I like that elizabeth bennet had the guts to reject mr darcy and called him out for his behavior.. but it takes great courage for jane eyre to straight up leave mr rochester WHILE knowing that she's deeply in love with him.
OMG yes....this is pure emotion !!!! and i think the difference is that EB was not so in love when she reject MrD, she felt for him later, but Jane was madly in love but she defended her honor....that was soooo hard.....
@@monmothma3358 Which actually prompts one to wonder how on earth Rochester, knowing this, still managed to convince himself that Jane would consent to go along with this once she learned the truth -- because in the book, Rochester promises to tell Jane the truth about Grace Poole (and, one assumes, the truth about Bertha Mason) after "a year and a day." Granted, Rochester himself admits to Jane that he has not paid enough attention to his principles and that they are probably not what they should be...but especially since Jane's purity of heart and strength of character is what attracted him to her in the first place and prompted him to fall in love with her, why did he think she would willingly agree to throw all that away for a life of comfort when that would only mean that she's not that much different from Celine Varens?
I love how at 2:26 you can see Jane steel her resolve --- the way she closes her eyes and visibly pulls herself together. Then when she says "I must respect myself" she's looking over Rochester's shoulder like she knows she'll give in if she looks at him. Masterful acting on both of their parts.
I definitely believe that these two actresses gave the best acting ever in all film, but mainly in that scene. I've seen almost all the Jane Eyre's versions, and I do not want to underestimate none of them. But the acting of those, was quite theatrical, but this of Michael and Mia, was so natural, so touching! Congratulations!
This was good, but I'm actually partial to Dalton's version of Mr. Rochester. Hearing him at the end in this scene gave me goosebumps. You can tell they did a softer version w/this one.
This version is so good, but the Samantha Morton/Ciaran Hines version is very passionate and the Orson Wells/Joan Fontaine version is more in line with the magical aspect and a wonderful version. These are my 3 favorite versions.
ปีที่แล้ว +7
My fav is the BBC adaptation from 2006 with Toby Stephens and Rachel Wilson. A lot is different from the book, but the whole "feel" of JE is so there...to me, more than some of the closer adaptations. Toby Stephens managed to show the funny side of Rochester really well.
What? He did no such thing. She denied him even though it almost killed him because of how much he loved her. If you don’t see the beauty and depth of their love then you’re missing out on what true love is.
@@lisagarnet2000 did he love her? yes. Was he selfishly trying to hide things from her to deny her the chance of making her own choice? Also yes. While many may not agree with Jane's morals, no good or lasting love will come from deception or tricking someone into doing what they feel is wrong. The book's universe makes it very clear that if Jane had stayed against her conscience, things would have ended terribly, no matter their love for each other.
It was said in the novel that Mr. Rochester threatened Jane that he will commit violence. It doesn't say whether he will hurt her or himself. Majority of "Jane Eyre" adaptations omit that part as it would potentially ruin Mr. Rochester's image further.
I really like this scene despite many unfauvorable comparisons to the 1983 and 2006 miniseries: to me, Mia is a far better Jane! Zelah was flat and a bit wooden, Ruth was hardly innocent and just flirtatious. Mia, IMO, really captures the inner torment of Jane in this scene. And she DOES look like she is 18!
It's classical literature from the author Charlotte Bronte, that alone should tell one😂. The book is really lovely though- the life journey Jane survives to eventually find love is the stuff that heroines are made of ❤🩹❤🩹❤🩹
This is amazing acting, but nothing will ever touch the version with Timothy Dalton and Zelah Clarke. That one made me cry every time (more than Titanic). Being alive and out of reach is like a living death (as far as love is concerned, and humans seem hard-wired to need love, lol). It's torment just to get up in the morning, still breathing. But thank God for everything, including the tests.
They nailed this scene. I don’t think this is the best adaptation of the ones I’ve seen, but it definitely nailed all the crucial Jane and Rochester scenes. But Rochester’s lack of morality really ruined his appeal to me as a reader and I’m surprised Jane would go back to him when he wanted her to commit adultery with him and so easily brushed aside morals.
