How Putin's naval ambitions were blocked by NATO | Robert Fox
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 มิ.ย. 2024
- Putin meeting in CHina and Push for Kharkiv could be part of a bid to see Russia recognised as a global naval and military power, but with the Baltics surrounded by NATO allies this might be impossible says Robert Fox, defence editor for the Evening Standard.
📻 Listen to Times Radio - www.thetimes.co.uk/radio
📍 Subscribe to our channel - / @listentotimesradio
🗞 Subscribe to The Times www.thetimes.co.uk/subscribe/...
📲 Get the free Times Radio app www.thetimes.co.uk/radio/how-...
Rushia the only country on the planet to lose a naval war against a country with no navy😂😂😂
So you keep saying every day bot,but guess what? Ukraine is getting hammered 🤣
@@davidjones-wt2qq Silly boy🙃
@@davidjones-wt2qq The only thing I see getting hammered are rushn' oil refineries 😂😂😂
No navy 😂 lol Ukraine sunk a few landing craft ,you have no idea 🤣
@davidjones-wt2qq Russia is getting hammered by a much smaller country with much less equipment and 1/3rd of the manpower 😂😂😂
His overestimation of the Russian war machine has hints of Cold War adoration of his former nemesis. Not so much ‘cold water in the face’ as one foot in the past.
He's on the payroll.
Yes that is my take as well Russia exported its greatness myth to many starstruck progressive academics and they continue to work by this faulty paradigm. This is the case for the POTUS and his cabinet as well
'Let's see what Russia's minimal demands will be'!? The whole of Ukraine, the Baltics, Moldova, Georgia, for starters? Just listen to what they say! All they want now is a little pause, call it 'peace', and then strike again! Just read their manual, ffs!
@@paultemple3660well said
So if this guy doesn't understand why the Ukranians didn't build defensive lines, he could ask why the Russians didn't do likewise? It was just too dangerous and easily within reach of barrel artillery on both sides.
We were building defensive lines, but when we were putting dragon teeth in, but our equipment was being shelled and destroyed. We weren't able to finish the lines.
important point, it's nearly impossible to build defenses under artillery fire, AND especially when you have limited manpower. Russia has 10 times the manpower to build things.
Especially when ukr can't fire back
Exactly. Correct, all of you. Major defensive lines aren't built that close to the border and enemy artillery. Still defenses have still been built. They can easily be seen on Google maps.
There's lines on both sides
Are you serious? Zelensky was talking non stop since the start of the war, about Ukraines deficiency in the air. Ukrainians begged for air power support of any kind. What a shameful thing, suggesting that Ukraine somehow didn’t give air power aspect enough attention.
Excellent point. The West didn't lift a finger for the whole first year. If they had taken it seriously we'd have been on the sencond tranche of fighter jet donation and armament by now. If we had REALLY taken it seriously we'd have all allowed our pilots and equipment to go fight in Ukraine's side, at least as to the enforcement of air superiority.
It's important to put the blame for losing the war on Ukraine not us.
What an ignorant statement...
This guy speaks largely in hyperbole. He needs to simmer it down a bit and listen to what he's actually saying
@@gregoryadair3223trump sent javelins....Obama sent socks
Russia never was, isn't, and never will be a naval superpower. They want to be, but it just isn't so.
Pretty hard to be a superpower you don't even have a functioning aircraft Carrier. Rushns' are more of naval supercower😂
Ukraine is. And they challenge Brittania Rues the Waves
@@marioformosa4259 Tiny ukraine didn't even have an army 3 years ago. And using remote control drones they have once again caused the world to laugh hysterically at rusha'.
Port Arthur... they have never been a Naval Power
When Ol Pooty baby was helping out Assad in Syria that pos aircraft carrier was always moved by ocean going tug. It doesn't really move on its own. When they do fire it up, it gases everyone onboard. It's had so many non war related incidents that it has to be one of the most unlucky ships to ever be made.
