🧙 The Murder Mystery in Fire and Blood you missed
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 13 ก.ย. 2024
- Long ago on Dragonstone, Androw Farman staged a Westeros horror story on Dragonstone and planned to make his wife Queen Rhaena Targaryen his seventh victim. But these actions seemed out of the unimpressive Androw's abilities to pull off alone. Who in the realm wanted a Targaryen Queen and her court gone from their home of Dragonstone and had resources and will to make it happen? Puzzle out the mystery of the horror story on Dragonstone with JoeMagician.
MaddieKayRay: / maddiekayray
Poll: forms.gle/WZRQ...
Subscribe: bit.ly/2EBHniX
Twitter: bit.ly/2ESrfJp
Patreon: bit.ly/2HQ6cVd
Instagram: bit.ly/2Mao9Bd
Questions: AskJoeMagician@gmail.com
Audible Free Trial link: audibletrial.co...
Amazon Affiliate Links:
Buy Fire and Blood: amzn.to/2UH4yQd
Buy A Game of Thrones book 1: amzn.to/2DoDACZ
Buy A Song of Ice and Fire: amzn.to/2D2rwal
Buy Game of Thrones Seasons 1-7: amzn.to/2UF0xvG
Grand Maesters:
Steven Stark, Grand Maester of Dragon lore. Here be Dragons
Sue the Fury, Grand Mistress of Whispers
Archmaesters:
Nessie the Questing Beast and Archmaseter Valyrian Tinfoil
Erin M, Executive Assisstant of the Slack
Brynden B Fish: Right Farter of the Fandom Truth
Kasey D
Leathery Wings
MaesterMerry
Notacast
Lady Shar, Mother of Dragonflies
ZombieJesus
Maesters:
Adrianna A
Crowfoods Daughter
Amber G
Axey
Bill F
Faceless Man
Growltiger
Heather B
Ivan T
John the Elfstone, High King of Gondor and the North
Julie beth of tarth
Lady Kaffee Stark, Curator of the Winterfell Glass Gardens, Cultivator of the Winter Roses
Lady Elaine Fairchild
Liam M
Lone Stark state
Sanrixian, Mother of Drawgons
Ser Small Paul
Yohann A
Music:
Lord of the Land by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommon...)
Source: incompetech.com....
Artist: incompetech.com/
Air Prelude by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommon...)
Source: incompetech.com...
Artist: incompetech.com/
Dark Times by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommon...)
Source: incompetech.com...
Artist: incompetech.com/
Classic Horror - Madness Paranoia by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommon...)
Source: incompetech.com...
Artist: incompetech.com/
Spy Glass Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
creativecommons...
Faceoff by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommon...)
Source: incompetech.com...
Artist: incompetech.com/
Intro music: Manuel Senfft www.tagirijus.de
Tagirijus - Hidden Castle
Art:
Fire and Blood by George R.R. Martin
The World of Ice and Fire by George R.R. Martin
The Lands of Ice and Fire by George R.R. Martin
Fantasy Flight Games
Doug Wheatley / wheatley_doug
Magali Villenueve www.magali-vill...
A Wiki of Ice and Fire awoiaf.westero...
HBO Game of Thrones and History and Lore
Sanrixian sanrixian.com/en/
#GameOfThrones #asongoficeandfire #houseofthedragon #got
I loved the video! I always thought it odd how Andrews story ended, not that he grew so bitter, but how capable he suddenly turned. Only thing I am not sure about is that almost all these ideas are made for political reasons. Sometimes it is personal. But Jahayres personality seamed to have hardened with age, you see that in the way he treated his younger children and how he increasingly got into arguments with his wife and seemingly distanced himself from her. Thanks for making me reconsider my views
One thing I think about him is his name. conciliator. That's not the kind, the good, the great, etc. It just means he solves problems. Sometimes problems he creates or makes worse. Like for instance, his relationship with Rhaena is probably what informed his strained his relationships with women in his life and his dedication to keeping them out of power. That when he was young, he felt emasculated by Rhaena and had to work against her to keep his throne and transferred that to his children who resembled her personality.
@Canadian Alison Yes, also it's the same maquiavellian(? I don't know how to write that, sorry) puzzle that GRRM asks us all over the series.
What's the life of a boy against a kingdom? It's everything.
