I thought it was season 4 now. Season 1: The vote and ”will they/wont they trigger article 50”. Season 2: Article 50 is triggered and negotiations play out. Season 3: Negotiations stop, parliament rejects the deal which triggers the chaos. Season finale is the scene Bercow makes during the closing of parliament. Season 4: Starts with the supreme court handling the legality of the prorogation, parliament resumes work with everyone’s favorite speaker bringing OOOORDAAAA to the house.
As a Canadian, may I remind the British parliament that, as the model on which many other Commonwealth parliaments have been based, because it serves as a model to the others, it has a responsibility to show how effectively it can run. The extreme partisanship displayed there is not at all a model. Why had the minority government not reported on details of its Brexit negotiations with the EU? Why is it not preparing the British public to vote in a referendum on the Brexit withdrawal agreement it hopes that the EU will accept?
Hello 👋 we had a referendum. We voted OUT. We were not given an option to negotiate NOR did we ask for any agreement of withdrawal. The options were remain or leave. Simple.
@aud loves life The first referendum was acted upon when article 51 was submitted. The opposition are now trying to block the Uk leaving without a Deal, which goes against the referendum result.
Boris: We need to prorogue Parliament so we can write a Queen's Speech. It's not about Brexit I swear. Court: Not a chance mate, we don't believe you. Boris: Dratted Remoaners trying to block Brexit at every turn!!!! Also, a bonus sketch. Boris: We need to prorogue Parliament so we can write a Queen's Speech. Public: Okay, how long do you need? Boris: Five weeks. I'm a really slow writer, but Michael promised to check my spellings for me.
Perfect parliament series 1. Government with no majority, 2. No plans for Brexit 3. Prime Minister breaking the law. Hosted by my favorite Speaker Bercow with stellar performances Jeremy Corbyn, Ian Blackford, Anna Soubry, Boris Johnson will keep us in chaos and suspension until Holloween
Prorogation was cancelled. The Supreme Court ruled that the Prorogation never happened, in turn we don't need a Queens speech cause that would mean the end of a Prorogation, again which never happened.
They are now saying they can do it in 2 or 3 days with another prorogation, so why did it need to be 5 weeks? I think every atom in the sorry souls includes a lie.
In America they have political appointees as judges. The ruling power in politics can stack the judiciary in such a way that any wrong-doing goes unchecked. Donald Trump has broken the law, members of his cabinet break the law and the opposing parties are stymied because of the judicial choke hold and the ability to drag things out via the courts. I could not be more proud of our independent judiciary. BoJo steps out of line once and the people can slap him back down because of the independence of our judicial system. Whether you agree with Brexit or not, fair play is true Britishness.. if we abandon that which Britain should be proud, what are you fighting for?
A. Egan. Ian Duncan Smith has recently chaired a committee for 'social justice' meeting and revealed state pension age will be 75. Now, he can't work until he's 75 because he hasn't started yet. As I said, this is a grand idea from the above mentioned, C. For S Justice. The baffling thing is, how can the name I D Smith and word justice, be contained in the same sentence
Classic Freudian slip at 7:35 - Peter Bone says "The Government did what he thought was right." Does he mean BoJo or tRump? Either way, there is more than one person in HM Government, or does Mr Bone see that differently?
So the opposition is scared for an election, the government is scared for a second referendum. As an outsider I think that the only way out of this mess is first a second referendum to deal with Brexit and second a election to deal with everything else. Personally I thing the British population will never ever give Brexit a majority, so problem solved.
Jeroen, are you Dutch? You've delivered a sensible pathway here, but unfortunately the shower of cabbage people in the clip aren't taking in much in the way of good balance at the moment.
MrMmnngghh The strange thing is that I don’t hear that strategy from MP’s and in my opinion it would be best to walk that path. Make the final deal that parliament is willing to approve, put that to the people, get that it of the way and then an election on the issues that are determined by party-politics. Things could be so easy to solve.
The attorney general just blew the snakes out of the water. Its about time someone stood up and told them all what we think of them. Its time for a general election so the public can get shut of these traitors and get some people in there that actually want to do some good
He is the Attorney General, just not a very good one....................quite an average one.....................a poor one................quite an incompetent one...................a fucking old wanker of one.
Do the opposition have ANYTHING else to say but; "WE FINALLY GOT A BROWNIE POINT". Agree to a general election and see how clever you are and what the PUBLIC really want. But believing in democracy is not really their thing is it?
You seamed to have failed to grasp that the UK is a parliamentarian democracy which in short means the parliament's wish rates higher legally than a referendum
@@jacobjorgenson9285 There you go again. SCREW the wishes of the people. WE are better than you and didn't really want to know what you wanted as respectfully we are indeed a dictatorship disguised as a democracy.
@@EggReports Simple majority of about 3%, voting majority at that, not majority of the whole country because not every citizen that could vote did. People also lied and some have changed sides, you can't say a % from 3 years ago is the same % as today.
They are a disgrace and a shambles behaving in a sanctimonious manner in their illegal contrived manner to remain with the EU. What next!. Do we have to boycott everything coming from the EU. It could happen. Think carefully when you shop everyone!
@@colinmitchell9212 Will have to wait and see. Last I heard the EU stated there will be NO EXTENSION past the October 31st deadline. There is also the part of the Article 50 that states the PM can declare the UK out of the EU ANYTIME after commencement. IS this correct?
Is the media that biased that they would show the European flag during the introduction???? Then as the broadcast progressed, there were always European flags in the background when the cameras went outdoors.. Dont they have pride in their own flag??/
The whole thing just gets worse and worse. I can’t stand to watch it anymore. Is there one EU country with the backbone to block any further delaying tactics and force the UK out on the 31st of October?
The people get the politicians they deserve. Despise these politicians all you like but know that the people are not entirely blameless for the current state of democracy.
