Both China and Russia had their struggles. The battle of stalingrad was so deadly that other ww2 battles were considered stalingrads whenever the casualties were high. But if we combine the casualties of changsha, it’s bloody as stalingrad
@@vincentxu4709The losses in the battles in Changsha are definitely far behind the battle of Stalingrad. The Chinese army suffered around 180,000 casualties in the four battles, including the Yichang offensive. The IJA 11th army suffered 4,000-5,000 casualties in the first battle, 7,000 casualties in the second battle, and 7,000-8,000 casualties in the third. I'm not sure about the losses in the fourth battle, but it should number in the thousands at most. The battle of Shanghai is still more bloody than all four battles of Changsha combined.
In fact, the Chinese Communist Party rarely participated in the war against Japan. They mainly developed their strength secretly in non-war areas. The Chinese Kuomintang took the responsibility of resistance. After the end of World War II, the Chinese Communist Party immediately defeated the battered Kuomintang.
Come on, you can see how absurd your words are if you look at the Japanese forces in the frontal battlefield and the guerrilla battlefield behind enemy lines in the middle and late period of the war.
At the same time, do you know the composition of communist party and the Kuomintang army? Do you know the process of civil war in China in detail? Learn more about history.😅
China failed in the battle, but succeeded in strategy. The Battle of Shanghai prevented China from being destroyed as quickly as France in the all-out war with Japan. China turned Japan's envisioned blitzkrieg into a protracted war. After the outbreak of the Pacific War, at least 50% of the Japanese army was trapped in the Chinese battlefield and was not withdrawn to fight the Allied forces in the Pacific battlefield. This is the contribution made by China (Republic of China) to the victory of the Second World War!
@@liuyiyang1996 In the west, we are all taught that America won WW2, it's shown in all our media, films, video games, schools and many books. However over the last decade many in the west have realized and accepted that America was a sideshow in Europe and that Russia did the heavy lifting to beat Germany. American's coped by saying, "well at least we still have the pacific theater". And now we find out the Sino Japanese War was absolutely huge and took up 80% of all Japan's resources, it's beginning to look like America was just a sideshow in the pacific too lol. America was just a sideshow to the entire war who turned up late and took all the credit.
Because the "Shanghai Concession" was a colony, many foreigners lived there, and if something like the Stalingrad had happened, the "Shanghai Massacre" would have been widely publicized instead of the Nanjing.
@@KijbyThe battle of Wuhan was claimed to be the deadliest and bloodiest battle in the Second Sino Japanese war, but it’s not recognized nor consider “The Chinese Stalingrad”
You’re the one who is brainwashed. You guys been loving Small Japan since from the start of 1912-2024, and you think the PRC citizens have been brainwashed? If we were brainwashed then the Chinese would be racist towards foreigners in their country
02:01 as far as i understand, we are talking about the The Battle of Shanghai - 1937 and in this year the M1 "Bazooka" (first appeared from 1942(!)) looks more than out of place!
The Chinese believed that if they surrounded and provoked the Shanghai Naval Landing Force, Japanese reinforcements would attack from the center of Shanghai and Chinese would repel the reinforcements with pillboxes and heavy machine guns. However, reinforcements of the Japanese army landed at from the north coast of Shanghai, therefore the Japanese landing changed the main Shanghai battlefield. By confining many foreigners to the Shanghai concession and making the battlefield the "outskirts of Shanghai," the Japanese military likely intended to hide the atrocities.
No, Japan had already invaded China in North China in 1937, and the war had already begun. The Nationalist government attacked Shanghai to attract the strategic direction of the Japanese army to the coast, to prevent the Japanese army from encircling China from the west like the Mongols did. It was to exchange space for time, and at the same time, as a Chinese, I was grateful for the help of the United States.
@@yuansishen I guess that’s hindsight.” Chiang Kai-shek declared the recovery of the ``Shanghai Concession'' with the political purpose of clearing up Chinese past shames. And Chiang Kai-shek wanted first chinese victory no matter what. He hoped for a major victory by annihilating the 6,000 sailors defending the Shanghai Concession with 70,000 Kuomintang soldiers. However, that plan collapsed when the 40,000-man Shanghai Expeditionary Force successfully landed on the north coast of Shanghai.
@@ステラリスおじさん You may not understand the situation at that time. In fact, since Japan began to invade Northeast China in 1931, Chiang Kai-shek has been preparing to deal with Japan's attack on inland China. He may not be a good politician, but he is an outstanding military strategist. He knows that there is no possibility of winning the battle with the Japanese army in Shanghai, because the firepower of a Japanese warship is better than the sum of all Chinese warships at that time. But if Japan follows the original plan to encircle China from the west of China along the Mongolian attack route in the 13th century, then China will definitely fail. Therefore, changing the direction of the Japanese army's attack, retreating to the mountainous areas in western China, and waiting for the international community, especially the United States and Britain to join in, is the only way for China to survive. Finally, I believe that there will never be a war between China and Japan, nor with any other country. Everyone can live like real neighbors, drink beer together, and talk about girls together
I definitely agree that WW2 started in 1937 and not 1939 which is a western centric date. Though you can also kinda argue it started in 1935 or 1936 with Abyssinia and Spanish Civil War, considering Abyssinian War basically reignited in WW2 anyways with the underrepresented East African Theater of WW2. Meanwhile Spanish Civil War had Germany trying out all it's new tactics and weapons there, as well as Italy and the Soviets and even many Brits went to fight there and that war lasted till 1939. You also have Khalkin Gol which really should be included in WW2 as it's Japan vs Soviets and it started only a few months before WW2 and went right into WW2 and finished up while Poland was midway through it's invasion. In fact the Soviet army went straight from Khalkin Gol right into Poland without a single days break.
The first ten days-arguably the most important as it was the only chance for the Chinese to dislodge the Japanese defenders-were fought solely by IJN and its ground forces. IJA didn't arrive until August 23 and even then their focus was more on the suburbs. The urban fighting in Shanghai's densest districts such as Zhabei was mostly by SNLF.
