When this video came out it was hard hitting and Phil Collins donated all the profits from this song to homeless charities. At his concerts he would have collection buckets for people to donate, whatever was collected and Phil Collins would match the amount from his own pocket. Also, just another example of an artist using their platform for humanitarian purposes. This is one of the best songs ever performed by Phil Collins!
I saw an article before about people who were in bands who went on to solo careers, and the two most successful were Peter Gabriel and Phil Collins, both from the same band.
This song always hits deep inside. He kept it simple and subtle yet his plea in his voice is deafening so the message can hit through. Truly brilliant.
Attended that tour. They had volunteers, dozens of them, at each show taking collections for the local shelters & organizations helping the homeless. I put my $40 of 'fun money' that night right into the bucket. 'Another day in paradise' indeed.
In case nobody knows Phil wrote this song because he is truly a caring man all proceeds from this song went to helping Homeless and every time he performs this song even to this day he passes around donation buckets around the whole concert crowd and whatever is donated he matches it he is a empathetic person
@@crand20033And after decades of homelessness being present in this country, and countless tens of millions spent trying to overcome the problem, homelessness is as bad as ever. The Churches used to help people with this, but then the government decided to take it over....I'm glad you are no longer homeless my friend.
❤❤❤❤❤thanks Phil..from a poor Australian. We do what we can hey. Gardening.cleaning.shopping or like someone as yourself ...a great generosity..Father and Jesus' blessing. I have cervical 1-7 bad damage. Saw you in Sydney. Love your drumming...and obviously your voice and sense of humour. 😅❤😅😅love to your family too😊
Just in the first verse alone, Phil Collins painted a scene that many homeless people have described as being invisible. The surgical precision with which he writes in a way that cuts to the heart is vastly underrated.
It seems to me that this is the most harmful part of being homeless, that they are cast out from society and dehumanised by people ignoring that they even exist. I have never had enough money to regularly donate to charities to help but I think that even if we don’t have anything to give to homeless people it would probably make their day a little better to at least acknowledge them and talk to them when you see them. I can’t imagine what it must feel like to be ignored by everybody like that.
It’s simple yet it’s beautifully precise and difficult to perfect. Not impossible but Phil makes it sound beautifully easy. His voice is always direct yet smooth and you never question his intentions in a song. I just love him ❤
Its true, I used to spend time talking to various street people here in PDX. Many were very interesting, and it is dehumanizing the way people ignore them just because they find it a hassle . I am also guilty of this, though nowadays i do try and at least say hello. Part of the issue is that there are actually legitimately dangerous and unhinged people on the streets, whether from drugs or mental illness. Sometimes these people will be aggressive even if you simply look their direction. These are also broken and hurting people that need our help, but I don’t blame people for wanting to avoid being accosted, verbally or physically by them. You can’t be sure which ones are good people who are suffering, and those who best avoided. They all need help, im just saying its somewhat understandable. Also, drugs can turn previously wonderful people into very dangerous untrustworthy people, I’ve seen it in my own personal life.
This song always brings a lump to my throat. Reminds me of somebody I knew at school who I found out many years later had been living on the streets and she had died of hypothermia over Christmas 2009.
One of my all time favourites. No matter my emotional/mental state, I can find something that resonates in that moment. And i TOTALLY, ABSOLUTELY have been caught out stunting asking at (almost) the top of my lungs in public surf my headphones in, in my own little world...
Speaking as a homeless person myself, I find that watching videos by entertaining content-creators like yourself (whenever I am able to find a free Wi-Fi signal) helps keep my mind thinking more positively without circling back to my situation. So keep up the good work! Coming to videos from this channel is like visiting an old friend who doesn't judge me for the life choices I've made which put me in this situation. In general, though, we are all just looking for acknowledgement. Yes, we may be looking for spare change for food, not just for a "fix", and that may make your day worse being accosted by us, but don't ignore us, Sometimes it can take a lot of courage to break through one's pride to be able to ask for help in the first place; to have you just ignore us or quickly cross the street away from us can only decrease our feelings of self worth. Just please notice us, because we are not going away any time soon, in fact our numbers are growing daily, Remember: if you do not belong to the upper 1% who rule the rest of us, there is a good chance that you are only 2 missing paychecks away from joining us! Great analysis, as usual !
As someone who has been out on the streets, I feel you man. I never did drugs or abused alcohol one day in my whole life-but was there due to financial diffilculties. While on the streets, I met all kinds of people. Some bad, most good people, but all in a bad situation. I finally found my way off the streets (with the help of some very good friends), but I will never forget the experience-or the people who may still be out there.
I never cry. It seems I pretty much lost that ability when I grew up. But this song does it every time. My chest tightens and I find my self lost in the message. This is one of my favorite songs. And the lyrics hits like a freight train. This has to be Phil Collins's greatest musical achievement. I can listen to this song again and again, and I will never get bored with it.
Compare and contrast with Billy Joel 'we didn't start the fire'. He's preachy, he's beating you over the head with THE MESSAGE. Whereas here, Phil is inviting you, 'just think about it'. He's not trying to bludgeon you with HIS thinking. He is dramatically undersinging it. To allow you to CHOOSE to be open to it.
In my opinion, he is one of the most dominant artists of the 80's and 90's. His sound, both solo and with Genesis was just always present. Incredibly talented, and not that it matters, but how is he not in the Rock an Roll Hall of Fame as a solo artist? May be the largest oversight of that HOF to date, considering some of the "great's" they are enshrining year after year.
I feel the Rock-'n'-roll Hall of Fame has gotten away from what it was intended to be. Rappers have been inducted for instance. There are Halls of Fame that cover multiple genres of music, but the RnR HOF is for RnR. 🤷
My exact same sentiment. If his solo career is not a HOF career I don't know what is. Other artists that had already been inducted with their bands and had much less impactful or significant solo careers were acknowledged for their solo careers. Some even in the last 5 years. And he hasn't even been nominated once. His imprint is all over the 80s. How many other people are Hall of Fame songwriters (as he is, Songwriter's Hall of Fame did not sleep on him), singers, producers and a virtuoso with their instrument?
@@garymaidman625I also don’t agree with Rap being included in the HOF because it’s basically a copy of someone else’s music with a guy talking over it. Not saying it doesn’t take some talent but musically, it’s not that original and much less difficult to create than a Pop or Rock song from scratch. But the HOF basically has said that Rap is included under the Rock umbrella along with Pop, Jazz, Metal, Grunge, etc.
Phil Collins is a rare talent in any one of his three skill sets alone, but to have composition, vocal, and percussion abilities all at his extremely high level is simply hard to believe as real. When you experience it, it just strikes awe.
"I don't care anymore", drips vitriol from every word, " The roof is leaking " is heartbreaking and "Driving the last spike" celebrating those who built the railways through mountains, valleys and died in their thousands doing so, all those will bring you to a different place. Collins is a god tier songwriter and performer. -Mark
Driving the Last Spike has been one of my favourite songs since I was a child. That, No Son of Mine and Dreaming While You Sleep by Genesis all hit like a tonne of bricks and are SO effective at portraying the stories they are trying to tell. Phil's voice is always the absolute icing on the cake. Such talent.
THANK YOU for mentioning The Roof is Leaking. I thought I was the only one who thought that song was one of his masterpieces that never got the recognition it deserved.
Oh I feel the gut punch every single time I hear this song . You can picture every single word he says. I can even see the man crossing the street ignoring this lady pleading for his help. He has a dark blue suit on in my head. Perfect voice for this message. Almost like an Angel reminding you to be kind and to help and care for others.
Thank you so much for telling us that. It makes it even more valuable, richer. He was the perfect choice. You inspired me to look it up - the talented Dominic Miller on electric + classical guitar and the wonderful Leland Sklar on bass. No wonder it is so beautifully produced. My day is better for having experienced this. Thanks again.
I usually do not chime in but this song rings personal to me. I was a homeless veteran when this song was on the airwaves. There are many reasons people become homeless. Not all homeless people are drug addicts. Some of us are suffering from other issues economic, mental health, trust issues, or histories that we are running from. Many homeless people beg for money because they do not know about available resources or the apathy presented by society to the problem. Many will not turn to shelters because of the necessity to listen to a sermon or be 'prayed over'. Many do not believe that there is the possibility that god even cares for them. They feel like people who work at these places are just doing this to feel good about themselves. Much like how people only think about veterans on Veterans day or Memorial day, they only think of homeless people on Thanksgiving or Christmas. Veterans are veterans for the rest of their lives. We bear the scares forever, not just twice a year. Those who are homeless are homeless more than twice a year, they need help everyday. We live in a country that sends billions to other countries to lift their citizens out of poverty but our own government refuses to take some of that tax money to help the homeless or homeless veterans. I do not want to get political but how is it right that people who di not cross the border appropriately are housed in hotels while homeless veterans can't even lay on a bus bench because some city councilman decided to make it impossible. I am no longer homeless thanks to a kind individual many years ago who took a chance on me and gave me a place to live until i could get on my feet. Veterans, If you read this, please, if you find a homeless veteran please take them or point them to the nearest VA hospital so they can get assistance instead of ending up like I almost did, I think you know what I mean. Till Valhalla my Brothers and Sisters in Arms.
