'Do you believe Israel should exist?' Columbia University protester quizzed by Ben Kentish | LBC
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 พ.ค. 2024
- Ben Kentish speaks to one pro-Palestinian protester, Marie Adele Grosso, who was arrested at Columbia University during anti-Israel demonstrations.
Police have stormed the campuses of two US universities after pro-Palestine protests descended into chaos.
The protesters had taken over a university building called Hamilton Hall and barricaded themselves inside.
After making the arrests, police said that the protest had put the public, students and staff at risk.
Police commissioner Edward Caban said students had tried to lock officers out of Hamilton Hall.
Listen to the full show on Global Player: app.af.globalplayer.com/Br0x/...
#BenKentish #Israel #gaza #LBC
LBC is the home of live debate around news and current affairs in the UK.
Join in the conversation and listen at www.lbc.co.uk/
Sign up to LBC’s weekly newsletter here: l-bc.co/signup
“Hamas wanted a democratic system” is she delusional
more like brainwashed. but yes.
How did she get into Columbia
Lol - same Hamas that got elected and immediately cancelled all future elections
@@giltuito1545
Brainwashed by whom? I think it's more delusional than brainwashed. Something like e read this 1 thing and then didn't check other sources or didn't ask others. Idk.
That's actually true. Hamas campaigned for democratic elections in the West Bank in 2021 because there was a chance they could win. They're very pro-Democracy when it favors them. Afterwards, not so much.
As a Columbia alum who marched in the 70's against aparteid I do not approve her message.
Speaking as a South African. Thank you
The fact that this is an Ivy League student is mind blowing
She's a professional protester and victim , I wish her parents could see what their money is being used for by paying large fees for her education but she is here living in a tent pretending to be upset about anything she doesn't like
Most of these kids have grown up in a political and intellectual bubble and have never been challenged in this way before. Social media echo chambers make complex thinking very difficult. If a priori you're told that everyone falls into suppressor/suppressed categories, and that all subsequent political equations factor from that dichotomy, then any behavior is defensible on the part of a "suppressed" culture against a "suppressor" culture. Of course the ultimate irony is that, if this young woman were in Palestine, her ability to voice her opinion and protest would be, to say the least, limited. Talk about biting the hand that feeds you . . . .
Now we know where poison ivy comes from.
@@ClandOp And she's joined by many other social media bubble inhabitants, like John Mersheimer, Max Blumenthal, Norman Finkelstein, Noam Chomsky, Scott Ritter, Glenn Greenwald, Illan Pappe', and Aaron Mate.'
IT shows how broken the universities and colleges are these days,
Why do they wear the Palestinian scarves, isn't that cultural misappropriation?
No! Trendy!!! ...and cheap!
Probably supplied by Hamas, they all have the same scarves ,someone is making a motza
That's how I would have started the interview ... "Are you Palestinian? Why are you wearing a Keffiyeh?"
@@coachgkap I think she is Palestinian from what I can find online.
@@maryann2970 Could be. That would be odd because she refers to Palestinians as "they" multiple times. Most significantly when she says "they are asking for us to protest". Her linkedin claims Arabic language skills and her mother is a prof at Michigan State. But who knows - which is why I'd have asked.
Listening to this girl argue her case is just unbearable.
Painful to listen to so many words making no sense.
They broke into a building held maintenance hostage. Those people are so traumatized they’ve not been able to return to work.
This is being funded and organized by outside interests with very deep pockets. Columbia University has disgraced itself.
Because she literally has no idea what she's talking about. just word salad filled with marxist talking points.
Too much truth for you
😂😂no truth at all.
Feel sorry for her
the girl said, "Hamas wanted a democratic system", ????? how she got accepted by Columbia?
Almost...I said ALMOST funny, but definately NOT!
I don't understand your question.. she got accepted at Columbia because of her belief system.. I wrote belief not knowledge. it is not an academic institution anymore but a political and activist one. The question should be, how someone with moderate or even conservative values can get accepted there, not the other way around.
I know a pro-Palestinian Israeli who was accepted into Columbia grad school and she didn’t have an undergraduate degree. You’re welcome.
😅 True
I feel dumber after listening to her.
There are moments such as these that I wonder when the world will end! It seems we are beyond our expiration date.
Of course you would. But the brainwashing will wear off after a while and you might feel a little smarter then.