@@paolabruno4437 Which leads us to the next question: what do our answers to these questions say about us all?
@@JoeMagicianjehaerys wasn't dedicated to keeping women out of power he was literally the only king in the history of Westeros to give them any kind of power or help them out, but such is life if you give someone 10000$ they'll cuss you out for not giving them your house and clothes too.
@alisonsheep many who hate rhaegar, sympathise with saera which is pretty hypocritical.
Honestly if you read about saera you wouldn't feel sorry for her, she was straight up a psychopath and was comfortable getting her father k*lled, why would he have any affection for someone like this, she destroyed the lives of two young girls and was always very cruel and heartless.
When you first brought up Jaeherys as a possible culprit I thought there was no way that wise old King Jaeherys would do something so despicable, but by the end I'm almost convinced that it was in fact done on his orders. If nothing else he is at least a very strong candidate. Well done!
*checks box* mission accomplished. Glad you enjoyed!
it would be so GRRM for jaeherys to be a murdering scumbag based on how everyone loves him.
@Angeal zeal yeah but the honorable Jaehaerys planning to kill his own sister by poison that littlefinger levels of scummy. Plus in fire and blood alot of people who had beef with Jaehaerys happens to drop dead mysteriously. I'm pretty convinced that if everyone loves and respects a historical figure there probably a monster. Look at raehgar's actions and why people think he's so great.
@Angeal zeal wasn’t she just doing her thing on Dragonstone by that time? She calmed down.
The histories present him as a wise old king. He still did some pretty stupid stuff though.
I think you missed one particular candidate… Elissa Farman.
She was resentful of being stuck on Dragonstone after having asked Rhaena to leave and being repeatedly denied.
She and Androw were extremely close.
She was an experienced sailor and had in fact gone to Braavos after fleeing Dragonstone. Someone that worldly and always wanting to explore elsewhere would have been researching other parts of the world such as the Free Cities if their long term plan was to build a fleet there then travel the world.
Selling the dragon eggs to the Sea Lord of Braavos would have given her funds to pay for the Tears of Lys in addition to funding her voyage.
The limits here would have been opportunity, as no one officially knew where she was or what she was doing, but she could have found a way to pass instructions and the Tears through a cut-out to Androw.
If it went through multiple cut-outs, one could be Princess Aerea, who had wanted to go with Elissa on her journey but was forbidden by her mother. It would also potentially explain why she subsequently claimed Balereon and disappeared, as yet another opportunity to leave Dragonstone had fallen through.
Yes, Elissa and Rhaena were likely lovers and very close, but Elissa had long term plans that Rhaena was forbidding her from going through with simply because she thought she couldn’t bear to be without her.
The main point against this is that Elissa was in hiding while constructing Sun Chaser and that sending someone to kill Rhaena would have left loose ends that could have been tied back to her. And they were already pissed at her over the eggs… being complicit in murders that threatened members of the royal family would have gotten Jaeharys to step up Rago Draz’ efforts to find her.
Those dragon eggs she stole are probably the ones that ended up being gifts to Daenerys! I'd bet on it
They were in the private menagerie of the Sea Lord of Bravos, and later sold to Mopatis, the man who housed Dani and Viserys, when they fled Dragonstone.
Time is a flat circle.
@@nikkishears6402 thats a theory but we dont know forsure.
@@kiddbuu5178 , it's from Mopatis himself. It's not a theory. It's either the truth or a lie.
@@nikkishears6402 when did he say he got them from the sealord?
Damn, her reading of that Lysa passage was extremely well done.
Maddie is great
@@JoeMagician No kidding, this is going on my best content on YT playlist.
@@JoeMagicianWho is wearing the gimp suit?
I feel almost bad for Lysa with how good this reading is, it is like perfect
Androw truly was a perfect fall guy it was the perfect close book case a jaded psuedo lover who was being mocked and shamed by the whole village along with his sister being a treacherous thief that left her own brother to face the consequences of her actions.
I'd say Androw's brother, Franklyn Farman, is more likely than first appearances would indicate. He was Lord of Fair Isle, thus likely had more connections than his brother and more means to purchase the poison, and would have had the time and opportunity to communicate with Androw to a) convince him to commit tehse crimes and b) send him the poison. He also had a bone to pick with Rhaena specifically. To be able to convince someone like Androw to commit these crimes it would have had to have been people he trusted enough to convince him and help him, which his brother could have been.
