I have wondered that myself for the last ten years…I think its embarrassing…Toto had similar problems with Bobby Kimball. Thankfully Joseph Williams is back and sounds great and in tune…
Yes, Mangini is brilliant, but Portney brings impulsive tones, despite this being lucid and clean, which adds to DT the aggressiveness of metal. I'm divided between who is best for the band, but satisfied with Portney back.
@@miguelachaneto I think if they want to keep him they should adapt - he seems fine at lower tones (verse) but loses control at higher pitch, maybe change so the chorus stays low pitch? They're definitely good enough musicians and artists to work around some limits as a team
James is actually performing well. You can not expect that a protagonist who is afraid of getting drowned in a barrel of wine in a secluded cellar sings in the key. He will scream like a pig, which is exactly how JLB performs it.
If only they had a singer...
I have wondered that myself for the last ten years…I think its embarrassing…Toto had similar problems with Bobby Kimball. Thankfully Joseph Williams is back and sounds great and in tune…
Yes, Mangini is brilliant, but Portney brings impulsive tones, despite this being lucid and clean, which adds to DT the aggressiveness of metal. I'm divided between who is best for the band, but satisfied with Portney back.
yes, portnEY can sing too
He only screws up the chorus but sings all the verses pretty well
James.. how is it possible he is so incredibly off key so frequently?? Wow..
I don't get why they keep him - the rest of the musicianship is so good, then the singer is just.... not up to the same standard
@@omgu8mynewt He has a tone of voice that created the band's characteristics, changing it would be a big mistake, but he's really out of tune.
@@omgu8mynewt Joe Satriani doesn't need a singer, but Dream Theater needs LaBrie!
He is definitely struggling.
@@miguelachaneto I think if they want to keep him they should adapt - he seems fine at lower tones (verse) but loses control at higher pitch, maybe change so the chorus stays low pitch? They're definitely good enough musicians and artists to work around some limits as a team
Meu Deus! Ver o Labrie cantando no refrão chega a doer de tão ruim! 😂 Poderiam colocar um autotune na voz dele, não? Ficaria menos feio pelo menos!
Portnoy should have never returned. Sons of apollo live > DT live
James is actually performing well. You can not expect that a protagonist who is afraid of getting drowned in a barrel of wine in a secluded cellar sings in the key. He will scream like a pig, which is exactly how JLB performs it.
That was kind of rude yet surpriselly accurate...
Mio Dio che ha fatto la voce di James ?
they should play only instrumentals imo ... labrie is ruining the song :(
This is a terrible mix
Por dios! Tan mal esta cantando james?