I feel a lot smarter after comparing myself to her
while watching this ... i swear i could feel my IQ going down ... but it came right back when the video ends ... hmmmm strange
You're on PRIVATE PROPERTY. Just because you have a student ID doesn't mean you have a right to go and be where ever you want. If they tell you to leave and you don't, you ARE TRESPASSING!
💯
University is private property??
@@SaifulIslam-eo8mi Depends on the University. A state school would be state or city property while schools like Harvard, Columbia, and NYU are private schools. I went to Nassau Community College (public college), SUNY Farmingdale (public university) and NYIT (private university)
@@TheCaniblcat Students are allowed to use university grounds for study, dating, gaming, picnic'ing....but when they use it for protesting , the grounds are private....such selective use is morally dubious
If you're so concerned about trespassing on private property, please speak out and condemn the hundreds of thousands of Israeli settlers who are living on stolen Palestinian land in the West Bank.
Democratic system in Palestine…darling, get off your unicorn 🦄 😂
not had a vote since hamas got in.
very expensive braids. 80000/year.
@@martyy4073 but they did vote for and actually well over 50% support Hamas. But they're all innocent victims.
@@martyy4073 ok i agree but then again, why did hamas get into power and what happened to the democratically elected party that used to be there? west bank is democratic but the stats show over 300 murders by israely soldiers in 2024 (keep in mind that the west bank IS NOT in israel and israely soldiers are by law invaders)
Like Egypt with the Islamic Brotherhood x 100
I am amazed how such an entity is a student of an elite university. She is parroting hamas propaganda without checking on the facts. She is fit to live in Gaza and not in the USA.
Did you check the facts? If so enlighten us
Some folks are beyond enlightening. There are people who are a bit dim, and then there are people whose minds are so tightly shut, absolutely no light can enter. But just because we’ve identified you doesn’t mean anyone can solve your problem.
rest of world disagrees with you mate...must be lonely in your cave
A lot of them are paid activists.
She should have been stopped to the hamas propaganda
Calling for the boycott of Jewish businesses. When did we hear that kind of retoric before?
exactly.
She said Israeli businesses not Jewish businesses. Why do you assume that all Jews are Israelis?
'Stop interrupting my ignorant ramblings with questions which require me to think. These lies are all I have'.
Hilarious.
Hillarious but worryingly sad. I hope she looks back at this video in years to come and is embarrassed
Does she understand how ignorant she sounds?
Do you?
I’m pretty sure Dvrdwn understands how ignorant that girl sounds.
She sounds hateful.
She only knows she sounds - she doesn't care how she sounds - just as long as she is sounding ...
There's a lot she doesn't understand!
I lost -20 IQ points after hearing her blabber.
... Oooh the cheap comment that I could have made...
Nice
@@martinportelance138 Should have made. But you did almost as well with your comment.
Particularly when she dodged the question about Gazan companies funding Hamas and gave the verbal mush comparing this to oil spills. I almost physically felt those 20 IQ points get torn out.
So you're down to ~30 ?
This is unbearably idiotic, and the worst part is that she has no idea how disconnected from reality she is
These students are educated with lies of hamas
Brainwashed by Hamas.
She's living in her own Lala land😂
they all are
"Palestine" is la la land.
😂😂😂 she don't know anything about Palestine
"Entirely peaceful" and a minute later "property may have been destroyed"
@@derekaitken Lol ! 😅😅
She doesn't even know where Palestine is. Our college students are an embarrassment.
There is no Palestine.
@@judigrumm7190 and even if there was, the Palestinians don’t deserve it.
I said before she won't get a PhD in History---it's most likely she won't get one on geography either.
Yep, and this is Columbia.
Well it doesn't exist..
She has convinced me. I'll look for Israeli products every time I go shopping.
Doing that already for some time now😂 BTW... I stopped buying pomegranades, avocados and dates if they are not from Israel
Yes, that's the problem. You BELIEVE the land is "Palestinian" when it's not and never was.
Incorrect, it's always been Palestinian, they are the descendants of the Canaanites, they've been there time immemorial
@@StylinRedromans gave name palestine to exchange judea and samaria in 136CE😂
Always Palestinian never Jew land
@@sammys7830 so? The Palestinians are the descendants of the Canaanites... They are the modern day Canaanites, as are the Mizrahi Jews. The European zionist colonisers are simply that... Europeans 🤷♂️
@@sammys7830 if you knew anything of history you would know the israelites came from UR (modern day Iraq) they're not from the land of Canaan
If this young woman is an indication of the level of students in the USA, then we are in trouble. Her ignorance is so extreme, it is sad and frightening.