The ORCS don't have a navy 😅
Or an air force 😂
Total losers 😂
Look up Potemkin Villages. Russia has a Putinkim Army !
So, did loosers crush an Ukrainian counter offensive last year, and take Avdeevka, Chasov Yar and Ocheretino this year?
You have to respect your Ukrainian troops just a little bit😅
Russophobia syndrome..Quick recovery to you.
@@StPiter111 After his visit to Peking, Putin has got to sit on a very soft cushion for a week.
Luckily for him Xi, like most Chinese, is not very big 'in that department!'
Haha.
@@fresh6993 Putin has signed over Siberia to Xi.
I am not convinced that Mr Fox knows much about the current situation in Ukraine and related geo-politic. Talking a lot but not saying much.
Robert Fox i think is a very bad Arm chair General, i think his assessments are all wrong. Sorry Kate but couldent put up with more than half of it. Slava Ukraine and NATO
Same. Waste of time
Same. He's just waffling.
Same here.
I'm here to give potatoes to bots.
Brilliant I totally agree !
Putin should be worried about China reclaiming North Manchuria. China has already started using Manchu names on maps for areas in Russia that were once Chinese.
Also, Japan reclaiming their islands!
And Ukraine should build trenches around Lviv. The Poles are getting restless and want their Polish cities in Ukraine back
@@marioformosa4259 doubtful…more likely is Germany gets Koenigsburg back.
Strategists ! ! ! Awesome.
@@bmunson4920 That would be wonderful. But it would have to be run by the EU as the Poles and Lithuanians wouldn't like it.
It's not possible to build defensive lines at the border when there is constant bombardment, when Ukraine is not allowed to strike within ruzzia. The ruzzian military enjoys sanctuary on their side of the border. This is why they moved in. Ukraine saw the troops buildup and could not do anything about it.
So if you have weak area of defence ( and not all areas can be equal )then it would be normal to reinforce that area with armour , artillery and air support.
Anyone who says Ukraine needs to negotiate with russia has absolutely zero expertise in military or geopolitics and should not be taken seriously.
?
@@stevecross9922 The USSR and then Russia have never negotiated in good faith, and will break any agreement as soon as they feel it is to their advantage. A pause will just give them time to refit and improve their military before their next push.
Exactly
Easy saying that sitting there in your pyjamas while hundreds of thousands of have died in this conflict.
What's wrong with negotiating? It doesn't mean you have to accept an unpalatable offer
As a Canadian we really need to step up our game as far as spending on defense..especially for the arctic theater
Cool fact - our Canadian Arctic Rangers are trial running EV skidoo's. That'd be a heck of a way to sneak up on someone.
Its probably worse here in australia. Our government seems more concerned about the plight of palestinians more than ukranians. Theres no feeling of urgency about defending democracy at all
I was in Canadian navy many years ago..one of my trainers in basic was a ranger..nothing but respect for them
Zelensky asking more money more weapons but I cannot understand why do Ukrainian men between the ages of 20 and 25 not have to join the army and can live and have fun in other countries like girls?
@@unsalbulentThere are better ways to get an answer than posting your question here. You could easily find out if you really wanted to know.
The reason why Ukraine is struggling was the drip feed of equipment with unrealistic retrictions on there use. Dont blame it on Zellinsky blame it on Biden et al. The Ukranians still have done wonders with all that.
Enough equipment not to loose, not enough to win.
The Russian Navy needs to make the ultimate sitcom. They make us laff so much. Ha, ha ha 😂 🤣 😆 😄 😅 😜
Navy Lark
The difference is the lack of ability to strike at gathering forces using US weapons. It is not about Ukrainian capabilities. Hopefully this will change.
The US kindly gave everything to the Taliban peasants
I'm still wondering why people are lining up at the US and UK border to get in...and are lining up at the rushn' border to get OUT.🤔
Before the end of the year the rushn' government has promised to stabilize the ruble. Even two, if possible.🤭
@@dpelpal Look how many posts you have made,what a desperate bot you are 🤣ps Ukraine is losing badly 🤣
Hi , dpelpal, glad you are back to work after hospital treatment in Ukraine,it was dull without you. How's your mental health, you started to speak with yourself.