It wasn't obvious that the prorogation was unlawful. Why else would the English and Irish court rulings, prior to the judgement of the Supreme Court, determine that Boris was perfectly within his rights to do what he did? To argue that Boris was clearly in the wrong from the start, without citing personal opinion, is simple nonsense.
The only possible explanation is that they are all secret Brexiteers, being paid off by the ERG in a conspiratorial and biased anti-EU judicial system. But that is ludicrous.
Grymbaldknight you’re right, but the fact that the government saw fit to sail so close to the wind as to be verging on illegality is fairly despicable. The government should behave in a way that is beyond reproach. It has still not been adequately explained why the government needed 5 weeks to do something that usually takes a week to organise.
They didn't say it was within his rights, they just said it was a political matter the courts didn't want to get involved in. It's the equivalent of saying "no comment".
Thats the problem our MPs don't get out of London they never come to my town Boston 75% leave. Strangely we never have any remoaner protests either Ha Ha.
She's a Constitutional Monarch, the power to remove MPs lies with the voters. Seriously what do you guys do at school? Imagine having the future of the country being determined by people who don't understand how the country works.. oh wait.
@Albert Pike that's not what BoJo said. He has publicly said he wants a deal. So I guess you're defending BoJo for naught? Wake up, crashing out with No Deal is stupidity. You don't gain anything by causing chaos. You cannot trade with WTO rules if there is no pre agreement in place with the EU, or pray miraculously no one in WTO would somehow not make a protest on your tariff schedule. Also if you build a hard border between Ireland and Northern Ireland you break the Good Friday Agreement, which means you are asking for the Troubles to start again. Think man. Don't be sheep for Farage. He's got an EU passport through his German wife.
I have absolute respect for the integrity and competence of the Attorney General? What integrity? What competence? What medications is Oliver Letwin taking, or forgetting to take?
What better way to take a month off , when your country is approaching a critical deadline !"October first we will vote to surrender all land and territory to the USA ! Now let's all take a month off m see you two weeks before October 31." No I know what you're thinking , but that's not going to happen , far to many liberals . 😆
After all these years I have come to the conclusion that the Leave side never really had a plan of making Brexit work because I don’t think they were going to win the referendum. Add that to the fact that they couldn’t get a Leave supporter to lead the Tories once Cameron resigned, and the chain reaction leading to the train wreck began.
The supreme court did not say what length of prorogation would have been 'lawful'. Four weeks, 3, 2, 1? They might say it's not just the length but the purpose of prorogation that must be 'lawful'. In the future, who will judge what is the true purpose and whether it is 'lawful'? In the future, who will decide the 'lawful' length of prorogation? A judge? In the future, shall we be governed by judges? Judges have no empathy, sympathy, pragmatism or common sense. Judges can see no further than their own personal concept of the law. They are not competent for politics and they should stay well out of it. They should withdraw their judgment on the prorogation.
If they had ruled any other way, they would have given the government the right to suspend the parliament, i.e. the citizens right to representation, for an interminate period. That is, it would have also enabled a remainer national unity government replacing Johnson's to cancel Brexit and prorogue parliament for two years preventing Brexiteer parliamentarians from criticising/scrutinizing government. Therefore, the Court said that a prorogation typically lasts for 4-6 days and if it is longer, it must not constitute a hampering of the parliament's ability to legislate and scrutinice the government. The government serves at the pleasure of the parliament, not the other way around.
How would they know the advice was illegal until the court found it illegal?? these critics are nonsensical, hysterical. I cannot see how this news report is neutral as he is putting his own negative view and interviewing people biased one way.
it's called holding the PM and government to account which is a parliamentary issue, if you dont believe that shouldn't have happened, then you are mindless and we are already lost... what say you?
@@Freemouse159 Forgive me for saying so but simply check the mainstream media and you'll be reminded EVERYWHERE that it did indeed happen. With regard to the fact it "shouldn't have happened" and that, that would make me "mindless". It did happen for good reason. The main reason being the opposition blocking EVERY bill presented by the government AFTER extensive house debates. Then by your own admission as such. Shouldn't the opposition present a bill of no coincidence in the sitting government and force a general election? Sorry for my lengthy "mindless" response. However this issue is not made any easier by closed end statements which is in fact why parliament are making little progress on ANY issues facing us all. What say you?
Boris was conspicuous by his absence. He probably overslept, Donald probably forgot to set the alarm. Rumour has it he had a sun bed session booked with Donald, look out for the white panda eyes on his return.
@@EggReports I didnt understand a single point within your last post, so I'm going to boil it down for you and hope I get a coherent response back... Parliament was shutdown with the reason being there was a queens speech on the way... the Govt was taken to court and they lost because they were found to be lying to the queen for shutting the house down. simple. If you think that's unfair (which boggles the mind) then you are mindless, as a taxpayer and citizen I want my MP to be in Parliament WORKING, not being sent home just because the BoJo govt wants an easy walk through Brexit, would you rather not have a brexit done so that all the issues we will face have been talked about and made sure its resolved or are you ok with blindly doing things just because your are so desperate to leave? Respond sir!
I'm lost. Surely if the queen has the power to prorogue parliament (which she did), she must also be reconvene it? After all she is not subject to the wisdom of of a corrupt and partisan court is she? How can they just pitch up without her authorisation?
I am so very sorry to all people who pay hard earned money in taxes to see a smirking politician say they accept a ruling from court knowing they misused and twisted aka "interpretated" the system in the first place resulting in high court administration costs and disruptions to other cases which the people will in essence have to account for. The money wasted on all this nonsense should be given back to the taxpayers. And no I dont agree to word twister below.
@@nompho7820 detail the calculations and if there is waste then everybody should absolutely be held accountable but facts please because everybody can simply quote numbers without back up, too easy these days.