Its a real mad woman that replaced bertha who had grudge aganist roschester she brought by mysterious person from some folks that hang out at cemetery remember bertha lived somewhere else he took jane away for two years.
now i am reading the book in Turkish and i am so close to finish it and i feel so excited and sad about them. Also i want to say, british accent is sooo good i wish i speak in british accent rather than american🎉
Jane already came from a painful past,her childhood was dark,she said a line,"I must respect myself", meant that she thought that marrying him at that point of time was not correct,jane is gifted with humour and cleverness which I like,but she definitely misunderstood some things.
ER: “I’m not violent, I just want to break your neck…” Some time later… JE: “Well, look what you’ve become, my wild beast, I feel safe now … there’s no one between us and will never be…” It’s so hard to figure out Jane in these adaptations, she either sheds not a single tear like with Timothy Dalton (best Mr. Rochester by FAR) or looks like she just came down from a medieval painting, wrong period. ER was twice her age and she was a child by modern standards, a traumatized child only to feel affection towards an emotionally manipulative entitled man who saw her innocence and still couldn’t respect her enough to protect her feelings by being open with her. It took a tragedy and for him to become a mockery of what he used to be to turn into someone who wouldn’t harm her and who she can accept, but she deserves so much better…
I read it in 8th grade and almost gave up because of the never-ending, insufferable party, lol. I certainly wouldn't have been able to write a even a mediocre book report for school on it, but I guess I did find it fascinating because I kept reading it and reading it, probably about nine times, once I read it four times in a year. Let me tell you something there's not much you don't pick up after reading something nine times, lol😂 I don't even like other books of this era or by this author, just Jane, lol
@@zayinm31 i named my child Jane because of Jane Eyre. I wonder what she’ll think when she’s old enough to watch them all, all the adaptations or if she won’t ever watch them🙀
I was gonna say, she inherited her family’s fortune so what’s the problem then I remember, he imprisoned his first wife. Sure she’s crazy I know, buuuut it’s kinda hard to forgive and forget that.
@@monmothma3358 He was abusive towards his real wife Bertha and he is an adulterer and he knew what he did was wrong. It was no more a mistake than someone choosing to commit a crime, knowing the consequences. I have no sympathy for such corrupt deceitful people. Jane was right to leave and should have kept moving on without him.
@@EmilyGloeggler7984 How was he abusive to Bertha? Genuine question. He kept her in the attic because it was the only alternative to sending her to a mental facility where she would be certainly abused and left for dead. Given the time period what else could you reasonably expect him to do?
@@mysharona9097He didn’t love his wife. He gave up on her. Then, he committed adultery against her with an innocent unmarried woman. I have been through what Jane did, when I was accosted by guys who had been with other women and who even had a child with another woman. I have no interest to be with a polygamist. God gave me the freedom to find a monogamist Godly man. I ended up doing so and I thank God. I never went back to any of those disgusting ex’s once I found out what they were and what they did. My husband was worth the wait. :)
His idea of love to his mentally challenged wife was to lock her away and cheat on her (rather than send her way ... what what, no 3rd choice? For better or for worse??) . When Jane came back to him, after his wife committed suicide, she should marry him, lock him up, and then take the missioary man down the aisle, without telling him of her shameful past. It is the same thing. This movie is messed up, brainwashing women and men on their relationship roles and ideas of "love". Jane was an idiot for ever going back. Evidentally, inept spouses should be locked away ... did she learn nothing??
To send her away would have been more horrific then her present state. Read what insane asylums were like. That he almost died trying to save her speaks to his character.
What do you propose as the 3rd choice in your infinite wisdom and 200 years of technological progess? She is not "inept" as you put it, she is dangerously and VIOLENTLY insane. Girl would still be locked up in our time, either in jail or institution. You don't seem to understand what the story is saying about love or just about anything in general.
