CAPTURE ONE 16.3 WITH AI MASKING IS OUT! IS AS GOOD AS LIGHTROOM'S MASKING? TOP 4 STANDOUT FEATURES
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 มิ.ย. 2024
- In this video we look at Capture One's long awaited and much requested AI masking feature. Is it as good as Lightrooms? Watch the video and find out!
I already updated yesterday. Fantastic update. And Capture One makes masks quite accurately and cleanly. And it turns out you can make styles with AI masks, and then apply batch corrections with AI masking. Wow!
You are certainly fast! A lot of people will be switching to Capture One I believe. Good for them, yes the batch processing with AI masking is really useful. I don't LR has the same technology. Good for them, they waited til they came out with a polished feature. Really curious if others can emmulate AI object masking and catch up. I hope so.🙂
Styles with AI masks! My gosh! It's almost exactly like the adaptive presets they've had in LR for nearly two years. Only ... not as accurate or flexible and near-useless for landscape photography. Other than that - great!
Have to try these styles/adaptive presets myself to see why one is better than the other!
Since the masks in 95% of my attempts, I think this masking is on par with what Topaz could offer 20 years ago! This is at the moment a joke, but will probably (hopefully) be usable in the future.
I have never deleted a software that fast from my computer. Honestly, can you tell me one single program that make worse masks? Try to select a person and try to add a graduated filter on top of that. LOL
Awesome, rigorous, and very illustrative video. I agree with you, implementation in CO is more friendly than in LR. Thanks a lot for this content.
Thanks. I made the video not knowing what others thought waiting for LR users to correct me. But none have so far.
For me, one thing I miss in C1 update is "intersecting masks". About the method used by each, I like C1 a little bit more.
Yes their technology in intersecting not as good as lightroom which is seamless
Video perfect!
Thanks!
Can it automatically select people, and their features? Faces, cloths, body parts? I have been using C1 since 2017 and love the speed of the interface vs. LR. But, I just went back to LR a few weeks ago and am BLOWN away at the AI in LR (and the new PS). For me (which is a wedding, and portrait photographer) it's a far better match for that type of work. But,, I am glad to see C1 is at least offering something in the AI (even though it looks faily basic).
it can automatically select the subject, but it doesn't have the one click select of hair, teeth of etc of lightroom...You can manually select it though by dragging a rectangle over the hair, face, teeth etc as shown in the video
Great comparison😀I much prefere Capture one Ai mask over Lightroom. More simple and easy to use. And Capture one has refine tools make it for me the the best option to choose Capture one
Yes I agree. I guess they did the right thing and thought through how lightroom's methodology could be improved. I always thought that there were too many steps but then again they pioneered this technology.🙂
I would have liked to see a more detailed look at the hairselection. How good is it? I has to be good to be useful!
It is actually pretty good. The sample I gave in the video was not a simple problem but Capture One handled with no effort. However let me see if I can test it out with others.
As a real estate photographer, I would love to see the masking feature used for masking windows in a room, allowing a window pull to be achieved, I currently use Lightroom to do this and it’s hit and miss on many windows usually includes the window frame which involves an extra step painting the frame out, in the video with the boat I was impressed with how you removed the windows, could the same technique be used in reverse, probably by inverting the mask?
Yes, in Capture One masking can be done on its own layer which you can invert. The recommendation from capture one is to zoom in really close to be able to mask small details like perhaps the window frame.
Thank you
I did download the 30 day trial and checked it out on a dozen real estate photos, unfortunately I found the masking quite sporadic and not as accurate as I was hoping for, both in distance and close up view, hopefully this will get better in time, but for now I’ll be keeping with LR & PS
Ok thanks for the feedback!
Update: since being a little disappointed with my first attempt at using the new masking tool, I have been trying different techniques and feel that I have found the perfect solution, rather then using HDR images processed through LR, I decided to process my images through Aurora and found that C1 works brilliantly for masking the windows in a room with very few spill over onto the window frame, I am so excited to learn all about Capture One and move forward away from LR & PS
I’d be curious how well this works on files from the Leica monochrom cameras
Capture One explicitly says they work with Leica files on their website. I'll be surprised if there's an issue.
I mean in the sense of how well selections would work if the files are only in black and white. I'm kinda thinking without color it may be less accurate.