I was told to always question things because many political and powerful people in history quoted things which were not true and as a result caused chaos and wars, so I would not quote a figure unless I researched it myself, it is easy to say something without proper back up. If you choose to believe without backup and full root cause analysis then that is your choice but please respect mine and don't try to twist my words in an attempt to cause friction. I see this all the time here from this "movement" as they call themselves and i am so tired of 1940s style propagandists.
If as Hezeltine says, the subordinate courts are wrong, why even bother with them? The unanimous reversal by the Supremes over The AG, Parliament, precedent, and lower courts, smack of political bias to me!
Ugh, the speaker is doing his job. It's not his job to help the PM, it's the Speaker's job to empower Parliament. The difference is because first Theresa May as PM couldn't get her majority to pass her deal. Now the PM has tossed his majority away. That means Boris Johnson is in essence the opposition. That means the Speaker empowering Parliament means the government isn't going to get what they want. All of this wouldn't be an issue with the ERG had voted with the whip for their PM's deal. They ignored their PM because they've decided that despite not being even mentioned in the Leave campaign the referendum was on Remain or No Deal. It's apparently the new normal though to retroactively change what things mean. See "the prorogation was exclusively for a queen's speech" into "we needed to continue the prorogation to deliver Brexit!". It's the Boris Johnson two step that gives us "I will follow the law-I'm not going to follow the laws I don't like-I absolutely will follow the law". So much for Leaving being about the rule of law and the importance of UK laws and courts.
And I'm proud to be an American ! Cause at least I know I'm free ! And I won't forget the men who died to give that right to me ! And I'll proudly stand up next to you and defend her to this day ! Cause there ain't no doubt I love this land ! GOD BLESS THE USA ! 🇺🇸
If Geoffrey Cox has, as he said himself, lost so many court cases, then maybe he is not really qualified to be the attorney general. Just a thought. :)
It's funny they say since the Supreme Court made a decision it is now the law of the land but they don't create law nor is it the highest body in government, in fact the highest body in UK government is Parliament which is actually the lawmaking body for the country as well. Parliament had the opportunity to remove the PM, or change the rules, or both, they chose none of the above. Instead they chose an underling governmental body to make a decision that they nor the PM has to follow make a decision that they should have done on your own. How difficult is it to just write up all the rules especially with all of those people in Parliament
You clearly know nothing about the legislature and the separation of powers. Obviously the Supreme Court isn't an arm of government, it is supposed to be entirely separate to the government, or parliament. Nor are the Supreme Court supposed to be lawmakers, they are supposed to uphold the law, which they did when t hey found that Boris acted unlawfully. So everything you have said is baseless.
The people have voted Brexit in the UK because of immigration, and that is a good reason. But the EU is exactly what the UK wanted it to be in terms of finances, currency, agriculture policies etc. Why don’t you stay in the EU and try to change things with your natural partner, ie the other member states?? Come on! You say that we do not like you and we think exactly the same. Just a misundertanding!!!!
The country is at a loggerheads, parliament is confused , the general public is fed up, businesses are unsure, the whole country is in turmoil. I think the queen should step into BREXIT issue and come up with a reasonable solution. It is about time the queen indulged into BREXIT rather than political parties fighting it out. Does the queen have powers to step into BREXIT controversy ?
My estime to Lord Heseltine: the majority of people can be manipulate by vicious media campaign. Nobody seriously explained the economic consequences of Brexit and the consequences for Northern Ireland and Scotland. Easy job to campaign against other and with lot of lies...
@Albert Pike Or vice versa... More money for the NHS? I am waiting to happen! Meanwhile You will get more Doctors and Nurses from non-EU countries... English nationalism will kill the UK! But hey... that`s also called democracy LOL
Another clown who doesn't understand checks and balances. Executive has overstepped it's bounds by silencing the Parliament through Prorogation. This is the facts. They didn't rule against it because of Brexit, they upheld the supremacy of Parliament. Another clown who's moaning because he didn't get what he wants. Pathetic.
2nd referendum with the choice of a clearly defined Brexit deal or remain. This parliament can’t sort it and there’s no guarantee that the next one will.
jeffex1 once article 50 is extended I think there’ll be one. However Brexit is a one question issue, why confuse it by bringing the normal GE stuff of NHS, education, welfare etc into the mix when a clear cut outcome is far from guaranteed.
@@derekwhyle1884 all because they refused to accept the result. its a disgrace. they want to revoke its as simple as that. yet they will not give the people a general election.
Most of yesterday was spent hurling insults and provocations at each other. What a waste of time and OUR money this lot are. High time it was all swept away. They need to shape of, or the next referendum might not be about leaving the E.U.
This isn't about any political party or a discrace of a speaker. This is about getting brexit done and obeying the will of the people. Not sitting patting each other on the back and gloating at their victory in court while hiding from a general election with their lame excuses. The people have democratically spoken get it done or accept the consequences of being made redundant.
Boris LIED to our Queen and put her in a terrible situation, forcing her to act illegally. He isn't welcome in Australia or Canada or anywhere in her majesty's Commonwealth. He should do the decent thing and resign. Frankly I am APPALLED that England and Wales do not seem to universally share our opinion. If an Australian PM was caught doing this he would be out the next day. There is something seriously wrong in England. I don't give a rat's about Brexit, what he did is the equivalent of lying to YOUR mother and embarassing her - don't YOU want him to go? Nigel Farage does...
@@endintiers you actually need to read the judgement. No one was accused of lying as it would have been impossible to proove. What actually happened was the court decided the action of resting parliament for this length of time was not in the best interests of governance and so judged the action illegal. This decision was made by 11 pro remainer judges so even their reasoning of their decision must be questioned due to impartiality.
