Can You Hear the Difference Between a Tuned and Out of Tune Piano?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 มิ.ย. 2024
- Can you hear the difference between a tuned piano and a out of tune piano? Hear that test!
My Piano Course: bit.ly/2YHI5S6
Be a Member! bit.ly/2Nlupas - บันเทิง
Little known fact about Vinheteiro: He can't miss a note because if he does that portrait behind him comes to life and stranggles him to death
MostlyLost it talks to him while he sleeps
That’s mozart as a kid btw
Thats not even the most amgry portrait he owns
I think the portrait (That is the kid Mozart xd) Would stranggle his balls for each mistake, this way he has become a master.
@@manoelfernandez3461 that would make him a Master Baiter
Has anyone else noticed he moves the painting in the back whenever he switches piano so it always stares at you
Corey i think there was a mirror back on the black one
No then it would not be in other videos and also it would be turned through the mirror
Boarding Life you re right just wanted to appeal
Daddy Amadeus
ann_ lmao
out of tune has little echo bounces, but ironically it has more mood
고옹 that’s probably just how the piano sounds but if def is flat it’s very obvious for notes on the middle part of the keyboard
The pieces I knew sounded odd to me on the out of tune one, the ones I did'nt know just sounded diffrent to the samples from the tuned one.
Thousand like
oh, hankookin balgyeon!
@@kwon06 OH!NADO
Somehow it feels like the out of tune piano has more character, which might not be good for classical music but sounds very good with more “informal” styles
Liana Schwarz yep. I love the entertainer on the out of tune piano!
This is why us musicians collect different instruments. I'm sure he likes the tone of both.
Phasing my friend!
Kyle you guys missing the point. It’s not about tone, that older piano needs to be tuned. It sounds cool sure, tone wise. The pitch of the notes is off and dissonant. If you can notice it, it’s not pleasing. The tone of the piano maybe pleasing, but the dissonance from it being out of tune is not. Not easy to pick up small differences like that unless you have trained ears.
Jake Zee I don’t think anyone missed the point lol the dissonance is very clear but from a stylistic standpoint it’s interesting to hear, I’d rather hear the out of tune entertainer in say a period piece movie than the in tune version
The out of tune Piano sounded like it was going through a chorus effect. It actually didn’t sound bad to my ears.
try to listen trough the chorus and on the actual notes. on some it wouldnt make that much difference but on the classical ones with very clear single notes its horrible
Thats essentially what chorus is. One straight normal line and a wiggly slightly out of tune one.
No, because all the keys are out of tune. It wouldn't sound bad
the1trueporkchop Right！
The second piano is out of tune but is still tuned. It's common to tune old pianos slightly flat to reduce tension on string.
Interesting note. The tuning of all pianos are offset because the frequencies between octaves don't double. If a piano was perfectly tuned the lowest A and highest A would sound out of tune
The "Out of tune" piano sounds like a Saloon piano to me (and ironically, "The Great Entertainer" sounded much better in that piano)
That’s because they would purposely leave saloon pianos out of tune in order to produce that twangy sound.
The Entertainer was written on those kind of pianos anyway
Yes it's the musical soul of Scott Joplin
I would imagine that the saloon pianos of old only sounded like that because nobody bothered to keep them tuned. They probably got quite a hammering from all sorts of people!!
Sounds like my piano lol 😂 not paying almost £100 to tune it
There’s no way I’m the only one who thinks The Entertainer sounds better slightly out of tune
it"s true th-cam.com/video/g8syRhvSZdk/w-d-xo.html
Ragtime sounds best on a honky tonk.
it gives it style Dx
God Christ Jesus bless you all :" )
It gives it an old timy bar or cantine feel
The untuned piano sounds more “hollow” while the tuned sounds “solid.” Sorry, I’m not really familiar with piano terminology.
@@technicalthug just who died and made you queen of everything ( cleaned that up )
@@technicalthug as another OVER EDUCATED and lacking manners ....
@@ivanolsen7966
How are they being disrespectful or rude?
