Sanātan Dharma and Siḱhi -2 | Guru Nidar Singh | Prof. Kapil Kapoor| Prof Jagbir Singh|
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 ก.ค. 2024
- The four Indic faith systems - Sanātan Bauddha Jain and Siḱh have all originated from the same soil and hence have a shared core of human values and concepts.
In this panel discussion the eminent personalities are elaborating on the background of the religions that emerged from the Vedic Spirituality and Gyan. A comparative study of Sanātan Dharma and Siḱhi's similarities, varied interpretations of values and concepts and their differences.
Panelists:
1. Prof Kapil Kapoor - Academician & Former: Chairman - IIAS & Pro VC - JNU
Prof Kapil Kapoor's Books - amzn.to/41oKFg2
2. Gurudev Nidar Singh Nihang - The last surviving master of Sanatan Shastar Vidiya. The ninth Gurudev of 'Shastar Vidya Akhara' - a martial arts school founded in 1661(Punjab) & author of several books related to martial history.
Nidar Singh Nihang's Books - amzn.to/3ovkqWp
3. Prof Jagbir Singh - Chancellor, Central University of Punjab, Bathinda.
Prof Jaguar Singh's Books - amzn.to/3UTALkc
Sanātan Dharma and Siḱhi | Part - 1 - • Sanātan Dharma and Siḱ...
Subtopics:
0:00 Power Staements
1:10 The importance of five Ks in Sikhism - Kesh, Kangha, Kada, Kripan, Kachcha
5:50 In British Raj imposed Act to control Gurudwaras
9:45 Khalsa was madeto protect Hindus
12:30 Sikh warriors used Pashupati symbol on head and trishul in hand
17:19 The sword represents the Aadesh of the WaheGuru - Brahma
21:19 The mis-interpretations spring from the ignorance
23:05 The oldest philosophy of the world in RigVeda is reflected in the Gurubani
26:54 Sanatan dharma and Sikhi have common philosophy
29:50 The essence of religion
35:15 Sikhi is not new revelation, it was in the eco system ever renewing itself
40:00 Sikhi does not destroy, it builds
45:14 Guru Gobind Singh ji says, The only true idol is Ego
49:17 Q: The invalidation of the puratan Maryada and constructing a new maryada has created difference and seperation - Any solution?
57:25 Khalsa panthi has a historical, political and spiritual aspect, the disha and dsha varies in these all, Why the political movement surpasses the spiritual aspect?
1:04:50 Why BJP does not get seats from punjab?
Join our newsletter for getting updates on upcoming lectures:
www.sangamtalks.com/subscribe
Join our TH-cam video channel for learning about new video releases:
Hindi : / sangamhindi
English : / sangamtalks
Tamil : / @sangamtamizh
Punjabi : / @sangampunjabi
Bhojpuri : / @sangamtalksbhojpuri
Marathi : / @sangammarathi
Malayalam : / @sangammalayalam
Shorts : / @sangamtalkstv
Bangla : / @sangambangla
For updates you may follow us on:
Facebook : / sangamtalks
Instagram : / sangamtalks
Telegram : t.me/sangamtalks
Twitter : / sangamtalks
Koo : www.kooapp.com/profile/sangam...
Website : www.sangamtalks.org
Donate : www.sangamtalks.org/donate
I can see the happiness on Kapil Kapoor Ji's face....he has done alot to unite Hindus and Sikhs and alot for the Hindu community....love for these 3 great people ❤️
Huge respect for Guru Nidar Singh Ji Nihang. True master and thanks for reiterating the meaning and essence of Sikhi. All the Gurus belong to Bharatvarsh and Guru Granth Sahib reiterates the essence of Sanatan Dharm and more. All Hindus are Sikhs and vice Versa. Wish Guruji is able to spread this wisdom and knowledge throughout India and particularly Nihang culture and needs to be supported.
Waheguru ji.Har Har Mahadev.Jai Mata De.
Beautiful and profound knowledge and discussion.
Very good ⚘️ 👍 Waheguru ji ⚘️ 🙏 ❤ WaheGuru Ji ka Khalsa WaheGuru Ji ki Fateh ji Khalsa ji
Salute our sanatani Sikhs, 🙏🙏🙏
He is the SADHGURU of martial arts.
