Thank you for writing such a wonderful story. I've been holding onto this story to make an audio production of for years because of how much I loved it but it wasn't until this year that I was able to really do it justice (along with my wife's acting of course lol). I'm so glad you enjoyed it! :)
For a moment I thought that Nightmare Rarity came back, but at the end with the reveal of how Rarity looked made me think that she was somehow turned into a werepony
I love how this is a metaphor for the fear of messing things up and hurting others, and the fear that you experience when you imagine how angry others must be at you. How people will construct this monstrous unforgiving being in their head that is so consumed by the hurt you caused them, that you couldn't possibly gain their forgiveness and own up to your mistakes. I feel this shows the fear and self-reflection one has to take on to understand, and then appropriately apologise for their actions as to solve conflict of a bad fight. I think what Pinkie (and the author) wrote about sorry isn't enough to save you, but it is worthwhile, and is a necessary process. I like how it's left on a cliff-hanger as well, implying that even if they don't forgive each other, and even if there is uncertainty in how their friendship will continue, evolve, or end, Pinkie still did the right thing to try her best for Rarity, and was brave enough to apologise in the face of fear. It's also nice to see you back! Been a fan for years and it's genuinely very exciting to know that after being gone for so long you still wish to peruse narration!
It's so fitting that soon after I get back into listening to MLP stories, you re-appear! You've been sorely missed, Lost Narrator! Welcome back, wnjoy your stay, and don't force yourself to push more content than you want to!
So glad to have you back Lost. Your return was magnificent, and Mag has outdone herself with this monstrous Rarity. Take it easy on getting back into making content, don't push yourself too hard.
Welcome back Lost!! It’s been too long! Despite all that has happened to you this past year, you have survived, and you made it back to us all! Hope all is well! Stay spooky!!
Woah, Lost is back!! I kinda thought that they would be another case of "childhood TH-camr goes MIA and never comes back and their channel dies," but I'm so glad that I'm wrong.
Saw this in my recommendations… couldn’t be a more perfect time. You’re my favorite Grimdark reader, and it’s so exciting to see you uploading another video again! We missed you!
Even though our special corner of the internet isn't what it used to be, I am so glad you are still making ponie content, even though I have been gone for quite some time. Your vids really helped me get though 2020, Lost. Thank you.
I just found your channel a while ago and absolutely fell in love! The way all of the voices, sound effects, background music and artwork are put together is pure perfection🔥 As a person who finds any audio distortion or overall poor quality of anything i listen to extremely irritating, i always fear for the worst but with you, i experience none of that. You have a reason to be proud of yourself and the people you work with🌌
Oooh, this one is genuinely creepy. Usually grim darks and creepy pastas don't even make me flinch. This genuinely creeped me out! Amazing work, y'all. Wow!! 😅
I missed Lost's storytelling. It is always something I look forward to. Listen to what story she and the others are gonna do. It is always something great. You were greatly missed Lost and Mag.
I'm so excited!! I just got back into creepypastas and mlp after years and years and recently found out about your channel! I love your work and I'm glad you're feeling up to doing any videos :3
I don't think I can listen to anyone else with mlp. Still find it strange I'm somehow here listening to these. Your great narrator. I don't regret subbing after i was recommended yours. Your narrations actually got me back into creepypastas after like i think 4 or 5 years. I did listen to couple here their lost interest soon after. Been listening to alot of yours well narrations lately looking forward to whatever you upload next ^^
It’s crazy how as soon as I start listening to mlp stories again after so long you come back, thank you so much lost! You’re by far my favorite narrator for mlp and I’m so happy ur back 💜
It's nice to see you back after over a year. This reading was really good. I hope you'll have the desire and the time to do more readings in the future. It's always nice to see something from you. I really like that you added the titles of the songs when they started to play. It's a really nice touch. If anyone wants to know the specific kind of song playing in the background, they just need to go back a bit until they see the title. This is really practical for those who want to know the songs and I appreciate that you did this. Magpie's voice acting for Rarity is really great. The way she delivered her lines sounded so natural. There was a lot of emotion behind them.