This content is SO underrated especially in an age where very silly clickbaity videos get millions of likes. It's like a mini novel within a very minor sub plot. So many hours would've gone into putting all of this together. This is absolutely incredible work!
Such a well constructed video!! I never considered this as a whodunit, but, MAN, _NOTHING_ can be taken for granted in Fire & Blood!
Chapeau 👏
GRRM says a good man doesn't always make a good king. Jahaerys is considered one of, if not the best king. What does that say about him as a person?
@serdownofhousebad1127 Yep. The best rulers listen to the advice of others, I still believe Jaeherys was a good ruler(and person) on his own, but the sheer heights his rule reached was a team effort.
The only times they ever clashed on a problem was when they had to confront the ugly fact that their society is built around the suppression of women…
I really enjoyed this. I liked the style you did it, the murder mystery thing. Good job.
It was a new thing, glad to hear you enjoyed it! Playing with the music was the most fun part, trying to match the mood of the quotes and what I was saying.
@@JoeMagician Yeah it definitely was effective and I didn't even realize how effective until you mentioned that you'd done it. Which, imo, means you've done a really good job with it. Plus I know that HoW has done analysis and stuff of the Targaryen book, but I havent seen a ton of vids getting into the minutia of it like this. Glad you're back btw. :)
Androw reminds me of LittleFinger in his lack of “typically male” interests and skills. He “plays up”how non-threatening he is to deceive those he wants to take vengeance on
YES!
Great point
My first thought was, that this is usualy a feminin revange plot or typ of crime
I think Baelish is far cleverer, with Androw it sounded like he had nothing going on in his head beyond the most base desires. You are right about both having to rely less on masculine qualities to survive though.
but the thing his, he apparently lacks any kind of interests and skills, not just typicly male ones.
U miss the obvious suspect, Elissa Farnam herself. Whatever love between her and Rheana was long gone, from Elissa's pov at least, and she knew Rheana would hunt her to the ends of the earth. Elissa never hesitated to use and abuse her brother, and if she did harbor a secret guilt then what better way to alleviate it than to facilitate his revenge. If you're Elissa what better way to ensure your getaway than to murder the one person guaranteed to chase you.
How would she have done it, where did she get the poison from, how did she avoid detection when everyone was on the hunt for her?!
@@SingingSealRianashe had an entire crew of sells words and cutthroats, can't be hard to achieve especially if she stumbled across a faceless man.
@@lillypharaoh5945one doesn’t just ‘stumble across a faceless man.’ 😂
@@carastone3473 not literally no
This sweet summer child is happy
Franklin Farman, he hated her the MOST. Rhaena took advantage of his little brother and wouldn’t leave his little sister alone. Frankie could have had secret correspondence with Androw because no one was paying attention to what Andy was doing, anyways.
Someone literate would have had to have been a go-between, because I believe Andrew was illiterate.
Definitely one of my favorite storylines in Fire And Blood. Thank you!
I agree that there some very funny things going on at Dragonstone while Rhaenea was there. I think your close but off the mark. Most likely it was actually Allysane who might have been behind it. On a personal level she loved Dragonstone most of all and was likely not happy with what her sister was doing with the place. I think she aided Ellissa in stealing the dragon eggs. Remember that the deal Septon Barth reach with Bravos fixed the financial crisis once and for all. In other words the Iron Thorne benefited most from the theft. Ellissa got a ship, one ship and the money to finance her expedition with help from the Redwynes. The question is who'd be more willing to trade those eggs for money to fix the countries finances, Allysane or Jahaerys? Allysane would in my mind if she had assurances the eggs would not be hatched. Its telling that the eggs went through Driftmark and then Pentos before getting to Bravos. I also feel that Jahaerys and Rhaenea almost got along, it was Alysanne who fought with her. I disagree that Rhaenea was ever a target for the poison. You fail to mention it but the younger Maester who was stabbed in the back, not killed in a struggle but stabbed in the back, was the likely supplier of the poison. It comes down to whether you think it was Jahaerys or Alysanne. My ideas about this are too long to really get into but I think it was Alysanne. Another thing to keep in mind is that the Targaryeans likely had a glass candle at this point. Its hard to believe they would've been dependent on informers for all their information all though the existence of such a thing is never mentioned in the book.
