What is Allah? | Hieromartyr Fr. Daniel Sysoev
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ส.ค. 2024
- The first video for a playlist on Hieromartyr Fr. Daniel Sysoev. In this as of until now untranslated video, Fr. Daniel speaks on "What is Allah?" - The ways in which Allah can and can not be conceived, as well as Muhammad's supposed revelations by this entity.
Fr. Daniel's Matushka's fund for families of dead priests matushkideti.ru/
Muslims don’t have a concept of اقنوم or personhood so they describe the persons or اقانيم of the Trinity as divine attributes.
Relevant Hadiths ; Mishkat Al Masabih 119, Al Tirmidhi - 38, Sahih Al Bukhari 3783, Sahih Al Muslim Kitab Al Qadar 1848.
Let me sum up all the comments to this video by Muslims. They fall into two categories:
1) Quoting the Quran, as if that's supposed to prove something. It does not. We as Christians do not believe the Quran to be divinely revealed or inspired, so quoting it to us to prove a theological point is utterly meaningless; and
2) All non-Muslims who critique Islam apparently don't understand Islam. There is this pervasive Muslim mindset that it is impossible to understand Islam correctly if you are a non-Muslim critiquing it. Only Muslims have the capability to understand Islam. Yet, every single Muslim perfectly understands Christianity and is capable of critiquing it.
In other words: Muslims can't refute our content, they don't know their own religion or are embarrassed by it, and so they just cope.
What a load of self-comforting and self-serving rubbish. Whatever helps you sleep at night.
@Saad Bin Masud
Sorry to disappoint you but I am not a nurse. If you are hurting so bad try applying it to yourself. If you cannot reach 'the spot' then you need to pay someone to help you or seek medical advice.
@@mosesrocco6614 Cry more abdul.
@@maxpayne3628 if Jake is so focused on atheism , why is he doing his PhD on Christian theology?
@@toomanymarys7355
Women are what? Haha Utter rubbish. Nice stereotyping.
You cannot offer evidence for that claim if your life depended on it.
“At that moment the killer burst into the temple, wearing a mask and carrying a gun. He shouted: “Where is Sysoyev?” He began shooting, wounding the choir director. Father Daniel came out of the altar saying: “I am here,” walked fearlessly towards the killer, and was mortally wounded.”
“For each and every Orthodox Christian the life in Christ is the most important part of living. And this good intention - to live in Christ - has an intercessor in Father Daniel, because the Orthodox know that he is alive, and is praying for all those who have gone astray.”
I wasn't aware he was martyred. May God grant him rest with the Saints.
Lord Have Mercy
Fr. Daniel Syosev, pray for us!
Father Daniel always said with joy that the best death for a Christian is a martyrdom for Christ
We can see how Islam in its Sufi interpretations falls into monism by what Fr. Daniel says. Wish he lived longer and wasn't killed so ruthlessly for preaching the truth.
The Russian law enforcement authorities ignored him, at best. At worst, they might have even actively participated in his demise. It's one of the bigger failures of the contemporary Russian government.
@@markeedeep Why would that be? What did he do?
@@Cobruh_Commander I think it was Gregory Decapolite youtube channel which recently published a short video (i went to find it so as to link it to you now but seems like it has been deleted) which, if true, is gut wrenching. The author of the video does not believe these things to be true, but simply posted certain texts and confessions of certain Russians (some clergy and other people who say they worked for sinister faculties of the Russian Government) which (the texts and confessions) come together to strongly suggest (according to the video) the Russian Government is fighting against authentic Orthodoxy even by means of 'traditional' 'politically right' 'monarchist' entities, such as on the internet. And so the video says it seems to be a possiblity that even Fr Seraphim Rose was murdered! That was in the second half of the video, and i got chills when i read that. I would've preferred to just send u the video but cant find it. Now, I don't know about these things, so just because my username is in Greek, I dont want anyone thinking i agree or am anti-Russia or something. This just popped into my head when i read your questions. Do with what i wrote as you will, whether to research more or whatever. Now then, God bless and Christ is Risen!
@@dikaioskyrios He is truly risen!