The audio quality on your videos is fantastic and greatly appreciated. I've recently been trying to get through silent ponyville 3 and while the narration is excellent, the constant mouth noises trigger my missophonia so badly.
Is that what that's called? I remember trying to explain to someone once why I edit my audio the way I do. I know some people like the mouth noises, especially in the sense of ASMR, but for myself personally, it's like nails going down a chalkboard lol Also, thank you for the kind words! I'm glad you can appreciate my efforts. :)
Welcome back! We missed you so much aaaaa! I hope you're doing well, and I can't wait for this reading to come out. I just hope you know you don't need to be cranking out content all the time, you can work at your own pace and we can be patient. Have a nice day Madame Lost.
Happy to see you back !! I remember wondering a little while back what happened and why you hadn't uploaded in a while, but I understand life gets in the way. Love your narrations, they're so well put together and engaging to listen to, and you know just the right way to emphasise words and when to do it! :>
Yayy! I’ve been hype for this and was not disappointed! I really enjoyed this story so happy to see videos from one of my favorite pony channels again! 😊
OMG MY GOODNESS!! I just got into your video reading of grimdarks-- iIm late, I know-- and you suddenly return! We're so happy to have you back! Hope you and Mag doing well as of late!
That was a great grimdark! I haven't listened to a mlp fic in a while and yeah that was great. I love how you did the voices of Pinkie and Rarity, very spot on! You got yourself a sub : ). Still that ending, I love it! Horror needs mystery and needs to keep people and everypony coming back for more ;3c.
Hey Lost, you're back! I really missed your readings. Also, I loved this story >:) (I also liked how you put the song names in the video. plz do more of this, if you don't mind that is.)
Ah RariPie, One of the many mlp ships i greatly support! i really had fun listening to this masterpiece!!! Sweet Celestia is it fantastic that you're back Lost we've missed you! It was such a delight to be able to once again be witness another one of your sensational Grimdark fanfic readings, You never fail to give us top quality spooky content thank you ever so much for blessing our eyes and ears with your collaborative creepy genius! Everyone did a perfectly astounding job on this vid make no mistake about it, Simply glorious work!!! 👏👏👏
YAY, MAGPIE FINALLY LET LOST OUT OF THE BASEMENT!!! Edit: Also, happy belated anniversary you two! Seriously though, I'm so glad to see you return and hope y'all have been doing well (at least as well as can be in these chaotic times) I'm fairly new to your channel (been kinda hesitant since grimdark isn't really my thing 😅) But after listening to your "Beloved" series... after I found it WAS a series and not a one-shot like I thought it was after listening to part one years back... I've become a BIG fan! Looking forward to seeing more from you and Mag and hope y'all stay safe, happy, and healthy!
@@RandiBrightSpecrum Relax, I'm only teasing. 😜😆 In all seriousness, I think Lost probably just wanted some time away from social media for awhile. Which, you know... *sees on social media that the world is burning* ...fair...
Omg they have returned : D I'm so excited, I been re listening to ur other stories and creepypastas and I was hope u will return, welcome back, love ur work
Welcome back losty!!!! it feels so good to have you back even if it’s been so long it’s totally worth it. I’m really looking forward to see more mlp spooky & nightmare tales!! I hope you enjoy happy anniversary with Magpiepony! XD 🏳️🌈❤️🧡💛💚💙💜🏳️🌈
Kabi: LOSTY! i'm so worried about you and i'm so glad your okay! 😄 after for a lot's of months and it's been just last year that you had stopped uploading before, and i'm so proud that you've returned from this great year! it is a long story than i ever imagine!
hi i just wanna say you got me back into the mlp fandom when i saw your frist video and i've watched all of the storys and songs i love your channle so much thank you for being the best story teller ever🥰
![Angel of Mercy [MLP Fanfic Reading] (Grimdark)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/PIEWKy1TmjA/mqdefault.jpg)
![Angel of Mercy [MLP Fanfic Reading] (Grimdark)](/img/tr.png)
![When They Deflate [MLP Fanfic Reading] (Grimdark / Romance)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IvV0ZQBifHw/mqdefault.jpg)
![Pony Tales [MLP - FiM Fanfic Readings] 'Forever Faithful' by Konseiga (horror / darkfic)](/img/n.gif)
What a delightful discovery this was! I'm so pleased you decided to choose my story to read. This was so well done.