LOLS TOTALLY! 😄👌👌👍👍👌👌
सतनाम वाहे गुरू जी 💐💐💐💐🙏🙏
Guru Nidar singh ji is the most inspiring person I have run into . God bless you
LOVE HIM !! HE IS BEAUTIFUL !! TRUE GURU AMONGST THE UNDESERVING INDIANS! 🙏🙏🙏😔
Great Respect for Nadar Singh ji ❤️🇮🇳🙏
All Sikhs are Sanatanis !!! We are one.
We are one..Waheguru Ji..Jai Hind!!
Sikhs are sanatanis . Hindus are not
Kisi jatt sikh ko bol kar dekho
@@maxmad813 you mean Junior Agricultural Tribe sikh?
Right as a sikh I agree, but these modern Sikhs don't know
Much awaited episode
Salutations to the real knowledge propagated by Gurus and I feel humbled by the clarity of facts about two sons of Mother India and really love and respect these Gurus to help bond them together and the flow of feelings make me feel becoming one of family.Thanks ji
Many thanks to all gunni jan for clearing the most misconceptions clearing the horizon and path to it
Highly appreciated
जय हिन्द 🙏🚩 वन्दे मातरम् 🙏🚩
Jai hindurashtra good discussion and analysis bharat mata ki jai vande matram jai hanuman har har mahadev
Wonderful enlightening discussion
Har har mahadeva waheguruji jai gurunanak ji jai sriram
A very informative video & thank you to the panelists for sharing their extensive knowledge. Pre British Raj Sikhism was very different & it is good that discussions on this matter are taking place.
सत्य सनातन धर्म की जय सीखी ही सनातन धर्म की जड़ है गुरु गोविंद सिंह साहब की जय जय श्री राम इंस्पेक्टर रिटायर्ड कुंवर सिंह रावत देवभूमि उत्तराखंड
I luv the attitude and fearlessness of babba Nidar singh ji..... One man army🙏🙏
Amazing talk.
Someone said " IF YOU CAN'T SEE SADGUN IN YOUR NIRGUN, THEN YOU ARE NOT LOOKING NIRGUN AS A WHOLE.
Sree Gurubhyo Namaha 🙏🏻💐🙏🏻
Pranam guruji.
I have watched almost all the videos of Guru Nidar Singh Nihang. You can see very old videos of Guruji on you tube displaying martial art of old sanatan shashtra Vidiya
Love guru Nihar Singh Ji.
4 arms of Vishnu are representing Lakshmi & Narayan
Nicely explained Sikhism by Baba ji ......could understand that they are true Rishis of Santan Dharm who worship Nirgun upasana and know ancient shastar vidya .Muge baut acha laga Baaba ji app pura parchar kero on this subject on Hindus manch . Jo app bole baut dil ko sakuan dene wali vani lagi
Wahe guru🙏
Excellent vedio 🙏🏻
Conversation worth spreading
Fateh Sanatan! Fateh Bhagwati!
Very enlightening
Want to be like fighter Nidar Singh
But people don't listen to truth or akaal, jab kaal aata hain bhudhhi atmghaati ho jaati toh bhudhhi sirf sampurn nahi h. Akaal takht sanatani guru maharaj ji shakti saadhna ka pratkash pramaan hain. Aur sampurn bharat ki akaal shakti ka punj hain. Jai shakti mata, jai waheguru. Sabhi sanatani apne aaradhya ke liye aad sach bane. 🕉️🙏Waheguru.
There was a guy in the end who said that Sikh dharm is not dharm but a political movement - I just want to reply to him that if it had been a political movement none of our gurus or Sikhs would have sacrificed their lives for motherland or for anyone. Because in politics you do not think of loosing anyone from your family parivaarwaad is prominent in politics. especially Guru Govind Singh ji who not just sacrificed his life but family. yeh Sikh Panth hai pls don't call it a political movement
🙏🙏
*आदेश (हिन्दी शब्द)* = हुक्म (उर्दू शब्द)
Urdu isn't a language. It's Arabic word. When you combine Hindi with Arabic and Persian loan words, it becomes Urdu.
@@anixes true, better word for urdu is Ashuddh Hindi:)
AbyghahoSik
🔥💐🙏💐🔥
Towards the end, the two guys asked questions of how Sikhi is a political movement, nope it’s not. It’s a full blossomed panth, dharohar of Sikh Gurus, just like Buddhism and Jain et el. It has its own identity, the final word is coexist!
👍👍🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽
❤❤❤
The father of first guru of sikh is from hindu Arora clan
And Buddha is also from a chatriya rajput clan..