Thank you so much for doing my favourite battle of WW2. Chinese-Singaporean here! 🇸🇬 Even though it is just a video game simulation, i can tell you did your research put alot of effort into it and tried to make it as accurate as possible! May i request: Wolfenstein Germany vs Imperial japan? (Maybe after Hitler took over the world, he decided to turn on his allies or smth)
유비, 징기스칸은 민심장악과 대의명분, 프로파간다를 중시 했지. 징기스칸은 전쟁시작전에 퍼포먼스로 산위에 올라가 하늘에 대고 적군의 부당함과 아군의 정당성을 호소했다고 해. 독일군에게 훈련받은 장개석의 친위대가 일본군과 대등하게 싸우면서 강력한 방어전을 펼쳤지. 그러자 일본군은 몽골군이 했던 도성작전을 해서 중국군의 의지를 꺽으려 했어. 마치 요즘의 푸틴처럼. 푸틴이 체첸에서 이 방식으로 효과를 볼 수 있었던 건 사우디가 같은 이슬람인 체첸을 끝없이 지원해 주지 못했기 때문이야. 마치 지금 미국나토가 우크라이나를 지원하듯이...간지가 말한 대동아공영권의 핵심기술은 각국의 독립성을 유지시켜주고 산업화를 이룬뒤 일본이 아시아의 맹주가 된다는 것인데 이것을 잘 실천했으면 미소냉전에서 소련의 위치를 일본이 할 수 있었겠지. 하지만 현실은 상하이 전투후에 도성작전으로 난징대학살을 자행하고 3.1절 대학살, 마닐라대학살 기타등등... 이런 형태로는 민심장악이 힘들지. 목택동이나 홍수전, 삼국지의 오두미도, 일본전국시대의 일향종처럼 민중들에게 뭔가 이익을 잘 베풀어 줄 필요가 있어. 삼국지의 오두미도와 일본전국시대의 일향종은 현대에도 그 명맥을 유지하고 있다고 하네.
Japan mistakenly invaded China🇹🇼 due to the instigation of militarists, but in the end China did not lose any territory because of Japan. The Russians have been expanding for hundreds of years and still occupy a large amount of land. China and Japan can be friends, and Russia can also be a friend if it returns the land.
@Yuaretrash The CCP is the product of the Soviet Union's ideological invasion of China, and now the Chinese people are being enslaved by the Soviet ghost.The Chinese people, controlled by the ghost of communism, are waiting for the Kuomintang🇹🇼 to liberate them.
@Yuaretrash The CCP is the product of the Soviet Union's ideological invasion of China, and now the Chinese people are being enslaved by the Soviet ghost.
@@Yuaretrash The CCP is the product of the Soviet Union's ideological invasion of China, and now the Chinese people are being oppression by the Soviet ghost.
The entire Second Sino-Japanese War actually began with Japan's invasion of Manchuria during the Mukden Incident in 1931. Throughout the war, the contributions of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) were minimal, largely due to the "7-2-1" strategy. This strategy allocated 70% of their efforts to expanding their own power, 20% to dealing with the Nationalists, and only 10% to resisting Japan. As a result, the war was almost entirely fought by the Republic of China under the leadership of the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT). Many in the West have been misled by Communist propaganda, mistakenly believing that the war was fought by the CCP, which is a grave and foolish misconception.
Yep, i’ve noticed that in Chinese war movies that the Kuomintang troops have old ww1 German equipment and not any current 1937 German equipment, even when it was 1940 and yet i never see any changes of the Kuomintang army and their equipments
China is no match for Japan. China only had infantry weapons, yet Japan had the support of the Navy, Airforce and artilary. The few tanks that China owned, weren't even protected by the infantry. Infantry and tanks supposed to depend on one another.
Chiang Kai shek ordered the retreat too hastily; resulted in a total capitulation of the Chinese defense force in Shanghai, sending it into a chaotic retreat. The concrete fortified Hindenburg line which was constructed with German assistance in the 1930s to protect Nanjing was totally abandoned by the retreating Chinese. Which was a shame.
The Japanese army knew about the trenches, and they deliberately took detours to avoid them. Therefore, the main force did not attack from Shanghai, but landed from the north coast of Shanghai.
The problem is that Chiang Kai Shek should have authorized the retreat in early October as was planned. However, the League of Nations announced that they would hold a conference to talk about ending the war while President Roosevelt gave a speech in support of China right before Chiang Kai Shek is about to do so. Thus, he instead ordered the freshly-arrived Sichuan and Guangxi armies alongside his exhausted Central and Guangdong armies to launch a massive counterattack. The 10-day counterattack resulted in very heavy losses for the Chinese and Iwane Matsui immediately ordered an offensive after, causing multiple defence lines to be breached as the those had been disrupted by the initial counterattack.
@@CentCent69-zv8vq The order of the retreat was not issued properly. There were plans for certain Chinese units to perform rearguard actions to cover the retreats of other Chinese forces. However, some units were informed of the retreat, while other units were kept in the dark. Some divisions only realized that there is a general withdraw when they saw adjacent divisions began to withdraw. This created panic, which turned a suppose orderly retreat into a total capitulation. Many nationalist army commanding officers retreated before telling their own units to withdraw. Adding to the fact there were many collaborators working for the Japanese as informers. Generalissimo Chiang falsely believed that the league of Nations and the Germans were negotiate with the Japanese on China’s behalf. And you are right, this delayed the general withdraw of the Chinese forces. Even then, Chiang still held hope by ordering a regiment of the 88th division to hold the Shanghai warehouse at all cost in order to show the international community that Chinese forces are still fighting in Shanghai.
@@lamchan8674 German and League of Nation did negotiate on China behalf. For German they don't want a war between its trading partner and ally, for League of Nation they want to focus on European battle (Soviet and Germany) while want to stop Japan from expanding. However doubt Japan would listen, even the attack on pearl harbour and even the war with China was agaisnt by the commandor, but they still do it.