Cheers,
Donny's Boy
Thank you for writing such a wonderful story. I've been holding onto this story to make an audio production of for years because of how much I loved it but it wasn't until this year that I was able to really do it justice (along with my wife's acting of course lol).
I'm so glad you enjoyed it! :)
Great story! I hope there's more content of your's that Lost can bring to life.
So what happened in the end?
Yeah, what happened? I absolutely adore the story but I’m quite curious
@@thelostnarratordid Pinkie Pie die ??
Only by venturing into darkness, do we gain the clarity to see the light.
“In sterquiliniis invenitur, in filth will it be found: that which we need the most will be found where we least want to look.” ~ Carl Jung
True to some. True to the brave and the pure 😊
When the world needed them the most... they returned
Yea
Indeed
im so glad theyre okay bro i was getting worried 😭
This is the best 🎉
They?
For a moment I thought that Nightmare Rarity came back, but at the end with the reveal of how Rarity looked made me think that she was somehow turned into a werepony
There was a howl
I love how this is a metaphor for the fear of messing things up and hurting others, and the fear that you experience when you imagine how angry others must be at you. How people will construct this monstrous unforgiving being in their head that is so consumed by the hurt you caused them, that you couldn't possibly gain their forgiveness and own up to your mistakes. I feel this shows the fear and self-reflection one has to take on to understand, and then appropriately apologise for their actions as to solve conflict of a bad fight. I think what Pinkie (and the author) wrote about sorry isn't enough to save you, but it is worthwhile, and is a necessary process. I like how it's left on a cliff-hanger as well, implying that even if they don't forgive each other, and even if there is uncertainty in how their friendship will continue, evolve, or end, Pinkie still did the right thing to try her best for Rarity, and was brave enough to apologise in the face of fear.
It's also nice to see you back! Been a fan for years and it's genuinely very exciting to know that after being gone for so long you still wish to peruse narration!
Aquiline Lockheart
Yeah and Poor Pinkie Pie and looks like Rarity turned into a Shadow version of Nightmare Rarity.
Im gonna take notes from this for if I ever do a werepony fic. Those growls mixed with raritys voice are peak. Along with all the canid sounds.
It's so fitting that soon after I get back into listening to MLP stories, you re-appear! You've been sorely missed, Lost Narrator! Welcome back, wnjoy your stay, and don't force yourself to push more content than you want to!
I deeply agree I miss your talent as a stroy teller
@@Molly_Mauk
Bet Rarity became Nightmare Rarity.
Yah don't stress yourself.
magpie is absolutely INCREDIBLE at voice acting . i didn't check the desc at all when before i listened so i thought this had two va's !!!
Holy crap, ive listened to this dozens of times and never realized!!
So glad to have you back Lost. Your return was magnificent, and Mag has outdone herself with this monstrous Rarity. Take it easy on getting back into making content, don't push yourself too hard.
Welcome back Lost!! It’s been too long! Despite all that has happened to you this past year, you have survived, and you made it back to us all! Hope all is well! Stay spooky!!
Woah, Lost is back!! I kinda thought that they would be another case of "childhood TH-camr goes MIA and never comes back and their channel dies," but I'm so glad that I'm wrong.
The mare, the myth, the legend has returned from the shadow realm!
So nice to see another upload from you! We really did miss you! Hope you and Mag are and continue doing well!
Saw this in my recommendations… couldn’t be a more perfect time. You’re my favorite Grimdark reader, and it’s so exciting to see you uploading another video again! We missed you!
My brother and I were just talking yesterday about all the fanfiction readers that we haven't heard from in a while..
And here you are!
Honestly, I think that was the best possible way for that ending to have been written. This was a spectacular story to choose on your part Lost.