But
Is bharat mitti mai hi kuch baat hai
Ki yaha human consciousness bohot hi High hai
Sbne apna alag alag panth banaya hai sanatan ke bhalaye ke liye
One's head used for study is Brahmin
Arms and Chest for saving the suppressed is Kshatriya
Stomach and intestine satisfaction is Vaishya
Legs for labour is Shudra
It's all about ones perspective which is Dharma......
🚩🇮🇳🇮🇳🚩
We should all learn the truth and care about each other were all one people really it's sad what the British done in india. ❤
वाहे गुरुजी का खालसा ,वाहे गुरुजी की फतेह !
The word HINDU is derived from the two sanskrit words Hinsa (Evil/Violence) Dhushnam (End/Destroy ) hence destroyer of evil
🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
SO TRUE REHAAT PAYARI MUJJKOO SIKH PAYARA NAHI.......GOODGOING KHALSA G
I wish I could understand Punjabi. Whatever tuti futi I understood is gold too
🇮🇳🚩🚩🇮🇳
🚩🚩🚩🚩
Allusion is a literary device through which a writer advances its message by using cultural entities--personalities, events etc. Same has been done by Sikh Gurus, they used Hindu and Islamic cultural context so that people could readily grasp their spiritual message.
Singh Sahib ji, you are talking about spiritual connection between Sikhs and Sanatan, but beware the goal of organiser seems like political.
यही तो हमारे सनातनी योद्धा हैं । नमन् है ।
Guru govind Guru devji .govid is Maha vishnu name, guru means Acharya,
This panel should meet for a discussion with the khalistani group...
All mathams in bharath in sanathan dharma.
ஏன் முடியலன விட்டுவிட வேண்டியதுதான
Sikhism was ended when Khalsa panth was born
😂
khalsa apane ander jo gyan volta he ye hi khalsa he
41:00 Question by the woman, Gurudwaras were never temples, they were not broken to build Gurudwaras. They were built in fresh places where the Gurus left their bodies or some important event relating to Gurus took place.
Sikhs are not Mughals lady!
Baba ji Guru Sahib ji ne fir Jung kyu ladi
kalakar murti kar chiterkar painter panther per ram ram leekhne wala bajrgbali an hotel she kese bañte
The questions were not good. Wasting time. I was excited, but ehh, the level was low.
.... SANATAN IS NOT A RELIGION, IT IS A BUNCH OF DIFFERENT SECTS PUT BY MUSLIMS IN ONE VESSEL... BRAHMINS TOOK ADVANTAGE OF MUSLIM FEAR IN INDIAN MASSES. GURU NANAK TOOK A LEAD IN CHALLENGING BRAHMINS, FOR THEIR IN-HUMANITARIAN ACTS.
You cannot do Naam Jap without sovereignty.
Need to ban it then 10:43
Sikh are real sanatni all hindu duplicate sanatni🇮🇳🙏
1:05:09 God is not a purush or male. God is all genders and God is genderless
Good to see #Shilpi Tiwari ji.
A fraud and vile person exposed his agenda many a times.
He misquoted and Put in wrong translations of many texts just to bad mouth sikhism.
Not at all happy to see such frauds
@@nirvairrr
I have no interest in Hindu Sikh unity.
I am only interested in ka'fir ka'fir unity.
And Hindu RAJPUTS militarized SIKHS
th-cam.com/video/HDFy1DXAHl8/w-d-xo.html
Sare guru khatri ne .. te kabja jaata ne ku kita peya . Hari mandir sahib vich
Bilkul sahi ..
Kitne khatri Sikh bane? 2 percent?
Shatri not khatri.
Our ancestors knews Guru nanak ji is dev, that's why we call him guru nanak dev, now people who have khali esthan in their mind will always talk nonsense 🤣.. all guru r khatri, if say in Sanskrit language its kshatriya..
😂😂 4 varn ni shadne jo mrji ho je
Jinko english nai ati un k liye yeh adha adhura gian hai. 😞
Sikh and snatan are not sapret every sanatani is sikh and every sikh is sanatani there is no difference
There is a undercurrent of egoism. Today's sanatani are RSS. So Sikhs ask them selve are they RSS, or shiv sena well answer is clean denial. Sanatani cc annot be a hindu, a rss, a shiv saini.. you can be one not all. Ideal can not be idol or idolatory. Here lies a great manipulation.
So why Sikhs don't claim sanatanism as rss is not the sanatan why not tell that what true sanatan dharma is? Why palayanvad/escapism?