@@lainolaing4053 They supported the decision of the Court of Sessions which DID say he mislead the Queen. They were just being 'cute' when they didn't comment more on it. It doesn't matter - he embarassed her and forced her to commit an act that was later found illegal. This was forshadowed BEFORE he did it. This is not something he can just laugh off. He must go.
Lord Heseltine:. Thank you for your clarity, integrity, and strong opinion. And personaliy, thank you for believing and creating the MDC back in the 80's
I grew up admiring the English people, with age my view of English changed a lot. Now, I see bunch of arrogant comedians unable to make a decision about their country, which they ruined it beyond repair.
![กิโลเมตรที่ 0 เดินทางรอบโลกไม่ใช้เครื่องบิน [Around The World Ep. 1]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/toJG9oofLFY/mqdefault.jpg)
Sorry to say, but right about now the UK is like a living example of what happens when the lunatics run the asylum....
Agree 1000%
Moral : never ask the people to decide on economic issues with grave repercussions
Sorry to say you may be right. We need an election. It's going to be a biggy.
some mentaly challenged people do have their clear moments - that's the diffrence
@@addydiesel6627 WHY? Because these fools know better ?
One could make a TV series of all the Brexit drama that would make House of Cards look like a joke
House of cards was a comedy, a black comedy ,this is truth stranger than fiction.
Sorry to be pedantic but all the drama stems from the remain side all we want to do is leave.
@Daniel McGrath What do you say to a remainer...nothing they are too thick to understand
@Daniel McGrath so remoaners like to beat women? Good to know 👍
Weird that House of Cards was based on a British series. 😉
Season Five: The Parlament Returns.
There was never going to be a five-week ad break.
Why wont they show us Bercow's post-timeskip powerup yet? Surely he has mastered Haki and Nen by now
Ha ha
I thought it was season 4 now.
Season 1: The vote and ”will they/wont they trigger article 50”.
Season 2: Article 50 is triggered and negotiations play out.
Season 3: Negotiations stop, parliament rejects the deal which triggers the chaos. Season finale is the scene Bercow makes during the closing of parliament.
Season 4: Starts with the supreme court handling the legality of the prorogation, parliament resumes work with everyone’s favorite speaker bringing OOOORDAAAA to the house.
more like: The fallen kingdom
7:36 "The government did what HE thought was right"
Says it all really.
He did what he had to do to stop the mob halting brexit.
Lol!!! Whoops
@@ancietman Well, it's the mob that wants it. So, I guess that makes it even?
@SoulFire Only in a dictatorship can someone be considered to be the government.
So that's the point - A Freudian slip on his part.
@SoulFire Not at all
The Attorney General adds Shakespearean tones to the new Brexit season!!
For a moment I thought it was an episode of Rumpole when he spoke.
he sounds like hitler
Sieben Q really?? 😂 in what world smh
As a Canadian, may I remind the British parliament that, as the model on which many other Commonwealth parliaments have been based, because it serves as a model to the others, it has a responsibility to show how effectively it can run. The extreme partisanship displayed there is not at all a model. Why had the minority government not reported on details of its Brexit negotiations with the EU? Why is it not preparing the British public to vote in a referendum on the Brexit withdrawal agreement it hopes that the EU will accept?
Hello 👋 we had a referendum. We voted OUT. We were not given an option to negotiate NOR did we ask for any agreement of withdrawal. The options were remain or leave. Simple.
@aud loves life The first referendum was acted upon when article 51 was submitted. The opposition are now trying to block the Uk leaving without a Deal, which goes against the referendum result.
Boris: We need to prorogue Parliament so we can write a Queen's Speech. It's not about Brexit I swear.
Court: Not a chance mate, we don't believe you.
Boris: Dratted Remoaners trying to block Brexit at every turn!!!!
Also, a bonus sketch.
Boris: We need to prorogue Parliament so we can write a Queen's Speech.
Public: Okay, how long do you need?
Boris: Five weeks. I'm a really slow writer, but Michael promised to check my spellings for me.
9 of the 11 Supreme Court judges voted remain. They are another brick in the establishment wall against the will of the people.
Its brexciting that's what is is.
"I'll tell you what it is....t's a Psychobilly Freakout, THAT'S what it is!" - The Reverend Horton Heat
Best speaker & best ties of all times!
Perfect parliament series 1. Government with no majority, 2. No plans for Brexit 3. Prime Minister breaking the law. Hosted by my favorite Speaker Bercow with stellar performances Jeremy Corbyn, Ian Blackford, Anna Soubry, Boris Johnson will keep us in chaos and suspension until Holloween
I thought he prorogued parliament to do a queens speech. You had 2 weeks where's it at
Prorogation was cancelled. The Supreme Court ruled that the Prorogation never happened, in turn we don't need a Queens speech cause that would mean the end of a Prorogation, again which never happened.
They are now saying they can do it in 2 or 3 days with another prorogation, so why did it need to be 5 weeks? I think every atom in the sorry souls includes a lie.
stopped by Gina Miller Labour and liberals with the aid of Swinson
@Ady P hahahaha
@@davebrennan1509 and....
I 'm stoked we didn't have to wait too long after the season finale yesterday for episode 1 of the new season today.
It’s not just the building that’s decayed beyond use
In America they have political appointees as judges. The ruling power in politics can stack the judiciary in such a way that any wrong-doing goes unchecked. Donald Trump has broken the law, members of his cabinet break the law and the opposing parties are stymied because of the judicial choke hold and the ability to drag things out via the courts. I could not be more proud of our independent judiciary. BoJo steps out of line once and the people can slap him back down because of the independence of our judicial system. Whether you agree with Brexit or not, fair play is true Britishness.. if we abandon that which Britain should be proud, what are you fighting for?
Totally agree with you
s1rmunchalot!
s1rmunchalot how did trump break the law?