Ivan Olsen I don’t think he or she was being rude but rather saying that they didn’t have much knowledge about the piano either and were just saying their opinion of what it sounded like to them.
It's probably just because of the different piano. Also, Ivan Olsen, can you please calm down?
Pieces:
0:00 - Nocturne is C# Minor by Frederick Chopin
1:07 - The Entertainer by Scott Joplin
1:49 - Nocturne in Eb Major by Frederick Chopin
2:47 - Arabesque no. 1 by Debussy
3:47 - Rondo in D Major by Mozart
4:32 - Pineapple Rag by Scott Joplin
(HELP ME BY COMMENTING THE PIECES IM MISSING)
2:47 is the Arabesque n 1 by Debussy
2 :48 1st Arabesque Debussy
Debussy - Arabesque
Other way round in your format
@@inanis9801 Thank you
"If a piano is falling on your head, you better C# or you'll Bb."
-Anonymous
Just Bnatural
*See sharp,* or you'll *be flat.*
You're so Sol(G) Ti(B)!
You’ll be Ab person if u aren’t # too
if a piano is falling on your head, you'll see Gsus
The "out of tune" piano sounds like the typical recording of a late 60s saloon piano concert.
1860’s maybe...saloons went out of style in the early 1900’s
An old western saloon as it has been bashed so many times it has detuned!
The out of tune piano feels like it has a soul
Can’t relate
@@udontsubugay86 Edgy
and also tryna escape out of it😂
Feels kind’ve of haunted
Because it’s old. It would still have that sound if it was tuned, it just wouldn’t sound like shit melodically.
Young Mozart is staring into our souls as well.
Paul Osborne that’s what I said 😂
*Young Mozart has joined the party*
Seriously did he move the picture for the filming on the two pianos...? I was looking through the comments to see if anyone had noticed !
@@braddusfaction5996 Actually no, look exactly, the portrait stands beside the newer piano, but there's a mirror beside the other one. When he's playing on one piano, you can't see what's directly beside it, but only that, what is beside the other piano in the background.
Also the Entertainer what he plays is on a 1915 piano x
I bet those yellow keys smell like cigarettes and broken dreams.
Haha...Nice line. Write a song around it.
Why broken dreams? Why couldn’t it have been owned/played by a happy, successful person?
@@ViaticalTree You've obviously never been in a bar during a time when smoking was permitted.
sockcutter I’ve been in plenty of smoky bars. Never one with a piano in it.
@@ViaticalTree Plenty of bars had pianos in them. Also get a fucking sense of humor. Your the reason nobody invites spergs to parties.
The "out of tune" piano is, OBVIOUSLY, out of tune; however, the "tuned" piano is out of tune, as well.
Brian Bennett THANK YOU lol I thought so too.
I was thinking the same thing! Sounds a bit tinny.
What a relief, I thought it was just me!! 😅
you are a Ling Ling noticing this
@@marijo268 iNtErEsTiNg piano tuning
It's important to remember that a "tuned' piano is, in fact, simply "evenly out-of-tune" because it's using tempered intonation rather than just intonation.
Well that my friend depends entirely on how you define tuning.
So an in tune piano is, well, in tune.
The untuned piano sounds so good for ragtime
Noodleman they use untuned pianos for ragtime and saloon music
What song in test 2?
fitall o “The Entertainer” by Scott Joplin
fitall o The Entertainer by Scott Joplin
@@fitallo8440 The entertainer
I can hear it easily,but this out-tuned piano sounds great playing ragtime,jazz or soundtrack in old cinemas with silent movies..
That's more true than you think.
I couldn’t concentrate with that dude staring at me like that.
That seems to be his shtick.
He was thinking the same about you😆
Pro tip : *look* *away*
LOOOLL ME TOO!! I haven't even watched the video yet and I'm laughing!!
I got distracted by the painting placement until I realized that he had just set up for two separate angles and spliced the footage from those angles together
The out of tune piano sounds like a totally different kind of piano to the point that I'm not even sure this proves anything. I can hear a lot of note bouncing and some strokes sound totally mismatched to the song pitch, but really to me I think it would have been a better comparison if both pianos were identical save for the tuning (Though I understand this isn't exactly possible, pianos aren't cheap LOL just trying to make a point).