I think that the wife is a sort of symbol of how in that era and in so many cases, women have to lock away their "untamed" side. Even more so in british culture. Jane throughout the book is controlling herself tightly while she has a storm of feelings inside that she can never let out, because society will make her pay for it
I like that elizabeth bennet had the guts to reject mr darcy and called him out for his behavior.. but it takes great courage for jane eyre to straight up leave mr rochester WHILE knowing that she's deeply in love with him.
OMG yes....this is pure emotion !!!! and i think the difference is that EB was not so in love when she reject MrD, she felt for him later, but Jane was madly in love but she defended her honor....that was soooo hard.....
Exactly. And Jane is that morally and mentally strong, that's part of what Rochester admired in her
@@monmothma3358 Which actually prompts one to wonder how on earth Rochester, knowing this, still managed to convince himself that Jane would consent to go along with this once she learned the truth -- because in the book, Rochester promises to tell Jane the truth about Grace Poole (and, one assumes, the truth about Bertha Mason) after "a year and a day." Granted, Rochester himself admits to Jane that he has not paid enough attention to his principles and that they are probably not what they should be...but especially since Jane's purity of heart and strength of character is what attracted him to her in the first place and prompted him to fall in love with her, why did he think she would willingly agree to throw all that away for a life of comfort when that would only mean that she's not that much different from Celine Varens?
If only Jane had kept moving on and never looked back. Sadly, that was her fatal error.
Wait i had the same thing happen to me, does it mean i'm i have great courage😌
I love how at 2:26 you can see Jane steel her resolve --- the way she closes her eyes and visibly pulls herself together. Then when she says "I must respect myself" she's looking over Rochester's shoulder like she knows she'll give in if she looks at him. Masterful acting on both of their parts.
And then the way he immediately begins to panic and pseudo-threatens her out of desperation…
Jane is stronger than most of us.
I definitely believe that these two actresses gave the best acting ever in all film, but mainly in that scene. I've seen almost all the Jane Eyre's versions, and I do not want to underestimate none of them. But the acting of those, was quite theatrical, but this of Michael and Mia, was so natural, so touching! Congratulations!
This was good, but I'm actually partial to Dalton's version of Mr. Rochester. Hearing him at the end in this scene gave me goosebumps. You can tell they did a softer version w/this one.
This version is so good, but the Samantha Morton/Ciaran Hines version is very passionate and the Orson Wells/Joan Fontaine version is more in line with the magical aspect and a wonderful version. These are my 3 favorite versions.
My fav is the BBC adaptation from 2006 with Toby Stephens and Rachel Wilson. A lot is different from the book, but the whole "feel" of JE is so there...to me, more than some of the closer adaptations. Toby Stephens managed to show the funny side of Rochester really well.
@pcarebear1 Definitely the version with Zelah Clarke and Timothy Dalton. It's larger-than-life gut-wrenching.
yeeeeeeeee
He made an adulterer out of her. His deceit caused her to unknowingly transgress her moral values.
However, this is Jane Eyre we are talking about, and she refused that fate out of deep love and integrity.😌
But his marriage didn't count
What? He did no such thing. She denied him even though it almost killed him because of how much he loved her. If you don’t see the beauty and depth of their love then you’re missing out on what true love is.
You know how much I’d transgress to get a piece of Michael Fassbender 😅😂
@@lisagarnet2000 did he love her? yes. Was he selfishly trying to hide things from her to deny her the chance of making her own choice? Also yes. While many may not agree with Jane's morals, no good or lasting love will come from deception or tricking someone into doing what they feel is wrong. The book's universe makes it very clear that if Jane had stayed against her conscience, things would have ended terribly, no matter their love for each other.
Amazing scene...so full of passion and desperation. Wonderful actors who had great chemistry in this film.
Both great acting but she is incredible. Thats an extremely difficult part to play correctly. WOW.
Nothing says heart wrenching love like a hint of homicide.
😂😂😂
Yep, threatening to break someone’s neck is the epitome of love. SMH
It was said in the novel that Mr. Rochester threatened Jane that he will commit violence. It doesn't say whether he will hurt her or himself. Majority of "Jane Eyre" adaptations omit that part as it would potentially ruin Mr. Rochester's image further.