To our place of Work. ? Good Joke .
I thought that comment was hilarious too.
Work translates to sleep.
Yeah some even lie down like it's their lounge. Pathetic.
A. Egan. Ian Duncan Smith has recently chaired a committee for 'social justice' meeting and revealed state pension age will be 75. Now, he can't work until he's 75 because he hasn't started yet. As I said, this is a grand idea from the above mentioned, C. For S Justice. The baffling thing is, how can the name I D Smith and word justice, be contained in the same sentence
Classic Freudian slip at 7:35 - Peter Bone says "The Government did what he thought was right." Does he mean BoJo or tRump? Either way, there is more than one person in HM Government, or does Mr Bone see that differently?
So the opposition is scared for an election, the government is scared for a second referendum. As an outsider I think that the only way out of this mess is first a second referendum to deal with Brexit and second a election to deal with everything else.
Personally I thing the British population will never ever give Brexit a majority, so problem solved.
Jeroen, are you Dutch? You've delivered a sensible pathway here, but unfortunately the shower of cabbage people in the clip aren't taking in much in the way of good balance at the moment.
MrMmnngghh The strange thing is that I don’t hear that strategy from MP’s and in my opinion it would be best to walk that path.
Make the final deal that parliament is willing to approve, put that to the people, get that it of the way and then an election on the issues that are determined by party-politics.
Things could be so easy to solve.
The attorney general just blew the snakes out of the water.
Its about time someone stood up and told them all what we think of them.
Its time for a general election so the public can get shut of these traitors and get some people in there that actually want to do some good
@Matthew Smith He's not the Attorney General. He is Boris' puppet.
He is the Attorney General, just not a very good one....................quite an average one.....................a poor one................quite an incompetent one...................a fucking old wanker of one.
My wife is at the theatre watching the Downing Street movie as I type. Watching this drama is so much more entertaining from this side of the pond!
My favorite reality show is back early!
Do the opposition have ANYTHING else to say but; "WE FINALLY GOT A BROWNIE POINT". Agree to a general election and see how clever you are and what the PUBLIC really want. But believing in democracy is not really their thing is it?
You seamed to have failed to grasp that the UK is a parliamentarian democracy which in short means the parliament's wish rates higher legally than a referendum
@@jacobjorgenson9285 There you go again. SCREW the wishes of the people. WE are better than you and didn't really want to know what you wanted as respectfully we are indeed a dictatorship disguised as a democracy.
@@EggReports Simple majority of about 3%, voting majority at that, not majority of the whole country because not every citizen that could vote did. People also lied and some have changed sides, you can't say a % from 3 years ago is the same % as today.
It's an obvious Elephant Trap...
They are a disgrace and a shambles behaving in a sanctimonious manner in their illegal contrived manner to remain with the EU. What next!. Do we have to boycott everything coming from the EU. It could happen. Think carefully when you shop everyone!
bring out the dead....Tarzan is back, must be all those EU Landlords securing their bunce!!
This is becoming a running joke!
3.5 years no deal! Now the UK people WANT Brexit! Crybaby MP's do not!
They want another extension to continue moving their funds and assets before Brexit occurs.
@@ericharvey9456 Didnt the EU say they would not give another extension? What then?
@@ericharvey9456 never a truer word have been spoken.
@@davidshore264 they will give it. They do not want there cash machine leaving and secondly there are 39billion other reasons to consider.
@@colinmitchell9212 Will have to wait and see. Last I heard the EU stated there will be NO EXTENSION past the October 31st deadline. There is also the part of the Article 50 that states the PM can declare the UK out of the EU ANYTIME after commencement. IS this correct?
The National interest says in the referendum by 17.4 people is Brexit Leave what part of that is confusing ? nothing about a deal
The losers keep throwing tantrums.
Is the media that biased that they would show the European flag during the introduction???? Then as the broadcast progressed, there were always European flags in the background when the cameras went outdoors.. Dont they have pride in their own flag??/
Next move for the government , stop channel 4 flying these Eu flags, it pathetic
What's pathetic is that you think those flags belong to Channel 4.
@@shumoon1 they do.
@@shumoon1
They sleep under them.
Get rid of that idiot outside with the loud speaker imagine being married to that git 😡
I quite like the colour
4:08 fewer options not less options
Nope. The options are less. As in worse.
Lets face it they just dont want to leave the EU Boris is fighting a losing battle 😡
The whole thing just gets worse and worse. I can’t stand to watch it anymore. Is there one EU country with the backbone to block any further delaying tactics and force the UK out on the 31st of October?
GH1618 you're right... I agree
Michael Hesseltine goes on about democracy then says we should overturn the result. Can he just vanish!
Hahaha labour talking about transparency
Geoffrey Cox doesn't even need a microphone.
The people of the UK are grateful to Mr. Cox for explaining to the remoaners how the people judge their behaviour.
The people get the politicians they deserve. Despise these politicians all you like but know that the people are not entirely blameless for the current state of democracy.
It wasn't obvious that the prorogation was unlawful. Why else would the English and Irish court rulings, prior to the judgement of the Supreme Court, determine that Boris was perfectly within his rights to do what he did?
To argue that Boris was clearly in the wrong from the start, without citing personal opinion, is simple nonsense.
The only possible explanation is that they are all secret Brexiteers, being paid off by the ERG in a conspiratorial and biased anti-EU judicial system. But that is ludicrous.
Grymbaldknight you’re right, but the fact that the government saw fit to sail so close to the wind as to be verging on illegality is fairly despicable. The government should behave in a way that is beyond reproach. It has still not been adequately explained why the government needed 5 weeks to do something that usually takes a week to organise.
I ask you, what law did he break? Which paragraph in some dusty tome was breached by the UK govt doing what it has done a 1000 times before?