For all of his accolades, talents, skills, etc that have been attributed to Phil Collins over the years, the most underrated skill is his ability to tell a story. One of my all time favorite artists. He not only can emote, but he can make you *feel* the lyrics, not just hear them. A once in a lifetime talent.
Phil is AMAZING. He sang, arranged, wrote , precusion. All around musician. I know he's not well right now. I wish him well Phil was a huge voice in the 80s. I'm great full I was alive to hear most of his music real time.
I find myself watching Elizabeth. This song is in my top ten all-time, so every devastating line appears to have the same reaction for her as it did to me so many years ago. Stunning. When it first came out I’d burst into tears every time I’d hear it. Then 27 yrs later I myself was homeless. New perspective… Elizabeth nails exactly the reasons this recording’s so powerful.
A lot of what Elizabeth relates about the mechanics of singing goes over my head and the way that she chops videos much more than many other "reactors" is at times off putting, but the way she wears her heart on her sleeve is so endearing that I have to keep coming back, especially when the subject is a song or artist I'm invested in.
Phil is such an authentic, emotional and relatable singer, so when he executes a dead stop and turns away after "He walks on", he demonstrates so powerfully how a break in empathic connection feels. Suddenly one feels alone and on one's own. And he achieves that gut punch with such small, delicate details! A grand master.
Only just got into your channel so I don’t know how into percussion you are, but all the drumming he did through the 70’s and 80’s with Genesis is genuinely phenomenal. His poppier stuff is a bit of a meme (even though a lot of it is great) but he is an INCREDIBLE drummer, despite In the Air Tonight being his most known fill. One of Neil Peart (Rush)’s biggest inspirations, definitely shows
Her reaction to In the Air Tonight was hilarious. "He is singing very precisely on the beat, almost like percussion.. He could almost be a drummer" "What's he doing now, sitting at the drum kit?"
As a French kid when the song came out, I could not understand the lyrics yet, but I felt the power of it and it stayed in my heart. Later, when I started playing the keyboards, I had to play this beautiful melody every time I played. Then, I started to play the guitar, and again, I found a way to play the song on my acoustic guitar and I wanted to sing along, so I had to learn the lyrics…and that’s when I got the message… When I was 20, I’ve been kicked out of my mother’s house for some sad reason, and started to sleep under bridges. I had a few friends that could help me, but I hid it and never asked for help, pretending I was fine….I wasn’t. One night, after a year and a half of wandering, I was preparing my spot to sleep under this f*cking bridge, and a friend of mine who was taking his dog out for a walk saw me and said: What the f*ck are you doing here, dude?! I told him everything I was going through, and he offered me a shelter, giving me a chance to move on. I got back on my feet, and when I’ve been able to buy a guitar, this song was the first song that came to my mind when I grabbed it. Always on my set list when I busked in the streets, always passing my hat after it and always giving my tips to someone who needed this money to survive. I had no addiction, no mental illness except depression because of my situation, had a job, friends…but no home, and it wasn’t my choice…it’s hard. Whenever I got the blues or flashbacks of this period of my life, this song comes back to me. I know all Phil Collins’ phenomenal musical achievements, but this song will always be my favorite, for sure! Thank you Ma’am, for reacting to it and help spreading the message, because decades after it came out, we still have more and more people, HUMAN BEINGS, dying outside, and ignored by most of those who can’t walk a mile in a homeless’ shoes, at least for a day!
This song addresses the consequences of ignoring the needy and homeless. Collins told The Mail on Sunday: "I wrote this after being in Washington DC where I was amazed by how many people I saw living in boxes." Collins told The New York Times how the song came together: "It was begun at the piano. I started playing and put it down on a tape so I wouldn't forget it. Then I decided to see what would happen when I started singing. When I began, the words just came out, 'She calls out to the man on the street.' I didn't set out to write a song about the homeless. Those were just the words I happened to sing. It was only then that I decided that was what the song would be about." The video to this song conveys the lyrics perfectly. Another song that conveys a similar message is Metal Church - Anthem to the Estranged
That makes me think of another Metal Church song called, Watch The Children Pray. At least it has a similar vibe. I need to check out that song, Anthem to the Estranged
I've loved Metal Church since their debut in 1984. I've seen them many times, including a few nights ago. Their new singer, Marc Lopes, is fantastic and reminds me of the David Wayne era (RIP).
I read somewhere that he said the song came about when he noticed that everyone was ignoring the pleas for help from the homeless and that he caught himself doing the same thing and this song was in response to these actions.
This man is definitely in the top 5 artists of all time. His songwriting capabilities and generosity is world-renowned. He's helped SO many other artists achieve their dreams and helped to write songs for them. He's one of only 3 artists to ever sell over 100 million albums both as a solo artist and a member of a band. And yes it is a complete shame that he is not in the Hall of Fame as a solo artist.
Phil did something most people don't know about - He financed David Crosby's liver transplant. Dave was just digging out from his massive addiction & prison term when his liver failed. Being friends with him, Phil stepped up & paid for it in full. He stated afterwards that, even if they weren't so close, he would have done it, as David was a talent that he felt could NOT be lost. He was right.
Love Phil Collins. If you want another amazing production song by him I highly suggest I Wish It Would Rain Down. There is a bit of comedy in the bit before and after the video, but the song is amazing, and Phil Collins stretches out his vocal power a bit more.
You know it's a good song when it automatically inspires you to talk about its subject instead of the technicalities. Phil is a master on producing tracks that instantly deliver their meaning
Phil had so many great songs, solo and with Genesis. The song “Mama” would be fun to see next as he uses his voice so much differently, and the tone of the song it wildly different. It was a huge hit, and used in an episode of Magnum PI that was directed by the star Tom Selleck. Wild times.
He sings like a drummer. Not a lot of drummers are also singers, especially of his caliber. And he just sings right in the pocket like a good drummer would.
This is the first time i have really listened to this song. I only recently found you here and I appreciate your input on his music. Wonderful and uplifting
Phil had an amazing career: appearing as a child extra in "Hard Days Night"; enjoying his role as the anonymous drummer behind flamboyant Peter Gabriel in Genesis; being shoved into the spotlight by his bandmates after Peter's departure; enduring harsh criticism for exploring new musical directions; becoming a rock superstar who was half adored/half derided; and then falling victim to all sorts of ailments that have left him unable to play. Meanwhile, Ringo drums on.
I live in the UK. The Home Secretary of the UK (one of the most powerful positions in the UK government), Suella Braverman, wants to bring in new legislation to ban charities from giving tents to homeless people in cold weather. I don't need to say any more, do I? I'm a Buddhist and I do care. I tried to make a difference especially when I was working in Manchester and walking past suffering people. I couldn't do much but I could buy food. This song makes me cry every time I hear it 😢 It is by far my most favourite Phil Collins track (solo career, not in Genesis) - just a fabulous track. Thank you so much for reviewing this, Elizabeth 🥰
@@brianswift2706 Indeed (or not in terms of a choice as the case may be). It doesn't matter what your political persuasions are, denying homeless people tents is a whole new level or universe of cruelty. If this law goes through, UK homeless people will die this winter. Who knows what Phil Collins is thinking (although he has enough of his own health problems at the moment).
I've been watching your channel for a couple years now, and although I've been mostly impressed by your technical knowledge (voice and audio engineering) and animated reactions, it's really the goodness of your heart that impacts me deepest. In addition to being smart and beautiful, you seem to be a truly good person.
One of Phil's best vocal performances is "Mama." There are several good live videos. His piercing anguish is wonderful. I saw Genesis on this tour, and it remains one of the best shows I've ever seen (and I've seen Pink Floyd and David Bowie). His drum duets with Chester Thompson were amazing. Off the drum, Phil was a very good showman.
Back in the early 2000 nd's I heard quite a few people described Phil Collins as boring. That's why he will never be great . To me that explains why to much of the current music culture has very little story telling. Phil Collins is great and a genuine treasure.
Music used to be much more. It used to be a medium for change, protest, and ideas. Today's crap has 3, and only 3, themes (with a few rare exceptions) - Get rich, Get laid, Get even. Don't believe me? Check out the last decade of musical schlock that's being played now. Show me an important theme anyone under the age of 30 has put to music & that people are taking to heart. There aren't any. This aging Boomer, proud to be one too, has spoken.