Such deep deep ignorance
She actually sounds more intelligent than most of our politicians
You are so right on the target. Thx.
She also can't stand anyone challenging her opinion. Notice the treble in her voice when her monologue is interrupted?
@@phemykadri9487
If it is so: On what grounds is she more intelligent, explain with specifics from her own talking points in video.
Blocking people from entering the campus is peaceful, destroying property is peaceful?. What a joke
They’re peacefully disrupting educations of the other hard working students that paid to get in the school.
All this girl said was they weren’t going to stop until they get their way.
This particular event has opened my eyes more than anything else. It might seem minor to most but there is something so demonically sinister behind blocking a certain ethnicity from entering a public place.
Imagine if it was you who was blocked and vilified because of your religion!@@OliveCandy38
@@user-od6wt6nc5g I couldn't imagine. It sickens me.
Hmm... Blockades are acceptable when you feel you're not getting attention? But not when your national security is at risk. Okay, I got it. That makes so much sense.
Privileged Ivy league student whose only trauma has probably been getting the wrong order at starbucks or mis-gendered commenting on a situation she has no idea about or has even took the time to learn about makes me despair about the future. In clown world no one knows whats real anymore. I hate it and i'm going back to bed.
Tell her NOT to get breat cancer screening or medical therapy for it. Tell her not to get tested for diabetes, or her family. As it was Israel was the country that developed, researces for the cure of breaat cancer and diabetes. Shes just reciting from talking points given to her by Hamas supporters. Threw her education away.
this student is educated with lies
Which "lies"?
@@Samaa-os7hxThe ones she and you believe.
@@ranndino yet you have no clue what they are.
You can almost see her head spinning with lines from
Her propaganda book. Her answers sounded robotic
Trolls are out.
The stupidity and ignorance of this generation is frightening. It will end badly.
I also believe this....
You are so correct
Theae are students but never open a book.
Marxist playbook
The underlying statement was they didn’t get what they wanted so they threw a fit and broke things. Spoiled children. This is what happens when people don’t discipline their children.
So... because the University wouldn't bend to their will, violence was justified?!
Stop funding these schools.
Columbia University has a $13 billion as of 2023. Harvard was at $50 billion! Our taxes absolutely do not need to go to these brainwashing institutions.
Better yet: Take away freedom of expression and the right to protest. 🤐
@@martinportelance138 Are there any limits to freedom of expression and the right to protest ? If so, where do you draw the line ? It seems you are happy for people to break some laws in the name of protest? If so which ones ? Does the end always justify the means, or does it depend on the gravity of the situation ? If so, who decides how grave the situation is, and what the appropriate response should be ? In summary, your remark seems a little simplistic.
@@timparis70 Just reverse the roles/opinions expressed and the answer to your question will come naturally.
@@martinportelance138 I don't undertsand your response, but I feel comforted that all will soon become clear. Because these are questions I have been reflecting on since well before the latest Israel-Palestine confict, and currently I don't have the answers.
I never expected supposedly ‘smart’ students could be so easily brainwashed. There is no critical thinking whatsoever, but all talking points.
SO SAD!!! The "system " allows well heeled idiots. Did her PARENTS attend this school?
Typical "scholars"
That’s what our colleges and our public school systems are failing miserably at, critical thinking and common sense. The so called “professors” these colleges hire are mostly leftist, gen z activists.
I was counting how many times she said the word “again “. Absolutely not open to hearing anything, but what the script is she’s reading. I give her a F
Dang that’s dumb so from the beginning they were blocking students with their bodies that’s not peaceful. And peaceful protests are to persuade not to coerce.
The girl is an essence of the real problem of America - the shallowness of the young people who do not delve into any subject, but only recite empty slogans like parrots.
How is this individual an Ivy League student 🤯
So much stupidity, and a complete lack of understanding the reality
From you you mean?
@@historiaeresistencia832 From Marie. Did the interviewer offend you? If so, how?
Actually, I disagree. This girl was smart and well spoken. The times she stumbled, it was because she was trying avoid traps. I one occasion, she was smart enough to ask for time to gather her thoughts. The problem was that the dude was smarter and was able to easily point out her B.S. She has been brainwashed like so many in this generation. She is so brainwash that she could not bring herself to admit that Israel is in a very difficult situation. One day, she is going to wake up and realize she was sadly mistaken about this whole ordeal. By then, she's probably will be too old for anyone around to care about what she has to say.
That's all the LBC presenters in a nutshell 💯
@@hfontanez98another college genius. Go to Palestine dear and let us know how they treat you!