This just made me hate islam and muslims even more! I am orthodox, but I will never consider a muslim a friend. Hope all 1.9 billion or more will get their punish form our Lord . AMIN!
They couldn't refute him so they slayed him in the temple like Zechariah. Now he is glorified throughout the world as a new martyr bringing even more Muslims to the true Faith. Glory to God.
Excellent. I’ve been reading Father Daniel’s books lately. He was a wonderful Orthodox teacher.
Btw, your channel is great. The constant saltiness from many other TH-cam Orthodox content creators gets really old, especially if you are not a new convert/catechumen. It often times comes off as try-hard and insecure to those who are interested in Orthodoxy but do not hate the heterodox group they are thinking of leaving.
After you’ve been in the church for several years, the desire to constantly btfo Catholics and other non-Orthodox wanes significantly and the combativeness and snark that many of the other channels engage in really becomes irritating. I appreciate your well-made content and I really appreciated your balance of truth and information with professionalism and grace. It’s proof that you can be firm in asserting the truth without being a complete knob to everyone who disagrees with you.
This is a thoughtful and surgically precise presentation on the foundation of Islamic theology. Often Christians and apologists will fall back on tropes or prejudices, but Fr. Daniel knows the Quran and Islamic teaching well. And he exposes it brilliantly.
Thank you Qai! I hope Hieromartyr Father Daniel Sysoev is canonized as a saint soon.
What happened to him?
@@andys3035 martyred for christ
@@pravoslavie123 I read an article about it shortly after watching this video. Sad what happened but he is in the presence of Christ now which is better by far.
@@andys3035 Yes of course Golry to Christ. He has life everlasting. I am so happy for him. I wish we orthodox to have that faith and zealous. But the think I can not grasp is that if a priest has a false teaching even thou he is martyred he will not enter life with christ. He said about biometrics that it is nothing serious. But what I know is that the prophecy of the tsar and patriarch by serafim of sarof came true God revealed him and he said against biometry and all these cards. I think that God forgave him because in the age of ecumenizm to stand in truth is beautiful. Glory to God and Rejoice Fr. Daniel unto the ages of ages. Amen
@@pravoslavie123 Many people we hold as saints have said things that were incorrect. In the end being right 100% of the time is not a requirement to be in the presence of God! I do not think we have to worry for father Sysoev!
Saint Daniel Sysoev pray for us☦️🙏🏻
Killer logo and graphics guys. But more importantly your content is fire 🔥. Keep doing what you’re doing!☺️ May God bless you and your ministry.
Great video, very informative
Can you possibly translate more of Fr Daniel's videos? ☦️
im a catechumen and this is the first i’ve encountered this man. im very intrigued.
"Christianity and Islam are engaged today in a very important task in the world. They seek to remind humanity of the existence of God and of the spiritual dimension present both in man and the world." Patriarch Alexy II of Moscow
@@BTyler808 it is not so, only because the Patriarch said this. This is his delusion. Thanks God, we don't treat priests and bishops as living saints and gurus.
Father Daniels critique of Islam is outstanding! 🙏☦️
خريستوس آنيستي آليثوس آنيستي، المسيح قام بالحقيقة قام، Christ is Risen, He Has Risen Indeed, Χριστός ἀνέστη, Ἀληθῶς ἀνέστη, Xrictoc anecth. 🔥🔥🔥♥️♥️♥️☦️
Arab orthodox Christian and proud🔥🔥🔥♥️♥️♥️☦️💟🇺🇸🇪🇬👍🤙💯🙏🎈👏✌️
Kristus telah bangkit! Betul-betul bangkit!
Wonderful video. Please keep going with this amazing work.
This was a great video; thanks for posting.
Amazing work
Islam teaches that Allah has already predestined and willed our lives - even our actions are "created" by Allah Himself, both the good and the bad. Thus, we are essentially enacting Allah's divine script. Our lack of knowledge about the actions we will take is irrelevant, as what Allah has written for us will still occur. There is no escape from the divine will of Allah! Therefore, we cannot do anything in this life to override what Allah, over 50,000 years ago (as the ahadith mention), had already decided about our actions and fate.
