Alex: "Necessary things are not contingent" MH: "Is there a necessary existence?" A: "Yes" MH: "Gotcha! That's what we think God is! Also, necessary things explain everything" A: "That's not what I said" MH: "SO YOU TAKE IT BACK?!"
Why do you all think Mohammed won here? Mohammed was clearly taking something Alex said out of context - not even allowing Alex to explain the context.
"It doesnt mean that its god" He hates the idea of god so much that even if his own argument supports god, he would ditch it and go against it even if the latter argument is very bad and easilt refutable.
How can Alex say that this was something he "USED" to believe in, when the statement was not long ago.. There is a short amount of time which when he said it and when this debate was taken place. The statement he made about the link between a "necessary existent" and determinism was just almost 10 months ago, lol.. Here is the link which Hijab is referering to. The conversation starts at 48:00 and onwards. "Debate: Something from nothing? | Alex O'Connor vs Cameron Bertuzzi" Link: th-cam.com/video/DGpkGRoLBQ8/w-d-xo.html . Start from 48:00 and onwards. *A person which are in this field and around these kinds of topics almost everyday, and are very deeply into it, it is very unlikely and questionable that he takes away that kind of statement in that short of timeframe...
I define myself as an atheist but still found the Muslim man to be more reasonable, rational, articulate and fair than I've ever seen any Christian being in a debate. He did not resort to false logic & double-speak (as most Christians do). I think that most Christians don't actually believe what they claim to believe otherwise they wouldn't resort to these kinds of tactics just to "win". These two men worked toward a mutual understanding of each others points.
this doesnt feel like dawah...it feels like egos clashing. dawah is from the heart not logical fallacies. mashallah brother muhammad you have a lot of knowledge but try and give your approach a little less fire and a little more love inshallah :)))) may allah reward you for your efforts akhi
selam alaykum brother, im soooooooo happy you debated him, he was annoying me so much. He kept criticizing unpopular, unknown Muslims who were saying silly things... May Allah bless you guys and may Allah put barakah in your dawah. amin
These debates are a waste of time for me, i dont understand half of these terms. To keep up i have to write down so many words and terms and look them up.
Am I the only one who has noticed this or are Muslims overpowering Atheists lately? Either way, Brother Hijab is a powerhouse. He completely cornered Alex and it's funny seeing him struggle. 😂
Its not down to the moderator to say "this is not speakers corner" shudnt the moderator remain neutral!! Muhammad Hijab simply too good. Alhamdolillah.
It’s quite obvious that the atheist changed the meaning of his argument because he was cornered. Well done brother hijab. Plus I like the way you dealt with him. You didn’t go soft on him and that’s the way it should be.
I watched the debate and Godbless Mo & Abdullah with their patience man, the way the atheist side was going in circular argumentation, me as the viewer was getting annoyed, let alone them.
May Allah ease ur path of doing service to Islam... May all ur work on dawah increase in multiples and may our Lord increase ur life span with much good health.. All d best brother... from srilanka
⚠️ Every person who believes Jesus is the son of God & Jesus has died for their sins is not following the bible correctly : Yet these so called bible followers carry it 📖 around with them telling the rest of the 🌍 these are the teachings of God & must be followed
Is it just me or does the Atheist sound like a robot? Now he might cite that there's problems with the audio. But I choose to believe he's evolved into a robot. Ramadan Mubarak!
I really enjoyed it and every single Mohamed hijab his words it’s full of meaning and truthful without upset masha Allah tabarakallah well done may Allah Swt reward you and bless you with your deen Barakallah I’m very proud of you ❤️❤️❤️
Alex: "Necessary things are not contingent"
MH: "Is there a necessary existence?"
A: "Yes"
MH: "Gotcha! That's what we think God is! Also, necessary things explain everything"
A: "That's not what I said"
MH: "SO YOU TAKE IT BACK?!"
Akhi went in...speakers corner mode 😂
Hahaha
NAH i am not that smart to watch this, i will just re watch his debate to DAVID WOOD
Lol. He changed his argument because he was cornered. Typical insincere people
You got him. His friend brought up speakers corner as a cheap shot 'ad hominem'.
