Adam Audio T8V vs Yamaha HS8 vs KRK Rokit 8 (STUDIO SPEAKER SOUND TEST)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 มิ.ย. 2022
- Hello everyone.
In this video you will listen to a test for Adam Audio T8V, Yamaha HS8 and KRK ROKIT 8 Professional Studio Speakers. I created this recording in home studio environment and with deca tree recording method. Thanks for watching and listening.
Speakers (aff link)
Adam Audio T8V: amzn.to/3mYJd1c
Yamaha Hs8:amzn.to/3QBBpQO
KRK Rokit 8: amzn.to/3zKzUth
#yamaha #krk #rockit #adam
▶To take advantage of channel privileges: bit.ly/TH-cam-Join-Button
▶2-month Artlist membership with a gift: bit.ly/Artlist-SS
▶ be aware of new videos bit.ly/SercanAnlatiyor
▶ my equipments: kit.co/sercansolmaz
İLETİŞİM / CONTACT :
Bana sormak istediğiniz sorularınızı videoların altına yorum olarak yazabilirsiniz. Her gün TH-cam videolarıma gelen yorumlara cevap vermeye çalışıyorum. Ancak daha spesifik sorularınız, eğitim /danışmanlık ve işbirliği teklifleriniz için aşağıdaki mail adresini kullanabilirsiniz.
📮 me@sercansolmaz.com (feel free to write in Eng)
Adam Audio T8V: amzn.to/3mYJd1c
Yamaha Hs8:amzn.to/3QBBpQO
KRK Rokit 8: amzn.to/3zKzUth
WHat mic was used for the recording please ?
which one is the best in your oppinion?
The Yamaha sounds crystal clear very nice !!
Teşekkürler bu güzel tanıtımlar için.
Ben vakit ayırıp izlediğiniz için çok teşekkür ederim Selçuk Beyciğim. çok naziksiniz..
I see why a lot of people rave about the Yamaha HS series. They truly shine in the mid and high range they don't crank the low rang up so there's absolutely no distortion at all no matter how high the volume is.
I see why my cousin and the man at guitar center were trying to get me to purchase the Yamahas.
The Yamaha's really are great sounding. Im running the vxt4 with a 10s and trying to get those balanced together but omg for listening enjoyment Im in heaven.
I have the HS8’s. They’re fantastic. If you add the HS8 subwoofer, it’ll bring the low end down to 22Hz effortlessly. Truly amazing. And that sub is under $400.
Yamaha hs series is unbeatable in studio
The Yamaha HS8's are crystal clear👌 I'm running the HS5's which have less bass but are even clearer! Going to add a subwoofer later for a real fullrange sound👀 I think that will be a unbeatable sound for the price.
been rocking hs50s with hs8s sub for years now, cannot beat the performance at that price.
@@JESS-E_official considering to do the exact same thing. I just miss the low notes that I'm used to hear from my full Klipsch speaker system with 2x 12" subs😂 Then, when it's time to make music myself and i switch to my other setup with the yamaha's, there is 0% bass below 50hz. It just feels like the entire weight of the sound is non existent. I know how to work around it by using a analyzer plugin called "SPAN" while mixing/mastering. But just hearing what I'm doing in the low frequency range is still pretty necessary and also more enjoyable if you ask me. It's not that i want my bass to be boosted (i do like to do that every now and then because it's fun😁), but 90% of the time i just want to hear low notes when the content has it.
drummer here, might need full range bass to fully comprehend what I recorded
I got the hs8 a few years ago and don't regret it. I also listen to music on them too, just so I know the speakers, so when I am mixing or mastering, I can get the best possible mix. though I don't think any frequency is too much in them. I did have to add some acoustic treatment to the back of the speakers though, but since then I have moved my desk back to the wall. So I guess there wouldn't be a problem anymore with the phasing of the bass.
You can not hear the advantage of the ribon tweeter if you hear this video on your speaker at home with a normal tweeter. Go to a shop and hear the HS8 and T8V side by side. You will hear the big difference. The HS8 sounds like a towel lay over the speaker. The Adams have way less distortion in the highs. So hearing is much less ear tireing.
I heard circa 30 Monitos at Music Sore Thomann. And the Yamaha, KRK and the Presonus have a midrange Overboost (like the old NS10) The Adams have a linear frequency response similar to genelec or neumann. The Yamaha, KRK and Presonus are not linear. This is for they who think Yamahas are linear. They are not!
Go to a music store and hear it by yourself.