In Surah An-Nisa (4), Ayah 88, it says that people are misguided and fall into disbelief because of Allah. He (arkasahum) or "casted us" with these acts of disobedience which led to our disbelief. Why does Allah do this? His reasoning is given in the ayah: because of "what they have earned." However, if "what they have earned" (acts of disobedience) were already predestined for this group of people before they were even born, then these acts of disobedience go back to Allah, for it was Allah who made the above group of people partake in these sins in the first place. (Allah in Surah Al-Fatir (35), Ayah 8, says that He makes the "evil of his [creation] deed" be "attractive." In Surah Yunus (10), Ayah 100, Allah says that He sets "uncleanness" upon people, with other translations such as Pickthall saying, "He will place doubt" on people.) It is a vicious circle.
TL;DR: Allah's reasoning for our disbelief is because of the acts of disobedience that we have done (acts that Allah Himself predestined!).
Now, imagine that you are a practicing Muslim and continue to be so for many years, even decades upon decades. However, you reach a day when everything will be changed forever. Allah has predestined a thought and act that would then lead to your disbelief right before you die, causing you to enter into eternal hell. Would Allah be just for doing that?
A few verses around this topic:
Surah Yunus (10), Ayah 99-100: “And if your Lord had pleased, surely all those who are in the earth would have believed, all of them; will you then force men till they become believers? And it is not for a soul to believe except by Allah’s permission; and He casts uncleanness on those who will not understand”. So, Allaah could have guided us all to be believers, but He chose in eternity past for some people to be believers, and for some people to be disbelievers. How is this in any way, fair?
Surah Al-A'raf (7), Ayah 178: "Whomsoever Allah guides, he is the one who follows the right way; and whomsoever He causes to err, these are the losers." Here, we learn that Allah can guide and misguide whomever He wants; nothing is up to us. What we think or do is ultimately because of Allah.
Surah Al-Fatir (35), Ayah 8: "Then is one to whom the evil of his deed has been made attractive so he considers it good [like one rightly guided]? For indeed, Allah sends astray whom He wills and guides whom He wills. So do not let yourself perish over them in regret. Indeed, Allah is Knowing of what they do." Again, Allah sends astray whom He wills, and Allah also makes our evil deeds seem "attractive" so that we can be misguided. How is that fair? Did we choose to be in the way we are now, to think and act the way we do, for Allah to increase us in our evil deeds and punish us? No.
Surah As-Sajdah (32), Ayah 13: "If We had so willed, We could certainly have brought every soul its true guidance, but the Word from Me will come true, 'I will fill Hell with Jinns and men all together'." As the Creator of His own creation, Allah is saying that He could have made everybody believe, but instead of doing that, He rather opted to guide some while leaving the rest to be misguided. If Allah willed in eternity past to create us because He supposedly loved us, then why did He also will in eternity past for some of His creation to not be guided to His Truth? Allah simply did this because He made a promise that His Word will be fulfilled (i.e., of Hell being filled with mankind and jinn). Why was such a promise necessary to be made? If such human beings and jinn will only continue to misguide others with their confusions and lies, then why create them in the first place?
Interesting ahadith:
Narrated `Abdullah: Allah's Messenger (ﷺ), the truthful and truly-inspired, said, "Each one of you collected in the womb of his mother for forty days, and then turns into a clot for an equal period (of forty days) and turns into a piece of flesh for a similar period (of forty days) and then Allah sends an angel and orders him to write four things, i.e., his provision, his age, and whether he will be of the wretched or the blessed (in the Hereafter). Then the soul is breathed into him. And by Allah, a person among you (or a man) may do deeds of the people of the Fire till there is only a cubit or an arm-breadth distance between him and the Fire, but then that writing (which Allah has ordered the angel to write) precedes, and he does the deeds of the people of Paradise and enters it; and a man may do the deeds of the people of Paradise till there is only a cubit or two between him and Paradise, and then that writing precedes and he does the deeds of the people of the Fire and enters it."
The mother of the believers, 'Aishah, said: "One of the children of the Ansar (who had died) was brought to the Messenger of Allah so he prayed for him." 'Aishah said: "How fortunate he is, one of the little birds of Paradise. He never did any evil or reached the age of puberty." He said: "It is better not to say anything, O 'Aishah Allah, the Mighty and Sublime, created Paradise and created people for it, He created them in the loins of their fathers. And He created Hell and created people for it, and He created them in the loins of their fathers."
