Thanks for the wonderful program by shri G S Mani. MSV is like god to me. I felt so happy to hear about him through Mani sir. My Pranams to the genius 🙏🙏
I happened to see this video only today. Wonderful It Is. Lucky I could.... A Great Singer doing a great service and rendering wonderful music to invited audience. So much to understand and learn. But to my surprise I found the audience interested only in themselves and chit chatting most of the time. Very Sad to watch. This sight is very disturbing...
One cannot hear what the person in Pink or violet shirt is speaking. His voice is feeble and he has not adjusted the Mike. Please have correct posture in the future while speaking and adjust the Mike. thanks
All seems to be educated audiance with no basic discipline. Even during the prayer song many were talking. it's a tribute to a legend. It's not a comedy show.
Vijaikanni Kothandaraman ...... “”Grey hair alone..never shows maturity. “”...basic manners...Ethics.... They more ladies gather here to gossip. &. Not even single male with spine to pull the gossipers It is most unfortunate...not even great GSM.to put a stop for this,,,,!!!!!!!
Mani mama - Soundscaping or sound design is also an art and an integral part of music... creating music only with melody or composing with one or no instrument while amazing, does not have to be the central piece in music. At its core, how is melody not a form of sound-scaping or engineering? Where did the harmonium come from? Have you considered that it was cutting edge technology the day after it was invented? Can you pitch bend on a harmonium like a veena or violin? By using your own standards of musical purity, I would contend that you shouldn’t use the harmonium as it cannot properly render gamakas and sliding scales. Should we call blasphemy then on the harmonium sullying the holy waters of this high art form? (We shouldn’t). Also, since you seem so reviled by sound “producers”, perhaps you should try performing concerts or cutting an album in the future without the sound engineering mixing or mastering artists. To the modern wars, sound producers/artists have the ability to transport you to another world. Sounds exactly the same as what melody producers are trying to do. Your generation did stunning work creating melodic compositions based on raagas. But the world is more connected and there are other frameworks to produce music. Be it Kuthu, Gaana or Jazz. Accepting, learning and enjoying those works including “sound production” as musical art shows an evolved mind, in my view. I can’t help but think of an imaginary old iyer mama (not old in age), back in the day, yelling at his son for participating in the forbidden sensual dirty business called movies and producing “music” for the same. And that too, producing music with a harmonium! Lol. While I say all that, you are still a superb artist in my mind and deserve much respect to you for your contributions to music. “Sound producers” are musical artists too and deserve the same respect as Indian classical melody creators.
Thanks for the wonderful program by
shri G S Mani.
MSV is like god to me.
I felt so happy to hear about him through Mani sir.
My Pranams to the genius 🙏🙏
Not only MSV sir , you are also a genious in music Excellent voice and knowledge you too have sir Fantabulous programme
Genious music director was MSV sir I love his music and his dedication in music
Nice to see
Your legend Mr Mani
I happened to see this video only today. Wonderful It Is. Lucky I could....
A Great Singer doing a great service and rendering wonderful music to invited audience. So much to understand and learn. But to my surprise I found the audience interested only in themselves and chit chatting most of the time. Very Sad to watch. This sight is very disturbing...
It's always a pleasure to listen & Interact with our dear MANI GARU ... GENIUS ...
Thanks Mr. RS Raman for sharing your thoughts here. Hope you too felt the same while watching the video.
very nice prog !!!
M.S.V the Greatest University of Music- Haja, Qatar
தாங்கள் மேற்கோள் காட்டிப் பாடிய இரண்டு பாடல்களுமே எனக்கு உயிர் ஐயா!!
நானன்றி யார் வருவார்,
தங்கரதம் வந்தது வீதியிலே
Kalaivani maru avatharam than MSV sir
it is unfortunate that some of the audience are talking among themselves.
Thi much effort full programme reached only few people.....why don't you people try to reach common people...
One cannot hear what the person in Pink or violet shirt is speaking. His voice is feeble and he has not adjusted the Mike. Please have correct posture in the future while speaking and adjust the Mike. thanks
All seems to be educated audiance with no basic discipline. Even during the prayer song many were talking. it's a tribute to a legend. It's not a comedy show.
Vijaikanni Kothandaraman ...... “”Grey hair alone..never shows maturity. “”...basic manners...Ethics....
They more ladies gather here to gossip. &. Not even single male with spine to pull the gossipers
It is most unfortunate...not even great GSM.to put a stop for this,,,,!!!!!!!
That is the unique trait of Indians did you not know.
It is a tribute to the legend. People should have observed basic discipline.
Voice not clear! Why!?
Audio is very poor
What are you trying to say you know english ver y well
Mani mama - Soundscaping or sound design is also an art and an integral part of music... creating music only with melody or composing with one or no instrument while amazing, does not have to be the central piece in music. At its core, how is melody not a form of sound-scaping or engineering? Where did the harmonium come from? Have you considered that it was cutting edge technology the day after it was invented? Can you pitch bend on a harmonium like a veena or violin? By using your own standards of musical purity, I would contend that you shouldn’t use the harmonium as it cannot properly render gamakas and sliding scales. Should we call blasphemy then on the harmonium sullying the holy waters of this high art form? (We shouldn’t). Also, since you seem so reviled by sound “producers”, perhaps you should try performing concerts or cutting an album in the future without the sound engineering mixing or mastering artists. To the modern wars, sound producers/artists have the ability to transport you to another world. Sounds exactly the same as what melody producers are trying to do.
Your generation did stunning work creating melodic compositions based on raagas. But the world is more connected and there are other frameworks to produce music. Be it Kuthu, Gaana or Jazz. Accepting, learning and enjoying those works including “sound production” as musical art shows an evolved mind, in my view.
I can’t help but think of an imaginary old iyer mama (not old in age), back in the day, yelling at his son for participating in the forbidden sensual dirty business called movies and producing “music” for the same. And that too, producing music with a harmonium! Lol.
While I say all that, you are still a superb artist in my mind and deserve much respect to you for your contributions to music.
“Sound producers” are musical artists too and deserve the same respect as Indian classical melody creators.