failure force a failure of the wood grain rather than accept a failure of the glue OR the lignin. That said, stop worrying so much about face grain vs. end grain for glue surfaces - that's not really what matters."
great comment, thanks
I am with you if i didn't see it i wouldn't have believed those 2 joints could withstand that force of you standing on them. I am as stunned as you, tthey didn't even appear to flex at all. I know Dovetails are strong but the rabbet as well!?
A new day in the shop 👍
I remember assembling a cabinet with dadoes using just glue 30 years ago. To my knowledge it's still in use. I never heard back from the client.
It is probably still good
Hey Rob. I actually make all my drawer boxes with that rabbit joint and they stay together forever. I have many draws that are 40 years old that haven’t moved at all.
Thnaks for that info. Lots of folks wondering if the rabbet would hold up over time...I think you just answered the question
One thing to consider with the rabbet joint though is that the glue is in the place where the wood will move seasonally. So if the glue doesn't flex it may separate from the wood itself, and that may cause the joint to fail earlier than the dovetail joint, which will stay strong longer since the way the glue is positioned moves way less.
I’ve now seen all four videos, starting with Patrick Sullivan and found them all very interesting. As my French daughter in law has taught me, each time I have gone to bed less stupid 🌞