Even though our special corner of the internet isn't what it used to be, I am so glad you are still making ponie content, even though I have been gone for quite some time. Your vids really helped me get though 2020, Lost. Thank you.
When the world needed her the most, she returned. Welcome back to TH-cam Lost, glad to see you and Mag.
Welcome back Lost! You've been very missed! Can't wait to see what you and Maggie have put together this time
I like the open-ended ending! The narration and voices in this are really good too!
I really, really, really hope you and mag were doing beautifully and healthy these past months and years. It's glad your back.
The lost narrator has returned after a long absence with a new tale to be told...
The Queen of Grimdark Narrations is back!
I just found your channel a while ago and absolutely fell in love! The way all of the voices, sound effects, background music and artwork are put together is pure perfection🔥
As a person who finds any audio distortion or overall poor quality of anything i listen to extremely irritating, i always fear for the worst but with you, i experience none of that.
You have a reason to be proud of yourself and the people you work with🌌
Oooh, this one is genuinely creepy. Usually grim darks and creepy pastas don't even make me flinch. This genuinely creeped me out! Amazing work, y'all. Wow!! 😅
Your narration was amazing Lost. Also Mag did an amazing job voicing Pinkie and Rarity.
I missed Lost's storytelling. It is always something I look forward to. Listen to what story she and the others are gonna do. It is always something great. You were greatly missed Lost and Mag.
I'm so excited!! I just got back into creepypastas and mlp after years and years and recently found out about your channel! I love your work and I'm glad you're feeling up to doing any videos :3
I hope this is a sequel to "a fleeting light in the darkness "
Glad to see you’ve returned! I hope you and Magpie are well.
I don't think I can listen to anyone else with mlp. Still find it strange I'm somehow here listening to these. Your great narrator. I don't regret subbing after i was recommended yours. Your narrations actually got me back into creepypastas after like i think 4 or 5 years. I did listen to couple here their lost interest soon after. Been listening to alot of yours well narrations lately looking forward to whatever you upload next ^^
It’s crazy how as soon as I start listening to mlp stories again after so long you come back, thank you so much lost! You’re by far my favorite narrator for mlp and I’m so happy ur back 💜
Imagine just finishing another mlp darkfic just to see that the queen returned
OMGG!! This was amazing!! I'm glad I pulled out my phone at school and waited at 2:58, I'm also glad your not dead!! Keep up the great work!
She’s back! So nice to see the lost narrator again!!
It's nice to see you back after over a year. This reading was really good. I hope you'll have the desire and the time to do more readings in the future. It's always nice to see something from you.
I really like that you added the titles of the songs when they started to play. It's a really nice touch. If anyone wants to know the specific kind of song playing in the background, they just need to go back a bit until they see the title. This is really practical for those who want to know the songs and I appreciate that you did this.
Magpie's voice acting for Rarity is really great. The way she delivered her lines sounded so natural. There was a lot of emotion behind them.
So great to see you back Lost! This was phenomenal! Please don’t push yourself, and I wish you and Mag well! ❤
So happy you’re back. I’ve loved these stories for years, and it’s always a pleasure and a thrill to listen to them.
I'm so happy to see you narrating again! Good story as well, narrated by the grimdark queen herself.
The audio quality on your videos is fantastic and greatly appreciated. I've recently been trying to get through silent ponyville 3 and while the narration is excellent, the constant mouth noises trigger my missophonia so badly.
Is that what that's called? I remember trying to explain to someone once why I edit my audio the way I do. I know some people like the mouth noises, especially in the sense of ASMR, but for myself personally, it's like nails going down a chalkboard lol
Also, thank you for the kind words! I'm glad you can appreciate my efforts. :)
@@thelostnarrator Yes, that's exactly it. And you're welcome! You've certainly earned the praise. You're one of the best narrators I've listened to.
Welcome back! We missed you so much aaaaa! I hope you're doing well, and I can't wait for this reading to come out. I just hope you know you don't need to be cranking out content all the time, you can work at your own pace and we can be patient. Have a nice day Madame Lost.