Commenters said about M1 Bazooka as anachronistic。I've seen Tommy Gun as out of place since the NRA in Shanghai were mostly equipped with rifles，stick grenades，LMG and water-cooled GPMG。But，no SMG。
Few American equipment (they did use Thompsons, but are rare in this stage of the war), prominently Czech and Swiss LMGs (ZB 26, and KE7), and uh, barely have any AT capabilities
Because of Chiang Kai-shek's "final crucial point" Speech, Shanghai Naval Landing Force was instead surrounded by the Chinese Nationalist army, so the they did not take part in the siege fighting. This video confuses the "Shanghai Naval Landing Force" with the "Shanghai Expeditionary Force". To explain the circumstances, the Shanghai Naval Landing Force guarding Japanese embassy was surrounded, the ”Shanghai Expeditionary Force” dispatched from Japan landed at Wusong Pier on the north shore of Shanghai, ”Shanghai Expeditionary Force” attacked from the side of the Chinese Nationalist army's counter-encirclement line of "the Shanghai Naval Landing Force".The Chinese Nationalist army were outflanked by "the Shanghai Expeditionary Army"(not "the Shanghai Naval Landing Force")and gradually retreated, and after Hangzhou Bay was taken by the Japanese 10th Army, they retreated to Nanjing.
Nice battle liked the simulation of sihang house battle, i have done similar one for the defense of sihang house and battle of dachang and battle of shanghai from cinematic and historical prespective events but for gates of hell
seutallin geuladeu?seutallin geuladeu jeontuneun dog-ilgun-i hangbog-ilado haessji jung-iljeonjaeng bomyeon jung-guggun-eun gyesog milligiman haessneunde Stalingrad? In the Battle of Stalingrad, the German army surrendered, but if you look at the Sino-Japanese War, the Chinese army continued to be pushed back.
It would’ve not since Communist and Kuomintang didn’t have Allied equipment, but it could have ended in 1955 where maybe the soviets would’ve given their new weapons
Can you please teach the men of war and call to arms How can the soldiers be arranged in an orderly manner so that they can appear from behind the lines and not show them ourselves
@@FernandoFilipino they were able to split japanese army into 2 with bare hands 😂 I mean with such power, it is almost u thinkable how the japnese army lasted so long over there
If the actual combat casualties were as shown in the game, China would not have to fight Japan for eight years. The actual casualty ratio is closer to one to ten.
Similar thing that happened before. During the battle of Changde, the Japanese sent waves of their forces but failed lots of times that they had to use Mustard gas to destroy the Chinese defending forces, yet the Japanese still lost to the Chinese smaller forces
Historically, the battles that happened in China were way more bloody and worse than the battles in Russia.
Both China and Russia had their struggles. The battle of stalingrad was so deadly that other ww2 battles were considered stalingrads whenever the casualties were high. But if we combine the casualties of changsha, it’s bloody as stalingrad
Hello? From... Austria, Vienna(Österreich)@@vincentxu4709
@@vincentxu4709The losses in the battles in Changsha are definitely far behind the battle of Stalingrad. The Chinese army suffered around 180,000 casualties in the four battles, including the Yichang offensive. The IJA 11th army suffered 4,000-5,000 casualties in the first battle, 7,000 casualties in the second battle, and 7,000-8,000 casualties in the third. I'm not sure about the losses in the fourth battle, but it should number in the thousands at most. The battle of Shanghai is still more bloody than all four battles of Changsha combined.
11:30
China didn’t get M1 Bazookas until they were in Burma
Let's not talk about the Yokosuka D4Ys at the beginning which didn't even exist in 1937
In that case, the coastline defense part shouldn't even exist..
@@tomau0506
Exactly!
It didn't..
But whatever 🤷
I mean Bazooka 1942 onwards, battle Shanghai 1937...
... What Chinese doing in Bruma? I doesn't really educate about it?
Oooh outstanding as always!!
中華民国軍が時期別に軍服が違っていて良き
日本軍も海軍陸戦隊なのが、再現度高い!!
中国国民党軍は「同時期」に様々な軍服があったのですよ。蒋介石の中央軍とその他軍閥（地方で勝手に武装している非合法勢力）の雑軍が入り乱れたのです。
また海軍陸戦隊は中国国民党に包囲される側で、衝突後、上海北岸から上陸した「上海派遣軍」が中国国民党軍を駆逐したのです。海軍陸戦隊のほうから攻め込んでるシーンがあり、それだと国民党軍が巧妙に構築した陣地で反撃されて大損害されてお仕舞です。上海近郊に上陸した上海派遣軍が国民党軍陣地を横から刺したのです。
3:08 Me not wanting to wake up on a weekday morning.
Me when my mom says "its time for school"
@@nakitaluckysibih5581same 😅
In fact, the Chinese Communist Party rarely participated in the war against Japan. They mainly developed their strength secretly in non-war areas. The Chinese Kuomintang took the responsibility of resistance. After the end of World War II, the Chinese Communist Party immediately defeated the battered Kuomintang.
1.抗日战争结束，中国解放战争开始时，共产党和国民党军队比例是127万对430万。2.中国共产党是最早组织抗日的军队，1931年日本侵略东三省，中国共产党就领导组织了东北抗日联军。3.无知就多读书，不要闹笑话
Come on, you can see how absurd your words are if you look at the Japanese forces in the frontal battlefield and the guerrilla battlefield behind enemy lines in the middle and late period of the war.
At the same time, do you know the composition of communist party and the Kuomintang army? Do you know the process of civil war in China in detail? Learn more about history.😅
@@fengding3606 You should read more historical materials besides those provided to you by the CCP
@@skorpion7365典中典真相那老一套
The battle of Shanghai was a big lost for China.