Thanks for the video (I think!) as it's made me just purchase a matched pair of HS8. They sound far nicer to my ears in this video
Damn nice recording 👍👍
The Yamahas are really clear. The Adams have a different "tone" on the higher frequenzes, maybe its the type of elements they use that just sounds different.
When the bass whit the vocals dropt i chose Adam !
Video için çok teşekkürler emeğinize sağlık Sercan abi. Karşılaştırmayı KRK Rokit 8'den dinleyip Rokit 8'in eksiklerini duyabilmek çok ironik oldu :)
Erol Beyciğim çok enteresan olmuş gerçekten de. Dinleme gibi dinleme olmuş hakikaten :)
Krk 8 almayı düşünüyordum. Deneme şansım yoktu. Adam bi tık daha iyi gibi geldi. Sevdiğim müzik tarzları elektronik hiphop psy (bas agırlıklı). Ama vokaller de geri planda kalsın istemiyorum. Krk 8 mi Adam mı sence? Tesekkür ediyorum..
selamlar hangisi seçtin? memnun kaldın mı? :D Ben de ikisinin arasındayım.
@@osmancetin6467
Şahane içerik hocam elinize sağlık. O kadar farklılar ki telefonda bile duyuluyor🙄
çok çok teşekkür ederim Metin Bey. o kadar çok hoparlörde sonucu almaya çalıştım ki özenli bir test olmasına dikkat gösterdim. bu sözleri duymak mutluluk verici çok teşekkür ediyorum 🙏
Getting excited to receive my RP5G4's. This test proves that the treble will be just as smooth and non-sibilant as I was hoping. Compared to the other two, at least.
HS8 sin duda, muy buen video, un trabajazo felicidades
Thanks for this test, what I found really interesting is that after a while I could tell with my eyes closed which was playing. The Adams, had the widest sound field with a bit of a hole in the middle (almost like a phase issue?), the KRK's had a slightly nasal mid range, the Yamaha's's had the most neutral balance and the most pronounced centre image.
Thank you for the comparison. I think it depends on the type of music you want to mix if one monitor works more than the other. Personally in the electronic I find the KRK more interesting because it seems a more analog sound, while Yamaha seems more digital to me. Adam shines on acoustic and vocals. It could also be that some difference could be due to the position of the left microphone in the KRK, more towards the cone than in the others. The bass also seems more sonorous on the KRK, which is a monitor more suited to the type of music I compose. This video changed my preference for the Yamaha 8H that I wanted to buy. Now I'm leaning more towards the KRK rokit 8.
Türkiye’yi geçtim, dünyada böyle bir kalitese kıyaslama varmıdır bilemedim. Ellerine sağlık Sercan beyciğim
Çok mutlu oldum bu güzel yoruma, çok çoook teşekkür ederim Mert Beyciğim 🙏🙏🙏
Thank you!
Wow! The midrange on the HS8 is far superior than the others.
Este sies un buen test de prueba 👋👍👍
Ah zoom h8 ah. Seni aldım alalı çok işime yarıyorsun, burada da iyi iş çıkarmış. Emeklerinize sağlık Sercan Bey.🙏
Özgür Beyciğim çok teşekkür ederim çok dikkatli ve naziksiniz. Güzel kayıtlar almanıza da çok sevindim. Bolca keyifli işler dilerim
Excellent video, thanks! I hesitated between HS7 or T7V (or HS5 T5V + a Sub), but after hearing this video, it is difficult for me to decide for the 7s, trade off on the bigger size of the 8s!
thank you sir
The HS8's hands down.
Yamaha HS8 oldukça başarılı. Orta kısımlar gayet düz, kayıp frekans yok tonlama kulağa doğru geliyor.
Positive music frequency
Everyone's hearing preferences are all different, but for my ears the T8Vs tick the boxes. I usually like Yamahas, but in this comparison they sounded like they were behind a curtain.
First of all, you rock dude. This is the greatest comparison video ever. It was the dealbreaker for my decision, I needed it. Thanks so much.
And second, I'll have to go with the KRK's. Reading reviews I was inclining towards the Yamahas because they have their reputation, but man listening to this it's clear that the KRK's are the best for pop/rock/urban music production in my opinion. The three are awesome, but love the balance between mids and highs on the KRK. The Yamaha sometimes was too sharp on the high end, and the Adams were too focused on the low end.
Again, thanks so much!!!
You can also adjust the sound on the back in the krk.
The hs8 sounded best in my opinion.