I loved your reaction and analysis of this, Elizabeth. It's a wonderful song and after being homeless myself just before its release it always spoke volumes to me, as does the song, 'Streets of London' by Ralph McTell (another beautifully moving song), I was living in London at the time of my homelessness. Other Phil Collins tracks which I recommend are: 'Against All Odds', 'Easy Lover' a duet with Philip Bailey of 'Earth, Wind and Fire'. There are many great tracks from him but these are good ones to continue with.
Phil was rarely in lists of greatest vocals but for me he always had a voice that’s somehow soothing, comforting, and simply beautiful in its own way. As an 80’s kid he was one of seemingly countless performers and bands that were absolutely awesome but he always stood out just a bit more than most. I have the same feelings about how Steve Perry’s voice impacted me but he was definitely in everyone’s list of greatest vocalist. Their voices were some kind of magic. 🤙🏻
I love how the drums consistently get more and more intense as the song builds, like giving the song urgency. It wouldn't be a Phil Collins song without the percussion being a standout feature.
It's up to 150 million that they will admit to; it's incredible how a song can be so beautiful and so sad at the same time. Every time I hear it, I tear up.
I grew up listening to Phil Collins and Genesis, as he was one of my Mom and Dad's favorite singers. I was 8 when this song came out, and we were living in Baltimore at the time. We used to travel into DC fairly regularly, once a month at minimum, to go to the National Zoo, or the Smithsonian Museums, or whatever. I remember being shocked at how many homeless people there were right in our nation's capitol, and it made me cry. Especially when I'd see parents with children... I saw so many kids that looked to be my age, or my little brothers age, and it broke my heart that I had a warm home to go back to, and they didn't. Watching your reaction to this video today transported me back 34 years, to when I was that little girl who wore her heart on her sleeve. This song STILL breaks my heart, and makes me tear up. Phil is an absolute legend for the simple reason that he makes you FEEL the lyrics. This is why I still love him to this day! ❤
I must admit, when this song first came out in 1989, I didn't really listen to the verse lyrics enough to "get" the story. When I was on the verge of homelessness myself and heard it again... BAM! Total gut punch, as you said. The photos really add to that. And that's even before we get to the absolute beauty of this song!
Two Phil Collins musts are “Against all odds” and “Wish it would rain down”. The first is among the most emotional love songs ever…..soooo powerful to hear the longing and desperation in his voice. The second is just a powerful ballad with the extra bonus of Eric Clapton playing guitar. In that one, it’s really Clapton’s guitar that provides the emotion. Both are best by playing the videos.
Against All Odds has some of the most bizarre chord changes ever in a pop song, but somehow Phil Collins just makes it work. It's a really unique song.
I remember how powerful this song was when it came out. I was just a child, but I loved his work even then. Little did I know I would face homelessness several times in my own life, and have to face that invisibility. I am grateful to be on the other side of that; to have learned those lessons and to strive to be of service when I can. To appreciate the paradise that I now live in
I'm so glad to find your channel Elizabeth - I had the privilege of backlighting Phill Collins on the 'Jonathon Ross Friday Night Live Show' in London early 90's - Ewart Television studios. There was always a buffet afterwards and we got chance to meet and mingle with the performers. This guy was is an awesome bloke!... kind, fun, polite, totally grounded and an absolute music icon! Coming from a musical family (Mother was a professional pianist and opera singer) , I thank you for reigniting my music instrumental passion. After a ten year layoff, now practicing acoustic guitar version of Blue on Black (Kenny Wayne Shepherd) by Smith & Myers and loving it again 👍Sending hugs n' thanks from UK across the pond 😊
I remember driving south in the eighties on highway A1A in Florida, when this song first came out and I heard it. Funny how songs can make a powerful impression on you, and I was thankful for what I had. Funny thing 24 years later, I had lost my home that I had built, was divorced, and was homeless living out of my truck. I have recovered, but I will never forget that humbling experience. Sometimes you need a whoopin, so you can open your eyes.
Every time I feel tired with life or burdened with my problems, I put this song and it shines a light on how trivial some of my problems are. I have a house. Things could have been much much worse. Think about it and be grateful for the things you have (achieved) in life. The ending of this song always brings tears in my eyes.
Phil Collins was well known for using gated reverb in his percussion techniques. You will discover that he used this effect in many of his songs, to varying degrees.
The main drum groove is Phil’s trusty TR-808 drum machine. Use of a drum machine & the gates on the sound was considered a bit odd for a live drummer, but it didn’t cheapen the sound like the dance tracks of the 80’s 90’s, he instead used it to richen the sound. There’s a mix of 808 & live drums throughout. Freaking genius.
Bit more than well known for using, it was when he was working with Hugh Padgham on Peter Gabriel's 1980 Album they discovered this sound effect that defines so much of 80's pop music
This song gives me goosebumps every time and can be a real tear jerker! Him using his voice and music to portray how tough life if for some out there is absolutely phenomenal!!!!
I've always loved this song. As I've gotten older I seem to have been able to connect to the emotional aspects of songs a lot easyer. Lot more tears well up to old favorites.
It's because this song jas been out for GENERATIONS. He told us the message. And for some reason, we have spent every DECADE since judging the splinter in others eyes whilst ignoring the beam in our own. Focusing on people in countries that hate us instead of taking care of our own people. Until now almost every major city is failed or failing. Someone needs to do an angrier version that phil's warning was ignored, like disturbed did with 'the sound of silence'.
I believe Phil never got enough credit for his work. From his drumming for Genisis, taking over the lead vocals whilst still drumming, movie srar in Buster to solo artist. Some of my favourites would have to be Rain Down On Me, Against All Odds and Genisis songs like Follow You Follow Me and a total opposite to this song in style and voice, Mamma. Truly amazing talent. ❤
Phil's got it all: Huge vocal chops, emotion, vocal range, excels in multiple genres, and NOBODY does the 'gut punch' better! Best 'gut punch' examples for me are Turn It On Again, Missed Again, Misunderstanding, and Thats All but there are many more.
If you want to hear another dimension of Phil's voice, you should check out some of his work with Genesis! I'll recommend both Land of Confusion, and Mama. Mama brings out some of his more aggressive tones, and both of these have him wailing. Glad to hear how much you like him solo. He's had such an incredibly and lengthy career.
I was homeless with very little hope for a time a few years ago. This song & video are DEAD ON. Everything described in the lyrics I experienced. Luckily, I swallowed my pride & asked for help from a friend. She took me in, supported me in rebuilding my life, and honestly, I think saved my life. A debt I can never repay. We really need more love & compassion in this world. NEVER take anyone for granted.
We are heading into fall here in Western Cape. South Africa....Phil Collins has always put bindings on our hearts. I was doing some rumbling around on the interweb...His health has deteriorated, to the point no longer sings or plays. I can not imagine..His eyes are sharp... But having all the music still inside if him..and not being able to set it free. I remembered your reaction's and came back to revisit them. Both Paradise and In the Air... You know music is good when it can still tug at hear and bring tears.. Thank You..... Siriah
I watched and listened Phil Collins twice. On his Fare Well Tour in Düsseldorf 2007 and 2016 sitting in a chair in Cologne. The second time he couldn't be drumming any more. But his son did it. Unforgettable moments ❤
The musical 🎼 Genius of Phil Collins cannot be overstated, from Lyrics, musical composition, voice and INCREDIBLE drum playing. Few people know he had over 3 number one hits BEFORE he even started Genesis, musical lyric's and compositions he wrote for MANY other famous artists. Thank you so much for an excellent reaction/analysis of one of the all time Greats in the industry.
Phil Collins joined Genesis in 1971, a couple years after Genesis was created. Before that he was in a group called Flaming Youth and they did not have hits.. What hits do you mean? But, Yes, Phil is a musical genius!
I’ve been homeless and not, I find that each story is different and even being there my heart broke to see anyone hungry, hurt, or tired. Education on how to rent and the laws surrounding that, mental health, abuse, addiction, all kinds of people all kinds of reasons. Also there are NO domestic violence shelters for men with children let alone single men! Most shelters don’t accept boys over twelve!!! We stayed in our car because we were rare and lucky to at least have that. I love this song! Always have. I’ve changed a lot and learned soo soo much during this journey am looking into becoming an advocate of some kind I’d really LOVE to become part of a solution bringing my own unique and not so unique experiences to the table. Anyway I have mad respect for you Elizabeth truly the definition of beautiful human being! Just get you CARE! I adore what you’re doing!
this was the song chosen for the mother-son dance at my eldest son's wedding....I cried so hard I made HIM cry...my 1st baby, the one who made me a mom. Can never hear it again without tears.