Doesn't matter where else you debate.
You won with style and mind.
They can't win they resort to mocking
They forgot that bro Hijab is a speakers corner lion. He was born for the 1 on 1.
Mohammed Hijab is like Dr Zakir Naik on steroids
"guys this is not speakers corner" 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Why do you all think Mohammed won here? Mohammed was clearly taking something Alex said out of context - not even allowing Alex to explain the context.
then thats god. looool. u got him there. truth has prevailed and falsehood has been destroyed for falsehood by its nature is bound to be destroyed
"Guys we are not in speakers corner" that's so silly of him
An atheist changing his argument when it’s no longer convenient for him... pfff not surprised at all lol
Let me change my belief real quick to counter your argument BTW 😅
Can anyone explain in layman’s English what they were debating in this video. I have not a clue.
"It doesnt mean that its god"
He hates the idea of god so much that even if his own argument supports god, he would ditch it and go against it even if the latter argument is very bad and easilt refutable.
Why change the argument when losing.stick with your statement
How can Alex say that this was something he "USED" to believe in, when the statement was not long ago.. There is a short amount of time which when he said it and when this debate was taken place. The statement he made about the link between a "necessary existent" and determinism was just almost 10 months ago, lol.. Here is the link which Hijab is referering to. The conversation starts at 48:00 and onwards.
"Debate: Something from nothing? | Alex O'Connor vs Cameron Bertuzzi"
Link: th-cam.com/video/DGpkGRoLBQ8/w-d-xo.html . Start from 48:00 and onwards.
*A person which are in this field and around these kinds of topics almost everyday, and are very deeply into it, it is very unlikely and questionable that he takes away that kind of statement in that short of timeframe...
Love you my muslim. Brothers. From Bangladesh. May Allah bless you. More. And more.
Much respect to Alex. Very professional and top notch individual.
A little more practice and your quote mining skills and ability to avoid all context could rival that of Sye Ten Bruggencate.
thanks you ustadz hijab, i have got learning my religion and increase my english speaking.
Lmaoo dude changed his opinion on the argument as soon as it got refuted
I define myself as an atheist but still found the Muslim man to be more reasonable, rational, articulate and fair than I've ever seen any Christian being in a debate. He did not resort to false logic & double-speak (as most Christians do). I think that most Christians don't actually believe what they claim to believe otherwise they wouldn't resort to these kinds of tactics just to "win". These two men worked toward a mutual understanding of each others points.
this doesnt feel like dawah...it feels like egos clashing. dawah is from the heart not logical fallacies.
mashallah brother muhammad you have a lot of knowledge but try and give your approach a little less fire and a little more love inshallah :))))
may allah reward you for your efforts akhi
The geezer right at the end though 🤣🤣🤣
selam alaykum brother, im soooooooo happy you debated him, he was annoying me so much. He kept criticizing unpopular, unknown Muslims who were saying silly things... May Allah bless you guys and may Allah put barakah in your dawah. amin
These debates are a waste of time for me, i dont understand half of these terms. To keep up i have to write down so many words and terms and look them up.
Hijab and Andalusi debating together. dream come true.
Brother hijab Mashallah. The other side of the table couldn’t validate or stick to their claims, they were beating around the bush.
I saw this person in an Arab channel talking to someone from Egypt about atheism
Well he basically admits defeat right there...owned...
Mans quacking in his boots!!! Take them all out brother hijab...
Allahu Akbar, Tabarakallah.
Indonesia here
Am I the only one who has noticed this or are Muslims overpowering Atheists lately?
Either way, Brother Hijab is a powerhouse. He completely cornered Alex and it's funny seeing him struggle. 😂
Its not down to the moderator to say "this is not speakers corner" shudnt the moderator remain neutral!!
Muhammad Hijab simply too good. Alhamdolillah.
Ad hominem Speaker's Corner. Hijab practices on Speaker's Corner and crushes on stage - Mashallah
MashAllah br. Mohammad. Watching you from Egypt 🇪🇬 ❤️
This is taken out of context. But great debate. Honestly spectacular.