I think the idea is that Androw was underestimated, even by history. So the fact that these murders indicate a capability at odds with the picture history paints of him reflects more of the failure of history than a conspiracy.
It is real curious where he got the poison, though. Maybe he made it himself; being illiterate doesn't _necessarily_ mean he wouldn't have the knowledge...
Martin knows that history doesn't actually repeat itself. However it frequently rhymes!
I always thought from the first time that I've read the books that it was Jahaerys, but now that you've suggested it , Rogar Baratheon is also a good option. But I still think that based on Androw wanting to go to King's Landing when Rogar wasn't there it is more probably Jahaerys
Every single time i hear some new lore about Jahaerys, Im blown away by how absolutely gangster yet noble he is.
Man was an OG.
(The hints that it's false in the text are great too, love this series 😂)
Thank you! Great video! I read your post about being demonetized, that’s so bizarre! I don’t see why this would be, it’s so informative and awesome! Great work Matt.
what a great journey to be taken on! thank you Jo!
just the little detail that he says "save my son" not child is oh so telling
I would not have disagreed with Rhaena feeding him to her dragon
@@JoeMagician me neither, one could have argued, that she was overreacting, reading sexism, where it was not intended, but that he did not even consider it could have been a girl . . . . it just totaly proved her point and I get why Rhaena was so bitter and angry all the time.
I feel like she gets a worse wrap then she deserves. The describtion of her as a child read like an introvert, not a mean kid, there was no allusion to her abusing the kids she was supposed to play with, she just prefered books and tend to hide from strangers.
When she for her castle, she pointed out she needed her own space, where she could ensure the safety of those she chose.
She sure as hell fucked up later on, by choseing a man she can treat the same way she felt treated, by messing up her kids upbringing, by antagonising a lot of people needlessly and all . . . . but she is not the mean bitch incarnet, a lot of her anger is valid and quite some male characters get a pass for similar behavior (the hound for example)
@@SingingSealRiana but the hound is cool af tho, dude got his face burnt😭
@@SingingSealRiana what I like about his story is he was treated exactly the way all lords treat their wives in this story. He was married off to a powerful family, but he had no power in his own home, nor did he have control over his wife, and he hated it. He learned first hand exactly how most ladies in Westeros feel, and it was so bad it pushed him to murder. Basically Grr Martin is pointing out how fragile the male ego is! Lol
@@taylorgayhart9497 Fragile? When Cersei was mistreated, she had ex with her brother, and produced bastards, if anything women are fragile. Also, he was emotionally abused.
Man, I want this story next if HotD does indeed become more of an anthology series, even more so than the conquest.
This is EXCELLENT. Exactly the ASOIAF content we need! Thanks for the hard work. A++
I always appreciate any take that points out how biased the accounts of Jahayres (and Alyssane, for that matter are in the histories). Not that I'd paint them as 100% villains or anything either, it's just that whenever I see the accounts we get of them as so perfectly good and wise presented as unvarnished, uncomplicated truth, well, it just kinda bugs me a little, since it's pretty clear the narratives we get presented in the histories are only one side of the story.
There is no such thing as a "good king" you can be good or efficient but never both in a position like that
I have always felt that Androw's failures were the result of laziness, not stupidity. He wasn't good at anything because he couldn't be bothered to try. I think he was quite capable of dreaming up the whole plot. But you are right that he would likely have needed help in acquiring the Tears to carry it out. What is most likely is that Androw, using the ex-commander of the garrison, got in touch with Draaz and Massey and they, out a misguided belief they were helping, assisted him. I doubt very much that Jaehaerys would murder his own sister, no matter what a pain in the neck she was. He had ample opportunities to have her disposed of. Not to mention Draaz, who could have done it far more effectively.
Yeah, bis problem was lazyness, but the mind only developes when used. Without reading and contacts he would not have knowen about the poison to beginn with.
I think he was used by people who felt they were doing Jaeherys' bidding. Might have been a "will no one rid me of this meddlesome priest" sort of situation.
@@aaronzegas5270 Draaz certainly seems like the sort of guy to think he was helping the king by murdering his sister
You felt but isn't the case.
You felt that way because you had no empathy for Androw.
Androw was a mentally disabled man who was likely abused and used maliciously throughout his life, you calling him lazy and dismissing any disadvantage he had makes it easy for you to justify your lack of empathy.