Phil always kills it, and he is great live. Please check out the live version of "driving the last spike" and "no son of mine"from the 1992 genesis tour. Spectacular performances.
Phil's personal life plagued with pain, injury an depression resonates so deeply with me. I am a professional Architect but due to over 20 years of severe chronic pain from Trigeminal Neuralgia Type 2 (facial nerve pain), I have lost my family, my career and self confidence, I now find myself homeless and recovering from a failed suicide attempt. My love of music has been a stable constant in my life, providing an escape and a record of the good times in my life, each memory linked to a particular poignant song. Phil Collins has been a favourite for decades.
You gotta hear "Against All Odds"... only the studio version (critical.) It is Phil's best vocals without question. And it is an amazing, passionate song.
Just a genuine man with in my opinion one of the most unique and not easy to imitate vocals out there. He is big on getting that message out there if whatever he is singing on in a calm yet powerful hit of emotion to really feel it. I had always wanted to see him in concert as i love him and this is actually my favorite song. I know his health has gotten bad and he may never perform so I'm sad at knowing that but I hope he gets better and enjoys his time and we as lovers of music with message and everything, can love and appreciate all the amazing things he has done to help others and basically get everyone to as he says in this song but it's really for many of his songs "just think about it". Masterpiece
Hes such a great writer, drummer, singer, producer. He does a majority of the work on these song's. This song definitely hits me in the feels. I can remember when this came out.
Thank you for bringing this song back to my mind. I was fourteen when it came out and everyone loved it. And then, two or three years later, Phil Collins suddenly became embarrassing. I don't know why. Maybe it was that he sounded 80s when Europe entered the Techno Decade. Listening to him now allows me to appreciate what a great artist he is.
There is something really amazing in the subtlety with which the buildup of the song and the expression in Phil Collins' singing goes - from this small, sad, introspective feeling to a more frustrated, almost angry, activating feel. You can almost not hear an actual difference in his singing but you still *feel* his emotions shift from sad to angry and that's just mind-blowing to me. Amazing song and great analysis, thank you 🙏🏻
Moving from the "She" and "He" articles, and over to the "You" half way through is just one of those really subtle touches that i absolutely live about this song. Might just be a silly observation but ive always liked that part.
The "...But Seriously" album (the black one) is filled with tracks like this, that have a profound meaning to them and that are just so beautifully executed. I love it so much.
Phil Collins is an amazing artist from every aspect. His voice is godlike, he is such a great drummer, performer on stage, songwriter, you name it. A really rare talent
Emotion is something Mr. Collins can handle so well, yet so honestly. You can hear and feel it. A master musician. To add to your respect, besides his work in supporting charities, he collected money at his concerts where he sang this and match it. He gave it to a homeless shelter in the town in which he sang. Love this video and how intimate it is. Phil looks so good here and his attention to detail is legendary. He was a music producer. He also graduated from a drama school in London. The man is vastly under-estimated. Both he and Genesis had a very humanistic world view and the themes running through their music are deep. They are excellent at uniting music, lyrics and feelings into a whole that few can equal. He never promotes himself, but always the music. Peter Gabriel (also of Genesis) has spent his life supporting causes that help people. Early Genesis is so good. Please indulge. Love your message of caring and understanding. Giving to support agencies may seem distant but it is the best way to get help where needed. I can't bring myself to give directly because I am unsure of the 'head space' of the individual and whether my 'aid' is going to something constructive or supporting a destructive lifestyle. Mental health is an area that needs far more support!
I was 8 when this song came out, and it was a gut punch even at that young of an age. Where I live now, we have a community "fridge" which is actually a covered fridge and shelving unit. On the shelves there are labeled tote bins - toiletries, hats & mittens, dried and canned foods, etc. Community members and groups donate food items and necessities (milk, fully assembled meals, fresh fruit & veggies, etc to the fridge & freezer, and dried goods and personal items in the bins), and anyone is welcome to come grab something they're in need of at any time. Does it sometimes get abused? Likely.. but it also legitimately helps. If folks can't donate their stuff, they donate their time to keep the fridge and shelves clean, take out the garbage that accumulates in the bin next to it, etc.
When this video came out it was hard hitting and Phil Collins donated all the profits from this song to homeless charities. At his concerts he would have collection buckets for people to donate, whatever was collected and Phil Collins would match the amount from his own pocket.
Also, just another example of an artist using their platform for humanitarian purposes. This is one of the best songs ever performed by Phil Collins!
Even italian pop group Pooh did this in 2006 for their 40 years career concert in my hometown, but I don't know if that was the case.
He also allowed homeless charities to use the video and song to publicise and highlight their individual fundraising efforts.
My ex and I saw that Carousel Tour in Cleveland in 1989. Almost three hours long without an opening act. What a great show he put on.
I saw Phil on this tour and remember the donation buckets. I was glad to be able to give a little to this very worthy cause!
@@ericmayle8510 I was there too! You were close, it was August 1990.
This man is not in the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame as a solo artist. Let that sink in for a minute. 🤯🤯
Utterly ridiculous isn’t it 🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️
Is he in it for the fame? If so, wouldn't that make the bar far higher? If not, he doesn't care; why should you?
I saw an article before about people who were in bands who went on to solo careers, and the two most successful were Peter Gabriel and Phil Collins, both from the same band.
😢
Yeah it’s times like this I realize they have no idea what they’re doing over there.
Can say this, from Cleveland.
This song always hits deep inside. He kept it simple and subtle yet his plea in his voice is deafening so the message can hit through. Truly brilliant.
Kind of like the first time you hear the theme song from M.A.S.H., but with the lyrics.
Attended that tour. They had volunteers, dozens of them, at each show taking collections for the local shelters & organizations helping the homeless. I put my $40 of 'fun money' that night right into the bucket. 'Another day in paradise' indeed.
In case nobody knows Phil wrote this song because he is truly a caring man all proceeds from this song went to helping Homeless and every time he performs this song even to this day he passes around donation buckets around the whole concert crowd and whatever is donated he matches it he is a empathetic person
I was homeless once and I never got any money from his donations. Hard to find any help.
@@crand20033And after decades of homelessness being present in this country, and countless tens of millions spent trying to overcome the problem, homelessness is as bad as ever. The Churches used to help people with this, but then the government decided to take it over....I'm glad you are no longer homeless my friend.
Indeed,This one hit Phil hard and his efforts to help the homeless are well documented.
❤❤❤❤❤thanks Phil..from a poor Australian. We do what we can hey.
Gardening.cleaning.shopping or like someone as yourself ...a great generosity..Father and Jesus' blessing. I have cervical 1-7 bad damage.
Saw you in Sydney. Love your drumming...and obviously your voice and sense of humour. 😅❤😅😅love to your family too😊
Just in the first verse alone, Phil Collins painted a scene that many homeless people have described as being invisible. The surgical precision with which he writes in a way that cuts to the heart is vastly underrated.
It seems to me that this is the most harmful part of being homeless, that they are cast out from society and dehumanised by people ignoring that they even exist.
I have never had enough money to regularly donate to charities to help but I think that even if we don’t have anything to give to homeless people it would probably make their day a little better to at least acknowledge them and talk to them when you see them.
I can’t imagine what it must feel like to be ignored by everybody like that.
" painted a scene that many homeless people have described as being invisible. "
-Sometimes that is the purpose.
It’s simple yet it’s beautifully precise and difficult to perfect. Not impossible but Phil makes it sound beautifully easy. His voice is always direct yet smooth and you never question his intentions in a song. I just love him ❤
Its true, I used to spend time talking to various street people here in PDX. Many were very interesting, and it is dehumanizing the way people ignore them just because they find it a hassle . I am also guilty of this, though nowadays i do try and at least say hello. Part of the issue is that there are actually legitimately dangerous and unhinged people on the streets, whether from drugs or mental illness. Sometimes these people will be aggressive even if you simply look their direction. These are also broken and hurting people that need our help, but I don’t blame people for wanting to avoid being accosted, verbally or physically by them. You can’t be sure which ones are good people who are suffering, and those who best avoided. They all need help, im just saying its somewhat understandable. Also, drugs can turn previously wonderful people into very dangerous untrustworthy people, I’ve seen it in my own personal life.
This song always brings a lump to my throat. Reminds me of somebody I knew at school who I found out many years later had been living on the streets and she had died of hypothermia over Christmas 2009.
Please more Phil Collins and Genesis. Please don't make us wait another 2 years!
Domino, parts I and II together
or lamb - do the whole album@@domandred
Mama, I would like to hear Elizabeth's reaction on the 'haha' in this song...
Yes, please!
No Son of Mine is another Phil song that will punch you in the feels. So good.
Yes. A great Genesis song!!
