00:00 Eva Benefield Issue 07:58 Eva Benefield Takes the Stand 20:53 Jurors Questioned about Media Coverage #CourtTV Catch up on FL v. #AshleyBenefield here: www.courttv.com/tag/ashley-benefield/?
@@Baddcompany999 if youre saying the mass majority in the last few months is not woman kiling their man youre wrong the other place i posted this several people wondered the same. its in the main comments in this video comment section These are just a few in the last few months that i remember and also found in the top portion (very recent videos on this channel sarah boone woman that was extradited from italy Lindsey shiver Christine ricci Kouro richins Marcia thimpson shanna gardner
To be fair the judge gave the witness very clear instructions. Why taking any risk by talking with the press or by posting on Tik Tok? Also, the reporter is partially guilty here by taking advantage of a very vulnerable witness.
did you see her t shirts? my dad got murder and all I got was this tshirt. her mom was killed. They will test Rene body for same toxins the lab said was in Ashleys now that I am eager to see
@@Jessica-bx5kjShe’s savy enough to use her present notoriety to promote her jewelry on Tik-Tok. I don’t know her exact age but wld guess she is at least college-age.🤷🏻♀️
I tagree. And I don't see that the defense attorney is being aggressive; this is his job, to protect his client's interests. I think he's being straightforward and not bullying. The young girl knew what she was doing was prohibited. I"m very sorry for her, of course, but she shouldn't have.
I thought John Pryor was the most annoying defense lawyer ever (there was another trial at the same time with another incredibly annoying loudmouth lawyer--can't recall right now) but this guy is ridiculous and rude and unprofessional. I love how the judge shuts him down and basically tells him to stfu
You know media loves to frame every big case one way or the other. They usually go for the framing of guilty and it’s weird how they always do that. How can anyone get a fair trial when media is salivating all over the case? Media is excellent at bending minds but terrible at just giving the information so people can decide for themselves.
That's not crazy. You are told, as a juror, that you can't watch news commentary or coverage outside of the trial. A: It could be wildly false or speculation. You shouldn't arrive at a verdict based on speculation or commentary which may be wildly inaccurate or wrong. It's not impossible to not watch news or social media that's ridiculous. You turn away, that's all.
Once the Jurors are questioned, the defendant tries hard to squeeze some "smiles" reflecting upon the "right" look she should pull off ! She is so manipulative and calculated.
There is no excuses. She is 23 years old. Old enough to know and she would have been informed about the procedures of taking the stand. This generation is clueless and how entitled is she? This is not just a murder case but one who is defaming her father and somehow the court has to take a break to talk about her conduct. Eva Benefield is a young woman who needs to wake up the people who like your videos are not your friends. Talking to strangers with microphones are there for their own interests not hers. This is not a tik tok post this is reality. This is not about how Eva Benefield feels it is about getting justice for her father. She is a crucial witness and at present she is working for the prosecution.
Seriously, the state should pay for your lunches so they aren’t putting this position to go out and find their own lunch and be exposed to people talking about it when the trial is being streamed live. They’re in the community where a high profile case is being held it’s being extreme live on TV, of course they’re going to run in and be around people who start talking about it, not knowing who they are. You should not be putting in this position and situation.
I'm really trying here, especially because I was personally subjected to living with a severely abusive man who was married to my mother and would beat her like a rag doll, but this woman- Ashley - just doesn't convince me. She looks as fake as they come. Her fake victim look is so over the top. She comes across like Shanda Vander Ark. I just don't buy what she's trying to sell.
I'm sorry to hear what your mother went through and that you had to witness that😢. I was waiting for someone who knows true abuse to comment because she comes across as so phony.
What a dumb way to accuse someone of being a murderer. All the evidence including statements in court made by the victim where he admits to abusing the defendant, he also admits to shooting a gun inside there home to intimidate the defendant. At the very least she was obviously afraid of the victim. He displayed psychology and stalking behavior for years and numerous witnesses have confirmed this. I can't believe how horrible this case has been so far the prosecutor has come no where close to proving guilt beyond a reasonable doubt
@kerri-lynbryant293 This young lady has lost her mother and father, her father in terrible circumstances. She had been in court providing evidence which is tremendously stressful. She was then caught off guard as she was leaving, she did not give away anything important. Please have some compassion for this young lady. Have you ever had the experience of yoyr father being murdered not long after your mother had died?