Then again, I could be wrong, both pianos are supposed to sound identical, and this was exactly the point of the video. I'm honestly not sure.
Exactly. This comparison is pointless as they are two different pianos. Only one variable should be changed when comparing.
You’re listening for the wrong thing. Don’t care about tone; you’re trying to hear the notes that are out of tune. The out of tune piano sounds awful (not the tone, the dissonance in the intervals of the chords).
@@jaakezzz_G get the hell out of here mate. Trying to be better than everyone else. I am here just to enjoy the piano sense I do play after all.
@@learningchannel3850 Calm down there, he's got a point, I want to make sense of what I'm listening to
Cost is no excuse. Take an out of tune piano, record the playing. Tune it, re record the same songs.
Those old saloon songs only work on out of tune pianos
Exactly! Especially "Entertainer", it sounds more authentic
What's the name of the song by the way
"An out of tune pianer? I LOVE out of tune pianers!"
I like out of tune pianos they sound better in my opinion idk if it’s the character it gives them but from playing a while grands almost sound computer generated because of how clean they sound. But classical sounds way better on a grand. Idk that’s just my opinion *I’m a ragtime pianist btw that’s probably why*
Ragtime...
The out of tune piano makes ragtime sound as it's supposed to.
I agree! I would rather hear ragtime played on that out of tune piano than on a piano that’s in tune any day!!!
It has a different colour of tone too.
@Disobedient One yep, it absolutely has a nice sound, cannot lie.
@Disobedient One
It seems slightly detuning a piano really isn't that different from slightly detuning a synth, you get a different but still highly musical sound.
Agreeed
I'd say the out of tune piano works more with the ragtime style, just because u get the vibe that it's a piano that hasn't been tuned for years at a saloon.
Guido Mista Off-key pianos have a tendency to sound surprisingly good with romantic music as well and the odd melancholy classical-classical piece.
People with perfect pitch: *Physically dying*
Comlet Mix yesss
I'm not PP but the pain is real
Comlet Mix um sorry chief im chillin
Very sad times
So that people can't listen harpsichord or baroque music (baroque tuning)
Plot twist: None of the pianos were in tune
technically no piano is ever in tune
Ditto ditto! 😁
うぉ〜でぃん ....... Korg Legacy Digital edition is always in tune,........i know im being pedantic, but you didn’t say genuine piano and you was also being pedantic that allows me to feel that i am allowed to. 😂😂
@@wohdinhel - technically, you are right, because they use a tempered scale on pianos. If they did not do so, the piano would sound in tune on some keys and out of tune on others. So, be as pedantic as you wish.
@Howardsend88 negative
I definitely hear the difference, but I can't say that out of tune piano sound bad.
It's got more of a "Saloon" Vibe to it I feel
Honkie Tonk Piano
James Jdog same here! Especially with that 2nd tune which sounds like background for some silent movie...
becouse isn't out of tune technicly
You wanna hear my piano, it’s been out of tune for about 12 years
It genuinely sounds “normal” to the human brain as long as the difference between the notes remains the same.
If you know the song really well tho you’ll notice
bittewarten 🤔 no. Sounds WAY DIFFERENT. The notes are not the same....
Most people have relative pitch which is what you are referring to. Some people have perfect pitch and can recall the sound of a note or the "feeling" of a note from memory or are able to tell the exact letter pitch (c,d,b,g,f#, etc) of a note they just heard, even if it is in between letter pitches (between f# and G for example). The difference in the notes makes it sound fine, but you can IMMEDIATELY tell the its out of tune if someone has perfect pitch even if they havent heard the song before.
piano notes are created with multiple strings (except for the very low notes), so when they are not tuned the same, a single note on a piano can be out of tune. ;)
Tree it’s real fun seeing how good the ears are, when you have a tuning box, you tune it yourself, AND THEN turn on the tune box and see how close you are. WHEN, I did play guitar, I could get that thing so close, one string usually needed a partial (1/64)twist to get it
Tree yes, very few have “absolute” musical ear, most, including me, have “relative” pitch appreciation. I barely can feel if the individual note is b or c unless i hear them one after the other, not in the same piece starting with different notes. Some people can’t even hear the relative pitch.
why compare this with two pianos that sound completely different in the first place, regardless of tuning
Because it's easier than retuning the piano.....