Sir, what are the basis of your claim when you refer s "khand khand Chandika..." as Chandi Devi. I argue that you are ignoring the fact that when Guru Gobind Singh uses words "Bhagyoti", "Kaali", or "Chandika", he is refering them as the manifestation form (Shakti) of Akal-Purkh or Mahakaal; there is no dualism here.
Gurbani starts with EKONKAR (it is one Akal-Purkh who is creating, sustaining, and destroying in this universe) thus the Guru Sahiban, at the very outset, puts a full-stop on this dualism.
The orign from onkar comes from the saraswati brahmins they used onkar instead of omkar. Sikhs later adopted this.
@@hindukhatri5516 What is the base of your this argument? Please cite the SOURCE on the basis of which you are proclaiming it.
@@jasmeetsingh4334 gaudapadacharya check in onkareshwar he attained siddhi. Even if sikhs do ardaas the main thing is ard to ask or beg. The important part of ardaas is chandi di vaar who is she ma bhavati this part of ardaas in found in the bhavat puran. Read the history of sikhi. Dharma is Sanatan and the Guru’s were their to restoe Dharma. I am khatri punjabj like most of the Guru’s were but i am alsways looking at the history. British changed allot about the sikh history they were even in contol of the Akal Takht and they choose the jatts to controle it later
@@hindukhatri5516 Before starting a discussion, let me clarify few things: 1) For Enlightened souls, The source of spiritual knowledge is not any particular religion but God itself; 2) i would appreciate if the goal of this program would have been to highlight common spiritual values, i.e. that are beneficial for all, including Hindus and Sikhs. But that's not the case here. The goal of this program is to prove Sikhism just a SECT of Hinduism; since it has been done with political motives, therefore, i staunchly reject any claim of similarity between Sikhism and Hinduism.
Now let's start the discussion:
1) The Onkareshvar temple you are referring here is a Shivji temple, it has no similarity with the much holistic concept of "Ikonkaar". Listen this: th-cam.com/video/5sgdVXKnwB0/w-d-xo.html
If you are declaring Sikhism as an offshoot of Sanatan just because Guru ji used the word ONKAR, then number of times Guru sahibans used ALLAH also. If we go by ur logic then that means Sikhism is an offshoot of Islam also. Hence, I argue don't go by signifier but signified; don't go by the BODY of the word but the MESSAGE behind it. Guru ji professing about that Grand Entity who created countless Brahmas, Vishnu, and Shivji (Hindus worship them but Sikhs pray before only "IKONKAR")
And most importantly as I mentioned earlier the source of spiritual knowledge of Gurus is Akal-Purkh itself not any particular prevalent religion. Guru ji directly said :"Hindu Anna, Turku kaana; Doha te Gyaani siyaana". And moreover, Guru ji says, Gurbaani is "dhur ki bani"-- it is neither a Sanatani bani nor an Islamic bani.
Paad ditti shilpi tiwari di 😂
Nihung saab ne 😂
so called Guru Nidar Nihang.please read the Guru Granth sahib ji.sikh ideology is miles Apart than Hindu Brahman cast ridden ideology.ਭੈਰਓ ਮਹਲਾ ੫. page 1136 ਵਰਤ ਨ ਰਹਉ ਨ ਮਹ ਰਮਦਾਨਾ.ਤਿਸ ਸੇਵੀ ਜੋ ਰਖੈ ਨਿਦਾਨਾ.ਏਕ ਗੁਸਾਈ ਅਲਹੁ ਮੇਰਾ.ਹਿੰਦੂ ਤੁਰਕ ਦੁਹਾਂ ਨਬੇਰਾ.ਹੱਜ ਕਾਬੈ ਜਾਉ ਨ ਤੀਰਥ ਪੂਜਾ.ਏਕੁ ਸੇਵੀ ਅਵਰ ਨ ਦੂਜਾ.ਪੂਜਾ ਕਰਉ ਨ ਨਿਵਾਜ ਗੁਜਰਾਉ.ਏਕ ਨਿਰੰਕਰ ਲੇ ਰਿਦੇ ਨਮਸਕਾਰ. ਨ ਹਮ ਹਿੰਦੂ ਨ ਮੁਸਲਮਾਨ. ਸਿੱਖ ਗੁਰੂਆਂ ਦਾ ਇਹ ਫਰਮਾਣ ਹਿੰਦ ਰਾਸ਼ਟਰ ਦੇ ਵਾਰਸਾਂ ਨੂੰ ਹੱਜਮ ਨਹੀਂ ਹੋ ਰਿਹਾ.