OOOOOOOO YESSSS IVE BEEN LITERALLY LISTENING TO YOUR READS ON LOOP IM SO HAPPY YOU’VE DECIDED TO RETURNNNN :DDDDDD
Interesting. Very interesting.
I wish there was a sequel to this
The Narrator returns!! Welcome back to the present from my childhood.
It's lovely to have you back! I absolutely adore your work and am very glad you're still around!
This was absoloutely amazing, Lost and Mag your narration and voice acting was so amazing! Welcome back Losty!
Happy to see you back !! I remember wondering a little while back what happened and why you hadn't uploaded in a while, but I understand life gets in the way.
Love your narrations, they're so well put together and engaging to listen to, and you know just the right way to emphasise words and when to do it! :>
Yes. You’re back. Even though I’m new to your channel I’ve been binge watching your stories and blooper and I’m a huge fan now. Can’t wait
Welcome back! I always love listening to creepy pastas- I’m glad your back. :)
Yayy! I’ve been hype for this and was not disappointed! I really enjoyed this story so happy to see videos from one of my favorite pony channels again! 😊
OMG MY GOODNESS!! I just got into your video reading of grimdarks-- iIm late, I know-- and you suddenly return! We're so happy to have you back! Hope you and Mag doing well as of late!
You are the one the only Lost Narrator! I love your stories so dark and chilling that it makes the perfect way to end the day for me.
That was a great grimdark! I haven't listened to a mlp fic in a while and yeah that was great. I love how you did the voices of Pinkie and Rarity, very spot on! You got yourself a sub : ). Still that ending, I love it! Horror needs mystery and needs to keep people and everypony coming back for more ;3c.
She’s finally back!, I’m happy to see you making this again
Welcome Back Lost! I swear I lost my marbles when I saw this in my recommended! Really a dream come true!
Definitely enjoyed the fic. It was good to hear from you again, Lost. Welcome back.
LOSTY! I’ve missed your grimdark readings soooo much! It’s great to see you back! Hope you’re doing well 💕😊
What a great reading! So great to see you return as well, Lost!
Welcome back, Lost! You've been missed so much! We're glad to have the queen return!!
Lost im so incredibly delighted you are back ! Ive missed you on the grimdark side of my yt so much. I rewatched many old ones already
Hey Lost, you're back! I really missed your readings. Also, I loved this story >:)
(I also liked how you put the song names in the video. plz do more of this, if you don't mind that is.)
Welcome back Lost! Hope your health (mental and physical) is going well, I missed these.
Finally I was hoping you'll return because I really miss your content and I hope you'll post more..your fanfic narrations always bless me
Happy to see another one of your videos Lost.I can't wait to see more of your videos!I hope you and Mag are alright.
I’m glad you’re back, and hope you’ve been well. This was excellently put together :)
I'm so glad you're back! Wish y'all the best of this year and your stories keep getting better!
Good to know you're doing alright lost! You did amazing on this story!
Lately I was watching some of your videos and I was wondering why you disappeared, I'm so glad you're back, I missed you so much. Greetings from Italy
Welcome back! Good to see you again :3 We missed you!
The Lost Narrator: Return of the Queen
OMG- When the world needed them most, THEY RETURNED
Ah RariPie, One of the many mlp ships i greatly support! i really had fun listening to this masterpiece!!!
Sweet Celestia is it fantastic that you're back Lost we've missed you! It was such a delight to be able to once again be witness another one of your sensational Grimdark fanfic readings, You never fail to give us top quality spooky content thank you ever so much for blessing our eyes and ears with your collaborative creepy genius! Everyone did a perfectly astounding job on this vid make no mistake about it, Simply glorious work!!! 👏👏👏
Scalyess Flare
I agree with you
This is a ship I never knew anyone shipped, but I find it pretty cool 👍
@@questworldiangreenknight7455 Well RariPie is one of the lesser known of the Mane 6 fan shippings, But it's one that I also support.
@@TheCommenterDragon
Wow that's cool.