@@Silverado6505 yeah no shit
defeats the point of comparing them though
Notes are universal. a G on a guitar is the same as a G on a clarinet, and the same as a G on a french horn. The instrument being different shouldn't change tone of the note.
@@MsRheyRhey that only goes for sine waves.
different instruments will have different harmonic content on top of the fundamental frequency of the note you play. which is why comparing a slight difference in tuning should be done with matching instruments.
@@MsRheyRhey Wow, I didn't know that if you played a G on a drum, an oboe, and a violin that all of them would sound completely identical. Why even have different instruments if they all make the exact same sounds?
Am I the only one who noticed young Mozart in the frame changes place and look into our souls?
me too
You're not alone, bud. I noticed that too!
I noticed too. I was just like "oh hey, Wolfie." *switches pianos* "Oh. Hey. . . again. . ."
I saw it too
It's so creepy!
Scott Joplin sounds much better on the out-of-tune pianos...
I was just thinking the same thing... think it's more about other factors than the tuning, but it definitely sounded more appropriate on the upright.
@@zhazhagab0r Which one isn't upright?
@@markuzick lol you are right, my brain is frozen. Not used to seeing exposes innards on an upright & since I was mostly listening than watching, I just short-circuited to grand.
It’s also bcs of the sound of the piano. And Back in the days the tuning used to be different
Marcos Daniel Moyano for real tho
You can easily tell that the second piano is out of tune, because everything is like 10-cents sharp!
I just want to put my two cents in here.
@@eti313 yah. Iirc there were captions too.
Except if it was tuned at 438, it's actually a few cents *flatter* then 440
wrong.
I think both sound amazing :) Out of tune pianos have so much charm to them, providing they are in tune enough to have some kind of harmony still!
My monitor only goes to 144Hz, how the hell am i going to hear the difference then??
Human eye can only see a 60 fps so you can't hear it
@@jakubs6793 human eye can only see 8gb of ram
Monitor isn't usually for hearing, but for watching.
Ξενοφώντας Σούλης whooöoosh
R/wwooooosshiewoosh why can't people understand a fecking joke
The untuned piano's notes will have a slight frequency offset which will produce the "phasing" effect commonly used in synthesizers. This is why it sounds different (and in some cases "better") than the tuned piano.
Being in tune, means all musical notes are at the correct intervals.
A-440hz is the standard we use today.
A-420hz was the standard at one point in musical history.
A-432hz is just as acceptable.
What matters, is that all the other notes are tuned to match the different frequencies. Which is where 12-tone equal temperament comes in. So long as 12-TET is used, the piano is, in tune, just tuned to a different frequency.
Break the 12-TET, THEN we will have ourselves a piano that isn't tuned.
@@deathsheir2035 The very obvious phasing effect, caused by interference between the wavelengths, means that the individual strings are not tuned to each other. (There are 2-3 strings per note in a piano). Although the piano itself is in tune enough for the notes to fit within the 12-TET standard, the individual note strings are not perfectly in tune with each other. This also means the whole "438HZ" thing doesn't really make a difference.
Ah, I remembered physics class that taught me slight different frequencies cause plural peaks in a phase and that's called howling sound, if my understand is correct.
@@user-nt3rn4ne7y haha m00t on your playlist
@@waveplasma1369 Exactly! Couldn't have said it better myself. Thanks for having a brain and using it.
In 90s we had the out of tune piano in school ( for the music lessons, concerts and so on), so it sounds quite normal to my ear.
Thank you, this helped us so much!