Go to Palestine love, tell them you’ve been supporting them, and protesting against Israel, and see how they thank you……….
Do you know what Palestine is like? Have you ever been there? It has British laws from the mandate in the 1930s, its always been a peaceful place with women's rights and acceptance of all religions, who lived together in peace before 1948. You are so ignorant
@@doggieclaude sure thing! 🤣
@@doggieclaude Peaceful? Do you know that when Hamas won the 2006 election they murdered all their Fatah rivals?
@@doggieclaude😂😅😂
@@doggieclaude are you serious?
😂😂 She saying Israel is the reason theres not Palestinian democracy. 😂😂😂 omfg
imagine being in a relationship with this person. and listening to this every day.
When kids are not taught history. They feel the earth started yesterday
When actually it started on October 7th -- right?!
@@Matthew-ve7uv The farther back you go, the more evidence you find of Hebrew presence in the land, solidifying the Jews' link to the land.
They act like this stuff is new, the marxism they have brainwashed in is a new Maoist form but its still just communism. Now with a side of Islamists
@Matthew-ve7uv this round started Oct 7th yes. Israel left Gaza 15 years ago
@@rockysandman5489
Yes same as Chinese "nine dash line" of claim in South China Sea
"This is a movement started by the people who are being oppressed" she says as she gestures to her own self. Lord, save us from these hypocrites and fools.
She's originally from Gaza
@@DeviLisBackAgain.🥳🙃🙂😜
She is stending a university??????????amirica is doomt😮
@DeviLisBackAgain. This is terrible, she has Hamas propaganda in her head. She doesn't know how to think independently. Palestine will be a democratic country. 😊Hamas has not held elections for 17 years. Is this democracy?
She clearly said that the Palestinians asked to organize a protest. Behind the Palestinians are Hamas, Qatar and Iran, which most needs this war. She doesn't want to know that there are Palestinians who are demanding to be freed from Hamas. Their voices are not heard because of such fools.
Even if you're right, I don’t care. She's fully brainwashed. @@DeviLisBackAgain.
If that girl didn't have double standards, she would have no standards at all...
Jesus Christ can we defund these schools since they're obviously not doing anything for these idiots! This is a college student this is horribly sad
Bombs being dropped on our loved ones? She looks like she’s from Wisconsin 😂
"Love your neighbor as yourself". I guess are foreign words to you. The only way conflicts can be settled is if someone in the fight steps up and shows some empathy. These students are trying to model that empathy and shame Israel and our government into doing the same. Palestinian struggles since '48 have never been acknowledged by Israel or its allies.
She should choose to invest and buy from companies that she prefers and has no business telling an American university who to invest in or who to digest from… She can go to a different college.
Michigan, but close enough.
@@RAsphaltIsrael gave Palestine Gaza
Israel gave Palestine West Bank
Now Palestine wants Israel
You're parroting social media. Educate yourself @RAsphalt
For starters, this young lady has been brainwashed with superficial talking points that do not coincide with actual facts.
And panic'd when she got a little push back. Then LBC just allowed her to carry on her nonsense. These protestors have been chanting for the death of jews. In America you have that free speech, but in the UK that is considered violent yet LBC never questioned her on her legitimacy of peaceful protests
What is there to wash when there is nothing in that head...
And that's putting it mildly.
The irony of your comment will be lost upon you and all the ignoranta giving it a thumbs up.
@@monkoman4172 please rebut it with facts rather than a silly comment like that. She got SO much wrong. eg, Hamas wants a democracy 😆 that's why they've held no elections since the 80s.
I am a retired educator -- this is a college student without a cogent train of thought. She has absolutely no clue what she is talking about -- a incredible lack of knowledge of history. I think some of these kids are easily manipulated by propagandists who appear sincere. She obviously has no knowledge of what is in Hamas' horrific charter or the history of the area she claims to be arguing for. This is just sad.
Sad and frightening.
I’ll pay for her one-way ticket to Gaza if she wants to go protest over there
Hey I will give you half if she accepts.
One thing that all these protests have taught me that I didn't know, is that there's a large number of people even in the top top universities in the world that are still absolute idiots and can't put a comprehensive argument together
Yep, that`s the sad truth.
Tell me you've been brainwashed without telling me you've been brainwashed.
You've been brainwashed. Of course you're not aware cos that's how it works.