@@takebetterphotos8132
Yes that's possible but that would be a poor limitation if that were. Will try this and see!
ACDSee Photo Studio Ultimate 2024 has AI object selection. Ditto Luminar Neo. Also no intersections for masks? I mean, I'm glad Capture One have finally added some AI masks, but it's a pretty basic implementation.
Hi ACDSee has AI object selection in their layers editor not in the RAW editor yet (Develop module). As for luminar neo, they do a limited set foliage, sky, people but as far as I'm aware you can't select over an unknown object and have luminar detect it as an object. I haven't used luminar neo lately but let me know if I'm misinformed.
Acdsee added the AI selection in their latest version. but doesn't ON1 do AI object selection better than all of these?
ON1 has an excellent quick mask AI but I don't believe the masking is not as accurate nor is their UI as polished as Capture One's. That being said its still very good. Their Brilliance AI also does its own object masking of skies, foliage, people etc...also pretty good.
@@takebetterphotos8132 best in class object selection is Lightroom Classic - by a mile. I've been testing C1's extensively and it's very hit and mess with fringe bleeds into colours and weird bleeds where there is very strong edge definition. I can drag the LR object brush around a pale cloud and LR will nail it.
Thanks for the feedback. Won't be surprised if you stress test object masking that lightroom would come out on top. From my own photos though didn't really see anything that was a glaring issue for C1 that I needed LR to solve it.
At 7:31 you seem to be selecting the lower lip, which results in a masking of the entire face. This detail is taken care of in LR. But with the masking system in e.g. the free raw editor Darktable, this is not a problem at all without AI. Just takes a bit longer (maybe), which in that case could cause a terrible waste of time for the AI disciples with their tailored smart-flows.
Oh for that was the preview kicking in. When you move the mouse over an object, it will highlight a preview of the object detected. In that case I must have moved the mose over the face. You still have to click it to confirm it as a selection. Alternatively, you can drag a rectangle over the object to make the selection. The behavior is similar to ON1's super select AI 🙂 Lightroom doesn't give any previews so wont have this behavior.
@@takebetterphotos8132 No, I am aware of the selection via a rectangle with C1, I just missed that it was the preview. But what would happen when you - as far as I could see - drew a rectangle around the lower lip and entered it. Will it select the lower lip or both lips?
Let me go to capture one and check this again 🙂
@@takebetterphotos8132 All right.
I purchased the update and instantly regretted it. I had over 80 headshots that a customer requested the solid gray backgrounds knocked out to white. I purchased the upgrade specifically because of the new masking features and it failed on at least 75% of the images. It selected skin tones, patterns in fabric, etc. Almost every single mask had to be manually adjusted... and THEY WERE SOLID GREY BACKGROUNDS. This functionality is limited and in my personal experience, worthless. I could've done the masking quicker in v.22 with the selection tool. Add to the poor performance the fact that Capture One is now obsessed with selling subscriptions, I see a switch back to lightroom in my future. I won't even go into the complete lack of pricing transparency for customers looking to upgrade.
Thanks for the feedback. Just to understand, you were trying to automatically mask with styles and capture ones AI failed on 75 percent?
I 100% agree with you.
I was using the "Background" selection feature.@@takebetterphotos8132
ok let me try replicate it on some samples for both lightroom and capture one.
Capture One is a better, more professional tool. But in their race to catch up, and probably lack of manpower, they have forgotten in the way to finish underdeveloped basic tools, like keystone or reframe tool, which is a pity.
Thanks for the info! What's the issue with their keystone in your view?
Да, действительно, маскировка в лайтрум раздражает своим неудобством.
Yes indeed, amount of steps can be reduced
Excellent video, thank you! I'm Alexander Svet, a photographer and Capture One expert. I follow your work and love your Capture One tutorials! I develop various products for Capture One: styles, video tutorials, ebooks. I think we have a lot of opportunities for our partnership. You have a large audience of Capture One photographers and I offer excellent Capture One products with up to 30% commission for my affiliates. If you're interested, I'd be happy to provide you with free copies of all my styles! What do you think?
Hello Alex thank you for your invitation. What kind of products are available? I am not really a user of styles very much
Actually better AI interface than lightroom
I do agree as well, I prefer their more coherent UI design. Though lightroom is faster and more responsive.