I honestly don't care. I just came here to listen to you play the piano 😁
Wow μια ελληνιδα που δεν βλεπει τις μπουρδες της ελλαδας
so do i
@@jax4952 iparxoun kai paidia pou exoun kati sto kefali, oxi monw mpourdes xD
Same
@@domi3821 if u play the piano nice i play the guitar
*LingLing can feel the resonance of all pianos in 100 sqkm and tune 15 pianos in one second using his force*
ps. Pianos out of tune sound dayum nice，I need one at home
yasss 😂 where the linglings at?
LangLang bru LingLing plays violin
What are You doing you should be practicing your 40hours a day ! 😂
@@athallaabhinayaxmipa3376 ling ling can play anything perfectly
Ling ling doesnt have time for that, hes always practicing
i honestly love the reverberation you get from an out of tune piano, it's very good for setting allot of moods
Aww!! The Great Entertainer brought back memories! I used to play that back in grade four
Name of video should be : Classical piano vs western piano
Ouch.
Classical piano vs Saloon piano!
Steinways exist!
That’s pianE, not pianO
Name of the video should be teacher pianos vs practice room pianos
The out tune piano sounds like piano from old West films.
Marcio Magno sounds like the piano at my school
that might be because the recording devices weren't as good before the earlier half of the 20th century.
that woman in the background freaked me out.
Naiver Miigon that's... Mozart... Not a woman.
@@markbuckman1211 LMAO
🤦🤦😄
lmaoo
Honey..... that’s.... that’s Mozart..... how could you think it’s a woman????
1:50
What a coincidence! I'm learning this on piano. It's fun to play.
Of course if he doesn't stare at us Baby Mozart will as well
Lol
Ikr
Imma need you to start putting the songs in the description
One Good Meme the first one is a Chopin nocturne (I think Rousseau did a video with this one IIRC)
The second one is the entertainer by Scott Joplin
The third one is yet another Chopin nocturne, op 9 no. 2
The fourth one is arabesque no. 1 by Debussy
The fifth one is rondo in d major by Mozart
The sixth one is the pineapple rag by Scott Joplin
One Good Meme its not a song it’s a piece.
The Beaups “someone didn’t use the proper word so I’m gonna show how smart I am by correcting them”
Very easy to distinguish the two. I actually like the out of tune sound for certain types of music. It evokes a feeling reminiscent of hearing a piano in an old saloon. Reminds me of my glory days back in the 1800s.
Stares at camera intensely: “Do you hear this shit!?”
Honey I need to order a second piano.
Wife: why?
Husband: we need one that's out of tune.
Wife: But why?!
Husband: THIS IS IMPORTANT MAGGIE!
Liaten to me, Maggie.
Rayssa Monroy liaten
Э
Go listen to some quarter-tone music composed for two pianos, one of which is tuned a quarter step higher than the other. There's your use case.
Saddly he doesnt has a wife. He is looking to find a nice champola hahahahh
Well, clearly. The old out of tune piano always reminds me of a saloon fist fights in a western movie. :)
Ohhhh Nocturne in Eb major sounds so good on the out of tune one
the sine waves out of sync by a few hz gave a really cool flanger/phaser lobe type modulation....
Me: overclocking my pc
Vinheteiro: overclocking his piano
Actually under-clocked the piano. 2nd one is flat.
Playing "the entertainer" on a detuned piano just adds a little extra charm to the song, it's like it was meant to be played that way!
not a song
piece of music?
@@alexradu1921 What else do you think I mean lol
@1Me Neither is this one :-)
@1MeThats what I meant ;0
In a time when all we see is perfect people with perfect lives... the imperfect piano is more relatable. It might not be in perfect tune but it still has its own voice . Its not trying to be what people say it should be. It has its own unique identity that gives songs new personality. Buying a piano in tune would be easy. But buying a piano to these exact measurements would be a task
Some studios have 440 and 442 as the later is for a lighter pop music tuning. Although, the 3 strings per note are each needed to be different for a ringing quality, the bass is slighter lower than pitch and the treble slightly higher across the full range.