Because Japan boasts that they will defeat China in three months
Wuhan was actually the biggest lost for China
在战役上我们失败了，但在战略上我们成功了，“淞沪会战”使得中国在和日本的全面战争中，没有像法国那样迅速亡国，把日本设想的闪击战打成了持久战，使得在太平洋战争爆发后，有80%的日本陆军深陷中国战场，没有被抽掉到太平洋战场上和盟军作战，这就是中国（中华民国）对二战胜利所作出的贡献吧！
China failed in the battle, but succeeded in strategy. The Battle of Shanghai prevented China from being destroyed as quickly as France in the all-out war with Japan. China turned Japan's envisioned blitzkrieg into a protracted war. After the outbreak of the Pacific War, at least 50% of the Japanese army was trapped in the Chinese battlefield and was not withdrawn to fight the Allied forces in the Pacific battlefield. This is the contribution made by China (Republic of China) to the victory of the Second World War!
@@liuyiyang1996 In the west, we are all taught that America won WW2, it's shown in all our media, films, video games, schools and many books. However over the last decade many in the west have realized and accepted that America was a sideshow in Europe and that Russia did the heavy lifting to beat Germany. American's coped by saying, "well at least we still have the pacific theater". And now we find out the Sino Japanese War was absolutely huge and took up 80% of all Japan's resources, it's beginning to look like America was just a sideshow in the pacific too lol. America was just a sideshow to the entire war who turned up late and took all the credit.
People often forget China during World War II thank you for your video！
I need more China！🇹🇼
人們總是忘記中國在二戰的貢獻，謝謝你的影片！
我需要更多的中國！🇹🇼
中国侵略を行いすいませんでした今後には認め合い友好関係を築きましょう。
@@user-wt5ru9ov9b 我們不會忘記日本侵略的歷史，但我們已經原諒日本的行為，當年蔣中正已經要我們以德報怨了！因為要放下仇恨才能夠進步！
This is ROC🇹🇼，not PRC belongs to CCP🇨🇳
這是中華民國，不是屬於中共的中華人民共和國
@@hhhhhing818 你阿公不是臺籍日本兵嗎？🤔🤔🤔🤔 裝三小的正統國軍啦
中國是CN不止是TW
Because the "Shanghai Concession" was a colony, many foreigners lived there, and if something like the Stalingrad had happened, the "Shanghai Massacre" would have been widely publicized instead of the Nanjing.
It's called 'stalingrad' cause it was a big urban battle with high casualties that changed the course of the war.
@@Kijbyhell, even they have their own "Pavlov's House" with the warehouse
@@RandomFurry07Although the Sihang warehouse was similar to parlovs house, it was nowhere close to the house’s casualties
@@KijbyThe battle of Wuhan was claimed to be the deadliest and bloodiest battle in the Second Sino Japanese war, but it’s not recognized nor consider “The Chinese Stalingrad”
@vincentxu4709 Probably cause Battle of Wuhan was after the Shanghai and not that famous compared to latter? Don't know. Ask historians.
국민당군의 총기를 보면 미국 , 일본 , 영국 , 소련 , 체코 등 ... 다양한 무기를 혼합 사용했다는 것이 놀랍다 . 탄규격과 정비부품이 모두 달랐는데 ... 어떻게 유지하고 운영했는지 신기할 정도 ... 당시 국민당군 소속 보급관은 머리가 터졌을꺼다 .
非常出色的影片
感謝作者忠實的還原歷史 作為中華民國國民 我很感謝作者及 粉絲認同該作品及頻道❤
(然而在如今的中華人民共和國PRC政府不斷的洗腦是共產黨率領 打贏的戰爭 但事實上是中華民國ROC)
(畢竟這段歷史相對來說複雜 隨著國共內戰的失利 中華民國轉移到台灣 國際上的角色也變得相對弱勢)
上一代人(經歷過那段歷史,這是他們親身經歷我無法否決) 或是有部分人討厭日本 但我覺得時代的進步 我們要學習如何接納擁抱世界甚至拋棄成見
纠正你一下：中共那边也拍长沙保卫战和中国远征军。还有昆仑关战役，中日空战。常德保卫战等只有小粉红认为中共是抗日主力。国民党主要在正面抵挡日军进攻，共产党在日占区村镇建立抗日根据地。都很艰苦。
You’re the one who is brainwashed. You guys been loving Small Japan since from the start of 1912-2024, and you think the PRC citizens have been brainwashed? If we were brainwashed then the Chinese would be racist towards foreigners in their country
thank you, i wanted to see this video for years.
02:01 as far as i understand, we are talking about the The Battle of Shanghai - 1937 and in this year the M1 "Bazooka" (first appeared from 1942(!)) looks more than out of place!
The Chinese believed that if they surrounded and provoked the Shanghai Naval Landing Force, Japanese reinforcements would attack from the center of Shanghai and Chinese would repel the reinforcements with pillboxes and heavy machine guns.
However, reinforcements of the Japanese army landed at from the north coast of Shanghai, therefore the Japanese landing changed the main Shanghai battlefield.
By confining many foreigners to the Shanghai concession and making the battlefield the "outskirts of Shanghai," the Japanese military likely intended to hide the atrocities.
是的
No, Japan had already invaded China in North China in 1937, and the war had already begun. The Nationalist government attacked Shanghai to attract the strategic direction of the Japanese army to the coast, to prevent the Japanese army from encircling China from the west like the Mongols did. It was to exchange space for time, and at the same time, as a Chinese, I was grateful for the help of the United States.
@@yuansishen I guess that’s hindsight.” Chiang Kai-shek declared the recovery of the ``Shanghai Concession'' with the political purpose of clearing up Chinese past shames. And Chiang Kai-shek wanted first chinese victory no matter what. He hoped for a major victory by annihilating the 6,000 sailors defending the Shanghai Concession with 70,000 Kuomintang soldiers. However, that plan collapsed when the 40,000-man Shanghai Expeditionary Force successfully landed on the north coast of Shanghai.