If I was that judge, I would taken full precautions to preserve this trial and would have dismissed that juror The court needs to supply meals to the Jury to avoid things like this. At no fault to that juror but it’s risky
Poor Eva, she lost her mother to cancer and now her father to a murderer! Eva is an orphan with no parent to guide her and protect her through life. Her dad, Doug should have done better by Eva instead of skirt chasing. Doug destroyed his true family through his poor choices. The father that men should look up to and model themselves after is Martin Holmes, Katie Holmes's father. That is a man watching out for his daughter always!
Right …. Because you know him right? Lmao 😂and not poor eva !! That girl is a freaking weirdo and could use a hair brush and some damn mascara . Don’t care what YOU say or think but a LOT of Women NEED makeup . She looks just awful and so does the ex wife . Huge bags under her eyes and just yuck! Anyone can be a model I guess ! She looks like a zombie it’s gross
Case dismissed 😊 Who could take her testimony seriously after that. You seem to be right Ashley, with discipline for that kid. If you don't hold the kid responsible, then it's on her lawyers for not haven taken the weight of the courts rules seriously.
This is the first time I am watching a trial on you-toube with so many hiccups. I'm afraid the victim will not get true justice by Ashley pro manipulative ways.
I have followed this awful case. The US law "system", in and out of the jury as they should not hear "certain things", some object can not be presented etc etc is scary, mildly said. I am SO glad i fall under Sweden´s jurisdiction!!!
I think you've got it wrong. The jury can't hear certain things because it would be very prejudicial. This is because a defendant is entitled to a fair trial. Commentary, with speculation, could cause a juror to form a wrong impression. I am proud that the United States takes these matters seriously. We have a thing called the Constitution. And, for the record, Sweden's judicial system has similar protections in place.
@@patricias5122 Thank you for humble answer! I understand your point, and knowledge, but i do not agree in all. I do know about the court "system" in Sweden. We do not have a jury (apart from if it is a "goals of freedom of the press". The judge (in all the other cases) and the jurors is present during all the time. Keep well!
The daughter gave more than one interview. I just watched one on Court TV in front of the courthouse, which is clearly not the one they are referring to. So how was she "caught off-guard" twice? This is not okay.
7/30/24 Defense Attorneys objections throughout this trial were mainly over Hearsay! Absurd, making them look really bad after already talked to! Atty doesn’t even know what day it is!!
If you have NEVER been in a abusive relationship, you don’t really have a valid opinion! There is a honeymoon phase, then the abuse starts… honeymoon phase, etc. It’s very difficult to get out of this circle of abuse. One’s self-esteem hits the floor after significant time in the relationship. She definitely was abused, and was scared of him and what he would do to their daughter. He didn’t even care about the baby… he just wanted HER! Shooting a gun in the ceiling is abuse. Striking her in the face is abuse. Following her around is abuse… anything that frightens her and he deliberately acted on is abuse. Shame on his daughter for going on tik tok to disparage her, and that little six year old girl is her half-sister… whom she doesn’t care about.
7/30/24 This is first clip of Eva on stand re: Issue w/reporter, 2nd half a lot of people saw from 4days ago many comments. Different title Grilled on Stand? Jury not included in that 1
I believe he was abusive. I lived that life at one time. His text messages, along with other things showed me alot. Now about the shooting I'm waiting on the entire trial before I say my opinion on that.
@Morgan-ke7xm Hello 😊 Firstly, let me say to Eva’s Credit that I understand Different People **Grieve** Differently and that They may Sometimes Do and Say **Strange Things** after a Tragic Situation. BUT Miss Eva has Shown herself to be a **WEIRDO** by her **Actions** Imo, Chalk it up to Either ReckLess youth or Stupidity, she has Also Demonstrated Disrespectful Behavior to the memory of her Deceased Father and she seems DeVoid of Decency.
@@reneeb.8351 im nit saying anything about self defense or any specific trial you kinda read all that into my comment but this is not a statistic ive ever heard can this be verified ( course im gonna search it) but honestly theres 1 or 2 cases right now that are not a woman mrdr or self defense kiling their husb/ lver. its nausiating. this is not how court tv was until now starting a few yrs ago when i began watching around 2020
I agree with the others that it will be a mist trial, but I think it’s more so how the judge is handling the case… I disagree with those who think he’s doing a great job
00:00 Eva Benefield Issue
07:58 Eva Benefield Takes the Stand
20:53 Jurors Questioned about Media Coverage
#CourtTV Catch up on FL v. #AshleyBenefield here:
www.courttv.com/tag/ashley-benefield/?