They didn't say it was within his rights, they just said it was a political matter the courts didn't want to get involved in. It's the equivalent of saying "no comment".
Parliamentary meltdown as seen through the distorted remainer lens of channel 4
Parliament Return my depression its over!
Forget brexit concerning Boris Johnson it's headexit
I find Jon Snow's addiction to staginess unbecoming to an old man. I daresay he thinks he's splendidly dignified and not a ham at all. Noisome.
Who holds parliament to account
The people?
What punishment is Boris Johnson getting for acting unlawfully and involving the queen in his crime? 5 years? 10 years?
boris has told no lies
Re-election.
a free haircut?
@@jonathanhammerton9418 lying isn't necceserily unlwaful, acting unlawful is. Nobody cares about lying politicians - but the HULK got caught
Lets get these southern bed wetters out of parliament and let the Vikings rule
you're absolutly right about the bed wetters, it's been said for ages, but where would the Vikings be?
Víkingarnir? Hvađ meinarđu .. okkur Íslendingum? Ūađ er mjög svalt =)
Racist nords, accept the Imperium , no to SKYRIMXIT
Thats the problem our MPs don't get out of London they never come to my town Boston 75% leave. Strangely we never have any remoaner protests either Ha Ha.
The vikings were bastards!
Queens speech ? She should fire all these guys...
She's a Constitutional Monarch, the power to remove MPs lies with the voters. Seriously what do you guys do at school? Imagine having the future of the country being determined by people who don't understand how the country works.. oh wait.
@Albert Pike I suppose BoJo has to be drawn and quartered then for lying to a sovereign?
@Albert Pike go ahead and ask for another referendum to remove the Monarchy. Go ahead. As if one referendum isn't stupid enough.
@Albert Pike BoJo broken his vow to serve the people in good faith too, why don't you ask him to resign then?
@Albert Pike that's not what BoJo said. He has publicly said he wants a deal. So I guess you're defending BoJo for naught? Wake up, crashing out with No Deal is stupidity. You don't gain anything by causing chaos. You cannot trade with WTO rules if there is no pre agreement in place with the EU, or pray miraculously no one in WTO would somehow not make a protest on your tariff schedule. Also if you build a hard border between Ireland and Northern Ireland you break the Good Friday Agreement, which means you are asking for the Troubles to start again. Think man. Don't be sheep for Farage. He's got an EU passport through his German wife.
Smoke and mirrors! We’ve probably been at war for the last 3 years! What a bunch of weasels
Say that to an English WWII vet !
stop brexit
@weaverspell the people of russia...
#PrimeMinisterTrump 2020
@weaverspell How many are still alive?
I have absolute respect for the integrity and competence of the Attorney General? What integrity? What competence? What medications is Oliver Letwin taking, or forgetting to take?
Its turning into a bad comedy,
I thought unlawful means unlawful....!!!
And what? They're back aren't they.And how did they spend that precious time they wanted back? BLOCK COMPLAIN & BLAH BLAH BLAH
"Even fewer options."
What better way to take a month off , when your country is approaching a critical deadline !"October first we will vote to surrender all land and territory to the USA ! Now let's all take a month off m see you two weeks before October 31." No I know what you're thinking , but that's not going to happen , far to many liberals . 😆
After all these years I have come to the conclusion that the Leave side never really had a plan of making Brexit work because I don’t think they were going to win the referendum. Add that to the fact that they couldn’t get a Leave supporter to lead the Tories once Cameron resigned, and the chain reaction leading to the train wreck began.
The people have voted, get Brexit done NOW
Love how Snow messes her name up 5 times.
That's the only comment that you had to make?
So happy to hear the Speaker’s voice again! I love Bercow!!
The supreme court did not say what length of prorogation would have been 'lawful'.
Four weeks, 3, 2, 1?
They might say it's not just the length but the purpose of prorogation that must be 'lawful'.
In the future, who will judge what is the true purpose and whether it is 'lawful'?
In the future, who will decide the 'lawful' length of prorogation? A judge?
In the future, shall we be governed by judges?
Judges have no empathy, sympathy, pragmatism or common sense.
Judges can see no further than their own personal concept of the law.
They are not competent for politics and they should stay well out of it.
They should withdraw their judgment on the prorogation.
If they had ruled any other way, they would have given the government the right to suspend the parliament, i.e. the citizens right to representation, for an interminate period. That is, it would have also enabled a remainer national unity government replacing Johnson's to cancel Brexit and prorogue parliament for two years preventing Brexiteer parliamentarians from criticising/scrutinizing government.
Therefore, the Court said that a prorogation typically lasts for 4-6 days and if it is longer, it must not constitute a hampering of the parliament's ability to legislate and scrutinice the government.
The government serves at the pleasure of the parliament, not the other way around.
Q: "What next...?"
A: ORDER! ORRRRRDER! ORDERRRRR! Oh dear! Oh dear! HEAR! HEAR! Followed by: Clear the House!
How would they know the advice was illegal until the court found it illegal?? these critics are nonsensical, hysterical. I cannot see how this news report is neutral as he is putting his own negative view and interviewing people biased one way.
the thing is that the PM LIED to the Queen about the reasons asking for prorogation, and that is why the advice is Unlawful or Ilegal.
So parliament came back just to shout at the PM and NOT to discuss parliamentary issues. Confused!
it's called holding the PM and government to account which is a parliamentary issue, if you dont believe that shouldn't have happened, then you are mindless and we are already lost... what say you?
@@Freemouse159 Forgive me for saying so but simply check the mainstream media and you'll be reminded EVERYWHERE that it did indeed happen. With regard to the fact it "shouldn't have happened" and that, that would make me "mindless". It did happen for good reason. The main reason being the opposition blocking EVERY bill presented by the government AFTER extensive house debates. Then by your own admission as such. Shouldn't the opposition present a bill of no coincidence in the sitting government and force a general election? Sorry for my lengthy "mindless" response. However this issue is not made any easier by closed end statements which is in fact why parliament are making little progress on ANY issues facing us all. What say you?