Just ordered my Yamahas the Adam’s sound great to tho 🔥
HS7 with HS8 to compliment my NS1000Ms and NS-10 and quite a happy camper here.
Greate video.
Было очень интересно, спасибо!
Большое спасибо, что нашли время оставить комментарий.
Yamaha HS8 Forever. Insane mid and high range characterized by fullness, clarity, strength of sound and a nice stage, they will never dissapoint you and if u just like to listen music just add an DAC like ex :"Topping E50" with xlr cables conections and u get a nice set without spending much money!!! Remember most recording studios have a pair of Yamahas.
El adam tiene un sonido muy transparente, el yamaha siento que tiene un realze en las frecuencias medias lo cual no me gusta, y el krk tiene un poco de graves mas, pero se puede atenuar gracias a su eq incorporado, pero su sonido tiene profundidad, medios y agudos equilibrados y muy aparte que tiene más campo stereo que los otros dos ✌️ me gusta más el krk
Sağol Sercan Bey çok yararlı oldu. En temizi Yamaha.
Herkes kulağına hangisi hoş geldiyse ona göre yapmış yorumu.Aslında frekans dalgalarına bakarak yapmış olsalardı H8 bana göre gereğinden çok High ve High MIdler yükleniyor.KRK 8 kullanıcı olmama rağmen Adam Audio tonlamaları ve frekans dalgalarına bakarak en yakın gibi duruyor.
Why do the T8V sound so different on the same song at 6:53 vs 7:09 ? 7:09 sounds awesome!
would be useful to add the source track to compare
Adam Audio builds the best room, very nice differentiated, Instruments can be clearly allocated. HS8 has clean sound but doesn't create a large room, so I'd see then a nodge begind. The KRK are totally of, abysmal.
Oh fuck the HS8s sound so good. Glad I made this purchase lol
Gotta say I'm more impressed with those mics you're using
got the Adam :) nice
Nice recording! What did you use to record?
HS 8 shining
Hs80 almayı düşünüyordum,telefondan dinledim dolby atmos açık bir şekilde.Gerçi dolby atmos sinyali almamış olmadığımı düşünüyorum fakat telefonum 3 monitör arasındaki farkları gayet iyi bir şekilde ayırt etmemi sağladı.Yüksek frekansları ağırlıklı olarak duydum hs80 modelinde bu biraz yanıltıcı geldi kulağıma ve düşük frekans ile dengede olmadığını düşündüm.Krk ve Adam modellerinde aşırı bir fark yoktu.Krk modeli biraz daha iç içe geçmiş arada kalmış gibi geldi.İşte bu dediğim kulağımı hazlandıran,dengeli hissettiren ise Adam modeli oldu.Emeğiniz sayesinde bu farkları tespit edebildim.Çok teşekkürler.
T8V, escucharlo en vivo es otra experiencia. Es como descubrir nuevamente toda tu música. Tengo amigos que se asombran con el sonido que producen y decían "como pueden sonar así". Eso sin mencionar la potencia y profundidad de los bajos a la que pueden llegar. 🤷🏻♂️
We don't need you here
Watched another vid comparison of the HS8 and the T8V where they sounded much closer to each other - I know that the Adams have a little weak mid-range, but is it really that extrem in person like I hear in the vid? P.s. great vid, thx for comparing these speakers!
Saw the same, I also felt like they were really close, now this has me questioning
Rokits are too bassy, Phasing issues with the Adam’s….BUT that H8 is clean on all frequencies! Great way to do a comparison!
hs8 best sound but for mixing I prefere KRK , more transient details
Try closing your eyes and listing.
You can hear the HS8.
I went to Musik Produktiv in Ibbenburen Germany and decided to go with Adam T8V
congratulations on a great decision
I prefer the adam t8v, overral better clarity & more airness, open sound and better soundstage thanks to the ribbon tweeter and overral quality & fine tuning i think. They sounds better in the lows (deeper lower end response). The test by amir on audiosciencereview recommand them to erveryone, they are the best in their price range far better than the yamaha and krk.
Yani en iyisi adamslar bence :)
Wich are the best?
why do the KRKs sound so muddy? I mean I`ve used them IRL many times and they sound much better than the pair shown here. Maybe it`s just me but it just seems like some has messed with the EQ. I wonder if they were set to the "flat" setting.
HS8 sound the best, like they sabotage those Adams mid-range for more bass. The KRK's are off-balanced...The real test with the Adams would be a pair of Adam A7x's that will tell the tale...Yamaha HS8 has the most accurate sound!