The whole Genesis Album ❤
Whitney 👍👍, I forgot about that one
'Both Sides Of The Story' is another gut punch, and one of his best songs.
He has a plethora of amazing tracks... I wish it would rain is one of my favourites
There will never be another singer like Phil Collins
Against All Odds is such a great song. Really a perfect pop tune
One of my all time favourites. No matter my emotional/mental state, I can find something that resonates in that moment. And i TOTALLY, ABSOLUTELY have been caught out stunting asking at (almost) the top of my lungs in public surf my headphones in, in my own little world...
Goosebumps every time in that last chorus
I think "Throwing It All Away" is my favorite of his although it is technically a Genesis song.
Speaking as a homeless person myself, I find that watching videos by entertaining content-creators like yourself (whenever I am able to find a free Wi-Fi signal) helps keep my mind thinking more positively without circling back to my situation. So keep up the good work! Coming to videos from this channel is like visiting an old friend who doesn't judge me for the life choices I've made which put me in this situation.
In general, though, we are all just looking for acknowledgement. Yes, we may be looking for spare change for food, not just for a "fix", and that may make your day worse being accosted by us, but don't ignore us, Sometimes it can take a lot of courage to break through one's pride to be able to ask for help in the first place; to have you just ignore us or quickly cross the street away from us can only decrease our feelings of self worth. Just please notice us, because we are not going away any time soon, in fact our numbers are growing daily,
Remember: if you do not belong to the upper 1% who rule the rest of us, there is a good chance that you are only 2 missing paychecks away from joining us!
Great analysis, as usual !
As someone who has been out on the streets, I feel you man. I never did drugs or abused alcohol one day in my whole life-but was there due to financial diffilculties. While on the streets, I met all kinds of people. Some bad, most good people, but all in a bad situation. I finally found my way off the streets (with the help of some very good friends), but I will never forget the experience-or the people who may still be out there.
I never cry. It seems I pretty much lost that ability when I grew up. But this song does it every time. My chest tightens and I find my self lost in the message. This is one of my favorite songs. And the lyrics hits like a freight train. This has to be Phil Collins's greatest musical achievement. I can listen to this song again and again, and I will never get bored with it.
Compare and contrast with Billy Joel 'we didn't start the fire'. He's preachy, he's beating you over the head with THE MESSAGE.
Whereas here, Phil is inviting you, 'just think about it'. He's not trying to bludgeon you with HIS thinking. He is dramatically undersinging it. To allow you to CHOOSE to be open to it.
My all time favorite song is Under pressure. It has a very powerful message also if you LISTEN to the words carefully (or turn on captions).
When i was pregnant, every time i heard this song it would have me in tears. He's a beautiful musician.
In my opinion, he is one of the most dominant artists of the 80's and 90's. His sound, both solo and with Genesis was just always present. Incredibly talented, and not that it matters, but how is he not in the Rock an Roll Hall of Fame as a solo artist? May be the largest oversight of that HOF to date, considering some of the "great's" they are enshrining year after year.
I feel the Rock-'n'-roll Hall of Fame has gotten away from what it was intended to be. Rappers have been inducted for instance. There are Halls of Fame that cover multiple genres of music, but the RnR HOF is for RnR. 🤷
My exact same sentiment. If his solo career is not a HOF career I don't know what is. Other artists that had already been inducted with their bands and had much less impactful or significant solo careers were acknowledged for their solo careers. Some even in the last 5 years. And he hasn't even been nominated once. His imprint is all over the 80s. How many other people are Hall of Fame songwriters (as he is, Songwriter's Hall of Fame did not sleep on him), singers, producers and a virtuoso with their instrument?
@@garymaidman625I also don’t agree with Rap being included in the HOF because it’s basically a copy of someone else’s music with a guy talking over it. Not saying it doesn’t take some talent but musically, it’s not that original and much less difficult to create than a Pop or Rock song from scratch. But the HOF basically has said that Rap is included under the Rock umbrella along with Pop, Jazz, Metal, Grunge, etc.
@@coolcat6303don't get me wrong, I think artists like Eminem and Outkast are excellent, however it's not Rock'n'roll.
Phil Collins is a rare talent in any one of his three skill sets alone, but to have composition, vocal, and percussion abilities all at his extremely high level is simply hard to believe as real. When you experience it, it just strikes awe.
You've forgotten about his awesome piano playing skills too!
@@Millietant-x3l You are sooo right, I completely missed it! Please accept my apologies Phil and others!!
"I don't care anymore", drips vitriol from every word, " The roof is leaking " is heartbreaking and "Driving the last spike" celebrating those who built the railways through mountains, valleys and died in their thousands doing so, all those will bring you to a different place. Collins is a god tier songwriter and performer. -Mark
I recommend "Woman in chains" Tears for Fears with Oleta Adams. Beautiful song with amazing production
Driving the Last Spike has been one of my favourite songs since I was a child. That, No Son of Mine and Dreaming While You Sleep by Genesis all hit like a tonne of bricks and are SO effective at portraying the stories they are trying to tell. Phil's voice is always the absolute icing on the cake. Such talent.
@@missingmonk4601Which Phil happens to play drums on. Great song!
THANK YOU for mentioning The Roof is Leaking. I thought I was the only one who thought that song was one of his masterpieces that never got the recognition it deserved.
Roof is leaking amazing track bud and everyone forgets it
Oh I feel the gut punch every single time I hear this song .
You can picture every single word he says.
I can even see the man crossing the street ignoring this lady pleading for his help.
He has a dark blue suit on in my head.
Perfect voice for this message.
Almost like an Angel reminding you to be kind and to help and care for others.
The late, great David Crosby provided the backing harmony in this. I highly recommend his work!
agreed. I always felt that Croz was the greatest harmonizer rock and pop ever had
Thank you so much for telling us that. It makes it even more valuable, richer. He was the perfect choice. You inspired me to look it up - the talented Dominic Miller on electric + classical guitar and the wonderful Leland Sklar on bass. No wonder it is so beautifully produced. My day is better for having experienced this. Thanks again.
David could sing harmony with a clock.
Another song where Phil Collins and David Crosby combined their voices to great results is Hero.
I'd love to see reaction and analysis of CSN/CSNY. They had harmony for days...
I usually do not chime in but this song rings personal to me. I was a homeless veteran when this song was on the airwaves. There are many reasons people become homeless. Not all homeless people are drug addicts. Some of us are suffering from other issues economic, mental health, trust issues, or histories that we are running from. Many homeless people beg for money because they do not know about available resources or the apathy presented by society to the problem. Many will not turn to shelters because of the necessity to listen to a sermon or be 'prayed over'. Many do not believe that there is the possibility that god even cares for them. They feel like people who work at these places are just doing this to feel good about themselves. Much like how people only think about veterans on Veterans day or Memorial day, they only think of homeless people on Thanksgiving or Christmas. Veterans are veterans for the rest of their lives. We bear the scares forever, not just twice a year. Those who are homeless are homeless more than twice a year, they need help everyday. We live in a country that sends billions to other countries to lift their citizens out of poverty but our own government refuses to take some of that tax money to help the homeless or homeless veterans. I do not want to get political but how is it right that people who di not cross the border appropriately are housed in hotels while homeless veterans can't even lay on a bus bench because some city councilman decided to make it impossible.
I am no longer homeless thanks to a kind individual many years ago who took a chance on me and gave me a place to live until i could get on my feet. Veterans, If you read this, please, if you find a homeless veteran please take them or point them to the nearest VA hospital so they can get assistance instead of ending up like I almost did, I think you know what I mean. Till Valhalla my Brothers and Sisters in Arms.
Amen brother, from one veteran to another, I salute you
For all of his accolades, talents, skills, etc that have been attributed to Phil Collins over the years, the most underrated skill is his ability to tell a story. One of my all time favorite artists. He not only can emote, but he can make you *feel* the lyrics, not just hear them. A once in a lifetime talent.
Elizabeth’s analysis of this song is just incredible…she totally gets it 👍🇬🇧
Phil is AMAZING. He sang, arranged, wrote , precusion. All around musician. I know he's not well right now. I wish him well
Phil was a huge voice in the 80s. I'm great full I was alive to hear most of his music real time.
Phil Collins in my opinion is a very deliberate lyricist, he is a master and his music always makes you feel something. Enjoy the PC journey.
This is one of these songs...you can play it 1000 times and never gets old. A masterpiece.
Sounds like you have played it 1000 times and are speaking from experience.
Trust me, the radio played it more than 1000 times back then 😁
Good covers these days, too
I can't listen to this song without crying. It pulls your heart strings.