Don't make up crap, just admit that you lack empathy.
Channelling your inner Preston Jacobs here.
If Androw was a catspaw his loyalty to whoever used him was remarkable.
Glad we eventually got this video.
What was the problem?
Or the official record didn't record if he named anyone *puts on tinfoil hat*
No idea, youtube never told me why it was held up. They just approved it.
@@JoeMagician
Capricious, they are.
@@alanpennie8013 0
forgive me on the timeline, been a while since i read the books, so i might be mis-remembering the order of event chronologically.
Rogar is the only 1 i don't buy into having been the backer behind Androw & the poisoning . at the time of his wifes death, who he had cheated on (iirc) numerous times, gotten his wife with child after being told by Maesters that she couldn't bare anymore children. not long before that he had even betrayed, got caught out, then been forgiven and welcomed back into the Kings peace for his plots, scheming & subterfuge. after that i feel like he turned a new leaf.
i reckon he was cowed & significantly humbled by this point and let it pass as her mother had just died, + this she is a literal dragon queen. I seem to remember seeing Rogar in a positive light after all was said & done,, and liked his character despite his shortcomings
That's about right. My thought on Rogar's motive is that he really hates Rhaena and has a streak of mysoginy. When she threatened to Harrenhal him in his own hall, that would've been something he couldn't ignore and wanted revenge. Also the closeness in the text is interesting to me. We hear about that right before Androw's murders show up. Authors putting information like that back to back should make your eyebrows rise, that it was intentional Grrm wanted us to know Rhaena made an enemy of Rogar then Androw happens.
There was a bedding ceremony, attended by the Farman's liege lord Lannister, so yes. The marriage was consummated. The problem was that it was more or less a sham marriage. She was fond of Androw, but in love with his sister, very passionately at that. Odds are good she was like Aegon was with his sisters, 10 to 1, and Androw, that poor, simple fool did not know any better, but when Elissa deserted both him and Rhaena and Rhaena turned sour on him he went ahead and did what he had to did, cuz they had no kid
Where did you get from, that there was a bedding ceremony?
@@SingingSealRiana Fire and Blood, page 30
she used him as a beard so that she could in all but name marry his sister. its obvious.
I love this kind of content I hope you keep making these kind of vids!
Quality video here. As someone who has read fire and blood more than once there is still so much I didn’t realize until this.
great video btw, the narration, sound & background music is amazing. loved it
This is the first ASOIAF theory I've seen where all the options you presented are equally valid. Top tier video.
Great work!
Aww shucks
I really enjoyed your analysis and can almost hear you smiling as you narrate it. You made me think about re-reading F&B which I did not like much. Great mind!
Your videos are always so interesting and thought provoking! Thank you for making them!
Love the video!! All your videos are awesome imo.... Part of me always felt bad for Androw yeah he deserved what he got at the end but if he wouldn’t have killed anyone then his story would’ve been so sad. He did not deserve to be treated the way he was by the queen and her friends. I wonder if at first he knew his marriage was a scam or if he was tricked into marrying her thinking she loved him and his sister or something
It appears that Elissa was the glue holding the two of them together, and when she left neither Androw nor Rhaena had the emotional support systems to deal with that loss. So they turned on each other, although with Androw someone enabled his anger and put poison in his hands. It's a rough situation for all involved, and largely caused by the inheritance laws of Westeros. I don't think Androw was tricked, but rather he was hopeful that over time his feelings would be reciprocated despite Rhaena making it clear they weren't and it was a sham marriage.
@@JoeMagician Rhaena's role In this relationship falling apart is larger and rather cruel on her part.
I wonder if Androw knew he was a merkin and didn't care, because he liked the power and privileges that came with being married to the most powerful woman in the Seven Kingdoms. Or maybe he was just a sad sack and a mediocre fool who really thought the marriage was real and was just constantly humiliated.
This is no disease, this is....MMMMM-URDER!
-quote I wish someone would've said in the book
I think it was Alysanne!
Slut O'Crat exactly she’s just watching everything happen. Plus think about it, she held their mum’s hand through the “birth” of their youngest sister and Rhaena couldn’t even look at it but just blamed Rogar, which made Jaehaerys and everyone look bad
Why?
No. She can't be a suspect, she is a woman and women are moral beacons of light.
You make me grateful for this time to catch up and focus on things and people I love instead of feeling stuck and scared at home. Corona can kiss my....