I have krk5 inches now but I wanted to upgrade my monitoring
.
On the other hand, the focal 50 evo and the yamaha hs8 are relatively close to each other in the price range
.
What do you suggest? Focal 50 or yamaha hs8 or even focal 65evo?
Thanks
I came to hear a comparison between the KRKs and the ADAMs. I left wanting the HS8s.
Don't be fooled. The yamahas over emphasize the mids and highs so they're way off from the true mix.
devi farci ascoltare anche il file audio originale in modo che possiamo sentire la differenza dall'originale con l'audio dei monitor
Müzik tarzlarına göre değerlendirme yapçak olursak r&b hip hop tarzı müzik ile uğraşanlar krk tercihi elektronik müzikle ilgilenenler dengeli mid ve izleri bakımından kesinlikle adam audio bütçem tam arasında diyenlerde hs8 tercih etmeli diye düşünüyorum video için çok teşekkür ediyorum fiio k5 ve sennheiser hd 25 plus ile dinleyip yorum yaptım ve kesinlikle ref monitörü tercihim elektronik müzik dinleyicisi olarak adam audio oldu tekrar çok teşekkür ediyorum
You have a piece of music between 1.30 and 1.45 minutes that in those 15 seconds you should have changed from KRK to HS8, the same 15 seconds of sound on two speakers.
Yet you change from KRK to HS8 when exactly at 1.46 a different piece begins. So this suggests a change in sound but you can't judge if its different because of the change of speaker
or that the music changes. You do this several times after that. The best way to test is a continious music that goes on for 15 seconds, after 7 seconds you change the speaker to present
the sound of the remaining of the 15 seconds. But don't change the speaker when the music changes cause then its not clear if the speaker is performing better or not.
yamaha hands down
HS8s have natural sound , i like them
I like Bass KRK R8, Sub Adam T8V and treble Yamaha HS8
Great concept, but mic positioning and/or monitor volumes were not setup accurately. Panorama is off. Makes judgement difficult. Good effort though.
in the first song we heard male vocals performed by two monitors, and female vocals performed by one monitor
Who is the First Artist song playing? I love it.
They all have their strengths the way I see it and owning 2 of the demos shown
Rokit good for bass music but lacks high end a bit
Hs amazing clarity but lacks in low end
Adams has what both lack in
The rockit can be tuned......no demo is ever a full representation of what it can do. Too much bass? Tune it out. Not enough highs? Tune them in....
LIST OF SONGS?
PLEASE
i prefer to adams sound than the other
başarılı video siz genelde ne kullanıyorsunuz merak ettim?
çok teşekkür ederim. benim ilk tercihim adam..
I would stick with the krk (classic) based on how mixes that I’ve heard done through them sound compared to the others, but of the exact models in this test, I might choose Yamaha instead
The midrange weakness of the Adam T8V described in tests can be heard wonderfully here. I also had the Adam T8V and found it great in the highs but weak in the upper mids, where it seemed too thin and not very neutral.
That’s because he Ribbon tweeters cannot go as low as a silk done or metal tweeter requiring the woofer to do the job. = loss of detail.
The Adams have no midrange weakness. The Yamaha and the KRK have an overboost in the midrange. I heard circa 30 Monitors side by side at Thomann Music Store. And for example Genelec and Neumann have a similar frequency response like the Adams. The Yamaha, KRK and the Presonus have a midrange overboost. And they are not linear.
Then we have different experiences. I also spoke to an Adam technician who confirmed the Adam t8V's weakness in the mid-range and said that the T5V plays much more linearly here. @@OMPTraxxs
It’s probably just my ears. Does the RP8 sound fuller than the others? The RP8 also sounds like it has a broader spectrum. What do you all think?
def not. junky bass and junky top treble.
Really difficult to choose between the incredible crystal clear from yamaha or the incredible stereo separation and subbass from krk... lol
No it's not.
Been using KRKs for 8 years. They're fantastic monitors, but those muddy mids get old quick.
Get the HS8s. They won this hands down
Your 8 years oldf are not G4. KRK changed a lot in quality@@silkroad1201
Can anyone tell about the hiss/noise level of them when on "standby"? Thanks
The Yamaha 's Are The Best Hands Down..!!👍🏾
For Adam, this arrangement of the microphone is incorrect due to the horn waveguide.
Hearing this, the best one is the Yamaha. I have a pair of KRK 8 G3, just for listening, not producing.