I find myself watching Elizabeth. This song is in my top ten all-time, so every devastating line appears to have the same reaction for her as it did to me so many years ago. Stunning. When it first came out I’d burst into tears every time I’d hear it. Then 27 yrs later I myself was homeless. New perspective… Elizabeth nails exactly the reasons this recording’s so powerful.
A lot of what Elizabeth relates about the mechanics of singing goes over my head and the way that she chops videos much more than many other "reactors" is at times off putting, but the way she wears her heart on her sleeve is so endearing that I have to keep coming back, especially when the subject is a song or artist I'm invested in.
@@grandpascottshodgepodge9318I cackle everytime someone criticises a reactor for reacting. Want uninterrupted watch the og of the song
This is the best example of narration in melody. Soul searching sonnet in song.
Phil is such an authentic, emotional and relatable singer, so when he executes a dead stop and turns away after "He walks on", he demonstrates so powerfully how a break in empathic connection feels. Suddenly one feels alone and on one's own. And he achieves that gut punch with such small, delicate details!
A grand master.
I adore the acoustic guitar through out this song❤❤❤❤❤
Only just got into your channel so I don’t know how into percussion you are, but all the drumming he did through the 70’s and 80’s with Genesis is genuinely phenomenal. His poppier stuff is a bit of a meme (even though a lot of it is great) but he is an INCREDIBLE drummer, despite In the Air Tonight being his most known fill. One of Neil Peart (Rush)’s biggest inspirations, definitely shows
Her reaction to In the Air Tonight was hilarious. "He is singing very precisely on the beat, almost like percussion.. He could almost be a drummer" "What's he doing now, sitting at the drum kit?"
Yep he was drumming in a band called Brand X too - jazz fusion. Had to give that up when Genesis got too busy I think.
The Charismatic Voice’s biggest faux pas was cutting off Phil’s iconic drum solo in that video! 😢😮
Didn't expect to see you here lol a man of culture I see
Not bad at all for a drummer Genesis found through a newspaper advert..
As a French kid when the song came out, I could not understand the lyrics yet, but I felt the power of it and it stayed in my heart. Later, when I started playing the keyboards, I had to play this beautiful melody every time I played. Then, I started to play the guitar, and again, I found a way to play the song on my acoustic guitar and I wanted to sing along, so I had to learn the lyrics…and that’s when I got the message…
When I was 20, I’ve been kicked out of my mother’s house for some sad reason, and started to sleep under bridges. I had a few friends that could help me, but I hid it and never asked for help, pretending I was fine….I wasn’t.
One night, after a year and a half of wandering, I was preparing my spot to sleep under this f*cking bridge, and a friend of mine who was taking his dog out for a walk saw me and said: What the f*ck are you doing here, dude?!
I told him everything I was going through, and he offered me a shelter, giving me a chance to move on. I got back on my feet, and when I’ve been able to buy a guitar, this song was the first song that came to my mind when I grabbed it. Always on my set list when I busked in the streets, always passing my hat after it and always giving my tips to someone who needed this money to survive. I had no addiction, no mental illness except depression because of my situation, had a job, friends…but no home, and it wasn’t my choice…it’s hard. Whenever I got the blues or flashbacks of this period of my life, this song comes back to me. I know all Phil Collins’ phenomenal musical achievements, but this song will always be my favorite, for sure!
Thank you Ma’am, for reacting to it and help spreading the message, because decades after it came out, we still have more and more people, HUMAN BEINGS, dying outside, and ignored by most of those who can’t walk a mile in a homeless’ shoes, at least for a day!
This song addresses the consequences of ignoring the needy and homeless. Collins told The Mail on Sunday: "I wrote this after being in Washington DC where I was amazed by how many people I saw living in boxes." Collins told The New York Times how the song came together: "It was begun at the piano. I started playing and put it down on a tape so I wouldn't forget it. Then I decided to see what would happen when I started singing. When I began, the words just came out, 'She calls out to the man on the street.' I didn't set out to write a song about the homeless. Those were just the words I happened to sing. It was only then that I decided that was what the song would be about."
The video to this song conveys the lyrics perfectly. Another song that conveys a similar message is Metal Church - Anthem to the Estranged
Aqualung- Jethro Tull is another one
Ralph McTell - Streets of London
That makes me think of another Metal Church song called, Watch The Children Pray. At least it has a similar vibe. I need to check out that song, Anthem to the Estranged
I've loved Metal Church since their debut in 1984. I've seen them many times, including a few nights ago. Their new singer, Marc Lopes, is fantastic and reminds me of the David Wayne era (RIP).
I read somewhere that he said the song came about when he noticed that everyone was ignoring the pleas for help from the homeless and that he caught himself doing the same thing and this song was in response to these actions.
This man is definitely in the top 5 artists of all time. His songwriting capabilities and generosity is world-renowned. He's helped SO many other artists achieve their dreams and helped to write songs for them. He's one of only 3 artists to ever sell over 100 million albums both as a solo artist and a member of a band. And yes it is a complete shame that he is not in the Hall of Fame as a solo artist.
Phil did something most people don't know about - He financed David Crosby's liver transplant. Dave was just digging out from his massive addiction & prison term when his liver failed. Being friends with him, Phil stepped up & paid for it in full. He stated afterwards that, even if they weren't so close, he would have done it, as David was a talent that he felt could NOT be lost. He was right.
Love Phil Collins. If you want another amazing production song by him I highly suggest I Wish It Would Rain Down. There is a bit of comedy in the bit before and after the video, but the song is amazing, and Phil Collins stretches out his vocal power a bit more.
^ This. Plus it features this new guy on the guitar, Eric... something?
@@LudvikMjust some nobody. LOL, jk!
Agreed, Rain Down was a great vocal performance by Phil, I think that whole album was a effort to push performance boundaries.
Genesis "Driving the last spike" , is another good example of Phil Collins vocals
I think David Crosby is on backing vocals on this one. Crosby co-wrote on the album.
I’ve always loved Phil Collins. He’s never looked the part of a rock singer, but he was fantastic.
Phil is an incredible and iconic talent. His voice is immediately recognizable.
This song hits even harder in combination with the video. 😢
You know it's a good song when it automatically inspires you to talk about its subject instead of the technicalities. Phil is a master on producing tracks that instantly deliver their meaning
Phil had so many great songs, solo and with Genesis. The song “Mama” would be fun to see next as he uses his voice so much differently, and the tone of the song it wildly different. It was a huge hit, and used in an episode of Magnum PI that was directed by the star Tom Selleck. Wild times.
Absolutely! Mama is a real monster of a song, such atmosphere. His voice is so pliable and Mama really showcases that.
Second that. The stories told in both this song and Mama are so emotional.
Mama would get my vote
Absolutely! "Mama" it's one of my favorite Genesis tunes.
I was looking for this, another vote for Mama!
He has the ability to paint the emotion into the lyrics and it rips through his voice.
I love Phil's articulation, the words and lyrics are always (especially when English isn't your first languages) easy to follow
He sings like a drummer. Not a lot of drummers are also singers, especially of his caliber. And he just sings right in the pocket like a good drummer would.
@@brandonbuchner1771 Dave Grohl is also a drummer who plays guitar and sings. Noticable twith him too
This is the first time i have really listened to this song. I only recently found you here and I appreciate your input on his music. Wonderful and uplifting
I NEED your analysis of "Against All Odds" in my life. It's such a fantastic song
That's a great song, no doubt, but to me, In Too Deep is his greatest song (even though it's a Genesis song).
@@garymaidman625 In Too Deep is amazing, no doubt about that!
His voice in this has a high degree of sincerity and simultaneously an aspect of vulnerability. It is honest, and carries the message beautifully.
Phil had an amazing career: appearing as a child extra in "Hard Days Night"; enjoying his role as the anonymous drummer behind flamboyant Peter Gabriel in Genesis; being shoved into the spotlight by his bandmates after Peter's departure; enduring harsh criticism for exploring new musical directions; becoming a rock superstar who was half adored/half derided; and then falling victim to all sorts of ailments that have left him unable to play. Meanwhile, Ringo drums on.
As does Lars...
Ringo abides
Composed, played some of the percussion, and sang the Tarzan soundtrack, which is an overlooked gem. Also, a cameo as the Inspector in Hook.
As does his son. Playing for Genesis in the last tour, Mike and the Mechanics and his own projects....
Way to bring someone else down while making your point. Any way you can talk about someone's career without also shitting on others?
I love that you forget yourself, and see the world from the homeless ones view. That is a beautiful blessing you have passed on.