Nothing like a good murder story in the end times!
As always great content from Joe Magician. Your videos are top of the line for deep thought and inquiry. Research and referenced passage flawless. Keep you the great work as always looking forward to seeing your next project. Thanks for the amazing content.
This would be an amazing movie or mini series
Even if it wasn't Jaehaerys himself who ordered the poisonings, someone on his council might have taken matters into their own hands.
"Won't someone rid me of this troublesome sister?"
@@JoeMagician Henry II
Wouldn't her fight with Rogar make it more necessary for her to be around for Jahaerys? She constantly shows him in a better light, makes his wife a better claimant than Rhaena, and she is easily dismissed considering that everyone including her husband disliked her. Jahaerys should have been bummed if she had died because it would have brought critics from her to him. Plus he seems too smart to make a plan that would even have a chance at failing. Which being overly vindictive would have been.
The amount of risk in using Androw Farman as an assassin is definitely an issue with it. Although I doubt anyone expected Androw to get so carried away and kill her court as well. They would've wanted him to kill the maester to ensure he can't save Rhaena then Rhaena as well. The quarantine could have been a measure to make sure no one went there to stop Androw before he got to Rhaena.
But by the same token, Littlefinger took a big risk too using Lysa to kill Jon Arryn rather than a faceless man or another professional. Perhaps money was an issue in hiring someone, and they figured Androw could pull off dropping poison into two goblets not the six he did.
@@JoeMagician I mean if he was best buddies with the guard then wouldn't have been better to use him than the clearly weird unstable guy who had a weird grudge against her? But using Lyssa makes much more sense to me, she was totally in for whatever little finger wanted. Farman was a wildcard. Jahaerys just seemed much cleaner than having such big deal in the hands of someone he absolutely shouldn't have trusted.
@@lanestapp2 that's one reason I like rogar for it. His other plots were similarly poorly thought out or relied on a lot of risk. Coryanne Wylde, trying to kidnap Rhaella and Aerea. He would think this was a good plan.
@@JoeMagician He was clever enough that he might be successful, but not clever enough for it to work. Plus he always left a trail of obvious rumors.
@@JoeMagician
For a supposed master mind Littlefinger took some extraordinary risks at the beginning of the story. Lucky he had GRRM looking out for him.
I finished this chapter earlier today, didn't think about it too much until I stumbled on this vid! Jaeherys was one of my suspects, but I thought no he wouldn't right? But you've convinced me! It's also awfully convenient that Jaeherys had ships at the ready and ordered a quarantine and wanting the 'sickness' to fully play out instead of wanting to get his own family off the island
I never realized the high tension between Jaehaerys and Rhe, sheesh
Great video! I never thought about their relationship in that way. Interesting the situations that come up in terms of power and hard things that might need to be done.
This era would make great tv. Awesome video!
I definitely think baratheon was behind it. While jahearys would be interesting, him intervening and ending up saving her life doesn’t really make sense if he supplied tears of lys to make sure it was unnoticed, he wouldn’t have needed to bring in an expert either. Although it doesn’t really seem to fit rogars style to poison, she threatened to burn him and his family alive after his wife just died. I think he would’ve thought she needed to die by any means, and he couldn’t exactly attack the kings sister
Great video!
Too kind :)
"Merrett Frey wrote a mathematics textbook." HAHA
I think Jaehaerys knew something about Androw's plan before It happened.
As a Rhaena stan and “what if Jaehaerys was a terrible person actually” truther i love this
The young rheana did not sound mean, just introverted
Wow! This was great! I’m going to have to re-read F&B.
It's a good time, Kinda confusing on the first read through but once you get a handle on reading through the bias it's a lot more fun and interesting.
I immediately thought Lord Lannister.
I think he pulled it off alone. He didn’t have to come up with the plan himself, he just had to overhear it one day. Then he plots, whether it’s gathering money slowly or finding where he can steal the tears on Dragonstone. Finally, one day he has enough OR he’s had enough, and he spikes their drinks knowing no one would think twice about him serving wine.
Where and how stole he the poison when it was not on dragons tone and who would have conviniently talked about the poison plot for him to overhear?
Is this how the 3 eggs ended up with Ilyrio in Essos?
Yes. The ones Elissa stole end up with Dany.
