I live in Norway, have a 2021 model 3; My brother-in-law has the BYD. I can definitely confirm these tests are the real deal. The BYD suv is very good, and only getting better.
Sam, an interesting analysis of the comparison study-as always! But I’m a small, inexpensive car guy. So for me, your programs on low-priced EVs light my fire; e.g., your recent report on the $14,000. Geely. So, do keep us old fixed-income geezers in mind when you are prepping your reports. In spite of this small caveat, you’re the best. Frequently, I share your programming with my grandson, who just got his driver’s license: one geezer driver out, one teen-aged driver in. Best regards from the U.S., Bob Campbell
AFAIK, Dongchedi, a Chinese automotive media, has its own winter EVs large group test too. "Dongchedi conducted a winter range test of 41 EVs in November 2021. The test vehicles included pure electric, hybrid, and extended program electric vehicles, and were tested for range, charging, air conditioning, cold start, and other winter issues. NIO EC6 achieved 336.9 km, with a winter range achievement rate of 54.78%, making it number one. The Second went to the XPENG P7, which achieved 316.2km of real range. Third place went to the Zeekr 001 with a final range of 298.4km." No any BYD in the top ten list.
i went to see the test they conducted. it's a freaking joke. They arent even testing the range. Some cars had 20km 40km attached. I saw the Tang DM range at 44km.. HAHAHAHA.. Their barometer was when the tang activated their hybrid system to be more efficient while maintaining performance. They put the tang at 44km because they got pissed they couldnt switch to full EV motor.. A test that says the Tang DM range is 44km?? Ya right. Worst test i've seen in a long while. They better stay in china and fool the ignorant. As for you, i dont know what your motive is, but stop misleading people. You have been marked.
I detect a clear bias in favor of BYD. I suspect that is because you perceive a very high value in that company's line of vehicles. You seem to 'need' or 'desire' a four-wheel drive SUV with seven seats. And, I have to admit, you've piqued my curiosity about BYD as well. And, as one Viking to another, I really enjoy your channel and your commentary.
I no longer think range is a problem with BEV's. Once you get beyond 400km per charge it would cover more than 97% of all usual travel. 97% of most peoples trips are under 120km so at 400km range it would only affect a few large distance drivers in regards to range.
Thanks Sam. Great video, as always. Two points: 1) Isn't the Tesla Model X a 4 wheel drive, 7 seater SUV? 2) Towing capacity of 1.5 tonnes is the biggest you've seen for any EV? There's a recent video on TH-cam with a Ford F-150 Lightning towing a 6,000 pound caravan. That's 2.67 tonnes. Its maximum load wasn't mentioned.
If I turn the volume down to 30% and increase the playback speed to 3x then the audio is mostly cleaned up. It would be nice to just have cleaner audio though.
I’m curious. When you said the tests were done at freezing temperatures, what were they? -1C -20C -40C? The ranges do degrade even more as it gets colder. As a Canadian who is looking for his first electric vehicle, I’d like to know the ranges at worst case scenarios for my location.
@@lesliecarter4295 I guess that depends on where you are in the world. -10c is extreme where I am and just a few hours drive away anything below 16c is considered cold with anything below 0c being intolerable. At least there is a benchmark that you could extrapolate from.
@@Seibar42 fair point. Though this was supposed to be in Norway in winter. When I did my forces winter training there it was much colder and also very dark.
Batteries weaken when too warm. It may be that, with a smart heat pump monitoring and maintaining ideal temp in the battery pack, the main loss here came from driving on snow and ice.
How much of the range reduction is due to batteries being affected by the cold and how much is the drain from the heater? I would like to see how much battery power would be used when it is parked for the same time as the driving test just maintaining the temperature.
the new Tang with 6 seats and more battery thus more range is the model to go, imo. if one wants more tech geeky feeling AND luxury features AND size, ES8 is worth considering, albeit a bit more expensive. those two are pretty much the only affordable full size pure electric suv's right now. There is another EHS9 but that one is probably too plush for family use. Tang ev has sold about 2100 units in Norway, a country with 5 mil population, in the last 12 months. that is not too shabby.