Ubadah b. al Samit said to his son: “Son! You will not get the taste of the reality of faith until you know that what has come to you could not miss you, and that what has missed you could not come to you. I heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say”: ‘The first thing Allah created was the pen. He said to it: Write. It asked: What should I write, my Lord? He said: Write what was decreed about everything till the Last Hour comes.’ Son! I heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say: ‘He who dies on something other than this does not belong to me.”
Abu Hurairah reported the Messenger of Allah (May peace be upon him) as saying: “Adam and Moses held a disputation. Moses said: ‘Adam you are our father. You deprived us and caused us to come out from Paradise.’ Adam said: ‘You are Moses Allah chose you for his speech and wrote the Torah for you with his hand. DO YOU BLAME ME FOR DOING A DEED WHICH ALLAH HAD DECREED THAT I SHOULD DO FORTY YEAR BEFORE HE CREATED ME?’ So Adam got the better of Moses in argument.”
‘Imran b, Husain told of two men of Muzaina who said: “Messenger of God, tell us whether WHAT MEN DO TO-DAY and strive over is something WHICH HAS BEEN DESTINED FOR THEM AND HAS PREVIOUSLY BEEN DECREED FOR THEM, or whether it is something their prophet has brought them with which they are encountered and which has become binding upon them.” He replied, “No, IT IS SOMETHING WHICH HAS BEEN DECREED FOR THEM AND PREVIOUSLY DECREED FOR THEM.” The verification of that is found in God’s Book which says, “By a soul and Him who formed it and implanted in it its wickedness and its piety.”
Abu Huraira reported Allah's Apostle (ﷺ) as saying: “Verily ALLAH HAS FIXED THE VERY PORTION OF ADULTERY WHICH A MAN WILL INDULGE IN, and which HE OF NECESSITY MUST COMMIT. The adultery of the eye is the lustful look, and the adultery of the tongue is the licentious speech, the heart desires and yearns, which the parts may or may not put into effect.”
Ibn ‘Abbas: “Everything [that happens] is by way of al-Qadr [divine decree], even when you place your hand upon your cheek." [Khalq af'al al-'ibad by Imam Al-Bukhari (96)].
Reading the above texts, we can come to the understanding that it is not possible for people to behave in any other way for their destiny to be altered, as Allah has already written and fixed an individual's fate.
How can anybody believe in such a "god"?
Phenomenal amount of sources , thank you sir !
calvin has left the chat
From my understanding, Muslims believe that every thing that Allah will bestow on a person has already been determined, (Rizq in Arabic). But it is up to the person to obtain it in a halal or haram manner, aka permissible or forbidden way.
For example Allah has predestined that you will get two coins. A man asks you to watch his horse while you go in to town. While he is gone you steal the reins of his horse and go to sell them. While you are in the market selling the stolen reigns the man is on his way back to his horse and is planning on paying you two coins for watching his horse. He arrives at his horse and finds that the reins are gone so he sends a boy to buy him some reigns. The boy goes to the market and finds you and pays you 2 coins for them.
In the end the 2 coins were always going to be yours, but you had to choose either to earn them properly or to steal them. I believe this story was from a narration of something that happened to Ali, the 4th Caliph of Islam. It may have been someone else but that is beyond the point.
Hope it can add to this interesting conversation of predestination. Peace be apon you all.
@@saltymangoparty
I wonder then, about those whom the God of Islam supposedly foreordained for eternal suffering. 🤔
I'm glad I can stake my faith in Jesus Christ instead, together with His Father and the Holy Spirit, who desires the repentance and salvation of all men.
Sounds like Calvin on steroids!
Memory Eternal.
I could listen to him for days and not get bored!!! Thanks for sharing this video and a merry Christmas
what an amazing video clip. thank you for posting.
More on New Martyr Daniel, please. ❤️☦️
It's absolutely insane to me how similar Calvinism and Islam are, and also, how Islam only exists because Christian heresies confused Muhammad.
Heresy is literally the worst thing on this Earth.