@@ステラリスおじさん You may not understand the situation at that time. In fact, since Japan began to invade Northeast China in 1931, Chiang Kai-shek has been preparing to deal with Japan's attack on inland China. He may not be a good politician, but he is an outstanding military strategist. He knows that there is no possibility of winning the battle with the Japanese army in Shanghai, because the firepower of a Japanese warship is better than the sum of all Chinese warships at that time. But if Japan follows the original plan to encircle China from the west of China along the Mongolian attack route in the 13th century, then China will definitely fail. Therefore, changing the direction of the Japanese army's attack, retreating to the mountainous areas in western China, and waiting for the international community, especially the United States and Britain to join in, is the only way for China to survive.
Finally, I believe that there will never be a war between China and Japan, nor with any other country. Everyone can live like real neighbors, drink beer together, and talk about girls together
Most people consider the invasion of Poland to be the start of WW2 but it was actually when Japan 🇯🇵 invaded china 🇨🇳 in 1937 .
증공이 아니라 중화민국 입니다
@@미국고양이-d2uoh
I definitely agree that WW2 started in 1937 and not 1939 which is a western centric date. Though you can also kinda argue it started in 1935 or 1936 with Abyssinia and Spanish Civil War, considering Abyssinian War basically reignited in WW2 anyways with the underrepresented East African Theater of WW2. Meanwhile Spanish Civil War had Germany trying out all it's new tactics and weapons there, as well as Italy and the Soviets and even many Brits went to fight there and that war lasted till 1939. You also have Khalkin Gol which really should be included in WW2 as it's Japan vs Soviets and it started only a few months before WW2 and went right into WW2 and finished up while Poland was midway through it's invasion. In fact the Soviet army went straight from Khalkin Gol right into Poland without a single days break.
@@123mandalore777interesting
Not fake China
Thank you for making such a wonderful video！
Thanks from the Republic of China.🇹🇼🎉
Thanks @johnj4042 !
Republic of China was fking weak. Japan wouldnt dare to invade if it was communist China
国军就是战五渣，老共三十万步兵在朝鲜能跟美国五五开，要是1937年老共手上有一百万军队，还不把小日本翔打出来
感謝! 製作的非常精彩逼真,看到中華民國旗幟 國徽,令人感動
This is great video! Very few videos are being made about the Japanese forces and also the Pacific war.
In fact it's was Asia
@@hhhhhing818Well tbh it’s similar
Most of the Japanese troops in Shanghai were from the Imperial Japanese Army, not Japanese Special Naval Landing Force.
The initial attack was around Japanese Marine base, then the IJA landed behind 87 and 36th division which was a decisive defeat for the Chinese
The first ten days-arguably the most important as it was the only chance for the Chinese to dislodge the Japanese defenders-were fought solely by IJN and its ground forces. IJA didn't arrive until August 23 and even then their focus was more on the suburbs. The urban fighting in Shanghai's densest districts such as Zhabei was mostly by SNLF.
This was an amphibious attack, there were lots of Japanese marines too
Wow, amizing contents as always, you are my favorite youtuber. i'd like maybe more content about an alternative story in cold war? Bye ❤❤❤
Thanks ❤ yes sure, I'd like to visit more Cold War
Yeah ..next germany vs Japanese battle of tsing Tao ww1 , loved your channel
Awesome like always ! 🤗 Thx for your time to make this content ❤
Thanks!
I'll take these graphics over any 4K, clean, polished ultra photorealism from modern games
Beautiful work, Warfaregaming !!!!!! Keep it up !!!!! 😁👌❤️
Thank you so much for doing my favourite battle of WW2. Chinese-Singaporean here! 🇸🇬
Even though it is just a video game simulation, i can tell you did your research put alot of effort into it and tried to make it as accurate as possible!
May i request: Wolfenstein Germany vs Imperial japan?
(Maybe after Hitler took over the world, he decided to turn on his allies or smth)
솔직히 똑같은 36년도안에 독일과 일본이 적국이었다가 두달만에 동맹국이 되는 어처구니 없는 상황이 벌어집니다.
유비, 징기스칸은 민심장악과 대의명분, 프로파간다를 중시 했지. 징기스칸은 전쟁시작전에 퍼포먼스로 산위에 올라가 하늘에 대고 적군의 부당함과 아군의 정당성을 호소했다고 해.
독일군에게 훈련받은 장개석의 친위대가 일본군과 대등하게 싸우면서 강력한 방어전을 펼쳤지. 그러자 일본군은 몽골군이 했던 도성작전을 해서 중국군의 의지를 꺽으려 했어. 마치 요즘의 푸틴처럼. 푸틴이 체첸에서 이 방식으로 효과를 볼 수 있었던 건 사우디가 같은 이슬람인 체첸을 끝없이 지원해 주지 못했기 때문이야. 마치 지금 미국나토가 우크라이나를 지원하듯이...간지가 말한 대동아공영권의 핵심기술은 각국의 독립성을 유지시켜주고 산업화를 이룬뒤 일본이 아시아의 맹주가 된다는 것인데 이것을 잘 실천했으면 미소냉전에서 소련의 위치를 일본이 할 수 있었겠지.
하지만 현실은 상하이 전투후에 도성작전으로 난징대학살을 자행하고 3.1절 대학살, 마닐라대학살 기타등등... 이런 형태로는 민심장악이 힘들지.
목택동이나 홍수전, 삼국지의 오두미도, 일본전국시대의 일향종처럼 민중들에게 뭔가 이익을 잘 베풀어 줄 필요가 있어.
삼국지의 오두미도와 일본전국시대의 일향종은 현대에도 그 명맥을 유지하고 있다고 하네.
36이면 엄청 긴 시간임.
20살 청년이 56살 노인이 되는 시기
@@hder9 조금은 빗나간 리플을 하셨군요. 제말은 1936년도 안에 불과 두달만에 일어난 일이라는 겹니다.