I don't think it is sold outside the US yet. Also imagine some unknown Chinese company delivered a few times more cars in a 5 million people country than Rivian did in the US (that is if what I found is correct and they had avout 2100 cars delivered until early May).
Based on your judgement on EQS, that means a van should cost more than an eqs ‘cause it has mare space and bigger trunk. EQS is luxury. Is above premium. The downside of it is actually the weight
Illumination can frighten him who does not seek enlightenment. Wisdom is a gift conspired through love and through power. Any situation that you find yourself in, is an outward reflection of your inner state of beingness.
Sam mate! Off topic but..., that Amoxycillin story scared the crap out of me (for you)..., here's why... About 1yr ago my wife was given a penicilin-based antibiotic (one she had had before) and broke out in a rash..., started getting hot, her head started getting weird - called local pharmacy (where we got the drugs), suggested we "might" want to take her to hospital (weekend) or come up to the pharmacy. So I raced her up to the pharmacy (closer) like a mad man (she was in medical distress), the guy took one look at her and hit her with an epi-pen - saved her life...! Don't make too many assumptions about your experience with this thing Sam... 🙏
Sam, these tests were conducted on dry roads at temperatures ranging from Zero down to minus 10 degrees. Real winter data needs to be at much lower temperatures down to at least - 25, and with snow and ice. Then you will then see the degradation is typically 25 to 35%, and there are many tests on youtube backing this up.
@@rogerstarkey5390 Its 107 KWh vs 82 KWh so not 60% No it shouldnt if you knew A little about consumtion in winter The air is more dents in winter and a bigger car will allways have higher consumtion. Its allmost 900 kg more then A tiny model 3. Can Even compare them.
"According to a study conducted by the American organization AAA Automotive Research Center, the distance traveled by electric cars on a single charge can be reduced by an average of 57 percent as a result of cool air". Consumer Disputes Board in Finland: Hyundai Kona Electric 2019 "When using the car, the buyer stated that the range is considerably shorter than stated. The consumer told the seller, based on his three-week driving experience, that the range in normal winter conditions was almost half as short as the range according to the WLTP standard".That 11 % losses is more like by tire slipping.
Not only do westerners not know the BYD brand (they will), BYD needs to rename their models, in the west. Tang? Powdered fake OJ? Why not call it something like Cascadia, or some other US place name (think Telluride, Sequoia, etc.). Their marketing leaves something to be desired. Seems like a great BEV though.
Why try to pretend and hide behind its name. If don't like it don't buy it its a free market and if you got plenty of money spare get the most expensive one with the establish brand.
Look at the BYD Tang and the chevy Blazer ev. They look identical. Easy to see how gm plans on making so many models by 2030. Gm has been doing this for decades.
Surely the external temperature is irrelevant if there is an internal temperature control system? The only drop in efficiency would be caused by the generation of heat or use of cooling refrigeration? The Chinese are coming. Is it a surprise? The main car makers source over half their components from China FOR CARS SOKD IN EUROPE. Why should Chinese cars be inferior when the same CHINESE components go into ALL cars?
How about a providing a table with the car model and range. It would add so much to your video.
Yeah Mr Sam how bout a chart with ur small fries fav colors
I live in Norway, have a 2021 model 3;
My brother-in-law has the BYD. I can definitely confirm these tests are the real deal. The BYD suv is very good, and only getting better.
Over th air ?
Sam, an interesting analysis of the comparison study-as always! But I’m a small, inexpensive car guy. So for me, your programs on low-priced EVs light my fire; e.g., your recent report on the $14,000. Geely. So, do keep us old fixed-income geezers in mind when you are prepping your reports. In spite of this small caveat, you’re the best. Frequently, I share your programming with my grandson, who just got his driver’s license: one geezer driver out, one teen-aged driver in. Best regards from the U.S., Bob Campbell
AFAIK, Dongchedi, a Chinese automotive media, has its own winter EVs large group test too.
"Dongchedi conducted a winter range test of 41 EVs in November 2021. The test vehicles included pure electric, hybrid, and extended program electric vehicles, and were tested for range, charging, air conditioning, cold start, and other winter issues.
NIO EC6 achieved 336.9 km, with a winter range achievement rate of 54.78%, making it number one.
The Second went to the XPENG P7, which achieved 316.2km of real range.