Gracias 🙏 Dios lesbendiga siempre amen you familia amen 🙏🌍🙏🥰♥️🏠🕊️✝️
I live in the UK. The Home Secretary of the UK (one of the most powerful positions in the UK government), Suella Braverman, wants to bring in new legislation to ban charities from giving tents to homeless people in cold weather. I don't need to say any more, do I? I'm a Buddhist and I do care. I tried to make a difference especially when I was working in Manchester and walking past suffering people. I couldn't do much but I could buy food. This song makes me cry every time I hear it 😢 It is by far my most favourite Phil Collins track (solo career, not in Genesis) - just a fabulous track. Thank you so much for reviewing this, Elizabeth 🥰
Don't you know that homelessness is a 'lifestyle choice'? According to Braverman anyway. Depressing isn't it?
@@brianswift2706 Indeed (or not in terms of a choice as the case may be). It doesn't matter what your political persuasions are, denying homeless people tents is a whole new level or universe of cruelty. If this law goes through, UK homeless people will die this winter. Who knows what Phil Collins is thinking (although he has enough of his own health problems at the moment).
I've been watching your channel for a couple years now, and although I've been mostly impressed by your technical knowledge (voice and audio engineering) and animated reactions, it's really the goodness of your heart that impacts me deepest. In addition to being smart and beautiful, you seem to be a truly good person.
Absolutely
💯
One of Phil's best vocal performances is "Mama." There are several good live videos. His piercing anguish is wonderful. I saw Genesis on this tour, and it remains one of the best shows I've ever seen (and I've seen Pink Floyd and David Bowie). His drum duets with Chester Thompson were amazing. Off the drum, Phil was a very good showman.
Back in the early 2000 nd's I heard quite a few people described Phil Collins as boring. That's why he will never be great . To me that explains why to much of the current music culture has very little story telling. Phil Collins is great and a genuine treasure.
Music used to be much more. It used to be a medium for change, protest, and ideas. Today's crap has 3, and only 3, themes (with a few rare exceptions) - Get rich, Get laid, Get even. Don't believe me? Check out the last decade of musical schlock that's being played now. Show me an important theme anyone under the age of 30 has put to music & that people are taking to heart. There aren't any. This aging Boomer, proud to be one too, has spoken.
I loved your reaction and analysis of this, Elizabeth. It's a wonderful song and after being homeless myself just before its release it always spoke volumes to me, as does the song, 'Streets of London' by Ralph McTell (another beautifully moving song), I was living in London at the time of my homelessness. Other Phil Collins tracks which I recommend are:
'Against All Odds',
'Easy Lover' a duet with Philip Bailey of 'Earth, Wind and Fire'. There are many great tracks from him but these are good ones to continue with.
Gut punch and tears. I try to always acknowledge anyone who reaches out, just to acknowledge you see them is often healing.
Best songs by Phil for a vocalist reaction: Mama and I don’t care anymore. Thanks for the great heart felt reaction and vocal breakdown as always!
I agree Mama Live performances have incredible vocals from Phil
Phil was rarely in lists of greatest vocals but for me he always had a voice that’s somehow soothing, comforting, and simply beautiful in its own way.
As an 80’s kid he was one of seemingly countless performers and bands that were absolutely awesome but he always stood out just a bit more than most. I have the same feelings about how Steve Perry’s voice impacted me but he was definitely in everyone’s list of greatest vocalist.
Their voices were some kind of magic. 🤙🏻
Wow You're absolutely right! I lived that too!
I love how the drums consistently get more and more intense as the song builds, like giving the song urgency. It wouldn't be a Phil Collins song without the percussion being a standout feature.
It's up to 150 million that they will admit to; it's incredible how a song can be so beautiful and so sad at the same time. Every time I hear it, I tear up.
I grew up listening to Phil Collins and Genesis, as he was one of my Mom and Dad's favorite singers. I was 8 when this song came out, and we were living in Baltimore at the time. We used to travel into DC fairly regularly, once a month at minimum, to go to the National Zoo, or the Smithsonian Museums, or whatever. I remember being shocked at how many homeless people there were right in our nation's capitol, and it made me cry. Especially when I'd see parents with children... I saw so many kids that looked to be my age, or my little brothers age, and it broke my heart that I had a warm home to go back to, and they didn't. Watching your reaction to this video today transported me back 34 years, to when I was that little girl who wore her heart on her sleeve. This song STILL breaks my heart, and makes me tear up. Phil is an absolute legend for the simple reason that he makes you FEEL the lyrics. This is why I still love him to this day! ❤
I must admit, when this song first came out in 1989, I didn't really listen to the verse lyrics enough to "get" the story. When I was on the verge of homelessness myself and heard it again... BAM! Total gut punch, as you said. The photos really add to that. And that's even before we get to the absolute beauty of this song!
there is a reason phil was one of the best if not the best of his generation
Two Phil Collins musts are “Against all odds” and “Wish it would rain down”. The first is among the most emotional love songs ever…..soooo powerful to hear the longing and desperation in his voice. The second is just a powerful ballad with the extra bonus of Eric Clapton playing guitar. In that one, it’s really Clapton’s guitar that provides the emotion. Both are best by playing the videos.
Against All Odds breaks me every time. The emotion in his voice 😭
Against All Odds has some of the most bizarre chord changes ever in a pop song, but somehow Phil Collins just makes it work. It's a really unique song.
I remember how powerful this song was when it came out. I was just a child, but I loved his work even then. Little did I know I would face homelessness several times in my own life, and have to face that invisibility. I am grateful to be on the other side of that; to have learned those lessons and to strive to be of service when I can. To appreciate the paradise that I now live in
I'm so glad to find your channel Elizabeth - I had the privilege of backlighting Phill Collins on the 'Jonathon Ross Friday Night Live Show' in London early 90's - Ewart Television studios. There was always a buffet afterwards and we got chance to meet and mingle with the performers. This guy was is an awesome bloke!... kind, fun, polite, totally grounded and an absolute music icon!
Coming from a musical family (Mother was a professional pianist and opera singer) , I thank you for reigniting my music instrumental passion. After a ten year layoff, now practicing acoustic guitar version of Blue on Black (Kenny Wayne Shepherd) by Smith & Myers and loving it again 👍Sending hugs n' thanks from UK across the pond 😊
Phil's voice always sounds like it's echoing through time.
I remember driving south in the eighties on highway A1A in Florida, when this song first came out and I heard it. Funny how songs can make a powerful impression on you, and I was thankful for what I had. Funny thing 24 years later, I had lost my home that I had built, was divorced, and was homeless living out of my truck. I have recovered, but I will never forget that humbling experience. Sometimes you need a whoopin, so you can open your eyes.
Phil Collins is amazing!
Every time I feel tired with life or burdened with my problems, I put this song and it shines a light on how trivial some of my problems are. I have a house. Things could have been much much worse. Think about it and be grateful for the things you have (achieved) in life. The ending of this song always brings tears in my eyes.
I'm a heavy metal and classic rock person but I've been known to take over the Bluetooth device after some rum and coke and play my Collins playlist
Another fantastic video covering one of my favourite singers of all time.
Thank You ❤️ I'm going to join your patreon I think you're fantastic 💫💛
Phil Collins was well known for using gated reverb in his percussion techniques. You will discover that he used this effect in many of his songs, to varying degrees.
That's the 'some kind of percussion' she comments on right at the beginning of the song
The main drum groove is Phil’s trusty TR-808 drum machine. Use of a drum machine & the gates on the sound was considered a bit odd for a live drummer, but it didn’t cheapen the sound like the dance tracks of the 80’s 90’s, he instead used it to richen the sound. There’s a mix of 808 & live drums throughout. Freaking genius.
Bit more than well known for using, it was when he was working with Hugh Padgham on Peter Gabriel's 1980 Album they discovered this sound effect that defines so much of 80's pop music
This song gives me goosebumps every time and can be a real tear jerker! Him using his voice and music to portray how tough life if for some out there is absolutely phenomenal!!!!
I've always loved this song. As I've gotten older I seem to have been able to connect to the emotional aspects of songs a lot easyer. Lot more tears well up to old favorites.
It's because this song jas been out for GENERATIONS. He told us the message. And for some reason, we have spent every DECADE since judging the splinter in others eyes whilst ignoring the beam in our own. Focusing on people in countries that hate us instead of taking care of our own people. Until now almost every major city is failed or failing.
Someone needs to do an angrier version that phil's warning was ignored, like disturbed did with 'the sound of silence'.
@@DixonsCider disturbed did land of confusion.
@@adams5613 that too
@@adams5613 and tears for fears's "SHOUT"
I believe Phil never got enough credit for his work. From his drumming for Genisis, taking over the lead vocals whilst still drumming, movie srar in Buster to solo artist. Some of my favourites would have to be Rain Down On Me, Against All Odds and Genisis songs like Follow You Follow Me and a total opposite to this song in style and voice, Mamma. Truly amazing talent. ❤
You're probably right!