Islam is not similar to Calvinism and Christianity is actually a jewish heresy itself... Neither are the religion of Abraham
@@tahahagar7664 Come back & talk smack once God stops punishing you apostates like he did since 70 A.D.
@@tahahagar7664 there are many reasons why modern Talmudic Judaism is a perversion of what the Hebrews believed under the law and the prophets. It’s a very anachronistic faith that has doubled down on the mistakes of the Pharisees in Jesus’s days. If you read Genesis, the Trinity is there. There are dozens of instances in the Torah of the Trinity being made manifest. You should also read Daniel 9, you will be shocked by what it says about when the Messiah would come. Hint, we are well past the date at this point.
If you mean in terms of biblical doctrine of predestination and Islamic concept of Qadr, I would disagree, latter being a form fatalism, which is not biblical.
Most excellent 👌👏👍🙌
Great summation! Keep up the great work.
Things I learned today that Muslims don't talk about when 'evangelizing'
- So there is no concept of freedom of thought or choice. Everything can be pre-destined.
- The Quran's view of the Trinity is an extreme heresy that was found locally in Arabia (making Mary a goddess) and doesn't even address the beliefs of 95% of all Christians.
- God needs to move to a closer Heaven to hear people? What on earth is that about? If anybody is making God to sound pagan, this would be it...it resembles an old polytheist belief about gods being in literal areas and having limitations because of it. A lot of the ancient Arabian gods literally lived in a certain cave or mountain so you had to go there. so strange.
@@mdjdjjjdjd7129 All of your comment is literally straw manning.
Glory to God
Thank you for this well made video and translation!
Beautiful video!
Mohammadens never ask “what is Allah” because they’re too busy debating “where is Allah”:
We (We’re called Muslims not Muhammadens) don't need to ask, we know Allah is the creator of the heavens and earth.
@@mosesrocco6614 The creator of the Heavens and the Earth needs to descend down to the first Heaven to hear your prayers during the Ramadan?
@Ha Neul
The Quran says what? I suggest you reconsider what you think the Quran says. Otherwise you will look even more foolish than you already do, by continuing in making crazily erroneous claims about the Quran.
I’m trying to be polite here.
@Ha Neul
There is nothing to refute. You have made an erroneous claim. And as you are the person making the claim, you need to substantiate it. Until you provide a legitimate source that agrees with your assertions it’s just a claim. Repeating them doesn’t make them true.
You haven’t even bothered to post the texts you talk about.
So let’s see you justify with evidence, the things you’ve been saying..
Over to you
@@mosesrocco6614 Are you denying Al Istiwa...?
Very eloquently and logically put.
I like how he describes Allah as seeing God as this distant light. But it is when we encounter him as incarnate that we see most clearly the triune God who is love. And in Christianity we do speak of how all are called but not all are chosen. There is a debate about the interaction of God’s grace and our free will.
Good vid bro may God bless you
It could be argued that the only reason that the angelic entity self-identifying as "Ǧibrīl" to Muḥammad in the cave on Mount Ḥirāʾ -- and so corroboratively identified thereto by H̱adīǧah when she served to confirm to him that he truly was the Apostle of Allāh -- spoke only Arabic, and that Arabic was avowed by Muḥammad to be the divine language of the heavens and even of Allāh himself; is that this angelic entity self-identifying as "Ǧibrīl" was at that particular time in actual reality the demonic guardian of Southern Arabia and, specifically, of the Ḥiǧāz.
The fact that this "Ǧibrīl" knew only Old Southern Arabic (i.e., Classical Arabic, or "al-Fuṣḥā"), and even appeared to have proclaimed it as the language of Allāh himself, would suggest that the only reason for this fact was that Classical Arabic was all that he was able to observe through his specific noetic filter of understanding as so being spoken, in that this fell well within his Divinely-ordained commission as the erstwhilely angelically fallen and now demonic guardian of the area known as Southern Arabia and, specifically, the Ḥiǧāz.
In other words, the actual demon blasphemously self-identifying as "Ǧibrīl" -- by God's permission, obviously -- was then and is now one of the demonic host, of "al-šayāṭīn".