I prefer rarijack
You're back! It's nice to see another upload from you after so long. I can't wait to watch this.
Yay sooo happy to see you back and already a perfect reading to add to my late night listening
Welcome back lost! You and Mags have been missed!! ❤
Yes! So need this right now. Welcome back Lost. u have been missed.
AHHHHH I LOVE WHEN YOU DO THIS I BEEN WAITING FOR ONE IM GLAD YOUR BACK CAN'T WAIT TO HEAR THIS
Oh my god Lostyyyyyy welcome back! We missed you!! Can’t wait to listen to the new badass fanfic this time!! ❤❤❤
Oh Cursey!!! The Grimdark Goddess! Welcome back! Your Fire has never been Forever Lost!
Im so happy your back its been awhile and ive been checking your account for any new post and when i saw this i screamed😭😭❤️
It's great to see you back with another fantastic narration!
I'm so glad to see u back Lost! Regards to you and Magpie from an Argentine fan!
Great story and so glad to know you are doing readings again.
This is crazy, nice seeing you post another video again.
YAY, MAGPIE FINALLY LET LOST OUT OF THE BASEMENT!!!
Edit: Also, happy belated anniversary you two!
Seriously though, I'm so glad to see you return and hope y'all have been doing well (at least as well as can be in these chaotic times) I'm fairly new to your channel (been kinda hesitant since grimdark isn't really my thing 😅) But after listening to your "Beloved" series... after I found it WAS a series and not a one-shot like I thought it was after listening to part one years back... I've become a BIG fan! Looking forward to seeing more from you and Mag and hope y'all stay safe, happy, and healthy!
Basement?! She better not have I mean I already know that she would not actually do that because she is her wife
@@RandiBrightSpecrum how do you know? Maybe they're into that kind of thing. You're not kink shaming. Are you? 🤨😜
Absolutely not!!!!
@@RandiBrightSpecrum Relax, I'm only teasing. 😜😆 In all seriousness, I think Lost probably just wanted some time away from social media for awhile. Which, you know... *sees on social media that the world is burning* ...fair...
And I have something for lost that I made on my channel that would make her get well soon
Omg they have returned : D I'm so excited, I been re listening to ur other stories and creepypastas and I was hope u will return, welcome back, love ur work
AAAAAH NEW FIC!!
Edit: Once again exceptional work. Can't wait for the next fic or otherwise.
Welcome back Lost and Magpie! We missed you both so much! ❤️🎶
Another awesome video Lost! Great reading!!!!!! Good to see you're feeling better.
Cameron J Smith
I agree with you and now we need CreepyPastaJr coming back and uploading his videos too .
Welcome back, Lost! Hope things are well and I hope you and Magpie are staying safe and healthy in this cruel and crazy world.
Hey, you're back!
I remember listening to your fanfic readings back then
Glad your back and hope you and Magpie are doing well Lost
Welcome back losty!!!! it feels so good to have you back even if it’s been so long it’s totally worth it. I’m really looking forward to see more mlp spooky & nightmare tales!!
I hope you enjoy happy anniversary with Magpiepony! XD
🏳️🌈❤️🧡💛💚💙💜🏳️🌈
Kabi: LOSTY! i'm so worried about you and i'm so glad your okay! 😄 after for a lot's of months and it's been just last year that you had stopped uploading before, and i'm so proud that you've returned from this great year! it is a long story than i ever imagine!
The Lost Narrator is back from the dead! Can’t wait!
Edit: This was great! Good job! Hope you have a good day/night!
I really miss your readings!! Welcome back lostnarrator!!
Total cliff hanger tho. I guess we'll never know if pinky lives 😭
It’s good to see you and Mag back, Lost. You two did a fantastic job with this one.
hi i just wanna say you got me back into the mlp fandom when i saw your frist video and i've watched all of the storys and songs i love your channle so much thank you for being the best story teller ever🥰
By the way, I wanted to say thank you again for letting me do the "The Tale of The Lost Narrator Series" review.
You have no idea how amazing it is to have you back, I’m so glad you’re doing better and I can’t wait to hear more stories