Industrial Design vs Mechanical Engineering | Fictiv

In this panel discussion, experts from 3 of the top product firms explore the give and take between design and engineering in the development of hardware products.
For all of our industry-leading content, subscribe to the Fictiv Blog:
www.fictiv.com...
To learn more about Fictiv and their services: www.fictiv.com/
FOLLOW & CONNECT WITH US on:
• Twitter | / fictiv
• Facebook | / fictivmade
• Instagram | / fictivmade
• LinkedIn | / fictiv
Create your free account: app.fictiv.com...

[@kentvandervelden]

Interesting topic and video. I've enjoy reading the content on your website as well. With panel videos, consider normalizing the audio a bit, i.e., increasing the gain for audience questions or when panelists are talking without the mike. Would help the viewer not have to frequently tinker with the volume control.

[@billschnoebelen40]

It depends on the product. If you have a product which requires development on how it will interact with human emotions, such as a robotic dog, use ID. If you have a cell phone case which needs to look different than the other 100 cell phone cases, use ID. If you have a product which solves a problem and needs to be functional, use ME firms. Our strategy is "fast to functional". BTW: Mold making efficacy increased because 1. Coated variable flute endmills which handle higher feedrates 2. Constant contact/constant load HSM CAM toolpaths 3. Faster controller hardware to huck the CNC mass around much faster. We take advantage of this technology in our mechanical development process everyday. We can get creative and test a lot of mechanical solutions in the real world. Form follows functionality. When the product works functionally and the BOM is below cost making it look good is not too difficult. It certainly a lot easier than the other way around.

[@foysalahmmed8981]

Can you provide a video about industrial engineering and production engineering?

[@ashmakmoon8833]

Help me choose: Glasgow school of arts and University of Glasgow's [MSc in Product Design Engineering] or
Loughborough Universities' [MSc Integrated Industrial Engineering].
My background: B.Tech in Mechanical Engineering from IIT Bombay Currently a Research Engineer at IIT Bombay in collaboration with BARC and L&T.

[@proteusindustriesinc2637]

Which one do you think is more advanced?

[@kareemelhosini1683]

An engineer can be a designer but a designer can't be an engineer

[@gembongbaskoro4608]

design is concept and engineering is implementation

[@salsun7437]

No, concept does not equal design.

[@karanrathod9016]

i would say cocept in terms of cars is a first hand manufacturing of a car with a design that is made by the designer with improvements

[@devarshivyas]

It's corelated like software and hardware.. doesn't matter how beautiful ur idea is if it's not functioning it's not producable/profitable/markatable by common sense. In other word rather than contrary Both r complementary to each other.
Solve problem Beautifully [Engineering+Aesthetic]

[@Charlie300]

design is presentation, concept is idea and engineering is functionality. A good concept design could be all put together.

[@barefootvivi]

Anyone can tell me where to find a good hardware developer?

[@samuelroscoe6815]

Designers + Engineers = Design Engineers ...

[@vickoaguilar9692]

sound is awful

[@Norman_Peterson]

no fight? good!

[@johnjacob688]

I don't know why but I'm annoyed at the guy in the front row wearing a hat.

[@jason9336]

blah blah blah