There's about 4 Million Ukrainians in Russia as refugees.
@@cheztaylor8 And the Moskva still sails as well!😂😂😂😂
Our Politicians are obsessed with the electoral cycle. The people just want coherant leadership. Which is sadly lacking at the moment!
This nutty professor still doesn't understand Ukraine after 2 years.
MISSING point!! Due to US rules, Ukraine could not attack Russia accumulated on Russian land.
US Rules? No,far from it.PUTIN WARNIN to the WEST: If RUSSIA proper is stricken by a non UKRANIAN missile then RUSSIA,reserves the right in response to the strike,to strike the manufacturing nation,outside OF UKRAINE INCLUDING IN ITS' native soil.IT'S amazing,what a WARNING can achieve.
"That sounds a bit Irish," - Robert Fox
Don’t involve the Irish. I don’t want to have to come on over and sort this all out.
@@TonyM540yeah... and don't involve the Scottish either.... would hate to dig up my great great great grandmother "muzzy" Bennett and send her over....
@@kaltenburg2637 😃
Are you serious suggesting Ukraine is not giving enough attention to air defence? WE are not giving enough systems to protect the civilians in Ukraine.
Fox touches on a lot of points. Some of them he's right about, some of them not so much.
Pretty much right on all of it I’d say.
It never seems to amaze me all these people come on here and talk about this war but they haven't never stepped one foot in Ukraine to actually see what's really going on they just go by what they think and what they hear on other podcasts 😒
I've been to Ukraine and Russia (worked there). What's your point?
how do you know that ?
Zelensky asking more money more weapons but I cannot understand why do Ukrainian men between the ages of 20 and 25 not have to join the army and can live and have fun in other countries like girls?
Just because you’ve not been anywhere! I’ve been to Ukraine, Belarus and Russia. What are you finding complicated about this war? Putin is quite matter of fact about it and Zelensky gives details on their struggle.
@@unsalbulentin your country young men can’t have fun? Cool.
Worst "expert" I've heard. Wrong on every point on the Kharkiv offensive.
Crazy to hear him say that sounds a bit "Irish" in the middle of everything. Not a phrase he should be saying. Showing his age I guess.
What does it mean?
Summer of 2024 will decide the outcome of this war
I don’t think in his 55 years he has gained much real knowledge of warfare, or this situation in general!
I’m sure he’s a fine gentleman but his thesis of the situation is not the consensus, nor does it line up with the actual battle field conditions.
Lots of interviews and reports on the defense’s in the area and even the age of Ukr forces..
New troops on the way but lots of youth, in leadership positions and fighting admirably.
WHY do all of you make these videos and title them one thing and talk about something entirely different? I look at them by the title.
ISW is not too optimistic. They just don't believe Russia has any motorized ability to break through any lines in a proper way. Just grind like they have done for 2 years now. I don't see it as optimistic. Also critical of Ukrainian ability for counterattacks. He just listen to George Barros more intently.
Thank God for a truth-teller, at last.
INteresting this Robert Fox, good to hear his views, all information is helpful to better understand Putin, Russia and Ukriane!
Excellent as usual Kate
Good to get clarity on the wider influences of Russia, china etc. think we’ve missed the opportunity to be ahead of the game and now will be reacting rather than proactive. Our infrastructure is so vulnerable
why did she stop him from talking about how vulnerable gps is?
Haha the Russian navy has never been up to much, air force has a more competent history.
@19:00 Sounds a bit Irish? What's the meaning 🤔
Is like to know what he means too
Putin looks shaky...what are you talking about?
Someone needs to close the lid on this guys box.🙃
Blinking is living up to his name
🇺🇦❤💪🇬🇧💪❤🇺🇦
I don't think Russia got 300,000 plus soldiers in there if that's the case then that means Ukraine military already killed at least 300,000 of them because Russia invaded Ukraine with at least least 180,000 of them
Interesting, was that Shoigu who called you before his promotion.