That's projection
I think your not using common sense if you call this a brainwash
Israel isnt breaking international law and hasnt been since the 50s.Hamas are a terrorist group that came out of nowhere and the attacks on October the 7th were a massive surprise to People like BeBe even though he never let them get more money than the PLO becasue he wants a 2 state solution and not the death or atleast displacement of the people that never owned the land in "Israel".
Nobody can even tell who you’re talking about there’s two opposing views in this video
Wonder how she would feel if she was at the music festival on Oct 7 witnessing & experiencing the violence women her age experienced.
Why not just stop paying tuition as a protest? I mean, it is 90,000 usd a year. They should protest the tuition fee.
Marie Adele Grosso must have very rich parents and they must be paying double of the CU tuition. She speaks like a 14 year old not an CU student.
She is on the daddy/uncle acceptance program.
Exactly she didn’t get in by taking any tests. Her parents paid her way, but they should have started paying in kindergarten,that way she would have had a brain by now.
@@Jones40-sy2fg
SAT. Wasn't there an investigation about fraud in College Board?
Sounds like a 7th grader trying to fool the teacher about having read the assignment when she didn’t.
She tried very hard, problem is lack of knowledge. These young people are being brainwashed and they don’t know how much they will regret it in 20 years when they finally realize what happened!
That's all projection dear
What did happen? Why don’t you tell us, seeing as you know everything?
20 years? Maybe next year.
@@ameliayaqub7358
I’m not here to teach you, you go read history and watch the news. Maybe looking into why Egypt and Jordan refuse to let them in
Yeah the students at the best Universities in the world are probably not as smart as you. LOL. Like they were not right about Vietnam back in the 60`s.
The stupidity of youth today. It is shameful
Of course Israel should exist. ❤ It’s not an opinion. Should China exist, Nigeria, Russia? Turkey? Pakistani? This student has no skills, is so uninformed, loses on every point, then tells interviewer to do his research. I’m so embarrassed for her. “I appreciate, I’m so sorry… “ Ugh!
I'm happy that she is wearing no mask and one day she has to pay the price for spreading these lies.
I hope her future employers look up these videos and don’t hire her
@@Pete-xu5yx There is an industry that hire such people - such as NYT
@@Pete-xu5yxI hope your employers let you go but that assumes you don't work for the IDF
Don't worry - In 30 years she'll be Speaker of The House!
She jeopardised her future in USA
If that's what comes out of Columbia, then shut the universities...😂😂😂
Maybe dumb people will think as you.I personolly think Columbia students are great.
@@historiaeresistencia832*personally
Affirmative action cases 👎
completely! I got lost, so unimpressive student and messages
Or take away their federal funding. They will expel these students asap
To all the HR departments out there, remember this face. To her parents, boy did you blow it!
Indeed. That is what I was thinkin
couldnt have said it better myself
How old is she?? Not old enough to remember the holocaust nor know anything she is talking about.
I'm an American living in Germany. I have a fair amount of contact with German university students and they look at this stuff and are absolutely flabbergasted; they teach ACTUAL history in German schools.
Can you give me some examples?
@@ptolemyauletesxii8642 History look it up
Bruh this girl is not living in reality lol
Ya think????!!!
this is 99% of the mentality of the protestors, they are all completely delusional and lost
Are you
😂 brainwashed
Sounds like projection
Simple question, Israel as a nation, has a right to exist?
When will people learn that you cannot argue with ignorance. You will never win an argument.
193 countries in the world:
67 Roman Catholic
49 Islamic
49 Protestant
14 Eastern Orthodox
3 Hindu
And only ONE Jewish country.
That's not too much to ask.
And we're not asking.
Have it in Germany or Poland. Holocaust and the hate of Jews happened in Europe and Palestine got their lands taken from them due to this fact.
All we ask is that you stop genociding the Palestinians.
Nor should you have to, especially when that one Jewish country is about the size of Wales, and especially when Jews expelled from Arab/Muslim lands gave up an amount of land equivalent to about 5 Israels.
it's NOT your land and it was never the british own to give away! fo
@@deryck-kr2tlThe Ottoman Empire fell. The victor decides the spoils. There wasn't a Palestinian State under Ottoman rule. One was proposed at that time when an Israeli State was being offered to the Jews. It wasn't accepted. The Israelis took theirs. And paid the price facing a war the next day and they won.
This girl should get into politics she did not give a single direct answer 🤦♀️
You can see it when he asks her questions. She has no answer because it's only about how she feels about the situation.