Awesome video Joe. Compiled useful and interesting information for a book that is hard to digest for a lot of people. Really enjoyed this video mate.
Much appreciated!
Very good analysis.
Amazing video
Thank you!
the fact that the Pentoshi Hand (i forget his name) goes "definitely wasn't me though" does make him sound a bit suspicious huh. also Jahaerys has been shown to not be THAT keen of women's rights either, even trying to shut down Alysanne's plans on occasion only to have men then convince him it's a good thing actually. and then the way he treated and disowned his kids. When Aerea was heir he paid no attention to her either, he never intended to have her crowned. i think maybe he found the idea of Rhaena (or her only offspring being women) being crowned offensive: it IS because of him that the whole firstborn son succession rather than firstborn child is now a thing, he socially set that precedent for the rest of the lords and ladies. sure he did a lot of good, but Alysanne still had to fight for the few reforms for women's rights she made happen.
My previous comment was in jest, but what if The Lions of CastlyRock, the Storm Lord and The King were all part of it, the Lannisters provided the gold for the poison, Jarheys actually gets the poison (indirectly) and Rogar gets the poison and the know how to Andro...
I will grant it's a lot of moving parts, but perhaps they all played a hand in the murders on Dragonstone
Awesome video! I'm betting on Jahayres, especially since self-destruction seems to be a theme with house Targaryen.
Just ordered fire and blood and should be here any day now so I'll save this video for later. No spoilers.
His sister, perhaps...? She snuck out of dragon stone, why couldn't she sneak back in? She obviously had a beef with the princess, plus the added motive of distracting the targaryens from searching for her...along with a lifetime of experience manipulating Andrew.
Cause she was busy going on her travel around the world? Why waste the money she needed for her ship on the tears of lys? Why risk getting caught when she had everything she needed to be free?
Ok, I’m totally loving your videos and history
The person who was truly behind that whole operation was Androw Fahrman's sister. It was part of Elissa Fahrman's plan all along......
How?
You're wrong, it was Starks of Winterfell, the Kings of Winter, sounding the alarm that 'Winter is Coming'.... I jest
Please more Rhaena Targaryen 😍😍😍
I love this story so much because it flips the whole "woman scorned" idea you normally see. Its actually pretty sad that he was so twisted over such a long period of time that he decided to just go on a murder spree.
Somehow, it's made more depressing coming from a dude. Maybe it's because it's so different?
It's something that's a lot more common in real life than fiction. "Woman scorned" is a trope in media, but men who feel scorned romantically accounts for a massive amount of violence against women. Beatings, murders, physical attacks. In some countries men will throw acid on the faces of women who rejected them. In a very depressing way, Androw's attack is a very common one in our real world and something that women live with every day as they try to mitigate the chances that some rejected man will get violent in response.
@@JoeMagician Yep. The most dangerous time for a woman in an abusive relationship is when she finally leaves (if she's still alive). Of course this isn't to say that men do not suffer domestic violence, it's just a much more common thing for women to suffer physical violence from male partners or rejected suitors.
@@made-line7627 its more talked about not more common
The woman spurned is such a weird trope given its prominence and just how much more likely it is for a woman to get hurt or killed by a spurned lover then the other way around.... The statistic is insane and depressing, but sure, women are the crazy murderers
@@connorhicks1712 not true. Just like with sexual harrasment and voilance, women are disproportionately more often the victim and men the aggressors and the level of how bad it is tends to be way higher, that's just a fact. You are absolutely right, that there is gianormous amount of men who never report, but there is also a big amount of women who never report and the chasim is to big for it to come out as equal in the end. You can twist the numbers on how often one gets hit, or sexual harassment but not of homocide!
I would not argue, that women are inherintly better for it though, but if you are physicly inferior it is plainly way harder to pull of that level of voilance.
You'd think the Maesters serving at least the High Lords and Royal family would be required to know the effects of the Tears of Lys poison since it's so dangerous and primarily used on high nobles and royals.
It wouldn't be hard to send Maesters to Lys to learn about it. Unless of course, it's a closely guarded secret which is what I assume. At that point, have Maesters who are the most experienced in it to teach others. May not stop the poison from being used but it'd at least be identified earlier to cross out a pandemic and remedied (if there's even an antidote, lol).
That was awesome
What are some of the other mysterious deaths you alluded to that occur during Jaehaerys rise to power?