59:06 bruh make a point, don't waste time
😂 if he think it was just their personal political matter why made it religious or godly then what about ramayan & Mahabharata that was personal & political too why they made it religious & godly
Your all propaganda don’t see lienage of 10 guru avatars
@@musicoflife9702 make a point
There is no point to make any point to foooish people
@@musicoflife9702 😂 then why did you write two different messages
First be very clear whom brahimin consider hindu ?
Brahimin had/has/would be certificate of declaring someone hindu but with subcategories A,B,C,D
How hindu word came in existence?
From indus (hindu)valley or moguls gave this name ?
Do you know any yug when caste was not exist?
My dear it’s not Brahmin who give certificates. Our holy book Ramayan is written by SO CALLED DALIT. The name given by you guys( Hindu haters) , missionaries, jihadis , khalistani. Brahmin is just priest community who’d are tagged by you , Muslims and britishers to spread hate between Hindus and easily convert them into your religion. All the time you guys chant Dalit, brahambaad etc. we been ruled by Muslims for 800 years and by Christians for 200 years and by Sikhs in Punjab from 1947 until today. I mean from 1947 until today there is zero hindu CM in Punjab. Because you guys are RACIST people , who just wants spread hate. But don’t worry, at the end only SANATAN will survive . Rest all extremist religions such as khalistani+Jihadi+ Lala luiya will end up fighting each other. You came from Santan and look what you have become now. Just terroristic kind people on earths .
59:46 😆🤣🤣 somebody tell this guy to get some life, bro do something worthwhile in your life, don't waste your and others time
Agar angrez ya Mughal ya or koi invade na krta bharat mai to pakistan or Bangladesh vgera bharat ka hissa hota
Guru sahibon ke jamane me alag se koi Sikh dharm nahin tha. Sikhon ke alag dharm ki manyata angrezon ki sajish thee, jisme ek hi parivaar ke logon ko alag alag kar diya. Hinduon ke mandiron, saray, aashram, akhaadon par jabardasti kabja Kara Diya Gaya.
Prathviraj chauhan ki haar ke bad Mughlon ne laalach dekar Kai jaateon ke logon ka sangathan banaya tha jo deshdrohi poori tarah unko samarpit the, unse roti beti ka bhi sambandh hua, ye hi log 400 sal mughlon ke, 100 varsh angrezon ke samay Raja maharaja Bane, baki sab log bhikhari ya banchari hue aur poora desh gulami me raha. Shivaji maharaj ne bhi mughlon aur gaddar rajputon se ladne ke liye kai jaateon se logon ko lekar sangathan banaya tha jo marathe kahe gaye. Dhan aur bal me Mughal aur rajput bhari pade aur marathon ko haarna pada. Angrezon ke aane par marathe bhi samarpit ho gaye aur gaddaron me shamil hokar Raja maharaja Bane, baaki sab log bhikhari ya banchari, aur poora desh gulam. Angrzon ne saare bhartiyon se ladne ke liye ek naye Sikh dharm ko manyata di, Bhai Bhai ko alag kar diya, mandir, gurudware, saraay, akhade, aashram aur sabhi puja ke sthano par hinduon se chheen kar sikhon ka kabja Kara Diya, fauj aur civil ki naukari, sikh regiments, raje maharaje sikh, baki sab bhikhari ya banchari aur poora desh gulam.
Is desh ki kai jaatyan sadabahar hain jo vakt ko dekhkar, jo jyada khata peeta aur jiska palda bhari hai, unke sath shamil ho jaati hain. Ve bhi in gaddaron me shamil hue aur Raja maharaja bhi Bane.
Kuchh jaatiya esi bhi hain jinko kuchh nahin haasil hua lekin jhoothi shaan ke liye apne ko oonchi jaat ya rajputon ya brahmnon me ginti karne ke liye aatur hain aur in gaddaron me shamil hona chahte hain.