Third place went to the Zeekr 001 with a final range of 298.4km."
No any BYD in the top ten list.
i went to see the test they conducted. it's a freaking joke. They arent even testing the range. Some cars had 20km 40km attached. I saw the Tang DM range at 44km.. HAHAHAHA.. Their barometer was when the tang activated their hybrid system to be more efficient while maintaining performance. They put the tang at 44km because they got pissed they couldnt switch to full EV motor.. A test that says the Tang DM range is 44km?? Ya right. Worst test i've seen in a long while. They better stay in china and fool the ignorant. As for you, i dont know what your motive is, but stop misleading people.
You have been marked.
The Tang is the one I am interested in. The IX is about $96000 US at the BMW dealership.
Extremely interested in th Tang too
I detect a clear bias in favor of BYD. I suspect that is because you perceive a very high value in that company's line of vehicles. You seem to 'need' or 'desire' a four-wheel drive SUV with seven seats. And, I have to admit, you've piqued my curiosity about BYD as well.
And, as one Viking to another, I really enjoy your channel and your commentary.
I no longer think range is a problem with BEV's. Once you get beyond 400km per charge it would cover more than 97% of all usual travel. 97% of most peoples trips are under 120km so at 400km range it would only affect a few large distance drivers in regards to range.
Range is irrelevant w/robotaxi
Thanks Sam. Great video, as always. Two points: 1) Isn't the Tesla Model X a 4 wheel drive, 7 seater SUV? 2) Towing capacity of 1.5 tonnes is the biggest you've seen for any EV? There's a recent video on TH-cam with a Ford F-150 Lightning towing a 6,000 pound caravan. That's 2.67 tonnes. Its maximum load wasn't mentioned.
Mr Elon said th Tesla semi will out pull a diesel semi BACKWARDS UPHILL ina tug of war
Range for the money is the best assessment and at the end of the day it’s the best metric 👍
you have multiple 7-seaters from china in Norway now. NIO, Honqi and Voyah Free. Also tesla x offcourse
If I turn the volume down to 30% and increase the playback speed to 3x then the audio is mostly cleaned up. It would be nice to just have cleaner audio though.
I love your #Tesla Videos
I’m curious. When you said the tests were done at freezing temperatures, what were they? -1C -20C -40C? The ranges do degrade even more as it gets colder. As a Canadian who is looking for his first electric vehicle, I’d like to know the ranges at worst case scenarios for my location.
According to the article: "The test was performed in temperatures between 0 and minus 10 degrees." as translated by google.
@@Seibar42 seems a bit warmer than you would expect for a winter test.
@@lesliecarter4295 I guess that depends on where you are in the world. -10c is extreme where I am and just a few hours drive away anything below 16c is considered cold with anything below 0c being intolerable.
At least there is a benchmark that you could extrapolate from.
@@Seibar42 fair point. Though this was supposed to be in Norway in winter. When I did my forces winter training there it was much colder and also very dark.
I suppose it depends on whether you purposely travel long distances in extreme cold.
Most sensible drivers don't
Batteries weaken when too warm. It may be that, with a smart heat pump monitoring and maintaining ideal temp in the battery pack, the main loss here came from driving on snow and ice.
To me, this looks more like a video of Tang than a video of 31 cars. :)
How much of the range reduction is due to batteries being affected by the cold and how much is the drain from the heater? I would like to see how much battery power would be used when it is parked for the same time as the driving test just maintaining the temperature.
Preheated before charging an limited use of super chargers ext new battery life
@@sparkysho-ze7nm I was wondering how much the range is reduced due to the cold and how much is due to heating the cabin and batteries.
the new Tang with 6 seats and more battery thus more range is the model to go, imo. if one wants more tech geeky feeling AND luxury features AND size, ES8 is worth considering, albeit a bit more expensive. those two are pretty much the only affordable full size pure electric suv's right now. There is another EHS9 but that one is probably too plush for family use. Tang ev has sold about 2100 units in Norway, a country with 5 mil population, in the last 12 months. that is not too shabby.
Ty 4 ur comment
14:53 The Rivian R1T can tow 11,000 lbs or 5 metric tons. Or does the R1T not count as a car? The R1S can do 7,700 lbs or 3.5 tons.