Maegor was the first one, with him found dead on the throne. Then Septon Moon outside of Oldtown. I gave the quote where Lord Massey suggested hiring assassins for Septon Mattheus. I can't remember off the top of my head, but there was a lot of lucky breaks for the young king.
@@JoeMagician
Was it the maesters' doing do you think?
23:06 Dear HBO . Basically, give me awesome character moments/ dialog like this, and House of the Dragon will be incredible
I named my daughter Rayna Daenerys. I thought I was naming her after Daenerys Targaryen, never knew she had an ancestor named Rhaena..wow
Wow great video! I felt bad for Andrew while reading Fire & Blood as at first it just seemed like he was a nice enough guy who helped out a friend in her hour of need--ie keeping Rhaena from another political marriage that she didn't want--and acting as a wing-man for his sister. Only to then be treated as Rhaena's whipping boy because her life didn't go as she planned. That obviously ended when we got to the whole murder plot thing.
If this was Jaeherys' plan, the one hitch I'm seeing was killing the other girls on Fair Isle. If you want to hide the deaths as an epidemic, the other people need to die, or at least get very sick with the same symptoms as I think people would notice if no one else came down with this 'disease'. Which would explain the maester but... I don't buy Jaeherys ordering the poisonings of the other people as well. After all, the Hand of the King's NIECE was there, and other nobles whose only real crime was their proximity to his troublesome sister. Even if he only ordered Andrew to give them smaller doses so they'd get symptoms but not die, that is an incredibly risky move.
Although like you said it could just have been Andrew going off script, as he was JUST supposed to kill the maester and Rhaena.
Great in depth theory
The least based man in Westeros💪
Man....hearing that rendition of Lysa's rant to Petyr B gave me a near attack of female-related PTSD
I see some people trying to demonise Androw bu saying he was just mediocre and lazy to justify the decades of mistreatment and abuse at the hands of Rhaena but this 4:36 clearly proves he was mentally disabled.
Even if he were lazy, he could have atleast left the gates and had more freedom.
Yesss finally a good story teller❤ 👍
I vote spurned lions. Great video!
Who were Area and her twin's (Baela?) father?
Aerea and Rhaella's father was her first husband's, Aegon.
I find it funny how the targaryens are described as solving all their problems with incest and polygamy, but their whole reign in fire and blood has them doing exactly not that.
Jaherys could have married rhaena and had her run the dragon program. Make her a proper queen following in visenya's footsteps
Will it be worse than The Night Fort?!
Nothing is worse than the Night Fort
Ramsay's private chambers?
Honestly I'm not sure it was any of them it might be it really was just Androw acting by himself
Great theory!
A weasel in the bowels helped him.. also known as a maester
Which one, the one he poisoned?
Baratheon!!
Nice one, bud. 💗
Maddie really selling that Rhaena eh?
Could Rhaena have gotten Tears of Lys? A convenient death and she is queen regent.
Lickspittle husband comes across vial tests it on a few then pours some into the maestre to finish him first possibly to silence him from saying your husband asked what is this Tears vial? By then Rhaena is on guard and protects herself from Tears of Lys. So husband confesses when caught out?
This video got me thinking that Elissa Farman stealing eggs that might have already been *petrified* was part of Jaehaerys' plan to humiliate Rhaena, and also those eggs wouldn't have been a threat to his reign.
Oh interesting, I like that take too
Really doesn't make any sense. How would removing three unborn dragons change the fact that Dragonstone is home to like 5+ living breathing dragons that Rhaena could still use to challenge his reign? Not only that but half of Joe's reasoning as to why Jaehaerys would be driven to kinslaying (completely out of character by all accounts of Jae we've gotten) is because Rhaena lost those eggs to begin with, so the logic becomes circular if we accept that Jae also ordered the eggs to be stolen.
Feel like ppl are giving Joe's Jaehaerys theory a lot more credit than it deserves. It doesn't really hold up under any amount of scrutiny.
I think Andrew just blacked out and had a moment of genius to come up with the plot, just like Frank the Tank from "Old School".
Everytime I hear this voice I think of the actor from SNL with the pretty mouth..... She does the bubble bath scene. Someone tell me they know what I'm talking about
Feels like they asked for it . I would feel bad for him, but it seems he got his . No need to feel anything for the situation. But intrigued.
Very good telling of the tale.
💚