Doesn't matter whether the piano is tuned or untuned, Vinheteiro will make it sound it the best!
It sounds like ragtime was composed almost perfectly to be played on an untuned piano?
100%
My thought too. The Entertainer sounded perfect at 438.
Not so much. Modern ears associate both rag time and out of tune pianos with a stereotype. It seems better because it's what you expect.
And the out of tune piano is out of tune, not tuned to 438. That would be tuned and only well trained ears hear that small of a difference.
The Entertainer sounded MUCH better untuned..
Albert Yang I thought it sounded better on the tuned piano.
As someone who once held dreams of grandeur in regards to the piano, the out of tune one is soothing, as it holds the nostalgia that makes the warm fuzies.
When I’m home I practice one a 1800’s piano, and when I go to my piano lesson I play on 2000’s piano, the difference is a lot!
You think that piano is out of tune! You should see mine.😂
For mine, some of the notes in bass clef actually sound like a banjo
Yeah mine too lol, its very out of tune, even some keys stick too much
If you want to see how bad it is, I actually uploaded a video of it. I have no idea what would make it make that sound
Mine had to be purposefully tuned a semitone out to avoid damaging the strings and frame lol
Ling Ling would be able to sense an out of tune piano by just feeling its vibrations
Hello
Justin ! You are faster than me!
Big daddy is already here
Why do i see your comments everywhere
If you L¡Ke this and 与uß to me your crush will ask you out :-):-)
I’ll 与uß to everyone who
与ußs to me ;-) ;-)-)) :-)
Man I love your piano and those beautiful violins
It's like a piano being played through a leslie cabinet.I love it!
The "Out of tune" piano have some flanger effects with loss ot sound purity.
The ragtime songs sounded better on the out of tune piano
@sploofmonkey agh, just tried to listen to it, but I can hear and can't stand that she isn't in tune with the band.
No. Definitely did not.
@@notinterested8452 we're all entitled to our own opinions
@@GriffXJ yes.
@@KazzakRaider Sounded jazzy to me... but what's the difference in jazzy and out of tune?
I really wish that we could do this sort of tuning test with the same piano... I think it would be a lot easier to tell
The out of tune piano sounded like “Prey - Reprise” by Myuu from The Dark Piano. They have the same echo vibe
I don't know if what I'm hearing is the out of tune difference, or the sound difference between a piano and a honk tonk thing 🤷♂️
The out of tune piano sounds like the background of a Western bar scene. A poorly tuned piano might add authenticity to a house of ill repute. I think Hollywood has also used poorly tuned instruments in the horror genre. Because we are sensitized to these sounds, we may not consider them poor so much as different.
Harpsicord
sunfeatherX3 NO ITS NOT!!! Its a violin
@@sunfeatherX3 it's just a Brite piano
That Mozart picture is everywhere
Mesmo estando desafinado, se a desafinação for por completo continua agradável aos ouvidos, porque estamos acostumados a apreciar o que está num padrão..
I liked the tuned one. I thought I’d like the out of tune more.....but I didn’t. You play so wonderfully. 🥰🖤🎶.
I can hear the difference, it's SO subtle but it's driving me insane
It’s not exactly subtle. In fact, it’s pretty vulgar. It’s easier to tell when a piano is out of tune than almost any other instrument.
I think it’s subtle for you because you’re not musician, are you ? (Sorry for my english btw, i’m french)
@@thereyougoagain1280 true. Probably the fact that each piano key plays two or three strings, which can be out of tune between them, helps a lot.
No, I'm a musician, I just don't play the piano. If it was say, a guitar, or something like that, I'd be able to tell Immediately. Yes I know they're both stringed instruments
@@Darkopolypse98 hey same, I can tell if a guitar is un tuned even in the slightest
Sound engineer: Why you using an out of tune piano??
Piano player: It's the sound I'm going for man...
@Praise the Sun You obviously not heard or seen Spectre sound Studios here on you tube land..