Asli kshatriya aur deshbhakt ve hain jinhone kabhi bhi mughlon aur angrezon ko samarpan nahin kiya, balidan diye, phansi par hazaaron ki tadad me latke, na kabhi jaat badli, na dharm badla. In sab deshdrohion ne milkar unka shoshan Kiya, oonch neech paida kiye, saari suvidhayen chheen leen, inki Jamin jaydaden chheen kar gaddaron ko de di gayeen. Kuchh se to ye itne khafa the aur darte bhi the, jinko sabhi moolbhut suvidha aur naukriyon se vanchit karke jarayam pesha, criminal tribes, chor ki upadhiyan de jangalon me jaanwaron ke saath rahne ko mazboor kar diya. Yah vansh naash ya genocide tha jiska dansh ye jaatean aaj tak jhel rahi hain. Gaddaron ki santanen inhen apni jhoothi shan dikhane ke liye aksar chidhate bhi rahte hain.
Bharat ki Kai jaatian itni swabhimani theen ki unhone kabhi bhi angrezon ko samarpan nahin kiya aur we unki nigaahon me sabse badi rukavat theen. 1857 ke gadar ki shuruaat gurjar dhansingh kotwal jila meerut ki den thee jisko angrezon ne phansi par latka diya tha. Meerut jile ka gazettier aaj bhi is baat ka sabut hai. Mahino baad Mangal pandey ne kartooson ke istemal se mana kar diya tha, use bhi phansi de gayee, vah bhi naman yogya hain, lekin kranti ka janak in rajputon aur brahmnon ki mili bhagat se dhan Singh gurjar ko nahin bata kar Mangal Pandey ko bataya gaya. Jaise gurjar, ahir tatha kai anya jaise chamar, Balmiki ityadi par In logon ne in jaation ke upar jitne atyachar kiye unka lekha tayyar nahin ho sakta. Brahman aur vaishya to har jamaane me apne pushteni peshe me mast the, kabhi koi fark nahi pada. Rajput Raja, maharaja aur baki sabhi kaum bhikhari ya banchari ho gaye. Aur aaj ye hi log OBC SC ST ban kar rah gaye hain jinko ye log abhi bhi vikash ki dhara me shamil nahin karna chahte hain. Gurjar, saansi, thevar v kai anya jaation ko to angrezon ne sampatti se vanchit karke criminal tribes ya jarayam pesha ghoshit kar diya aur sabhi suvidhaon v naukriyon se vanchit kar diya. Yah itihas ka sabse bada vanshnaash ya genocide tha jiska dansh ye jaatian aaj tak jhel rahi hain. Is baat ke upar agar aaj bhi koi vyakti ya sanstha angrezon par genocide ka mukadma antar rashtriya court me chalaye aur genocide ka harzana mange to poora England bik jayega. Ye swabhimani log bheekh to nahin maang sakte the jangalon aur banon me jaanwaron ke saath gujaara karne ko mazboor the. Ye log apne jaanwaron ko charane walon se churane wale bata diye gaye. Kuchh kaumon ka sikhon par bhari karza hai jise ve kabhi nahin utar sakte. Maharaja Ranjit Singh the great was born in a saansi kaum. Dasamguru saheb was born from mata gujari.
.Sikhs think that gurus have done greatest sacrifices, so we have every right to be highest in the society. If enter some gurudwaras, see their museums, pictures of people killed due to various reasons, a sikh will come out as an enemy of Hindus. They are busy in making such paintings in a planned way. Who is doing it. Almost all institutions of Sikhs teach their students in a water tight compartment the messages against Hindus. Openly criticize hindu philosophies. Whole scriptures are based on the criticism of hindu gods and goddesses. If this criticism is taken out there remains nothing in these granths. If a Hindu boy gets admitted in any sikh institution, he will come out as a mentally sick person.
Another bad thing of this religion, fanaticism and cornering the teachings of saints. Only a particular sect is capable to know the teachings, in their own manner, in their books, in their places.
This religion in many aspects is akin to mulla philosophy. They can not think beyond a particular syllabus of madarsa. They brain wash the childern only to a narrow thinking. Same is true with Sikhs. Biggest thing is that they expect everybody to think in their way only to do things in their way only. They don't have compassion for any Hindus. Their charity is great, their services to society are great but full of a narrow philosophy of, only we can do it. Gods and goddeses idols are inanimate, true. But worshipping the granth thinking as animate is praiseworthy.
If you think there is one and only one God it is good. Hindus also say the same thing. This can be said without any criticism.
All Sikhs were born from the soil of this country, from the parents of this society, brought up in this environment, but our Sikhs have bee provided with a spectacle which can see only in very narrow range, think in a narrow range and behave in a narrow range as creation of some other celestial power to hate only Hindus.