I don't think it is sold outside the US yet. Also imagine some unknown Chinese company delivered a few times more cars in a 5 million people country than Rivian did in the US (that is if what I found is correct and they had avout 2100 cars delivered until early May).
Based on your judgement on EQS, that means a van should cost more than an eqs ‘cause it has mare space and bigger trunk. EQS is luxury. Is above premium. The downside of it is actually the weight
Illumination can frighten him who does not seek enlightenment. Wisdom is a gift conspired through love and through power. Any situation that you find yourself in, is an outward reflection of your inner state of beingness.
Sam mate! Off topic but..., that Amoxycillin story scared the crap out of me (for you)..., here's why... About 1yr ago my wife was given a penicilin-based antibiotic (one she had had before) and broke out in a rash..., started getting hot, her head started getting weird - called local pharmacy (where we got the drugs), suggested we "might" want to take her to hospital (weekend) or come up to the pharmacy. So I raced her up to the pharmacy (closer) like a mad man (she was in medical distress), the guy took one look at her and hit her with an epi-pen - saved her life...! Don't make too many assumptions about your experience with this thing Sam... 🙏
Sam, these tests were conducted on dry roads at temperatures ranging from Zero down to minus 10 degrees. Real winter data needs to be at much lower temperatures down to at least - 25, and with snow and ice. Then you will then see the degradation is typically 25 to 35%, and there are many tests on youtube backing this up.
Model 3 is A small car dude
The EQS is way bigger
And did almost the same km.
Model 3 has 614 wltp
It also has a 60+% larger pack.
It SHOULD go further
@@rogerstarkey5390
Its 107 KWh vs 82 KWh so not 60%
No it shouldnt if you knew A little about consumtion in winter
The air is more dents in winter and a bigger car will allways have higher consumtion.
Its allmost 900 kg more then A tiny model 3.
Can Even compare them.
Yep same here i want more range for the money they ask
"According to a study conducted by the American organization AAA Automotive Research Center, the distance traveled by electric cars on a single charge can be reduced by an average of 57 percent as a result of cool air". Consumer Disputes Board in Finland: Hyundai Kona Electric 2019 "When using the car, the buyer stated that the range is considerably shorter than stated. The consumer told the seller, based on his three-week driving experience, that the range in normal winter conditions was almost half as short as the range according to the WLTP standard".That 11 % losses is more like by tire slipping.
Are you having floods in your area, Sam, Sydney is really getting clobbered
Tesla x has 2.25 tonn towing capasity.
What about a 7 seater Tesla Model Y
They should include an ice vehicle just to provide context.
eViking choose Tang.
Niobjorn choose ES8.
Both choices are currently unavailable for me and Thai people.
Ev’s need the quoted range to be hwy.
Not only do westerners not know the BYD brand (they will), BYD needs to rename their models, in the west. Tang? Powdered fake OJ? Why not call it something like Cascadia, or some other US place name (think Telluride, Sequoia, etc.). Their marketing leaves something to be desired. Seems like a great BEV though.
Why try to pretend and hide behind its name. If don't like it don't buy it its a free market and if you got plenty of money spare get the most expensive one with the establish brand.
Beat it.....beat it.....
Look at the BYD Tang and the chevy Blazer ev. They look identical. Easy to see how gm plans on making so many models by 2030. Gm has been doing this for decades.
GM is also $35 billion ((more?) In debt and "trying" to catch up.
mercedes ditched the heat pump for the 150k € eqs
the price of that mercedes is for people who don't care about prices. I suggest they double the price still. what does it matter?
The line would be shorter
Surely the external temperature is irrelevant if there is an internal temperature control system? The only drop in efficiency would be caused by the generation of heat or use of cooling refrigeration? The Chinese are coming. Is it a surprise? The main car makers source over half their components from China FOR CARS SOKD IN EUROPE. Why should Chinese cars be inferior when the same CHINESE components go into ALL cars?
Gudday Mr Sam come on mane who’s gon buy th terminally ugly model Y I mean REALLY ???
if You use 20-80% and 20% range is gone in winter, you only have half the range.....
My life has totally changed since I started an investment of $6,000 and now earning over $ 57,000
*Scam alert!*