@@TechGamer45 That guy is a loud mouth old-school elitist metal head who wants everyone to write and record the exact same way every classic metal or hard rock band did, which is why every band I've seen him involved with sounds like boring butt-rock for boomers who can't get over the fact that rock music has evolved past Blizzard of Oz or generic metalcore.
Sorry, I saw Spectre and got triggered.
@Praise the Sun You would think so But it happens.
@Praise the Sun I would ask that. Helps get behind the artists intention and possibly support it technically as well. For example, using a vintage mic to pick up the sound, if the intention is to make it sound old.
so basically, animal collective recording feels
1:30 this gives me western vibes :D it’s like a talented player rocks his notes on an old bar piano xD
Honestly i couldn't see much different. Good job! :)
Well, ragtime sounds right on a detuned piano. Classic and Romanticism in this pitch sound like it's 4th grade and you're in music class
I don't know, I think I liked arabesque better on the out of tune piano.
I don't know, I think I liked arabesque and rondo on the out of tune piano better.
Не настроенное - звук, знакомый с детства! Во всех школах, актовых залах, у соседей, чья дочка учится играть ... ММмммм....
Ет точна:)
даа)
А щас у каждого цифровое пианино за 100к)
..а может это клавесин ? =)
@@FREM1337 не у каждого
One thing I find quite interesting is listening to / playing old pieces on historic instruments. Mozart sounds quite nice on modern pianos, but for me it is more fun to play his pieces on a Spinett, it just adds some hilarious Sound variety.
I was watching one of my old piano videos from years a go (I was around 8 or 9) that my mom sent me. My piano was so out of tune I don’t even know how I played it! I have the same piano now (it is tuned) and it sounds so different
Каждый раз, когда музыкант смотрит в камеру, у меня ощущение, будто он знает про все мои грехи.
А мне он как буд то в душу смотрит. И знает чем я по ночам под одеялом занимаюсь.)
PUTIN!!!
@@besthouseadventuresstar5032 ...The best!!!
Wut
девид блейн)
Q : What happens if you throw a piano down a mineshaft?
A : You get 'A' flat miner
I've always heard the answer as "A miner be flat"/"A minor b flat"
@@Richard_Nickerson No musician on Earth says it like that
@@mickkennedy1344
Well, since I'm a musician and that's how I know it, and I learned it from a musician, I think my comment's existence proves your statement to be completely false.
@@Richard_Nickerson I've been a musician for 49 years, been to other countries and met musicians from all over the world -- never ever heard any of them describe Ab minor as 'Am bFlat ' -- there's an entire big world outside America, 'theory' is for non-natural musicians
@@mickkennedy1344
Oh I get it. You straight up misunderstood or misread me.
You're an idiot.
Well, it would be great to hear this comparison on two equal pianos. I ve tried that on two Yamaha keyboards and it was difficult to notice, but I must say that playing both at the same time sounded very weird
point well made to the ear,but some temperance is required to get along with all the keys and not be limited to just
The Entertainer always sounds better on an outta tune piano 😉
GOTCHA 😜
And remember, young Mozart is watching you from behind
I thought the same lol
OML XDDD
Lol😂😂
It must have been dreadfully annoying to switch it back and forth like that...
Ok. It's weird when you have one guy staring at you... He did NOT have to call in BACKUP! HE DOES IT WELL ENOUGH BY HIMSELF!!!
I love how he just stares at you to make sure you're paying attention.
The slightly out of time version makes it sound old western. Like kinda what you would hear in a saloon. Tone wise that is.
You have to also realize it's an entirely different kind of piano, it's like comparing a rock guitar to a jazz guitar
@@DaRat100 I didn't even know that. I didn't watch the video. I listened to the video. as soon as I hit play I closed my eyes because I wanted my ears to be the only thing telling me stuff.
The second one doesnt have an accurate sounds of notes, it feels like when u are using a key, it produces various note sounds, not just one.
Well done ! In facts, that's exactly what's appenning in an untuned piano : each note on the piano is composed of multiples strings, and with time each string change tune in a different manner. That's why there is a difference between a piano that is artificially out of tune, where the notes are off, but each string of a note has the same tune as the others, and an untuned piano in which individual strings are out of tune.