Any of the ten gurus did not say it, but for the modern sikh, if he does not criticise Hindus, he is not a sikh. When some body says that he believes in Hindu Sikh unity, it means that he has already realised that both are a separate entity. Otherwise there was no need of any unity. The fundamental difference is again with their dress code with weapons inwhich identifies them different from others. It means one can not be sikh or sishya or disciple by mind but only by dress, not by deeds but by fanaticism.
In their gurudwara they behave in most fantastic way. Once in Delhi I lived in a house which was about 200 meter away from a gurudwara. Every morning I was awake some times at 3 am, some times 4 am due to loudspeakar playing guruwani. Once I was awake at 2 AM due to this nuisance. Nuisance because loud voice in a language which can be understood only by a Punjabi. They don't realise that other people may be sleepless, students disturbed, heart patients at risk. It was cold winters and I decided to visit gurudwara to make a protest. On my visit I could enter easily but there was nobody in the varandah where a record player was running on full volume. When I shouted in loud voice, is there any body over here, an old man appeared from a room which was locked. I told him you are sleeping in a room where this voice can not reach to you, others are sleepless from your lodspeaker. He woke up a boy after opening the doors of another room and said, it is only 2am and you have run the loudspeakar. Boy said, I am sorry, the gurudwara clock is not working so I did it only by chance. It was so funny, they were having sound sleep with no voice and left whole neighbourhood for loud noice which was not understandable. Only out of respect for gurus, Hindus are tolerating their nuisances, but they think it is their birth right.
In almost all cities where ever there is some vacant public land they will occupy it clandestinely as their birth right. Once in a prime park of Delhi some Sikhs put up a tent as they had come to see republic day parade. Inside the tent they started enacting a gurudwara. Fortunately it was seen by some NDMC official in time and they were removed from there with great difficulty. All praise for guru saahibaan but all ............... for present day fanatics. So long they are there with their strange philosophies it will continue and uh it is only a matter of time when public anger is fueled up.
They have another dangerous thinking. Where ever guru saheb passed, all these territories are theirs. They can put a pole any where and call it nishan saheb as if he is a living being, and shall make a gurudwara. If they have a choice, they will convert whole earth into nishan sahibs and gurudwaras with nothing left for others.
In fact it is not their fault, Britishers had identified Sikhs as a separate religion for their nefarious designs of dividing the society in which one child was ogffered to sadhu. They gave them all kinds of favours, power, property, all temples, aashrams, Sarays, akhadad etc by snatching from Hindus. Now they are separate religion with political ambitions and every thing against Hindus.
Vaise to aaj ke jamane me jaati, vansh, khap ya kisi nasl ka koi mahatva saamajik aur vegyanik drashti se nahi hai. Ram Krishna ke baad hazaaron laakhon peedhiyan gujar gayeen, kitne antarjaatiya, antardharmi vivah ho gaye, kitne jayaj ya najayaj sambandh Bane, kitne log vaishyalyon me apne kul ke bachhe paida kar aaye, aur ham abhi bhi kishi ke vanshaj hain. Ham log kab insan banenge, manushya banenge, kab sirf bhartiya banenge, kab visva bandhu banenge. Jai hind
Kitab likho bhai.......yahan jagah kamm hai...
Tankhayia from Buddha dal teaching sikhi.
oh McSikha 2 lina ratne naal gurbani da gyaan ni hunda. GGSJ pad lae pura pher gal kri.
@@sandysandeepful tere nalo zyada he parhe hona. Je Nei tankhayia fer gal kr. Ethe aa ke jabliee na mar.
@Yash Joshi tu oh jehnu pashu keha guru gobind Singh ne
@Yash Joshi 😂😂 tu he siyana jammea. Btw I am not Sikh. I am learning from the granth’s. Tu ta jammea he bhaman ki keh sakde hun
@Yash Joshi dude, you came up with stupid attitude, whatever I said was history with fact, tenu nhi changi lgi, I don’t care.
Nidar is not a Sikh scholars nor is he an good example of a Gursikh. Take what he says with a pinch of salt. Also I feel alot of his martial skills are copied from other martial traditions and made up on the spot. Search bhai sewa sigh tarmala who lived a life of a real Gursikh. .
Kahe ko pahan poojta ha pashu, pahan mein parmeshwar nahi. -Guru Gobind Singh. Now please say we are sanatani 😂😂😂
We are
You are stuck till your neck in the mud of ignorance. May god bring you out of this
@Yash Joshi guru nu galt prove krda tu? Teri Matt mar gai bhamana
@@s1nghxPreet tu bni ja fer shudr ehna da
@@manroopsingh oh yaar tussi saadi sikhi chad do, je musalman bnna taa bn jao, sannu chadd do.