Loving it!!! A nice appetiser before I watch the whole thing.
It’s quite obvious that the atheist changed the meaning of his argument because he was cornered. Well done brother hijab. Plus I like the way you dealt with him. You didn’t go soft on him and that’s the way it should be.
Muhammad Hijab, please put indonesian subtitle
Im enjoying this, thanks hijab👍, looks like your smashing them alhumdulilah
He changed his own words because he feels like it. I love how it's so convenient.
For anyone who wants to delve further into the argument Mohammed Hijab used in this debate as well as the background around it google 'Ibn Sina'.
Alhumdulilah may Allah continue to prosper you and give u further knowledge we need more intellectuals like urself may rab ulalameen reward u .. ameen
Bro this was amazing
Mate that wasnt speakers corner mode that was Hijab mode 😁
Loved it
Nice job bro Hijab.Where can i find the full debate?Salam
I watched the debate and Godbless Mo & Abdullah with their patience man, the way the atheist side was going in circular argumentation, me as the viewer was getting annoyed, let alone them.
بارك الله فيكم نرجو وضع ترجمة للمناظرة كاملة..
May Allah ease ur path of doing service to Islam...
May all ur work on dawah increase in multiples and may our Lord increase ur life span with much good health..
All d best brother... from srilanka
Please add subtitle for this clip..
Every single so called sceptic atheist agnostic theologian taking on Islam fails providing the Islamic representative has some knowledge of Islam.
Hahaha now we are on the speakers corner 😂
Hijab is very good at this
so foolish ....a perfect machine comes from nowhere 😂😂😂😂
Ahhh yes "used to believe" of course...
MashAllah brother hijab. May Allah swt bless and persevere you.
Islam is peaceful and truth religion
Determined says nothing. It could be determined otherwise.
Muhammad Hijab you are great man. CONTINUE this with passion
SubhanAllah
Alhumdulillah
AllahuAkbar
When is the full debate coming out?
⚠️ Every person who believes Jesus is the son of God & Jesus has died for their sins is not following the bible correctly : Yet these so called bible followers carry it 📖 around with them telling the rest of the 🌍 these are the teachings of God & must be followed
way to go my brother hijab...
Start a chain of ayat ul kurdi for his protection
Speaker corners standard debate...he3
Is it just me or does the Atheist sound like a robot?
Now he might cite that there's problems with the audio. But I choose to believe he's evolved into a robot.
Ramadan Mubarak!
GOD bless the Muslim brothers.
Mohammad hijab...we as a Muslims are so proud of you❤️
@muhammad hijab, your using Avicenna's برهان الصديقين،
احسنت اخي
There is no lack of atheist in Bangladesh, will you come?
he used modus ponens rule
Speaker *Cosmic Skeptic* Cornered
R.I.P atheisism 🙏
Catch 22 situation for Alex!! 😂
Well done brother in Islam, nice job
HIJAB TURNED ON BEAST MODE 🙂
what is the point when ignorant more power than knowledge
I really enjoyed it and every single Mohamed hijab his words it’s full of meaning and truthful without upset masha Allah tabarakallah well done may Allah Swt reward you and bless you with your deen Barakallah I’m very proud of you ❤️❤️❤️
MashaALLAH may ALLAH increase your knowledge even more bro hijab and save you from nazar
Masha Allah
Alhamdulillah ❤️❤️❤️🔥
Speakers coner mode lol
Alex bit just a tiny little bit more than he could chew.
This atheist guy seeems to be very confused....
Lmao why he so tight with him
What ????
First 🇦🇱
muhammad hijab you are awesome....
MashAllah
☝️
that moment when u r tryin to be a philosopher but u dont know why is the cup possible not necessary
👍👍
Lol knock out SC style
exposed
May Allah bless muhammad hijab ameen may Allah give him more knowledge ameen
‘’Then thats god, debate over, thank you very much’’
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 You are untouchable ! 💪🏼👊🏼🤜🏻🤛🏼
Bodied him
Hijab you solider
Athiests have their own god,athiesmo