WHY ARE 99% of the cases on court tv woman mrdring their men? like literally WHY!
@@8Platinum8Because people are interested in female perpetrators.
@@8Platinum8 that's wildly incorrect lol.
@@Baddcompany999 what are you talking about?
@@Baddcompany999 if youre saying the mass majority in the last few months is not woman kiling their man youre wrong the other place i posted this several people wondered the same. its in the main comments in this video comment section
These are just a few in the last few months that i remember and also found in the top portion (very recent videos on this channel
sarah boone
woman that was extradited from italy
Lindsey shiver
Christine ricci
Kouro richins
Marcia thimpson
shanna gardner
This poor girl. She must be going through absolute hell. Thank goodness this judge has common sense.
To be fair the judge gave the witness very clear instructions. Why taking any risk by talking with the press or by posting on Tik Tok? Also, the reporter is partially guilty here by taking advantage of a very vulnerable witness.
did you see her t shirts? my dad got murder and all I got was this tshirt. her mom was killed. They will test Rene body for same toxins the lab said was in Ashleys now that I am eager to see
yup she is young and does not have either one of her parents. I hope she has a good lawyer or someone keeping an eye out on her.
I totally agree! Why would you speak to a reporter or post on social media. She’s not 12, so she knows that can derail the trial.
@@Jessica-bx5kjShe’s savy enough to use her present notoriety to promote her jewelry on Tik-Tok. I don’t know her exact age but wld guess she is at least college-age.🤷🏻♀️
I tagree. And I don't see that the defense attorney is being aggressive; this is his job, to protect his client's interests. I think he's being straightforward and not bullying. The young girl knew what she was doing was prohibited. I"m very sorry for her, of course, but she shouldn't have.
He is an excellent judge!
She is guilty AF! She should not use a reality such as Domestic Violence to cover her crime. It's not fair to the real victims of domestic violence!
Why don't the court just call up the news station and review the tape of the interview with Eva?
I thought John Pryor was the most annoying defense lawyer ever (there was another trial at the same time with another incredibly annoying loudmouth lawyer--can't recall right now) but this guy is ridiculous and rude and unprofessional. I love how the judge shuts him down and basically tells him to stfu
Think the one you can't recall might be the treadmill boy/dad case... that defense attorney was obnoxious.
Its crazy to think the jurors are not going to see anything via media coverage. Its EVERYWHERE!
@@kerri-lynbryant293 yes, I've often wondered about that....
You know media loves to frame every big case one way or the other. They usually go for the framing of guilty and it’s weird how they always do that. How can anyone get a fair trial when media is salivating all over the case? Media is excellent at bending minds but terrible at just giving the information so people can decide for themselves.
That's not crazy. You are told, as a juror, that you can't watch news commentary or coverage outside of the trial. A: It could be wildly false or speculation. You shouldn't arrive at a verdict based on speculation or commentary which may be wildly inaccurate or wrong. It's not impossible to not watch news or social media that's ridiculous. You turn away, that's all.
Once the Jurors are questioned, the defendant tries hard to squeeze some "smiles" reflecting upon the "right" look she should pull off ! She is so manipulative and calculated.
There is no excuses. She is 23 years old. Old enough to know and she would have been informed about the procedures of taking the stand. This generation is clueless and how entitled is she? This is not just a murder case but one who is defaming her father and somehow the court has to take a break to talk about her conduct. Eva Benefield is a young woman who needs to wake up the people who like your videos are not your friends. Talking to strangers with microphones are there for their own interests not hers. This is not a tik tok post this is reality.
This is not about how Eva Benefield feels it is about getting justice for her father. She is a crucial witness and at present she is working for the prosecution.
Seriously, the state should pay for your lunches so they aren’t putting this position to go out and find their own lunch and be exposed to people talking about it when the trial is being streamed live. They’re in the community where a high profile case is being held it’s being extreme live on TV, of course they’re going to run in and be around people who start talking about it, not knowing who they are. You should not be putting in this position and situation.
This judge is good
I'm really trying here, especially because I was personally subjected to living with a severely abusive man who was married to my mother and would beat her like a rag doll, but this woman- Ashley - just doesn't convince me. She looks as fake as they come. Her fake victim look is so over the top. She comes across like Shanda Vander Ark. I just don't buy what she's trying to sell.