She IS a politician wannabe. I don't think she actually cares
She answered every question, YOU just don't like her answers😂
Hard to like an answer when it’s not there
@Samaa-os7hx I guess it's safe to assume you understood her. I guess it's also safe to assume that's how you answer questions too. It must be frustrating talking with you in person.
She's not answering the questions cuz all she has is her parrot response
Columbia University is a Private Institution on Private Property, which means even though you have a student ID, they have the right to ask you to leave from an area of the campus or the campus as whole. If you do not vacate said area you can be arrested for trespassing.
This is what brainwashing looks like
100%. It is astounding how many factually incorrect statements she made. Just when I though she could not say another another piece of BS came out of her mouth. It would have been more honest and a much shorter interview had she just said "I hate Jews" which is what it all boils down to.
Yeah, listening to LBC's spew nonsense half the day - it's a sad thing.
@@MegaLozenge who started the 1948 war?
Come on American can clearly see.. it's pro-jewish agitators. Then they claimed the victim just like they are now..
Yeah the interviewer's brainwashing is thorough, and his statements were hilarious at the end where it was cut off 😂😂😂
Columbia lost all reputation 😂
@stinanordland how ??
As if the people parroting this rhetoric can even get in 😂
You're jealous because you never made it past even a single gcse😂
@@Samaa-os7hx Mohamed go to Gaza and take Aisha with you and your goats too
I am an atheist that is why I am intitled to say that those who mock someone else' s religion is not serious or respectful.@@Stinanordland
all this filmed with an iphone packed full of Israeli technology, she should try and divest from her iphone first 😂
Considering how competitive the selection is supposed to be for going to Columbia, it makes you wonder who is selecting and then training these ignoramus who seem like brainless puppets. It is obvious these students have never read anything about Gaza or Israel. Can someone expose the background of who is in charge of the selection at Columbia and who are the teachers with such brilliant results?
She's 19. Still has many years to grow out of her ignorance. If only there was some kind of a system to teach children history and critical thinking... 🤔
Unfortunately many ppl at old age still have not mature
Example: karens
all the hyper-opinionated people I knew when I was in school have only become more so with time, she can't be wrong, she will never acquire the ability to be corrected. she is probably a really pill at family dinners LOL
I agree with you completely.
Historicallly the Core cirricuum at Columbia College was the best at doing that.
I'm extremely confused. Can anyone point to any argument that she made that is wrong or lacks critical thinking?
She exactly just stated, "Hamas has wanted a Democratic govt and isreal has interfered with it " --- she is HAMAS.....
yes! she is!
Okay, that's when I knew with certainty that she was beyond help. :(
She may by the least impressive student I have ever seen giving an interview. is that what columbia produces?
Yes, strange, an educated american.; Should inspire you.
@albertmockel6245 Hamas wanted a democratic system and Israel stopped it? When was this? Just making up random things now 😂😂😂
She clearly has no idea what she’s talking about.
He could have backed her into a logistical corner in a round room.
If ever there's evidence of the phrase, "speaking isn't thinking," surely this is an exemplar.
This is the EDUCATION that is GIVEN to this GENERATION.... what a SHAME.
The mental gymnastics she uses to justify her 'cause' she could work at Cirque du Soleil. Beyond ridiculous.
😂😂😂 agree
She could be a great juggler, lol.
True. When he straight up asked her, "so, by your logic, the Israel state can target Palestinian businesses," she had no rebuttal, so she just digressed to another point. What a clown.
@@paulcarfantan6688 except she trips herself up.
she's jacked up on something.
I studied college in united states. The first thing I realized about american students is they hardly have elementary school knowledge about the world, politics, history etc…
11:21 “let me remember what am I supposed to say” hmm lol
There was never a self ruling state called palestine
Palestine is basically a term coined by British and later on reterm as a phenomena carried out by arab and yasir arafat's PLO.
And there will never be ☺️
@@DeviLisBackAgain.Palestine is what the Romans renamed Judea. They got it from the Greeks.
@@womenlifefreedom2024 syria palestina didn't stay there for long, syria palestina was for romans to mock jews
@@DeviLisBackAgain.Actually it was pointed by the Roman’s in the II century, to humiliate the J3WS because a riot they had made.
Does she not notice that Israelis are able to protest in the streets if they disagree but would the people of Palestine be allowed to publicly protest against the actions of Hamas at anytime.
And, never mind Hamas, one thing the people of Gaza are definitely NOT allowed to protest against - peacefully or otherwise - is the Israeli blockade. Look up the Great March of Return 2018
You have been living under a rock then if you think palestinian can protest freely. Millions are under military law which is worse than martial law. No protest is allowed and you can be jailed without charge as they are tried under military court not civilian ones.