1 Yamaha
2 Adam
3 KRK
Hs8 ile hs80m arasindaki fark nedir acaba bilen varsa bilgilendirirse çok iyi olur
adam sound almayi dusunuyorum ,electrik gitari rahat kullanabilirmiyim ? mac booktan line 6 helix e giricem .helixde ses karti var , helixden de adam sound a giricem .ama rokit mi yoksa adam mi karar veremedim
benim tercihim adam oldu.. soundun bana daha iyi geldiğini düşündüm. Bu konuda karar sizin tabi
@@SercanSolmaz eyvallah cok sagol , ingiltede son modelleri rokit yada adam hemen hemen ayni fiyat ,
What's the song name at 3:50?
hi. this song >> artlist.io/song/32377/fall-until-i-fly
6:20 la vocal del adam se escucha mas opacado , en cambio en el yamaha o rokit se escucha mas claro
This is first video where i can hear that yamaha is the best
Much better then the krk.
Hi guys, I need some new speakers..I’m a keyboard player on tour, but i also play my keyboards at home…
I run all my keyboards in stereo into my Soundcraft EFX12 Mixer, then from there into the speakers… I’ve just sold my Yamaha HS7’s, I hated them! Awful sound and way too much midrange and boxy sounding, all I want to do is play my keyboards and sing through whatever speakers i now buy, also listen to TH-cam and WAVS and MP3’s
I do NOT do any mixing or recording…
Would the Rokit RP8 G4’s be okay for me? I will have to have them on stands and they will be around 8 inches from the wall, my room is square and no I don’t have any acoustic treatment…
My room size is 9ft 2 inches by 9ft 5 inches
Thoughts?
thank you very much, but to an accurate analitycal listening you should play more complex music, like classical or jazz, not only EDM music, which is flat...in my HMO 🙂
Krk 🔥🔥🔥
KRK Rokit 8 aklımda vardı ama adam audio daha iyi gibi sanki
Very nice comparison. Please anybody write what is the song name starting at 0:56. Second song.
Yamaha 👍🏻
Adam good
Yamaha has a amazing clear audio, but krk has eq
Hs8 👍👍👍👍👍👍☝️
Bonjour, j'ai commandé sur AMAZON le presonus ERIS 5 XT, KRK 5 G4 et ADAM T5V.
Le ERIS a des aigus présent, des médiums timides et des basses encore plus présente et pas très propres je dirais.
Le KRK sonne réellement propre dans l'ensemble, je dirais peut être juste des médiums un peu colorés.
Le ADAM..les aiguë sont limpide, les mediums magnifique, et les basses propre et très profonde dans les très basses pour un 5 pouces.
Bonjour, merci beaucoup d'avoir pris le temps de faire ce précieux commentaire. J'espère que vous apprécierez l'utilisation de vos moniteurs.
Yamaha has the clear sound
Hs sounds a lot of high freq range which in my opinion may cause hearing fatigue and its incredible to me that adam has less attack on low freqs idk why, it could be because the yamaha has more high freq range??¿¿?
HS8 gang 😈
Hs8
The treble of Yamaha HS8 is irreplaceable
As expected, the Adams are not as precise in the mids, which was also audible in my room.
Yamaha hs 8 👍👍👍
It was quite hard to choose between T8V and HS8 (dont like KRK), but at 7:30 rock melody showed a lot. Listen close to that electric overdriven guitar playing. On HS8 you hear it clearly. On T8V guitar is muddy, deaf and not clear. Then at 7:49 guitar plays smth over the main guitar melody with higher strings-like 2-4 strings. And again. On HS8 I hear it well, but on T8V its quieter and too much bass. Muddy even
Maybe its the way you recorded them? Something to do with the mic? Because if it has nothing to do with how you recorded it and HS8 just sounds way better here, then if someone makes rock music-he should go HS8
Do you also hear this difference? Why do you think that is? I am into rock listening and mixing
On T8V that whatever guitarist is doing is simply sounding off and bad and bassy. As if some cloth is hanging over the speakers. How can they be more analytical than as you found out? That rock thing sounds perfect on HS8. Mid range guitar riffs is there, bass is there and highs. All balanced
The waveguide on the T8V is designed to reduce vertical dispersion on the AMT ribbon. The mic is sitting just below the ribbon and may be out of the sweet spot.
@@lb659 hm. If thats true, its good. Otherwise, T8V sounded really worse there
Also, many people report that T8V color music and they give that HiFi experience. HS8 translate better. Also t8v have exaggerated bass