Phil's got it all: Huge vocal chops, emotion, vocal range, excels in multiple genres, and NOBODY does the 'gut punch' better! Best 'gut punch' examples for me are Turn It On Again, Missed Again, Misunderstanding, and Thats All but there are many more.
This song has one of the most beautiful bridges in all of music.
If you want to hear another dimension of Phil's voice, you should check out some of his work with Genesis! I'll recommend both Land of Confusion, and Mama. Mama brings out some of his more aggressive tones, and both of these have him wailing. Glad to hear how much you like him solo. He's had such an incredibly and lengthy career.
Oh my gosh yes!!! Mama and Home by the Sea are two of all time favorites.
Absolutely- I believe that Mama is his best vocal performance as it has every facet of his voice.
I was homeless with very little hope for a time a few years ago. This song & video are DEAD ON. Everything described in the lyrics I experienced. Luckily, I swallowed my pride & asked for help from a friend. She took me in, supported me in rebuilding my life, and honestly, I think saved my life. A debt I can never repay. We really need more love & compassion in this world. NEVER take anyone for granted.
We are heading into fall here in Western Cape. South Africa....Phil Collins has always put bindings on our hearts. I was doing some rumbling around on the interweb...His health has deteriorated, to the point no longer sings or plays. I can not imagine..His eyes are sharp... But having all the music still inside if him..and not being able to set it free.
I remembered your reaction's and came back to revisit them.
Both Paradise and In the Air... You know music is good when it can still tug at hear and bring tears.. Thank You.....
Siriah
I watched and listened Phil Collins twice. On his Fare Well Tour in Düsseldorf 2007 and 2016 sitting in a chair in Cologne. The second time he couldn't be drumming any more. But his son did it. Unforgettable moments ❤
The musical 🎼 Genius of Phil Collins cannot be overstated, from Lyrics, musical composition, voice and INCREDIBLE drum playing. Few people know he had over 3 number one hits BEFORE he even started Genesis, musical lyric's and compositions he wrote for MANY other famous artists. Thank you so much for an excellent reaction/analysis of one of the all time Greats in the industry.
Phil Collins joined Genesis in 1971, a couple years after Genesis was created. Before that he was in a group called Flaming Youth and they did not have hits.. What hits do you mean? But, Yes, Phil is a musical genius!
@@nightHawk66 Easy Lover is the first to come to mind, believe he also wrote a chart Placer for the 4 Topps, I think those were in the 80's
I’ve been homeless and not, I find that each story is different and even being there my heart broke to see anyone hungry, hurt, or tired. Education on how to rent and the laws surrounding that, mental health, abuse, addiction, all kinds of people all kinds of reasons. Also there are NO domestic violence shelters for men with children let alone single men! Most shelters don’t accept boys over twelve!!! We stayed in our car because we were rare and lucky to at least have that. I love this song! Always have. I’ve changed a lot and learned soo soo much during this journey am looking into becoming an advocate of some kind I’d really LOVE to become part of a solution bringing my own unique and not so unique experiences to the table. Anyway I have mad respect for you Elizabeth truly the definition of beautiful human being! Just get you CARE! I adore what you’re doing!
A song from his "Tarzan" soundtrack would be awesome. "You'll Be in My Heart" is amazing.
this was the song chosen for the mother-son dance at my eldest son's wedding....I cried so hard I made HIM cry...my 1st baby, the one who made me a mom. Can never hear it again without tears.
It’s so good! I always feel so silly that a “Disney song” makes me cry every time I hear it.
The 80th was simply the best time ever!!!! You can´t NEVER top it!
Phil always kills it, and he is great live. Please check out the live version of "driving the last spike" and "no son of mine"from the 1992 genesis tour. Spectacular performances.
Oooo, no son of mine is a gut punch.
Thanks for the like Elizabeth!
Saw these two songs live during their We Can’t Dance Tour in London in 92. Spine tingling songs and memories.
This song takes me back…Jesus. So sad, yet so gorgeous. That keyboard riff takes me back to my youth. This song has made me tear up for 30+ years.
Genesis Home by the Sea has to be the most impassioned I've heard Phil sing. Incredible song with an incredible vocal performance.
Phil's personal life plagued with pain, injury an depression resonates so deeply with me. I am a professional Architect but due to over 20 years of severe chronic pain from Trigeminal Neuralgia Type 2 (facial nerve pain), I have lost my family, my career and self confidence, I now find myself homeless and recovering from a failed suicide attempt. My love of music has been a stable constant in my life, providing an escape and a record of the good times in my life, each memory linked to a particular poignant song. Phil Collins has been a favourite for decades.
You gotta hear "Against All Odds"... only the studio version (critical.) It is Phil's best vocals without question. And it is an amazing, passionate song.
The studio version is my favourite. The live versions are okay, but the pain he puts into his voice in the last verse and chorus is palpable.
It has a very dated sound, but I'd pick I Wish It Would Rain Down. The way he's absolutely belting out from the bridge on out is emotionally jarring.
Gut punch for sure but more a broken heart. Thanks for highlighting this song and Colllins’ mastery of how he conveys this message. ❤️
Just a genuine man with in my opinion one of the most unique and not easy to imitate vocals out there. He is big on getting that message out there if whatever he is singing on in a calm yet powerful hit of emotion to really feel it. I had always wanted to see him in concert as i love him and this is actually my favorite song. I know his health has gotten bad and he may never perform so I'm sad at knowing that but I hope he gets better and enjoys his time and we as lovers of music with message and everything, can love and appreciate all the amazing things he has done to help others and basically get everyone to as he says in this song but it's really for many of his songs "just think about it". Masterpiece
genius drummer, genius singer, genius songwriter... GENIUS
Hes such a great writer, drummer, singer, producer. He does a majority of the work on these song's. This song definitely hits me in the feels. I can remember when this came out.
Thank you for bringing this song back to my mind. I was fourteen when it came out and everyone loved it. And then, two or three years later, Phil Collins suddenly became embarrassing. I don't know why. Maybe it was that he sounded 80s when Europe entered the Techno Decade. Listening to him now allows me to appreciate what a great artist he is.
There is something really amazing in the subtlety with which the buildup of the song and the expression in Phil Collins' singing goes - from this small, sad, introspective feeling to a more frustrated, almost angry, activating feel. You can almost not hear an actual difference in his singing but you still *feel* his emotions shift from sad to angry and that's just mind-blowing to me. Amazing song and great analysis, thank you 🙏🏻
In my opinion this is a stunning example of the emotion connected to the story of the song.💖💖
When music comes with a purpose. Phill Collins is a genius
Phil is one the greatest vocalists of all time. Absolutely amazing. every song, every time
Moving from the "She" and "He" articles, and over to the "You" half way through is just one of those really subtle touches that i absolutely live about this song. Might just be a silly observation but ive always liked that part.
The "...But Seriously" album (the black one) is filled with tracks like this, that have a profound meaning to them and that are just so beautifully executed. I love it so much.
Phil Collins is an amazing artist from every aspect. His voice is godlike, he is such a great drummer, performer on stage, songwriter, you name it. A really rare talent
I forgot about this song. It was one of my favorites as a kid. Thank you for the walk down memory lane.
Emotion is something Mr. Collins can handle so well, yet so honestly. You can hear and feel it. A master musician. To add to your respect, besides his work in supporting charities, he collected money at his concerts where he sang this and match it. He gave it to a homeless shelter in the town in which he sang. Love this video and how intimate it is. Phil looks so good here and his attention to detail is legendary. He was a music producer. He also graduated from a drama school in London. The man is vastly under-estimated.
Both he and Genesis had a very humanistic world view and the themes running through their music are deep. They are excellent at uniting music, lyrics and feelings into a whole that few can equal. He never promotes himself, but always the music. Peter Gabriel (also of Genesis) has spent his life supporting causes that help people. Early Genesis is so good. Please indulge.
Love your message of caring and understanding. Giving to support agencies may seem distant but it is the best way to get help where needed. I can't bring myself to give directly because I am unsure of the 'head space' of the individual and whether my 'aid' is going to something constructive or supporting a destructive lifestyle. Mental health is an area that needs far more support!
I was 8 when this song came out, and it was a gut punch even at that young of an age. Where I live now, we have a community "fridge" which is actually a covered fridge and shelving unit. On the shelves there are labeled tote bins - toiletries, hats & mittens, dried and canned foods, etc. Community members and groups donate food items and necessities (milk, fully assembled meals, fresh fruit & veggies, etc to the fridge & freezer, and dried goods and personal items in the bins), and anyone is welcome to come grab something they're in need of at any time. Does it sometimes get abused? Likely.. but it also legitimately helps. If folks can't donate their stuff, they donate their time to keep the fridge and shelves clean, take out the garbage that accumulates in the bin next to it, etc.