Japan mistakenly invaded China🇹🇼 due to the instigation of militarists, but in the end China did not lose any territory because of Japan. The Russians have been expanding for hundreds of years and still occupy a large amount of land. China and Japan can be friends, and Russia can also be a friend if it returns the land.
Amd the chinese thank them for taking their land 😂😂😂😂 this is why I love the chinese,
@Yuaretrash The CCP is the product of the Soviet Union's ideological invasion of China, and now the Chinese people are being enslaved by the Soviet ghost.The Chinese people, controlled by the ghost of communism, are waiting for the Kuomintang🇹🇼 to liberate them.
@Yuaretrash The CCP is the product of the Soviet Union's ideological invasion of China, and now the Chinese people are being enslaved by the Soviet ghost.
@@Yuaretrash The CCP is the product of the Soviet Union's ideological invasion of China, and now the Chinese people are being oppression by the Soviet ghost.
@@Yuaretrash The CCP is the product of the Soviet Union's ideological invasion of China
Excelente recreacion de un momento tan historico como dramatico. Muchas gracias.
Hello from India 🇮🇳
Hi
主さんにリクエストです。「シビル・ウォー アメリカ最後の日（Civil War）」の西部勢力VS連邦政府の主さん版の内戦バージョンを見てみたいです。そして、主さんなりのその後の世界情勢も描けれたらお願いします。
週二戰前中國德國是比較友好關係當時有蘇聯的軍事顧問，還有德國軍事顧問在中國，但是後來國民政府採納的是德國的軍事顧問，所以才有德械師（如果有講錯的歡迎糾正）
1936년에 단 2달만에 적국에서 동맹국이 되버리지요.
The entire Second Sino-Japanese War actually began with Japan's invasion of Manchuria during the Mukden Incident in 1931. Throughout the war, the contributions of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) were minimal, largely due to the "7-2-1" strategy. This strategy allocated 70% of their efforts to expanding their own power, 20% to dealing with the Nationalists, and only 10% to resisting Japan. As a result, the war was almost entirely fought by the Republic of China under the leadership of the Chinese Nationalist Party (KMT). Many in the West have been misled by Communist propaganda, mistakenly believing that the war was fought by the CCP, which is a grave and foolish misconception.
We need Gates of Hell-Sino Japan DLC or pacific DLC
100%
Il est terrible de penser que c'est la France qui a entrainé l'armée japonaise (ainsi que ses troupes de marine 陸戰隊)
Long live the Republic of China!🇹🇼
Long Live The Republic of Taiwan, to be One China.
Long live the people's republic of China,we are the current China🇨🇳
Sounds like some kind of curse
Hello from Österreich,Vienna
Hi!
@@warfare11gaming 1
Imagine fighting an enemy that is being supplied by your allie.
Germany cheaply sold or donated old surplus helmets rifles amo clothing to China.
Yep, i’ve noticed that in Chinese war movies that the Kuomintang troops have old ww1 German equipment and not any current 1937 German equipment, even when it was 1940 and yet i never see any changes of the Kuomintang army and their equipments
In fact, all German M35 helmets were given to China first Germany was out of stock of M35 helmets until 1940 because they were all bought by China.
@@vincentxu4709
In fact, China's equipment has been replaced. In 1938, there were Soviet weapons
@@hhhhhing818 Dang🥶
週二戰前中國德國是比較友好關係當時有蘇聯的軍事顧問，還有德國軍事顧問在中國，但是後來國民政府採納的是德國的軍事顧問，所以才有德械師
3:09aaaaaa😂
China is no match for Japan. China only had infantry weapons, yet Japan had the support of the Navy, Airforce and artilary. The few tanks that China owned, weren't even protected by the infantry. Infantry and tanks supposed to depend on one another.
对，当时中华民国由于清朝时期注重于轻工业发展，重工业没发展起来导致了我们当时抗战十分艰难，也多亏了外国盟友们的武器和装甲支援我们也是挺过来了
@@天琦肖 在美國對日宣戰之前，中國的武器只有從德國入口，但德國又是日本盟友，所以爲了不觸怒日本，拒絕進口任何大殺傷力武器。結果最大的非大殺傷力武器是駁殼槍。中國也沒挺過來，不是美國用5萬海軍陸戰隊的生命跟原子彈換來了勝利，中國到今天都未必有能力打得過日本。中國今天才勉强有3艘航母。日本二戰就有19艘航母。
@@taotao98103 请教一下日本现在航母多少艘？
@@songhojin3955 你想說中國現在比日本厲害？不是美國打敗了日本，控制日本軍隊規模，日本今天一樣比中國先進。而且現在説的是二戰的日本。二戰的日本除了武器，科技先進，諜報也非常先進。媮襲珍珠港的時候，日本完全掌握了珍珠港的情況。跟日本交過手的歐洲部隊也知道日本的諜報有多先進。
@@taotao98103 你过度理解我的问题了，单纯想问下日本目前的数量而已。我从没认为中国军事实力比日本强，就算是现在中国跟日本单挑也不一定打的过
Chiang Kai shek ordered the retreat too hastily; resulted in a total capitulation of the Chinese defense force in Shanghai, sending it into a chaotic retreat. The concrete fortified Hindenburg line which was constructed with German assistance in the 1930s to protect Nanjing was totally abandoned by the retreating Chinese. Which was a shame.
😢
The Japanese army knew about the trenches, and they deliberately took detours to avoid them. Therefore, the main force did not attack from Shanghai, but landed from the north coast of Shanghai.
The problem is that Chiang Kai Shek should have authorized the retreat in early October as was planned. However, the League of Nations announced that they would hold a conference to talk about ending the war while President Roosevelt gave a speech in support of China right before Chiang Kai Shek is about to do so. Thus, he instead ordered the freshly-arrived Sichuan and Guangxi armies alongside his exhausted Central and Guangdong armies to launch a massive counterattack. The 10-day counterattack resulted in very heavy losses for the Chinese and Iwane Matsui immediately ordered an offensive after, causing multiple defence lines to be breached as the those had been disrupted by the initial counterattack.