Zelensky asking more money more weapons but I cannot understand why do Ukrainian men between the ages of 20 and 25 not have to join the army and can live and have fun in other countries like girls?
"It never seems to amaze me all these people come on here and talk about this war but they haven't never stepped one foot in Ukraine to actually see what's really going on" Your quote. Have you been to Ukraine?
@@stream2watch Probably it was possible for him but I doubt, he would risk his life.
Ukraine's running count of inflicted casualties against Russian military has just reached 490k.
Why is it that Times Radio lies the most about Russian success.🙃
Robert Fox is mistaken if he thinks that the $300 bn of Russian frozen funds will not be sent to Ukraine.
Belgian Euroclear holds most of it and even I know that. Slava Ukraini
Anyone who was familiar with Russian history knew with 100% certainty that Russia would not allow Ukraine to go over the to the Western alliances. As soon as Yanukovych was ousted the current path was set in stone. Russia had already been preparing to head off Ukraine' move toward the West but that was just the final trigger. Russia has always obsessed over keeping the Black Sea ports.
They are unrealistic keeping Russia in the UN when it is not a member, too.
So how vulnerable are all navys now, could be a lesson for everyone.
ukrainiens dont like defensive lines like more to take money in their pockets
Horribly arrogant in his certainty and extremely myopic in his outlook. He accuses others of being over optimistic but one could throw the opposite accusation at him.
Opinions are like.....everyone's got one.
Who is more credible, a man on his own drawing on long past experience or a team of people with various expertise who are dedicated to the field they are analysing?
Times Radio seriously need to adjust their volume settings. I can hardly hear ANYTHING. Do they not listen to their productions? Ever? ADJUST THE SETTINGS FFS!
Where are F 16 promised to Ukraine?
The idea that he would call out The Economist and ISW for being too optimistic, on Time Radio, is ridiculous. As if this news source hasn't been the most optimistic of anyone about this war.
Ceurope needs to watch Russia ,with its own army and American keep an eye on their own back yard
What does "that sounds a bi Irish" mean? from 18:50
Just a bit of casual bigotry from this journo-dinosaur. He's well matched to The Times lame journalism though 🤦🏻♂️
Dr. Robert Fox needs a little workshop on the second Chechnyan war.
He has only himself to blame.
Just as he starts about the vulnerability of GPS, she interrupts him.
Ukraine and NATO losing together like true allies
Misinformation is allowed in war but never won any war
❤ms kate true professional 😊
Retire, old man. Most of what you said is inaccurate.
Soldiers are not trained
He is spot on! We in the west lot but in the end too little too late…
As time goes by, we look too much within ourselves while politics and war goes on outside and it continues. It hasn’t changed from day one in the war and we need to remember that.!
We need to speed up and realize what is going on. I’m not just talk about it but do something.
We need to go into war industrial speed.
NATO Has trained for Over 50 years to deal with EXACTLY This!!! So, why are they just watching it happen?
Is the Evening Standard still Russian owned?
At the moment they have one very broken aircraft carrier ... it really is a pile of junk.
Opinions are like arseholes...
Not impressed by fox at all. No real military experience at all.
Slightly different topic: What about North Korea, any news, it got kinda silent about that!?
And also, newsflash, aside from launching missiles at ukraine, this conflict in no way is a naval dominance situation. This guest is stuck in about 1985
Look how many new submarines he's added!
Time for an Alliance to go into Ukraine. I'm not so sure that it can be NATO though.
Well, that was fun. On the whole I would rather listen to Gen. Ben Hodges.
This bloke is off his chops. I’d love to know where he gets his intel from.
This guy is full of wind.
All will be Ukraine!💙💛
All while the westcwhistles in the Air...
I think they're mostly just laughing at rushia' 😂😂😂😂
@@dpelpalNobody is laughing in Kharkov nowadays.