Therefore:
Islām, given the history of its self-proclaimed Prophet and Founder Muḥammad as well as of all the curious linguistically cognative similarities within Islām to such self-similar religiously-centered credal systems so preceding it, could technically be referred to as a "unilaterally nestorianistically heretical luciferian militaristically-expansive diabolatrously monotheistic antichristian thanatocentric religious cult"; so to speak.
That's a bit of an insufferably lengthy appellation on my part of such a religion, I indeed would warrant;
But I would say that it nonetheless is also rather right properly exhaustive, as such.
Thank you for this channel:
I thank God for it;
May God Bless You And Keep You.
Excellent!
He was taken from us too soon, may he pray for us
Deutoronomy 18 and John 16 are prophecies about Muhammad in the Bible. Your video has been refuted.
😂😂
WHERE ARE YOU JOHN WICK?
Lol
The Lord thy God will raise up unto thee a Prophet from the midst of thee, of thy brethren, like unto me; unto him ye shall hearken;
Deuteronomy 18:15
Thy brethren... Wow! I didn't know Muhammad was a jew!
No
There is no freewill with 'Allah'
Great ! Thank You !
Very well summarised!
First thing he said was objectively wrong, the word "person" in Arabic is either الشخص or الأقنوم
الأقنوم Is a loanword from syriac
Hello brother. Could you please translate the debates Father Daniel had with the muslims? I know they are long and there is alot of work but i think alot of muslims would benefit from them. Im willing to help in any way i can.
Holy Hieromarty Daniel Sysoev, pray for us that we might continue your missionary work and spread the truth of Orthodoxy though all the nations, and that God may grant us the steadfast faith in the face of death that he granted you
This is very interesting. How do Arabic speakers formulate the doctrine of the Trinity? Do they just bring in the Greek words into Arabic?
What are the best books for an orthodox appraisal of Islam?
Hello! Could you please give me a link to the original video without the subs? I'd like to translate it into Portuguese, but I need the video without the English subs already "burned in" (hardcoded) the screen. Thank you!
m.th-cam.com/video/vfxiA7VEFlY/w-d-xo.html
@@omorthon5774 Thank you!! :)
I have met Jesus. I have felt/heard the Father. Both were tangibly _people._ The Muslim notion of an impersonal god is anathema to my own experiences, and actively offensive to me.
Impersonal god? We aren’t deists you know! 😂
@@mosesrocco6614
Then tell me, how exactly is Allah a personal god? Because from all I've researched, Allah is nothing but a cruel, impersonal taskmaster.
@@Xbalanque84
‘Because from all I’ve researched Allah is a cruel and impersonal task master..”
😂 Sounds like you’re open minded then? 😂 If your research only says the one thing, I suggest you are not sincerely researching, but instead only looking to confirm your biases. Because verses are clearly for one reason or another, excepted or hidden from your research. 🤔
As for your question, let’s define terms here. What do YOU mean by an ‘impersonal god’? Because the term impersonal god usually refers to a deist god. And nobody in their right mind would claim Allah is a deistic god.
U say Arabic doesn’t have the term, but there surely were Arabic speakers who were Christian or Jewish before Mohammed
Doesn’t all prophecy posit a literal predestination by God? And was it Paul’s free choice to be blinded and converted on the road to Damascus while intending to persecute the church?
Of course it was his choice to be converted.
God knew that he will choose this path, for sure.
Moon God
not exactly correct translation
3:10 wrong, the beads are used to make tasbih (subhanAllah, alhamdulillah, Allahu akbar) not to mention the names of Allah. 5:45 he makes so many mistakes, it's not on the night of ramadhan, but every night, and its not because He can hear better, but because He is asking who wants to be forgiven at that time (last third of night).
So allah can't ask from the 7th heaven? Maybe he needs to raise his voice lol
@@josephsaab7208 if you want earth destroyed, similar to the mountain crumbling when moses asked to see God. Also God doesn't change His way, angels are the ones delivering His speech to the prophets.
Muslims: MUH ONE
Talmudists: MUH ONE
Poopists: MUH ONE
Atheist: you dummies just have blind faith in your saints even existing
Me: *pulls up this video*
But seriously how cool is it that we have video of our 1900s saints and on.