@@Freemouse159 pm has told no lies, remainer judges are corrupt
Boris was conspicuous by his absence. He probably overslept, Donald probably forgot to set the alarm. Rumour has it he had a sun bed session booked with Donald, look out for the white panda eyes on his return.
@@EggReports I didnt understand a single point within your last post, so I'm going to boil it down for you and hope I get a coherent response back... Parliament was shutdown with the reason being there was a queens speech on the way... the Govt was taken to court and they lost because they were found to be lying to the queen for shutting the house down. simple. If you think that's unfair (which boggles the mind) then you are mindless, as a taxpayer and citizen I want my MP to be in Parliament WORKING, not being sent home just because the BoJo govt wants an easy walk through Brexit, would you rather not have a brexit done so that all the issues we will face have been talked about and made sure its resolved or are you ok with blindly doing things just because your are so desperate to leave? Respond sir!
Scot's Law enabled this ruling,thankfully!
Explain yourself!
The Conservatives are about winning Power
there's a massive difference between legal and lawful
Our revolution was illegal 🇺🇸, and since 1815 you have not left us alone ! 😆
I'm lost. Surely if the queen has the power to prorogue parliament (which she did), she must also be reconvene it?
After all she is not subject to the wisdom of of a corrupt and partisan court is she?
How can they just pitch up without her authorisation?
I am so very sorry to all people who pay hard earned money in taxes to see a smirking politician say they accept a ruling from court knowing they misused and twisted aka "interpretated" the system in the first place resulting in high court administration costs and disruptions to other cases which the people will in essence have to account for. The money wasted on all this nonsense should be given back to the taxpayers. And no I dont agree to word twister below.
Yip I think the opposition should be made to pay it for all this blocking democracy nonsense. Sooner we LEAVE the better for ALL us taxpayers I guess.
What about the 1 billion per month the opposition have been wasting for the last 3 years!
@@nompho7820 detail the calculations and if there is waste then everybody should absolutely be held accountable but facts please because everybody can simply quote numbers without back up, too easy these days.
@@NJ-xp4eb PM quoted these figures during parliament. Are you suggesting he is lying to Parliament?
I was told to always question things because many political and powerful people in history quoted things which were not true and as a result caused chaos and wars, so I would not quote a figure unless I researched it myself, it is easy to say something without proper back up. If you choose to believe without backup and full root cause analysis then that is your choice but please respect mine and don't try to twist my words in an attempt to cause friction. I see this all the time here from this "movement" as they call themselves and i am so tired of 1940s style propagandists.
"There is no consensus in the country as to what should happen". Erm... 52%???
it just waits for the right screenwriter and the amount of time to absorb it. normally it takes ca 20-30 years
Hezeltine ignores the fact that UK will be a mere footnote in history if UK does not avoid the nation-smashers in the EU.
Toby W That is your opinion, not a fact.
If as Hezeltine says, the subordinate courts are wrong, why even bother with them? The unanimous reversal by the Supremes over The AG, Parliament, precedent, and lower courts, smack of political bias to me!
Why doesn't Boris Johnson declare a state of emergency and seize the military and judicial powers? That will solve the Brexit problem
Does any one know when the next elections will be if not allowed by the parliament now?
Ugh, the speaker is doing his job. It's not his job to help the PM, it's the Speaker's job to empower Parliament. The difference is because first Theresa May as PM couldn't get her majority to pass her deal. Now the PM has tossed his majority away. That means Boris Johnson is in essence the opposition. That means the Speaker empowering Parliament means the government isn't going to get what they want.
All of this wouldn't be an issue with the ERG had voted with the whip for their PM's deal. They ignored their PM because they've decided that despite not being even mentioned in the Leave campaign the referendum was on Remain or No Deal. It's apparently the new normal though to retroactively change what things mean. See "the prorogation was exclusively for a queen's speech" into "we needed to continue the prorogation to deliver Brexit!". It's the Boris Johnson two step that gives us "I will follow the law-I'm not going to follow the laws I don't like-I absolutely will follow the law". So much for Leaving being about the rule of law and the importance of UK laws and courts.
Leave properly by any means necessary to protect democracy. This is what the majority of Britain wants.
leave properly what does that even mean?
Freemouse159 they are going to physically move Britain off to Narnia or something
@@frenchguitarguy1091 🤣 Most Devonians live in the closet and visit Narnia already, inbreds and GCSE Dodgers the lot of em.
dont lie. Do a 2nd referendum and lets see what people want. Scared?
Freemouse159 it explains the centaurs, i previously thought they were the result of Chernobyl’s nuclear fallout but I guess the more you know
Can he not just prorogue parliament again??
He can try. What are the odds of it getting slapped down again in the Supreme Court? Why not negotiate and get a deal through Commons?
And I'm proud to be an American ! Cause at least I know I'm free ! And I won't forget the men who died to give that right to me ! And I'll proudly stand up next to you and defend her to this day ! Cause there ain't no doubt I love this land ! GOD BLESS THE USA ! 🇺🇸
Brexit should be cancelled all together
If Geoffrey Cox has, as he said himself, lost so many court cases, then maybe he is not really qualified to be the attorney general.
Just a thought. :)
agreed!
he knows all tricks 'cause he fell for every single one?
It's funny they say since the Supreme Court made a decision it is now the law of the land but they don't create law nor is it the highest body in government, in fact the highest body in UK government is Parliament which is actually the lawmaking body for the country as well.
Parliament had the opportunity to remove the PM, or change the rules, or both, they chose none of the above.