I'm sorry to hear what your mother went through and that you had to witness that😢. I was waiting for someone who knows true abuse to comment because she comes across as so phony.
@@nicolecordascarapicchia6380 THAT'S the word, Phony. Thank you 😊
@@chilenitaprotrump 🤙🤙
What a dumb way to accuse someone of being a murderer. All the evidence including statements in court made by the victim where he admits to abusing the defendant, he also admits to shooting a gun inside there home to intimidate the defendant. At the very least she was obviously afraid of the victim. He displayed psychology and stalking behavior for years and numerous witnesses have confirmed this. I can't believe how horrible this case has been so far the prosecutor has come no where close to proving guilt beyond a reasonable doubt
@ryancox7155 Your opinion has no bearing on mine, nor am I on the jury.
The daughter should've been smarter. No interviews!
@kerri-lynbryant293 This young lady has lost her mother and father, her father in terrible circumstances.
She had been in court providing evidence which is tremendously stressful. She was then caught off guard as she was leaving, she did not give away anything important. Please have some compassion for this young lady.
Have you ever had the experience of yoyr father being murdered not long after your mother had died?
@@kerri-lynbryant293 L take
If I was that judge, I would taken full precautions to preserve this trial and would have dismissed that juror The court needs to supply meals to the Jury to avoid things like this. At no fault to that juror but it’s risky
Ashley Benefield is all over Eva being on the stand. Psychotic.
all you people judging people you dont even know...his daughter may be the psychotic one
What does "all over Eva" mean?
@@ChrisinChicago guess because she's looking at her..like where is she suppose to look....this is the danger in media. Cases get made before verdict
@@ChrisinChicago really? 🙄...Ashley pushed for her attorney to make sure Eva was questioned.
@@thewanderer1139 No. Wrong.
Its your responsibility to get that footage and see and listen to it ....
This is definitely going to be a mistrial.
Poor Eva, she lost her mother to cancer and now her father to a murderer! Eva is an orphan with no parent to guide her and protect her through life. Her dad, Doug should have done better by Eva instead of skirt chasing. Doug destroyed his true family through his poor choices. The father that men should look up to and model themselves after is Martin Holmes, Katie Holmes's father. That is a man watching out for his daughter always!
Right …. Because you know him right? Lmao 😂and not poor eva !! That girl is a freaking weirdo and could use a hair brush and some damn mascara . Don’t care what YOU say or think but a LOT of
Women NEED makeup . She looks just awful and so does the ex wife . Huge bags under her eyes and just yuck! Anyone can be a model I guess ! She looks like a zombie it’s gross
Case dismissed 😊
Who could take her testimony seriously after that.
You seem to be right Ashley, with discipline for that kid. If you don't hold the kid responsible, then it's on her lawyers for not haven taken the weight of the courts rules seriously.
They should have lunch order for them to prevent this drom happening then a d now going foward
Correct. Most trials I watch do just that. Order in for the jury. Guess Fla. cannot afford that.
@@MSgirl67 Too busy taking Disney to court!
This judge is fantastic. He's so professional.
This is the first time I am watching a trial on you-toube with so many hiccups. I'm afraid the victim will not get true justice by Ashley pro manipulative ways.
That girl needs to be commended for maintaining her poise about this.
I have followed this awful case. The US law "system", in and out of the jury as they should not hear "certain things", some object can not be presented etc etc is scary, mildly said. I am SO glad i fall under Sweden´s jurisdiction!!!
I think you've got it wrong. The jury can't hear certain things because it would be very prejudicial. This is because a defendant is entitled to a fair trial. Commentary, with speculation, could cause a juror to form a wrong impression. I am proud that the United States takes these matters seriously. We have a thing called the Constitution. And, for the record, Sweden's judicial system has similar protections in place.
@@patricias5122 Thank you for humble answer! I understand your point, and knowledge, but i do not agree in all. I do know about the court "system" in Sweden. We do not have a jury (apart from if it is a "goals of freedom of the press". The judge (in all the other cases) and the jurors is present during all the time. Keep well!
Wow, she really just.... told everyone she could?
tik tok ? seriously girl, get yourself together !
Agreed
GUILTY
Ok..no worries..
It’s really sad that people are more worried about being seen on social media! Keep on being reckless you’re going to cause a mistrial
Taking notes of every jury member.
I'm surprised the jury wasn't sequestered.