@@CentCent69-zv8vq The order of the retreat was not issued properly. There were plans for certain Chinese units to perform rearguard actions to cover the retreats of other Chinese forces. However, some units were informed of the retreat, while other units were kept in the dark. Some divisions only realized that there is a general withdraw when they saw adjacent divisions began to withdraw. This created panic, which turned a suppose orderly retreat into a total capitulation. Many nationalist army commanding officers retreated before telling their own units to withdraw. Adding to the fact there were many collaborators working for the Japanese as informers. Generalissimo Chiang falsely believed that the league of Nations and the Germans were negotiate with the Japanese on China’s behalf. And you are right, this delayed the general withdraw of the Chinese forces. Even then, Chiang still held hope by ordering a regiment of the 88th division to hold the Shanghai warehouse at all cost in order to show the international community that Chinese forces are still fighting in Shanghai.
@@lamchan8674 German and League of Nation did negotiate on China behalf. For German they don't want a war between its trading partner and ally, for League of Nation they want to focus on European battle (Soviet and Germany) while want to stop Japan from expanding.
However doubt Japan would listen, even the attack on pearl harbour and even the war with China was agaisnt by the commandor, but they still do it.
Good 👍🏻 video
Thank you 👍
GLAD TO SEE WAR FARE GAMING BACK ON YOU TUBE ENJOY EVERY MINUTE!
Next time you can show about Japanese army landing in Malaya 1942 in Kota Baharu Kelantan
Commenters said about M1 Bazooka as anachronistic。I've seen Tommy Gun as out of place since the NRA in Shanghai were mostly equipped with rifles，stick grenades，LMG and water-cooled GPMG。But，no SMG。
Pleas do the battle of Normandie
Can you do a battle where British soldiers fought Japanese soldiers in Hong Kong?
This map was amazing, but some firearms was wrong.
中華民國萬歲
Looks like the Chinese forces are not only using German weapons and equipment, but British and Soviet weapons and equipment as well.
Few American equipment (they did use Thompsons, but are rare in this stage of the war), prominently Czech and Swiss LMGs (ZB 26, and KE7), and uh, barely have any AT capabilities
@@RandomFurry07I think the Chinese NRA also used M3 grease but i’m not so sure if it’s true or not
@vincentxu4709 yes actually, but they are only produced in 1943, and only got em in late 1943 early 1944
Hello from Russia👋🇷🇺
Hi comrade
Прывітанне таварыш
Здарова зае....
VICTORY AGAINST PUTINAZIS
SLAVA UKRAINI 🇺🇦 🇺🇦 🇺🇦 ❤
Ukraine!
畫得內容有點不太對，當時中日雙方都對於衝鋒槍這種武器的好處不清楚，所以應該不常見到。此外，中國軍用的主要還是漢陽兵工廠的步槍、VZ26以及馬克欣機槍，中國也沒有那麼多的裝甲車
日本當時的裝備遠比中國裝備好很多，這點沒錯！綜觀看來，這個繪製得不錯就是
to be honest, Japan forces in China during Ww2 almost were called masscared the Chinese forces
A lot of Chinese-made war movies are based on this.
Like the “Defenders” and the “800”
Because of Chiang Kai-shek's "final crucial point" Speech, Shanghai Naval Landing Force was instead surrounded by the Chinese Nationalist army, so the they did not take part in the siege fighting.
This video confuses the "Shanghai Naval Landing Force" with the "Shanghai Expeditionary Force".
To explain the circumstances, the Shanghai Naval Landing Force guarding Japanese embassy was surrounded, the ”Shanghai Expeditionary Force” dispatched from Japan landed at Wusong Pier on the north shore of Shanghai, ”Shanghai Expeditionary Force” attacked from the side of the Chinese Nationalist army's counter-encirclement line of "the Shanghai Naval Landing Force".The Chinese Nationalist army were outflanked by "the Shanghai Expeditionary Army"(not "the Shanghai Naval Landing Force")and gradually retreated, and after Hangzhou Bay was taken by the Japanese 10th Army, they retreated to Nanjing.
Nationalist Chinese troops used a combination of Chiang Kaishek Mauser (Mauser Standard Model) and Hanyang 88, not Mosin Nagant
I was literally watching the 800 hundred movie about this battle but good job I really like this video keep up the good 👍
Nice! What a sick movie.
Yeah it’s a good movie and once again good job making this 👍👍
Nice battle liked the simulation of sihang house battle, i have done similar one for the defense of sihang house and battle of dachang and battle of shanghai from cinematic and historical prespective events but for gates of hell
Hello from Österreich , (Austria) Vienna 🇦🇹
5:38 Back then there should be using Traditional Chinese fonts.👀
5:58 Why did i hear a Chinese soldier saying “EAT HUMAN, QUICK LET ME EAT HUMAN.” and then another Chinese soldier said “YOU ARE A SOLDIER”
I think he said "Support,quick give me support."
@@Helmet-Amiya-Donky Yes, that’s probably the most realistic sentence but like why is my brain telling me “EAT HUMAN, QUICK LET ME EAT HUMAN”💀💀💀
@@vincentxu4709
Wait I hear it too.
@@BruhTNT4258Oh nah that’s crazy
CHINA 🇹🇼 JAPAN 🇯🇵 1937 S WAR
中国敗戦
Hello from Minsk)
Hi
I don't believe that revolutionary army has tank with cannon at the time, only turret with machine guns.
I'm like video war Japan vs china, try make animation war Indonesian vs Japan vs Dutch please🙏🙏
点赞！ 正好是点了 第1937的赞
Epic battle
Jin Jie is Alive!! You need to tell to others!!
REPUBLIC of CHINA🇹🇼
5:47 the chinese characters should be written from right to left.