As Father says in the video, in the Quran there is a curse placed on Christians who claim they can be 'children of God' Surah At- Tawbah 9:30. In Islam they do not believe that Jesus is the Son of God and that we can likewise become one with God, co heirs as Christ promised, or partakers of the divine nature as Peter tells us in the scriptures as well as what the later early church fathers such as Athanasius tell us. In Islam Muslims do not believe in any kind of communion with God. So who is this Allah? Christians need to understand this better. Surah At-Tawbah 9:30-37 in the Quran shows us just how misunderstood Muhammad and others were about Christianity. St John of Damascus was right to call Islam a Christian heresy for most of the Quran is a misunderstood rehashing of Scripture according to the belief that Muhammad learned from heretics in his own family such as the Nestorians as well as the demonic visions he had that resulted in the Quran.
This did not age well …
wy?
What do you mean?
@@juliusbakker4415 I found out. He was martyred
Allah is arabic term for " One True GOD " .
●Adam is his servant & prophet , created without Father & mother .
●Jesus is his servant & prophet , created without father.
.
Mohammad is his servant & last prophet to all Mankind .
Peace be upon them.all.
.
May Allah(one true GOD) guides us.. All.
That is what the term 'Allah' means, sure. Arabic-speaking Christians and Jews use this term to refer to the God of Abraham. The problem, of course, is that Islam is a plagiarized religion that takes the partial knowledge Muhammad had of Judaism and Christianity, combines it with pre-Islamic Arabic pagan worship rituals (tawaf, pilgrimage to Mecca, etc), and then claims to be a new Abrahamic revelation. It isn't. It's a forgery.
Adam is not a prophet, he lived at the time when human kind could talk to God and there was no need for prophets
Jesus is the Christ, not a prophet
Muhammad is arabic slave traider who is more likely to exist on the pages of quran than in real history
Muslim apologetics is so utterly laughable. They actually should apologise for it! 😅
бог един это одно точно
Конечно, и это Святая Троица.
The Qur’an answered him even before he spoke
Quran
9. 32] They desire to extinguish the Light of Allah with their mouths; but Allah seeks only to perfect His Light, though the unbelievers hate it.
[9.33] It is He who has sent forth His Messenger with guidance and the religion of truth to uplift it above every religion, no matter how much the idolaters hate it.
[9.34] Believers, many are the rabbis and monks who in falsehood defraud people of their possessions and bar people from the Path of Allah. Give glad tidings of a painful punishment to those who treasure gold and silver and do not spend it in the Way of Allah.
[9.35] On that Day they (the treasures) will be heated in the fire of Gehenna (Hell), and their foreheads, sides, and backs will be branded with them, and told: 'These are the things which you have treasured. Taste then that which you were treasuring! '
@Saad Bin Masud
انت هههه
@Lord have Mercy
You will discover the matter of this unholy man at some point as the truth of all your clerics is revealed. Just be patient and you will see
Those aren't answer at all
-_-
@Lord have Mercy
Aisha has reached puberty and there are various hadiths about her age, the number nine narrated by one man who, at the end of his life, has become forgotten and some of the first scholars do not take his hadith. Your hypocrisy is manifested when you object to the Prophet’s marriage with an adult, and you do not object to killing infants and keeping young girls when the God of love orders it according to your books
Numbers
17 Now therefore kill every male among the little ones, and kill every woman that hath known man by lying with him.
18 But all the women children, that have not known a man by lying with him, keep alive for yourselves.
@Ha Neul
These hadiths were narrated by a man named Hisham Ibn Urwa. It is known that when he grew old he became forgotten and some of the early scholars did not take his hadith. However, even those who accept these hadiths say that the reason for waiting three years was to reach puberty, and that is the age of marriage. And you can ask if the goal is to marry a young girl, why wait three years? Is not six years of age closer to childhood, especially at that time when nine years is like a teenager?
***
At least this was a marriage and she was given a three-year chance to grow up. Isn’t this much better than the fate of the infant children whose males were killed and the young girls were preserved? I don’t know how you dare even talk about Aisha when your books are like this.
He misrepresents a lot of Islam
What specifically ?
@@visancristian8450
What a ignorant view of Islam and Muslims you have. Get yourself educated.