I can't even think of a murder trial where the jury was sequestered. Not sure why this one would be any different.
@@naomi.7777 I may be Mistaken, but by way of **Example**, wasn’t the jury **Sequestered** in the OJ Simpson trial?? 🤷🏽♀️
Il il y a pas de caméra dans le restaurant??
The daughter gave more than one interview. I just watched one on Court TV in front of the courthouse, which is clearly not the one they are referring to. So how was she "caught off-guard" twice? This is not okay.
Leave poor eva alone!!
Who is taking care of Ashley if she’s under 18.
Very immature
The reporter needs to identify the juror or jurors.
7/30/24 Defense Attorneys objections throughout this trial were mainly over Hearsay! Absurd, making them look really bad after already talked to! Atty doesn’t even know what day it is!!
If you have NEVER been in a abusive relationship, you don’t really have a valid opinion! There is a honeymoon phase, then the abuse starts… honeymoon phase, etc. It’s very difficult to get out of this circle of abuse. One’s self-esteem hits the floor after significant time in the relationship. She definitely was abused, and was scared of him and what he would do to their daughter. He didn’t even care about the baby… he just wanted HER! Shooting a gun in the ceiling is abuse. Striking her in the face is abuse. Following her around is abuse… anything that frightens her and he deliberately acted on is abuse. Shame on his daughter for going on tik tok to disparage her, and that little six year old girl is her half-sister… whom she doesn’t care about.
Amen
Where is everyone seeing vinnie interviewing and a car crash happens on air?
State Attorney looks like Kathy Kinney on the Drew Carey show🤦♀️ bless her heart. She needs a make up lesson on eyeshadow. We’re in 2024.🤣
👍🏽 😂😂😂😂
7/30/24 This is first clip of Eva on stand re: Issue w/reporter, 2nd half a lot of people saw from 4days ago many comments. Different title Grilled on Stand? Jury not included in that 1
I believe he was abusive. I lived that life at one time. His text messages, along with other things showed me alot. Now about the shooting I'm waiting on the entire trial before I say my opinion on that.
She shot him in the back, and she was the only one armed.
What texts did you see?? The ones I saw didn’t show him as the way you’re describing him.
@@jesusisgod4992Not in the back. It was from the side.
Agreed … covert narc 100%
Love bombing and abuse
Just an excuse for the defence to get a mistrial and then this manipulator can walk free without consequence or conscience.
Looking quite beige today
its sad she using her dads death to get her 15 minutes of fame. SMH, she comes off like a weirdo.
This is unnecessarily mean to this young woman that lost so much.
@@dannywhite670 unnecessary opinion.
Not a bright bulb
The daughter knew exactly what she was doing. Probably looking for more Instagram followers and 5 minutes of fame. Shameless behavior.
Leave her alone everyone processes tragedy differently
Mistrial
Yah the daughter is definitely a weirdo
how?
@Morgan-ke7xm Hello 😊 Firstly, let me say to Eva’s Credit that I understand Different People **Grieve** Differently and that They may Sometimes Do and Say **Strange Things** after a Tragic Situation. BUT Miss Eva has Shown herself to be a **WEIRDO** by her **Actions** Imo, Chalk it up to Either ReckLess youth or Stupidity, she has Also Demonstrated Disrespectful Behavior to the memory of her Deceased Father and she seems DeVoid of Decency.
@@renewashington791 Can you be more specific about what actions were so horrible
Did you see Eva’s eyes when he asked about seeing her phone? Panic!!
WHY ARE 99% of the cases on court tv woman mrdring their men? like literally WHY!
Well. Theres a rash of women murderers the last few years. Its a problem
Self-defense is not murder. The trial is not over yet and the majority of murders that happen in this country are women.
I was literally thinking the same after I saw the new one about the firefighter's wife who off'd him, claiming - drum roll - self-defense.
I had been thinking that myself Sydney (Australia
@@reneeb.8351 im nit saying anything about self defense or any specific trial you kinda read all that into my comment but this is not a statistic ive ever heard can this be verified ( course im gonna search it) but honestly theres 1 or 2 cases right now that are not a woman mrdr or self defense kiling their husb/ lver. its nausiating. this is not how court tv was until now starting a few yrs ago when i began watching around 2020
mistrial !
I agree with the others that it will be a mist trial, but I think it’s more so how the judge is handling the case… I disagree with those who think he’s doing a great job
Mistrial
Mistrial