Ненастроенное пианино звучит как в кабаках из фильмов про ковбоев
Не так уж и важно, на компе можно донастроить звучание если идёт запись отдельным треком от других инструментов
это фертепиано
Yeah that’s right!
Да я тоже вспомнил фильмы о ковбоях!
@@sergey54716 как ты сделаешь, чтобы, в уже записанном треке пианино, интервалы звучали неравномерно, как на этом старом пианино?
The out of tune piano has a lot of character still. It reminds me of fuzzy warm memories of my early childhood. It has a very nostalgic tone to it, and i feel like someone could do something by intentionally using an out of tune piano.
Edit: i just got an idea. A movie or game or something that has out of tune piano music at the beginning and becomes tuned at the end. The untuned and unprofessional nature of the beginning would give a feeling of comfort and familiarity, and unexperiencedness.
Hahaha love your sight when looking to the camera 😅 great movie 💪 I thankfully hear the difference
Ac/Dc tuned their guitars 1/4 step flat in their early days and I can hear the difference. They did that to match the pitch of the bagpipes lol.
Bagpipes are tuned a semitone sharp though?
Here I am, I’m the not Russian comment you were looking for.
Edit: Please, stop sending Russian comments ‘cause I’m curious and every time you send one I should take a photo to the screen, cut it, and then pass it through the translator.
Yess thanks ! I didn't search really far thank god.
Saved my life!
in a Brazilian channel
Бро,да всем насрать.
Learn Russian 😈
Yes it’s very tiny and had small echoes sort of rebounding. Exactly like my old piano.
Yes. This is also like asking if can you tell the difference between a digital and an analog synthesizer.
Absolutely no one:
Vinheteiro: 👀🎹👀🎹👀🎹👀🎹👀🎹👀🎹👀🎹👀
Hahahaha this made me laugh
🎹😶👆👉
no
You’re not wrong
@@matrixmirage2148 🎹😐👆
Even the in-tune one sounds a little out of tune because it's tuning is well-tempered. You can hear this better in high-quality pianos that have crisper resonance chambers. Sometimes lower-quality pianos are harder to hear out of tune because their resonance is "fatter" and less-defined as far as pitch. That is to say that higher-quality pianos have better harmonic resonance where the well-tempered tuning is more evident. You don't hear the conflicts in the harmonics as well in a cheaper piano.
@Jim Pemberton. Huh? Pianos are usually tuned to 12-tone equal temperament these days. shakahara.com/pianopitch2.php/ Well temperament generally refers to one of several historically earlier systems of tuning that is intended to sound good in any key, but is not necessarily 12-tone equal temperment, which is more precise, and which sound the SAME (or theoretically the same) in every key, as well as "well" in every key. That is, they are the same percentage out of tune in one key as in any other key. I am not aware of any part of a piano that is called a "resonance chamber." Nor do I know what "fatter" resonance is. There is something called "definite pitch" but it refers to pitch and not resonance. A bigger, better piano has partials that are closer to precise harmonics.
@@soilmanted 12-tone equal is a bit wrong in every key. It spreads the pain of the comma evenly.
Yes, in equal temperament all the intervals ate slightly out of tune except octaves
Yeah, I was surprised when the 2nd piano was obviously, massively out of tune. The first one also doesn’t sound right to me. I have only found one technician that can tune my Steinway A “properly” - I can tell as soon as I play and sustain an E major chord, the harmonics “dance” across the soundboard, after he gets finished with it. Other tuners can make it “correct”, but not as musical, just dull, like that first piano.
@@soilmanted His "in tune piano" could still use a tuner going through it, the unison strings are not all unison.
At first it didn't seem to different but after listening for a while the out of tune had a kind of "sour" sound to me.. Although it could just be my imagination since I knew it was out of tune.. that is why I play the drums.. thanks.. I just love this site..
I want to hear the theme song from “Cheers” played on the out of tune piano