@Saad Bin Masud
That’s your opinion.
@Blob is the best Orthodoxy
What do you expect from someone who says that God cannot forgive without killing His word, and that Christ is a curse, and Satan is the Lord of this world. Leave him he has a date that he will not be able to miss and say Praise be to God for the blessing of Islam
Quran
9. 32] They desire to extinguish the Light of Allah with their mouths; but Allah seeks only to perfect His Light, though the unbelievers hate it.
[9.33] It is He who has sent forth His Messenger with guidance and the religion of truth to uplift it above every religion, no matter how much the idolaters hate it.
[9.34] Believers, many are the rabbis and monks who in falsehood defraud people of their possessions and bar people from the Path of Allah. Give glad tidings of a painful punishment to those who treasure gold and silver and do not spend it in the Way of Allah.
***
The Qur’an answered him even before he spoke سبحان الله
This guy should not mention hadith if he doesn't know and state their grading. Easy way to say things that are untrue.
2 of the Hadith are straight from Bukhari and Muslim, the other Hadith about about throwing the white and black objects is confirmed separately in Al Tirmidhi and Mishkat al Masabih. (Check the video description for the specific Hadith)
@@omorthon5774
I read the description before I posted. Appreciate your post nevertheless.
@@mosesrocco6614 so are you saying the isnad is poor on the Bukhari and Muslim Hadiths? I thought these books were supposed to be heavily authoritative in Sunni Islam. Are you Shia?
@@omorthon5774
No, I'm not a Shia. You said yourself this man uses texts outside Bukhari and Muslim. Also using authentic hadith does not necessarily mean any argument built upon one's interpretation is also accepted, as I'm sure you know already.
@@mosesrocco6614 and as I’m sure you yourself understand there are really 3 Hadiths cited in the video ; 2 are Bukhari/Muslim and undeniable . The last one as mentioned is a Hadith that is common among other canonical Hadith books. The Al Tirmidhi Hadith is generally graded “Hassan” but since it is corroborated by OTHER sources it’s quite sound to assume this is a Hadith that is recognized by the Ummah. If you disagree, please provide reasons why; there are other Hadith books besides Bukhari that are used in Masjids so don’t act like this is some apocryphal source. Secondly , there is no binding authority for the entire Ummah on which Hadiths are recognized . It’s likely that Muslims Fr Daniel interacted with accepted this narration. And I don’t see anything “unislamic” about it, it’s simply describing Qadar
Muslims do NOT describe the trinity as divine attributes. That's what you want to believe.
We reject the trinity as against monotheism. And even against the Bible. HEAR O' ISRAEL, YOUR GOD IS ONE!
Jesus and Moses never said three in one.
We get it. You're threatened by Islam but please don't lie about us.
Ad hoc nonsense. Saying the Lord is one doesn't contradict the Trinity since we believe in the nature/person distinction. Don't tell us how to interpret our own texts (which you believe are corrupted, another ad hoc, lol) since we have our own hermeneutic.
You would be surprised ! Al Shahristani certainly did! Take a look at the OS video on the Attributes. The sources are there
@@omorthon5774
Al Shahrastani is no authority to us.
@@Cobruh_Commander
Firstly I am not telling anyone how to interpret anything. The Shema hardly needs exegesis anyway. Unless one wishes to interpret 1 as 3 in 1, I suppose.
If you want to believe God hid his nature from his own prophets and believers for thousands of years, made no mention of the concept in the entire Bible and everything else. Go for it!
I’m just asking this guy not to mislead people, whether through design or error.
Thanks...
Barely a paragraph in and you made three (and likely more) textbook errors: 1) Thinking words (like the Shema in this case) aren't theory-laden and are just to be taken at face value regardless of worldview (except yours, how convenient).
2) Strawmanning the Trinity as more or less "1+1+1=3"
3) Saying that the Trinity doesn't exist in the Bible since it doesn't mention the phrase/concept explicitly, which is a stupid eisegesis foisted on the text. Also, Tawhid is not in Quran, you're done by that logic.
All this is basically a stew of ad hoc, strawmen and rhetoric addressed and obliterated in this video:
th-cam.com/video/JnvX_lgZNWQ/w-d-xo.html