Nope
There are bills in the US Congress that would prohibit anti-Israeli protests and to prohibit protestors from flying.
@@michaelgj23Bullshit. Provide evidence. A link. Anything.
When he straight up asked her, "so, by your logic, the Israel state can target Palestinian businesses," she had no rebuttal, so she just digressed to another point. What a clown.
American tax payers should divest from funding these schools with my tax dollars - and who are her “loved ones”? This girl is an embarrassment.
She obviously didn't boycott the Israeli technology that she's using to speak on IE her phone, laptop. Hypocrisy!
Laptops were created by a British guy
Perhaps but the likelihood that the Intel chip in her laptop is produced in Israel is extremely high
Best comment!
😅😅😅😅😅😅@@ibettch4122
@@CropsykillsI would argue America first haha, but neither here nor there - Israel had/has nothing whatever to do with it.
Moreover, not enough western supporters of Israel know this, but they’re in fact a welfare economy! I can’t speak for the UK, but in ‘murica the demographic most supportive of Israel is the least supportive of welfare/welfare states - that’s the basis for FOX and the fear mongering tactics they dub as “reporting.”
Where were you after civilians were bombed in Ukraine, Syria, Afghanistan and Iraq?
This is what I'm yet to understand. I think that these children are misinformed.
The magic word is Jew
Where were they for the 'Woman Life Freedom' protests???
Fkn nowhere is where...
Where was she when Hamas was killing the palestines who fought against their regime? when they piled up bodies in the streets in the cities of Gaza as a message to anyone who would oppose them?
The problem is that Israels crimes have been going on for over 70 years and humanity has had enough. You can argue that the US has committed worse crimes but that's debatable.
Westerners backing organisations such as Hamas is like turkeys voting for Christmas
Oh my lord. How did she get admitted into Columbia!?? First, she is incorrect that most Palestinians want divestment - as until Oct 7th tens of thousands of Palestinians worked daily in Israel and relied on the Israeli economy (and lived with a much higher standard of living than those that work in Gaza). And then the nonsense about Gazan democracy! And Iranian involvement!!?? Wow.
I wonder if she’ll look back on this interview in another 20 years, with an absolute devastation level of embarrassment
She may be young and less educated on the subject . She sure has compassion and she will be proud of her self in many years to come
She'll probably be pleased that she was on the right side of history
She will not. She's obviously brainwashed. It's called ideological subversion. Coming from former Soviet Union I witnessed this with some of my family members. Even though they suffered greatly and unfairly due to communism, they still held a firm belief in the ideals of communism. If you get brainwashed during your coming of age years it's extremely hard to overcome. Not everyone is susceptible to brainwashing, but those who are there's not much you can do for them.
No, she won't.
She'll just be at another rally or protest. She's creepy. Did he invite her to spew her speech or was that supposed to be an interview?
Israel have 100% right to exist and it’s an undeniable matter & fact.
have you even read what the 2 co-founders of this current concoction of is rael said about the Pal est ini ans being the closest linked ancestors to the is rael ites from the times of David and Solomon??
It's *Pal est ini ans land* nu mbn utts... 😲😬😱🤫
That would be incorrect.
Right on. They've fought multiple times for the right to exist and they've won every time.
@@15walkeen That's a shame.
@@JohnSmith-dh3kx - You some kind of lunatic ?
Instead of wondering what planet we'll leave our children, let's ask ourselves what children we'll leave this planet.... 😊
She will be complaining that when she gets out of school she can’t get a job. No one is going to hire her after this display on campus. Rightfully so.
Well done girl, you're officially a TikTok graduate, go get your approval 😑
😆🤣
😢
"I want to note there are Jewish Palestinians" Is she talking about the hostages the Palestinians are holding?
Prior to the establishment of modern Israel in 1948 there was a 30% Jewish minority living in the British Mandate for Palestine, a steady increase from 8% in 1897, the year Zionism "officially" began. The lowest percentage on record was in 1517 when Palestine, then ruled by the Ottoman Empire, had a Jewish minority of only 1.7%.
@@georgesprat9697
1. Before Israel, there was a British mandate, not a Palestinian state
2. Before the British Mandate, there was the Ottoman Empire, not a Palestinian state.
3. Before the Ottoman Empire, there was the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, not a Palestinian state.