Fassbender is a brilliant Rochester. So proud that he's Irish.❤❤
De hecho es alemán también
That was quite the knee-slapper.
I’ve been dispatched🤣💀
Wasn’t it just!😂
Romantic? Yes, extremely. Comedy? Haha, no.
Jane Eyre is not a romantic comedy...
I really like this scene despite many unfauvorable comparisons to the 1983 and 2006 miniseries: to me, Mia is a far better Jane! Zelah was flat and a bit wooden, Ruth was hardly innocent and just flirtatious. Mia, IMO, really captures the inner torment of Jane in this scene. And she DOES look like she is 18!
If Jane Eyre feels like comedy, someone needs a doctor.
Have you read the book? It is a comedy 😂
@@brittanywoodbury6938 It is humorous but hardly a comedy genre man
@@ihatenwo I didn't think it was humorous when I read it.
@@alethehamster well Certain parts did
@@ihatenwo could you give me an example? because, tbh, i can't think of any
I LOVE Michael Fassbender as an actor. He’s hot to boot too!
Ikr so smoking hot 🔥 I can't, Fassbender is the most handsome and most talented actor in the world 😍
Love him in Inglorious Bastards (spelling, lol)
No lies are ever truly supportive of love. Only in what is real and true can love grown He should have trusted her with truth.
Wonderfull acting! Soo emotional and raw! ❤❤
Like Samantha in SATC said:"I love you Mr. Rochester, but I love me more" 😂🤣😂🤣😂
Nothing alike
Are we sure this is a romcom?
right, more like a gothic romance
It's classical literature from the author Charlotte Bronte, that alone should tell one😂. The book is really lovely though- the life journey Jane survives to eventually find love is the stuff that heroines are made of ❤🩹❤🩹❤🩹
This is a good book.
It's actually a romantic drama
Lol - it’s definitely not a romcom…based on an excellent book though
I wish I could stitch all the versions of Jane Eyre together to include the scenes performed by each pair. I would include this one for this scene.
Just commented on that! I prefer this scene and Mia's portrayal than the adaptations of 1983 and 2006
this is not a "rom-com" nor are many other movies categorized on site
How is Jane Eyre a romcom?
Elevated acting!
Great acting👏👏👏
I love this book 🤗
This is amazing acting, but nothing will ever touch the version with Timothy Dalton and Zelah Clarke. That one made me cry every time (more than Titanic). Being alive and out of reach is like a living death (as far as love is concerned, and humans seem hard-wired to need love, lol). It's torment just to get up in the morning, still breathing. But thank God for everything, including the tests.
Agree 💯 ❤
Dalton's Rochester screamed and cried when Jane refused to stay with him. I felt so bad for him I wanted to weep too
I liked him but not her rendition
They nailed this scene. I don’t think this is the best adaptation of the ones I’ve seen, but it definitely nailed all the crucial Jane and Rochester scenes. But Rochester’s lack of morality really ruined his appeal to me as a reader and I’m surprised Jane would go back to him when he wanted her to commit adultery with him and so easily brushed aside morals.
no verdadeiro amor existe perdão.
So easily? It didn’t seem easy to me.
Its a real mad woman that replaced bertha who had grudge aganist roschester she brought by mysterious person from some folks that hang out at cemetery remember bertha lived somewhere else he took jane away for two years.
Definitely not a romcom
now i am reading the book in Turkish and i am so close to finish it and i feel so excited and sad about them. Also i want to say, british accent is sooo good i wish i speak in british accent rather than american🎉
너무 슬퍼요...ㅠ
Jane already came from a painful past,her childhood was dark,she said a line,"I must respect myself", meant that she thought that marrying him at that point of time was not correct,jane is gifted with humour and cleverness which I like,but she definitely misunderstood some things.
These two actors are not Charlotte Brontë's Jane Eyre and Edward Rochester.