Surovikin didn't defend alleppo he destroyed it
Just reflecting on why you would want the young people to stay behind to keep the economy going.... That doesn't really make sense because if you have 15-20 years of experience, you can easily keep things going, but the more unexperienced and younger people will not be as successful. Unless what you are talking about is factory workers doing manual labor?
Russian submarine fleet has always been the real threat
The surface fleet not so much
Another washed up has been ! Has no idea on the real situation in Ukraine !
all but 1 baltic countries are NATO ?? which baltic state does he not believe to be NATO ? or does he confuse Kaliningrad with a baltic nation ?. would be benefitial to raise the bar here for socalled experts
Russia doesn't need a large navy. England is an island. The U.S. needs a navy to carry out operations in europe, the middle east, and asia. Trains and superhighways in Russia would allow them to transport personnel and equipment to places in Russia faster. BTW, the English navy is not what it was. England leased some ships in order to carry out operations in the Falkland Islands. The Russians had an unimpressive navy in WW2.
The only Baltic country that is not in NATO is Russia itself ("St Petersburg *and* Kaliningrad.)
Is this a re-post of an interview made before Sweden officially joined?
Pacific is Naval warfare. Europe is ground combat & air combat. Israel is both. If we see anything in South America, that’s a USCG problem. Africa is a wild card where we would use USAF.
Jesus nato step in with air superiority game over Russia
14:42 _[Russia] wants to ensure and strengthen access to the Baltic... [but is] surrounded by the Baltic Coastal Partners _*_all but one are NATO now_*
Barring Russia, which country on the Baltic Sea is not a part of NATO? (Is he referring to land-locked Belarus?)
Sounds abit irish? Made perfect sense to me
love the candor
It's 1905 in slow motion for Putin. All weapons provided to Ukraine came with the understanding that Ukranians can do with them as they wish, no matter what anyone says officially in public.
No, it didn't sound even remotely Irish.
Edit. Everything else he said sounded reasonable to me.
Another thumbnail putting absurd rosy spin on the current situation. Is Putin 'crushed' ?
I think people are not unstanding one thing with border of Russia being so close Ukraine can't use artillery or long range stuff because of America saying they can't use weapons inside Russia so how can defend a area so close too Russian border you can't use long range assets too push or slow Russian but Russia can exspolit there border too use there long range assets like artillery so it pretty much one sided maby people need stop saying thing that give Russian the advantage and put Ukraine at disadvantage like we did by making them throw troop at Russian heavly defend areas which has now put them on back foot as well as delaying the supply
Ukraine will get far more done than this guy expects if the US just gives them the damn weapons they need. Honestly, the US could make a huge difference by putting aircraft maintainers as advisors so that the F16s can get into combat.
Do you really pay this guy??…..
😊
Just listening to him is so negative
Don’t worry the usual propaganda programming will be coming soon. Where Russia already lost the war ten years ago and NATO is GREAT!
What is he talking about. Sounds like a bubbling old man with little understanding of Ukraine war and Russian’s weakness. He still sees Russia as a super power.
Like it or not, russia has the initiative at the moment and by all accounts their moral is high. The west has been far to slow to respond and 2 years into the war we still haven’t been able to supply Ukraine with the same number of missiles fired by Russia…let alone exceed it. NATO obviously has the superior army to Russia but what about if China and Belarus get involved ? This war isn’t over until russia has been kicked back to its borders.
The ukrain border was being monitored by Russia for years and every time they tried to build strength, they would be targeted so unable to build anything, nor construct anything , so they put the main defence many k behind the border. The border force role was to hold them for 24 hours to allow back fill with forces……. So not as bad as the news and some people call it.
Tsushima
The silliness continues over at Times Radio.
His constant stuttering makes this hard to listen to, " of...of...of...","in...in...in...in...in", "that...that...that..."
Ukraine is weak because of the slow walking of the defense equipment Ukraine is fighting with one hand behind there backs !
Ive been a fan of the times for decades, but unfortunately this guest is the worst i have ever seen the times stoop so low as to have as an expert.