4. Before the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, there was the Ayubid Arab-Kurdish Empire, not a Palestinian state.
5. Before the Ayubid Empire, there was the Frankish and Christian Kingdom of Jerusalem, not a Palestinian state.
6. Before the Kingdom of Jerusalem, there was the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, not a Palestinian state.
7. Before the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, there was the Byzantine empire, not a Palestinian state.
8. Before the Byzantine Empire, there were the Sassanids, not a Palestinian state.
9. Before the Sassanid Empire, there was the Byzantine Empire, not a Palestinian state.
10. Before the Byzantine Empire, there was the Roman Empire, not a Palestinian state.
11. Before the Roman Empire, there was the Hasmonean state, not a Palestinian state.
12. Before the Hasmonean state, there was the Seleucid, not a Palestinian state.
13. Before the Seleucid empire, there was the empire of Alexander the Great, not a Palestinian state.
14. Before the empire of Alexander the Great, there was the Persian empire, not a Palestinian state.
15. Before the Persian Empire, there was the Babylonian Empire, not a Palestinian state.
16. Before the Babylonian Empire, there were the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, not a Palestinian state.
17. Before the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, there was the Kingdom of Israel, not a Palestinian state.
18. Before the kingdom of Israel, there was the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, not a Palestinian state.
19. Before the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, there was an agglomeration of independent Canaanite city-kingdoms, not a Palestinian state.
20. Actually, in this piece of land there has been everything, EXCEPT A PALESTINIAN STATE.
A little more history for those wanting to 'restore Palestine'.
In 132 AD the Emperor Hadrian resolved to stamp the Jews and their religion out of existence. He sold all Jewish prisoners into slavery after the revolt of Bar Kikhba, forbade the teaching of the Torah, renamed the province Syria Palaestina, and changed Jerusalem’s name to Aelia Capitolina. He renamed Israel to wipe out the national identity of Israel and the Jews.
So if you are looking to 'restore Palestine to the Palestinians', you need to give it back to the Jews.
@@jstewart4205 If you were trying to look like a lunatic, you succeeded.
@@georgesprat9697well, the thing is, even though he may be denying the present Arab population’s self-identification as Palestinians, which is completely legitimate on its own, what he’s describing here is as accurate as they come.
There’s a legitimate desire, by the local Arab population in the region, to establish a Palestinian state. Arguably, that state already exists: it’s Jordan. But OK, they want another Palestinian state. Who are we to deny them their desire.
That still has no connection with the facts he is enumerating.
Whatever you think or believe, there has in fact never existed, until the creation of Jordan arguably, an independent Palestinian state.
@@hexistenz OK... and?
Columbia appears to have lowered its standards… I wonder if she’s had her drinking water checked lately for heavy metal contaminants?!?
I used to feel like I wasn’t smart because I didn’t get into an Ivy League school. I’d to wholeheartedly thank these students for releasing me from that insecurity.
these kids are large toddlers having a temper tantrum
This is Karen in the making
The ignorance of the history and the current situation is quite unbelievable
One of the worst I have seen. And yet she is so confident. Likely because her whole life everyone has told her how smart she is. With any luck she has made herself unemployable.
@@gheller2261She is intelligent just young and nervous. Of course you were perfect at this age. Now even more perfect now.
Andrew Neil wrote a great piece for The Mail over the weekend...check it out.
@@blackseed9293 - "Intelligent" implies intelligence...she has none!
Western nations do not teach the world history properly
That was excruciating to listen to. So Ill informed and patronising. I doubt she could even pinpoint Palestine on a map.
She's wearing a Kufiya invented by Britain for a conceptual Nation of Palestine invented by Britain
She literally doesn't know what she's talking about...
It's much worse. She thinks she does know what she is talking about.
She learned words. Apartheid, Oppression, Divesting, Boycott
She really likes to use the word 'peaceful.' She's a very skilled liar!
She supported hamas that's why
That's because she's a supporter of the so-called "peaceful community".
Peaceful is the most threatening word nowadays.
We asked politely, but they rejected our demands, so we started tantruming 😅
Spokesstudent is limited in capability with limited knowledge as well as espousing many incorrect facts. She probably mirrors many of the protestors with regard to knowledge and limited truths. She does try to appear respectful to the interviewer while blithely and with apparent difficulty parroting her revolutionary world message that is somewhat mixed up. Woe to us all if she or her ilk one day leads this country. Hamas would probably label these kids useful idiots. Would be interesting to interview her 20 years from now in seen if she learned much.