ER: “I’m not violent, I just want to break your neck…”
Some time later…
JE: “Well, look what you’ve become, my wild beast, I feel safe now … there’s no one between us and will never be…”
It’s so hard to figure out Jane in these adaptations, she either sheds not a single tear like with Timothy Dalton (best Mr. Rochester by FAR) or looks like she just came down from a medieval painting, wrong period. ER was twice her age and she was a child by modern standards, a traumatized child only to feel affection towards an emotionally manipulative entitled man who saw her innocence and still couldn’t respect her enough to protect her feelings by being open with her. It took a tragedy and for him to become a mockery of what he used to be to turn into someone who wouldn’t harm her and who she can accept, but she deserves so much better…
Donde la puedo ver completaaaa
i read jane eyre in 9th grade and i didn't understand anything lmao
deep scene tho
I read it in 8th grade and almost gave up because of the never-ending, insufferable party, lol. I certainly wouldn't have been able to write a even a mediocre book report for school on it, but I guess I did find it fascinating because I kept reading it and reading it, probably about nine times, once I read it four times in a year. Let me tell you something there's not much you don't pick up after reading something nine times, lol😂 I don't even like other books of this era or by this author, just Jane, lol
@@zayinm31 i named my child Jane because of Jane Eyre. I wonder what she’ll think when she’s old enough to watch them all, all the adaptations or if she won’t ever watch them🙀
You gotta love how 'modern audiences' can't for the life of them understand anything outside their perception or worldview.
Looks like me breaking up with my ex 🤣
Ni medio ruego necesito
2:44
Oooooooh.
I was gonna say, she inherited her family’s fortune so what’s the problem then I remember, he imprisoned his first wife. Sure she’s crazy I know, buuuut it’s kinda hard to forgive and forget that.
Jane should have left that abusive adulterer and never went back.
He made a big mistake, but he wasn't abusive
@@monmothma3358 He was abusive towards his real wife Bertha and he is an adulterer and he knew what he did was wrong. It was no more a mistake than someone choosing to commit a crime, knowing the consequences. I have no sympathy for such
corrupt deceitful people. Jane was right to leave and should have kept moving on without him.
@@EmilyGloeggler7984 How was he abusive to Bertha? Genuine question. He kept her in the attic because it was the only alternative to sending her to a mental facility where she would be certainly abused and left for dead. Given the time period what else could you reasonably expect him to do?
@@mysharona9097Jane was wise to leave an adulterer.
@@mysharona9097He didn’t love his wife. He gave up on her. Then, he committed adultery against her with an innocent unmarried woman. I have been through what Jane did, when I was accosted by guys who had been with other women and who even had a child with another woman. I have no interest to be with a polygamist. God gave me the freedom to find a monogamist Godly man. I ended up doing so and I thank God. I never went back to any of those disgusting ex’s once I found out what they were and what they did. My husband was worth the wait. :)
His idea of love to his mentally challenged wife was to lock her away and cheat on her (rather than send her way ... what what, no 3rd choice? For better or for worse??) . When Jane came back to him, after his wife committed suicide, she should marry him, lock him up, and then take the missioary man down the aisle, without telling him of her shameful past. It is the same thing. This movie is messed up, brainwashing women and men on their relationship roles and ideas of "love". Jane was an idiot for ever going back. Evidentally, inept spouses should be locked away ... did she learn nothing??
He is too handsome to be treated like that
To send her away would have been more horrific then her present state. Read what insane asylums were like. That he almost died trying to save her speaks to his character.
What do you propose as the 3rd choice in your infinite wisdom and 200 years of technological progess? She is not "inept" as you put it, she is dangerously and VIOLENTLY insane. Girl would still be locked up in our time, either in jail or institution.
You don't seem to understand what the story is saying about love or just about anything in general.
I think that the wife is a sort of symbol of how in that era and in so many cases, women have to lock away their "untamed" side. Even more so in british culture. Jane throughout the book is controlling herself tightly while she has a storm of feelings inside that she can never let out, because society will make her pay for it
She’s not mentally challenged she’s mentally insane in the book it says she was literally crawling on all fours that’s literally demonic
She is not Jane for sure. So disappointed with her performance.