期待下一個影片
Yesss!!
seutallin geuladeu?seutallin geuladeu jeontuneun dog-ilgun-i hangbog-ilado haessji jung-iljeonjaeng bomyeon jung-guggun-eun gyesog milligiman haessneunde
Stalingrad? In the Battle of Stalingrad, the German army surrendered, but if you look at the Sino-Japanese War, the Chinese army continued to be pushed back.
NICE VIDEO😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎😎
In Stalingrad no one escaped from well fortified positions.
Just like the trailer
こんな戦争がなければ今も中国と仲良くやれてたかもしれないのに…(もしかしたら蒋介石と毛沢東の激しい内戦が続いていたかもしれないけど…)
It would’ve not since Communist and Kuomintang didn’t have Allied equipment, but it could have ended in 1955 where maybe the soviets would’ve given their new weapons
共産党があるはずもない
이미 만주까지 점령하고 있는 것만도 반일감정은 충분했습니다.
しゃあないよ、アメリカが戦争起こすように仕向けたから
亡國的條件我們中國人絕不答應，這裡有我們的血和淚！！！
1）世界では漢字を使う国は中国と日本しかない、確かに兄弟の国（文化上の親近感がある）だと思う！2）当時日本軍の侵攻が無ければ、共産党軍は既に全滅寸前で激しい内戦とは大げさだね！3）毛沢東は日本が蒋介石と戦っている間に力を蓄えることができたこともあり、日本軍に感謝の念さえ抱いていたのだ！終戦時、大量日本軍の武器及び満州国軍（日本籍、朝鮮籍込み）の編入などによって、激しい内戦になるわけ！4）動画は現在の宇露戦争のように、残酷さを再現した。いくら兄弟の国（文化上）と言いても、現在の日中関係と一緒さ！
中华民国背负了太多历史伤痕😢 中华民族铭记历史 国军永垂不朽！
Make vidio in india Pakistan war 1971
希望你可以放台海續集🫸🫷
The Chinese army have bazookas ?Are you kidding me?
I mean they did have it
Just not the right time period, they barely have any anti armour capabilities
Can you please teach the men of war and call to arms How can the soldiers be arranged in an orderly manner so that they can appear from behind the lines and not show them ourselves
Can you make WW2 battle of Malaya 🇬🇧⚔️🇯🇵
這部影片二戰國軍有戴德制鋼盔和英式鋼盔欸
@@韋發祥 畢竟國軍這兩種鋼盔最為常見
@@hhhhhing818 而且英式鋼盔和德式鋼盔不是仇敵嗎？感覺二戰國軍帶著英式和德式鋼盔打日本人之類的
@@韋發祥 那時候的國軍是哪裡有武器可以買就會去買，畢竟國內產能不足，所以武器上可以說是真正意義的「聯合國」，也因此有一句話說中國的武器是「軍武收藏家的天堂，後勤補給官的惡夢」
@@hhhhhing818 怪不得都是軍閥，所以才會有全世界的鋼盔（德國，英國，法國，蘇聯，美國）
👍🔥
A ver sí haces algún vídeo sobre la guerra civil española
向所有抗日英雄致最敬禮
👍🇹🇷🇹🇷 videoyu perfcet broo
What game is this?
i watch the chinese drama all the time here at yt
@@FernandoFilipino they were able to split japanese army into 2 with bare hands 😂 I mean with such power, it is almost u thinkable how the japnese army lasted so long over there
You still working new video?
3:08 what in Tom and Jerry ahh scream is that lmaoo
If the actual combat casualties were as shown in the game, China would not have to fight Japan for eight years. The actual casualty ratio is closer to one to ten.
在真正的中國戰場，日本人見到中國守軍如此頑強，早已經不是派士兵去強攻，而是施放毒氣
@@hfdennycheng9010 could have just surrendered 😂
Similar thing that happened before. During the battle of Changde, the Japanese sent waves of their forces but failed lots of times that they had to use Mustard gas to destroy the Chinese defending forces, yet the Japanese still lost to the Chinese smaller forces
蒋介石の「最後関頭」によって上海陸戦隊は逆に中国国民党軍に包囲されていたので、「陸戦隊」は包囲戦の闘いに加わっていないはずです。大使館を守る上海陸戦隊が包囲されたので、日本本国から派遣された上海方面派遣軍が上海北岸の呉淞桟橋から上陸し、中国国民党軍の対陸戦隊包囲網の横を突いて「主戦場」が変わったのです。中国国民党の軍隊は上海派遣軍に横を突かれ、ジリジリと撤退し、杭州湾も日本軍の第10軍に落とされたので南京に撤退しました。
上海陸戦隊と上海派遣軍がごちゃまぜになってる点と、軍閥の雑軍が多すぎて「88師」の存在が薄いのが残念です
亡國的條件我們絕不答應，這裡有我們的血和淚！
th-cam.com/video/LgNAqiIH1VQ/w-d-xo.html
世界約200カ国の中で、現在も漢字を使う国は中国と日本しかない。仲良くすりゃ良いものの、現在の宇露戦争のように、兄弟の国に戻るのは難しいだろうし、
歴史考証があまりにも終わりすぎてて草
Why did the rocket launchers and Tommy guns that the United States provided to China in 1944 appear in Shanghai in 1937?
This game is probably not accurate, but it is quite entertaining to watch
I mean, M1921 Tommy Guns could be accurate, but those are M1A1 Thompsons that are shown there
So...
Could you do operation Kantouken (Japanese planees invasion of ussr)?
When did you make the video I requested last time?
Sorry, I get many requests, I can't remember which one was yours but I do write down many of them
@@warfare11gaming I understand, I want you to make more Videos Medieval Soldiers vs Modern Soldiers in a 21st century city, any city is fine
Can you make a battle of surabaya,
這就是淞滬會戰
Where did Bazooka come from in 1937？
Game balance
China army have not enough weapon to anti tank😂
Next vedio japan vs rus 1904