Instead they chose an underling governmental body to make a decision that they nor the PM has to follow make a decision that they should have done on your own.
How difficult is it to just write up all the rules especially with all of those people in Parliament
if you don't write it down, then it never happened. 4th rule of politics!
You clearly know nothing about the legislature and the separation of powers. Obviously the Supreme Court isn't an arm of government, it is supposed to be entirely separate to the government, or parliament. Nor are the Supreme Court supposed to be lawmakers, they are supposed to uphold the law, which they did when t hey found that Boris acted unlawfully. So everything you have said is baseless.
The people have voted Brexit in the UK because of immigration, and that is a good reason. But the EU is exactly what the UK wanted it to be in terms of finances, currency, agriculture policies etc. Why don’t you stay in the EU and try to change things with your natural partner, ie the other member states?? Come on! You say that we do not like you and we think exactly the same. Just a misundertanding!!!!
ANOTHER REFERENDUM !!!!!!!!!
The people want an election
The country is at a loggerheads, parliament is confused , the general public is fed up, businesses are unsure, the whole country is in turmoil. I think the queen should step into BREXIT issue and come up with a reasonable solution. It is about time the queen indulged into BREXIT rather than political parties fighting it out. Does the queen have powers to step into BREXIT controversy ?
Why are they so noisy this parliament/ house of commons..??
I mean their only idealistic that time they have accessibility to the shouting matches of the parliament
What's the punishment for criminal Johnson's illegal activity? F all punishment.
Glad sven goran Eriksson is still kicking! 03:25
in the third episode of this series, the canteen ladies gather round and toss his salad
My estime to Lord Heseltine: the majority of people can be manipulate by vicious media campaign. Nobody seriously explained the economic consequences of Brexit and the consequences for Northern Ireland and Scotland. Easy job to campaign against other and with lot of lies...
@Albert Pike Or vice versa... More money for the NHS? I am waiting to happen! Meanwhile You will get more Doctors and Nurses from non-EU countries... English nationalism will kill the UK! But hey... that`s also called democracy LOL
The people are supreme not the supreme court. In due time, the supreme court will be reminded that.
Oooh - mysterious veiled threats!
Another clown who doesn't understand checks and balances. Executive has overstepped it's bounds by silencing the Parliament through Prorogation. This is the facts. They didn't rule against it because of Brexit, they upheld the supremacy of Parliament. Another clown who's moaning because he didn't get what he wants. Pathetic.
I want an parody movie about the last 3 years with Brexit & Trump.
"Age of populism"
This is better than ..............Australia supports Brexit.
Show must go on.
Hesseltein mendacious reptile!
vittoria grant Who?
Learn to spell, Brexshithead.
Get a good deal!
2nd referendum with the choice of a clearly defined Brexit deal or remain. This parliament can’t sort it and there’s no guarantee that the next one will.
The people have already spoken - LEAVE
nom pho7 the people spoke again when they elected the current parliament
@@derekwhyle1884 lol so call A GE
jeffex1 once article 50 is extended I think there’ll be one. However Brexit is a one question issue, why confuse it by bringing the normal GE stuff of NHS, education, welfare etc into the mix when a clear cut outcome is far from guaranteed.
@@derekwhyle1884 all because they refused to accept the result. its a disgrace. they want to revoke its as simple as that. yet they will not give the people a general election.
Most of yesterday was spent hurling insults and provocations at each other. What a waste of time and OUR money this lot are. High time it was all swept away. They need to shape of, or the next referendum might not be about leaving the E.U.
What law exactly?
House of traitors ..
Johnny Bravo Damn that parliament that the EU control, but the prime minister can’t.
So good to see John Bercow again!
This isn't about any political party or a discrace of a speaker. This is about getting brexit done and obeying the will of the people. Not sitting patting each other on the back and gloating at their victory in court while hiding from a general election with their lame excuses. The people have democratically spoken get it done or accept the consequences of being made redundant.
Ugh this is parliament, this is democracy. What Boris did was illegal. Deal with it.
Boris LIED to our Queen and put her in a terrible situation, forcing her to act illegally. He isn't welcome in Australia or Canada or anywhere in her majesty's Commonwealth. He should do the decent thing and resign. Frankly I am APPALLED that England and Wales do not seem to universally share our opinion. If an Australian PM was caught doing this he would be out the next day. There is something seriously wrong in England. I don't give a rat's about Brexit, what he did is the equivalent of lying to YOUR mother and embarassing her - don't YOU want him to go? Nigel Farage does...
@@endintiers you actually need to read the judgement. No one was accused of lying as it would have been impossible to proove. What actually happened was the court decided the action of resting parliament for this length of time was not in the best interests of governance and so judged the action illegal. This decision was made by 11 pro remainer judges so even their reasoning of their decision must be questioned due to impartiality.
@@lainolaing4053 They supported the decision of the Court of Sessions which DID say he mislead the Queen. They were just being 'cute' when they didn't comment more on it. It doesn't matter - he embarassed her and forced her to commit an act that was later found illegal. This was forshadowed BEFORE he did it. This is not something he can just laugh off. He must go.
@@endintiers never heard of that legal judgement... Just being cute...
Lord Heseltine:. Thank you for your clarity, integrity, and strong opinion. And personaliy, thank you for believing and creating the MDC back in the 80's
Lord Heseltine's comments were superb, like the superb music composed by his late father..
Heseltine=traitor
Shame on Cathy Newman of Channel 4 News for what she did on Jan 16, 2018
...you mean "Doing her job"?
Rhees moggs...YUK!
I grew up admiring the English people, with age my view of English changed a lot. Now, I see bunch of arrogant comedians unable to make a decision about their country, which they ruined it beyond repair.
Nice start : Ordrrrrrrr 😂😂