"You are idol worshipper and I am Idol destroyer" --- Guru Gobind Singh ji to hindu Pahari Rajas.
Now say Sikhs are sanatani...
Out of context 😅😢
@@ripalpreetsingh1214 Yes its out of context for the ignorant😀
Is that y he read Chandi do waar?
@@gurpreetkaursandhu Chandi is term of Brahmgyan, which is used as character of Gurmukh in Second Granth of Sikhs, Dasam granth. Chandi is one who fights with demons and finish their existence. Chandi is Will power(Icha Shakti)/Command of God. It is also called Gurmat, which fights with Manmatt.
WHY CARRY RIFLES AND TALWARS ON BODY ALL THE TIME V V WRONG AGAINST LAW PROF JAGBIR SINGH JI TELL THEM OK WHY SO DANGERIOUS AGAINST GURU NANAK DEV AND TODAY BIRTHDAY OF 8TH GURU V YOOUNG NAME IS NOT SINGH NAME IS GURU HAR KRISHAN SAHIB JULY 11 ,2023 YESTERDAY WAS JANAM DIN BIRTHDAY NOT SINGH OK
Futile try by Niddar Singh.
Sikhs are a seperate path, totally different from hinduism.
We do not believe in rituals, fasting, idol worship and worship of devi devtaas.
We believe in one all powerful all prevading waheguru.
We love hindus but we are not hindus or sanantanis.
Guru Nanak rejected the Hindu Janeau and clearly said" Na hum hindu, na mussalmaan"
Guru Gobind Singh even said to pahari rajas-
You are the idol worshippers,
I am the idol destroyer.
How are we sanatani or idol worshipper then.
Niddar Singh condemns idol worship which a true Sanatani can't.
It's just what Sikh Gurus preached. Idol worship is discouraged among Hindu followers of Guru Nanak (Nanak Panthis) and is strictly prohibited for the Khalsa.
They are trying to copy Islam 😂😂😂😂
@@thor797 arya samaj also condems idol worship krishna in geeta says worship gods other than me gives temporary fruits he says following the vedas you can oly attain heaven not mukti he critics veda.
no one asked your op hence get lost
ram ram
@@thor797 read Geeta. Please
You please once read Shrimad Bhagwat Geeta....your doubt will be clear. And moreover Arya Samaj also criticised idol worship. And Sanatan Dharma was based on Nature worship and not Idol worship. First instance of idol worship were from Buddhism and not Hinduism.....you pls read Geeta. And then comment...
Na hum hindu na musalmaan.... Alha Ram ke pind praan....sikh love all religions.... But sikh have ter own unique identity..... Don't try to dilute .... This is a futile exercise...... You ll never succeed... Vry sory for you people 😅😅😅
Sikhs are neither Hindus nor Sanatanis. At the same time they do not hate either. They love them both as they love Muslims, Christians, Jainis or Buddhists. Sikhs are a separate religion with distinct philosophy and principles who love whole humanity.
Veer oh ta sabh thik hai . Haddis te quran padhi aa tusi?? Ya any abrahmic religion. Read and then please compare with guru granth sahib.
Guru Nanak Dev jis parents were Hindus. I hope you know that 😊
Na hum hindu na musalmaan.... Alha Ram ke pind praan....sikh love all religions.... But sikh have ter own unique identity..... Don't try to dilute .... This is a futile exercise...... You ll never succeed... Vry sory for you people 😅😅😅
@@AjitSingh-ol5zk - u r here to divide Hindu and Sikhs?
@@kapilmehta1476 na ham hindu na ham musalmaan guru nanak dev ji told now you want more clear explanation than this
Writing ch mafi likh ke hun ethe propaganda krda firda fake nihung
@Yash Joshi fer nihang kio bolda khud nu , udo jawab ni aya jdo puchea c ehnu? Rakho Tuhada banda RSS da exposed decade ago.
Aukha tera
@@NoOne-dv3gh je nhi likhi mafi fer gal kr. Avein gyan na de
@@manroopsingh khayal-i-stani IQ is negligible, keep barking lolu
Hankar bande di mat mar denda
Tan onu sach disda nahi
Baki aap study kar aatma di aawaz suno
sach sirf sache man ch he prakatda hai or truth always prevails sooner or later
🙏🙏
🙏